News

1596: Some Said He Was Henry VIII’s Son. On His Deathbed, Elizabeth I Offered Him an Earldom, and He Turned It Down

The windows of the bedchamber at Somerset House looked out over the Thames, and in late July the river smelled the way it always did in a London summer: of mud, tar, and too many people.

Somewhere below, boatmen were calling for fares.

Up here, the room was hot and quiet.

The man in the bed was seventy years old.

For most of his life he had been a soldier, a big-voiced, hard-swearing man who rode the Scottish border in all weathers and was said to fear nobody.

Now he could barely lift his head from the pillow.

The household had been told to expect a visitor.

When she came in, everyone in the room went down on their knees.

She was sixty-two, painted white, dressed in silk stiff with pearls, and she had ruled England for nearly thirty-eight years.

She was also his cousin.

Behind her, servants carried two things to the bed.

The first was a sheet of parchment, heavy with a royal seal.

The second was a robe of crimson velvet, lined and edged with white ermine: the robe of an earl.

The parchment, so the story goes, was the patent that would make him Earl of Wiltshire, a title that had once belonged to his own grandfather.

All he had to do was accept it.

The old man looked at the robe for a long moment.

Then he looked at the queen.

And then he said something that people would repeat for the next hundred years.

What could a dying man possibly say to a queen who had come to his bedside with a gift?

His name was Henry Carey, Lord Hunsdon.

He was the son of Anne Boleyn’s sister.

And for the whole of his life, a question had followed him from room to room, one that no one at court was foolish enough to ask aloud: who was his real father?

To understand what he told Elizabeth that afternoon, and why it may have been about much more than a title, you have to go back seventy years, to a whisper that cost the man who repeated it his life.

—

## The boy a priest called “the king’s son”

In the spring of 1535, a priest named John Hale was questioned by the king’s officers.

Hale was the vicar of Isleworth, a village on the Thames a few miles upstream from London, close to the great abbey at Syon.

He was an old man, and he had said things he should not have said.

He had spoken against the king’s new marriage to Anne Boleyn.

He had spoken against the king himself.

And somewhere in the record of what he admitted, there is one remarkable line.

Hale said that a man named Skidmore had once shown him a little boy, “young Master Carey,” and told him that the child was the king’s son, born to the queen’s own sister.

The boy in question was about nine years old.

He was Henry Carey.

It is the only time, as far as anyone knows, that a person at Henry VIII’s court was recorded saying it outright.

It was hearsay, passed from one man to another.

Hale hated the Boleyns, and he was a man with every reason to spread a scandal about them.

And within weeks, he had gone to Tyburn with a group of monks who had refused to accept the king as head of the Church.

Whatever he knew, or thought he knew, went with him.

But the story he repeated had a shape that made sense to anyone who had been at court in the 1520s.

The boy’s mother was Mary Boleyn, the elder sister of the woman who was now queen.

In February 1520, Mary had married a young gentleman of the king’s privy chamber named William Carey.

The king himself attended the wedding.

At some point in the years that followed, and no one wrote down exactly when, Mary became Henry VIII’s mistress.

It was never a public affair.

There were no grand gifts recorded, no titles, no announcements.

But the grants that flowed to her husband William in those years were noticed.

And in about 1524, Mary had a daughter, Catherine.

On March 4, 1526, she had a son.

The baby was named Henry.

In a court that watched names the way sailors watch weather, that was enough to start people counting months on their fingers.

By the time Henry Carey was born, most historians believe the affair with Mary was over, or nearly so.

By then the king’s eye had already moved to her younger sister.

That was the problem.

If the boy was the king’s son, he was the king’s son by the sister of the woman Henry now wanted to marry.

Under the Church’s own rules, that connection was itself an obstacle to the marriage.

It was not a story the king wanted told.

So did Henry VIII ever believe the boy was his?

The strange thing is how loudly he said nothing at all.

—

## Why the king never said a word

Henry VIII was not shy about his sons.

In 1519, his mistress Bessie Blount had given him a boy, and the king had made no secret of it.

In 1525, the year before Henry Carey was born, that boy, Henry FitzRoy, was made Duke of Richmond and Somerset at the age of six, in a glittering ceremony in front of the whole court.

He was given his own household, his own lands, his own council.

Some people even thought the king might name him as heir.

Nothing like that ever happened for the Carey children.

Not a title, not a ceremony, not a word.

