News

1502: Henry VIII’s Older Brother Died at 15. Twenty-Seven Years Later, His Marriage Was Put on Trial

The rain had followed the funeral all the way from Ludlow.

It came down on the roof of Worcester Cathedral in the last week of April 1502, and it ran off the shoulders of the men who carried the coffin up the nave, and it dripped from the black hoods of the mourners until the stone floor shone wet under the torches.

Inside the coffin was a boy of fifteen.

He had been dead for more than three weeks.

His body had come down from the Welsh border on roads so deep in mud that, according to the herald who rode with the procession, there were places where oxen had to be yoked to the wagon because horses could not pull it through.

Now he lay before the high altar, a few steps from the tomb of King John.

His mother was not there.

His father was not there.

His young widow was not there either.

It was the custom: kings and queens did not follow their children to the grave, and a royal widow did not walk behind her husband’s coffin.

So the chief mourner was a soldier, Thomas Howard, Earl of Surrey, and the men who stood closest to the grave were the officers of the dead boy’s household.

When the coffin was lowered, those officers did what Tudor officers did at the burial of a great lord.

They took the white staves that were the sign of their office, broke them, and threw the pieces into the grave after him.

Their master was gone.

Their jobs were gone with him.

The herald who wrote it all down said, in effect, that a man would need a very hard heart not to weep.

The boy was Arthur, Prince of Wales, the eldest son of King Henry VII, the heir to the throne of England.

He had been married for less than five months.

And the grave did not end his story.

Twenty-seven years later, in a crowded hall in London, Arthur’s name would be read aloud again and again before two cardinals of the Church.

Old men who had once been his servants would be brought in, one by one, and asked to remember a single morning in November 1501.

His widow, by then the Queen of England and married for twenty years to his little brother, would cross that hall and kneel on the floor.

And what she said there, about the boy in the rain-soaked grave at Worcester, would help break England away from Rome.

What happened in those five months?

Nobody alive today knows.

But this is the story of how a dead prince’s marriage ended up on trial, and of the one question no court, no king, and no Pope was ever able to answer.

—

## Why would a king name his first son after a legend?

The boy in the grave had been born in the middle of the night, in a priory, in the town that was supposed to be Camelot.

It was the early hours of September 20, 1486.

His father, Henry Tudor, had won the crown of England on a battlefield at Bosworth barely a year before.

Henry had no real claim to the throne beyond his sword and a thin line of descent through his mother, and every noble family in the country knew it.

So he married Elizabeth of York, the eldest daughter of the old Yorkist king Edward IV, and joined the two warring houses into one.

Then he did something carefully planned.

He sent his pregnant wife to Winchester.

In the stories of the time, Winchester was the site of King Arthur’s Camelot, and a great round table, said to be Arthur’s own, hung on the wall of the castle hall there.

The Tudors claimed descent from the ancient British kings through their Welsh ancestors.

A prince born at Winchester, and named Arthur, would be living proof that the legendary king had come home.

The baby arrived in St Swithun’s Priory, beside the cathedral.

Four days later he was carried into Winchester Cathedral to be baptized.

His grandmother, Elizabeth Woodville, the widowed queen of Edward IV, stood as his godmother, and his aunt Cecily of York had a place of honor at the font.

From the day he was born, he was Duke of Cornwall.

When he was three, his father created him Prince of Wales.

Then the work of making him a king began.

His first tutor was a churchman named John Rede.

After him came Bernard André, a blind French poet and friar who wrote the official praise of the Tudor dynasty, and who later claimed that his pupil had read or memorized large parts of Homer, Virgil, Cicero, and Livy before he was much more than a child.

Then came Thomas Linacre, one of the finest scholars in England, a physician who had studied in Italy.

The prince learned Latin, the language of every treaty and every royal letter in Europe.

He learned to ride, to shoot, and to dance.

He was thin and fair, and the few descriptions of him are respectful rather than warm.

What is certain is how much rested on him.

His father had come to power by killing a king.

Every year of peace that followed depended on one thing: a healthy heir, already grown, ready to take the crown without a fight.

Arthur was that heir.

And before he could walk, his father had already chosen his wife.

—

## Why did the bride take twelve years to arrive?

In March 1489, at Medina del Campo in Castile, English and Spanish envoys signed a treaty.

Arthur was two and a half.

The girl on the other side of the agreement was three.

She was Catalina, the youngest daughter of Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile, the two monarchs who had joined their kingdoms into the beginnings of Spain.

