1513: Henry VIII’s Sister Married the King of Scots. When He Fell Fighting Her Brother’s Army, His Body Was Never Given a Grave
The door at the end of the passage had not been opened in a long time.
It stuck at the bottom, and the man with the keys had to put his shoulder to it.
Inside, the air smelled of dust, damp stone and old lead.
This was Sheen, on the south bank of the Thames a few miles upriver from London, in the early 1550s.
Not long before, it had been one of the richest monasteries in England, a house of silent Carthusian monks founded by Henry V.
Now the monks were gone, the house belonged to a duke, and the rooms the monks had prayed in were being used for whatever a great household needed to store.
This one held rubbish.
Broken roof timbers lay in a heap against one wall.
There were rolls of old lead stripped from somewhere, loose stones, the kind of rubble that collects when buildings are being pulled apart.
And among it, on the floor, lay something long and grey.
It was wrapped in lead.
Whoever had sealed it had pressed the metal close, so that it followed the shape of what was inside: the round of a head, the line of shoulders, the length of a man.
The visitor that day was a London tailor with a passion for history, a man named John Stow, who spent his life collecting the stories of old buildings.
He looked at the shape in the lead for a long moment.
Then he was told whose body it was.
It was a king.
Not an English king.
It was James IV, King of Scots, the husband of Henry VIII’s own sister.
He had been dead for nearly forty years.
And in all that time, nobody had ever buried him.
How does a crowned king, married to a Tudor princess, end up lying among old timber in a storeroom near London?
The answer begins with a girl of thirteen who was sent north to seal a peace that was supposed to last forever.
It runs through a battle on a Northumberland hillside, a letter written by Catherine of Aragon, and a permission from the Pope that nobody ever used.
And it does not end with that storeroom.
Before the story was finished, a workman would take a tool to the lead, and a London glazier would carry something home with him, wrapped up, to his house in Wood Street.
The woman at the center of it all, Henry VIII’s elder sister, Margaret Tudor, would outlive her husband by twenty-eight years.
She would rule a kingdom, lose it, flee across a border, marry twice more, and quarrel with her brother over the very thing he would later tear England apart to get.
And in the end, her own grave would vanish too.
—
## Why a girl of thirteen was worth a peace “to last all time coming”
Margaret Tudor was born at the Palace of Westminster in late November 1489, the first daughter of Henry VII and Elizabeth of York.
Her brother Arthur was three.
Her brother Henry, the future Henry VIII, would arrive a year and a half later.
She grew up in a nursery full of royal children, and like every one of them, she was raised knowing that her marriage would not really belong to her.
For a Tudor princess, a husband was a treaty with a pulse.
The man her father chose for her was James IV, King of Scots.
For two hundred years, England and Scotland had been fighting, raiding, burning each other’s border towns and making alliances with each other’s enemies.
Henry VII wanted that to stop.
In January 1502 his envoys and the Scots signed what was called the Treaty of Perpetual Peace.
It promised a peace that would be “good, real and sincere,” and “to last all time coming.”
It was the first peace treaty between the two kingdoms in nearly two centuries.
Margaret was the seal on it.
She was twelve when the treaty was signed.
In January 1503, at Richmond Palace, she was married by proxy, with a Scottish earl standing in for the absent king.
She was now, in law, Queen of Scots.
The year that followed was brutal for her family.
Her brother Arthur had already died at Ludlow the spring before, at fifteen.
Less than three weeks after her proxy wedding, her mother, Elizabeth of York, died in childbirth at the Tower of London, on her own thirty-seventh birthday.
Margaret was thirteen, and in a few months she would be leaving for a country she had never seen, to marry a man she had never met.
In late June 1503 she set out from Richmond.
Her father rode with her as far as Collyweston, in Northamptonshire, the great house of his formidable mother, Lady Margaret Beaufort.
There he said goodbye.
From there the procession wound north for weeks, through Grantham, York, Durham and Newcastle, with heralds, trumpeters, ladies on palfreys, and the princess herself sometimes riding, sometimes carried in a litter.
Crowds came out in every town to see the English king’s daughter on her way to Scotland.
On August 1, 1503, she crossed the border at Berwick.
