1543: Henry VIII’s Painter Gave the World the King’s Face. Then He Died in London, and No One Knows Where He Is Buried
The neighbors came up the stairs in the afternoon, and they did not bring a lawyer.
It was the seventh of October, 1543, in a house near Aldgate, at the eastern edge of the City of London.
Inside, a man in his middle forties wanted to put his affairs in order while he still could.
He was not English.
He spoke English well enough to do business, but the men he had called to his side were mostly Germans like himself, craftsmen and merchants who lived in the same few streets.
The will they wrote down that day was short.
It began with a name and a job.
The man described himself as “servant to the King’s Majesty.”
Then came the plain business of a working life.
His goods were to be sold.
His debts were to be paid, a little over ten pounds to one man, six pounds to a goldsmith.
And there was one more thing.
He had two small children in London, and they were living with a nurse.
He set aside money, so much each month, for “the keeping of my two children, which be at nurse.”
A few streets west, and then a short ride along the river, there was a palace called Whitehall.
On a wall of its most private room, the king of England stood life-size in paint, legs planted wide, fists near his belt, shoulders as broad as a doorway, staring straight out at whoever dared to come in.
The man making his will had painted that king.
He had painted the king’s queens, the king’s son, the king’s ministers, the king’s enemies and the king’s friends.
His name was Hans Holbein.
Within a few weeks of that afternoon, he would be dead.
And then something strange would happen.
The most famous painter in England would simply disappear.
—
How does a man who gave England the face of its king leave the world with debts, two babies at nurse, and no grave that anyone can find?
The story runs from a frozen city on the Rhine to a house full of philosophers by the Thames, through a painting with a hidden skull, a bride who did not look the way the king expected, and a wall that burned in a single night.
For almost three hundred years, the world did not even know the right year of his death.
When the truth finally turned up, it was hiding in a dusty book of old wills.
And a great English earl, a century after Holbein died, went looking for his grave with every intention of building him a monument.
What he found is the reason this story ends where it does.
—
## Why a painter from Basel went looking for English gold
He was born in Augsburg, in southern Germany, in the winter of 1497 or early 1498.
His father, also named Hans Holbein, was a painter of altarpieces, a respectable craftsman with a workshop and more talent than money.
The boy and his older brother, Ambrosius, grew up among pots of pigment, wooden panels and the smell of linseed oil.
By about 1515, the two brothers had moved to Basel, a busy city on the Rhine where printers, scholars and merchants crowded together and there was always work for a young man who could draw.
Holbein drew title pages, letters, borders and little woodcut scenes by the hundred.
His brother Ambrosius disappears from the records not long after, probably dead young.
Hans stayed.
In 1519 he joined the painters’ guild, and around the same time he married a widow named Elsbeth, a few years older than himself, who already had a small son.
They soon had children of their own, a boy named Philipp and a girl named Katharina.
It should have been a steady life.
Then two things happened at once.
The first was that Holbein met the most famous scholar in Europe.
Desiderius Erasmus lived in Basel in those years, a thin, careful, chilly man who wrote books that everyone read and quarreled with half the churchmen of the continent by letter.
Holbein painted him more than once, bent over his writing, his long nose and narrow fingers caught with a precision that no one had quite managed before.
Erasmus sent the portraits to his friends as gifts.
One of those friends was an English lawyer named Thomas More.
The second thing was the Reformation.
By the middle of the 1520s, the arguments that had begun in Germany were tearing Basel in half.
Preachers thundered against images in churches.
A painter whose living depended on saints and Madonnas was watching his trade dry up in front of him.
In 1526, Erasmus wrote a letter that has been quoted ever since.
He said that in Basel the arts were “freezing.”
And he said that Holbein was on his way to England “to pick up some angels.”
Angels were English gold coins, named for the archangel stamped on them.
It was a joke.
It was also the truth.
Holbein left his wife and children in Basel, crossed the Low Countries, and arrived in London carrying a letter of introduction.
He was not yet thirty.
He did not know that he was walking into the house of a man who would one day die on the orders of the king, and that the same king would make Holbein the most important painter in his kingdom.
