1537: The Man Who Secretly Promised to Marry Henry VIII’s Niece, and the Love Poems He Wrote in the Tower
The lance came down level, and the horse began to run.
It was the first days of July 1536, and the court of Henry VIII was celebrating again.
The lists had been set up, the long wooden barrier down the middle, the stands hung with painted cloth, the ground beaten flat and dusty in the summer heat.
Trumpets.
The thud of hooves.
The crack of a lance shattering against armor, and the roar that went up when it did.
One of the riders that week was a young man of about twenty-five with a famous surname and almost nothing else to his name.
He was Lord Thomas Howard, the youngest son of a dead war hero, the half-brother of the most powerful duke in England.
He had no great estate.
He had no title of his own beyond the courtesy “Lord” that came with being a duke’s son.
What he had was a place at court, a talent for verse, a seat in the saddle, and a secret.
Somewhere among the women watching from the stands, or perhaps not there at all, was the secret.
Her name was Lady Margaret Douglas.
She was twenty.
She was the daughter of the king’s elder sister, which made her Henry VIII’s niece, and that summer, without anyone quite saying it aloud, it also made her one of the most valuable young women in Europe.
Thomas Howard had given her a ring.
She had given him her picture, and a diamond.
They had promised to marry each other.
Not one word of it had been said to the king.
He rode that week as if he had nothing to fear.
Within days, he would be taken through the gates of the Tower of London.
A law would be written with his name in it.
It would call him a traitor and sentence him to death.
The sentence was never carried out.
He never came to trial.
He never climbed a scaffold.
He was simply left where he was, a condemned man, for fifteen months.
So what happened to him in there?
And why, of all the things he lost in that fortress, did the words he wrote turn out to be the only part of him that escaped?
—
## Why would a man condemned to die be left alive?
The story of Thomas Howard is usually told as part of someone else’s story.
In most books he appears for a page or two in the life of Margaret Douglas, the king’s niece, who would go on to become the grandmother of King James I and the ancestor of every British monarch since.
He is the young man she loved first.
He is the reason she was locked up.
He is the one who did not come back.
But he was a person before he was a footnote.
He had a mother who outlived him.
He had brothers who would spend their own time in the Tower.
He had a nephew who would write about him years later, in lines that did not use his name but did not need to.
And in a small, battered book of paper that is now in the British Library, there are poems that many scholars believe he wrote, or copied out, or both, during the months when he was waiting to find out whether the king meant to kill him.
There is something else, too.
The king who condemned him never needed to send him to the block.
Henry VIII found a quieter way.
And when it was over, the king gave one order about the young man’s body, a single short phrase, that says more about the whole affair than the long law that had condemned him.
To understand it, you have to start with the family he was born into, and the battle that made it great.
—
## What did it mean to be born a Howard in 1511?
Thomas Howard was born in 1511, or perhaps early in 1512, into the most ambitious family in England.
His father was also called Thomas Howard.
He was already an old man by Tudor standards, close to seventy, a soldier who had spent his life climbing back from disaster.
He had fought for Richard III at Bosworth in 1485, been wounded, been captured, been stripped of his lands and titles, and spent years in the Tower himself.
He had won his way back into favor by being useful, loyal and very hard to kill.
His mother was Agnes Tilney, the old soldier’s second wife, a cousin of his first.
She was a strong, practical woman who would run great households for decades, and who would bury more of her children than any mother should.
Thomas was a younger son, and so he was never going to inherit much.
The great Howard title and the great Howard lands would go to his half-brother, also called Thomas, the son of the first marriage, who was nearly forty years older than him.
When the boy was about two years old, his father won the battle that changed everything.
In September 1513, while Henry VIII was away fighting in France, King James IV of Scotland invaded the north of England.
The old Earl of Surrey, as the elder Thomas Howard then was, marched north with an English army and met the Scots at Flodden, in Northumberland.
By nightfall the Scottish king was dead on the field, along with a great part of his nobility.
It was one of the most complete victories an English army ever won.
The next year Henry VIII gave the old soldier back the title his family had lost after Bosworth.
He became the second Duke of Norfolk.
There was a strange thread hidden in that battlefield, though nobody could have seen it then.