The English would call her Katherine, or Catherine.

For Henry VII, the match was a seal of approval from one of the most powerful royal families in Christendom.

For Ferdinand and Isabella, it was a way to tie England against France.

The dowry was to be two hundred thousand crowns, paid in parts.

The children did not meet for twelve years.

They were betrothed by proxy in 1497.

In 1499, at Tickenhill Manor near Bewdley in Worcestershire, a second proxy ceremony was held, with the Spanish ambassador, Rodrigo de Puebla, standing in for the bride.

Letters went back and forth in Latin.

In one that survives from the autumn of 1499, the thirteen-year-old prince told the princess how much he longed to see her, and that her letters made him feel as if he could already see her and speak with her.

It was the language of a schoolroom exercise, and his tutors almost certainly helped.

But it was the only voice either of them had.

There were long delays.

Spain hesitated while a Yorkist pretender was still alive in an English prison.

Catherine’s ship was driven back by storms.

At last, on October 2, 1501, she landed at Plymouth.

She was fifteen.

She had brought a household of Spanish ladies, priests, and servants, and she spoke almost no English.

On November 4, at Dogmersfield in Hampshire, Henry VII rode up to the house where she was staying and demanded to see her.

Her Spanish attendants protested that by the custom of their country a bride kept her veil down until her wedding day.

The king did not care about the custom of their country.

He saw her face.

Then Arthur arrived, and the two of them met at last.

They tried to talk in Latin, the one language they shared, and discovered that the English and the Spanish pronounced it so differently that they could barely understand one another.

That evening there was music, and Catherine danced the dances of Spain.

A few days later, Arthur wrote to her parents that he would be “a true and loving husband.”

He had ten days left before the wedding.

He had five months left to live.

—

## Who walked the bride down the aisle?

On the morning of November 14, 1501, a ten-year-old boy took the Spanish princess by the hand and led her into St Paul’s Cathedral.

He was Henry, Duke of York, Arthur’s younger brother.

He was tall for his age, red-haired, loud, and adored by the crowds.

No one in the cathedral imagined that the woman whose hand he was holding would one day be his wife, and that her wedding to his brother would one day be his obsession.

The cathedral had been prepared like a stage.

A long raised walkway, covered in red cloth, ran up the nave so that the crowd in the church could see the couple from every side.

The Archbishop of Canterbury, Henry Deane, performed the marriage, with the Bishop of London, William Warham, beside him.

Catherine was dressed in white satin, by the descriptions of the day, with a great veil.

Arthur was in white as well.

They were both fifteen.

After the vows, the bells of London rang and the wine conduits in the streets ran with free wine.

Then came almost two weeks of celebration.

There were jousts at Westminster.

There were pageants with castles on wheels, ships that seemed to float across the floor, and mountains that opened to let out dancers.

There were banquets where the dishes came in by the hundred.

And there was little Henry, who, according to one account of the festivities, danced with his sister Margaret, grew too hot, and pulled off his gown to dance on in his jacket, while his parents watched and laughed.

Everyone seemed to agree that the boy was a born performer.

Arthur was quieter.

He was the one who would be king.

His brother was the one who was meant to become a churchman, or a great duke, or simply a spare.

But in the middle of the feasting, on the night of the wedding itself, something took place that nobody thought worth remembering at the time.

Twenty-seven years later, it would be the only thing about Arthur that anyone wanted to talk about.

—

## Why did a royal bedchamber need witnesses?

The wedding night was spent at Baynard’s Castle, the royal house on the river near St Paul’s.

To modern readers, what happened there sounds strange.

To the Tudors, it was a matter of law.

A marriage of princes was a treaty between kingdoms, and a treaty had to be beyond question.

So at the end of the day, the young couple were brought separately to the bedchamber with ceremony, prayers were said, and the Bishop of London blessed the marriage bed in the presence of members of both households.

Then the guests withdrew and closed the door.

The rules for the ceremony had been set down by Arthur’s formidable grandmother, Lady Margaret Beaufort, who had written out how royal occasions were to be conducted.

It is the only public ceremony of its kind for a royal couple recorded in England in that century.

Its purpose was simple.

If anyone ever questioned whether the prince and princess had truly been husband and wife, there would be witnesses who had seen the marriage blessed and the couple left together.

In Church law, a marriage was made by the consent of the two people.

But it was considered fully completed, the lawyers’ word was “consummated,” only when the couple had lived as husband and wife.

