News

“You Will Walk There Yourself”: The German Officer Pointed At The White Building. She Had Already Asked The Commandant One Question…

Signature: drSb3xgv3CzC4hQgynjOeAkGQcVml3rtQYLeF6+L5YhiRd3VqdCOF/WAt1/yqZ7jJiB171/auZnL8C+EUh0DXoVcqAh5Nr2p1orDhjARzHaI1x7sCYu8zxcrBwLjMNAzpJwBnrlIkn7TQytigP5D5HtVgn86sIXLWW+efPNPuOT+foQ+U8jDZrSWTbOghYty1U+zO9H1fnxkNoXeSgXDwyi7BeocBmitGGuaEDB9De7hfIRJ5rFzWdIKfuXWhlRxFpYFrGsBcHcqYy2xi2Zh+sq6S6y6jHyeejUWj4G14cRvU/kPO2rUoUt8gRVemv8LwFKOygJw9x5E+q36LpqXt+Wk8vKMSOB/COZO5nBglvLtE9SLFu+mClUSG/BZgXH5uKylWnloncU0+8SqgiVy87TFwkIYjK8qc4lfKPCn9XfOocirBD8mbnTgycYEX0+n

They read the ten names out on the camp street, on a Sunday morning, in the middle of August, with the sun already warm on the tar paper roofs.

Danuta Krawiec heard hers fourth.

She was twenty years old, she weighed about as much as a schoolchild, and she was standing in the road between two rows of wooden barracks in a coat that had belonged to somebody else, with a stick in her right hand that a friend had cut from a broom handle.

Beside her stood Stefania Mazur, who was twenty-seven, and whose name had not been read at all.

Stefa had simply walked across the road and taken up a position at Danuta’s left shoulder, as if she had been asked to hold a place in a line.

Three officers came down the street toward them in dark uniforms and peaked caps.

The tall one reached them first and laid one hand on Danuta’s shoulder, quite lightly, the way a man might steady a ladder.

The one in the middle stopped a few feet away, and he was almost smiling.

The prisoners knew him.

He had been in that camp for a long time, he had never been seen to strike anyone, and they called him the Usher, because all he ever did was point.

He raised his arm now, with one gloved finger out, and pointed over Danuta’s head and down the length of the road.

At the far end of it, past the kitchens, stood a clean white building with frosted windows.

Everybody on that street knew what it was.

Everybody knew that people went into it on their own two feet, because they always had, for more than a year, one after another, in a line, when a name was read.

That was the only thing the Usher had come to make sure of.

He opened his mouth to tell her so, and behind him, thousands of people in the rows of the work columns stopped pretending not to watch.

What do you say to a man who has never needed to do anything but point?

—

Here is the promise of this story.

Twenty-three months after that Sunday morning, on a platform at the railway station in Lublin, in eastern Poland, a widow in a black headscarf stood waiting for a train with a Red Cross telegram folded in her hand.

The telegram said that her daughter was alive.

She had walked eleven miles to meet that train, and she had been there since before dawn.

Somebody did get off it, on a stick, very slowly, carrying a paper with the daughter’s name and the daughter’s number written on it.

It was not her daughter.

To understand who got off that train, and why she was carrying that paper, and what the widow said to her on the platform, you have to know what happened on the camp street.

To know that, you have to start with a pair of shoes.

—

## How a cobbler’s daughter learned to read the way people walk

Grodzka Street in Lublin runs downhill from the old market to the castle, and in the 1930s, about halfway down it, you could find a shop the width of a single door, which smelled of wax and glue and wet leather.

Jan Krawiec had repaired shoes there for twenty-six years.

He had one daughter and no sons, so Danuta grew up on a low stool beside his bench, holding the tacks.

He did not talk much, but he had one great subject.

He would pick up a customer’s boot, turn it over, and show her the heel.

“Look how she wears it down on the outside,” he would say.

“That one has a bad hip and does not know it yet. Give it five years.”

