1569: Catherine Carey, the Woman Some Whispered Was Henry VIII’s Daughter, and the Funeral Elizabeth I Paid For
The river was the loudest thing at Hampton Court that January.
It ran high and brown past the water gate, carrying ice down from the west, and on still nights the people lodged in the riverside rooms could hear it grinding against the stone.
Inside, the palace was all candle smoke and wood smoke and the cold breath that comes off old brick in winter.
Servants moved through the galleries with their sleeves pulled down over their hands.
Fires burned all day in the rooms that mattered, and the rooms that mattered most were the queen’s.
Somewhere close to them, in the second week of January 1569, a woman of about forty-five lay ill.
She was not a queen.
She was not a duchess.
She held no castle and commanded no army.
But for ten years she had been one of the very few people in England allowed to walk into Elizabeth I’s bedchamber without being announced.
When Elizabeth was frightened, or furious, or ill, this was one of the faces she wanted to see.
Her husband was not there.
He was more than two hundred miles to the north, in a square stone castle in the Yorkshire Dales, guarding the most dangerous woman in Britain on the queen’s orders.
His letters south were full of the things men wrote when they wanted to come home and were not allowed to.
So the women around her bed were the queen’s women, and the house around her was the queen’s house, and the question that hangs over her whole life hung over that room too.
Who was she, really, to the woman she served?
The official answer was simple, and it was cut into marble a few months later: she was the queen’s cousin, the daughter of Anne Boleyn’s sister.
The other answer has been whispered for a very long time, and nobody has ever been able to prove it or disprove it.
Her mother had been Henry VIII’s mistress.
Some people believe the king was her real father.
If they are right, the woman dying at Hampton Court was not Elizabeth’s cousin at all.
She was her sister.
What Elizabeth did when this woman died was something she did for almost no one outside her own family.
She paid for the funeral herself, down to the last penny, and the sum was recorded: six hundred and forty pounds, two shillings and eleven pence.
She gave her a grave in Westminster Abbey, a short walk from the tombs of kings.
And the words her family chose for that grave answer the old question in a way most people never notice.
—
## A girl born in years nobody wrote down
Her name was Catherine Carey, and nobody recorded the day she was born.
That small silence is where the whole mystery begins.
Her mother was Mary Boleyn, the elder daughter of Sir Thomas Boleyn, an ambitious diplomat who had married into the great Howard family.
Mary had spent part of her girlhood at the French court and come home around 1519 or 1520, by most accounts far less interested in politics than her father or her younger sister Anne.
On February 4, 1520, Mary married William Carey, a gentleman of the king’s privy chamber.
The king himself attended the wedding.
That was not unusual for a favored courtier.
William Carey was well liked, well connected, and close to Henry VIII in the way the young men of the privy chamber were close: they dressed him, gambled with him, rode with him, and slept in his rooms when he traveled.
A royal guest at the wedding was an honor, nothing more.
But at some point in the early 1520s, Henry VIII began an affair with William Carey’s new wife.
Nobody knows exactly when it started.
Nobody knows exactly when it ended.
There were no announcements, no gifts listed in the household books under her name, no letters that survive.
What survives is a scatter of small, telling signs.
In 1523, a ship in the king’s navy was named the Mary Boleyn.
Between 1522 and 1526, William Carey received a run of grants from the crown, lands and offices and income, of the kind that kings handed out for many reasons, and sometimes for one in particular.
And somewhere in the middle of all this, probably around 1524, Mary Boleyn gave birth to a daughter.
They called her Catherine.
It was the name of the queen.
A few years later, on March 4, 1526, Mary had a son, Henry Carey.
That name, too, was the name of a king.
Two children, born to a royal mistress during or close to the years of the affair, sharing their names with the queen and the king.
Her husband raised them as his own.
The king never said a word about them in public.
He had already shown, only a few years before, what he did when he believed a child was his.
—
## The son the king was proud to name
In June 1519, a maid of honor named Elizabeth Blount had given Henry VIII a baby boy.
Henry did not hide him.
The boy was christened Henry FitzRoy, which meant, quite openly, Henry the king’s son.
In June 1525, at the age of six, he was made Duke of Richmond and Somerset at Bridewell Palace, with the whole court watching.