Just over the line, at the little church at Lamberton, the Scots were waiting to receive her.
She had left England behind for good.
She was going to a husband who was thirty years old.
And she was about to discover that he had been living a very full life without her.
—
## The king who wore an iron chain under his shirt
James IV was, by almost every account, one of the most remarkable men of his age.
He spoke several languages.
He was fascinated by medicine and dabbled in surgery and dentistry, and the treasury records show him paying people for the privilege of letting him pull their teeth.
He built ships, including one of the largest warships in Europe.
He loved music, hunting, poetry and gambling.
He had a string of mistresses and several children by them, some of whom were being raised at his court.
And he carried a secret burden.
When he was fifteen, he had been the figurehead of a rebellion against his own father, James III, who was killed in the aftermath of the battle of Sauchieburn in 1488.
James never forgave himself.
For the rest of his life, as an act of penance, he wore an iron chain, or belt, around his waist under his clothes, and it was said he added weight to it every year.
This was the man who came riding out to meet his bride at Dalkeith, a few miles from Edinburgh, in early August 1503.
The English herald who traveled with Margaret wrote a long account of the journey and the wedding, and through his eyes the king comes across as eager to please.
He arrived in a velvet jacket, with his lute on his back, the herald noted, and he played for her.
He sat with her.
He kissed her in greeting, in front of everyone, which the English found charming.
On August 8, 1503, they were married in the abbey church of Holyrood in Edinburgh.
The court poet William Dunbar wrote a poem for the occasion, The Thistle and the Rose, in which the Scottish thistle and the English rose are joined forever.
It is still one of the most famous poems of its century.
Margaret, meanwhile, wrote home.
In a letter to her father not long after the wedding, she complained politely that the English lords who had escorted her were being pushed aside, and that the king’s favorite, the Earl of Bothwell, had her husband’s ear.
Then, at the bottom, in her own hand, she added a postscript.
It is usually quoted as saying she wished she were with her father now, “and many times more.”
It is the line of a homesick child.
Over the next nine years, Margaret did what she had been sent to do.
She gave the King of Scots children.
They did not live.
A son, James, was born in February 1507 and died a year later.
A daughter died the day she was born.
Another son, named Arthur after the brother Margaret had lost, lived less than nine months.
After the birth of her first son, Margaret fell so dangerously ill that James set out on foot to the shrine of St Ninian at Whithorn, in the far southwest of Scotland, to pray for her.
It was a walk of well over a hundred miles.
She recovered.
And on April 10, 1512, at Linlithgow Palace, she gave birth to another boy, James, who lived.
He would be king before he was two years old.
—
## What turned a brother-in-law into an enemy
In April 1509, Henry VII died, and Margaret’s younger brother became Henry VIII.
He was seventeen, golden, enormous, and hungry for glory.
Within a few years, the peace that was supposed to last all time coming was coming apart.
Some of the reasons were small and personal.
Margaret believed she was owed a legacy from her family, jewels and money left to her, and her brother kept finding reasons not to send it.
James wrote about it in his letters.
Henry did not hurry.
Some of the reasons were bigger.
In the summer of 1511, a famous Scottish sea captain named Andrew Barton was cornered in the Downs by two English ships commanded by the sons of the Earl of Surrey, Sir Edward Howard and Lord Thomas Howard.
Barton died in the fight, and his ships were taken.
To the English he was a pirate.
To James, he was a captain sailing under Scottish letters, and his death was an insult.
But the biggest reason was France.
Scotland and France had been allies for centuries, in what the Scots called the Auld Alliance, the old alliance.
Henry VIII dreamed of conquering France the way his hero Henry V had done a hundred years before.
He joined the Pope and Spain in a Holy League against the French king.
In 1512, James renewed his alliance with France.
He was trapped.
If he stood by while Henry crushed France, Scotland would be left alone with a bigger, richer, angrier England on its border.
If he helped France, he would be breaking the treaty he had sworn to at Glasgow Cathedral, with his hand on the Gospels.
Margaret was caught between them.
Her husband was preparing for war against her brother.
And because Henry and Catherine of Aragon had no living child, Margaret herself was next in line to the English throne, and the baby at Linlithgow came right after her.
