News

“Can You Cook?” The Nameless Gunslinger Asked The Apache Woman Tied To A Post By One Ankle Over A $14,000 Flour Contract… Her Answer Made Six Men Stop Laughing

They had tied her the way you tie a horse that will not stand for the farrier.

Elwood Swain had thought of it, and he was proud of it.

He had broken horses for twenty years, and he knew that an animal on three legs goes nowhere and does not need a man to watch it.

So he had lifted her left boot as high as it would go, lashed it against a pine hitching post in the middle of Main Street, and tied her hand up beside it where she could not reach the knot.

The other boot he left on the ground.

She could stand, if she kept her balance.

She could not do anything else.

Her name was Rufina Montoya.

She was twenty-nine years old, and until Saturday night she had been the best baker between Las Vegas and El Paso.

It was a few minutes before noon on Monday, the sixteenth of June, 1884, in the gold camp of Nogal, Lincoln County, New Mexico Territory.

The sun stood straight overhead, and the boardwalk threw the only shade in town.

Six men stood in it in a loose row with small glasses in their hands, watching her the way men watch a dull card game.

From somewhere up the canyon came the slow thud of the stamp mill at the Little Sister mine, which never stopped, day or night.

At the foot of the post lay a flour sack that somebody had slit with a knife, so that the whole town could see what she had used.

The flour had run out across the dirt in a long white tongue.

Forty people had been sick since Saturday.

She had baked the bread.

Then a man rode in from the Fort Stanton road, tied a tall bay horse to the rail, and walked out into the sun.

He wore a black hat and a heavy poncho in black and green, worked with white bands.

He did not look at the six men.

He did not, at first, look at her.

He looked at the ground.

Then he went down on one knee in the dust beside the spilled flour.

One of the men on the boardwalk laughed out loud.

The stranger took a pinch of the flour, rubbed it slowly between his thumb and his first finger, and held it close to his ear, as if it had said something.

He touched the thumb to his tongue.

He spat.

Then he looked up at the woman tied to the post, squinting against the light, and asked the last question anybody in Nogal expected to hear that day.

“Ma’am, can you cook?”

All six of them laughed now.

Rufina Montoya opened her eyes.

Her voice came out dry and cracked, and it carried all the way across the street.

“Better than any man on this street.”

She tipped her chin toward the porch of the Kuhn House, where a soft gray man in a good gray suit stood with his hands behind his back.

“Ask him why he won’t eat his own flour.”

The stranger looked at the man on the porch for some time.

Then he looked at Elwood Swain, and he did not raise his voice at all.

“Then untie her. He’ll eat what she bakes.”

They laughed at that too.

They had every reason to.

But by noon the next day, those six men would be white from their hats to their boots and sitting under guard, every woman in Nogal would be standing in Main Street holding up a glass of water, and the richest man in Lincoln County would be sitting on the hotel steps with a loaf of bread in his lap that he could not bring himself to bite.

The stranger would fire exactly one shot in all that time, and he would not fire it at a man.

And the only reason nobody fired back was something he had learned from a hole in the ground in Minneapolis.

—

## Why the best baker in Lincoln County learned her trade from bad bread

She had known what bad flour was before she knew how to read, because her aunt made sure of it.

Rufina was born Mescalero Apache, in the Sacramento Mountains, in 1855.

When the Army marched most of her people east to the Bosque Redondo on the Pecos, and put them on a flat, alkaline reservation with a few thousand Navajo and told them to become farmers, her grandmother kept the smallest ones hidden up in the high country.

Her aunt went.

What her aunt talked about afterward was not the soldiers.

It was the ration line.

The flour came in sacks, she said, and you mixed it with the bad water and baked it on a stone, and it did not rise.

It sat in the stomach like something you had been told to swallow on a dare.

On the night of the third of November, 1865, almost all the Mescalero got up and walked away from that place in the dark.

Her aunt walked home behind a stolen mule and never in her life let anyone in the family waste a spoonful of good flour.