—
## The house at Chelsea where he learned to paint the English
The letter took him to Thomas More.
More was then one of the cleverest and best-connected men in England, a royal councillor with a large family and a new house at Chelsea, a few miles up the Thames from the city.
He took the young German in.
Writing back to Erasmus that December, More put it simply.
“Your painter, my dearest Erasmus, is a wonderful artist.”
He added, according to the usual translations, that he feared England would not prove as fruitful for him as he had hoped, though he would do what he could.
He did a great deal.
Holbein painted More himself in 1527, in a heavy dark cloak with a fur collar and a gold chain of office, his face shaved and tired and watchful.
Through More, Holbein met the people who mattered.
He painted William Warham, the old Archbishop of Canterbury.
He drew the women of the More household, their daughters and their maids, and then he attempted something nobody in England had seen before.
He painted the whole family together.
It was not a stiff row of kneeling donors, the way families usually appeared in paintings.
It was a room full of real people, some sitting, some standing, a book open here, a little dog there, everyone caught in the middle of a moment.
The painting itself is lost.
But Holbein’s preparatory drawing survives, and it was sent to Erasmus, who wrote back that he recognized every one of them.
In 1528, Holbein went home.
He had made money in England.
He bought a house in Basel that summer, and he painted the picture that, for many people, is the saddest thing he ever made.
It shows his wife, Elsbeth, with their two children.
She sits half-turned toward us, red-eyed and heavy, a woman worn down by years of raising a family alone.
The little boy looks up at her.
The baby girl reaches toward something we cannot see.
Nobody in the picture is smiling.
All we know is what he painted.
A few months later, in February 1529, crowds broke into the churches of Basel and smashed or burned the images inside.
Erasmus packed up and left the city.
Basel’s council gave him some work, and for a while he took what there was.
But there was not much, and in 1532 he left again for London.
This time, when he arrived, he could not go back to Chelsea.
The house that had opened every door for him had become the most dangerous address in England.
—
## The painting with a skull no one could see
Thomas More had resigned as Lord Chancellor in May 1532.
He would not accept the king’s divorce from Catherine of Aragon or the break with Rome that was coming with it.
He was out of office, out of favor, and three years away from his death on Tower Hill.
Holbein needed new patrons, and he found them quickly.
The first were the German merchants of the Steelyard, the walled Hanseatic compound by the Thames, and he painted them one by one, at their desks, among their account books, seals, scales and letters, with little notes pinned to the wall behind them.
The second patron was the new power at court.
Thomas Cromwell, a blacksmith’s son who had become the king’s most useful servant, sat for him in about 1532 or 1533.
Holbein painted him in black, heavy-jawed, gripping a folded paper, looking slightly away as if he were listening to someone else.
It is the face of a man who knew where everybody’s secrets were kept.
And then, in the spring of 1533, came the painting that made Holbein’s name for the rest of time.
Two Frenchmen were in London that year.
One was Jean de Dinteville, the ambassador of the King of France, who, by his own letters, was unwell and longing to go home.
The other was his friend Georges de Selve, a young bishop, who came to visit him.
Holbein painted them standing side by side, almost life-size, on either side of a tall shelf crowded with things.
There are globes, one of the earth and one of the heavens.
There is a lute with one broken string, a hymn book lying open, a case of flutes.
And then there is the thing on the floor.
Across the bottom of the painting, slanting between the two men’s feet, is a long, pale, smeared shape that looks like nothing at all.
If you walk up to the painting from the front, it is a blur.
If you move to the right, close to the wall, and look along the surface at a steep angle, the blur suddenly snaps into shape.
It is a human skull.
Holbein had painted it stretched out of shape on purpose, so that it would only appear when the viewer stepped to one side and looked back.
In the top corner of the painting, half hidden by the green curtain, there is a small silver crucifix.
Nobody knows exactly what Dinteville intended by these things.
Scholars have read them as reminders of death, as private jokes, as a message about the troubles of the Church.
What is certain is that the painter who could make a skull appear and vanish depending on where you stood was not going to stay a merchants’ painter for long.
