1554: Henry VIII’s Niece Was Passed Over for the Throne. Her Daughter Was Made Queen for Nine Days. The Mother Survived. The Daughter Did Not
The road into Essex was dark, and the horses were tired.
It was the last week of July 1553, high summer, and even at night the air over the fields smelled of cut hay and dust.
A small party of riders was moving east, away from London, as fast as the road and the darkness allowed.
At the center of it rode a woman of thirty-six.
She was a duchess.
She was the niece of the late King Henry VIII, the daughter of his favorite sister, the granddaughter of the first Tudor king.
Three weeks earlier, she had been the mother of the Queen of England.
Now her daughter was a prisoner in the Tower of London.
Her husband had just been taken to the Tower as well.
And the woman she was riding to see, the new queen, Mary Tudor, was her own first cousin.
They had grown up together.
When she was a baby, Mary had been one of her godmothers.
Somewhere ahead in the dark stood Beaulieu, a great brick palace near Chelmsford that had once belonged to Anne Boleyn’s father, where Mary had stopped on her slow, triumphant road to London.
There would be guards at the gate.
There would be courtiers who had sworn loyalty to her daughter only days before and were now very eager to forget it.
And there would be Mary herself, who had every reason in the world to hate this family.
The rider’s name was Frances.
She was not coming to plead for the crown.
That was already gone.
She was coming to plead for the lives of the people she loved.
How much was she willing to give up to save them?
—
Frances Brandon is one of the most familiar faces in Tudor history, and one of the least known.
Almost everyone who has heard of Lady Jane Grey, the girl who was queen for nine days, has heard of her mother, and almost everything they have heard is bad.
She was the cold, ambitious mother, the story goes, who beat her gentle daughter, forced her into a marriage she hated, pushed her onto a throne, and then calmly married a young servant a few weeks after her daughter and husband were dead.
Some of that story is true.
Much of it was written long after anyone who knew her was alive.
And one of the most famous “facts” about her rests on a painting of a different woman entirely.
What really happened to Frances in the year she lost everything is stranger, and sadder, than the legend.
It begins in a bishop’s house in Hertfordshire, with a king who still had no son.
It runs through Henry VIII’s last will, a document that quietly took something away from her that she had been born to.
It reaches its worst point in a cold February, when the cousin she had knelt to signed two warrants, one after the other.
And it ends in Westminster Abbey, where Frances lies today under an alabaster figure of herself, beneath an inscription that names her parents and both of her husbands.
It does not name a single one of her children.
People still point to that as proof of what kind of mother she was.
The real reason is written in the year carved at the end of the tomb.
—
## Why a baby girl in Hertfordshire mattered to a king with no son
Frances was born on July 16, 1517, at Hatfield, in Hertfordshire, in a house that belonged to the bishop of Ely.
Her mother was Mary Tudor, Henry VIII’s younger sister, who had been Queen of France for less than three months before her old husband died.
Everyone at court still called her “the French Queen,” and she would carry that title until the end of her life.
Her father was Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, the king’s closest friend.
Two years earlier, in Paris, the widowed queen and the king’s friend had married in secret, without Henry’s permission, and it had very nearly ruined them both.
Henry forgave them, for a heavy price.
By 1517 the scandal was over, and the French Queen was having children.
A son, Henry, had been born the year before.
Now there was a daughter.
Her name may have been chosen in honor of Saint Francis, or, as some historians think, of the young King of France, Francis I, whose court her mother had so recently left.
Her godmothers were the most important women in England.
One was Queen Catherine of Aragon.
The other was the king’s only child, Princess Mary, who was seventeen months old.
The little princess could not have held anything heavier than a rattle, and like the queen she would have been represented at the font by a lady of the court.
But the choice said something.
In the summer of 1517, Henry VIII had been married for eight years and had one living child, a daughter.
His sons had died.
His sister’s children were royal blood, close to the throne, and the king wanted the world to see them gathered close to his own family.
Nobody at that christening could have imagined how close.
—
## The wedding, and the funeral seven weeks later
Frances grew up mostly in Suffolk, at her father’s house at Westhorpe, with her brother Henry and, from around 1519, a younger sister named Eleanor.