At sixteen she went to work in the kitchens at Fort Stanton, because it paid in money, and there she met the post baker, a thick-armed Bavarian named Kuhn who had been in the Army so long that he swore in three languages at his dough.

He put her to scrubbing troughs.

Within three years, the officers’ wives were asking which of the men had made the rolls, and old Kuhn would look at the ceiling and say it was a military secret.

He taught her to judge an oven with her bare forearm and a loaf by knocking on it.

And he taught her one trick that he said was worth more than all the rest.

He took a clean glass, filled it with water, and stirred in a spoonful of flour.

“Now you wait as long as a prayer,” he told her.

Good flour clouded the water and hung there, slow as weather.

Anything that dropped quickly to the bottom and lay there in a hard white line was not flour, no matter what was stenciled on the sack.

When Kuhn left the Army in 1879, he and his wife Adelheid put their savings into a two-story hotel in the new gold camp of Nogal, and he asked Rufina to come along and run the ovens at a wage and a share.

He died two winters later with flour on his shirt.

Adelheid Kuhn, who could not bake and knew it, kept the name on the sign and left the kitchen alone.

So by the summer of 1884, miners were walking down from the Little Sister on their one free day for Rufina Montoya’s bread.

She bought her flour from an old water mill on the Ruidoso, and it cost her more than the store’s.

Then, in January, the Ruidoso froze, and the mill stopped, and for the first time in five years she had to buy from Jerome Ballantyne.

She opened the first sack on a Tuesday.

She made up the sponge the way she always did.

It did not rise.

She stood looking at it for a while.

Then she went and got a glass.

—

## The mill that ran all night and never shipped a bar of gold

Everybody in Nogal knew two things about Jerome Ballantyne.

He owned the only large store in the district, with a warehouse behind it the size of a church.

And he owned the Little Sister, which had the only stamp mill in the canyon and ran it all night long.

He was fifty-two, soft-spoken, a deacon in a town that had no church yet.

He had come out from Ohio after the war and had done well selling to the Army, and he had done better still selling to the Indian Bureau.

For three years he had held the contract to supply flour to the Mescalero agency at South Fork, two hundred thousand pounds at seven cents, fourteen thousand dollars.

On the fourth of the month his wagons went south, and every sack on them was stenciled in black, U.S.I.D., MESCALERO AGENCY, and every sack was weighed by the agent on a certified scale, and every sack was exactly right.

It was the same flour he sold across his own counter at eight cents a pound.

What Rufina had in her glass that January morning was a white line as thick as a wedding ring.

She did not shout about it.

She had learned a long time ago how far a cook’s word carried in a Lincoln County store.

She tasted it, and it was gritty and tasted of nothing at all.

She scraped a little of the line out of the glass, let it dry on the back of the oven, and it set hard as a chip of plate.

And she began to think about the wagons.

They came up from the south at night, four or five a month, from the Tularosa country, and the drivers said they were hauling salt.

But they did not stop at the store.

They went on up the canyon to the Little Sister.

And it occurred to her that in eighteen months of listening to that mill run all night, she had never once heard of anyone who had seen a bar of gold come out of it.

Sixty miles southwest of Nogal lay a sea of white dunes that nobody wanted, as far as the eye could carry.

It was gypsum, as fine and bright as flour and free to anyone with a shovel.

Run it under five stamps until it was powder, and it would go into a sack of flour one pound in four, and no scale in the Territory would know the difference.

Fifty thousand pounds of nothing a year, at seven cents.

Rufina started keeping the tins that week.

They were flat tobacco tins, the kind every miner threw away, and every time a new sack came into the Kuhn House she did the glass test, dried what fell, and put it in a tin with the date and the lot number scratched on the lid.

She pulled up a loose brick in the floor beneath her oven and put them there.

By June there were twenty-three.

She wrote twice to the agency at South Fork, through a cousin who could carry a letter.

Nobody answered.

Then, in the second week of June, word came that a United States Indian Inspector named Whitford would arrive on the Tuesday stage to look over the agency’s accounts and sign Ballantyne’s new contract for three more years.