Catherine Carey would have been about one year old.
This is the first thing anyone weighing the old rumor has to set against it.
Henry was perfectly willing to acknowledge a child born outside his marriage.
He made FitzRoy a duke while Mary Boleyn’s children were in their cradles.
He never gave the Careys anything of the kind.
Of course, there were reasons he might not.
Bessie Blount had been unmarried.
Mary Boleyn was a married woman, and a child born inside a marriage was, in law, the husband’s child.
To claim one would mean declaring that the king had taken a courtier’s wife.
And a daughter was of far less use than a son to a king who needed heirs.
So the silence proves nothing either way.
What it did mean was that Catherine grew up as exactly what the world said she was: William Carey’s daughter.
For a few years, that was a comfortable thing to be.
Her father was rising.
By 1527, the king who had once paid attention to Mary Boleyn was writing passionate letters to her younger sister Anne.
That same year, Henry’s agents in Rome asked the pope for something that tells us the affair with Mary was no mere gossip.
To marry Anne, the king would need permission to marry the sister of a woman with whom he had already had a relationship.
The request was carefully worded.
It did not name names.
It did not need to.
Then, in June 1528, the sweating sickness swept through London.
It came fast, it killed within hours, and it took William Carey.
Catherine was perhaps four years old.
—
## The vicar who said too much
The death of William Carey left Mary Boleyn a widow with two small children and very little money.
The wardship of her son, Henry, was granted to her sister Anne, which meant the boy would be educated under Anne’s direction, away from his mother.
Her own father, now rich and rising with his younger daughter, was not inclined to help.
Catherine seems to have stayed with her mother, though almost nothing is recorded of her childhood.
In 1533, her aunt became queen.
In 1534, her mother did something nobody expected.
Mary Boleyn, sister of the Queen of England, quietly married a soldier named William Stafford, a younger son with no fortune and no prospects, and appeared at court pregnant.
Anne was furious.
Mary was banished.
She wrote to Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, a letter that still survives, defending what she had done.
She said she had chosen a man who loved her, and that she would rather beg her bread with him than be the greatest queen in Christendom.
It is one of the most quoted lines any Boleyn ever wrote, and it is the only one that sounds as if it was written by a happy woman.
Catherine was about ten.
Her mother was gone from court.
Her aunt was queen.
And her father, the only one she had ever known, was six years dead.
Then, in the spring of 1535, a priest named John Hale got himself into the kind of trouble that ended at Tyburn.
Hale was the vicar of Isleworth, a parish on the Thames not far from the royal palaces, and he was a bitter enemy of the king’s new marriage.
When he was questioned for treasonous talk, his words were written down.
Among them was a story.
He said he had once been shown “young Master Carey,” and told that the boy was the king’s son by the queen’s sister.
That boy was Catherine’s brother Henry, then about nine years old.
It is the only time, in all the records of Henry VIII’s reign, that anyone is known to have said aloud that one of Mary Boleyn’s children belonged to the king.
Notice what it does not say.
It does not mention Catherine at all.
And it came from a man who hated the Boleyns, repeating what a servant had told him.
Some historians see it as a glimpse of what the court whispered in private.
Others see it as the sort of poison the enemies of Anne Boleyn spread about her whole family.
Either way, within a year, there would be no Boleyn queen left to protect.
—
## What the king’s past did to Elizabeth
On May 2, 1536, Anne Boleyn was taken by barge to the Tower of London.
She was charged with adultery, with incest with her own brother, and with plotting the king’s death.
The charges are now almost universally believed to have been false.
On May 19, she died on Tower Green.
Catherine Carey was about twelve.
There is an old story that she was in the Tower with her aunt in those last days, and some writers have said she stood among the crowd on the morning Anne died.
There is no good evidence for either.
It is the kind of detail that gets added to a famous story because it feels as if it ought to be true.
What we know is only that she was Anne’s niece, that she was of an age to understand, and that the woman who had been the most powerful member of her family was gone.
And something else happened that May which tied Catherine to the little girl Anne left behind.
Two days before Anne’s death, Archbishop Thomas Cranmer declared her marriage to Henry VIII invalid.
The full grounds were never published.