Her parents’ marriage had begun in a way that made lawyers nervous, because Charles Brandon had been entangled with two earlier wives before he married the French Queen.
In 1528 the Pope issued a bull confirming that his marriage to Mary was valid and that her children were legitimate.
It mattered.
A girl whose parents’ marriage could be questioned was a girl whose place in the succession could be questioned too.
In 1533, when she was about fifteen, Frances was married to Henry Grey, Marquess of Dorset.
He was almost exactly her age, the head of an old and proud family whose great house stood at Bradgate, in Leicestershire.
He had been promised to another girl, the Earl of Arundel’s daughter, and broke the engagement to marry the king’s niece instead.
The wedding took place at Suffolk Place, her father’s great house in Southwark, across the river from the City of London.
It was the same spring that Henry VIII married Anne Boleyn and had her crowned.
Frances’s mother did not live to see the summer out.
The French Queen had been ill for some time.
She died at Westhorpe on June 25, 1533, at thirty-seven.
Her body lay at Westhorpe for weeks while the heralds prepared a funeral fit for a queen.
When the procession finally wound into the great abbey church at Bury St Edmunds, the chief mourner walking behind the coffin was her eldest daughter.
Frances had turned sixteen only days before.
She had been a wife for a matter of weeks.
Within months, her father had married again.
The next spring, her only full brother died.
By the time she turned seventeen, Frances was the eldest surviving child of the king’s sister.
She was, in plain terms, one of the most valuable women in England.
And her own life was about to become a matter for the king’s lawyers.
—
## The children who lived, and the ones who did not
The first years of the Dorset marriage are mostly silent in the records.
There were children.
A son, given his father’s name, and a daughter both died very young, so early that even their birth dates have been lost.
Then, probably in the autumn of 1537, a daughter was born who lived.
She was named Jane.
Many historians think she was named after the queen of that year, Jane Seymour, whose son, the long-awaited Prince Edward, was born at Hampton Court in October 1537.
If so, it was a tactful choice.
A royal cousin naming her daughter after the queen was a way of saying, without words, which side she was on.
A second daughter, Katherine, followed in August 1540.
A third, Mary, was born around 1545.
She was very small, smaller than other children her age, and she would grow up with a curved spine.
The family’s life moved between London, the court and Bradgate, a rose-red brick house set in a deer park of rocky hills, oak trees and bracken north-west of Leicester.
It was one of the first great country houses in England built of brick, and the Greys were proud of it.
Frances loved to ride and to hunt in that park.
Her husband loved learning, or at least loved to be seen as a patron of learning, and he filled the house with scholars and with books.
Jane was the one who took to them.
By the time she was nine or ten she was reading Latin and Greek, writing to Protestant scholars on the Continent, and impressing visitors who were not easily impressed.
Frances served the queens who came and went in her uncle’s life.
As one of the highest-ranking ladies in England, she had a place at the great court occasions of those years, from the reception of new queens to the funerals of old ones.
She stood very close to the throne.
Closer, in fact, than she knew.
Because in 1546, a dying king was already deciding what to do with her.
—
## What Henry VIII wrote about her in his will
By the end of 1546, Henry VIII was enormously fat, often in pain, and rarely seen outside his own rooms.
He had three living children.
Edward was nine.
Mary and Elizabeth had both been declared illegitimate, and both had since been restored to the line of succession by an Act of Parliament in 1544.
That same Act gave the king a power no English king had ever had.
If all three of his children died without heirs, Henry could decide by his own will who would come next.
He used it.
The will was dated December 30, 1546, a month before he died.
After Edward, Mary and Elizabeth and any children they might have, the crown was to pass to the descendants of his younger sister, the French Queen.
Not to the descendants of his elder sister Margaret, the Queen of Scots, whose granddaughter was the infant Mary, Queen of Scots.
That whole branch of the family was left out.
But there was something stranger in the will.
The crown was not left to Frances.
It was left to Frances’s heirs.
Her children, and their children, were placed in the line of succession.