That same summer, Anne Boleyn was crowned queen.
The Steelyard merchants paid for one of the pageants along her procession route, a scene of Mount Parnassus with Apollo and the Muses and a fountain that ran with wine, and Holbein’s design for it survives.
Within a few years, the king himself would want something from him that no painter had ever been asked to give an English monarch.
He would want to be made into a giant.
—
## The year the king stood still
By 1536, Holbein was being called the King’s Painter.
A French poet who knew him used that title in a letter that year, and the royal accounts soon show him on a salary of thirty pounds a year, paid in quarterly installments.
It was a good wage, though not a great one.
Lucas Horenbout, the king’s Flemish painter of miniatures, was paid more.
Holbein was not a lord, not a knight, not even an Englishman.
He was a servant on the payroll, like the king’s musicians and his clockmakers.
But the king who paid him was changing, and Holbein was there to see it.
In January 1536, Henry had been thrown from his horse at a tournament at Greenwich and, by one report, lay senseless for two hours.
That spring, Anne Boleyn went to the scaffold.
Eleven days later, Henry married Jane Seymour.
He was nearly forty-five years old.
His leg was troubling him.
His waist was thickening.
The handsome young athlete of the 1510s was gone, and the king who replaced him was something heavier, harder and far more frightening.
Holbein painted that new man.
The earliest surviving result is a small panel, not much bigger than a sheet of writing paper, now in a museum in Madrid.
It shows Henry from the waist up, turned slightly to one side.
He wears a flat black cap with a white feather and a row of jewels.
His doublet is embroidered in gold thread, slashed to show white silk, and studded with rubies.
Gold chains hang across his chest.
And above all that glitter is the face.
It is broad and pale and heavy, with small eyes that do not blink and a mouth pressed so tight that it almost disappears.
There is no anger in it.
There is no need for anger.
It is the face of a man who has never once in his life been told no and expects nothing to change.
That little panel is the only painting of Henry VIII that experts agree was made entirely by Holbein’s own hand.
It was a rehearsal.
The real thing was going on the wall.
—
## The giant on the wall at Whitehall
In 1537, the king commissioned Holbein to paint the Privy Chamber at Whitehall.
Whitehall was the palace Henry had taken from Cardinal Wolsey, rebuilt and enlarged into one of the largest royal residences in Europe.
The Privy Chamber was the room at its heart, the place where the king spent his private hours, received his closest servants, and sometimes met ambassadors he wanted to impress.
Very few people saw it.
Everyone who did would see Holbein’s wall.
He began the way he always did, with paper.
He drew the figures life-size, in ink and watercolor, on sheets glued together into enormous cartoons.
Then he pricked the outlines with hundreds of tiny holes, so that powdered charcoal could be dusted through onto the plaster to transfer the design.
When it was finished, the wall showed four people.
At the back, raised on a step, stood Henry VII, the founder of the dynasty, lean and grave, leaning on a ledge.
Beside him stood his queen, Elizabeth of York.
In front of them, on the right, stood Jane Seymour, the new queen, in a gown of gold and crimson.
And on the left, in front of his own father, stood Henry VIII.
He faced straight out of the wall.
His feet were set wide apart.
His shoulders, padded and slashed and sewn with gold, filled almost the whole width of his place in the painting.
One hand rested near the dagger at his belt.
The other held a pair of gloves.
His father, behind him, looked thin and gray and almost apologetic.
The son looked like a fortress.
In the middle of the group stood a stone block like an altar, carved with a Latin verse.
It praised both kings, but it left no doubt which of them was greater.
The father had ended the wars and brought peace.
The son, it said, had driven out the Pope and restored true religion.
Every word of it was propaganda, and every brushstroke around it was designed to make the words look like plain fact.
Nobody can say how the king first reacted.
But we know what other people felt.
More than sixty years later, a Dutch writer named Karel van Mander, working from the reports of those who had seen the wall, wrote that the king stood there so lifelike and so majestic that the viewer felt “abashed, annihilated” in his presence.
That was exactly what Holbein had been paid to do.
He had not just painted a man.
