News

1456: Henry VIII’s Grandfather Was Taken Prisoner at 26 and Died Before His Son Was Born. 82 Years Later, Henry VIII Closed the Church Where He Lay

The friars had been gone for weeks, and the church already smelled of damp.

Someone had taken the candlesticks.

Someone had taken the vestments, the books, the silver, the bells.

What was left in the choir of the Grey Friars at Carmarthen, in the far west of Wales, was stone, wood, glass and lead, and men with ladders were working out what each of those things was worth to the king.

The house had been surrendered to the Crown in the spring of 1538.

Like every friary in England and Wales that year, it was being emptied, priced and taken apart.

In the middle of the choir, where the brothers had once sung their offices day and night, stood a tomb.

It was not a plain slab in the floor.

It was a raised chest of dark polished marble, the kind of monument that cost more than most men earned in a lifetime, and around its edge ran a line of lettering in brass.

Anyone who bent down to read it would have found the name of an earl, and a date eighty-two years in the past.

And then a phrase that would have made any of the king’s men stop where he stood.

The man inside, the inscription said, had been “father and brother to kings.”

He was the half-brother of King Henry VI.

He was the father of King Henry VII.

And he was the grandfather of the king whose officers were now standing in his church, deciding what to do with the roof over his head.

His name was Edmund Tudor, Earl of Richmond.

He had died at twenty-six, in this town, while the men who had captured him held the castle on the hill.

He had never seen his only child.

That child had grown up to win a crown, and his grandson had grown up to close this church.

So what do you do with the bones of the king’s own grandfather, when the king has shut the house that guards them?

—

The answer was not as simple as it should have been.

It involves a French princess who married a Welsh servant in secret, two little boys who were taken from their father and handed to a nun, and a war that tore England in half before either boy was thirty.

It involves a bishop with ambitions of his own, who may have cared more about saving his cathedral than about honoring the king’s family.

And it involves one of the strangest reversals in the whole Tudor story: the man who took Edmund Tudor prisoner would later bring up Edmund’s son in his own house, at his own table, as if he were one of his own children.

By the end, Edmund would lie in a place of greater honor than he had ever known while he was alive.

But first, he had to die in a castle full of enemies, three months before his son was born.

—

## Why did two royal boys grow up as if they did not exist?

Edmund Tudor began his life as an embarrassment.

His mother was Catherine of Valois, a daughter of the King of France and the widow of Henry V, the hero of Agincourt.

When Henry V died in 1422, Catherine was barely twenty-one, and her baby son was now King Henry VI of England.

The men who governed in the baby king’s name had one great fear about the young widow: that she would remarry and give some ambitious nobleman a hold over the throne.

So Parliament made it a matter of law that a queen dowager could not marry without the consent of the king, and the king was a child who could not give it.

Catherine married anyway.

She did not choose a nobleman.

She chose a Welshman from her own household named Owen Tudor, a man with no title, no fortune and, under the harsh laws then in force against the Welsh, very few rights at all.

How and when they married has never been settled.

There is no surviving record of the ceremony.

What there is, is children.

Around 1430, at the manor of Much Hadham in Hertfordshire, a house belonging to the Bishop of London, Catherine gave birth to a son.

They called him Edmund.

A year or so later, at Hatfield, came a second boy, Jasper.

There may have been others who did not live long.

The boys spent their first years in quiet, well-fed obscurity, the half-brothers of a king who did not yet know they existed.

That ended in the winter of 1436 and 1437.

Catherine fell ill and withdrew to the abbey of Bermondsey, south of the Thames.

She died there in early January 1437, still in her mid-thirties.

Almost at once, the protection around her little family vanished.

Owen Tudor was summoned before the council, arrested, released, arrested again, and eventually locked in Newgate prison, from which he escaped and was recaptured.

Edmund was about seven.

Jasper was about six.