Frances herself, the eldest surviving daughter of the French Queen, the woman whose blood gave her daughters their claim in the first place, was simply passed over.
The same was done to her younger sister, Eleanor.
Nobody knows exactly why.
Some historians think Henry did not want a woman of his own generation, with a husband of her own, standing next in line behind his young son.
A girl could be guided.
A grown woman with a powerful husband might have ideas of her own.
Others think it was simply a lawyer’s way of reaching further into the future.
Whatever the reason, the effect was clear.
When Henry VIII died, in the early hours of January 28, 1547, Frances was twenty-nine years old.
Her uncle had made her daughters heirs to the throne of England.
He had made her the one person in her own family who could not inherit it.
She would have to watch it happen from one step away.
—
## The schoolmaster who came to Bradgate
In the summer of 1550, a Cambridge scholar named Roger Ascham rode up to Bradgate.
He was a famous teacher who had been tutor to the king’s sister Elizabeth, and he had come to visit the household’s learned young daughter.
When he arrived, the house was nearly empty.
The duke and duchess, and almost everyone else, were out hunting in the park.
Jane had stayed behind.
Ascham found her alone in her chamber, reading Plato in the original Greek.
He asked her, as he later told it, why she would miss such a pleasure.
She told him that all their sport in the park was only a shadow of the pleasure she found in Plato.
Then she said something that would follow her mother for nearly five hundred years.
According to Ascham, she told him that God had given her sharp, severe parents and a gentle schoolmaster.
When she was with her father or mother, whatever she did, whether she spoke or kept silent, sat, stood or went, ate, drank, sewed or played, she had to do it perfectly.
If she did not, she was so sharply taunted and threatened, she said, and sometimes punished with “pinches, nips and bobs,” and in other ways she would not name out of respect for them, that she thought herself in hell until it was time to go back to her teacher.
It is a terrible picture, and it is the main reason Frances has been remembered as a monster.
But look at how it reached us.
Ascham did not publish it in 1550.
He wrote it down years later, in a book about education called *The Scholemaster*, which was only printed in 1570, after his death, when Jane, her father and her mother had all been dead for many years.
Soon after the visit itself, he wrote to Jane and spoke warmly of her parents.
The words are the memory of one conversation with a girl of about twelve or thirteen, recalled by a man who was writing a book arguing that children learn better through kindness than through fear.
That does not make them false.
Tudor parents, especially great ones, were often harsh with their children by any modern standard, and Jane may well have been describing exactly what her life was like.
But it is one source.
And much of the rest of Frances’s evil reputation was built on top of it later, by writers who added things Ascham never said.
The story that Frances beat Jane into marrying the man she would later be forced to wed does not appear until the early eighteenth century.
There is no evidence for it at all.
In 1551, Frances’s two young half-brothers, her father’s sons by his second marriage, died within an hour of each other of the sweating sickness.
Through her, the title of Duke of Suffolk was given to her husband.
The Greys had never stood higher.
They were about to meet the man who would bring them all down.
—
## The wedding at Durham House
By 1553, the most powerful man in England was John Dudley, Duke of Northumberland.
He ran the government in the name of the boy king, Edward VI, who was now fifteen, fiercely Protestant and, by the spring of that year, very seriously ill.
If Edward died, the crown would go to his half-sister Mary.
Mary was a devout Catholic.
Everything Northumberland and the Protestant lords had built in Edward’s reign would be undone, and Northumberland himself might well lose his head.
On May 25, 1553, Whitsunday, three couples were married on the same day in a splendid ceremony at Durham House, Northumberland’s palace on the Strand.
One of them was Jane Grey and Guildford Dudley, Northumberland’s son.
Another was Jane’s younger sister Katherine, who was twelve, married to the Earl of Pembroke’s son.
The guests were dazzled by the gowns and the jewels, many of them supplied from the royal wardrobe.
What exactly Frances thought of her eldest daughter’s marriage, nobody wrote down.
What happened next, at least in part, was written down by Edward himself.
The dying king had drafted a document in his own hand, headed “My devise for the succession.”
In its first version, it left the crown, after his own death, to any sons that Frances might have.