He would be staying at the Kuhn House, and Rufina told Adelheid Kuhn that she meant to put twenty-three tobacco tins beside his breakfast.

She said it in her own kitchen, with the door open.

By supper, Jerome Ballantyne knew.

—

## What the deacon did not eat on Saturday night

He came to see her himself, which he had never done before.

He came in through the kitchen door on Thursday with his hat in his hand and said that he wished to give a supper on Saturday, at his own expense, for the leading people of the camp, in advance of the Inspector’s visit.

There would be forty at table.

And as a mark of his regard for the house, he would send over the flour.

Four sacks came within the hour.

She had them open before his wagon had turned around.

The line at the bottom of the glass was not as thick as a wedding ring.

It was as thick as her thumb.

She walked across the street in her apron and stood in front of his counter with the glass in her hand, in front of two customers and his clerk.

“That is not flour, Mr. Ballantyne. Near half of that is rock.”

He looked at the glass with mild interest and then he looked at her.

“Bake it,” he said.

She went back and told Adelheid she would not.

Adelheid Kuhn sat down on a flour barrel and began quietly to cry, and then she took a paper out of her apron and showed it to her.

It was a note on the hotel for eleven hundred dollars, with Jerome Ballantyne’s name at the bottom.

It came due whenever he said it did.

Rufina stood a long while with that paper in her hand.

Forty people would eat at that table whether she baked or not.

If she refused, she would be gone by Sunday, the house would be his by Monday, and the tins would go with the floor.

She baked it.

She blamed herself for that, for the rest of her life.

She made the loaves small and she made them few, and she cut them thin, and it was not enough.

Plaster does not poison a man.

It only sits in him.

By midnight on Saturday the doctor had been sent for four times, and by Sunday morning there were people lying on floors from one end of Nogal to the other, doubled up with cramps, and the doctor’s wife had moved a cot into the hotel dining room.

Nobody died, though two of the older men came close.

And on Saturday night, clearing the head table, Rufina Montoya had noticed one more thing.

There was a slice of her bread on every plate at that table, half eaten or eaten to the crust.

But at the place to the right of the mayor, beside a clean knife, the slice lay exactly as she had cut it.

He had sent her the worst four sacks he owned, and he had sat there all evening, smiling, and had not touched it.

They came for her on Monday morning.

Ballantyne did not come himself.

He stood on the Kuhn House porch while Elwood Swain and five others took her out through the dining room, past the cot.

He held a paper for her to sign, saying that she had put rat poison in the dough out of spite toward the people of the camp, and he explained to the street, in his soft voice, that she could sign it now or sign it when the Inspector arrived.

He wanted no violence.

He only wanted her where everyone could see her.

Nobody in Nogal would ever again listen to the woman who had poisoned the town, about flour or about anything else.

It was very neat.

She could almost admire it.

She had until ten o’clock on Tuesday morning, and she had one boot on the ground.

—

## Why a man would kneel in the dirt to taste what spilled

Now the stranger got to his feet, without hurrying, and brushed off his knee.

Elwood Swain stayed where he was, in the shade, with his glass.

He was a wide, pleasant-faced man in a black vest and a pale bandana, and he had stopped laughing, but only because he had finished.

“Who’s going to eat what, now?”

The stranger did not answer him.

He walked across to the porch steps and stopped at the bottom of them, and looked up at the man in the gray suit.

Jerome Ballantyne looked back at him kindly.

“Sir, I don’t know you, and I’m sure you mean well. That woman poisoned forty people in this town. If you’ve come looking for some kind of fee in the matter, I should tell you she hasn’t got any money.”

The stranger nodded, as if that were useful.

“Neither have I.”

Somebody laughed on the far side of the street.

It was a miner, one of a couple of dozen standing pale and hollow-eyed in the mouth of the alley.

“You say that’s clean flour?” the stranger said.

“I say that’s the best flour in the Territory. I sell it to the United States government.”