You can read that silence two ways.

Either Henry knew the boy was not his, or he knew perfectly well that he might be, and that saying so would wreck everything he was trying to do.

Nobody can prove either one.

What can be said is that in the summer of 1528, the boy’s world changed.

The sweating sickness came to London that June, a fever so fast that people said a man could be merry at dinner and dead by supper.

William Carey caught it.

Within days, he was gone.

His son was two years old.

A widow at court with small children had no money of her own, and Mary Boleyn was left in real difficulty.

Her sister stepped in.

Anne Boleyn took over the wardship of her little nephew, which meant she controlled his upbringing and his future.

She saw to his education.

For a time the boy was taught by monks in a Cistercian house, and later by a French poet named Nicholas Bourbon, whom Anne had sheltered in England.

Henry Carey was being raised, in effect, as a Boleyn boy at the very top of the court.

Then, in May 1536, it all came apart.

His aunt Anne was arrested, tried, and put to death on Tower Green.

He was ten.

His mother had already been sent away from court two years earlier.

In 1534, Mary Boleyn had secretly married a soldier of no fortune named William Stafford, and her furious family had cut her off.

In a letter that survives, she wrote that she would rather beg her bread with him than be the greatest queen in Christendom.

She lived quietly in the country with her second husband until her death in July 1543.

Her son was seventeen.

The whisper about who his father was did not die with his mother.

It simply went quiet, the way dangerous things did in Henry VIII’s England.

And the boy grew up into a man who would spend the next fifteen years learning a skill that would one day matter more than any title: how to stay alive while the people around him fell.

—

## The cousin who waited

On May 21, 1545, Henry Carey married Anne Morgan, the daughter of a Herefordshire knight.

It was a quiet match, not a great one.

It turned into a long and crowded marriage: the couple would have more than a dozen children together, and Carey would have others outside it.

Two years later, Henry VIII was dead.

His nine-year-old son became Edward VI.

Then, in 1553, Edward died too, and after nine days of chaos his half-sister Mary took the throne.

For a Protestant cousin of Anne Boleyn’s daughter, these were not good years.

Mary I had every reason to distrust anyone connected to the woman who had replaced her mother.

Her half-sister Elizabeth spent part of the reign under suspicion, at one point in the Tower of London, at another under guard in the country.

Carey kept his head down.

He sat in Parliament, he did not plot, and he did not flee abroad, as his sister Catherine and her husband did.

He waited.

It is worth pausing on what that waiting meant.

In 1558, Henry Carey was thirty-two years old.

He had no great title, no great fortune, and a family name that had been, for twenty years, a reason for the powerful to look the other way.

The one thing he had was blood.

His mother and Elizabeth’s mother had been sisters.

And if the old whisper was true, he and Elizabeth shared a father too.

On November 17, 1558, Mary I died.

Within weeks, the man nobody had bothered with was being summoned to the new queen.

—

## What Elizabeth gave him in her first eight weeks

Elizabeth I came to the throne at twenty-five with very little family she could trust.

Her mother was dead.

Her father was dead.

Her brother and sister were dead.

Most of her father’s other relatives were either Catholic, ambitious, or both.

But she had Boleyn cousins.

And she gathered them around her almost at once.

That November, Henry Carey was knighted.

On January 13, 1559, two days before her coronation, she made him a peer of the realm: Baron Hunsdon.

With the title came land.

She gave him the manor of Hunsdon in Hertfordshire, a red-brick royal house where her own brother and sister had lived as children, and where she herself had spent part of her childhood.

She gave him the manor of Eastwick nearby, property in Kent, and a pension of four hundred pounds a year.

Two years later, in April 1561, he was made a Knight of the Garter, the oldest and most exclusive order of chivalry in England.

In 1564 he became captain of the Gentlemen Pensioners, the band of well-born men who guarded the queen’s person.

That same year, when Elizabeth made her famous visit to Cambridge, he rode with her, and the university gave him an honorary degree.

It looked like a shower of favor.

In one sense it was.

But look closely at the list, and something is missing.

Elizabeth was famously sparing with titles.

She created very few new peers in her whole reign, and fewer earls still.

She would make her cousin a baron, a Knight of the Garter, the captain of her guard.

She would trust him with her life, her borders and, eventually, her own household.

She would not make him an earl.

He would wait thirty-seven years for her to change her mind.

In the meantime, she found a use for him that suited him far better than court ceremony.