The Scottish king who died at Flodden was the husband of Henry VIII’s elder sister, Margaret Tudor.
The widow would marry again.
And in 1515, she would give birth to a daughter, Margaret Douglas.
The victory that raised up the Howards had made a widow of the woman whose daughter the youngest Howard would one day love.
When the old duke died in May 1524, at his castle of Framlingham in Suffolk, his funeral was one of the grandest England had seen for a subject.
His body was carried in procession to Thetford Priory in Norfolk, where the Howards buried their dead.
There were banners, heralds, hundreds of mourners in black, a long requiem, all the display that the Tudor age could give a man who had saved the kingdom.
His youngest son Thomas was about twelve.
He would be buried in the same priory thirteen years later.
There would be no banners at all.
—
## How did a younger son end up so close to the throne?
After her husband’s death, Agnes Tilney, the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk, kept large households at her houses in Lambeth, across the river from Westminster, and at Horsham in Sussex.
They were busy, crowded places, full of the children of relatives and the young people of good families sent to be raised in a great house.
One of the girls who would grow up in the duchess’s care was a step-granddaughter, a child named Catherine Howard, the daughter of one of Thomas’s elder half-brothers.
Years later, that household would bring disaster on the whole family.
In the late 1520s and early 1530s, though, the Howards were rising faster than ever, and the reason had a name.
Anne Boleyn.
Anne’s mother, Elizabeth, had been born a Howard.
She was a daughter of the old duke’s first marriage, a half-sister of young Thomas.
That made Anne Boleyn his half-niece, even though she was older than he was.
When the king set his heart on Anne and spent six years breaking the church and the law to marry her, the Howards rode up with her.
Thomas’s half-brother, the third duke, was among the most powerful men in the king’s council.
Thomas’s nephew, Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, was raised alongside the king’s illegitimate son, Henry FitzRoy, and was already writing poetry that would one day make him famous.
Thomas’s niece, Mary Howard, was married to FitzRoy himself in 1533.
The whole family was wrapped around the crown.
Thomas was there for the triumph.
In the summer of 1533, Anne was crowned queen.
In September she gave birth to a daughter, Princess Elizabeth, and at the christening at Greenwich, Lord Thomas Howard was one of the men who helped carry the canopy over the baby.
He would have walked a few steps from the future Elizabeth I, under a cloth of gold, while the trumpets sounded.
It must have felt like the beginning of a life.
It was also, without his knowing it, the beginning of the end of one.
Because the new queen’s household was filling up with young women of the highest rank, and one of them was the king’s niece.
—
## What was the book that passed between the queen’s women?
Margaret Douglas came into Anne Boleyn’s household in the early 1530s.
She was the king’s niece, and so she ranked near the top of the queen’s women, close behind Anne herself.
She had come to England as a girl of about thirteen, in 1528, the daughter of a Scottish earl who had fallen from power and fled south.
Her parents’ marriage had been annulled.
Her mother was in Scotland.
Her uncle the king had taken her in, and she had been brought up beside her cousin, Princess Mary, the king’s daughter, who was almost exactly her age.
Now she was grown, and she was part of a circle of young people around the new queen who loved music, verse and games of words.
They kept a book.
It was not a grand book.
It was a gathering of paper, the kind that could be slipped into a sleeve or left on a window seat.
Over the years, many different people wrote in it.
They copied out poems by Thomas Wyatt, the finest poet at court.
They copied lines from Chaucer.
They copied verses of their own, or other people’s verses lightly changed.
Some poems have initials beside them.
Some have a word or two underlined, as if for a private reader.
Historians call it the Devonshire Manuscript, after the family of the Dukes of Devonshire who owned it for centuries before it went to the British Library, where it is known by the catalogue number Additional MS 17492.
At least three young women of the Howard circle left their handwriting in it.
One was Mary Shelton, a cousin of the queen.
One was Mary Howard, Thomas’s niece, the wife of FitzRoy.
And one was Margaret Douglas.
Thomas Howard was part of that world too.
Thomas would later say he had loved her for about a year.
—
## What did he give her, and what did she give him?
The few hard facts we have about their love come from the worst possible source.