“And she spoiled it?”

“She did.”

“Then it’s a simple thing. You’ve got a warehouse full of it. She’ll bake a loaf out of your sack tomorrow, right here in the street, when your Inspector gets in. Anybody who likes can watch her do it. And then you eat it.”

“If you’re standing at sundown, I’ll say I was wrong, in front of everybody, and I’ll ride on. It’s your flour. You can’t be scared of your own flour.”

Ballantyne smiled, but he took a moment to do it.

He looked across at the miners in the alley, and at the windows above the store, where the women had begun to come and stand.

He had spent three days making sure that all of Nogal was watching this post.

He could see as well as anyone what it would look like now if he said no.

“Tomorrow at ten,” he said gently.

“With pleasure. She’ll want to rest. She may remain where she is until then.”

“No,” the stranger said.

He turned around and walked back out across the sun to the post, and he stopped in front of Elwood Swain, closer than was comfortable.

His hands hung loose.

The revolver stayed where it was, in a worn holster on his right hip, and he did not look at it, and neither, after the first second, did anyone else.

“That’s your knot,” he said.

“A horse-breaker ought to know how it comes out.”

For a moment nobody moved.

Then Swain looked past him, up at the porch, and something in the gray man’s face told him it did not matter, it was only until morning.

He set his glass down on the rail and stepped out into the sun.

When the boot came down, she did not fall.

When the stranger offered her his arm she looked at it and did not take it.

She walked to the kitchen door of the Kuhn House by herself.

It was forty-one steps, and everyone on Main Street counted them.

Jerome Ballantyne watched her go, and then he leaned over and spoke quietly to Elwood Swain.

He had twenty-two hours and three hundred sacks to get rid of.

—

## What the stranger’s brother had been sweeping on the second of May

She sat with her foot in a bucket of cold water and looked at him across her own kitchen table.

He had eaten the heel of a Ruidoso loaf from before the Saturday sacks, and he had eaten it very slowly with his eyes shut.

“You knew before you asked me,” she said.

He held up his right hand and rubbed the thumb against the finger.

“My father ran a mill on the Genesee, at Rochester. So did his. You can tell a miller by that thumb, it goes flat. Flour ought to feel like nothing, like silk. That out there feels like a schoolhouse floor.”

“Who are you?”

“Merriam. Truman Merriam. I was riding through, and I was hungry.”

She pulled up the loose brick and set the tins on the table one at a time, all twenty-three, and told him about the mill that ran all night.

He read the lids.

He opened one and rubbed what was in it.

“Why isn’t a miller’s son in a mill?” she said.

He was a while answering.

“My brother Daniel went out to Minneapolis to work for Mr. Washburn. Biggest flour mill in the world. On the second of May, 1878, he was on the evening shift, sweeping. Nobody knows what started it, a spark off a millstone most likely. It’s not the flour that does it, you understand. Flour in a sack is about as dangerous as a pillow. It’s flour in the air. It was a fine clear evening and there were people who heard it in St. Paul. Fourteen men in that mill, and none of them came out. I went out and looked at the hole.”

He closed the tin and set it back in its place in the row.

“After that I didn’t want to be around a mill. But it seems I couldn’t stay away from the stuff altogether. I came out here and hired on riding guard for the flour wagons to Fort Stanton.”

She studied him for a moment.

Then she took the tin out of his hand and pulled the brick back over the hole.

“He won’t eat it,” she said.

“No.”

“He never meant to. Three hundred sacks stenciled for the agency, in a pine building. A fire in a warehouse is a hard thing to blame on anybody. Tomorrow there’s no flour but what I say there was, and I’m the poisoner.”

“When?”

“Tonight. He has no other night.”

“I expect that’s right.”

“I’ve been buying from that warehouse since January, Mr. Merriam, and before that I carried Kuhn’s orders there for four years. I know where the stairs are. And there’s forty sacks up on the loft sling that they haul with a rope through a block, right over the middle of the floor, because the loft boards won’t hold the weight.”