There were none.
Frances was thirty-five.
She had not had a living son in all her married life.
At some point that spring, as Edward grew weaker, the wording was changed.
By the usual reading of the surviving page, a few words were altered so that the crown no longer went to the sons of Frances, or even to the sons of Jane, but to “the Lady Jane” herself and her heirs.
Frances, who would have been next in line under any normal reckoning once Mary and Elizabeth were set aside, was passed over for a second time.
This time it was not by her uncle, but by her nephew.
According to one later account, Frances was at first outraged.
Then she had a private audience with the king.
When she came out, she had agreed to stand aside and give up her own claim in favor of her daughter.
We do not know what was said in that room.
We do not know whether she was persuaded, frightened, flattered or simply told.
On June 21, 1553, the lords of the council and the judges set their names to letters patent confirming the new order.
Edward VI died at Greenwich on the evening of July 6, 1553.
He was fifteen.
For three days, his death was kept quiet.
Then Jane was summoned.
—
## The nine days
On July 9, at Syon House beside the Thames, the lords knelt to a girl of fifteen or sixteen and told her that she was Queen of England.
By her own later account, she fell to the ground and wept, and said the crown was not her right.
She accepted it anyway.
The next day, July 10, she traveled down the river by barge to the Tower of London, where English monarchs traditionally waited before their coronation.
The guns fired a salute.
According to one account, it was her mother who walked behind her, carrying the long train of her gown.
If so, it is one of the strangest pictures in the whole story.
The king’s niece, who had been passed over twice, walking behind her own child into the royal apartments, holding up the hem of the dress.
The heralds proclaimed Queen Jane in the streets of London.
The crowds were quiet.
Hardly anyone cheered.
Mary, meanwhile, had not waited to be arrested.
She had ridden hard into East Anglia, proclaimed herself queen, and gathered an army of gentlemen and their tenants at Framlingham Castle in Suffolk.
The people of England, it turned out, did not care much for Northumberland’s plan.
They cared a great deal that Mary was King Henry’s daughter.
Northumberland marched out of London to face her on July 14.
Behind him, one by one, the lords of the council slipped out of the Tower.
On July 19, they proclaimed Mary queen in the City, and the bells of London rang all evening while people threw their caps in the air and lit bonfires in the streets.
Inside the Tower, Frances’s husband told his daughter that she was no longer queen.
The story goes that he pulled down the cloth of state that hung above her chair with his own hands.
He then went out onto Tower Hill and proclaimed Mary himself.
Jane stayed where she was.
The royal apartments became her prison.
Northumberland was arrested in Cambridge.
Within days, Frances’s husband was taken back into the Tower too.
For a short time, by the Abbey’s own account of her life, Frances was held there as well.
Her daughter was a prisoner.
Her husband was a prisoner.
Every man who had stood behind them was either in a cell or very busy proving that he had always been loyal to Mary.
That was when Frances got on her horse.
—
## What she said to her cousin
Mary’s journey toward London was slow, because everyone in the kingdom wanted to meet her on the way.
At the end of July she was at Beaulieu, the great house in Essex that her father had bought from the Boleyns and named for beauty.
Frances arrived there, by one account, on July 29.
She had ridden through the night.
No one recorded the words that passed between the two women.
What we can say is what each of them brought into the room.
Mary was thirty-seven, about to be the first queen to rule England in her own right.
For twenty years she had been humiliated, separated from her mother, declared a bastard, and forced to sign away her own legitimacy.
Now, after all of it, she had won.
She was also, by most accounts, a woman who took her faith and her friendships seriously, and who did not like to shed blood unless she felt she had to.
Frances was thirty-six.
She had known Mary since they were children at their uncle’s court.
Mary had stood, by proxy, at her christening.
Frances’s mother had loved Mary’s mother.
And Frances had just been part of a plan to rob Mary of her throne and give it to Frances’s own child.
There was no easy way to begin.
There were only the facts.
Her husband had proclaimed Mary queen himself, from Tower Hill, as soon as he could.
Her daughter had not asked for the crown.
The man who had wanted it was Northumberland, and Northumberland was now in the Tower.