In the summer of 1513, Henry crossed the Channel with a great army to invade France.
He left Catherine of Aragon behind in England to rule as regent.
He also left the old Earl of Surrey in the north, to keep an eye on Scotland.
James sent his herald across the sea to Henry’s camp outside the French town of Thérouanne with a final message.
It was, in effect, a declaration of war.
Henry’s answer, as the chroniclers record it, was furious and contemptuous.
He told the Scots herald that he was the true owner of Scotland, and that James held his kingdom by homage to England.
There was nothing left to negotiate.
Margaret was about to watch her husband ride off to fight her brother’s army.
And there were people in Scotland, the stories say, who tried very hard to stop him.
—
## The warning in the church at Linlithgow
Most of what we know about the last summer of James IV’s life comes from records, letters and treasury accounts.
Some of it comes from stories written down decades later.
Those stories are worth telling, as long as we say clearly what they are.
The most famous comes from the Scottish chronicler Robert Lindsay of Pitscottie, writing in the 1570s.
According to him, while James was at prayer in St Michael’s Church beside Linlithgow Palace, a strange old man in a blue gown walked up the aisle, leaned on the king’s desk, and told him not to go to war.
Then he vanished in the crowd, and no one could find him.
Pitscottie believed it.
Most historians think it was either a piece of theater staged by people who wanted the war stopped, or a legend that grew after the disaster.
Another story says that Margaret herself begged James not to go, and that she was afraid of dreams she had been having.
That is also a later tradition.
What is certain is that James had been excommunicated.
Under the terms of the treaty, the Pope was its guarantor, and anyone who broke it faced the Church’s punishment.
In the summer of 1513, under papal authority, the Archbishop of York declared the King of Scots cut off from the Church.
James went to war anyway.
There was also a ring.
The French queen, Anne of Brittany, is said to have sent James a turquoise ring and a letter, asking him to be her knight and to march three feet into English ground for her sake.
The ring story is old and much repeated.
Whether it happened exactly like that or not, James had made his choice.
On August 22, 1513, he crossed the River Tweed into England with the largest army Scotland had ever raised.
It may have numbered thirty or forty thousand men.
He brought heavy guns, the finest artillery in Britain, and he used them.
Norham Castle fell.
So did Etal and Ford.
At Ford Castle, another story says, the lady of the house, Elizabeth Heron, whose husband was a prisoner of the Scots, kept the king entertained while precious days slipped away.
It is probably just a story.
Then James moved his army to a ridge called Flodden Hill and waited.
He had picked a superb position.
To attack him, the English would have to climb straight up at his guns.
He was not going to make it easy for them.
But the old man coming north against him had not survived forty years of English politics by making things easy for himself either.
—
## How the English got behind the Scots
Thomas Howard, Earl of Surrey, was about seventy years old.
He had fought for Richard III at Bosworth, been wounded, imprisoned in the Tower, and slowly, carefully, earned his way back into Tudor favor.
His titles, his lands and his family’s future all depended on doing exactly what the Tudors needed.
And what the Tudors needed now was the Scots stopped.
Back in the south, Catherine of Aragon was raising a second army in case Surrey failed.
Henry was across the sea, besieging French towns, and the defense of England was in the hands of his Spanish wife.
She had promised him, in her letters, that she would keep his kingdom safe.
Surrey’s army was smaller than the Scots, perhaps twenty-six thousand men, tired, hungry, short of beer, marching through rain.
He sent a herald to James with a challenge to fight on Friday, September 9.
James accepted, but he stayed on his hill.
Surrey complained, the story goes, that it was not fitting for a prince to hide on a hill like a fortress.
James did not move.
So Surrey did something very risky.
On September 8, he marched his whole army away to the east and then north, in a long loop, out of sight of the Scots.
On the morning of September 9, he crossed the River Till, part of his army over the narrow stone bridge at Twizel and part by a ford.
By early afternoon, the English were north of the Scots.
They were standing between James IV and Scotland.
James had to turn.
He swung his army around to face the new threat, setting fire to the rubbish of his camp, so that smoke drifted across the valley and hid his movements.