They were taken from their father and placed in the care of Katherine de la Pole, the abbess of Barking, a great house of nuns on the marshes east of London.

For the next few years, their world was cloisters and bells and the careful kindness of a noblewoman who had been told to keep them fed, clothed, and out of sight.

The records of what they cost her survive, down to their food and clothing.

What the records do not say is what two small boys were told about where their mother had gone, or why their father did not come.

They were royal by blood and nobody by law.

And it would take a lonely young king to decide which of those things mattered.

—

## What did a king owe the brothers no one had told him about?

Henry VI was a strange, gentle, deeply pious young man, and when he came of age and learned that he had two half-brothers growing up among nuns, he did something unusual for a king.

He took them in.

From the early 1440s, Edmund and Jasper were brought closer to the court and placed under priests who saw to their education.

Henry seems to have felt real affection for them.

He had no full brothers and no sisters.

These boys were the only close family he had on his mother’s side, and they owed everything to him.

In a court full of great lords who each had their own armies and their own ambitions, two young men with nothing but the king’s favor were exactly the kind of people a king could trust.

By the early 1450s, the king had decided to make them great.

Edmund was created Earl of Richmond.

Jasper was created Earl of Pembroke.

On January 5, 1453, at the Tower of London, the two brothers were formally invested with their earldoms, in robes of velvet and cloth of gold that the king’s own wardrobe had provided.

That spring, they took their seats in Parliament among the greatest lords of the realm.

And Parliament did something that must have meant more to them than any robe.

After a petition from the Commons, the two brothers were formally recognized as the king’s lawful half-brothers, and the legal disabilities that hung over them because their father was Welsh were swept away.

They were no longer the hidden sons of a secret marriage.

They were the king’s own blood, declared so in public.

The gifts kept coming.

Edmund received lands in the north of England and the great London house of Baynard’s Castle on the river.

He even put money into the wool trade at Boston in Lincolnshire, as if he meant to build a fortune that would last.

But the greatest gift of all was not land.

It was a girl.

—

## Why did the king hand his brother the richest child in England?

In March 1453, King Henry VI granted Edmund the wardship of Lady Margaret Beaufort.

She was nine years old.

She was also, by a wide margin, the most valuable heiress in the kingdom.

Her father, the Duke of Somerset, had died when she was a baby, and she had inherited his estates.

Through him, she carried the blood of John of Gaunt and King Edward III.

Whoever controlled Margaret controlled her lands, and whoever married her would be bound into the royal family twice over.

The king meant that man to be Edmund.

Her story, from her own side, has been told on this page before, and it is a hard one.

Here it is enough to say the bare fact: Edmund Tudor and Margaret Beaufort were married on November 1, 1455, at Bletsoe Castle in Bedfordshire, when she was twelve years old.

It was a marriage of politics, arranged by a king, and it was legal in their world.

To us it is shocking, and it should be.

By the time of the wedding, Edmund’s world had changed completely.

In August 1453, Henry VI had suffered some kind of collapse.

For well over a year he could not speak sensibly, recognize the people around him, or understand what was said to him.

In October 1453, while he sat unaware, his queen, Margaret of Anjou, gave birth to a son.

Now there were two parties in England: the queen’s, who wanted to rule for the helpless king and protect her baby, and the party of Richard, Duke of York, the king’s cousin, who believed he had the better right to govern and, perhaps, a claim to the crown itself.

In May 1455, at St Albans, their armies fought in the streets.

The war we now call the Wars of the Roses had begun.

And the king’s two half-brothers were caught in the middle of it, because everyone knew whose side they were on.

They had only one side.

—

## Why was Edmund sent to the wild west of Wales?

In the second half of 1455, Edmund Tudor was sent into south-west Wales.

The region was, by every account, close to lawless.

The man who really ran it was a Carmarthenshire landowner named Gruffudd ap Nicholas.

He had made himself the power in the land through family alliances, royal offices and plain intimidation, and he ignored orders from London when it suited him.