He could tell you who was carrying something heavy, who was drinking, and who had stopped going to work and did not want the family to know.

“People lie with their faces,” he said.

“Nobody lies with their feet.”

She thought it was the dullest knowledge in the world.

Then, in September 1939, the German army came into Lublin, and within a few weeks the university was closed and its professors arrested, and a great many people in the city suddenly needed a way to carry a small piece of paper across town without anyone finding it.

A boot heel can be hollowed out with a sharp knife in about twenty minutes.

Jan Krawiec, who had never expressed a political opinion in his life, turned out to be very good at it.

His daughter was sixteen when she started walking those boots around Lublin, in her own size, for people she was told not to know.

By the time she was seventeen, she had worn out four pairs.

They came for her in November 1940, on a wet morning on Lubartowska Street.

A polite man in a raincoat stopped her, and he looked at her face for a moment, and then he looked down.

“You have very new heels,” he said, “for a cobbler’s child who walks so much.”

She remembers thinking that her father would have noticed the same thing.

—

## The building under the clock, and the train that left it behind

The German security police in Lublin had their headquarters on Uniwersytecka Street, in a building with a clock on the front, and everybody in the city knew it simply as Under the Clock.

Danuta spent eleven days there.

They wanted the names of the people who had given her the boots.

We are not going to describe those eleven days, except to say that she came out of them having given no names, and that her father’s shop was closed by the end of the week, and that he was sent somewhere from which he did not come back.

After that, she was held in the castle at the bottom of Grodzka Street, the same castle she had looked at every day of her childhood from her father’s door.

It was there that she met Stefa.

Stefania Mazur had taught German at a high school in Lublin until it was closed, and then she had gone on teaching it in people’s kitchens, along with a number of other things the occupation had forbidden, including Polish history.

She came from a village south of the city where her mother was a widow with four cows.

She was tall and plain and sarcastic, and she stood up very straight, and on the first morning she looked at Danuta’s feet and said that if they were going to share a mattress, she would appreciate it if Danuta took her boots off.

“They took my boots,” Danuta said.

“Then you have no excuse,” said Stefa.

On September 21, 1941, a large transport of Polish political prisoners left Lublin Castle for the railway station.

They had no idea where they were going.

Two days later, they got down from the train in a pine forest beside a lake, about fifty miles north of Berlin, at a small, pretty town called Fürstenberg, with church bells and fishing boats.

They walked from there, along the shore of the lake, in fives.

Danuta, out of habit, looked at the feet in front of her.

She could see who had been hurt, who was going to fall, and who would have to be helped.

She could not yet see the point of noticing any of it.

The sign on the gate said Ravensbrück.

—

## Why the doctors wanted people who had never been sick

For the first ten months, it was only a camp, if that word can be used for it.

There was a roll call in the dark, a work detail, sand to shovel, a piece of bread, and another roll call in the dark.

Stefa’s German got her noticed, and by the following spring she had been moved indoors, to a desk in the labor office, where prisoners kept the card files that told the camp who was assigned to what.

It was the best job in the camp.

She got the cards right, she told Danuta, because if she did not, somebody else would get them wrong on purpose.

Then, in July 1942, the prisoners from the Lublin transport were called out and looked at.

They were lined up by doctors in white coats, who took no interest in their faces.

The doctors were looking at their legs.

This is the part that has to be said plainly, because the men who did it wrote it down plainly.

In the spring of that year, a senior German official had died in Prague of an infected wound, after his surgeon, a man named Karl Gebhardt, had declined to use the new sulfa drugs on him.

Gebhardt was the personal physician of Heinrich Himmler, and now he had something to prove.

He needed to show that the drugs would not have helped.

To show that, he needed healthy young people with whom to reproduce the wounds of the battlefield.

So at Ravensbrück, beginning that July, young Polish prisoners who had nothing whatever the matter with them were taken to the white building, and their legs were deliberately cut open and deliberately infected, and the results were measured and recorded.

Later, other doctors came to see what could be done with bones, muscles and nerves.

