1545: Henry VIII’s Best Friend Secretly Married the King’s Sister. Thirty Years Later, the King Paid for His Funeral
The king had forgotten to close his helmet.
It was March 10, 1524, in the tiltyard at Greenwich, and the cold spring air smelled of churned earth, horses, and the smoke of the braziers where the grooms warmed their hands.
Henry VIII was thirty-two years old and wearing a new suit of armor, made to a design he had worked out himself.
At the far end of the barrier sat the man he had chosen to ride against.
Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, was about forty, broad in the shoulder, and had been riding in the king’s tournaments for fifteen years.
Inside a jousting helmet a rider saw the world through a narrow slit.
Brandon could see the king’s horse, the king’s shield, and the shape of a helmet coming toward him.
He could not see that the visor on that helmet was still raised, and that Henry’s bare face was open to the lance.
Somebody in the crowd saw it.
Then everybody did.
According to the chronicler Edward Hall, the people along the lists began to shout to the duke to stop.
“Hold! Hold!”
The duke heard nothing.
The two horses came together at full gallop, and Brandon’s lance struck the king on the brow of his helmet and shattered.
Splinters of wood flew into the open headpiece, around Henry’s eyes, across his face.
For one long moment, the men who stood around that tiltyard believed they had just watched the Duke of Suffolk kill the King of England.
Brandon pulled off his own helmet.
When he saw what had happened, Hall says, he swore that he would never run against the king again.
Henry did not shout.
He did not order the duke’s arrest.
He told everyone around him that no one was to blame but himself, and then, to show the crowd that he was unhurt, he called for fresh lances and rode again.
It was the kind of thing Henry VIII forgave in almost nobody.
He forgave it in Charles Brandon.
He had already forgiven him for something much worse.
Nine years earlier, this same man had been sent to France to fetch home the king’s widowed sister, and had married her behind the king’s back.
Men on the king’s council had wanted him locked away, or worse.
He had survived it.
He would go on surviving: the fall of a cardinal, the fall of two queens, the fall of the king’s chief minister, and the slow destruction of almost every other man who had ever ridden beside Henry in the tiltyard.
And when Brandon finally died, twenty-one years after that afternoon at Greenwich, the king did two things he did for almost no one.
He threw out the funeral his friend had asked for and paid for a grander one himself.
And, according to a story that has been told for centuries, he turned to his council and asked them a question that not one of them could answer.
What did a man with no fortune, no great family, and no talent for politics have that every other friend of Henry VIII lacked?
This is the story of the king’s best friend, and of the price he paid to stay that way for forty years.
—
## Why did a dead standard-bearer matter more than a living lord?
The story began with a flag, and the man who died holding it.
On August 22, 1485, near the village of Market Bosworth in Leicestershire, a young exile named Henry Tudor fought King Richard III for the crown of England.
Beside Henry Tudor rode his standard-bearer, Sir William Brandon.
A standard was not a decoration.
It showed every man on the field where the commander stood, which meant it also showed the enemy where to strike.
Late in the battle, Richard III saw Henry Tudor’s banner close by, with only a small guard around it, and gambled his crown on a single charge.
He and his household knights crashed into Henry’s bodyguard.
William Brandon was cut down, by most accounts struck by the king himself, and the great red dragon of the Tudors went down into the dust with him.
Minutes later, Richard III was dead too, and Henry Tudor was King Henry VII.
The new king did not forget the man who had died with his flag in his hands.
William Brandon left a widow and small children.
One of them was a boy of about a year old named Charles.
There was no great Brandon fortune for him to inherit; the family was respectable, and that was all.
What Charles had instead was a story: his father had died for the Tudors.
In the court of a new dynasty that trusted almost no one, that story was worth more than land.
The boy grew up around the royal household.
His uncle, Sir Thomas Brandon, was one of Henry VII’s trusted soldiers and household officers, and he brought his nephew to court.
By his teens Charles was serving in the households of the great, learning to ride, to fight with the lance, to dance, and to stand very still in a room where a king was angry.
He learned one more thing at that court.
He learned that a Tudor king’s favor was the only real wealth he would ever have.