But most historians believe the reason offered was the very thing the king had once asked the pope to excuse: that before marrying Anne, Henry had been involved with her sister.
Mary Boleyn’s affair with the king, in other words, was very probably used to undo the marriage that had produced Elizabeth.
Princess Elizabeth was two years and eight months old.
In a single stroke, she became the Lady Elizabeth, a king’s bastard, with no claim to the throne.
From that spring on, the two girls had something unusual in common.
Each of them had a Boleyn mother.
Each had a father whose name, for very different reasons, was a dangerous thing to say out loud.
For the next three years, Catherine vanishes from the records almost completely.
When she reappears, she is fifteen, and she is about to be sent to wait on a German princess the king had never met.
—
## A maid of honor for a queen who did not last
In the autumn of 1539, the court was preparing for a new queen.
Jane Seymour had died after giving birth to Prince Edward in October 1537, and Henry had agreed to marry Anne, the sister of the Duke of Cleves, having seen only her portrait.
A household had to be assembled to receive her, including a small group of unmarried maids of honor, girls of good family who would attend the queen and, if they were lucky, find husbands.
In November 1539, Catherine Carey was named one of them.
Another of the new maids was a teenage cousin of hers on the Howard side, a lively, careless girl named Catherine Howard.
Anne of Cleves landed in England at the end of December.
Henry married her on January 6, 1540, at Greenwich, and almost at once he began looking for a way out.
The queen could barely speak English.
The king was miserable and did not hide it.
And every girl in the household could see where the king’s eyes were going.
They were going to Catherine Howard.
Catherine Carey, meanwhile, was getting married.
On April 26, 1540, she became the wife of Francis Knollys, a gentleman about a decade older than she was, the son of a family that had served the crown for two generations.
He was serious, educated, and already one of the most committed Protestants at court, a man who believed that God’s purposes ran through English politics.
He was not glamorous.
He was not rich.
He was utterly reliable.
It turned out to be one of the best marriages of the Tudor century.
That July, Henry’s marriage to Anne of Cleves was dissolved, and within weeks he married Catherine Howard.
Catherine Carey, now Mrs. Knollys, had already left the life of a maid of honor behind.
Less than two years later, her teenage cousin the queen died inside the Tower of London, just as their aunt Anne had.
Catherine Knollys was not there to see it.
She was, as far as anyone knows, far from court, with her first child.
—
## The house that filled with children
The Knollys family home was Greys Court, at Rotherfield Greys, in the wooded hills above Henley-on-Thames.
It was an old manor, built around the ruins of a medieval castle, with brick walls, a courtyard and a great tower, on high ground looking across the Chiltern woods.
It was there, and in the family’s London lodgings, that Catherine spent most of the next twelve years being pregnant, giving birth, and raising children.
There would be sixteen of them, by the count carved on her grave, sons and daughters in equal number.
Some probably died young.
The eldest son, Henry, was born around 1541.
A daughter, Lettice, was born in November 1543 and would grow up to be one of the most famous and most hated women at Elizabeth’s court.
By the end of her life, she had married daughters into the nobility and sent sons into Parliament and the army.
Her husband rose steadily.
He served in the household of Prince Edward.
In 1547, he fought with the English army that invaded Scotland and was knighted after the battle of Pinkie.
Under the boy-king Edward VI, when England’s government turned hard toward Protestantism, the Knollyses were exactly the kind of family that prospered.
Catherine’s mother did not live to see most of it.
Mary Boleyn died in July 1543, in her early forties, in the obscurity she had chosen.
Where she was buried is not certainly known.
Catherine’s link to the royal family in those years ran through one person: her cousin, the Lady Elizabeth, ten years younger than she was, clever, watchful, and living most of the time in her own household away from court.
How close they were in the 1540s, nobody can say.
What is certain is that by the time Edward VI died in July 1553 and his Catholic half-sister Mary took the throne, Elizabeth regarded Catherine Knollys as someone she trusted.
Because when the Knollyses had to run, Elizabeth wrote to her.
—
## The letter signed with a broken heart
Mary I came to the throne in the summer of 1553 meaning to bring England back to Rome.
For Protestant families like the Knollyses, the danger came slowly, and then all at once.
The religious laws of Edward’s reign were repealed.