For most families, the difference never mattered.

For Arthur’s widow, it would one day decide whether she was a queen or nothing at all.

The next morning, the prince came out of his chamber and spoke to the gentlemen waiting for him.

What he said, or what he was supposed to have said, was not written down that day.

It would be written down in the summer of 1529, by lawyers, from the memories of men who were by then in their forties and fifties.

Hold on to that.

We will come back to it.

—

## Why did a fifteen-year-old prince go to live on the edge of Wales?

At the end of 1501, the prince and princess left London.

Arthur was Prince of Wales in more than name.

Since his childhood, a council had governed the Welsh borderlands in his name from Ludlow Castle, a great fortress of red stone above the River Teme in Shropshire.

Now he was to live there himself and learn to rule.

There had been talk at court about whether his young bride should go with him, or stay behind until they were both a little older.

In the end she went.

They traveled west by way of Tickenhill, the same manor near Bewdley where they had been married by proxy two years earlier, and they came to Ludlow by the early part of the new year.

It was a winter of wind and wet.

The castle was large and cold, and its great hall and lodgings looked out over a small market town and a wide country of hills and rivers.

Arthur had his council, his chamberlain, his chaplains, his steward Sir Richard Croft, and a household of men whose fathers had fought for his father.

Catherine had her Spanish ladies, and among them her strict, watchful governess, Doña Elvira Manuel.

She also had a problem that no one had solved.

The first part of her dowry had been paid, but the rest was still owed, and both fathers were arguing about money and plate and jewels even while their children ate at the same table.

What did the two of them talk about, in a language they pronounced differently, in a castle on the Welsh border?

No letters between them from Ludlow survive.

No diary.

No reliable account of a single conversation.

Everything we have about their few months together comes either from the formal records of a royal household, or from the arguments of lawyers a generation later.

What we do know is that, in the last days of March 1502, a sickness came to Ludlow.

—

## What was the “malign vapour”?

It came in the spring, the season when the Tudors expected fevers.

Both the prince and the princess fell ill.

A later account described the cause in the medical language of the time as a malign vapour which proceeded from the air.

Nobody in 1502 knew what that meant in modern terms, and nobody today can be sure.

Some historians think it was the sweating sickness, a terrifying fever that appeared in England in the years after Bosworth and could kill a healthy person between breakfast and supper.

Others suggest tuberculosis, which would mean that Arthur had been weak for months before anyone noticed, or plague, or a severe influenza.

There is no surviving physician’s report.

There is no description of the illness from anyone who sat beside his bed.

Catherine was sick enough to be kept to her own rooms.

She recovered.

Arthur did not.

He died at Ludlow on April 2, 1502.

He was fifteen years and six months old.

His council did not dare send the news to the king by an ordinary messenger.

They wrote to the Privy Council at Greenwich, and the councillors there sat with the letter and argued about who should tell Henry VII that his son and heir was dead.

The man they chose was the king’s confessor.

It was late in the evening of April 4 when the friar came to the king’s chamber.

—

## Who had to wake the king?

According to the account written by a herald at court, the confessor came into the room and asked everyone else to leave.

Then he spoke to the king in the formal words of a priest.

If we receive good things from the hand of God, he said, in substance, shall we not also accept the bad?

Henry VII understood at once.

He broke down.

He sent for the queen.

Elizabeth of York came to her husband and comforted him, according to the same account, reminding him that God had left him a fair prince and two fair princesses, and that they were both still young enough to have more children.

Then she went back to her own rooms and collapsed, and it was the king who had to come and comfort her.

Within a year, she would die herself, in childbirth, trying to give him the son they had promised each other that night.

There was one person in the palace whose life changed completely in those hours.

He was ten years old.

Henry, Duke of York, had been raised to be the second son.

He had been given a good education because a prince’s brother might one day be an archbishop, and because his father liked clever children.

He had been allowed to show off and dance and ride, because nobody had to worry very much about what he was learning to be.

Now he was the only son of Henry VII.

He was the heir to England.

From that night on, his father kept him close, and a few years later a Spanish envoy reported that the prince lived almost like a girl in seclusion.

Arthur had been sent away to Ludlow at fifteen to learn to govern.

Henry would never be sent anywhere.

He would grow up inside his father’s court, by that envoy’s account in rooms that could be reached only through the king’s own chambers, guarded like the last thing the king had left.

Because he was.