He took up a new position on Branxton Hill, still high ground, still strong.
Below him, the English formed up near the little village of Branxton and its church.
Between the two armies lay a slope, and at the bottom of the slope, a strip of ground that looked firm and was not.
It was late in the afternoon.
It had been raining.
And in a few hours, the King of Scots would be dead.
—
## What happened on Branxton Hill
The guns opened first, a little after four o’clock.
The Scottish cannon were great, heavy, beautiful pieces, the pride of James’s arsenal.
But they were on high ground, firing downhill, and most of their shots went over the English heads.
The English guns were lighter and quicker.
They found their range.
Shot began tearing into the Scottish ranks standing on the hillside, and the men could do nothing but stand and take it.
Under that kind of fire, an army cannot wait for long.
On the Scottish left, the Earl of Home and Lord Huntly moved first.
Their men, Borderers and Highlanders, came down the hill at the English right wing and broke it.
For a moment it looked as though the day might go the Scottish way.
Then James gave the order for the main attack, and the great columns began to move.
They were pikemen, trained in the new continental style, each man holding a spear perhaps fifteen to eighteen feet long.
French officers had drilled them.
In the right conditions, a block of pikes rolling forward in good order was almost unstoppable.
These were not the right conditions.
The slope of Branxton Hill was steep and wet, and the grass was slick with rain.
Men slid.
Ranks bent.
And at the foot of the slope, where a small stream ran across the valley, the ground turned soft underfoot.
The columns had to slow down to cross it.
When a pike column slows, the points waver, gaps open, and the whole formation begins to lose its shape.
That is when the English moved in.
Most of the English infantry carried a weapon called a bill, a heavy blade on a long pole, something like a farm tool built for war.
A bill could not stand up to a hedge of pikes on open, level ground.
But in a crush, in the mud, it could hack the pike heads off their shafts and reach into the gaps.
The fighting at the foot of Branxton Hill became exactly that kind of crush.
James IV did not watch from the rear.
He had never been that kind of king.
He went into the battle on foot, at the head of his own column, surrounded by the nobles of his household, with the great banner of Scotland above him.
He pushed straight toward the place where the English commander stood.
He was aiming for Surrey himself.
The old earl, in the center of the English line, was surrounded by his own men, and they did not break.
The chroniclers say James got within a spear’s length of him.
That phrase may be a story-teller’s flourish.
It may be true.
Either way, it was as close as he came.
On the English right, Surrey’s son Edmund Howard was almost overwhelmed and only just rescued.
On the far side of the field, the English under Sir Edward Stanley climbed the hill on the Scottish right and came down on the Highland contingent from the flank.
As the September light began to fade, the Scottish army found itself surrounded on three sides.
The men around the king did not run.
That is the thing every account agrees on.
They closed around him.
They fought in a ring.
The earls, the lords, the bishops and abbots who had followed him, the king’s own illegitimate son Alexander, the twenty-year-old Archbishop of St Andrews whom James had made a scholar under Erasmus himself, all of them stayed where they were.
The noise was immense: the crack of shafts, the clang of steel, men shouting in Scots and English and Gaelic, the screaming of horses somewhere behind the lines.
Then it began to thin out.
The fighting went on until it was too dark to see.
The English did not know they had won.
They did not know where the King of Scots was.
They spent the night on the field, cold and wet and exhausted, waiting for the morning to show them what they had done.
On the ridge above them, the great Scottish guns stood abandoned in the dark.
When the sun rose on September 10, the hillside was covered with the dead.
Nobody has ever been able to count them properly.
Most historians put the Scottish losses somewhere around ten thousand men, perhaps more.
Nine earls of Scotland had fallen.
So had fourteen lords of Parliament, the archbishop, two bishops and two abbots, and men from almost every great family in the kingdom.
For generations afterward, people in the Scottish Borders said there was hardly a family in the south of Scotland that had not lost someone at Flodden.
And somewhere in all of that, there was the king.
Lord Dacre, the English warden of the border marches, who had met James many times, went out across the field to look for him.
He took with him two Scots who had been taken prisoner, men who had been close to the king and would know him.
They walked slowly, turning over men who had fallen face down, looking at the faces of men in good armor.