She sent him to war.

—

## The winter the north rose

In 1568, Lord Hunsdon was appointed governor of Berwick-upon-Tweed, the fortified town on the very edge of England, where the River Tweed runs into the North Sea and Scotland begins on the other bank.

Berwick was the most heavily garrisoned place in the kingdom.

It was also cold, damp, expensive, and a very long way from the queen.

Hunsdon threw himself into the job.

He was, by every account, a hard, blunt, physically fearless man, and the soldiers liked him for it.

He had been there barely a year when the north exploded.

In November 1569, two of the greatest lords of the north, the Earls of Northumberland and Westmorland, rose in rebellion.

Their banners carried the Catholic symbols of the old faith.

They marched into Durham Cathedral, tore up the English prayer books, and heard the old Latin Mass said again.

Their aim, as the government understood it, was to free Mary, Queen of Scots, who was then a prisoner in England, and perhaps to put her on Elizabeth’s throne.

Thousands joined them.

For a few weeks, it looked as if the whole north might go.

Hunsdon rode south to Doncaster, then to Hull and York, gathering men and joining the queen’s commander in the north, the Earl of Sussex.

As the royal armies moved, the rebellion began to crack.

By Christmas, the two earls had fled across the border into Scotland.

It seemed to be over.

It was not.

One great northern lord had held back from the first rising: Leonard Dacre, a powerful and bitter man whose family held huge estates along the western border.

In the new year, he gathered his own force at his castle of Naworth, near Carlisle.

Some said he had pretended loyalty while he waited for his moment.

His men were border riders, hard and experienced.

And there were a great many of them.

On February 20, 1570, Hunsdon was moving with a force of about fifteen hundred men between Naworth and Carlisle.

Dacre came at him with roughly twice that number.

The ground was cold, wet, open moorland near the little River Gelt.

Hunsdon was outnumbered two to one.

He could have pulled back.

He did not.

By most accounts, he sent his horsemen straight at Dacre’s men and rode with them himself.

The fight was short and savage.

When it broke, it was Dacre’s men who were running.

Dacre himself escaped across the border to Scotland and never came home again.

When the news reached London, Elizabeth wrote to her cousin.

The official part of the letter was in the usual careful language of the queen’s secretaries.

But at the end, she took the pen herself.

“I doubt much, my Harry,” she wrote, “whether that the victory were given me more joyed me,” and then went on to say, in effect, that she was even gladder that it was he who had won it for her.

My Harry.

It is one of the warmest things Elizabeth I ever put in writing to anyone.

For a moment, he was the hero of the kingdom.

What she did not send with the letter was money.

And that, for the next quarter of a century, would be the story of his life.

—

## “My salary is unpaid”

Berwick ate money.

The garrison had to be fed, clothed, armed and paid, and the payments from London were always late.

The governor was expected to make up the difference from his own pocket.

Hunsdon had no great fortune to begin with.

In May 1572, he wrote to the queen’s chief minister, Lord Burghley, begging to be recalled.

His salary had not been paid, he said, and his own resources could no longer carry the costs of the office.

He was not recalled.

That same summer, he was handed a task he plainly hated.

The Earl of Northumberland, the leader of the 1569 rising, had been held in Scotland ever since.

In 1572, the Scots handed him back to the English for a sum of money.

He was delivered at Berwick into Hunsdon’s custody.

Hunsdon passed him on, as ordered, to another border officer, and in August 1572 Northumberland was put to death at York.

It was the kind of work a Tudor servant could not refuse.

Hunsdon did it, and went back to the garrison.

Twelve years later, in June 1584, he was still writing the same letters.

His pay was in arrears again.

This time, he said, his men lacked food and clothing.

A governor who cannot feed his soldiers is a governor who is waiting for a mutiny, and Hunsdon knew it.

Year after year, he held the border with promises.

He also held it hard.

Raiders who crossed into England during his time on the border could expect very little mercy.

The border families, English and Scottish alike, learned his name.

He was rough, loud, and quick to anger.

But his soldiers, by every contemporary account, respected him.

And the queen, though she never paid him what he was owed, never stopped needing him.

She needed him, very soon, a great deal closer to home.

—

## The man who held the keys to the queen’s rooms

In the mid-1580s, Elizabeth made her cousin Lord Chamberlain of the Household.

It was one of the most powerful posts at court, and one of the most personal.