They come from his interrogation.
On July 8, 1536, after he had been arrested, Thomas Howard was questioned about Margaret Douglas, and his answers were written down.
He admitted that he loved her.
Asked how long, he said, in the words recorded, for “about a twelvemonth.”
He told the questioners about the tokens they had exchanged.
He had given her a cramp-ring.
To a modern reader, that sounds like nothing.
To a Tudor courtier, it meant a great deal.
Every year on Good Friday, the kings of England blessed rings of gold and silver in a special ceremony, and those rings were believed to protect the wearer against cramps, seizures and the falling sickness.
They were given as gifts of care, the kind of thing you gave to someone whose body and life you wanted to keep safe.
A cramp-ring was, in its way, a little piece of the king’s own holiness.
Thomas had given one to the king’s niece, as a lover’s gift.
In return, she had given him her portrait and a diamond.
A portrait was not a casual present in the 1530s.
Most people never had their likeness painted at all.
A small picture of a woman, given to a man who was not her husband, was the kind of gift that only meant one thing.
And then, he said, after Easter of 1536, they had contracted themselves to marry.
That word, “contracted,” was the dangerous one.
Under the church law of the time, a marriage did not begin with a priest.
It began with consent.
If a man and a woman said to each other, in words of the present tense, that they took each other as husband and wife, they had made something the church courts could treat as a real and binding marriage, even if no priest was there, no banns were read and no family ever agreed.
A promise in the future tense, “I will marry you,” was weaker.
Words in the present tense, “I take you,” were very hard to undo.
Nobody now knows exactly which words Thomas and Margaret used.
Their questioners wanted to know.
So, very much, did the king.
Because by the time those questions were asked, the world around the two of them had turned upside down.
—
## Why did one terrible May change the value of a love affair?
On May 2, 1536, Anne Boleyn was arrested at Greenwich and taken by barge to the Tower of London.
She was Thomas Howard’s half-niece.
She was Margaret Douglas’s mistress.
And within less than three weeks she was dead, along with her brother George and four other men accused with her.
The man who had guarded her in the Tower, and who wrote reports to Thomas Cromwell about every word she said, was the Constable of the Tower, Sir William Kingston.
Thomas Howard would come to know him well.
The fall of Anne cracked the Howard family’s position at court.
The third duke, Thomas’s half-brother, had presided over his own niece’s trial, as Lord High Steward, and pronounced the sentence.
He survived by being useful, as his father had.
But the family’s grip on the king had loosened, and everyone could feel it.
Eleven days after Anne’s death, the king married Jane Seymour.
That summer, Parliament met to sort out what was left of the succession.
A new Act declared that both of Henry’s daughters, Mary and Elizabeth, were illegitimate.
The crown would pass only to children of Queen Jane, and Jane had none yet.
If the king had no lawful heir, he could name one himself.
He had one son, Henry FitzRoy, Duke of Richmond, but FitzRoy was illegitimate, and by early July he was very ill.
So who stood next to the throne?
On paper, after Henry’s own children, came the descendants of his sisters.
His elder sister’s son was King James V of Scotland, a foreign king born outside England.
Many English lawyers believed that alone barred him.
That left James’s half-sister.
Born in England.
Raised at the English court.
Unmarried.
Twenty years old.
The king’s niece.
Margaret Douglas had not changed at all between April and July of 1536.
But the deaths and the laws around her had changed what she was.
For a few weeks that summer, she looked to some people like the nearest English-born heir to the crown.
And she had promised herself to the younger brother of the Duke of Norfolk.
To Thomas, the promise was a love affair.
To the king, it was about to look like something else entirely.
—
## Who told the king?
Nobody knows exactly how the secret came out.
It may have been a servant.
It may have been a rival at court.
It may have been gossip in the queen’s old rooms, now emptied of Anne’s people and filling with Jane’s.
What we know is the timing.
In the first days of July 1536, the court was celebrating.
Thomas’s elder brother, Lord William Howard, had married, and there were festivities.
Thomas rode in the jousts.
A few days later, he was arrested.
It is hard to imagine a sharper turn.
One week, a young man in armor with the crowd shouting for the Howard colors.