Some historians believe Frances went further and told Mary that Northumberland had tried to poison her husband.
Whatever she said, it worked.
On July 31, Frances’s husband walked out of the Tower a free man.
He was pardoned and allowed to go home.
He had been inside for only a few days.
Jane did not come out.
But there was real reason for hope.
Mary told the imperial ambassador that she could not bring herself to put her young cousin to death.
The girl had been a tool in other men’s hands, the queen said, and was not truly guilty.
Northumberland went to the scaffold on Tower Hill on August 22, 1553.
Jane stayed in the Tower, in the house of the gentleman gaoler, with her own servants around her.
In November, she was taken through the streets to the Guildhall with her husband and two of his brothers and tried for treason.
She pleaded guilty.
She was sentenced to die, by burning or beheading, at the queen’s pleasure.
Everyone understood that the queen’s pleasure, for now, was mercy.
Frances, meanwhile, was at court.
Mary kept her close and treated her as a cousin.
There were even reports that the queen gave Frances and her own cousin Margaret Douglas a higher place at court than Mary’s own half-sister, Elizabeth.
It must have seemed that the worst was over.
All the family had to do now was wait quietly.
Frances’s husband could not wait.
—
## The cold February
In January 1554, a group of gentlemen decided to stop Mary from marrying Prince Philip of Spain.
The plan was for several risings at once, in Kent, in the West Country, in Wales and in the Midlands.
The Kent rising, under Sir Thomas Wyatt, was the only one that became serious.
But on about January 25, Frances’s husband slipped away from his house at Sheen, by the river near Richmond, and rode north into Leicestershire to raise his own tenants.
Nobody knows for certain what he meant to do.
He seems to have called on people to resist the Spanish marriage, not to make his daughter queen again.
It hardly mattered.
He was the father of a condemned girl whose name had been on a royal proclamation six months before.
Every move he made was a move for Jane.
Almost nobody came.
The city of Coventry shut its gates against him.
Within days he was hiding on his own estate at Astley, in Warwickshire, and the story goes that he was found hidden in a hollow tree, betrayed by one of his own keepers.
He was brought to London as a prisoner.
Wyatt’s men reached the edge of the City in the first week of February and were stopped at Ludgate.
The rebellion was over.
And Mary, who had been willing to wait, decided she could not wait any longer.
Her councilors told her that as long as Jane lived, there would be men willing to rise in her name.
The Spanish ambassador made it clear that his master’s son would not come to a country where the girl was still alive.
The warrant was signed.
Here the records go almost completely silent about Frances, and it is worth saying plainly what we do not know.
We do not know where she was when she heard.
We do not know whether she tried to see the queen again.
We do not know whether she wrote to her daughter.
If Jane wrote to her mother in those last days, the letter has not survived.
What has survived are her other farewells.
She wrote to her father, telling him that though it had pleased God to hasten her death by him, by whom her life should rather have been lengthened, she was glad of it.
She wrote to her sister Katherine, in the blank pages at the back of a Greek New Testament, telling her to learn to die.
She argued with the queen’s own chaplain, who had been sent to save her soul, and would not move an inch.
On the morning of Monday, February 12, 1554, Guildford Dudley was taken out to Tower Hill.
About an hour later, Jane was put to death on the green inside the Tower walls.
She was sixteen or seventeen.
Frances was still alive.
Her husband was not yet dead.
There was one more warrant to come.
On February 17, he was tried in Westminster Hall.
Six days later, on February 23, the man Frances had ridden through the night to save was taken to Tower Hill.
He was executed in front of a crowd, just eleven days after his daughter.
His brother Thomas would follow him that spring.
In less than two weeks, Frances had lost her eldest child and her husband.
The cousin she had knelt to had signed both.
She was thirty-six years old, with two daughters left, very little money, and a name that every man at court now spoke in a lower voice.
And she still had to go on living at Mary’s court.
What do you do, the morning after something like that, when you are a Tudor and the queen still expects you at dinner?
Frances did the one thing that could keep her last two children alive.
She made herself harmless.