He had painted the idea of a king who could not be argued with.
That October, Jane Seymour gave Henry his son, Edward, and then died twelve days later.
The queen on the wall stayed forever young and forever beside him.
The king himself would marry three more times.
Holbein would be sent to look at two of the women he considered.
And the second of those journeys would end with a man’s head on a block, though not, as people sometimes say, the painter’s.
—
## The portrait that crossed the sea for a king’s bride
By the end of 1537, Henry was a widower again, and the hunt for a new queen began.
The king could not easily travel abroad to look at the princesses of Europe, and he did not trust the descriptions his ambassadors sent home.
So Holbein was sent to bring their faces back.
In March 1538, he arrived in Brussels with an English diplomat named Philip Hoby.
The woman they had come to see was Christina of Denmark, the king of Denmark’s daughter, who had been married as a child to the Duke of Milan and was now a widow of about sixteen.
She gave Holbein a single sitting.
It lasted three hours.
From the drawings he made that afternoon, he produced a full-length portrait of a tall, pale young woman in a black mourning gown, her hands folded, her lips just on the edge of a smile.
Henry was said to be delighted with it.
He never got the bride.
A famous story claims she said that if she had two heads, one of them would be at the King of England’s service.
That same year, Holbein went home to Basel for a visit.
The city that had let him go now wanted him back.
The council paid him honor and offered him a pension to return for good, and later writers said he walked the streets dressed in silk and satin, like a man who had done very well in a foreign court.
He did not take the offer; after a few weeks he went back to England, and his wife and children stayed behind.
On New Year’s Day of 1539, Holbein gave Henry a gift: a small portrait of the prince, Edward, about fourteen months old, in a red gown and a feathered cap, one hand raised as if blessing the viewer.
Underneath, a Latin verse urged the little boy to be like his father, and suggested that if he could match him, the world would never need to ask for more.
That summer, he was sent abroad again.
This time he went to the duchy of Cleves, on the lower Rhine, to paint the two unmarried sisters of its young duke.
Cromwell had pushed hard for this alliance.
Holbein painted Anne of Cleves at the castle of Düren in August 1539.
She faces the viewer directly, calm and still, in a heavy red dress and an elaborate cap and headdress, with her hands folded in front of her.
It was sent back to England.
The marriage treaty was signed.
And on New Year’s Day of 1540, at Rochester, Henry met Anne in person for the first time, and he did not like what he saw.
He married her anyway, a few days later, because he could not find a way out, and then spent six months looking for one.
It is often said that Holbein flattered her, and that the king blamed him for it.
There is no evidence that Henry ever blamed Holbein for anything.
The man the king blamed was the one who had arranged the match.
Thomas Cromwell was arrested in the Council chamber in June 1540, and he died on Tower Hill at the end of July.
Holbein kept his post, his salary and his commissions.
But he had just watched two of his greatest patrons, More and Cromwell, go to their deaths.
He must have understood, better than most, how quickly a face at court could stop being worth painting.
—
## What the king supposedly said about seven earls
There is a story about Holbein that has been told for more than four hundred years.
It goes like this.
One day, while Holbein was busy painting in his studio, a nobleman came up the stairs and demanded to be let in.
When the lord would not take no for an answer, Holbein lost his temper and threw him down the stairs.
Then, terrified of what he had done, he ran straight to the king and begged for protection.
The nobleman arrived soon after, furious, demanding that the painter be punished.
And Henry, so the story goes, turned on him.
He told the lord that he could make seven earls out of seven peasants any time he liked, but he could not make one Holbein out of seven earls.
It is a wonderful story, and almost certainly not true.
It first appears in the book Karel van Mander published in 1604, sixty years after Holbein’s death, and van Mander got several basic facts about Holbein wrong, including the year he died.
But legends tell us what people wanted to believe.
And what people wanted to believe was that the most terrifying king in English history had valued this one foreign craftsman above his own nobility.
The real records tell a quieter story.
Holbein was paid less than the king’s miniaturist.
He was paid in quarterly amounts, like a clerk.
He did not receive lands, titles, or a house from the king.