One of his own descendants later described him as a man of a “hot, fiery, and choleric spirit.”

He had seized the royal castles that were supposed to keep the king’s peace: Aberystwyth on the coast, Carreg Cennen on its crag, and above all Carmarthen, the chief royal fortress of the region.

Edmund’s task was to take them back.

He did not go alone.

He brought his young wife with him, into a country neither of them knew well, and by the end of November 1455 the couple were at Lamphey, near Pembroke.

Lamphey was not a castle.

It was a palace belonging to the Bishops of St Davids, a comfortable country residence with gardens, fishponds and orchards, lent to the king’s brother as a base.

It is the first time the name St Davids touches this story.

It will not be the last.

Through the winter and spring of 1456, Edmund went to work.

It was a small, hard war of sieges and seizures, of riding between castles in the rain, of men changing sides and changing back.

By the summer, one letter writer reported that the two sides were “at war greatly in Wales.”

And Edmund was winning.

By early August 1456, he had taken back Carmarthen, Aberystwyth and Carreg Cennen.

For a young man barely twenty-six, raised among nuns, given an earldom by his brother and sent into a country of hostile castles, it was a real achievement.

He had done what the king asked.

But the castles he had won were not only the king’s concern.

Carmarthen and Cardigan, in particular, were royal offices that the Duke of York claimed for himself.

And York had decided to take them back.

—

## Who were the two thousand men marching west?

In August 1456, a force of around two thousand men set out from the Welsh borderlands.

They came from Herefordshire and the Marches, the hard country along the border, and they were led by two men who would matter a great deal in the years to come.

The first was Sir Walter Devereux of Weobley, a veteran of York’s household.

The second was his son-in-law, William Herbert of Raglan, a tough, ambitious Welshman in his early thirties who had fought in France and who was rising fast in York’s service.

Herbert was married to Devereux’s daughter Anne.

The two families were tied together by marriage, by land, and by loyalty to the Duke of York.

Two thousand men was an army, not a raiding party.

They marched on Carmarthen.

We do not know exactly what happened when they arrived.

There is no surviving eyewitness account of the attack, no list of the dead, and no record of what Edmund said or did.

We know the outcome.

The Yorkists took Carmarthen Castle, and they took Edmund Tudor prisoner inside it.

Then the army moved on.

They went north to Aberystwyth, which also fell to them, and they forced the town to submit.

Behind them, in Carmarthen, they left the king’s brother locked in the castle he had fought for months to win.

The castle stood on a ridge above the River Tywi, its walls looking down over the bridge, the quays and the roofs of the town.

From its windows, a prisoner could have seen the river going down toward the sea.

Somewhere to the west, at Lamphey or at his brother’s castle at Pembroke, his wife was carrying their first child.

She was five or six months along.

He was a prisoner of men who had no reason to love him.

And in the town below, people were beginning to fall sick.

—

## What happened inside Carmarthen Castle that autumn?

Nobody wrote down Edmund Tudor’s last weeks.

That is the first thing to understand about the most important death in the early history of the Tudors.

There is no letter from his cell, no account by a jailer, no chronicler standing at his bedside.

What we have is a handful of facts, a date on a tomb, and a long silence that historians have been arguing over ever since.

So let us be careful, and put together only what can honestly be put together.

It was late summer when the castle fell, and the season was turning.

In south-west Wales, autumn comes in off the Atlantic.

The rain arrives in long grey bands, the Tywi rises and runs brown, and the mornings smell of wet stone and woodsmoke.

Inside a medieval castle, autumn meant cold rooms, smoking fires, rush-covered floors, and walls that sweated with damp.

Edmund was not a common prisoner.

He was an earl and the king’s own brother.

Whatever the Yorkists thought of him, they had every reason to keep him alive.

A living Edmund Tudor was something to bargain with.

A dead one was a crime that the king, if he ever recovered his wits, would not forget.