—
## The marriage that made people laugh
Within a year or so of her husband’s death, Frances married again.
The exact date is still argued over, and some historians place it in the spring of 1554, only weeks after the Tower Hill scaffold, while others put it in 1555.
Her new husband was Adrian Stokes.
He was her Master of the Horse, the gentleman who ran her stables, her riding and her travel.
He was a Protestant, a former soldier, and a commoner, and he was younger than she was.
How much younger is another argument.
For centuries, the story was that he was about fifteen years her junior, a handsome boy servant whom the bereaved duchess had married in an unseemly hurry.
More recent writers think the gap was smaller.
There is a famous remark, repeated in many books and even on the Abbey’s own page about her, that Elizabeth I later said in disbelief, “Has the woman so far forgotten herself as to marry a common groom?”
Whether Elizabeth ever said it is far from certain.
But it captures exactly what the world thought.
The king’s niece had thrown herself away.
And that may have been the point.
A duchess who married a great lord could produce sons who might one day be pushed toward a throne.
A duchess who married her own Master of the Horse was no longer a piece in that game.
Her children by such a man would never be a danger to anyone.
Frances, who had been passed over twice for the crown, now stepped down from the chessboard altogether.
It may have been love.
It may have been safety.
It may have been both.
For a short while there was a chance of something else.
In 1555, the imperial ambassador reported a rumor that Frances might be married to Edward Courtenay, the last great-grandson of King Edward IV, which would have put her right back in the middle of the danger.
It never happened.
Instead, Frances’s last children came and went in grief.
A daughter born to her and Adrian Stokes in November 1554 was stillborn.
Another daughter, born on Frances’s own birthday in July 1555 and named Elizabeth, lived only a few months.
A son born at the end of 1556 did not live.
She was nearly forty.
She had buried more children than most of the women she knew.
Through it all she stayed at Mary’s court, in honorable poverty, close to the queen who had signed her daughter’s death warrant.
Her two surviving daughters, Katherine and Mary, served in the queen’s household too.
In November 1558, Mary died.
The new queen was Elizabeth.
And under Henry VIII’s will, which still had the force of law, the next heir after Elizabeth was Frances’s daughter Katherine Grey.
Frances knew very well what that meant.
She had seen it once already.
—
## The last winter
By the autumn of 1559, Frances was ill.
On November 9 she made her will.
It described her as “sicke in bodie but hole in mynde,” and it made Adrian Stokes her sole executor, with the duty of paying her debts and what she called the “greate chardges” of her funeral.
She died twelve days later, on November 20 or 21, 1559, probably at Sheen.
She was forty-two.
What happened next does not look like the treatment of a disgraced woman.
On December 3, Queen Elizabeth sent instructions to the heralds, Garter and Clarencieux, to add the royal arms to Frances’s own coat of arms.
The queen called her “our dearly-beloved cousin.”
Two days later, on December 5, 1559, Frances was buried in Westminster Abbey with the ceremony due to a woman of royal blood.
There was a hearse hung with black.
There were banners and banner-rolls painted with her arms, and dozens of small pennants and escutcheons.
Two heralds walked in the procession, and Clarencieux King of Arms called out her titles aloud over the coffin.
Her daughter Katherine, now the heir to the throne, was the chief mourner, her long black train carried behind her.
The service was in English.
The Ten Commandments were read, and the choir answered.
Katherine and her younger sister Mary received communion.
The sermon was preached by John Jewel, a scholar who would soon become Bishop of Salisbury, and it was said afterward to have been much commended.
It was, by some accounts, one of the very first Protestant funerals ever held in the Abbey.
Then the mourners climbed back into their carriages and went home to Sheen.
Frances was laid in the Chapel of St Edmund, near the tombs of medieval princes and the shrine of the Confessor.
For four years, her grave had no monument.
—
## What the tomb leaves out
In 1563, Adrian Stokes paid for one.
It still stands in St Edmund’s Chapel.
It is made of alabaster, and it shows Frances lying full length on a carved mattress of rushes, in a gown and a mantle lined with ermine, with a pendant at her neck, a coronet on her head and a lion at her feet.