In the 1540s, he kept taking private work to make ends meet: portraits of courtiers and merchants, small round miniatures, designs for jewelry, cups, daggers, clocks and book covers for the goldsmiths of London.
And then there were the faces.
He drew the courtiers of the 1530s and 1540s in colored chalk on pink-tinted paper, quick, exact studies made at one sitting, ready to be turned into paintings later.
Many of the paintings are lost.
The drawings survive by the dozen, most of them in the Royal Collection at Windsor.
Here is the young Earl of Surrey, proud and touchy.
Here is Thomas Wyatt, the poet, with his great beard.
They are all looking at the same man.
He was the person in the room whose job was to look back.
And by the early 1540s, he had looked at nearly everyone who mattered, except, perhaps, at himself.
—
## The face he saved for last
Sometime around 1542 or 1543, Holbein drew his own face.
He used colored chalks and ink on a small sheet of paper, the same quick method he used for the courtiers.
He was about forty-five.
He shows himself in a plain brown cap, his heavy beard going gray, his eyes turned slightly toward us, tired and steady.
There is no gold chain, no rich fur, none of the jewels and silks he had painted on hundreds of other people.
It is a working man’s portrait of himself.
The drawing ended up in Florence, where it has hung in the Uffizi Gallery for centuries.
Someone, perhaps later, added a gold background and a Latin inscription that names him as a man of Basel who drew himself at the age of forty-five.
It may be the last image of Holbein made in his lifetime.
That same year, he took on one more big royal job.
The barbers and surgeons of London had been joined into a single company by act of Parliament, and they wanted a painting to celebrate it.
It would show the king enthroned, handing the company its charter, with the leading surgeons kneeling on either side.
Holbein began it.
He did not finish it.
Other hands completed the painting after him, and it still belongs to the company today.
In it, Henry is older again, his face swollen, sitting rather than standing.
The giant on the Whitehall wall had been only six years earlier.
The king was failing.
So, it turned out, was the painter.
—
## The autumn of 1543
By the autumn of 1543, sickness was moving through London.
It was a plague year.
The court kept away from the city whenever it could.
People who could afford to leave did, and people who could not stayed and hoped.
Holbein stayed.
He lived in the parish of St Andrew Undershaft, near Aldgate, among the narrow streets where foreign craftsmen gathered.
It was the kind of place where the goldsmith next door might lend you money and the merchant across the way might sit for a portrait in return for a favor.
We do not know exactly when he fell ill, or what the illness was.
We know only that on October 7, 1543, he decided to make a will, and that he did it in a hurry.
Picture that room again.
There was no lawyer, no notary, no clerk with a properly drawn-up document.
There were neighbors.
The men who came in were the people Holbein trusted most in London, and most of them, like him, had been born somewhere else.
There was the goldsmith John of Antwerp, a man the king also employed.
There were several German neighbors.
Their names were written at the bottom as witnesses.
Holbein spoke, and someone wrote.
He called himself, in the words that have come down to us, “Johan Holbein, servant to the King’s Majesty.”
It is worth stopping on that phrase.
He had painted the king as a giant.
He had painted ambassadors, archbishops, chancellors, queens.
His work hung in palaces and was copied by every workshop in England.
At the end, he described himself the way a royal groom or a palace cook might have done.
He was the king’s servant.
That was his place in the world, and he knew it.
Then he turned to the money.
He wanted his goods sold.
He owed, so the will says, a little over ten pounds to a man described as the king’s servant at Greenwich, and six pounds to John of Antwerp, and he wanted both debts paid in full.
As it is usually printed, the will does not mention his wife in Basel.
It does not mention his children there, either, though the eldest were nearly grown by then.
He named no estate, no lands, no house.
And then he came to the two children in London.
Nobody knows who their mother was.
Nobody knows their names.
They were very small, small enough to be living with a nurse, and he left money to pay for their keeping, seven shillings and sixpence for every month.
That is the whole of what we know about them.
They appear in this one sentence, in this one document, and then they vanish from history completely.
When the witnesses had signed, they went home.