For the first time, something moved at the corner of his mouth.

“Does your foot hurt?”

“Yes,” she said.

She went to the drawer and took out her bread knife.

“Does that matter?”

—

## The two o’clock air in the Ballantyne warehouse

They heard the wagon first, a little after two, coming up the alley with sacking wrapped around the wheels.

They had been lying in the loft for four hours in the dark.

It smelled of burlap and mice.

Rufina had spent the first of those hours working her way along the sling on her belly, and with her bread knife she had opened every one of the forty sacks hanging there, a hand’s width along the bottom seam.

Below them the big door rolled back.

Six men came in.

The one in front carried a lantern with the wick turned low, and he was young and nervous, a mucker from the Little Sister named Peavy, twenty-four years old, who had taken Ballantyne’s dollar that morning and was beginning to wish he had not.

Behind him came Elwood Swain, and behind Swain two men with a pair of five-gallon cans.

The smell of coal oil came up through the boards.

Swain’s voice was low and cheerful.

They would load the dozen clean sacks by the door, the ones the Inspector would be shown, pulled out by brave men from the flames.

Everything else would go.

The men with the cans walked out into the middle of the floor.

They stood directly under the sling.

Merriam was lying on his chest at the edge of the loft, with his revolver in his hand and his elbow on a beam.

He had looked at the block and the rope a long time before dark.

He looked at it now.

It was about forty feet away, and he could see only a pale line of it against the lantern light.

He breathed out and fired.

The noise in that closed building was enormous.

Nobody below had time to look up.

The rope parted with a sound like a slap, the block screamed, and four thousand pounds of flour came down fourteen feet into the middle of the floor all at once.

The two men with the cans got out from under it by the width of a hand.

The sacks hit and burst, and the floor of the warehouse jumped, and a great soft wave of white rose up from it and rolled out in every direction and went up to the rafters and came down again.

And then there was no warehouse.

There was only the air.

It was like being inside a cloud with a small dirty sun in it.

That was the lantern.

It hung in the whiteness about thirty feet from the door, and it was shaking, and around it a faint golden ring had begun to appear in the air.

Somebody was coughing.

Somebody was cursing, and then Elwood Swain’s voice came out of the white, thick and furious, and the sound of a hammer going back came with it.

“Where are you, you son of a—”

“Don’t.”

It came from above them, somewhere.

It was not loud.

Nobody could have said how far off it was.

“I’d think about that thumb, Mr. Swain. I’d think about it very hard. Look at that lantern. Do you see that ring around it? Do you see the little sparks going up?”

Nobody breathed.

There was a tiny crackling, like somebody walking on dry grass a long way off.

“That’s flour burning. A speck at a time. My brother Daniel swept the floor at the Washburn A mill in Minneapolis, six years ago last month. He was standing in air just like this when somebody’s millstone threw a spark. They heard it in St. Paul. It took out two other mills beside it, and there was nothing of my brother to bury. Now, you’ve got a pistol in your hand. It throws two feet of fire out the front of it. You go ahead and pull that trigger, and I expect that nobody within a quarter mile will ever have to worry about flour again.”

Silence.

A long, sifting silence.

“Peavy,” the voice said.

“That’s your name? You’ve got the lantern?”

“Yes, sir.”

It was hardly a voice at all.

“Son, you’re doing fine. Don’t swing it. Don’t set it down. If you drop it, the glass breaks. Just hold it right there, as still as you’ve ever held anything in your life.”

“I can’t,” Peavy said.

“I can’t, mister, my arm’s going.”

That was when they heard somebody on the ladder.

The rungs creaked one at a time.

A shape came down through the white, not fast, favoring one foot.

It stepped off onto the burst sacks and it walked straight out across the floor, past a man with a coal oil can who was standing frozen with his mouth open.

It walked past Elwood Swain, close enough to touch, close enough that he could see the bread knife in her apron string, with his pistol in his hand and the hammer back and nothing whatever that he could do with it.