So we can assume he was held in some decency, with a servant or two, with food and fire, in one of the castle’s chambers rather than a pit.

We can also be fairly sure of what he did not have.

He did not have his freedom.

He did not have his wife.

He did not have news he could trust.

Every few days, word must have come up the hill about the war outside: Aberystwyth fallen, the Yorkists riding on, the king far away in England, the queen gathering her own people in the Midlands.

His brother Jasper was out there somewhere, the Earl of Pembroke, with men and castles of his own.

But Jasper could not simply ride into Carmarthen and take him home.

And then the sickness came into the castle.

Most accounts say it was plague.

The towns of fifteenth-century Britain were never really free of it.

It came in waves, in the warm months and into the autumn, carried along the roads and the rivers and the coasting ships, and Carmarthen was a busy port town on a tidal river.

When it came, it came fast.

The first sign was usually fever.

Then headache, weakness, a terrible thirst, swellings under the arm or in the groin, and a body that seemed to burn and freeze at once.

Some victims lasted a week.

Some were dead in two or three days.

There was no cure, and everybody knew it.

Priests were sent for before physicians.

If that is what happened to Edmund Tudor, then the end of his life looked like this: a young man of twenty-six, strong enough to have spent a year fighting his way between castles, lying in a borrowed bed in an enemy’s fortress, sweating through the sheets while the rain ran down the walls.

Somewhere a friar or a chaplain would have heard his last confession.

Somewhere, perhaps, someone wrote a message that he would never see answered.

We do not know whether he knew, in the end, that he was dying.

We do not know whether he spoke of his wife, or of the child, or of his brother.

And we must be honest about one more thing.

There is no contemporary document that actually says the cause of death was plague.

That is the explanation the later histories give, and it is very likely the right one.

But some historians have pointed out that Edmund died only weeks after a violent assault on a castle, in the hands of the men who had attacked it, and that wounds or harsh treatment can kill as surely as fever.

A few have gone further and wondered whether he was helped toward his grave.

Months later, royal officials did put the conduct of Herbert and Devereux under investigation.

The charges they faced, however, were about the violence of their whole campaign in Wales.

Nobody was ever convicted of killing Edmund Tudor, and no surviving record directly accuses anyone of it.

There is another uncertainty too.

Most accounts say he died still a prisoner in the castle.

A few say he had been released shortly before, and that the sickness caught him in the town.

Either way, he never left Carmarthen.

He died in the first days of November 1456.

The inscription that was later placed over him gives the first of the month, and many histories give the third.

It was almost exactly a year since his wedding.

He was about twenty-six years old.

His son had not been born.

The friars of the Grey Friars, the Franciscan house that stood in the town below the castle, claimed his body.

They carried it down through the streets of Carmarthen in the rain, a king’s brother on a bier with a handful of mourners and none of the great lords of England anywhere near.

They buried him in the choir of their church, close to the high altar, where the brothers would pray over him every day.

It was the right place for a nobleman’s body.

It was also, as things turned out, only a temporary one.

A messenger rode west, toward the coast, with the news.

His brother Jasper heard it first.

Then someone had to tell a thirteen-year-old girl, six months pregnant, that her husband was dead.

—

## Who takes care of a boy whose father is already in the grave?

Jasper Tudor did the only thing he could.

He took his brother’s widow into his own fortress at Pembroke, the great castle on its rock above the tidal river, with walls thick enough to keep out any army in Wales.

It was the depth of winter.

On January 28, 1457, in a chamber in Pembroke Castle, Margaret Beaufort gave birth to a son.

She was thirteen.

The birth was so hard that she never had another child.

The baby lived.

She called him Henry, almost certainly for King Henry VI, the gentle uncle he would hardly know.

He would never hear his father’s voice, never see his face, never even see a portrait, because no likeness of Edmund Tudor painted from life has survived.