He did not yet know that the king who would matter most to him was a little red-haired boy about seven years younger than himself, the second son of the house, whom nobody expected to rule.
—
## How did a boy with no fortune become the prince’s shadow?
Prince Henry was not supposed to be king.
His older brother Arthur was the heir.
Henry was the spare, raised among women and tutors, kept close to his mother’s household while Arthur was trained to rule.
Then, in April 1502, Arthur died at Ludlow, and everything changed.
The ten-year-old spare became the heir, and his father, terrified of losing a second son, kept him under watch almost every hour of the day.
The young prince was tall, restless, and in love with everything his father would not let him do.
He wanted to joust.
He wanted to hunt from dawn to dark.
He wanted men around him who could ride harder and laugh louder than the careful old councillors of his father’s court.
Charles Brandon was exactly that kind of man.
He was older, already experienced in the tiltyard, handsome by every account, and he did not come from one of the great noble families whose loyalty Henry VII watched so nervously.
He owed everything to the Tudors.
He could be trusted precisely because he had nothing of his own.
In April 1509, Henry VII died, and the seventeen-year-old prince became Henry VIII.
Almost overnight, the court filled with banquets, masques, and tournaments, and with young men who rode with the king.
Brandon was one of them from the start.
He became one of the king’s squires of the body, the men who attended him in his private rooms, dressed him, and slept near him.
In the great tournaments of those years, he was often the king’s partner, and just as often his opponent.
Hall describes him at a tournament at Westminster in February 1511, coming into the lists dressed in the grey robe of a religious recluse, as if he were a pilgrim come to pray, and then throwing off the robe to show his armor underneath.
The crowd loved it.
So did the king.
But the young Charles Brandon also had another reputation at court, and it had nothing to do with jousting.
—
## Why did his love life frighten respectable families?
Before he was twenty-five, Charles Brandon had made a tangle of his marriages that lawyers would still be sorting out decades later.
He had first promised himself to a young woman named Anne Browne, the daughter of a well-born courtier, and she had a daughter by him.
Then, instead of marrying her, he married her aunt.
Margaret Neville was an older, wealthy widow, and the marriage brought Brandon land he could sell.
He sold it.
Within a short time, he had that marriage declared void, on the grounds that he and Margaret were too closely related through his earlier promise to her niece.
Then he went back and married Anne Browne after all, first in secret and then in public.
She gave him a second daughter and died in 1511.
Respectable families drew their own conclusions about the king’s friend.
To Henry, he was not a scandal but a companion, cheerful, brave, and always on his side.
So the rewards began to arrive, one after another.
In 1513 he became Master of the Horse, in charge of the royal stables, one of the most coveted posts in the household.
That same spring he was made a Knight of the Garter, the most exclusive order of knighthood in England.
He was also given the title Viscount Lisle, through a marriage contract with his young ward, the heiress of the Lisle family, a girl of about eight who was in his care.
That contract was a matter of land and titles, not love, and it would later be dissolved.
That summer, Henry went to war in France, and Brandon went with him as one of the commanders of the army.
He was at the sieges of Thérouanne and Tournai.
In the Low Countries afterward, he flirted so openly with Margaret of Austria, the emperor’s daughter and the ruler of the Netherlands, that rumors of a marriage spread across Europe, and she had to deny them.
The king was delighted.
—
## What did the king give a friend who had nothing?
In the early months of 1514, Henry VIII did something that made the old nobility of England gasp.
He made Charles Brandon a duke.
At that time there were almost no dukes in England.
A dukedom was the highest rank a subject could hold, the rank of kings’ brothers and the oldest families in the land.
On the same occasion, the king restored the dukedom of Norfolk to the Howard family, a clan of soldiers with a long line of noble ancestors.
The Howards had blood.
Brandon had a dead father and the king’s affection.
He became Duke of Suffolk, a title that had once belonged to the de la Pole family.
The last de la Pole in English hands, Edmund, had been put to death in the Tower of London only the year before, because his royal blood made him dangerous to the Tudors.
Now the title went to a man whose blood made him dangerous to no one.
Foreign ambassadors wrote home in amazement.