She did not look at him.

She walked to the young man with the lantern and stopped in front of him, and she was so white that her eyes looked like holes.

“Look at me,” she said.

“Not at it. What’s your mother’s name?”

“Ma’am?”

“Your mother.”

“Ellen. Ellen, ma’am.”

She reached up and closed her fingers over the wire bail, over his fingers, and she held it.

Her hand was as steady as it had been on ten thousand loaves.

“When I say so, Ellen’s boy, you open your hand, and you stand right where you are. Now.”

He opened his hand.

She turned and started for the door.

It was thirty feet.

She knew, because she had crossed that floor with Kuhn’s orders for four years.

She carried the lantern out low and well away from her body, and she took each step the way you take a step on a frozen river, and the bad foot dragged a little.

The golden ring went along with her.

It was brighter now.

Sparks the size of pinheads were going up past her wrist and winking out, and some of them were not winking out as quickly as they had.

Nobody in the building did anything at all.

There were six armed men in there and the most dangerous man in Lincoln County up in the rafters, and every one of them stood and watched a cook walk across a floor.

Twenty feet.

Fifteen.

Something behind her settled with a soft thump, and the whole cloud stirred and rolled toward her back.

She did not hurry.

It was the hardest thing she ever did, and she did not hurry.

Ten feet.

She stepped through the big door into the night, and it was like coming up from under water.

The stars were all out.

She walked eleven more paces across the yard, to the horse trough beside the wagon, and she lowered the lantern into it, and it went out with a little hiss.

Then her knees let go, and she sat down in the dirt beside the trough and stayed there a moment, holding on to the edge of it.

Inside, in the black, the voice spoke again, and it sounded a little tired.

“Well. That’s the lantern. It’s still no place for gunpowder, gentlemen, and it won’t be for some time. Let’s have those pistols on the floor, one at a time and gently. Then I’d walk out that door, slow, with my hands where the lady can see them. She has a knife, and she’s had a very long day.”

They came out one by one over the next five minutes, into the starlight.

They were white from their hats to their boots.

They looked like six men made of plaster.

—

## What every woman in Nogal did with a glass of water

The Tuesday stage from Fort Stanton pulled in at ten minutes to ten.

Inspector Whitford, a long, dry, tired Vermonter with a carpetbag full of Bureau forms, climbed down into what looked to him like a county fair.

All of Nogal was in Main Street.

There were six men sitting in a row on the edge of the boardwalk, with a deputy from Lincoln holding a shotgun across his knees, and they had been allowed to wash their hands but not much else.

There was a plank table set out in the sun by the pine post.

Behind it stood a woman in a clean apron, with a bad foot, who had been up since four.

And on the hotel steps, in a fresh gray suit, stood Jerome Ballantyne.

Drunken men had broken into his warehouse, he said in his soft voice, before the Inspector had set down his bag.

The poisoner had plainly been a party to it.

Whitford looked at him and looked at the row of white men.

He had been looking at contractors for eleven years.

“I was told there would be bread,” he said.

Rufina Montoya set two loaves on the plank.

One of them was high and brown and split along the top.

She had made it with the last of her Ruidoso flour, and when she tore the end off it the steam came out and the smell went down the street, and people who had not been able to look at food since Saturday turned their heads.

The other she had made an hour earlier, in the same oven, from a sack with U.S.I.D. stenciled on it that the deputy had dragged out of the warehouse himself.

It was the color of a dishrag and half the height of the first.

She picked it up and knocked it against the post, and it made the sound of a stick on a fence.

She said nothing about it.

She filled a clean glass from a pitcher, took a spoonful of flour from the deputy’s sack, stirred it, and stood it on the plank in the sun, where the Inspector could look through it.

“As long as a prayer,” she said.

Everybody watched the glass.

It took a little under a minute.

The cloud thinned from the top, and at the bottom a hard white line began to form and grow, and by the time it stopped growing it was as thick as a wedding ring.

“Mr. Reinholt,” said Whitford, who had seen a good many things in glasses.