Everything the boy would ever learn about his father would come secondhand, from his mother, from his uncle, from servants who remembered.

He was born an earl.

He was the heir to his father’s title, the half-nephew of a king, and the grandson of a queen of England.

And at three months old he was, in the eyes of the Yorkists who held half of Wales, a problem.

In the spring of 1457, the royal court came west to deal with the disorder.

At Hereford, in April, a great inquiry was held into the violence of the past year.

King Henry VI was there.

Queen Margaret of Anjou was there.

So was Jasper Tudor.

Dozens of men were examined.

William Herbert, who had already been held in the Tower of London and released on bail and had fled back to Wales, was among those called to answer.

Everyone in that hall knew whose castle he had stormed and whose brother had died in it.

But the queen was a practical woman, and she needed fighting men more than she needed revenge.

She offered Herbert a pardon.

He accepted it.

Devereux stayed in prison for a time, then he too came back into favor.

For the moment, Herbert was the king’s man again.

Jasper must have watched it happen.

Whatever he felt about it, he kept to himself.

He had a baby nephew to protect, and the war was only beginning.

And the man the queen had just forgiven would not stay forgiven for long.

—

## Why did Edmund’s captor end up raising Edmund’s son?

In the spring of 1461, the war turned against the Lancastrians.

At Mortimer’s Cross in February, Jasper Tudor and his father Owen were defeated by the young Edward, Earl of March, the son of the Duke of York.

Owen Tudor, the Welsh servant who had married a queen, was put to death in the market place at Hereford.

His story has been told here before.

In March, in a snowstorm at Towton in Yorkshire, the Lancastrian army was destroyed.

Edward of York became King Edward IV.

Henry VI fled north.

Jasper fled abroad.

And a four-year-old boy was left behind at Pembroke Castle.

In September 1461, Pembroke was surrendered to the new king’s commander in Wales.

That commander was William Herbert.

Five years after he had taken the father prisoner at Carmarthen, Herbert walked into the castle where the son had been born, and took the son.

He did not harm the boy.

He did something far more calculating.

Early in 1462, Herbert paid the new king a thousand pounds for Henry Tudor’s wardship, an enormous sum, and took him home to his great new castle at Raglan in Monmouthshire.

Herbert was rising to the very top of Edward IV’s England.

He became Lord Herbert, and later Earl of Pembroke, the same title that had belonged to Jasper.

And in his household, among his own sons and daughters, grew the son of the man he had captured.

Herbert’s wife Anne, the daughter of Walter Devereux, the other commander at Carmarthen, became the closest thing to a mother the boy had in those years.

Henry Tudor was educated at Raglan, taught to ride and fight, and fed at the table of the family that had taken his father.

There is no sign that he was treated badly.

Herbert seems to have meant to marry him to his daughter Maud, binding the young earl’s blood and claims into the Herbert family forever.

Margaret Beaufort, far away in England with a new husband, could only write and visit when she was allowed.

It is one of the most extraordinary arrangements in English history.

The boy who would found the Tudor dynasty spent most of his childhood as the ward, and almost the adopted son, of the man whose army had locked his father in a castle to die.

What he made of that, as a child, nobody recorded.

But he never forgot Raglan, and in later years he treated Anne Herbert with kindness.

In July 1469, the arrangement ended in blood.

Herbert led an army for Edward IV against rebels at Edgecote, in Northamptonshire.

He lost.

Herbert was taken and put to death the next day at Northampton by the Earl of Warwick.

Twelve-year-old Henry Tudor, who had been brought along with the Herbert army, was led away from the field and, according to the usual account, taken to safety at Weobley, the Devereux family home, where Lady Herbert was waiting.

The man who had taken his father had now lost his own life.

And the boy had lost the only father he had known.

—

## What did a son do for a father he never met?

The next sixteen years of Henry Tudor’s life read like an adventure story.