A man of modest birth, with debts and a complicated marriage history, now stood above almost every lord in England.
To keep that rank, he needed land and money, and the king gave him both.
And Henry seems to have expected something in return.
Not money.
Loyalty, and obedience, and company.
Those were the terms of the friendship.
Charles Brandon would test them only once.
He would do it before the year was out.
—
## Why did the king make him swear an oath before he went to Paris?
In the autumn of 1514, the king’s younger sister Mary was sent across the Channel to marry the old King of France, Louis XII.
She was eighteen.
He was fifty-two.
Brandon crossed to France that November for the tournaments held to celebrate her coronation in Paris, and he fought there in front of the new queen and the French court.
On New Year’s Day 1515, less than three months after the wedding, Louis XII died.
Mary was a widow at eighteen, alone in Paris, with a new French king paying her far more attention than she wanted.
Someone had to go and bring her home, together with her jewels, her plate, and as much of her dowry as could be recovered.
Henry chose his best friend.
There was one problem, and the king knew it.
Mary had made her brother a promise before she left England: if the old king died, she would choose her next husband herself.
So before Brandon left, the king made him promise something.
According to Brandon’s own later letter, Henry had him swear, at the palace of Eltham, that he would not propose marriage to Mary while he was in France.
Brandon gave his word.
He rode for the coast.
Within weeks, he would break that oath, and he would know exactly what he was doing when he broke it.
—
## What does a man do when a queen gives him one chance?
The story of what happened in Paris has been told many times from Mary’s side: the darkened room, the white mourning gown, the young widow who refused to be traded away a second time.
From Charles Brandon’s side, it looked like a trap with no good exit.
He arrived in Paris at the end of January 1515.
Mary, meanwhile, told Brandon that if he would not marry her now, at once, she would never give him the chance again.
Brandon wrote home later that she wept so much he had never seen a woman cry like it.
He also wrote, more practically, that she would give him no peace until he agreed.
So, sometime in the first weeks of 1515, probably in early March, in a small chapel at the Hôtel de Cluny, with only a handful of witnesses in the room, Charles Brandon married the widowed Queen of France.
He had sworn to the King of England that he would not even ask.
Now he had to tell him.
He could not bring himself to write to Henry.
On March 5, 1515, he wrote instead to Thomas Wolsey, the king’s chief minister, and confessed everything.
And then he waited.
The answer that came back from England was worse than he had feared.
Wolsey told him that the king had taken the news “grievously and displeasantly.”
Henry had trusted him above all men, Wolsey wrote, and Brandon had betrayed that trust.
At home, members of the king’s council were saying aloud that the duke should be imprisoned, or that he should die for it.
To marry the king’s sister without the king’s consent was an attack on the king’s own power over his family, and men had lost their heads for less.
For a few weeks in the spring of 1515, Charles Brandon did not know whether he would ever see England again, or whether, if he did, he would see it from a cell in the Tower.
Then the king named his price.
—
## What was the price of the king’s sister?
The price was money.
An enormous amount of money.
Brandon and Mary would pay Henry £24,000.
They would pay it at the rate of £1,000 a year, which meant that the king had just made his best friend his debtor for most of the rest of his life.
They would also hand over the gold plate Mary had received as Queen of France, and the most famous of her jewels, a great diamond known as the Mirror of Naples.
Brandon would give up the wardship of his young Lisle heiress, and the title of Viscount Lisle with it.
It was ruinous.
It was also, in the circumstances, a gift.
The king had not taken his friend’s head, his dukedom, or his freedom.
He had taken his money, and he had kept the man.
After a second, public wedding in Paris, the couple crossed to Calais and waited for permission to come home.
On May 13, 1515, at Greenwich, the King of England stood in the church while his sister married his best friend for the third time.
It was a quiet ceremony.
Henry was there.
He had forgiven them, in his way.
But a forgiveness that is paid for in yearly installments is a forgiveness that never quite ends.
For years afterward, Brandon was short of money.
He borrowed, he sold land, he struggled to keep up the life of a duke on an income that never matched the title.
And he spent long stretches of time away from court, at his houses in Suffolk, while Wolsey grew more powerful at the king’s side.