Seventy-four Polish prisoners went through that building, along with a small number of others.

Five of them did not survive the operations, and more were shot afterward.

Many of the rest never walked properly again.

There was a word for them by that autumn.

The prisoners called them the *króliki*, the rabbits, because that is what you use in a laboratory.

The ones it was done to took the word for themselves, and they used it with a dry, terrible irony that the doctors never understood.

Danuta’s name was read out on an evening in October.

She had seen the first of them carried back by then, and she knew how it worked.

A nurse read the numbers from a list after the evening meal, and in the morning you went.

Nobody dragged you.

There was nothing to drag you for.

You stood up from your bunk, and you walked down the camp street in the gray light, past the kitchens, on your own legs, to the place where they would take those legs away from you.

It never occurred to anyone not to.

That was the most frightening thing about it, she said afterward, once she was able to think about it at all.

She walked there.

She was carried back.

—

## What Stefa did at five o’clock every morning

Roll call at Ravensbrück did not excuse anyone who could be made to stand, and for a long time after October, Danuta could not stand.

So at a quarter past four each morning, in the dark, Stefa came down from the bunk above, turned her back, and crouched.

“Up,” she said.

“I have not got all day. I have a very important job.”

She carried Danuta out to the square on her back, propped her upright in the row between herself and another prisoner, held her there by the belt for as long as the count took, and carried her back again.

Then she went to work.

Stefa never mentioned this in any way that could be taken for kindness.

She complained about Danuta’s elbows.

She said it was like carrying a bag of coat hangers.

Danuta, who had learned a good deal about bodies by then, watched the back of Stefa’s wooden clogs and saw that the right one had begun to wear down on the outside.

“You have a bad hip,” she said one morning, into Stefa’s neck.

“I have a bad passenger,” said Stefa.

By the winter, Danuta could stand with the stick.

By February, she could get to the square by herself if she started early.

She walked as she would walk for the next eighty years, and she was never again able to look at a flight of stairs without doing arithmetic.

In the block of the rabbits, they had begun to compare what they had seen.

The operations came in waves.

Each list came from somewhere.

And each time a list was read, seventy-odd people who could see exactly what was coming got up in the morning and walked down that road, one by one, each on her own, because the only alternative anyone could think of was to be shot, and because being shot was something that happened to one person at a time.

Danuta was the one who said it, on a bunk, in the dark, in the first week of March 1943.

She said it the way her father might have.

“Everybody who goes there walks.”

No one answered.

“I mean, look at the feet,” she said.

“They have never once had to carry anyone there. Not one. Have you thought about how many of them that would take?”

A new list had come that week.

—

## The question they wrote to the commandant

The rabbits decided to write a letter to the camp commandant.

There are several accounts of how it went, and in this story it is Stefa, who was not one of them and had no reason to risk her desk, who sat up with them in the block after the evening count, correcting their German in a whisper.

It was not an appeal.

It did not ask for mercy, which would have been a waste of paper.

It asked a question.

It asked whether the commandant was aware that operations were being performed in his camp on healthy political prisoners, and it asked whether he was aware that international law forbade such things.

“That’s very good,” Stefa told them, reading it back.

“You’ve left him nowhere to stand. He can’t say yes, and he can’t say no. He’ll hate it.”

Every one of them signed it.

Then the rabbits did something that no one in that camp had ever seen.

They went to deliver it themselves.

On a raw morning in March, a procession came down the camp street toward the commandant’s office, moving at about the speed of a funeral.

Some of them were on crutches.

Some were on sticks, and some were being held up by the elbows.

Danuta was somewhere near the middle, doing her arithmetic on every step.

They reached the office, and they stood there.

The commandant, Fritz Suhren, would not come out to see them.

The letter was taken in, and no answer ever came.

They stood for a while longer, and then, since they had said what they had come to say, they turned around and made the long trip back, past all those faces.

For the rest of that spring, when a nurse came to the block with a list, the people on it simply stayed in their bunks.