The next, a prisoner being rowed down the Thames, past the warehouses and the river stairs, toward the gray walls of the Tower.
Margaret Douglas was taken there too.
The imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, who sent long letters to the emperor about nearly everything that happened at court, reported the arrest.
As he understood it, the young lord was in prison for having promised to marry the king’s niece, and the lady had been locked up as well.
The questioning began at once.
Thomas was examined on July 8.
The questions came back, again and again, to the same points.
When had the promise been made?
In what words?
Who had seen them together?
What had passed between them?
Behind every question was another one that nobody asked aloud.
Had Thomas Howard meant to become the husband of the next queen of England?
It is very possible he had never thought of it that way.
He was in love with a girl he had known for years, and he had found a way to keep her.
But his family’s history spoke against him.
The Howards had placed one queen on the throne already.
They had watched her fall.
Now the youngest of them had quietly bound himself to the woman closest to the crown.
To a suspicious king, there was only one way to read it.
And Henry VIII did not answer it with a trial.
—
## What did Parliament say he had dreamed of?
On July 18, 1536, Parliament passed an Act of Attainder against Lord Thomas Howard.
An attainder was a law aimed at one person.
It needed no jury, no witnesses, no defense and no judge.
Parliament declared a man guilty, and the law itself became his sentence.
Thomas Howard never had the chance to speak in his own defense in public.
There was no trial at Westminster Hall, no crowd, no record of what he might have said.
The act spoke for him instead, and it did not spare him.
It said that he had acted falsely, craftily and traitorously.
It said that he had “imagined and compassed,” the old legal phrase for plotting, that if the king should “die without heirs of his body, which God defend,” then the said Lord Thomas, “by reason of a marriage in so high a blood,” should “aspire by her to the Dignity of the said Imperial Crown of this realm.”
In other words, the law said that a twenty-five-year-old younger son had fallen in love as a step toward the throne.
The act also went further than Thomas.
It made it high treason, from then on, for any man to marry, or try to marry, any of the king’s children, his sisters, his aunts or his nieces without the king’s permission, and declared that any such marriage would be void.
A love affair had become a law of the realm.
Thomas Howard was condemned to die as a traitor.
And then, nothing happened.
No date was set.
No scaffold was built for him.
The king did not sign anything further.
Thomas was left in the Tower, a man the law called a traitor, waiting.
Margaret was not named in the act.
Henry spared his niece the ruin he brought down on her lover.
But she was not free.
Five days after the act passed, on July 23, Henry FitzRoy died at St James’s Palace, at the age of seventeen.
The young duke was the husband of Thomas’s niece Mary Howard.
He was laid to rest at Thetford Priory, in the same Howard burial place where Thomas’s father lay.
The family had buried one of its own young men that summer.
It would soon be asked to bury another.
—
## What can a condemned man write inside a fortress?
The Tower of London in 1536 was not a single prison.
It was a small walled town of towers, gatehouses, lodgings, a chapel, a royal palace, an armory and a mint, set on the river at the edge of the city.
Prisoners of rank were not usually kept in dungeons.
They were held in rooms in one tower or another, sometimes with a servant of their own, sometimes allowed to pay for better food, sometimes even permitted books, paper and visitors.
Nobody now knows exactly which room held Thomas Howard.
Nobody knows exactly where Margaret was kept before she was moved.
The Constable, Sir William Kingston, and the Lieutenant of the Tower, Sir Edmund Walsingham, were responsible for both of them.
What they could not easily lock up was paper.
Among the poems in the Devonshire Manuscript, there is a group that scholars have linked to Thomas Howard and Margaret Douglas, and to their months of imprisonment.
They are written in more than one hand.
One hand is usually labeled by modern editors as “TH2,” and many scholars think it may be Thomas Howard’s own.
One of the poems in that sequence begins, in the spelling of the time:
“Wyth sorowful syghes and wondes smart / my hart ys persed sodaynly”
With sorrowful sighs and wounds that smart, my heart is pierced suddenly.
It goes on, in his voice, about tears that he cannot hold back no matter how he tries, and about the people who look down on “faythfull louers that be so trew.”