Fourteen years later, he and Wolsey would face each other in a crowded hall at Blackfriars.
And Wolsey would remind him, in front of witnesses, of exactly what he owed.
—
## How do you stay the king’s friend after you have betrayed him?
The answer, for Charles Brandon, was simple.
You never do it again.
After 1515, there is almost no sign that he ever crossed Henry VIII in anything that mattered.
He came back to the tiltyard.
He came back to the king’s private rooms.
In March 1516, Mary gave birth to a son, and the boy was named Henry.
By most accounts, the king himself stood as the baby’s godfather.
It was the clearest sign the court could have been given: the Suffolks were family again.
A daughter, Frances, followed in 1517, and another, Eleanor, a year or two later.
In June 1520, when Henry VIII met François I in the great pageant of tents and tournaments near Calais that history remembers as the Field of the Cloth of Gold, Brandon was at his side.
He rode in the jousts with the king.
In 1523, Henry sent Brandon back to France at the head of an army.
It was the biggest command of his life.
He marched out from Calais and drove deep into northern France, burning and plundering as he went, and came within a few days’ march of Paris itself.
Then the weather turned, the money ran short, the allies failed to arrive, and the army melted away in the winter cold.
Brandon brought what was left of it home.
The king was not pleased, but he did not blame his friend.
Within months, they were back in the tiltyard together at Greenwich.
That was the spring of the forgotten visor, the shattered lance, and the splinters around the king’s eyes.
Brandon had sworn, in front of the whole court, that he would never run against the king again.
He did not keep that oath either.
Before the year was out, Henry wanted his favorite opponent back, and the two of them were riding at each other once more.
That was how the friendship worked.
The king set the rules, and the king could change them.
Brandon’s only rule was to say yes.
—
## Who struck the table at Blackfriars?
By the late 1520s, the king wanted to end his marriage to Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn, and he had trusted Cardinal Wolsey to win him the Pope’s verdict.
In the summer of 1529, a church court sat at Blackfriars in London to hear the case.
Two cardinals presided: Wolsey, and an elderly Italian named Lorenzo Campeggio, sent from Rome.
Everyone at court expected a judgment for the king.
Instead, on July 23, 1529, Campeggio rose and announced that the court would adjourn.
The Roman courts were going into their summer recess, he said, and this court would follow their custom.
The king’s case was being sent away to Rome, where Henry would never win it.
What happened next was written down years later by George Cavendish, a gentleman of Wolsey’s household who was there.
The Duke of Suffolk stood up.
He struck his hand down on the table in front of him.
And he said, loudly enough for the whole room to hear:
“It was never merry in England whilst we had cardinals among us.”
The room went still.
The duke had not been speaking to the Italian.
He had been speaking to Wolsey.
And Wolsey, according to Cavendish, answered him in front of everyone.
Of all men in the realm, the cardinal said, Suffolk had the least reason to complain about cardinals.
If he, a simple cardinal, had not been there in 1515, the duke would at that very moment have had no head on his shoulders.
It was the most dangerous thing anyone could have said to him.
It was also, quite possibly, true.
Within a few months, Wolsey had fallen from power.
In November 1530 he died at Leicester, on his way south to face charges of treason.
Brandon had not caused the cardinal’s fall.
But when the king turned against Wolsey, his best friend was standing exactly where the king wanted him, on the other side of the table.
In the years that followed, Brandon became President of the King’s Council.
He was not a great minister and never tried to be one.
He was something rarer.
He was the man the king trusted to do the jobs no one else wanted.
And in the winter of 1533, the king gave him the worst one of all.
—
## Why did he hope for an accident on the road to Buckden?
The year 1533 broke Charles Brandon’s life in two.
In January, the king secretly married Anne Boleyn.
In May, the Archbishop of Canterbury declared his marriage to Catherine of Aragon null.
Mary Tudor, Brandon’s wife, had loathed Anne Boleyn for years, and she did not go to Anne’s coronation.
She was already ill.
On June 25, 1533, at the Suffolks’ house at Westhorpe, the woman who had once been Queen of France died.