The figure was possibly carved by Cornelius Cure, one of the finest monument makers in Elizabethan London.
At the west end of the tomb, carved into the stone, is the date 1563.
Around it run two inscriptions.
The English one tells you that here lies the Lady Frances, Duchess of Suffolk, daughter of Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, and Mary the French Queen, first wife to Henry, Duke of Suffolk, and afterward to Adrian Stokes, Esquire.
The Latin one, in the Abbey’s own translation, opens with the line “naught avails glory or splendour, naught avail titles of kings.”
It speaks of virtue, of death and of God.
It names her two husbands.
It does not name Jane.
It does not name Katherine.
It does not name Mary.
For a long time, people read that silence as one more piece of evidence about Frances.
A cold mother, the argument went, even in death, whose own family did not think her daughters worth a line.
Now look again at the date.
In 1563, Jane had been dead for nine years, condemned as a traitor.
Her name on a royal cousin’s tomb in Westminster Abbey would have been a provocation.
And Katherine, the chief mourner who had walked behind her mother’s coffin four years before, was a prisoner in the Tower of London.
In 1560, she had secretly married Edward Seymour, Earl of Hertford, without the queen’s permission.
For the heir to the throne, in the queen’s eyes, that was very close to treason.
When Katherine’s pregnancy could no longer be hidden in 1561, she and her husband were both sent to the Tower.
Her first son was born there.
In February 1563, so was her second.
To Elizabeth, every one of those babies was a possible rival.
Adrian Stokes was not a duke, or a lord, or a man with any power at all.
He was a widower with a sharp sense of how dangerous his late wife’s family was.
A tomb that named Katherine Grey, in the year she gave birth to a second son in a prison cell, would have been a message to a queen who was already furious.
He left the daughters out.
The silence that people later read as coldness was, almost certainly, caution.
The same caution that had led Frances herself to marry a man like him.
—
## Two daughters who could not stay safe
Frances’s caution saved her life.
It could not save her daughters from being who they were.
Katherine was kept under one form of guard or another for the rest of her life, moved from house to house, separated from her husband and her elder son.
She died in January 1568 at Cockfield Hall in Suffolk, still a prisoner.
She was twenty-seven.
Her sons were declared illegitimate, though Hertford never stopped fighting for them.
Mary, the youngest, the tiny girl with the curved back, made the same mistake.
In 1565 she married, in secret, a very tall widower named Thomas Keyes, the queen’s Sergeant Porter.
When it was discovered, he was thrown into the Fleet prison, and she was handed from one reluctant guardian to another for years.
She was only set at liberty after Keyes had died.
She died in London on April 20, 1578, and was buried in Westminster Abbey with her mother.
She has no monument and no marker of her own.
She lies, as far as anyone knows, in the same grave as Frances, beneath the alabaster figure that does not mention her.
Adrian Stokes lived on.
He married again, and died in the mid-1580s.
And the reputation of Frances Brandon, which had begun to sour with Ascham’s book in 1570, kept getting worse.
Victorian writers, who loved Jane as a Protestant saint, needed someone to blame for what happened to her, and the obvious candidate was the woman who was supposed to have loved her most.
They found a picture, too.
—
## The portrait that was not her
For generations, a striking double portrait by the Flemish painter Hans Eworth was reproduced in books as “Frances Brandon, Duchess of Suffolk, and her second husband Adrian Stokes.”
It shows a heavy-faced woman in black, with a much younger, slim man beside her.
Writers looked at it and saw everything the legend described.
The coarse older woman.
The boy husband.
The proof, in paint, of a mother who forgot her dead daughter in weeks.
Today that painting is identified as a portrait of a different woman altogether: Mary Neville, Lady Dacre, with her son Gregory Fiennes.
It has nothing to do with Frances at all.
No undisputed painted portrait of Frances is known.
A painting in the Royal Collection, from around 1560, is sometimes tentatively said to show her, but nobody can be sure.
The only image of her face that her own family commissioned is the alabaster one in Westminster Abbey, carved by a sculptor who may never have seen her alive.
It shows a calm, round-faced woman with her eyes closed and her hands joined in prayer.