Faithful lovers that be so true.
Another poem nearby begins “Now may I morne as one off late,” a man mourning that he has been driven away from his delight.
Another, right after it, starts with a question: “What thyng shold cawse me to be sad.”
Other verses in a woman’s voice seem to answer him, and they are usually read as Margaret’s, though even that is a judgment, not a certainty.
This is the honest truth about these poems.
Nobody can prove who composed each one.
Some may be Thomas’s own.
Some may be older poems he or Margaret adapted to fit their situation, the way people today might send each other a song lyric that says what they cannot.
One of the poems in this group is signed with initials that have been read as belonging to Margaret, or possibly to Mary Howard, Thomas’s niece, who seems to have helped keep the book.
The editors of the modern edition of the manuscript point out that Margaret could have written that one herself.
But the shape of the story is in the pages.
A man parted by force from the woman he loves.
A woman who refuses to say she was wrong.
Tears, faithfulness, enemies, and a promise that the heart will stay where it was given.
The book survived.
The man who may have written in it was running out of time.
—
## Why did Margaret write to Thomas Cromwell?
As the summer of 1536 turned into autumn, Margaret Douglas fell ill.
It is not clear what was wrong with her.
Later writers have speculated, some of them wildly, but the record says only that she was sick, and that her uncle allowed her to be moved.
Sometime late in 1536, she was taken out of the Tower and sent up the Thames to Syon Abbey at Isleworth, a wealthy convent of Bridgettine nuns, where she was placed in the care of the abbess.
It was a softer kind of confinement.
There were gardens, a great church, bells instead of sentries.
But she was still watched, and the number of servants she kept was decided for her.
The man who decided most things in England now was Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, the man who had organized the fall of Anne Boleyn.
From Syon, Margaret wrote to him.
The letter survives, and its message is plain.
She thanked Cromwell for helping her back toward the king’s favor.
She acknowledged that she had offended her uncle.
And she gave up Thomas Howard.
She assured Cromwell, in substance, that no affection for him remained in her heart, and that from now on her only care was to please the king.
Was it true?
We cannot know.
She was about twenty-one, alone, and writing to the most dangerous official in the kingdom, about a man who had already been condemned.
She had watched what happened to her mistress the spring before.
A letter like that was a lifeline.
Any young woman with sense would have grabbed it.
Whatever she felt, it worked.
Her road back to court began with that letter.
For Thomas Howard, there was no letter that could do the same.
He could not write to Cromwell that he had stopped loving the king’s niece.
That would not undo the act.
The law did not care what he felt now.
It cared only that he had once dreamed, as it put it, of aspiring to the crown.
His brother, the Duke of Norfolk, could have pleaded for him.
There is no sign that he did.
In October 1536 the north of England rose in a great rebellion against the king’s religious changes, the movement called the Pilgrimage of Grace, and Norfolk was sent north with an army to deal with it.
For much of the following months he was in Yorkshire and beyond, negotiating, threatening, and then, after a new outbreak early in 1537, helping to hunt down and hang rebels on the king’s orders.
The duke was proving his loyalty the only way the Howards knew.
His youngest brother sat in the Tower and wrote poems.
—
## How long can a man wait for a sentence that never comes?
Picture the second summer.
It is July 1537.
Thomas Howard has been a prisoner for a full year.
The law that condemned him is a year old.
Outside the walls, the city goes on as it always has, the bells of a hundred churches, the shouts of the watermen on the river, the smell of the tide coming up through the water gate.
Inside, nothing changes.
That is the thing about an attainder that is never carried out.
It does not end.
Every morning the man wakes knowing that the king could sign the order today.
Every evening he goes to sleep knowing that the king did not, and does not know why.
He cannot appeal.
He cannot ask for a trial, because the trial has already happened without him, in a Parliament where he was never allowed to stand up.
He has seen what happens to people in this place.
His half-niece Anne walked to a scaffold on Tower Green, inside these walls, only the summer before.
For Thomas, it never came to that.
As summer turned to autumn in 1537, the damp came up off the river into the stone.
Many prisoners in the Tower fell ill in the colder months.
The walls were thick and the windows were narrow, and in October and November the rooms could feel as if they had never been warm.