She was thirty-seven.
She was buried in the abbey at Bury St Edmunds, still the French Queen to the end.
Brandon did not stay a widower long.
In early September 1533, he married again.
His new wife was his ward, Catherine Willoughby, a wealthy heiress who had been living in his household and had been intended as a bride for his own son.
She was fourteen.
He was nearly fifty.
Marriages like that were made for land and inheritance in Tudor England, and courtiers raised their eyebrows at the speed of it rather than the ages.
But there was a detail in this marriage that would soon make Brandon’s life very uncomfortable.
The bride’s mother was Maria de Salinas, Lady Willoughby.
She had come to England from Spain more than thirty years before, as one of Catherine of Aragon’s ladies, and she was still the old queen’s dearest friend.
That winter, the king sent Brandon to Catherine of Aragon.
She was living at Buckden, a palace of the Bishop of Lincoln in Huntingdonshire, with a shrinking household of loyal servants who still called her the queen.
Henry wanted that stopped.
She was to be told she was no longer queen, only Princess Dowager, the widow of the king’s dead brother Arthur.
Her servants who refused to swear to the new order were to be sent away, and she was to be moved to a smaller, damper house.
Brandon was to lead the commission and make it happen.
According to reports from that time, the duke made it known that he had hoped some accident might happen to him on the road, so that he would be excused from going.
No accident came.
He rode to Buckden.
Catherine would not accept the title.
She would not accept the move.
When the commissioners pressed her, she went into her own chamber and shut the door, and she spoke to them through it, and she would not come out.
They could not drag a queen out of her bedroom by force.
They dismissed some of her servants, took the oaths they could get, and argued with her through a door for days.
Then they gave up and rode back to report that they had failed.
It is one of the few moments in forty years when Charles Brandon did not simply do what the king wanted.
He did not refuse.
He went.
He just could not make it work, and he let it be known that he had not wanted to.
Three months later, in March 1534, Brandon’s surviving son by Mary, the Earl of Lincoln, died at about the age of ten.
The boy who had once been the king’s nephew and Brandon’s heir was gone.
There would be no Tudor blood in the next Duke of Suffolk.
—
## Who was still standing after the spring of 1536?
By 1536, the king had begun to destroy the people closest to him.
In January of that year, Henry fell heavily from his horse in the tiltyard and lay unconscious for some time.
He never jousted again.
The game that had bound him to Brandon for a quarter of a century was over.
Four months later, Anne Boleyn was arrested and taken to the Tower.
With her went five men.
One of them was Sir Henry Norris, the head of the king’s privy chamber, one of the men who had spent more hours alone with the king than almost anyone alive.
He had been Henry’s friend for twenty years.
He died on Tower Hill on May 17, 1536.
Two days later, Anne Boleyn died on Tower Green.
Brandon had never liked her, and by some accounts he was among the lords who stood there to watch.
He only had to stand where the king wanted him to stand.
That autumn, the north of England rose in revolt against the king’s religious changes.
The first rising broke out in Lincolnshire in October 1536, and Henry sent Brandon at the head of an army to put it down.
The rebels had dispersed before he arrived.
Then he gave Brandon a new job.
The duke was to make his home there, in the middle of the county, and to be the king’s power in the land.
Over the next two years, Brandon handed many of his Suffolk estates back to the king and took Lincolnshire lands in exchange, many of them from closed monasteries.
He made his new home at Grimsthorpe, the inheritance of his young wife, and at the great brick tower of Tattershall.
He was over fifty, and the king had picked him up and moved him across England.
He went without a word of complaint.
And the men who had complained began to disappear.
In December 1538, Sir Edward Neville, who had ridden in the king’s tournaments since 1510, was put to death for treason.
In March 1539, Sir Nicholas Carew, another of the king’s companions of the tiltyard and a Knight of the Garter, followed him to the scaffold.
In July 1540, it was Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, who had arranged so many other men’s deaths.
Of the young riders who had jousted with the king in the bright first years of his reign, almost none were left.
Charles Brandon was still at the king’s side.
He was still the man the king sent for.
—
## What was the last thing the king asked of him?
In the summer of 1544, Henry VIII went to war in France one last time.