The Lord Chamberlain ran everything “above stairs” in the royal palaces: the queen’s own apartments, her ceremonies, her entertainments, the people who could come near her and the people who could not.

He was, in a very real sense, the keeper of the doors.

He held the post for the rest of his life.

It brought him into the darkest business of the reign.

In October 1586, he sat among the commissioners at Fotheringhay Castle who heard the case against Mary, Queen of Scots, the woman the northern rebels had once risen to free.

The commission found her guilty.

Four months later, she was dead.

Hunsdon had been present for the beginning and the end of her long English story.

Then, in 1588, the Spanish Armada sailed.

As the great fleet came up the Channel, England raised its land forces in a hurry.

One army was assembled at Tilbury on the Thames, where Elizabeth would famously ride out to speak to her troops.

A second force was raised for one purpose only: to guard the queen herself.

Its command was given to Lord Hunsdon.

Whatever else she thought of him, Elizabeth wanted her cousin between herself and the enemy.

What was he actually like?

Sir Robert Naunton, who wrote a short book of character sketches of Elizabeth’s courtiers a generation later, remembered him as “a fast man to his prince,” firm to his friends and servants, a man who could talk big but did far less harm than his words suggested.

Naunton also joked that Hunsdon’s Latin and his talent for hiding his feelings were about equal, which is to say that he had neither.

He swore constantly.

He said what he thought.

He belonged to no faction, and the smooth professional courtiers were a little afraid of him.

And, unexpectedly, he loved plants.

The herbalist John Gerard, who wrote one of the great gardening books of the age, counted him among the noblemen who took a real interest in rare flowers.

He was not a saint.

In his sixties, he kept a young mistress, Emilia Bassano, the daughter of one of the queen’s Italian court musicians, and paid her a yearly allowance.

When she became pregnant in 1592, he arranged for her to be married to another musician, Alfonso Lanier, and she gave birth to a son the next year.

She named the boy Henry.

Emilia Lanier would later become one of the first women in England to publish a book of her own poetry.

But the strangest thing about the old soldier, the thing that still keeps his name alive, has nothing to do with war at all.

It has to do with a group of actors.

—

## The players who wore his name

In the spring of 1594, after two terrible years of plague had shut the London playhouses, the theater world reorganized itself.

Two new companies emerged, each under the protection of a powerful man.

In Elizabethan England, actors without a noble patron could be treated as vagabonds.

With one, they wore his livery and his name, and they were his servants.

One company belonged to the Lord Admiral, Charles Howard, who happened to be Hunsdon’s son-in-law.

The other belonged to the Lord Chamberlain.

They became known as the Lord Chamberlain’s Men.

Among them were the actor Richard Burbage, the clown Will Kemp, and a writer and actor from Stratford-upon-Avon named William Shakespeare.

That autumn, a letter from Hunsdon to the Lord Mayor of London survives, asking that “my now company of players” be allowed to keep performing at an inn in the city through the winter.

It would be easy to make too much of this.

There is no evidence that the old soldier sat up late reading Shakespeare’s scripts, or that he chose the plays.

A patron’s job was to protect his players, to stand between them and a city government that wanted to close every playhouse it could.

He did that job.

But the plays his company is believed to have performed in the two years he was its patron include some of the most famous ever written.

Most scholars date *Romeo and Juliet* and *A Midsummer Night’s Dream* to roughly those years.

Every one of those performances was given, technically, by Lord Hunsdon’s servants.

And in the summer of 1596, as those servants were filling playhouses across the river, their master was dying.

—

## The summer of 1596

The summer began with a loss.

On July 19, 1596, Sir Francis Knollys died.

He had been married to Hunsdon’s sister Catherine, the woman whose funeral Elizabeth had paid for twenty-seven years earlier.

He had been one of the queen’s oldest servants, a stern Protestant who had guarded Mary, Queen of Scots in the first months of her captivity in England.

He was in his eighties.

With him, one more link to Elizabeth’s youth was gone.

Hunsdon was already ill.

He had been keeper of Somerset House, the great palace on the Strand, since 1574, and he was lying there now.

No one recorded exactly what was wrong with him.

He was seventy, he had spent decades on the border in the wet and the cold, and by midsummer he was not expected to recover.

Somerset House was not a quiet place to die.

It was a royal palace, and the Lord Chamberlain’s business did not stop because the Lord Chamberlain was in bed.

Messengers came and went through the courtyard.