Thomas Howard caught what the records call an ague.
To a Tudor doctor, an ague meant a fever that came and went, often with violent shivering, sometimes for weeks.
It was the word they used for many illnesses we would name differently today, including the kind of malaria that was common then in the marshy lowlands along the Thames.
He was about twenty-six.
On October 12, 1537, upriver at Hampton Court, Queen Jane gave birth to a son.
It was the news the king had waited for more than twenty-five years.
Henry VIII finally had a legitimate male heir, a prince named Edward.
Messengers raced down the river.
London lit bonfires.
Church bells rang across the city.
A great service of thanks was sung at St Paul’s.
The bells could be heard in the Tower.
We do not know what Thomas Howard thought when he heard them.
But it is not hard to see what that baby meant for him.
The question that had made his love look like treason, the question of who would inherit the crown, had just been answered in a nursery at Hampton Court.
Margaret Douglas was no longer the nearest English-born heir.
She was the king’s niece again, nothing more.
The reason for keeping Thomas locked away had, in a sense, disappeared.
Nobody came to tell him he was free.
Three days later, the prince was christened by torchlight in the chapel at Hampton Court.
The whole court was there in its best clothes.
Princess Mary stood as godmother.
Little Princess Elizabeth, just four years old, was carried in the procession.
The lords and ladies who had once danced and passed a book of poems from hand to hand stood in the galleries and watched.
Thomas Howard, who had helped carry the canopy over Elizabeth at her own christening four years before, was in a room in the Tower with a fever.
Then the queen fell ill.
For days after the christening, Jane Seymour grew weaker.
On the night of October 24, 1537, she died at Hampton Court.
The bells of London rang again, but slowly this time, the long, heavy toll that every Londoner knew meant death.
Black cloth went up in the churches.
The king shut himself away.
In the Tower, the fever came and went, and came again.
Five days after the queen’s death, on October 29, according to the usual account, Margaret Douglas was set free from her confinement at Syon.
Some writers place her release a little earlier, some a little later.
Most agree that it came at almost exactly the same moment that the man she had promised to marry was dying.
Whether anyone told Thomas that she was free, we do not know.
Whether anyone told her how ill he was, we do not know either.
There is no record of a priest at his side.
There is no record of a last letter, a last poem, a last word.
We do not know whether his mother was allowed to visit.
We do not know whether a servant sat with him through the nights, or whether he was alone in a room with a candle and the sound of the river.
What we have is a date.
On October 31, 1537, the eve of All Saints, one week to the day after the death of the queen, Lord Thomas Howard died in the Tower of London.
He had been a prisoner for about fifteen months.
He had been condemned to death by a law that was never carried out.
The king had never signed the order.
He had never needed to.
Time and the cold had done what he never ordered.
There is an old tradition that Thomas Howard was poisoned.
No evidence supports it, and most historians set it aside.
A fever in a damp fortress in late autumn needs no poisoner.
But the tradition says something about how his death looked to people at the time.
A young man the king wanted out of the way had died, very conveniently, in the king’s prison, just as the king’s son was born.
Some people found that hard to believe was chance.
The king’s answer, when he was asked what should be done with the body, came down to two words.
—
## What did “without pomp” really mean?
Thomas Howard’s mother was still alive.
Agnes Tilney, the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk, was now in her sixties.
She had buried her husband with banners and heralds at Thetford thirteen years before.
She had watched her step-granddaughter Anne Boleyn crowned and then killed.
Now her youngest son had died in the Tower, a condemned traitor.
She asked for his body.
The king agreed.
He allowed the duchess to take her son and bury him, on one condition.
It was to be done, in the phrase that has come down to us, “without pomp.”
No procession.
No heralds.
No banners with the Howard arms.
No great requiem with candles burning by the hundred.
Nothing that might make a public statement that a man condemned by Parliament had been honored in death.
So Thomas Howard’s body was carried out of London and taken east, across Essex and Suffolk into Norfolk, to Thetford Priory.
A London chronicler of the time, Charles Wriothesley, noted his death and recorded that he was carried to Thetford and buried there.
He was laid in the same priory as his father.