And something happened that nobody could quite believe.

Nothing happened.

The list went away.

April passed, and then May.

No one came, and no one walked down the road, and through June and July the frosted windows of the white building stayed dark in the evenings.

Stefa, at her desk in the labor office, noticed that certain cards had stopped moving, and she did not trust it at all.

“He has filed you,” she told Danuta.

“He’s a man with a filing system. He has not forgotten where he put you.”

—

## The Sunday he came back with a list of ten

On Sunday, August 15, 1943, the morning roll call ended a little before the usual time.

It was the Feast of the Assumption, which every Polish prisoner in the camp knew, and which the camp’s officers may or may not have known.

The columns were held in place on the street, as they sometimes were on a Sunday, waiting to be sent on to whatever work was left to do.

Danuta had gone back to sit down on the step of her block.

She looked up, because of the sound.

She knew that sound, the sound of good boots in no particular hurry.

There were three of them, and a clerk behind them with a sheet of paper, and the clerk began to read.

Ten names.

They were all rabbits.

Hers was the fourth.

Now there was nothing filed about it.

Danuta got hold of her stick and pulled herself upright, because she had decided a long time ago that whatever happened to her would not happen sitting on a step.

She walked out into the middle of the road.

She has said since that it was the longest eleven yards of her life, and that she was aware the whole way of her left foot, which turned in, and of what her father would have said about it.

In the labor office, somebody must have told Stefa, or she had seen them coming through the window.

The door banged, and she came across the road at a walk, with her back very straight and a pen still in her hand, and took up her place at Danuta’s left shoulder.

No one had called her.

Her name was on no list.

Danuta said afterward that she had never been so angry at anyone in her life.

“Go back to your desk,” she said, without moving her lips.

“Be quiet,” said Stefa.

“Your posture is terrible.”

—

## What she said when his finger came up

The tall officer reached them first.

He put a hand on Danuta’s shoulder and left it there, without any pressure at all.

It was warm through the coat.

The third one had stopped behind Stefa, who did not turn around.

The Usher stopped in front of them, a little to one side, as he always did, to leave a clear view.

Danuta had seen him many times from a distance, and she had never been this close.

He had a pleasant, rested, faintly amused face, and a shaving nick under his ear.

His boots were beautiful.

They were the best-kept pair of boots she had ever seen, with a hand-stitched welt, and they had been resoled not long ago by somebody who knew what he was doing.

She noticed the wear on the heels, perfectly even, left and right.

He had never carried anything in his life.

Up and down the road, the columns had gone completely quiet.

She could hear a bucket being set down somewhere.

She could hear flies.

He raised his arm, and the gloved finger came up, past her ear, and aimed itself down the road.

He spoke in the easy voice of a man giving directions.

“Your name is on the list. You will walk there yourself.”

It was two hundred and ten yards.

She had measured it once in steps, on the way there, a very long time ago.

She could see the white building at the end of the finger, and the sun on the frosted glass.

She felt something else too, and it took her a moment to place it.

It was the same thing she had felt on Lubartowska Street, when the man in the raincoat looked down at her heels.

It was the feeling of being read correctly.

He knew.

He had looked at her and he knew exactly how frightened she was, and he knew what she would do about it, because in thirteen months he had pointed at dozens of people and every one of them had done the same thing.

That was what the hand on her shoulder was for.

It was not there to hold her.

It was there to remind her how little holding she would need.

Her lips had gone numb.

She heard herself speak, not very loudly, in the German Stefa had drilled into her over a winter of whispered corrections.

“We asked the commandant a question.”

The Usher’s eyebrows went up a little.

It was not annoyance.

It was the look of a man who has been told something mildly funny by a horse.

He did not lower his arm.

His voice stayed light.

“This is his answer. Walk.”

Nobody on that street was breathing.

Danuta looked down the road, and then she did what she had been doing since she was four years old on a low stool.

She looked at the feet.

There were three pairs of very good boots.