In 1554, after a rebellion led by Thomas Wyatt, Elizabeth herself was sent to the Tower, suspected of plotting against her sister, and for weeks she believed she would not leave it alive.
The heresy laws were revived.
In February 1555, the burnings began.
Sir Francis Knollys had no intention of changing his religion.
Sooner or later, the family would have to leave.
At some point around the start of Mary’s reign, as Catherine prepared to go abroad, Elizabeth sent her a short letter.
It survives, and it is printed in modern collections of Elizabeth’s writings.
The year is uncertain, but the tone is not.
It is one of the warmest things Elizabeth ever wrote to anyone.
She told her cousin to set the sorrow of her long journey against the joy of coming home soon.
She told her that time and distance did not take away the love of friends.
She promised that while others made promises, she would act, and that if her power was small, her love was as great as anyone’s.
And she signed it not with her name, but with two words in Italian.
“Cor rotto.”
A broken heart.
It is easy to read too much into a single letter.
Tudor letters of friendship were often written in a formal style, with set phrases and careful balance, and Elizabeth was a young woman who had been trained to write beautifully.
But it is also hard to imagine her signing a letter like that to someone who was merely useful.
Catherine took it with her when she left.
The Knollyses were gone by 1556.
They went first, it seems, to Basel, in Switzerland, and then to Frankfurt am Main, one of the great refuges of English Protestant exiles.
They took children with them.
They took servants.
They took whatever money they could move.
They had no idea how long they would be gone.
—
## Frankfurt, and the long wait for a queen
Frankfurt in the 1550s was a free city of the Holy Roman Empire, a busy, crowded trading town on the river Main, famous for its book fairs.
It was also full of English people who had lost almost everything.
Hundreds of Protestant exiles had settled in German and Swiss cities during Mary’s reign: clergy thrown out of their churches, gentlemen who had sold their lands, scholars, printers, widows.
In Frankfurt they had their own congregation, and argued bitterly among themselves about how to worship, in a quarrel later called the Troubles at Frankfurt.
Sir Francis Knollys was a serious man in the middle of all this, a layman who cared about doctrine.
Catherine was a mother of a large family in a foreign city, speaking a language she had not grown up with, through cold Rhineland winters, with no idea whether she would ever see Greys Court again.
At home, things were getting worse.
Nearly three hundred people were burned for heresy in England during Mary’s reign.
Exiles in Frankfurt received the news in letters and printed pamphlets: names they knew, towns they knew, sometimes friends.
Elizabeth, meanwhile, was living under watch, first at Woodstock and later at Hatfield, careful of every word, attending Mass, and waiting.
Mary I had no children.
Her health was failing.
By the autumn of 1558, everyone who could count knew what would happen next.
On November 17, 1558, Mary died at St James’s Palace.
The Lady Elizabeth, at Hatfield, became Queen of England.
The news would have reached the exiles in Frankfurt within a couple of weeks.
It meant that the young woman who had signed herself “a broken heart” was now the most powerful person in the kingdom.
She had promised that when Catherine’s need was greatest, she would find her friendship greatest.
Now she was in a position to prove it.
—
## Why the queen wanted her cousin inside the door
The Knollyses came home in the first months of the new reign.
Sir Francis was made a member of the Privy Council and vice-chamberlain of the queen’s household.
Later he became Treasurer of the Household, one of the most senior offices at court.
He would spend the next thirty-seven years as one of Elizabeth’s most loyal and most outspoken servants, a man who argued with her about religion to her face and kept his place anyway.
Catherine was given something more personal.
She became one of the queen’s ladies of the bedchamber, and in time the chief of them.
Her own memorial calls her, in the spelling of the time, “Cheeffe Lady of the Quenes Maties Beddechamber.”
It is hard to overstate what that meant.
The bedchamber was the private heart of the court.
Lords and ambassadors waited outside.
Only a small circle of women went in.
They dressed the queen, kept her jewels, slept in her rooms or next to them, sat with her when she was ill, and heard what she said when she was angry.
For a monarch who trusted almost no one, they were the people closest to her moods.
Elizabeth chose many of them from her mother’s family.
This is the second great point anyone has to weigh before deciding that Catherine was the king’s daughter.