Thirteen years earlier, the hero of Flodden had been carried to that priory with banners, heralds and hundreds of mourners.
Now his youngest son came to the same place in silence, by order of the king.
The family that had once been allowed every kind of display was now told, in effect, to grieve quietly and be grateful that it could grieve at all.
Thetford Priory did not last much longer.
Within a few years, Henry VIII dissolved the monasteries of England, and Thetford was closed in 1540.
Some of the Howard dead were moved from there to the church at Framlingham, where the family’s tombs can still be seen.
Henry FitzRoy was among them.
There is no known grave of Thomas Howard today.
The priory is a ruin now, low walls of flint and stone standing in the grass beside the Little Ouse river, looked after by English Heritage.
Somewhere under that grass, or somewhere lost, is the young man who was given a ring and a diamond and a portrait, and was buried without pomp.
—
## What happened to the woman he loved?
Margaret Douglas lived another forty years after Thomas Howard died.
She went back to court.
She served Henry’s later queens.
In 1541, astonishingly, she was caught up in another romance with a Howard, Charles Howard, a half-nephew of Thomas and the brother of the new queen, Catherine Howard.
She was sent away from court and warned, through Archbishop Cranmer, to take more care.
In 1544 the king married her to a Scottish nobleman, Matthew Stewart, Earl of Lennox.
Their son Henry, Lord Darnley, married Mary, Queen of Scots, in 1565, and their grandson became King James VI of Scotland and, in 1603, King James I of England.
She was sent to the Tower twice more in her life for marriages the crown had not approved.
She died in 1578 and lies in Westminster Abbey.
It is not known whether she ever spoke of Thomas Howard again.
But the book with her handwriting in it was kept.
—
## What became of the family that was told to grieve quietly?
The Howards paid again and again for being close to the crown.
In 1540, the king married another of Agnes Tilney’s young relatives, Catherine Howard, the girl who had grown up in the duchess’s crowded household at Lambeth and Horsham.
Within eighteen months the new queen had fallen.
The investigation went back through her childhood, into the duchess’s house, into the doors and the keys and the chests of letters.
Agnes herself, by then an old woman, was sent to the Tower in 1541 and convicted of concealing what she knew.
Thomas’s brother, Lord William Howard, the one whose wedding celebrations had come just before Thomas’s arrest, was locked up as well, along with his wife.
Catherine Howard died on Tower Green in February 1542.
Agnes was eventually released.
She died in 1545, having outlived her husband by more than twenty years and her youngest son by nearly eight.
William Howard survived.
Under Henry’s daughters he rose high, becoming Lord Admiral and, in 1554, Baron Howard of Effingham.
His son, another Charles Howard, would command the English fleet against the Spanish Armada in 1588.
The third duke, the half-brother who had been away in the north while Thomas sat in the Tower, survived almost everything.
Almost.
In the last weeks of Henry VIII’s life, in the winter of 1546 and 1547, the duke and his son, the poet Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, were both arrested.
Surrey was condemned and beheaded on Tower Hill in January 1547.
The duke was condemned too, and he was saved only because the king died the night before his sentence could be carried out.
He spent the next six years in the Tower and was released when Mary I came to the throne.
That nephew, Surrey, is the one who wrote about Thomas.
And what he wrote is the closest thing to an epitaph Thomas Howard ever had.
—
## What did his nephew write about him?
Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, was one of the most gifted poets of the Tudor age.
He was about six years younger than his uncle Thomas.
They had grown up in the same family, at the same court, in the same circle of young people who loved verse.
Some years after Thomas’s death, Surrey wrote a long poem about a lady he called Geraldine.
In the middle of it, he turned aside to give a warning, and he used the story of his own uncle to do it.
He did not use Thomas’s name.
He did not need to.
“For you yourself doth know, it is not long ago, / Since that for love, one of the race did end his life in woe, / In tower both strong and high, for his assured truth, / Whereas in tears he spent his breath, alas, the more the ruth.”
One of the race.
One of the Howards.
For love.
In a tower both strong and high.
For his assured truth, which is to say, for being faithful, for keeping his promise.
In tears he spent his breath.