He was fifty-three, enormously heavy, his leg ulcerated and painful, but he crossed to Calais in July to lead his army in person.
The command of the siege of Boulogne went to Charles Brandon.
The two old friends spent that summer in front of the walls of a French port, the king watching from his camp, the duke directing the guns and the trenches.
In September 1544, Boulogne surrendered.
Henry rode into the town in triumph.
It was the last great victory of his reign, and he had won it with Brandon beside him, the way he had won his first tournaments thirty years before.
By the next summer, the French wanted their town back.
In July 1545, a French fleet sailed into the Solent, off Portsmouth, and landed troops on the Isle of Wight.
The king came down to the coast.
He watched, on July 19, as his great warship the Mary Rose heeled over and sank in front of him with most of her crew.
Brandon was in the south that summer too, among the commanders preparing the defense of the coast.
He was sixty, or close to it.
He was tired.
And the king had one more task for him.
He was to cross to France and take command at Boulogne, to hold the town Henry had won.
He never went.
—
## What happened at Guildford in August 1545?
The court was at Guildford in Surrey that August.
The king had a house there, and his councillors and household were lodged in and around the town while the summer campaign wound down and the plans for Boulogne were drawn up.
Charles Brandon was there too.
What happened to him, no one recorded in detail.
He fell ill.
There was no great accident, no long decline that anyone wrote about, no physician’s report that survives to name the disease.
He had spent his life in armor, on horseback, in siege camps and in cold castles, and his body had paid for all of it.
Only weeks earlier he had been dealing in orders about men, horses, and supplies for the crossing to France, the ordinary business of a commander.
Now that business went on around him without him.
Messengers still came and went in the yards of Guildford.
Councillors still met.
The plans for Boulogne still needed a commander, and the man they had been written for could no longer rise from his bed.
For the king, it was a summer of losses.
In July he had watched the Mary Rose go down with hundreds of men in front of his eyes.
Now, a month later, the friend who had stood beside him since before he was king was dying close by.
In those last days, he must have known what was coming.
His will was ready.
It was not the will of a man who wanted to be remembered in marble.
He asked to be buried at Tattershall, in Lincolnshire, in the church of the college there, the county the king had sent him to.
And he asked that his funeral be held without pomp, without any outward show of worldly pride.
The boy whose father had died holding a flag at Bosworth wanted, at the end, to be put into the ground quietly, far from court.
On August 22, 1545, Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, died at Guildford.
It was sixty years to the day since the battle of Bosworth.
Sixty years to the day since his father had fallen beside the Tudor banner.
The news would have reached the king within hours.
What Henry VIII felt, nobody wrote down at the time.
But what he did is in the record.
He threw out his friend’s last wishes.
There would be no quiet burial at Tattershall.
Charles Brandon would be buried at Windsor, in St George’s Chapel, the chapel of the Order of the Garter, the church where the kings of England lay.
And the king would pay for it himself.
It is hard, today, to understand how unusual that was.
Henry VIII was not a sentimental man about the dead.
He had let his only son, Henry FitzRoy, be taken to his grave in a closed cart covered with straw.
He had sent two of his wives to the scaffold and rarely, if ever, spoke of them again.
He had let friend after friend go to Tower Hill without, as far as anyone knows, a word of regret.
And now, for a man who had married his sister behind his back, nearly killed him in a tiltyard, and failed him at Buckden, he opened his own purse.
The funeral was held at Windsor in early September 1545.
Heralds walked in procession with the dead man’s banners and arms.
The coffin was carried into the soaring white stone chapel that Henry’s grandfather Edward IV had begun and his father had helped to finish, under the banners of the Knights of the Garter.
The duke whose blood had been too common for the old nobility was buried among kings.
Then there is the story that has been repeated about this moment for more than two hundred years.
According to that story, when the news of Brandon’s death was brought to the king’s council, Henry spoke about his friend to the men around the table.
He said that in all the years the duke had served him, he had never once tried to harm an adversary, and had never said a word to injure anyone.
Then he looked around at his councillors, the men who had spent their lives scheming against one another, and asked:
“Is there any of you, my lords, who can say as much?”