Elizabeth had almost no family left.
Her father, her brother and her sister were dead.
Her father’s relations were mostly Catholics, or rivals, or both.
But she had Boleyn cousins, and she gathered them around her: Catherine Knollys, and Catherine’s brother Henry Carey, whom she made Baron Hunsdon in the first weeks of her reign.
Through them, she honored the mother whose name she almost never spoke in public.
Catherine was, by most accounts, her favorite.
Catherine was about ten years older than the queen, a married woman with a houseful of children, an exile who had come home without changing her faith.
She was not a rival.
She was not a flatterer.
She had known Elizabeth since Elizabeth was a child.
And she had been named in a letter signed “a broken heart.”
Through the 1560s, Catherine was at the center of Elizabeth’s private world, through the years when the queen’s every move with Robert Dudley set the court talking and the autumn of 1562 when Elizabeth nearly died of smallpox.
She watched her own daughter Lettice marry Walter Devereux, a young nobleman who would become Earl of Essex.
She had found, at last, the kind of safety her mother never had.
It lasted ten years.
Then, in May 1568, a queen came across the border.
—
## The queen who crossed the Solway
On May 16, 1568, Mary, Queen of Scots, crossed the Solway Firth in a fishing boat and landed in England.
She had lost her throne, escaped from a castle on a loch and seen her last army broken, and she expected her cousin Elizabeth to help her win back her crown.
Elizabeth had no intention of doing so.
But a Catholic queen with a strong claim to the English throne could not simply be let go.
Someone had to hold her, politely and firmly, without ever quite calling it imprisonment.
Elizabeth chose Sir Francis Knollys.
He rode north to Carlisle to take charge of the Queen of Scots, and that summer he moved her to Bolton Castle, a great square fortress in Wensleydale.
He wrote long, honest letters back to London about his prisoner, whom he found intelligent, brave and much more dangerous than the court seemed to realize.
And he wanted to go home.
His letters to William Cecil, the queen’s chief adviser, grew more pointed as the months went by.
He asked to be relieved.
He complained about the cost and the impossible position of guarding a queen who would not admit she was a prisoner.
He was in his late fifties.
His wife, meanwhile, was ill.
What exactly was wrong with her, the records do not say clearly.
Some later writers have suggested a fever, others that she simply wore out after sixteen births and ten years of court life.
Some have even claimed that she died of grief at her husband’s long absence, which is the sort of thing that sounds more like a ballad than a medical report.
What is clear is that she was at Hampton Court, in the queen’s household, through the winter of 1568, and that her husband was at Bolton, two hundred miles away, guarding another woman’s cousin on the queen’s command.
Elizabeth needed him there.
She did not let him leave.
—
## Hampton Court, January 1569
The days were short.
By four in the afternoon in the middle of January, the light over the Thames was already gone, and the palace closed in on itself.
Candles were lit in the long galleries.
The guards changed at the gates.
Down by the river, the water ran fast and dark under the ice at its edges.
We do not have a description of Catherine Knollys’s sickroom, so what follows has to be built from what we know of how such rooms were kept.
The bed would have been curtained against drafts.
A fire would have been kept burning day and night, the smoke drawn up a chimney that never quite drew well enough.
There would have been the smell of herbs, perhaps rosemary or lavender, burned or strewn to sweeten the air.
Physicians would have come and gone, the queen’s own among them, in long dark gowns, consulting each other in low voices at the foot of the bed.
They would have examined what they could, ordered what they knew, and watched.
Around her would have been other women of the queen’s household, and very possibly some of her daughters.
Her eldest daughter Lettice was by then Viscountess Hereford, married for nearly a decade, a mother herself.
Her younger daughters were still unmarried, and girls of good family in that position were often placed at court.
If they were there, they would have taken their turns sitting by the bed, the way their mother had so often sat beside the queen.
Her husband was not.
Somewhere on the long road north, a letter may have been traveling in one direction or the other.
Sir Francis knew she was ill.
Whether he knew how ill, no one can say.
The queen, it seems, was close by.
Elizabeth was not, by nature, a woman who visited sickrooms.
She was terrified of disease, with reason: she had nearly died of smallpox in this very palace six years before.
She hated being reminded of death, and in later life she would refuse even to discuss who would succeed her.