They found him among his companions, where the fighting had been thickest.
The face had been badly hurt.
But they knew him.
They knew him by his features, and by the things he carried.
Dacre’s men lifted the body of the King of Scots out of the mud of Branxton.
A few miles to the north, the River Tweed ran along the border, and beyond it lay Scotland, and a palace at Linlithgow where his wife was waiting with a seventeen-month-old boy.
They did not carry him that way.
They carried him south.
—
## The coat that was sent to France
The body was taken to Berwick-upon-Tweed.
There it was embalmed, the way royal bodies were, and wrapped and sealed in lead.
The news traveled south faster than the coffin.
Catherine of Aragon was at Woburn, north of London, when it reached her.
She had spent the summer raising men and money, ready to ride north if Surrey failed.
Now she sat down and wrote to her husband in France.
Her letter, dated September 16, 1513, survives.
She told Henry that the great victory was God’s gift to him and his subjects in his absence.
And she told him she was sending him a present.
It was a piece of the King of Scots’ coat, the surcoat he had worn over his armor, torn and stained from the field.
She wanted Henry to hang it with his banners.
Then she wrote the line that has been quoted ever since.
“In this your Grace shall see how I can keep my promise, sending you for your banners a king’s coat.”
And she added, as if it were the most natural thing in the world: “I thought to send himself unto you, but our Englishmen’s hearts would not suffer it.”
She had wanted to send Henry the body itself.
Her advisers had talked her out of it.
It is easy to read that letter now and feel a chill.
But Catherine was writing as a queen who had just saved her husband’s kingdom while he was away playing soldier in France.
Henry’s own campaign had so far won him one French town, with a second under siege, and a skirmish so short that people called it the Battle of the Spurs, because of how fast the French cavalry had ridden away.
His wife’s army had destroyed the King of Scots.
It is hard not to wonder how Henry felt reading her letter.
What we know is that he wrote to the Pope about his victory, and that he asked for one more thing.
The man killed at Flodden had died excommunicate.
In the eyes of the Church, he could not be buried in consecrated ground.
And Henry VIII, for whatever reasons of his own, wanted the King of Scots buried in London.
In style.
In St Paul’s.
—
## The permission nobody used
On November 29, 1513, Pope Leo X granted it.
The papal document allowed Henry to have James IV buried with royal honors in St Paul’s Cathedral, on the grounds that the Scottish king had shown signs of repentance before he died.
It was an extraordinary gesture.
The great cathedral of London, the church where Henry’s brother Arthur had married Catherine of Aragon twelve years before, would receive the body of the enemy king.
It never happened.
No funeral took place at St Paul’s.
No tomb was built.
No record survives of anyone ever setting a date.
The body, sealed in its lead, was carried instead to Sheen, the Carthusian priory beside Henry VII’s palace at Richmond, and left there.
Nobody knows exactly why.
Perhaps Henry lost interest once the victory was no longer new.
Perhaps it was politics: a grand funeral for James in London would have been an endless reminder to the Scots, and to Henry’s own sister, of who had won.
Perhaps he simply did not want to pay for it.
Perhaps nobody wanted to be the one who reminded him.
The monks of Sheen kept it, as monks kept many things.
The months turned into years.
The years turned into decades.
And meanwhile, four hundred miles to the north, the woman who should have been the chief mourner at that funeral was fighting for her life in a different way.
—
## A widow of twenty-three with a baby king
When the news of Flodden reached her, Margaret Tudor was twenty-three years old.
She had lost her husband, and with him most of the men who had run Scotland.
Her son was seventeen months old.
And she was pregnant again.
Within days of the battle, the little boy was carried into the Chapel Royal at Stirling Castle and crowned King James V.
People called it the Mourning Coronation, because so many of those standing in the chapel were wearing black for husbands, fathers and sons.
James IV had left a will.
In it, he named Margaret as guardian of their son and regent of Scotland.
But there was a condition.
She would hold that power only as long as she remained a widow.
For a few months, she governed.
She held councils, wrote letters to her brother asking him not to make war on a country that had already lost so much, and kept the young king safe at Stirling.
On April 30, 1514, at Stirling, she gave birth to James IV’s last child, a boy named Alexander.