Nobody answered.
It is a perfect story.
It may not be true.
It does not appear in any letter or chronicle written at the time.
It appears in print much later, most famously in the history of England written by the philosopher David Hume in the eighteenth century, and modern historians, including Brandon’s biographer, have repeated it without being able to trace where it came from.
But even if the words were invented, the funeral was not.
The king paid for it.
And he chose the place.
Less than eighteen months later, he would come to that same chapel himself.
—
## Why did the king choose Windsor?
On January 28, 1547, Henry VIII died at Whitehall.
He was fifty-five.
In his will, he asked to be buried at Windsor, in St George’s Chapel, beside his third wife, Jane Seymour, the mother of his only legitimate son.
On February 16, 1547, after a long procession along the road from London, the king’s coffin was lowered into the vault beneath the floor of the choir.
It lay a short walk from the grave of Charles Brandon.
Historians cannot say for certain that Henry chose Windsor for his friend because he meant to lie there himself.
He had been planning a great tomb for years, and St George’s was the obvious place for it.
But the result is the same.
The two men who had ridden at each other in the tiltyard for twenty-five years ended in the same chapel, under the same Garter banners, within a year and a half of each other.
The grand tomb Henry had planned was never finished.
For almost three hundred years, the King of England lay under the choir floor with no monument at all, until a plain black marble slab was laid over the vault in the reign of William IV, in 1837.
Brandon fared no better.
There was no great effigy for him either.
Centuries later, the chapel’s records show permission being given to lay a stone over his grave, as if even the place where he lay had nearly been forgotten.
—
## What happened to the duke’s two little boys?
Brandon left behind a widow of about twenty-five and two small sons.
The elder, Henry, had been born in September 1535.
The younger, Charles, was born a couple of years later.
Hans Holbein painted them both as tiny circular miniatures, usually dated to 1541, two fair-haired boys in black against a bright blue background.
The paintings are still in the Royal Collection.
The elder boy inherited his father’s dukedom at nine years old.
He was raised alongside the king’s son, the future Edward VI, and became one of his companions, the way his father had once been the companion of another prince.
Later both boys went to study at Cambridge, where their tutors praised them as unusually gifted.
In the summer of 1551, the sweating sickness came to Cambridge.
It was the same terrible disease that had swept through England in the king’s youth, a fever that could kill a healthy person within a single day.
The boys were taken away from the town to escape it.
They went to Buckden, to the bishop’s palace, the same house where, eighteen years earlier, their father had stood outside a closed door arguing with a queen.
The sickness followed them.
On July 14, 1551, the young Duke of Suffolk died.
He was fifteen.
His younger brother became Duke of Suffolk in his place, and held the title for less than an hour, perhaps much less.
Then he died too.
The two brothers were buried together.
Their mother, Catherine Willoughby, survived them, and she poured her grief into faith.
She became one of the boldest Protestant women in England, and lived until 1580.
Charles Brandon’s dukedom of Suffolk, the title Henry VIII had given his low-born friend in 1514, ended in a single afternoon in a bishop’s house in Huntingdonshire.
His blood survived through his daughters.
His daughter Frances, Mary Tudor’s child, became the mother of Lady Jane Grey, the girl who would be queen for nine days in 1553.
The man with no royal blood had married it, and his grandchildren were born with it.
—
## What did Henry VIII forgive, and what did he never forgive?
There is a list, if you look for it, of the men who were closest to Henry VIII.
It is mostly a list of the dead.
Thomas Wolsey, who made him the greatest prince in Europe, died under arrest.
Thomas More, Henry Norris, Edward Neville, Nicholas Carew, and Thomas Cromwell all died on the scaffold.
Charles Brandon broke a sworn oath, married the king’s sister without permission, embarrassed him before the whole of Europe, and very nearly put a lance through his face.
He died in his bed.
Why?
Brandon was never a rival.
He had no great family behind him, no army of his own, no royal blood until he married it, and no ambition to run the government.
He never pushed a policy the king did not want.
When he was sent to Buckden, he went.
When he was sent to Lincolnshire, he moved.