But Catherine was not just any lady of the court.
There is no record of what passed between them in those last days, and it would be wrong to invent one.
All we can say is that the woman who had promised, in a letter signed “a broken heart,” that her deeds would match her words was under the same roof, and that when it was over, she acted as if she had lost one of her own.
The days went on.
Outside, the court went on, too.
Only a few weeks earlier, in December, this same palace had been the stage for one of the strangest meetings of the reign: a gathering of the queen’s council and a group of great lords, brought to Hampton Court to be shown the letters that the Scots said proved their queen guilty of her husband’s murder.
The prisoner Sir Francis was guarding two hundred miles away had been on trial in all but name, in the same palace where his wife lay ill.
Now the lords had ridden home.
Ambassadors still came.
Dispatches still arrived from the north about the Queen of Scots.
Messengers still splashed in through the gatehouse with their horses steaming.
Inside a court, sickness was always happening somewhere, and the world did not stop for it.
Somewhere in the palace, musicians practiced.
Somewhere, a page was being scolded.
Somewhere, the cooks were already planning the next feast.
In one room, it was very quiet.
Catherine Knollys was about forty-five years old.
She had been born in the shadow of a king.
She had been a child when her aunt was crowned and twelve years old when that aunt died on Tower Green.
She had served a German queen who was put aside and watched a teenage cousin rise to the throne and fall from it.
She had raised sixteen children, survived exile in a foreign city, come home to the safest place an English woman could stand, and stood there for ten years.
Now there was nothing anyone could do.
On January 15, 1569, at Hampton Court, she died.
Her husband was still at Bolton Castle.
He had ridden north in the late spring of 1568, and as far as the records show, he had not been home since.
The news went north by messenger, along the great road through Ware and Stamford and Doncaster, over the frozen ruts and across the swollen rivers, for days, until it reached the gate of a stone castle in the Dales where a gray-haired man was keeping a queen who was not his own.
What Sir Francis Knollys said when he heard it is not recorded.
What he did is.
He never married again.
At Hampton Court, the queen’s reaction came in the language Elizabeth used when she did not trust herself with words.
She paid.
—
## Six hundred and forty pounds, two shillings and eleven pence
The funeral did not happen at once.
Great funerals in Tudor England took time to arrange.
Heralds had to be consulted, black cloth ordered by the yard, mourners chosen by rank, a grave prepared.
Catherine Knollys’s body was embalmed and kept, and it was not until April 1569, three months after her death, that she was buried.
The place chosen for her was Westminster Abbey.
She was laid in the floor of the Chapel of St Edmund, one of the small chapels that open off the ambulatory around the shrine of Edward the Confessor.
It is a place crowded with medieval tombs, including those of lords and children of the royal blood from centuries before.
To be buried there, in the heart of the abbey where English monarchs were crowned and buried, was an honor given to very few people who were not themselves of royal rank.
The queen paid for all of it.
The bill was later recorded as six hundred and forty pounds, two shillings and eleven pence.
The papers of the expense are among the manuscripts at Hatfield House, the home of the Cecil family, whose head was the queen’s chief minister.
Modern equivalents for a sum like that vary enormously.
What matters is what it meant at the time.
Elizabeth was famously careful with money.
She haggled over the costs of wars and kept her favorites waiting for rewards.
For a woman like that to pay well over six hundred pounds to bury a lady of her bedchamber was not a routine courtesy.
It was the kind of thing a family did.
Later, a memorial was set up on the wall of the chapel near her grave: a colored alabaster tablet with columns and a decorated border, crowned with the crests of the families joined in her: a swan, a bull’s head, a maiden’s head.
Four shields carry the coats of arms of Knollys and Carey, and among the quarterings is the arms of Boleyn.
On it, in English, are the words that describe who she was.
The Right Honorable Lady Katherine Knollys.
Chief Lady of the Queen’s Majesty’s Bedchamber.
Wife to Sir Francis Knollys, Knight, Treasurer of her Highness’s Household.
Daughter of William Carey, and of the Lady Mary his wife, sister to Anne, Queen of England, wife to King Henry the Eighth, and mother to the Queen’s Majesty.