There were thousands of wooden clogs, in rows, on either side of the street, as far as she could see.

And suddenly the arithmetic was simple.

It had been simple all along.

She had worked it out on a bunk in March and had not really believed it until now.

She opened her right hand, and the broom-handle stick fell over in the road, and it made an astonishingly loud noise.

She looked up into his pleasant face.

“Then carry me, and let all of them watch you do it.”

Her legs were never very good by that time, and now she simply stopped using them.

She sat down.

She sat down in the road, on the tar and the grit, in that dead person’s coat, with her bad leg stuck out in front of her, and she folded her hands in her lap.

The hand slid off her shoulder, because there was no longer anything under it.

Beside her, with some dignity, and a small sigh, Stefania Mazur folded up her long body and sat down too.

For a time, nothing moved at all.

The Usher still had his finger in the air.

It is a hard thing to keep your arm up when there is nobody left at the other end of it.

Danuta watched him understand.

It took about as long as it takes to read a short sentence.

For more than a year, he had needed to do nothing but point, and he was now going to have to bend down.

He was going to have to bend down in front of everyone and pick up a person, and carry her two hundred and ten yards, in the sun, in those boots, and he would have to do it again for each of the others.

Up the road, one after another, the rest of the ten had seen.

They heard the sound first, the small clatter of a crutch being laid on the ground, then another.

Somewhere in the columns, a very old voice began to say the rosary, out loud, in Polish, and no one stopped it.

The Usher lowered his arm.

He looked at his glove for a moment, and then he said something quietly to the tall one, and he stepped back, and he took out a cigarette.

He would not do it himself.

It took a long time to fetch enough people.

They took her by the wrists and under the arms, and they were not gentle, and Danuta did not help them in any way at all.

She let her head hang back.

She saw the barracks upside down, and the sky, and then the faces.

There were thousands of them, row upon row, in absolute silence, watching people carried down that road who had always before walked down it alone.

She had thought she would be afraid.

She was, but what she mostly remembers is how many people it took.

—

## The price of two hundred and ten yards

They did not take them to the white building, as it turned out.

That had been ruined, and everybody knew it.

They took the ten to the punishment block instead, and the door was shut.

The rabbits’ whole barrack was closed up with its windows boarded and left without food for days, while the other prisoners crept up in the dark and pushed what they could through the cracks.

And the doctors came to them there, a few days later, in the punishment block.

There was no pretending anymore that anybody was walking anywhere.

What followed in those rooms, in the middle of August 1943, was the last round of the operations at Ravensbrück, and it was done by force, in the most squalid conditions of the whole affair, without any of the clean white ceremony.

Danuta was one of those it was done to.

We will say no more about it than she does.

She says that it was worse than the first time, and that she would sit down again.

It was the end.

No more lists came to that block.

There were no more operations on the rabbits at Ravensbrück after that August, and although nobody can say for certain why, the prisoners believed then, and some historians have believed since, that it had become more trouble than it was worth.

Stefa lost her desk.

She got three weeks in the punishment block herself, and then she was sent out to unload coal from the barges on the lake, which for most people was a sentence of about four months.

She did it for a little over eleven.

Her hip got no better.

And at the end of those eleven months, because the camp had grown to many times its intended size and the labor office could no longer find anyone able to keep its cards in order, somebody came down to the lake and asked if the tall Pole who knew German was still alive.

She went back to her desk in the summer of 1944.

She found the cards in a terrible state, and she said so.

She also found, in the cabinet, a small tab she had not seen before, attached to the cards of the rabbits, all of them.

She did not know what it meant yet.

—

## The night they came to say goodbye

By the winter of 1945, you could hear the Russian guns from the camp on a still night.

And there were now some sixty people in that camp whose legs were evidence.

They could be shown to a court.

They could roll up a trouser leg and point.

On Sunday, February 4, word came down through the prisoners who worked in the offices that the rabbits were going to be taken away the next morning, and everyone understood what that meant.

They spent that night in the block writing to their mothers.