There was a brief return of Henry VI in 1470, a brief reunion with his uncle Jasper, and then the final catastrophe of the Lancastrians at Tewkesbury in 1471, where Henry VI’s only son was cut down and Henry VI himself died in the Tower soon after.

Suddenly, through his mother’s Beaufort blood, the fourteen-year-old Henry Tudor was one of the last people alive with any kind of Lancastrian claim to the throne.

Jasper did not wait to see what Edward IV would do about that.

He took his nephew to the little port of Tenby, on the coast of Pembrokeshire, and the two of them sailed for France.

A storm drove them to Brittany instead.

They stayed in exile for fourteen years.

Through all of it, the boy who had never seen his father was kept alive by the brother who had buried him.

In August 1485, Henry Tudor came home.

He landed at Mill Bay, near Dale, at the mouth of Milford Haven, a short ride from the castle where he had been born.

Welshmen came out to join him as he marched north and east.

One of the most important of them was Rhys ap Thomas, the most powerful man in south-west Wales, who brought an army with him.

Rhys was a grandson of Gruffudd ap Nicholas, the very man whose seizure of the royal castles had sent Edmund Tudor west in 1455.

On August 22, 1485, near Market Bosworth in Leicestershire, Richard III was defeated and died fighting.

Edmund Tudor’s son was King Henry VII.

He was twenty-eight.

He had now lived two years longer than his father ever did.

The new king did not forget the people who had kept him alive.

Jasper became Duke of Bedford.

Margaret Beaufort became “My Lady the King’s Mother,” one of the most powerful women in England.

Rhys ap Thomas, by tradition knighted on the field, was showered with offices.

And the father he had never known was not forgotten either.

In 1499, when Henry VII’s queen, Elizabeth of York, gave birth to their third son, the king named the baby Edmund.

The little prince died the following year, before he was two.

But for a short time, the future Henry VIII had a baby brother who carried their grandfather’s name.

Henry VII also turned to the grave in Carmarthen.

In 1496 he paid for a new tomb for his father in the Grey Friars church, a fine chest of Purbeck marble with a brass inscription around its rim, and the work was overseen by Rhys ap Thomas.

The grandson of Edmund’s old rival was now the guardian of Edmund’s memory.

The inscription named Edmund as “father and brother to kings.”

That was true now, and proudly so.

It was carved into stone at a time when no one in England could imagine that one day the friaries themselves would be gone.

His grandson would see to that.

—

## What happens to the king’s grandfather when the king closes his church?

Henry VIII was born in 1491, thirty-five years after his grandfather’s death.

He was Edmund Tudor’s grandson as surely as Edmund was Henry VI’s brother, and there is no sign that he ever gave the man in Carmarthen much thought.

He had other things on his mind.

By the mid-1530s, he had broken with the Pope to marry Anne Boleyn and declared himself Supreme Head of the Church in England.

His chief minister, Thomas Cromwell, had begun the greatest seizure of property in English history.

First the smaller monasteries were closed, in 1536.

Then the greater ones fell, one after another.

In 1538 it was the turn of the friars, the Franciscans, Dominicans, Carmelites and Augustinians, who had lived and preached in English and Welsh towns for three hundred years.

The Grey Friars at Carmarthen surrendered to the Crown on March 30, 1538.

The friars were sent away.

Everything of value was inventoried.

The lead on the roofs was worth money, the bells were worth money, the timber and the glass and the dressed stone were worth money.

Churches like this one were stripped and sold, and many were simply pulled down, their stones carted away to build barns, houses and town walls.

That left the tomb.

The marble chest of the king’s grandfather stood in a building that was about to cease to exist.

It is natural to assume that Henry VIII himself gave the order to save it.

Many books say so.

Some say the king had his grandfather’s body reburied with honor.

But when you look for a royal command, it is hard to find one.

The historian Madeleine Gray, who has studied the tomb closely, has suggested a different and more interesting answer.

The Bishop of St Davids at that time was William Barlow.