—

## Why did the funeral take three weeks?

At Ludlow, the dead prince was embalmed, wrapped in cloth, and placed in a coffin that lay in state in the castle while his household kept watch.

On April 23, St George’s Day, the coffin was carried down into the parish church of St Laurence in the town, under a canopy, with torches and priests and the boy’s own household walking in black.

There is a tradition that his heart was buried there, in Ludlow, before the rest of him left.

Then the procession set out for Worcester.

It was the journey the herald never forgot.

The rain fell all day.

The roads through the hills were rivers of mud.

The funeral carriage stuck so badly that in places, he wrote, they had to bring oxen to haul it, because the horses could do nothing.

Riders went ahead to Worcester to prepare the cathedral.

Among them were Sir Richard Croft, Arthur’s steward, and Sir William Uvedale, the controller of his household, men who had spent the winter managing the prince’s money, horses, and meals, and who now had to manage his burial.

At Worcester, the clergy and the city met the coffin with torches.

Arthur’s own herald took off the coat of arms he wore as the prince’s officer and laid it on the coffin, because he no longer had a lord to wear it for.

The requiem was sung.

The staves were broken.

The grave was closed.

Catherine stayed at Ludlow.

She was still recovering, she was in deep mourning, and custom did not allow her to follow the coffin.

When she was well enough to travel, the queen is said to have sent a litter hung with black velvet to carry her back to London.

She came back to the city where, five months earlier, she had walked up a red-carpeted aisle with a little red-haired boy holding her hand.

She was sixteen.

She was a widow.

And now the two kings began to argue about what, exactly, she was.

—

## Why would no one send the widow home?

If Catherine went back to Spain, Henry VII would have to return the part of her dowry he had already received.

If she stayed, Ferdinand would have to pay the rest.

Neither father wanted to pay anything.

So she stayed, and for seven years she lived in a kind of royal waiting room.

The first idea came quickly.

Arthur had a younger brother.

By the summer of 1503, a new treaty had been agreed, and Catherine, at seventeen, was betrothed to Henry, who was eleven.

There was a difficulty.

The Church forbade a man to marry his brother’s widow.

The ban came from the Book of Leviticus, which described taking a brother’s wife as an unclean thing and warned that such a couple “shall be childless.”

But another book of the same Bible, Deuteronomy, told a man to marry his dead brother’s widow if the brother had died without children.

The Church had long held that the Pope could grant a dispensation, a formal permission, in a case like this.

So the request went to Rome.

And here the question of the wedding night appeared for the first time on paper.

Catherine’s mother, Queen Isabella, had been told by the Spanish household that her daughter’s marriage to Arthur had never been completed.

She wanted that stated.

The English wanted a permission that would hold whatever had happened.

The bull that Pope Julius II eventually issued, dated December 26, 1503, used a carefully cautious word.

It allowed the marriage even though the first marriage had “perhaps” been consummated.

In Latin the word was “forsan.”

It was meant to close every door.

Twenty-five years later, it would be the crack that a king’s lawyers tried to pry open.

The wedding did not happen.

In 1505, on the day before he turned fourteen, Prince Henry was brought before a small group of witnesses at Richmond and made a formal, secret protest that he had been betrothed as a child and did not consent to the marriage.

It was his father’s move in the money game, not the boy’s.

Catherine knew nothing about it.

She lived on at Durham House on the Strand with a shrinking Spanish household.

She wrote to her father that she could not pay for food for her servants, and that she had been forced to sell some of her bracelets to buy a dress.

She fell ill again and again.

She waited.

—

## Why did Henry VIII marry his brother’s widow?

On April 21, 1509, Henry VII died.

His son was seventeen, and he moved fast.

Within seven weeks, on June 11, 1509, the new king married Catherine of Aragon in a quiet ceremony at the church of the Observant Friars beside Greenwich Palace.

She was twenty-three.

He was a few weeks short of his eighteenth birthday.

On Midsummer Day they were crowned together in Westminster Abbey.

Henry later said that his father, on his deathbed, had told him to marry her.

He also said, many times and for many years, that he loved her.

In the early years it was obvious.

At tournaments, his costume was sewn with his initial and hers, H and K, side by side.

He fought under the name Sir Loyal Heart.

He left her in charge of England as regent when he went to war in France in 1513, and while he was away, an English army under the same Thomas Howard, Earl of Surrey, who had walked as chief mourner behind Arthur’s coffin, crushed the invading Scots at Flodden.