What happened next is one of the great stories of that war, and it is entirely true.

Before dawn, in the dark and the cold, thousands of prisoners from every nation in that camp came out for roll call.

Accounts of it say the lights failed.

The rabbits came out with the others.

And in the middle of that square, right under the eyes of their guards, hands reached out of the rows from all sides, and the rabbits were gone.

They were pushed down, pulled through, passed from row to row and from block to block.

French prisoners took some of them, and Russians took others.

They were hidden under floors and in attics and in the beds of the sick, with the numbers of people who had just died.

When the officers came for them, the block was empty, and it stayed empty.

No one gave them up.

Sixty-three people were hidden in a camp of tens of thousands for nearly three months, under constant searches, and not one was betrayed.

“You could say that the entire camp helped us, hid us, protected us,” one of them said long afterward.

For nine days, Danuta lay under the floorboards of a French block, on her side, with her bad leg bent the only way it would go, and every few hours a hand came down with something to eat.

She could tell by the sound of the shoes who was walking overhead.

On the tenth night, a pair of clogs came along the row, the right one dragging a little on the outside, and stopped directly above her.

The board came up.

—

## The card with her name on it

Stefa had a small candle stub and two cards.

She crouched down there in the dark, and it cost her something to do it.

“There’s a transport tomorrow,” she said.

“Two thousand to a small camp at an airfield in Mecklenburg. Neustadt-Glewe. They’re trucking the ones who can’t walk. Nobody there has ever heard of a rabbit, and they’ll count heads and not much else.”

She held up the first card, and Danuta looked at it in the candlelight.

It said *Mazur, Stefania*, with a number.

“You can’t,” said Danuta.

“I made the card,” said Stefa.

“I can do anything I like. They don’t have you. They have a list of sixty names with a tab on it, and you are on that. Nobody has any tab on me. I’m a clerk with a bad hip who is very useful to them. Tomorrow you’re her.”

“And what are you?”

Stefa held up the second card.

It belonged to a prisoner from Kraków, who had died in the infirmary that afternoon and whom no one had yet taken off the books.

“I will be keeping the other cards straight,” she said.

“There are forty more of you to move, and I’m the only one who knows where they are. I’ll be right along.”

Danuta had a great many things to say about this, and she said them all, in a whisper, while Stefa dripped wax on the floor.

She said that it was madness.

She said she would not do it.

She said that if they found the card, they would shoot them both.

She said she was tired of being carried.

Stefa let her finish.

“I know you are,” she said.

Then she did something she had never done before.

She reached down into the hole and took hold of Danuta’s foot, the bad one, in its rag, and held it for a moment in her big, chapped, ink-stained hand, as you might check a horse.

“You’ll have to stand up straight,” she said.

“I have a reputation.”

That was the last thing she ever said to her.

—

## Who was on the road near Malchow

Neustadt-Glewe was a place of hunger and mud at the edge of a Luftwaffe airfield, with far too many people in it, and there is very little to say about the eleven weeks that followed.

Danuta answered to Mazur.

She stood up as straight as she could.

On the morning of May 2, 1945, the guards were gone, and the gates were open, and within the next day or two the Allied armies had arrived.

A young person with a clipboard came through what was left of the barracks, working for the Red Cross, writing down everyone who could still say their name.

Danuta looked at her for a while.

She had been thinking for weeks about what she would say at this moment.

She had thought she would know.

But she had a card, and there was a rule at Neustadt-Glewe that you did not stop being your card until you were absolutely certain.

“Mazur,” she said.

“Stefania.”

It was three more weeks before she could make herself understood to anyone who could change it, and by that time, the list had gone in.

She tried then to find out about the other one.

The last great evacuation of Ravensbrück had begun in the final days of April, when tens of thousands of prisoners were driven out on foot, north and west, along the roads of Mecklenburg, with the Soviet army close behind them.

Nobody by the name on that Kraków card turned up anywhere, on any list.

There was one thing, and only one.