She departed this life, the tablet says, at Hampton Court, on the fifteenth of January, and was honorably buried in the floor of this chapel.
Below, a Latin verse speaks to her husband in a voice that sounds very much like his own.
She who was your wife, it says, lies dead under the chilly marble.
She was always loved by you.
She bore you sixteen children, as many daughters as sons.
The verse wishes she had lived many more years at his side.
But God desired it not.
Instead, it says, he willed that she should wait in heaven for her husband.
—
## Cousin or sister?
Look again at the words on that tablet.
The memorial names her father as William Carey.
It names her mother as Mary, and then, very deliberately, it climbs the family tree: Mary was the sister of Anne, Queen of England, the wife of Henry VIII and the mother of the queen.
The whole inscription is built to show that Catherine Knollys was close to the throne through her mother’s side.
It never once suggests that she was close to it through her father’s.
Of course, it never could have.
No family in 1569 was going to carve on a wall in Westminster Abbey that a dead woman’s real father was the late king.
So the tablet cannot settle the question.
But it shows how her family and her queen presented her to the world: as Elizabeth’s cousin, the daughter of a Boleyn.
So what is the case for the old rumor?
It rests on a few things.
Mary Boleyn certainly had an affair with Henry VIII, and the king’s own request to the pope makes that plain.
Catherine was born around 1524, which falls in or close to the years when the affair was probably going on.
Her brother was born in 1526, and a priest in 1535 repeated a story that the boy was the king’s son.
Elizabeth treated both of them with a warmth and generosity she showed to very few people.
And there is a portrait, painted in 1562 and long identified as Catherine, in which some people have seen a resemblance to the Tudors.
There is also a later story that when Henry Carey lay dying in 1596, Elizabeth offered him the earldom his Boleyn grandfather had held, and that he refused it, saying that if she had not thought him worthy of it in life, he would not take it in death.
It comes from a seventeenth-century anecdote.
It does not mention his father.
And what is the case against?
Nobody knows when the affair began or ended, and a date of “around 1524” for Catherine is itself an estimate.
Henry VIII openly acknowledged one son born outside marriage and gave him a dukedom; he never gave the Careys anything that marked them as his.
William Carey treated both children as his own, and the law did the same.
The only contemporary whisper concerns Henry Carey, not Catherine, and it came from a hostile witness repeating hearsay.
Elizabeth’s favor needs no secret to explain it: these were the children of her mother’s only sister, almost the only close family she had.
And the 1562 portrait itself is not certainly of Catherine; it is only “often identified” as her.
No letter, will or document of the time says Catherine Carey was the king’s daughter.
The honest conclusion is the one most careful historians reach.
It is possible.
It cannot be proved.
And it may not be true at all.
What can be proved is the thing Elizabeth did.
Whether she was burying a cousin or a sister, she buried her like family.
—
## What happened to all of them
**Sir Francis Knollys** stayed with the Queen of Scots for a few more weeks after his wife died, and by most accounts escorted her from Bolton to Tutbury Castle in Staffordshire at the end of January 1569 before he was finally allowed to hand her over.
He served Elizabeth for another twenty-seven years, as Treasurer of the Household, a fierce Puritan voice in Parliament and the council, and one of the few men who told the queen to her face when he thought she was wrong.
He was made a Knight of the Garter in 1593.
He never remarried.
He died in July 1596 and was buried at Rotherfield Greys.
**Henry Carey, Lord Hunsdon**, Catherine’s brother, became Lord Chamberlain in 1585, and from 1594 a company of actors performed under his patronage as the Lord Chamberlain’s Men.
One of them was William Shakespeare.
Hunsdon died in July 1596, within days of his brother-in-law, and lies in Westminster Abbey under one of the tallest monuments in the church.
**Lettice Knollys**, Catherine’s daughter, had her mother’s place at court but not her mother’s luck.
After her first husband, the Earl of Essex, died in 1576, she secretly married Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, the queen’s great favorite, in September 1578.
When Elizabeth found out, she was furious, and Lettice was banished from court for most of the rest of the reign.
Her son Robert Devereux, the second Earl of Essex, became Elizabeth’s last favorite; after a failed rising in 1601, he was beheaded in the Tower.
Lettice outlived almost everyone.