Catherine sent her husband a piece of the dead Scottish king’s coat as a trophy.

But the nursery stayed empty.

A daughter born dead.

A son, born on New Year’s Day 1511, who lived only a few weeks.

More pregnancies that ended in grief.

One daughter, Mary, born in 1516, who lived.

By the middle of the 1520s, Catherine was nearly forty, there had been no pregnancy for years, and the King of England still had no legitimate son.

Henry began to read the Bible differently.

—

## What did Henry find in the Book of Leviticus?

“They shall be childless.”

The king came to believe that the words were written about him.

He had married his brother’s wife.

God had given him no living son.

Surely, he reasoned, the two facts were connected.

And if they were, then no Pope had ever had the power to permit the marriage in the first place, because no Pope could set aside the law of God.

By 1527, the king was also in love with Anne Boleyn, who would not become his mistress and wanted to be his wife.

His conscience and his desires were pointing the same way.

In May 1527, Cardinal Thomas Wolsey, the king’s chief minister, opened a secret court at his London house to examine the marriage.

Catherine was not told.

She found out anyway, and she would not move an inch.

Her case was as simple as the king’s.

The dispensation had been valid.

And there had been nothing to dispense in the first place, she said, because her marriage to Arthur had never been completed.

In the autumn of 1528, the Pope sent an Italian cardinal, Lorenzo Campeggio, to England to judge the matter with Wolsey.

Campeggio tried to persuade the queen to settle everything quietly by entering a convent.

She refused.

Instead, he reported to Rome, she told him under the seal of confession, on her conscience, that she had come to Henry untouched by his brother, and she gave him leave to repeat it.

Then her side produced a surprise.

A copy of a second papal document had been found in Spain, a brief written in different words, which covered the marriage whether or not the first had been consummated.

Henry’s lawyers said it was a forgery.

The original was in Spain, where the emperor, Catherine’s nephew, would not let it go.

By the spring of 1529, both sides had their documents, and both sides had their oath.

The only thing left to try was evidence.

What had happened at Ludlow, and before that at Baynard’s Castle, in the winter of 1501?

Only two people had ever known for certain.

One of them had been under the floor of Worcester Cathedral for twenty-seven years.

The other was about to be summoned to court.

—

## What happened in the hall at Blackfriars?

The court opened at the end of May 1529, in the great hall of the Dominican friary at Blackfriars, between St Paul’s and the river.

It was a legatine court, a court of the Pope’s own representatives.

Its two judges sat high at one end on chairs covered in cloth of gold: Wolsey in his scarlet, and Campeggio, so crippled by gout that he often had to be carried in.

The bishops sat below them.

The lawyers sat at tables.

To one side, under a cloth of estate, was a chair for the king.

Further off, across the floor, was a chair for the queen.

On June 18, Catherine came for the first time, and she did not plead.

She read a formal protest that the court had no right to judge her, because the case belonged in Rome, and she left.

Three days later, on Monday, June 21, both of them were summoned to appear in person.

That had never happened before.

No living person had seen a King and Queen of England called by name into a court like any married couple in a quarrel.

The hall was packed.

There were bishops and abbots, lawyers in their gowns, lords of the council, the queen’s few loyal advisers, and as many Londoners as could push in at the back.

One man who was there was George Cavendish, a gentleman of Wolsey’s household.

Years later, after his master was dead, he wrote down what he saw.

Most of what we know about that morning comes from him.

The crier stood up.

He called the king.

“King Henry of England, come into the court.”

The king answered from his chair that he was there.

Then the crier called her.

“Catherine, Queen of England, come into the court.”

She did not answer.

She stood up.

Cavendish says she rose from her chair and did not go toward the cardinals at all.

She went the long way around the court, past the lawyers’ tables and the benches, until she reached the place where her husband sat.

And there, in front of the whole hall, she went down on her knees.

She was forty-three.

He was thirty-seven, a week short of his thirty-eighth birthday.

She spoke to him, Cavendish wrote, in broken English, as if there were no one else in the room.

She asked him, for all the love that had been between them, and for the love of God, to let her have justice.

She called herself “a poor woman and a stranger, born out of your dominion,” with no friend and no impartial counsel in his kingdom.

She asked what she had ever done to displease him.

She said she had been his true and obedient wife for twenty years and more, and had borne him children, though it had pleased God to take them, “which hath been no default in me.”

Then she came to the reason they were all there.

It was the one sentence anyone in England would remember.

She did not mention Arthur’s name.