It is not hard to imagine the room after they left: the papers, the brushes, the boards and colors that a painter keeps around him, and a sick man lying among the tools of a trade he could no longer practice.
Somewhere in that house, or in a workshop nearby, there may still have been unfinished faces waiting on their panels, the barber-surgeons among them, the king’s heavy features only half laid in.
The days went on.
We do not know how many.
Somewhere between that afternoon in early October and the end of November 1543, in the plague season, Hans Holbein died.
He was about forty-five years old.
There is no record of his last words.
There is no letter describing his death.
There is no royal order for his funeral.
The king, so far as anyone knows, said nothing at all.
On November 29, 1543, John of Antwerp appeared before the church court in London and took on the job of administering the estate.
That is the last trace.
For a long time, people assumed that Holbein had died of the plague.
Van Mander said so, and it fits the season.
Some modern historians doubt it.
They point out that his friends came to his bedside to witness the will, which people rarely did when a man was dying of plague, and suggest he may have died of some other infection.
Nobody can prove it either way.
And then there is the question of where they put him.
If he died of plague, he may have been buried quickly, perhaps in a crowded churchyard, perhaps in a pit with other victims of the season.
If he died of something else, there may have been a proper funeral in his parish church.
His parish was St Andrew Undershaft.
The church of St Katharine Cree stood a short walk away.
Either could have taken him.
But the burial registers of St Andrew Undershaft only begin in 1558, fifteen years after his death.
Those of St Katharine Cree survive only from 1663.
Whatever was written down in the autumn of 1543, if anything was written at all, is gone.
The king’s painter had walked out of the record as completely as the two children at nurse.
—
## The palace that burned with the king still on the wall
Henry VIII outlived his painter by a little more than three years.
He died at Whitehall in January 1547, in the same palace where Holbein’s giant stood on the wall of his private rooms.
But by then the giant had already escaped.
Holbein’s image of the king had been copied from the beginning.
Workshops all over England produced versions of it: full-length, half-length, head and shoulders, for the walls of noblemen who wanted to show their loyalty, for colleges, for town halls, for country houses.
All of them come from the same pattern.
The wide stance, the square shoulders, the jeweled cap tilted on the head, the small eyes, the fists near the belt.
Ask almost anyone today to picture Henry VIII, and that is the man they will describe.
One modern historian of royal portraits, Sir Roy Strong, called the Whitehall image arguably the most famous royal portrait of all time.
The wall itself lasted much longer than either the king or the painter.
It survived the civil war and the beheading of Charles I, who walked out to his death from a window of the same palace.
In 1667, King Charles II, who knew what a treasure he had, ordered a painter named Remigius van Leemput to make a small copy of the whole wall.
It was lucky that he did.
On January 4, 1698, a fire broke out in Whitehall Palace in the afternoon.
It burned for something like seventeen hours, and by the time it was over, most of the palace was gone.
So was the Privy Chamber.
So was the wall.
The king who could not be argued with had been reduced to ash and fallen plaster.
Except for one piece.
Somewhere along the way, part of Holbein’s original cartoon, the huge ink-and-watercolor drawing he had used to plan the wall, had been saved.
It was the left-hand section, the part showing the two kings, Henry VII and Henry VIII, father and son.
And all along the outlines of the figures, if you look closely, you can still see the tiny holes Holbein pricked through it in 1537 so the charcoal dust could pass through onto the plaster.
That cartoon passed down through the family of the Dukes of Devonshire.
In 1957, it was accepted by the nation in place of tax, and today it hangs in the National Portrait Gallery in London.
It is the closest thing left to the giant on the wall.
It is the only part of the most famous royal portrait in English history that Holbein’s own hand ever touched and that still survives.
—
## The wrong year, for three hundred years
There was another thing the fire could not touch, because nobody had found it yet.
Van Mander, writing in 1604, had said that Holbein died of plague in London in 1554.
That date was eleven years too late.
But it was in print, in the most important book about northern painters of its age, and for a very long time nobody had any reason to question it.
Biographers built their stories on it.
Paintings made in the late 1540s and early 1550s were confidently given to Holbein because everyone believed he was still alive to paint them.