She died on Christmas Day, 1634, in her nineties.
**William Knollys**, one of Catherine’s younger sons, lived to become Earl of Banbury.
In the early 1600s, he raised a great monument in the church of St Nicholas at Rotherfield Greys, where his parents lie in painted stone, side by side, with their children kneeling around them.
It is still there.
**Greys Court**, the house where Catherine raised her children, still stands in its gardens above Henley and belongs to the National Trust.
**Elizabeth I** reigned for another thirty-four years and outlived nearly all of the women who had been young with her.
**Catherine Carey, Lady Knollys**, lies where she was buried in 1569, in the floor of the Chapel of St Edmund in Westminster Abbey.
Her tablet, repaired and set higher on the wall in the 1960s, is still there.
—
## The fire by the bed
Go back to Hampton Court, to that January of 1569.
To the high brown river and the short days and the candles in the galleries.
To the room where a woman of about forty-five lay ill, with her husband two hundred miles away and the queen she had served for ten years somewhere down the corridor.
She had been born in years nobody wrote down, to a mother who had been the king’s mistress, and given the same name as the queen.
She had lived her whole life with a question attached to her that she may never have heard spoken aloud.
She left it unanswered.
What she did not leave unanswered was the one Elizabeth had put to her in a letter at the darkest point of both their lives: whether a promise made in words would be kept in deeds.
The queen had written that when Catherine’s need was greatest, she would find her friendship greatest.
She wrote that when she was a frightened princess with no power at all.
Fifteen years later, she was a queen.
She paid six hundred and forty pounds, two shillings and eleven pence, and gave her cousin a grave among kings.
Nobody can say for certain whose daughter Catherine Carey was.
Everyone could see whose family she belonged to.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Catherine Carey was born about 1524; no birth record survives, and the date is an estimate.
Her mother Mary Boleyn married William Carey on February 4, 1520, with Henry VIII present; Mary’s affair with the king is not dated in any surviving source, but it is confirmed indirectly by the papal dispensation Henry sought in 1527 to marry Anne despite his relationship with her sister.
The ship named the Mary Boleyn and the grants to William Carey in the 1520s are recorded, but their link to the affair is an inference.
Henry Carey was born on March 4, 1526.
The idea that Henry VIII was Catherine’s father is a rumor and a modern theory, not a documented fact; Henry never acknowledged either Carey child.
The only known contemporary statement, from John Hale, vicar of Isleworth, in 1535, concerns “young Master Carey,” Catherine’s brother, and is hearsay; it is paraphrased apart from that phrase.
The stories that Catherine attended Anne Boleyn in the Tower or watched her execution are not supported by good evidence.
The grounds for the annulment of Henry’s marriage to Anne in May 1536 were not published; that it rested on the king’s earlier relationship with Mary Boleyn is the view of most historians, not a certainty.
Catherine was appointed a maid of honor to Anne of Cleves in November 1539 and married Francis Knollys on April 26, 1540.
The family went into exile under Mary I and lived in Basel and Frankfurt; the exact dates of departure and of each move are uncertain.
Elizabeth’s letter to Catherine, signed “Cor rotto,” survives and is printed in modern editions of her works; it is paraphrased here except for the signature, and its date (often given as 1553) is uncertain.
Catherine’s title as chief lady of the bedchamber, her death at Hampton Court on January 15, 1569, her burial in St Edmund’s Chapel, Westminster Abbey, the queen’s payment of the funeral expenses, and the inscription on her tablet are documented; the tablet gives the year as 1568 because the old calendar began the new year in March.
The figure of £640 2s.
11d. is the sum usually cited from the expense papers at Hatfield House.
The cause of her death is not known; the claim that she died of grief at her husband’s absence is a later embellishment.
The sickroom, the physicians, her daughters’ presence and the messenger’s route are reconstructed, not taken from any description of her last days.
Nothing is recorded of any final meeting between Catherine and Elizabeth.
The story of Henry Carey refusing an earldom on his deathbed comes from a seventeenth-century anecdote and may not be true.
The 1562 portrait by Steven van der Meulen is often identified as Catherine, but the identification is not certain.
The December 1568 showing of the casket letters at Hampton Court is recalled from general histories and has not been checked against the original records.