The assayer had a shop next to the barber and a face like a sad owl.

He took the sediment on a spoon, held it in the flame of a spirit lamp for a while, added three drops of water, and stirred it with a matchstick.

Then he stood there with his watch in his other hand, as if he were waiting for a train.

After about four minutes he turned the spoon upside down.

Nothing fell.

“Sulphate of lime,” he said, in his sad voice.

“Plaster, you would say. From the white sands, I think, by the fineness. I have never before seen it in a sack that said flour on the outside.”

That was when Adelheid Kuhn came down off her own porch.

She was a heavy, frightened woman of sixty, carrying a water glass in both hands, as if it might bite her.

She had gone back to her own pantry and opened the barrel that came from Ballantyne’s store at eight cents a pound, for her own table.

She set the glass on the plank next to the other one.

It had a white line at the bottom.

Nobody said anything.

But across the way, the doctor’s wife turned and walked quickly into her house.

Then every woman on Main Street seemed to think of the same thing at once.

They went off through the doors and up the alleys with their skirts in their fists.

They came back carrying tumblers, jelly jars, tin cups, a cut-glass goblet that had come from Boston.

By a quarter to eleven, sixty-one glasses of water stood along the boardwalk rail in the sun, in front of the row of white men, from the hotel to the barber’s.

And all of them, every one that had come from Ballantyne’s store, had a line in the bottom.

They had been putting it on their own tables for a year and a half.

Nobody shouted.

They just stood there holding up their glasses and looking at the man on the hotel steps.

Truman Merriam walked over to the plank and picked up the gray loaf.

He carried it across the street, with the whole town watching, and he held it out.

“It’s your flour,” he said.

“I asked you yesterday. Nobody’s put anything in that but you.”

Jerome Ballantyne looked at the loaf.

He opened his mouth, and for the first time since anyone had known him, nothing came out of it.

His knees bent slowly, and he sat down on the second step.

Merriam put the loaf in his lap, and stepped back.

The woman with the bad foot had come across the street behind him.

She stopped in front of the steps.

She held out the bread knife, handle first.

“Eat it,” said Rufina Montoya.

He took hold of the loaf with both of his soft white hands, and he lifted it a little way.

They could all see him smell it.

Up the canyon, in the silence, you could hear the stamp mill going, thud, thud, thud.

He held it there.

He held it for four minutes by the Inspector’s watch, and a fly walked across the crust.

Then he lowered it to his knees again.

“I’m not hungry,” he said.

You could barely hear him.

She looked at him for a while.

“No,” she said.

“You weren’t on Saturday, either.”

—

## The name Elwood Swain had been trying to remember

It was Swain who broke first, and he did it before lunch.

He sat in the back room of the barbershop with the deputy and the Inspector, and he told them about the wagons, and the dunes, and the five stamps at the Little Sister, which by that afternoon had been shut down for the first time in two years.

They found forty tons of white powder in the bins up there, and no sign that anyone had broken a pound of ore since 1882.

He told them, too, about the four sacks for the Saturday supper, which Ballantyne had had mixed specially, half and half, and carried over himself.

When he had finished, he asked if he could ask something.

He asked it of the man in the poncho, who had come in and was sitting by the door with his hat on his knee.

“The Bonito road,” Swain said.

“Seventy-nine. There was eleven of us stopped a flour train at the ford, boys left over from the troubles. Fella on the lead wagon wouldn’t get down. He just sat there on the load with that blanket on, looking at us. Somebody asks him who he was, and he says, nobody, I ride with the flour. Then he shoots the hat off Johnny Bell, and Johnny sits down in the creek, and nobody’s hurt, and we all went home. Las Vegas paper had it in. They called him the nameless gunslinger of the Bonito.”

He stared at the poncho a while.

“I thought you was bigger,” he said.

“People do,” Truman Merriam said.

—

## What the United States did with a deacon

Inspector Whitford tore the new contract in two across the plank table and put the pieces in his carpetbag as evidence.