Then, in August 1514, less than a year after Flodden, she did something that astonished everyone.
She married again.
Her new husband was Archibald Douglas, Earl of Angus, a handsome, ambitious young nobleman from one of the most powerful families in Scotland.
The wedding was secret, in a small parish church near Perth.
When it came out, the Scottish lords were furious.
By the terms of the dead king’s will, Margaret had just given away the regency.
The council sent to France for the Duke of Albany, James IV’s cousin, a Scottish prince who had been raised as a Frenchman.
He landed in May 1515 and took over the government.
He also wanted the boys.
There is a famous Victorian painting of Margaret standing at a castle gate, holding her little son by the hand, refusing to hand him over to the lords who had come to take him.
The scene is romanticized, but the struggle was real.
In the summer of 1515 she held out in Stirling Castle with her two sons until it was hopeless, and then she surrendered them.
She never got them back.
Pregnant again, by Angus this time, she slipped away from the court, rode south and crossed into England.
At the remote border fortress of Harbottle, in October 1515, she gave birth to a daughter, Lady Margaret Douglas, who would one day become the grandmother of a king of England.
Margaret Tudor was so ill after the birth that for weeks she could not be moved.
While she lay recovering, news came from Scotland.
Her little son Alexander, James IV’s last child, had died in Scotland, not yet two years old.
The following spring, she came south to London.
Her brother welcomed her warmly.
He gave her rooms, money and gowns, staged a tournament in her honor, and introduced her to his own court, which she had last seen as a thirteen-year-old.
Did she ask him about the body at Sheen?
Did she ever go to see it, a few miles up the river from the palaces where she was being entertained?
No record says.
We only know that she went back to Scotland in 1517, to a husband who had already made his peace with Albany without her, and that the lead coffin stayed exactly where it was.
—
## Why Henry VIII called his sister’s divorce “shameless”
Margaret’s marriage to Angus fell apart almost as soon as she got home.
She found that he had been living with a former love, Lady Jane Stewart of Traquair, and paying for it out of Margaret’s own rents.
She wrote to Henry in 1518 that she was “sore troubled” by her husband.
She began trying to get out of the marriage.
It took her almost ten years.
Divorce, in the modern sense, did not exist.
What a woman like Margaret needed was an annulment from the Pope, a ruling that the marriage had never been valid in the first place.
And here the story of the unburied body comes back in a very strange way.
Because James IV had no known grave, and because no Scot had seen him buried, rumors had been running through Scotland ever since Flodden.
Some people said the body the English had taken was not the king at all.
Some said he had been seen riding away from the field.
Some said he had gone on pilgrimage to Jerusalem to atone for his sins, and might still come home.
Margaret’s case, according to her modern biographers, was willing to lean even on this.
If James IV had been alive when she married Angus in 1514, then that marriage had never been valid.
It was a desperate argument.
But the fact that anyone could make it at all tells you something about what an unburied king leaves behind.
In March 1527, Pope Clement VII granted her annulment.
A year later, in March 1528, she married her third husband, Henry Stewart, a younger man from her own household, whom her son later made Lord Methven.
In London, her brother was outraged.
Cardinal Wolsey wrote to her on the king’s behalf, protesting the “shameless sentence sent from Rome” and reminding her that marriage was divinely ordained.
If that sounds familiar, it should.
At exactly the same moment, Henry VIII was trying to persuade the very same Pope to annul his own marriage to Catherine of Aragon, the woman who had sent him the King of Scots’ coat.
Margaret got her annulment.
Henry did not, and he broke England away from Rome to get his.
By then his sister had stopped expecting much from him.
—
## The weary queen at Methven
Margaret’s son grew up and took power for himself in 1528, throwing off the control of her second husband, the Earl of Angus, and driving him into exile in England.
For a while, mother and son were close.
She acted as a go-between with England, trying to arrange a meeting between her son and her brother.
But she was growing older, poorer and more isolated.
Her third marriage went sour too, and when she tried to end it, her son refused to let her.
In 1536 she wrote to Henry, in a line that sounds as though it came from the bottom of her heart, “I am weary of Scotland.”
She asked to come home.