His only real crime had been committed in 1515, out of love, and he had paid for it in cash, every year, for as long as the king demanded.
But there may be a simpler answer too.
Henry VIII had very few people in his life who had known him before he was king.
His mother died when he was eleven.
His brother died when he was ten.
His father had kept him locked away in a world of tutors and rules.
Charles Brandon was the young man who had ridden into the tiltyard with him when they were both still young, who had laughed with him, fought with him, and known him as Harry before he was anyone’s majesty.
Perhaps a king who destroyed almost everyone could not bring himself to destroy the last person who reminded him of who he had been.
The record does not say.
It only says that the king forgave him, and forgave him, and forgave him again.
And that when he died, the king paid to bring him home to Windsor.
—
## What was left in the tiltyard at Greenwich?
Nothing is left of the tiltyard where the two men rode against each other in March 1524.
The palace of Greenwich, where Henry VIII was born, was pulled down in the seventeenth century.
The grand buildings of the Old Royal Naval College stand on the site now, and the green slope of the park runs up behind them toward the Royal Observatory.
Somewhere under the lawns and the paths, the old tiltyard lies buried.
There, on a spring afternoon, a crowd shouted “Hold!” and a man in a closed helmet did not hear them.
A lance shattered.
Splinters flew into the face of the King of England.
And the king took off his helmet and told the whole court that no one was to blame.
Almost every man who ever stood close to Henry VIII learned, sooner or later, that he could be blamed for everything.
One man never did.
His father had died for the Tudors with their flag in his hands.
He lived for them for sixty years.
And when he was laid to rest at Windsor, under the banners of the Garter, it was at the king’s expense, in the king’s own chapel, a short walk from the place where the king himself would soon lie.
He had asked for a quiet grave far away in Lincolnshire.
His oldest friend would not let him go that far.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Charles Brandon was born around 1484, the son of Sir William Brandon, Henry Tudor’s standard-bearer, who was killed at the battle of Bosworth on August 22, 1485; most accounts say he was struck down by Richard III in the king’s final charge.
Brandon died at Guildford on August 22, 1545, the sixtieth anniversary of Bosworth; the cause of his death was not recorded.
His early marriages, the Lisle contract, and his offices and titles are documented, though some dates differ slightly between sources.
The secret marriage to Mary Tudor took place in Paris in early 1515; the exact date is disputed, with early March most often given.
Brandon’s oath at Eltham is known from his own letter; his confession to Wolsey is dated March 5, 1515, and the phrase “grievously and displeasantly” comes from Wolsey’s reply.
The fine of £24,000, payable at £1,000 a year, together with Mary’s plate and jewels, is documented; the king later reduced what was owed.
The jousting accident of March 10, 1524, including the crowd’s cries and Brandon’s vow never to run against the king again, comes from Edward Hall’s *Chronicle*; Hall’s exact wording is paraphrased here.
Brandon’s words at Blackfriars (“It was never merry in England whilst we had cardinals among us”) and Wolsey’s reply come from George Cavendish’s *Life of Wolsey*, written about twenty-five years later; Wolsey’s answer is paraphrased.
The report that Brandon hoped for an accident to excuse him from the Buckden commission of December 1533 comes from accounts of the time repeated in older biographies; the exact source and wording are uncertain.
Brandon’s presence at Anne Boleyn’s death rests on chronicle accounts and is given here as uncertain.
Brandon’s will asked for a quiet burial at Tattershall without pomp; the king instead had him buried in St George’s Chapel, Windsor, at royal expense, in early September 1545 (one account gives September 9).
Henry VIII’s question to his council (“Is there any of you, my lords, who can say as much?”) is not found in any source written at the time; it appears in later histories, notably David Hume’s, and should be treated as a tradition.
Brandon’s sons Henry and Charles died of the sweating sickness on July 14, 1551, within a very short time of each other; Holbein’s miniatures of them are in the Royal Collection.
Scenes at Greenwich, Blackfriars, Buckden, Guildford, and Windsor are reconstructed from these sources; no dialogue has been invented for any named person, and Brandon’s thoughts are inferred from his letters and actions.