He stayed in Nogal for nine days, and he ate at the Kuhn House, and he asked to have his glass of water brought with his bread.

Jerome Ballantyne was tried in Santa Fe the following spring for defrauding the government and was given three years.

His store and his note on the hotel went to his creditors, and Adelheid Kuhn paid off the note, slowly, over six years, at a rate the court set.

Elwood Swain did a year.

Peavy turned state’s evidence and went to work for the mill on the Ruidoso, and it was said that he never again smoked a pipe indoors.

The flour for the Mescalero agency that winter came from the mill on the Ruidoso too.

Some of the older people at South Fork stirred the first of it into a cup before they would touch it.

They had heard.

—

## The man who left before the loaf was cold

He rode out the same Tuesday, late in the afternoon, when the street had finally emptied.

She found him at the rail, tightening his cinch.

She was carrying something wrapped in a clean flour sack, and it was warm.

“I owe you for something,” she said.

“I don’t know what the rate is.”

“Ma’am, you walked a lantern out of there. I only shot a rope.”

“I told you. She hasn’t got any money.”

“Neither have I.”

She held out the bundle.

He unwrapped one corner of it, and took out his knife and cut off the heel.

He stood there in the long light beside the empty post, and he chewed it slowly with his eyes shut, for as long as it took.

Then he opened his eyes.

“Well?” she said.

“You can cook,” said Truman Merriam.

He wrapped the rest up and put it in his saddlebag, and he got up on the tall bay horse and rode out by the Fort Stanton road.

So far as is known, she never saw him again.

The next year Rufina Montoya took over the empty store building across from the hotel, with Adelheid Kuhn’s blessing and a loan from the sad assayer.

She had one sign painted, R.

MONTOYA, BREAD, and she had no place to hang it, so she had it nailed to the pine post out in front, which nobody had ever gotten around to pulling up.

And on the counter, beside the till, she kept a pitcher of water and a row of clean glasses and a jar of spoons.

Any customer could take a spoonful out of any sack in the place and stir it, and stand there as long as a prayer.

Most of them did, the first time.

Then they stopped.

She ran that bakery for thirty-one years.

There is a story that sometime around 1900, a young drummer came in from the Carrizozo road, a smart man in a checked suit, selling baking powder.

He leaned on her counter and looked at the small gray-haired woman with the limp.

“Ma’am,” he said, “can you cook?”

She looked at him.

She looked for a moment out the window, at the post.

Then she reached for a glass.

—

## What is real in this story, and what is told

The people in this story are invented.

There was no Rufina Montoya, no Truman Merriam, no Jerome Ballantyne, Elwood Swain, Adelheid Kuhn, Inspector Whitford, or Mr. Reinholt, and there was no Little Sister mine or Kuhn House at Nogal.

The flour contract, the supper, the warehouse, and the sixty-one glasses belong to the story.

The setting is real.

Nogal was a gold-mining camp in Lincoln County, New Mexico Territory, near Fort Stanton, which was an Army post in those years.

The Mescalero people were confined with the Navajo at the Bosque Redondo on the Pecos River in the 1860s, under hard conditions and short and poor rations, and on the night of November 3, 1865, most of the Mescalero walked away.

The detail about the flour her aunt remembers is ours.

Contracts to supply Indian agencies and Army posts were a notorious source of fraud in the Southwest, and Lincoln County’s own troubles of the late 1870s grew in part out of the fight over them.

Adulterating flour with plaster and other white powders was a real complaint of the age.

The white sands of the Tularosa Basin really are gypsum, which is what plaster is made from, and burned gypsum really does set hard when it is wet.

The water-glass test here is a storyteller’s simplified version.

The Washburn A mill in Minneapolis really did explode on May 2, 1878, from flour dust in the air.

Eighteen people died, the blast destroyed two neighboring mills, and it changed how flour mills were built.

Daniel Merriam is invented.

The men who died that evening were not.

Those are the true threads.

Everything woven between them is a story.

You Might Also Enjoy