Clerks waited with papers that needed a decision.

His wife Anne, who had been married to him for more than fifty years, would have been in the house, and his grown sons were men of the court themselves, with offices and duties of their own.

Doctors came with their purges and their cordials and went away again.

Across the river, on the Bankside, the actors who wore his name were still giving performances in the afternoons, because the summer season was when the money came in.

Over the rooftops, if the wind was right, you could hear the trumpets that announced a play was about to begin.

Inside, the curtains of the bed were drawn against the heat and the flies.

He had outlived almost everyone he had started with.

His mother had been dead for more than fifty years.

His sister Catherine was gone, and now her husband too.

The Earl of Sussex, who had led the queen’s army north in 1569, was long dead.

So was the Earl of Leicester, the queen’s great favorite, and so was Sir Francis Walsingham, and so was nearly every man who had stood beside him in the Privy Council in the year of the Armada.

Lord Burghley was still alive, but old, ill, and carried about in a chair.

The generation that had made Elizabeth’s reign was disappearing one funeral at a time.

And the queen, who had outlived them all, was watching it happen.

What happened next is not in any official record.

It comes to us from a story told after his death and written down, in the form we know it, by the clergyman and historian Thomas Fuller in the seventeenth century.

The story says that the queen came to see him.

Imagine what that meant.

Elizabeth did not often visit the sick.

She was sixty-two and famously hated any reminder of death, including her own.

But this was her cousin, her “Harry,” the last close male relative she had left in the world.

She came into the room, and the household knelt.

According to the story, she had brought the patent for an earldom with her, together with the robes.

The title was Wiltshire.

It was no random choice.

Earl of Wiltshire was the title Henry VIII had given to Sir Thomas Boleyn in 1529, when his daughter Anne was rising toward the throne.

Thomas Boleyn was Hunsdon’s grandfather.

He was also Elizabeth’s grandfather.

He was the father of the two Boleyn sisters, the father of Elizabeth’s mother and of Hunsdon’s mother.

After his death in 1539, the title had passed out of the family for good.

Now, at the very end, the queen was offering to give that old family name back to the family.

The servants laid the robes across the bed.

Crimson velvet.

White ermine.

The parchment with its seal beside it.

The old man looked at them.

He had waited thirty-seven years for this.

He had held her border with unpaid soldiers.

He had fought Dacre’s army at two to one.

He had sat in judgment at Fotheringhay.

He had commanded the army that guarded her body in the year of the Armada.

He had asked, over and over, for money and for honor, and been given letters instead.

And now that he could no longer stand, she had brought him the robe.

He told her, so the story goes, that he would not take it.

The words have come down to us in slightly different forms.

In the version most often repeated, he said: “Madam, as you did not count me worthy of this honour in my life, then I shall account myself not worthy of it in my death.”

Nobody recorded what Elizabeth said in reply.

Nobody recorded her face.

We do not know if she argued, or wept, or simply gathered her women and left.

We know only that the robes went back out of the room with her.

Perhaps the parchment was never sealed at all.

Perhaps it was rolled up and put away in a chest somewhere at court, a title that had existed for one afternoon, in one room, and then had never existed again.

The servants went back to their work.

The doctors came back with their cordials.

Below the windows the boatmen went on calling for fares, as if nothing at all had happened.

On July 23, 1596, four days after his brother-in-law, Henry Carey, Lord Hunsdon, died at Somerset House.

He was seventy years old.

He had been born the son of a royal mistress, in a court that whispered about him.

He died a baron.

—

## Why a Boleyn grandson might say no

There is a second version of the story, and it is not as noble.

Fuller also reported that Hunsdon’s death had been brought on, or at least hastened, by bitter disappointment at never having been made Earl of Wiltshire.

In this version, the refusal was not grand dignity.

It was the last word of a proud, hurt old man who felt he had been used for decades and rewarded with nothing that mattered.

Both versions can be true at once.

A man can be hurt and dignified in the same breath.

And there is something in the answer itself that fits everything else we know about Hunsdon.

He was blunt.

He did not flatter.

He had spent his whole life saying exactly what he thought to people who could have ruined him for it.

It would have been very like him to say it one last time, to the most powerful woman in Europe, from his deathbed.

But think about what the earldom actually was.

It was not just any title.

It was the Boleyn title, the one that had been stripped of all its glory in 1536, when Anne fell and her father was left a broken old man.