It is not the face of a monster.
It is not the face of a saint, either.
It is the face of a woman who knew exactly how close she had stood to the throne, and exactly what it had cost.
—
## The rider at the gate
Go back, one last time, to that road into Essex in July 1553.
To the dust, the cut hay, the tired horses and the brick palace waiting at the end of the dark.
Frances rode there to save her family.
For a few days, she did.
Her husband walked out of the Tower.
Her daughter, everyone believed, would follow.
Then her husband rode out again, and the cousin who had forgiven them once did not forgive them twice.
Within the next ten years, Frances would lose her eldest daughter, her husband, three more babies, and in the end her own life.
Her surviving daughters would both be locked away for doing what their mother had done, marrying without asking.
And her own tomb, the last thing her family could do for her, would leave every one of her children out, to keep the ones still alive from danger.
Henry VIII’s will had passed her over so that her daughters could stand next to the throne.
Edward VI’s device had passed her over so that one of them could sit on it.
Frances spent the rest of her life trying to pull them back.
She was the only one of the three in that summer’s story, mother, father and daughter, who lived to see another one.
The daughter did not.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
**Solid:**
Frances was born on July 16, 1517, at Hatfield, the elder daughter of Mary Tudor, the “French Queen,” and Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk.
Her godmothers were Catherine of Aragon and Princess Mary.
She married Henry Grey, Marquess of Dorset, in 1533 at Suffolk Place, Southwark, and was chief mourner at her mother’s funeral at Bury St Edmunds that summer.
Her surviving daughters were Jane, Katherine and Mary.
Henry VIII’s will of December 30, 1546, left the crown, after his own children, to the heirs of Frances, passing over Frances herself.
Edward VI’s handwritten “devise” was altered to leave the crown to “the Lady Jane” and her heirs.
Jane was proclaimed queen on July 10, 1553, and deposed on July 19.
Frances’s husband was released from the Tower on July 31, 1553, after Frances went to Mary.
Jane was put to death on February 12, 1554, and her father on February 23, 1554.
Frances married Adrian Stokes, made her will on November 9, 1559, and died on November 20 or 21, 1559, aged forty-two.
Elizabeth I ordered the royal arms added to hers and called her “our dearly-beloved cousin.”
She was buried in Westminster Abbey on December 5, 1559, with Katherine as chief mourner and John Jewel preaching.
Adrian Stokes erected her alabaster tomb in St Edmund’s Chapel; it is dated 1563 and names her parents and her two husbands but none of her children.
Mary Grey was buried with her in 1578, without a monument.
**Disputed or uncertain:**
Why Henry VIII’s will passed over Frances herself is not known.
The story that Frances was first angry about the device and then gave up her claim after a private audience with Edward comes from later accounts.
The date of her ride to Beaulieu, July 29, comes from one account; nobody recorded what she said to Mary.
The suggestion that she told Mary Northumberland had tried to poison her husband is a historian’s reading of the sources, not a recorded speech.
The date of her marriage to Adrian Stokes, 1554 or 1555, and his exact age are both argued over.
Whether she died at Sheen or elsewhere near Richmond is not certain.
Who carved her tomb is not certain; Cornelius Cure is a possibility suggested by the Abbey.
**Legend or later invention:**
The story that Frances beat Jane into marrying Guildford Dudley first appears in the early eighteenth century, with no evidence behind it.
Ascham’s account of Jane’s complaint is real, but it was written down years later, published only in 1570, and is a single source.
The remark “Has the woman so far forgotten herself as to marry a common groom?” is attributed to Elizabeth I but cannot be traced securely to her.
The Hans Eworth double portrait long labeled “Frances Brandon and Adrian Stokes” actually shows Mary Neville, Lady Dacre, and her son.
The scene of Jane’s father tearing down the cloth of state and the image of Frances carrying Jane’s train into the Tower are each reported in later accounts and are not certain.
**What we have reconstructed:**
The weather, the smells of the road and the details of Frances’s night ride are imagined from the season and the place.
Her thoughts are never recorded; where this article says what she “must have known,” it is an inference from what she did.