He was a reformer, a protégé of the Boleyn circle and of Cromwell, and he did not much like his ancient cathedral, which stood in a remote corner of Pembrokeshire, at the very end of Wales, far from any town of importance.

He wanted to move his cathedral to Carmarthen, the biggest town in the region.

And Carmarthen had a large, newly emptied friary church.

To the clergy of St Davids, that was a threat to everything they had.

If the cathedral moved, their ancient church, the shrine of the patron saint of Wales, would become just another old building at the edge of the sea.

What better way to make their church impossible to abandon than to take the king’s own grandfather and lay him in front of their high altar?

In 1539, Edmund Tudor’s remains, and his marble tomb, were moved from Carmarthen to St Davids.

It was a journey of more than forty miles west, over roads that were hardly more than tracks, to a cathedral that sits in a hollow near the sea, built low, it is said, so that raiders could not see its tower from the water.

The tomb would have gone by cart, the heavy marble slabs packed in straw and roped down, the bones in a coffin of their own.

Then, under the great carved ceiling of the cathedral, it was set up again in the most honored position the church had to offer: in the choir, before the high altar, close to the shrine of Saint David himself.

Whether the clergy of St Davids moved Edmund to honor him, to flatter the king, or to save their cathedral from their own bishop, we may never know.

It was probably all three.

The plan to move the cathedral to Carmarthen came to nothing.

St Davids is a cathedral still.

And the king’s grandfather lies at the heart of it.

—

## What is left of him today?

If you walk into St Davids Cathedral today and go up into the presbytery, you will find him there, almost exactly where the clergy put him nearly five hundred years ago.

The tomb stands in front of the high altar.

It is a low, dark chest of Purbeck marble, set with shields bearing the arms of his family.

On top lies a brass figure of a knight in armor.

It is not the original.

In the seventeenth century, during the Civil War, soldiers stripped the cathedral and its monuments of their ornaments, and the old brass on Edmund’s tomb was lost.

When the architect Sir George Gilbert Scott restored the cathedral in the 1860s and 1870s, a new brass was made for the tomb in 1873 by the craftsman Thomas Waller, along with a copy of the inscription that runs around the edge.

The Victorian brass does not quite fill the space cut for the old one.

Whatever Henry VII’s craftsmen first put there was larger and finer.

But the words are still there, recut in brass.

“Father and brother to kings.”

The people who once surrounded Edmund mostly lost their graves.

His brother Jasper died in 1495 and was buried at Keynsham Abbey in Somerset, which Henry VIII’s commissioners closed in 1539; his tomb there has disappeared.

Rhys ap Thomas, who had overseen Edmund’s tomb at Carmarthen, was himself buried in the Grey Friars church in 1525, and his monument too was moved when the friary fell, to the church of St Peter in Carmarthen, where it can still be seen.

Margaret Beaufort lies in Westminster Abbey, in Henry VII’s chapel, not far from the son she gave birth to at thirteen.

The Grey Friars church at Carmarthen is gone.

Its site has been excavated by archaeologists, who traced its walls and found many of its burials, and modern Carmarthen has grown over the ground where the friars once sang.

Carmarthen Castle survives only in pieces, its gatehouse and fragments of wall standing beside the county offices that were built on the site in the twentieth century.

Pembroke Castle still stands on its rock above the river, and visitors are shown the tower where, by long tradition, Henry Tudor was born.

Lamphey, the bishop’s palace where Edmund and Margaret stayed in the winter of 1455, is a graceful ruin of arcaded walls among fields.

There is no portrait of Edmund Tudor painted from life.

There is no letter in his hand that tells us what he thought or how he spoke.

There is only a date, a few lines in the records, a marble chest, and the shape of what he left behind: a son who became a king, a grandson who became the most famous king in English history, and a great-granddaughter, Elizabeth I, whose reign is still called a golden age.