To take it would have been to accept, at the very end, the place of a Boleyn grandson, a cousin, a loyal servant, rewarded too late.

To refuse it was to say that he would rather die as what he had made of himself than be dressed up as something at the last minute.

And then there is the question that nobody at the bedside would ever have said aloud.

If the old whisper was true, the two people in that room were not just cousins.

They were brother and sister.

Both had been born to Boleyn sisters.

Both, perhaps, to the same king.

Elizabeth had been declared illegitimate at the age of two and had fought her way back to the throne.

Her cousin, if he was what John Hale had said, had never been acknowledged at all.

We will never know if either of them believed it.

There is no letter, no hint, no remark from Elizabeth or from Hunsdon that so much as mentions it.

Most modern historians think the evidence is too thin to say he was the king’s son, and some argue that by the time he was conceived the affair with Mary had already ended.

But the question hangs over that sickroom all the same.

What happened next, though, was no story.

It is written down in black and white, in the accounts of her own household.

—

## The tallest tomb in Westminster Abbey

Elizabeth I was famous for counting every penny.

She paid her cousin’s funeral herself.

On August 12, 1596, Henry Carey was buried in Westminster Abbey at the queen’s expense, in the Chapel of St John the Baptist, near the shrine of Edward the Confessor and the tombs of the medieval kings.

The full account of the funeral was kept among the records of the Lord Chamberlain’s own department, the department he had run for more than a decade.

A list of the costs survives among the papers of Lord Burghley.

His widow, Anne, and his eldest son, George, did the rest.

Sometime between 1600 and 1603, they raised a monument over his grave.

It is made of alabaster and marble, gilded and painted, with columns, obelisks and a great coffered arch, and it is thirty-six feet high.

It is the tallest monument in Westminster Abbey.

Look closely, and the monument tells a story of its own.

The obelisks in front of the tomb carry dozens of painted shields, the arms of about fifty families connected to the Careys by blood and marriage.

Among them is the name Bullen, the old spelling of Boleyn.

The Carey arms show three roses on a black band.

The family crest is a swan.

And under it runs the family motto, in French: *Comme je trouve.*

As I find it.

It is an odd and very honest motto for a man who spent his life taking the world exactly as he found it, unpaid salaries and all.

The long Latin inscription lists his offices: governor of Berwick, Knight of the Garter, Lord Chamberlain.

And it describes him, carefully and precisely, as the queen’s first cousin.

Not her brother.

Not the king’s son.

Her cousin.

Whatever anyone whispered in 1535, the family carved in stone the only thing that could be proved.

His wife was laid beside him in the vault in 1607.

Over the next century, many more Careys followed.

Their names are cut into a modern stone in front of the monument today.

—

## What happened to the Careys

His son George became the second Lord Hunsdon and, the following year, Lord Chamberlain like his father.

For a few months the actors were known as Lord Hunsdon’s Men, and then, once again, as the Lord Chamberlain’s Men.

In 1603, the new king, James I, took them under his own protection.

They became the King’s Men, the company for which Shakespeare would write *Macbeth*, *King Lear* and *The Tempest*.

George Carey did not live to see much of it.

He died in September 1603.

Hunsdon’s daughter Katherine, the wife of the Lord Admiral, became one of Elizabeth’s closest companions in her final years.

In February 1603, Katherine died.

The old queen took the loss terribly.

Within weeks, Elizabeth herself was ill, sitting for days on cushions on the floor and refusing to go to bed.

She died on March 24, 1603.

The last of Henry VIII’s children was gone.

It was Hunsdon’s youngest son, Robert Carey, who rode north through the night with the news.

He reached Edinburgh in about three days, battered and bruised from a fall on the road, and was the first to tell James VI of Scotland that he was now King of England.

James did not forget it.

Years later, under James’s son Charles I, Robert Carey was made Earl of Monmouth.

So the Carey family did get its earldom in the end.

It went to the son of the man who had refused one.

—

## The robe on the bed

Somerset House is still there on the Strand, though the palace Hunsdon knew was pulled down in the eighteenth century and rebuilt in grand stone.

At Hunsdon in Hertfordshire, a private house still stands on the site of the royal manor where three of Henry VIII’s children once lived.

Berwick’s great Elizabethan walls, the ones his garrison manned, still ring the town.

And in Westminster Abbey, the tallest tomb in the church stands over a man who was never more than a baron.