It never happened.
In October 1541 she was at Methven Castle, in Perthshire, when she was struck by palsy, probably a stroke.
She was fifty-one.
She sent for her son, the king.
Before he could reach her, on October 18, 1541, she died.
She had made no will.
She was buried in the Charterhouse at Perth, a monastery of Carthusian monks, the same church where King James I of Scotland lay.
It was a royal burial in a royal church, with masses for her soul.
It was everything her first husband had never received.
Margaret Tudor had a grave.
For eighteen years.
—
## What John Stow saw in the storeroom
Two years before Margaret died, her brother had closed Sheen.
In 1539, as Henry VIII dissolved the monasteries of England one after another, the Carthusian monks were turned out of the priory where the King of Scots lay.
The buildings and lands passed through various hands.
Under Henry’s son, Edward VI, Sheen went to Henry Grey, Duke of Suffolk, the father of Lady Jane Grey.
It was in those years, the early 1550s, that John Stow was shown the lead coffin in the storeroom.
He described it later, in his great Survey of London, published in 1598.
The body, he wrote, was “so lapped in lead,” and had been “throwne into an old wast roome” among old timber, lead and other rubble.
That is the scene this story began with.
But Stow had more to say.
Some years later, in the reign of Elizabeth I, the coffin was disturbed again.
“Workmen there,” Stow wrote, “for their foolish pleasure hewed off his head.”
He did not say who they were or why they did it, beyond the foolishness.
A man named Lancelot Young, master glazier to Queen Elizabeth, happened to be there.
According to Stow, Young noticed a sweet smell, the scent of the old embalming spices, and saw that the head had dried and kept its form, with the hair and beard still red.
He took it home to London, to his house in Wood Street.
He kept it there for some time, Stow says, because of the sweetness of the smell.
In the end, he gave it to the sexton of his parish church, St Michael Wood Street, who buried it among other bones taken out of the church’s charnel house.
No marker.
No name.
No service that anyone recorded.
That is the last thing anyone knows for certain about James IV, King of Scots.
St Michael Wood Street was rebuilt after the Great Fire of London and finally demolished in 1897.
The bones from its burial ground went elsewhere.
The rest of the body, the lead-wrapped shape that Stow saw on the floor at Sheen, has never been found.
The priory itself was pulled down long ago.
Its site is said to lie today beneath a golf course beside the Old Deer Park at Richmond, under the grass of a fairway where people walk past every day without knowing.
—
## Two Carthusian houses, two lost graves
On May 11, 1559, the Protestant preacher John Knox gave a fiery sermon against idolatry in St John’s Kirk in Perth.
When it was over, the crowd poured out into the town.
Within hours they were tearing apart the monasteries of Perth.
The Charterhouse, where Margaret Tudor lay in the same church as King James I, was sacked and destroyed.
Her tomb went with it.
Some later writers say her remains were dragged out and burned.
There is no eyewitness account to prove it, but there is also no grave.
Today the site of the Charterhouse is marked by a later building and a memorial, and nobody knows exactly where in that ground the queen was laid.
Think about the shape of that.
James IV lay unburied in a Carthusian monastery in England until Henry VIII destroyed it.
Margaret Tudor was buried in a Carthusian monastery in Scotland until the Scottish Reformation destroyed it.
The King and Queen of Scots, married in 1503 to bind two kingdoms together with a peace that was supposed to last forever, both ended up with no place on earth where anyone can stand beside them.
And yet Margaret left something that lasted longer than any tomb.
Her son, James V, had a daughter named Mary, the Queen of Scots.
Her daughter Margaret Douglas had a son named Henry, Lord Darnley.
Mary married Darnley, and their son was James VI of Scotland.
In 1603, when Henry VIII’s last surviving child, Elizabeth I, died without children, that great-grandson of Margaret Tudor and James IV rode south from Edinburgh and became King James I of England.
The thistle and the rose were joined after all, a century late, by the descendants of a couple who could not even be buried.
Every British monarch since has been descended from them.
The Earl of Surrey, who won at Flodden, was given back his family’s old title, Duke of Norfolk, the following year.