Then, in the middle of the nineteenth century, a researcher named William Henry Black went looking through old probate records in London.
Among the wills proved in the church courts of the city, he came across a short document dated October 7, 1543.
It was the will of “Johan Holbein, servant to the King’s Majesty.”
It had been sitting in the records, unnoticed, for more than three hundred years.
When it was published in the 1860s, it overturned what everyone thought they knew about the end of Holbein’s life.
He had not lived into the reign of Mary I.
He had died in the autumn of 1543, before Henry VIII himself, in the middle of the king’s reign.
Whole groups of paintings had to be taken away from him and given to other artists.
The biography of the most famous painter in Tudor England had to be rewritten from the last chapter backward.
And the discovery explained, at last, why nobody had ever found his grave.
People had been looking in the wrong decade.
But by then, it was far too late to look in the right one.
—
## The earl who went looking for a grave
The great collector of Holbein in the seventeenth century was Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel.
He was a great-grandson of the Earl of Surrey, the poet whom Henry VIII sent to the block in the last weeks of his reign.
He owned Holbein’s portraits of the Howards, his portrait of Erasmus, sketches and miniatures and designs for jewels.
He hired the engraver Wenceslaus Hollar to copy many of them, so that more people could see them, and some of those works now survive only through Hollar’s prints.
Arundel loved Holbein the way some men love a lost cause.
According to the story that has come down to us, he wanted to do one more thing for him.
He wanted to put up a monument over Holbein’s grave.
So he went looking.
He is said to have sought the grave at St Katharine Cree, the church near Aldgate that people believed was the right place.
He found nothing: no stone, no inscription, no record in the books.
The monument was never built.
In the eighteenth century, the historian John Strype wrote, in his expanded edition of Stow’s *Survey of London*, that Holbein was buried in St Katharine Cree.
Later scholars thought this was doubtful, a guess rather than a record.
Others argued for St Andrew Undershaft, his own parish church, a little to the west.
There are other stories, too.
People in the Victorian age said that when workmen tunneled beneath the area, they broke into a great mass of human bones, an old burial pit, and some writers have wondered whether Holbein might lie somewhere among them.
Nobody knows.
Both churches still stand.
St Katharine Cree is on Leadenhall Street, a modest stone building that survived both the Great Fire of 1666 and the bombs of the Second World War.
St Andrew Undershaft, his parish church, stands just around the corner.
It is a small medieval church with a square stone tower, and today it sits at the foot of one of the most famous skyscrapers in London, the tall glass tower that Londoners call the Gherkin.
Most of them have no idea that the man who painted the face of Henry VIII once lived in this parish, made his will a few streets away, and may be lying somewhere beneath their feet.
—
## What became of the people around him
Holbein’s wife, Elsbeth, lived on in Basel after his death.
She is thought to have spent her last years in modest circumstances, and to have died around 1549.
His son Philipp became a goldsmith, trained in Paris, and settled eventually in Augsburg, the city where his father had been born.
Another son, Jakob, is said to have gone to London, perhaps following his father’s trade, and to have died there in the early 1550s.
The two children at nurse in London disappear from every record.
They may have died young, in the plague years.
They may have grown up under other names, never knowing who their father was.
Henry VIII died in January 1547, and his body was carried to Windsor and laid beside Jane Seymour, the queen Holbein had painted on the wall beside him.
The prince whose baby portrait Holbein had given as a New Year’s gift became King Edward VI at nine, and died at fifteen.
The painting of the two ambassadors with the hidden skull went to France with Jean de Dinteville, stayed in his family’s chateau for generations, and later found its way to England, where the National Gallery bought it in 1890.
Thomas More’s portrait is in New York.
Cromwell’s is in New York too, in the same room, the two enemies facing each other across a fireplace.
Holbein’s drawings of the court, more than eighty of them, are in the Royal Collection, looked after by the descendants of the king who employed him.
The picture of his wife and children is in Basel, in the museum of the city he left.
His self-portrait is in Florence.
He himself is nowhere.
—
## The face, and the man behind it
There is something about the way the story ends that is hard to shake.