Go back, one last time, to the hot room above the river in July 1596.

An old soldier, too weak to lift his head.

A queen in white paint and pearls.

A robe of crimson and ermine spread across the blanket.

And a title that had belonged to the grandfather they shared.

She had come to give him, at the very end, a name from their family’s past.

He gave it back.

He would be buried as what he had been all his life: her cousin, her servant, her Harry.

And whatever else he may have been, he took that with him.

—

## What The Record Actually Says

**Birth and parents:** Henry Carey was born on March 4, 1526, the son of Mary Boleyn and her husband William Carey.

Mary’s affair with Henry VIII is accepted by historians, but its dates are unknown.

**The rumor:** The only known contemporary statement that Henry Carey was the king’s son comes from John Hale, vicar of Isleworth, in 1535, repeating what he said he had been told by another man.

Hale was hostile to the Boleyns, and his words were hearsay.

Only the phrase “young Master Carey” is quoted here; the rest is paraphrased.

Hale was put to death at Tyburn in May 1535.

Henry VIII never acknowledged Henry Carey or his sister, and most modern historians regard the paternity question as unproven; some think the affair had ended before Henry Carey was conceived.

**Childhood:** William Carey died in the sweating sickness of June 1528.

Anne Boleyn obtained her nephew’s wardship and paid for his education; his teachers included monks of a Cistercian house and the French poet Nicholas Bourbon.

Mary Boleyn’s line about begging her bread is paraphrased from her 1534 letter to Thomas Cromwell.

**Marriage and favor:** He married Anne Morgan on May 21, 1545.

He was knighted in November 1558, created Baron Hunsdon on January 13, 1559, granted Hunsdon, Eastwick and lands in Kent with a pension of £400 a year, made a Knight of the Garter on April 20, 1561, and captain of the Gentlemen Pensioners in 1564.

He received his degree at Cambridge during the queen’s visit of 1564.

**Berwick and the North:** He became governor of Berwick on August 25, 1568.

He defeated Leonard Dacre near Carlisle, by the River Gelt, on February 20, 1570, with about 1,500 men against roughly twice that number.

The opening words of Elizabeth’s handwritten note (“I doubt much, my Harry…”) are quoted from the standard printed text; the rest is paraphrased.

His complaints about unpaid salary (May 1572; June 1584) and the handing over of the Earl of Northumberland in 1572 are recorded in his letters and in the standard biographies.

**Court offices:** He was Lord Chamberlain of the Household from the mid-1580s until his death (sources differ between 1583 and 1585).

He sat on the Fotheringhay commission in October 1586 and commanded the force raised to guard the queen’s person in 1588.

Naunton’s descriptions are paraphrased from *Fragmenta Regalia*, written decades after Hunsdon’s death, apart from the short phrase quoted.

**Emilia Bassano (Lanier):** Her relationship with Hunsdon is known chiefly from the notebooks of the astrologer Simon Forman; the pension and her 1592 marriage to Alfonso Lanier are well documented.

**The players:** The Lord Chamberlain’s Men were formed in 1594 under Hunsdon’s patronage.

The dating of Shakespeare’s plays to these years is approximate.

**The deathbed:** Hunsdon died at Somerset House on July 23, 1596.

The story that Elizabeth visited him with the patent and robes of the earldom of Wiltshire, and that he refused them, is a later tradition reported by Thomas Fuller in the seventeenth century and repeated by the *Dictionary of National Biography*; it is not found in any official record of 1596.

The words given here are the version usually quoted; they should be treated as tradition, not as a transcript.

Fuller also reported that disappointment at not being made an earl contributed to his death.

The details of the tradition are not easy to square with the record: the earldom of Wiltshire had been granted again in 1550, to William Paulet, later Marquess of Winchester, and was held by his family in 1596.

Whatever was offered, if anything was, may not have been exactly as the story says.

The opening scene (the heat, the river, the kneeling household) is our reconstruction of that tradition.

**Funeral and monument:** He was buried in Westminster Abbey on August 12, 1596, at the queen’s expense.

His monument in the Chapel of St John the Baptist, put up between 1600 and 1603 by his widow and son George, is thirty-six feet high and is described by the Abbey as the tallest in the church.

The inscription calls him the queen’s first cousin.

**Afterward:** Robert Carey’s ride to Edinburgh in March 1603 is described in his own memoirs; he was created Earl of Monmouth in 1626.

You Might Also Enjoy