Then Surrey compared him to a gentle animal that nobody could move from its loyalty, one that would willingly go to its death rather than give up its true love.
It is a remarkable thing to have written under Henry VIII.
The king was still alive.
The law that had condemned Thomas was still on the books.
And here was the king’s own kinsman by marriage, the heir to the Duke of Norfolk, saying in verse that his uncle had not been a traitor at all.
He had been a lover who kept his word, and he had died of it.
This was the secret Thomas Howard’s story was hiding all along.
The act of Parliament said he had dreamed of the crown.
His family, quietly, in poetry, said something else.
They said he had died for being true.
And the king, who made the law, also gave the order that his body should go into the ground without a single banner.
He could control the funeral.
He could not control the poems.
—
## Where are the words now?
Go back to the lists in July 1536.
The dust, the trumpets, the painted cloth on the stands, the summer heat.
A young man of twenty-five rides at full gallop with a lance under his arm.
The crowd shouts.
Somewhere a young woman watches, or does not.
Somewhere a ring and a diamond have changed hands.
Everything in that picture is gone.
The tiltyard is gone.
The palace is changed beyond recognition.
The ring has vanished.
The portrait she gave him has vanished.
The diamond has vanished.
Even his grave has vanished, lost somewhere in the ruins of a priory beside a river in Norfolk.
What survived is paper.
In the British Library in London, in a manuscript of brown, fragile pages that once passed from hand to hand among the queen’s women, there are still the lines that many scholars believe Thomas Howard wrote or copied during the months he waited in the Tower.
A heart pierced suddenly.
Tears that will not stop.
Faithful lovers that be so true.
The law that condemned him used the words “falsely” and “traitorously.”
The poems use the word “true.”
The king buried him without pomp.
The book kept him anyway.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Lord Thomas Howard was born in 1511 or about 1512, the son of Thomas Howard, second Duke of Norfolk, and his second wife, Agnes Tilney.
He was a younger half-brother of Thomas Howard, third Duke of Norfolk, and a half-uncle of Anne Boleyn and of Catherine Howard.
He helped bear the canopy at the christening of Princess Elizabeth in September 1533.
His love for Lady Margaret Douglas, Henry VIII’s niece, and their secret contract to marry are known chiefly from his examination of July 8, 1536, in which he said he had loved her “about a twelvemonth,” described the tokens they exchanged (a cramp-ring from him; her portrait and a diamond from her) and placed their contract after Easter 1536.
The exact words of the contract are not known.
The jousts shortly before his arrest and the festivities around his brother William’s marriage are recorded in modern accounts of the affair; the details of the tiltyard in the opening scene are reconstruction, and it is not known whether Margaret was watching.
The Act of Attainder of July 18, 1536, condemned him without trial; the phrases quoted above come from its text as printed in modern accounts.
The act also made it treason to marry the king’s children, sisters, aunts or nieces without his consent.
The sentence of death was never carried out.
Margaret was not attainted.
The poems in the Devonshire Manuscript (British Library, Add MS 17492) linked to Thomas Howard and Margaret Douglas are attributed by scholars, not proven.
“Wyth sorowful syghes and wondes smart” is attributed to Lord Thomas Howard in the modern social edition of the manuscript and was entered in the hand editors call TH2; the same edition notes that its initials could point to Margaret Douglas or to Mary Howard.
Who composed, adapted or copied each poem in the group is still debated.
Margaret’s illness, her move to Syon Abbey and her letter to Thomas Cromwell renouncing Thomas are documented; the letter is paraphrased here, not quoted.
Suggestions that her illness was a pregnancy have no clear evidence behind them.
Her release is usually dated October 29, 1537.
Thomas Howard died in the Tower on October 31, 1537, of an illness described as an ague.
The tradition that he was poisoned is unsupported.
Henry VIII allowed his mother to bury him on condition that it be “without pomp,” and Wriothesley’s chronicle records his burial at Thetford.
No grave survives.
The lines from the Earl of Surrey’s poem are quoted in modern spelling.
Surrey does not name his uncle; the identification is the usual reading.
What Thomas Howard thought, felt or said in his last weeks is not recorded.
Where this story imagines his days in the Tower, it says so.