All of them descended from a young man who died at twenty-six in a borrowed bed in an enemy’s castle and never held his child.

In the spring of 1538, the king’s men walked into an emptying church in Carmarthen and found his tomb.

The inscription told them who he was.

It told them he was the father and the brother of kings.

It did not tell them that the king they served was his grandson, or that the house they were taking apart was the only home he had in death.

His grandson closed the church.

It took a cathedral fighting for its own life to carry him somewhere safe.

—

## What The Record Actually Says

**Birth and parents:** Edmund Tudor was born around 1430 at Much Hadham in Hertfordshire, the son of Catherine of Valois, widow of Henry V, and Owen Tudor.

There is no surviving record of his parents’ marriage; its date and form are unknown.

**Childhood:** After Catherine’s death in January 1437 and Owen’s arrest, Edmund and Jasper were placed in the care of Katherine de la Pole, abbess of Barking, and from the early 1440s under priests at the direction of Henry VI.

**Earldom and Parliament:** Dates for the creation of Edmund’s earldom vary between sources (1449 and 1452 are both given); the formal investiture of the two brothers at the Tower took place on January 5, 1453, and they were recognized in Parliament as the king’s legitimate half-brothers that year.

**Wardship and marriage:** Edmund received Margaret Beaufort’s wardship in March 1453; they married on November 1, 1455, at Bletsoe.

She was twelve.

**The Welsh campaign:** Edmund’s campaign against Gruffudd ap Nicholas in 1455 and 1456, his recovery of Carmarthen, Aberystwyth and Carreg Cennen, and his stay at Lamphey follow modern accounts; the phrase “at war greatly in Wales” is from a letter of that summer as quoted by modern historians, and the description of Gruffudd’s “hot, fiery, and choleric spirit” comes from a later family history.

**Capture:** In August 1456 a Yorkist force of around 2,000 men under Sir Walter Devereux and William Herbert took Carmarthen Castle and captured Edmund.

The details of the attack are not recorded.

**Death:** Edmund died at Carmarthen in early November 1456.

His epitaph gives November 1; many modern accounts give November 3.

Plague is the traditional cause, but no contemporary source states it.

Whether he was still a prisoner or had just been released is disputed; most accounts say he died in custody.

Suspicion that he was murdered rests on circumstance only, and no one was ever convicted.

**The prison scenes:** No account of Edmund’s last weeks survives.

The description of the castle, the season and the illness in this article is reconstruction from what is generally known, and is marked as such in the text.

**His son:** Henry Tudor was born at Pembroke Castle on January 28, 1457.

The Hereford sessions of 1457, Herbert’s pardon, his purchase of Henry’s wardship in 1462, Henry’s upbringing at Raglan, and Herbert’s death after Edgecote in 1469 are well documented; that the boy was taken to Weobley after the battle is the usual account.

**The tomb:** Henry VII paid for a new tomb at the Grey Friars in 1496, overseen by Rhys ap Thomas.

The friary was surrendered on March 30, 1538, and the tomb was moved to the choir of St Davids Cathedral, most sources say in 1539.

It has often been said that Henry VIII ordered the move; no royal order has been found, and the suggestion that the clergy of St Davids moved it to protect their cathedral against Bishop Barlow’s plans is the interpretation of Madeleine Gray, which we report as a possibility.

The present brass is a Victorian replacement made by Thomas Waller in 1873 during Gilbert Scott’s restoration; the original was lost in the seventeenth century.

**What we did not invent:** We have not given Edmund any words, because none survive.

The opening scene in the emptied friary is a reconstruction based on what is known of the dissolution of the friaries in 1538; the inscription is real.

**Uncertain details stated from general histories:** the burial of Jasper at Keynsham and the loss of his tomb, the moving of Rhys ap Thomas’s monument to St Peter’s, Carmarthen, the excavation of the Grey Friars site, and the tradition of the tower at Pembroke where Henry was born.

You Might Also Enjoy