Holbein spent his life making people visible.
That was the whole of his gift.
A merchant at his desk, a scholar at his book, a young widow in black, a frightened bride, a baby prince, a king who wanted to look like a mountain: he looked at each of them so hard and so honestly that we can still see them now, centuries after everyone who knew them has turned to dust.
He did it so well that, for most of the world, his version of Henry VIII simply is Henry VIII.
The real king, with his bad leg and his temper and his six marriages, is buried at Windsor under a plain black slab.
The king we picture when we hear his name is the one Holbein painted on the wall.
And the painter himself?
He left a few lines in a will, written by neighbors on an autumn afternoon.
He called himself the king’s servant.
He asked for his debts to be paid.
He remembered two small children at a nurse’s house whose names we will never know.
Then he walked out of the record, into the plague season, into a grave that no earl, no historian and no railway workman has ever found.
The man who gave England the face of its king left no face behind on his own grave.
He did not need one.
Every time someone pictures Henry VIII, standing with his feet apart and his fists by his belt, staring out at the world as if daring it to blink first, they are looking at Hans Holbein’s work.
They are just not looking at Hans Holbein.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
**Early life:** Holbein was born in Augsburg in the winter of 1497–98, son of the painter Hans Holbein the Elder, and was in Basel by about 1515; he married the widow Elsbeth Binsenstock in about 1519.
**Erasmus and More:** The phrases about the arts “freezing” in Basel and going to England “to pick up some angels” come from Erasmus’s letters of 1526, quoted in their usual English renderings; More’s line “Your painter, my dearest Erasmus, is a wonderful artist” is from his reply, and the rest of that letter is paraphrased.
**Works:** The More family painting is lost (the drawing survives in Basel); the portrait of Holbein’s wife and children (about 1528) is in Basel; *The Ambassadors* (1533) is in the National Gallery, London, and the meaning of its skull and crucifix is debated.
**King’s Painter:** The title appears in a 1536 letter of the poet Nicholas Bourbon; the salary of thirty pounds a year is in the royal accounts.
The Madrid panel (Thyssen-Bornemisza Museum, about 1536–37) is generally accepted as the only surviving painted portrait of Henry VIII wholly by Holbein.
**Whitehall:** The mural was painted in 1537 and destroyed in the fire that began on January 4, 1698; it is known from van Leemput’s copy of 1667, and the left-hand section of the cartoon is in the National Portrait Gallery (accepted in lieu of tax, 1957).
Our summary of its Latin verse is simplified, and “abashed, annihilated” is the usual translation of van Mander (1604), who was not an eyewitness.
**Christina and Anne:** Holbein drew Christina of Denmark in Brussels in March 1538 at a sitting of about three hours; her “two heads” remark is a later anecdote.
He painted Anne of Cleves at Düren in 1539; there is no evidence that Henry blamed him for the marriage.
**Legends:** The “seven earls” story comes from van Mander and is regarded as a legend; the silk and satin in Basel come from later accounts.
**The self-portrait** in the Uffizi is a chalk drawing that has been enlarged and reworked; its gold background and inscription are later.
**The will** is dated October 7, 1543, made at his home in the parish of St Andrew Undershaft and witnessed by John of Antwerp and German neighbors; the quoted phrases and sums follow the usual printed version, and the original spelling differs.
John of Antwerp took on the estate on November 29, 1543, so Holbein died between those two dates, aged about forty-five.
Van Mander said plague (and gave the year as 1554); some modern historians suggest another infection.
The will was found in the 1860s; the finder is usually named as William Henry Black.
**The burial** is unknown; St Andrew Undershaft and St Katharine Cree are the likeliest places, but their surviving registers begin in 1558 and 1663.
Strype’s claim for St Katharine Cree has been doubted; Arundel’s search for the grave, and the Victorian tale of a burial pit, come from later tradition.
**The family:** What we say of Elsbeth, Philipp and Jakob after 1543 follows secondary accounts and is given with caution.
**The opening scene** is reconstructed from the will; the stairs and the hour are our setting, not the record’s.