His son Thomas, who had commanded the English vanguard on Branxton Hill, became the uncle of two of Henry VIII’s queens, Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard.
On Branxton Hill itself, a granite cross was put up in 1910, on the spot where the fighting is thought to have been fiercest.
The words carved on it are short.
“Flodden 1513. To the brave of both nations.”
On the anniversary of the battle, people still come, from both sides of the border, and lay flowers at its foot.
It is the nearest thing James IV has to a grave.
The storeroom at Sheen is long gone.
So is the man with the keys, and the old timber, and the rolls of stripped lead, and the long grey shape on the floor that John Stow stood and looked at in the 1550s.
But somewhere between Richmond and Wood Street and the field at Branxton is a king who rode out to war against his wife’s brother and never came home.
His wife buried one baby son after another, and then lost the living ones to the lords who took them.
She asked her brother, over and over, for things he did not give her.
And the one thing he could have given her, without costing him anything at all, was a grave for the man she had married at thirteen.
He had the Pope’s permission.
He never used it.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
**Margaret Tudor** was born at Westminster in late November 1489 (sources give the 28th or 29th) and died at Methven Castle on October 18, 1541.
Her proxy marriage took place at Richmond Palace in January 1503 (dates of the 24th and 25th appear in different sources, alongside the treaty of January 1502).
She left Richmond on June 27, 1503, crossed the border at Berwick on August 1, and married James IV at Holyrood on August 8, 1503.
Her children with James IV, their dates, the birth of James V at Linlithgow on April 10, 1512, and of Alexander on April 30, 1514, follow the standard modern accounts.
**The will and the regency:** James IV’s will made her guardian and regent only while she remained a widow; her marriage to Angus on August 6, 1514, ended that.
Albany landed at Dumbarton on May 18, 1515.
**The annulment:** Clement VII granted it in March 1527; she married Henry Stewart on March 3, 1528.
The phrase “shameless sentence sent from Rome” is from Wolsey’s protest; the claim that her case was willing to use the myth of James IV’s survival comes from her modern biographers and should be read as an argument in the background, not the formal ground of the annulment.
**Flodden:** The battle was fought on September 9, 1513, near Branxton in Northumberland.
Numbers for both armies and for the dead vary widely; around ten thousand Scottish dead is a common modern estimate, not a count.
James IV was the last monarch in Great Britain to die in battle.
The details of the fighting (the guns overshooting, the wet slope, bills against pikes, the Scots closing around the king) are drawn from the standard accounts; the line that James fell “within a spear’s length” of Surrey is traditional.
**Identification:** The body was found the next day and identified by Lord Dacre with the help of captured Scots who had served near the king.
It was taken to Berwick, embalmed and sealed in lead, and later moved to Sheen Priory, where it remained unburied.
**Catherine of Aragon’s letter** is dated Woburn, September 16, 1513; the two sentences quoted here appear in the standard printed transcriptions, though early editions differ slightly in spelling and wording.
**The papal permission:** Leo X granted Henry VIII a dispensation on November 29, 1513, to bury James IV with royal honors in St Paul’s; no burial followed.
Why Henry never used it is not recorded; the reasons suggested in this article are possibilities, not facts.
**John Stow** described the body in his *Survey of London* (1598); the quotations about the “wast roome” and the workmen are his.
Everything about Lancelot Young, the sweet smell, the red hair and beard, Wood Street and the charnel comes from Stow alone.
Stow had no doubt that the body was the king’s; some Scottish writers, then and since, have disputed it.
**The legends** are legends: the old man in the blue gown at Linlithgow (Pitscottie, written in the 1570s), Margaret’s warning dreams, Anne of Brittany’s ring, Lady Heron at Ford, and the stories that James survived, went to Jerusalem, or was secretly buried in Scotland.
**Margaret’s grave:** She was buried in the Perth Charterhouse, which was destroyed on May 11, 1559, after Knox’s sermon.
That her remains were burned is reported by later writers; we have found no eyewitness source for it.
**The opening scene** is reconstructed from Stow’s own brief description; the door, the keys and the smell are our setting, not his words.
Margaret’s 1503 postscript (“and many times more”) is quoted as it is usually printed; the wording of other letters is given only where it is well known.