In the autumn, in a displaced persons’ center, Danuta met a French prisoner who had been on the road near Malchow in the last week of April.

They talked about nothing much, about feet.

The French prisoner remembered a very tall Pole, in the column just ahead of hers, who had been walking badly, dragging her right leg, and who kept on walking for at least two days.

She remembered her because of what she was doing.

She had somebody on her back.

Nobody knew who it was, and she was complaining about it, in several languages, loudly, for miles.

The French prisoner did not see what happened to them.

Nobody did.

—

## The platform at Lublin

She could have written.

She knows that.

She had almost two months to find a way of writing, and there was hardly any post, but there was some, and she did not use it.

By then the Red Cross had already done its work, and a telegram had gone out over the name of an office in Geneva, by way of Warsaw, to a widow with four cows in a village south of Lublin.

Danuta came east on a series of freight cars in July 1945, with a stick and a paper.

On a hot Saturday morning, the train came into Lublin, and it stopped with a long iron groan, and the doors were pulled back.

The platform was full of people, as every platform in Poland was full of people that summer, all of them looking at each face that came down, and then past it, and then at the next one.

Danuta got down last, because it took her a while.

She saw her at once.

She had never met her, but there could not be two of them.

She was a very tall old person in a black headscarf, standing bolt upright with a folded paper in her fist, a little apart from everyone else, and she had been looking at each face that came along that train with a kind of rigid patience, like someone checking accounts.

Her boots were gray with the dust of eleven miles of road.

They were a farmer’s boots, resoled at least twice, and the right one was worn on the outside.

Danuta could have turned around.

She has thought about that a great deal over the years.

There was an open door behind her.

Instead, she walked down the length of that platform, stick and foot and stick and foot, and it took about as long as you might imagine.

She stopped in front of her, and she held out the paper.

“Pani Mazurowa,” she said.

“I’m the one on your telegram.”

The widow looked at the paper.

She looked at the name written on it, and at the number.

She looked at Danuta’s face, without any expression at all, for what felt like the whole of the summer.

Then she looked down at her feet.

Danuta stood there on that platform with her bad leg turned in and her heart going, and she let herself be read.

“She carried you,” the widow said.

It was not a question.

Danuta tried to answer, and found she could not, and nodded.

“When she was nine,” said the widow, “she carried her brother home from the river with a broken ankle. Four miles. She complained the whole way. We could hear her from the yard.”

She took the paper out of Danuta’s hand and looked at it for one moment more.

Then she folded it up, together with the telegram, and put them both inside the front of her dress, and they never left that house again.

A train was getting up steam behind them, and people were crying and shouting all along the platform, for both of the usual reasons.

“Well,” said Pani Mazurowa.

She looked at the road outside the station, and she looked at the stick.

“It is eleven miles,” she said.

“And I am not carrying you.”

Danuta Krawiec laughed.

It was the first time she had done so since Grodzka Street, and it hurt, and she could not stop.

She went home with her.

She stayed for sixteen years, until the widow died, and it took them all that first day to walk there.

—

## What became of the men who only pointed

Four of the rabbits went to Nuremberg, and they were real, and you can look at the photographs.

In December 1946, Maria Kuśmierczuk, Maria Broel-Plater, Władysława Karolewska and Jadwiga Dzido came before the American judges at the Doctors’ Trial, and Dzido showed the court her leg.

Karl Gebhardt was hanged at Landsberg on June 2, 1948.

The commandant, Fritz Suhren, slipped out of American custody in 1946 and lived for three years under another name, working in Bavaria.

He was caught in 1949 and tried by a French military court at Rastatt, and he was executed in June 1950.

Whether anyone ever read that letter to him, we cannot tell you.

Danuta went back to mending shoes.

She reopened a very small shop in Lublin, under the name on her father’s old sign, and she made a good living from it, in a country where nobody had enough shoes, and she was known in the neighborhood for telling customers things about their hips.

She went back to her own name in 1946, after a long and tiring discussion with a clerk.

The Usher she never found.

She looked, for a time, in the only way she knew how.

For years, whenever she was in a crowd, in a railway station or a court corridor or on a street in Warsaw, she looked down, and she looked for a pair of beautifully kept boots, worn perfectly evenly on both heels.

She never saw them again.

She assumes he went home.

She assumes he has told his family that he never laid a hand on anyone, and she assumes that this is true.

—

## The one time she went back to that road

She is a hundred and three now, and she does not travel anymore.

The camp at Ravensbrück is a memorial, and the barracks are gone, but the line of the camp street can still be made out, along with the shape of the square and the lake with the same fishing boats at the far side of it.

She has been back there exactly once, in the spring of 1995, for the fiftieth anniversary of the liberation, when she was seventy-one.

Somebody’s grandniece pushed the chair.

The young people from the memorial were very kind, and they kept asking if she would like to be taken to the ceremony or to have some water.

She told them she would like to go down the road.

When they found the place, near where the kitchens had stood, she asked them to stop, and she asked for her stick, and they helped her up.

She stood there in the wind, on her own two feet, as straight as she was able.

She looked down the length of the road toward the place where a white building had once been.

It was still two hundred and ten yards.

She stood for about as long as it takes to say a sentence, and she was thinking, she says, about an extremely tall person with a bad hip and no patience, who had never once in her life been told to walk anywhere she was not already going.

Then she opened her hand, and the stick fell over on the ground, and it made a loud noise, and a few people turned around.

“Now,” said Danuta Krawiec, to the young person behind the chair.

“Now you can carry me.”

—

## What Really Happened

**Danuta Krawiec and Stefania Mazur did not exist.**

Neither did Jan Krawiec, Pani Mazurowa, the French prisoner, or the officer called the Usher.

They are composite characters, built from the documented experience of the Polish prisoners of Ravensbrück, so that this story could follow one person from beginning to end without putting invented words into the mouths of real survivors.

Danuta is not a real witness, and this is not anyone’s testimony.

The scene on the camp street, its exact words, the stick, the measured two hundred and ten yards, the card, the telegram, and the platform at Lublin are all the work of this story.

We have no record of a prisoner clerk swapping her identity in this way.

The illustration that accompanies this story is an AI reconstruction, not a photograph.

**The events around them are real.**

From July 1942 until August 1943, doctors under Karl Gebhardt, head of the clinic at Hohenlychen and Himmler’s personal physician, operated on prisoners at Ravensbrück, most of them young Polish political prisoners from the Lublin transport of September 1941.

Five died of the operations, and several more were shot.

The prisoners called them the rabbits, and the rabbits smuggled out letters in invisible ink.

**The protest is real.**

In March 1943, the operated prisoners signed a written protest to the commandant and refused to go to further operations.

Accounts describe them going in person on crutches and describe the commandant refusing to see them; we have told it from memory of those accounts and have not been able to check every detail against the original testimony.

The wording of the letter here is a paraphrase.

Survivors have recorded that in August 1943, prisoners who refused were taken by force, shut in the camp prison and operated on there, and that their block was punished.

The sit-down in the road is our dramatization of that refusal, not a recorded event.

**The rescue is real.**

In early February 1945, the rabbits learned that they were to be taken away and killed.

Other prisoners hid them, at roll call and afterward, gave them the numbers of the dead and moved some of them out to smaller camps under false identities; Krystyna Czyż, for example, reached Neustadt-Glewe, and freedom there in May 1945.

Sixty-three survived the war.

The words “You could say that the entire camp helped us, hid us, protected us” are those of a surviving rabbit, as quoted by the project Remember Ravensbrück.

The account of the lights failing that night is from memory, and we have not verified it.

Nuremberg and the fates of Gebhardt and Suhren are on the record.

The rest of it, the broom handle, the bad hip and the eleven miles, is only what we think it may have been like.

They were told to walk, and for a long time they did.

Then they stopped, and it took a great many people to move them.

You Might Also Enjoy