She did not need to.

“And when ye had me at the first,” she said, “I take God to be my judge, I was a true maid, without touch of man.”

“And whether this be true or no, I put it to your conscience.”

Nobody in the hall moved.

Think about what she had done.

The king’s lawyers had built their whole case on the claim that the first marriage had been completed and that no one could prove otherwise.

She had not argued with the lawyers.

She had not argued with the cardinals.

She had turned to the one other living person who could know the truth, and in front of every bishop in England, she had asked him to say it.

If he had been in any doubt, she was telling him, he of all men should have known.

Henry did not answer.

Cavendish records no reply from him at all while she knelt there.

She asked for time to write to her family in Spain for advice.

If that was refused, she said, she committed her cause to God.

Then she got up.

She made a deep curtsy to the king.

And instead of returning to her chair, she turned and walked toward the door.

The court officers called after her.

The crier called her name again: “Catherine, Queen of England, come into the court.”

Griffith Richards, her receiver-general, on whose arm she was leaning, told her quietly that she was being called back.

Her answer, as Cavendish remembered it, was short.

“On, on, it maketh no matter, for it is no indifferent court for me, therefore I will not tarry. Go on your ways.”

She went out of the hall.

She never came back to that court.

It was the king who spoke next.

Cavendish says that Henry, seeing her gone, told the court that she had been to him as true, as obedient, and as conformable a wife as he could in his fantasy wish or desire.

He said that his trouble was not with her.

It was with his conscience, which had been pricked, he said, by doubts about whether his daughter was legitimate, and by fear that God had condemned the marriage.

He said nothing about the night at Baynard’s Castle.

He said nothing about Ludlow.

He had been ten years old that winter.

Whatever he knew, he knew from her.

And she had just walked out of the hall leaving the question with him.

The cardinals declared her contumacious, a person refusing the authority of the court, and decided to proceed without her.

If the queen would not give them evidence, other people would.

The lawyers began calling in old men.

—

## What did the old men swear they remembered?

Over the next weeks, in the summer of 1529, depositions were taken from men who had been at court in November 1501.

Some came to Blackfriars.

Some were questioned at their own houses.

George Talbot, Earl of Shrewsbury, one of the greatest lords in England, gave his evidence on June 28, 1529, at Coldharbour, a mansion on the Thames.

The witnesses were asked the same things.

Had they been present at the wedding?

Had they seen the prince taken to the princess’s chamber that night?

Had they heard the prince say anything afterward?

How old had he been?

Their answers were written down in the dry language of a lawyer’s record.

Several remembered the ceremony of that first night: that they had escorted the prince to the princess’s chamber, that the Earl of Oxford and others had gone with him, and that they had left him there.

One deponent reasoned from his own life.

He had been married at fifteen himself, he said, and lived as a husband, so he supposed the prince had done the same.

Others said that, at Ludlow, the young couple had been treated in every way as husband and wife.

And one of them remembered a sentence.

Sir Anthony Willoughby, son of Lord Willoughby de Broke, had been one of the young gentlemen attending Arthur.

He testified that on the morning after the wedding, the prince came out of the chamber and asked for a drink, saying he was thirsty “for I have been this night in the midst of Spain.”

That was it.

That was the evidence.

A remark, remembered after twenty-seven years, attributed to a boy of fifteen who was dead and could not be asked what he meant.

As law, it proved very little.

Teenage boys boasted then as they do now, especially in front of other young men, and especially on the morning after a royal wedding when everyone around them expected a boast.

Catherine’s defenders said exactly that.

They also pointed out that the witnesses had every reason to remember what the king wanted them to remember.

These were men whose lands and offices came from Henry VIII, testifying in a case Henry VIII wanted to win.

On the other side, there was Spain.

Catherine’s Spanish household had always told the same story: that she had come to Henry as she had come to Arthur.

Her governess was reported to have said so in 1502.

Her mother had acted on it in 1503.

In later hearings held in Spain, a Spanish witness described the morning after the wedding very differently, with the princess’s ladies worried and disappointed, as though nothing had happened at all.

Those witnesses had every reason to remember what Catherine wanted them to remember.

So there it was.

English memories against Spanish memories.

The king’s men against the queen’s.

A prince’s boast against a queen’s sworn word.

That is the secret this story promised at the beginning.

There was no secret.

The court at Blackfriars, with its cardinals and its lawyers and its depositions, never found out what happened in the winter of 1501, because the only people who could have told it were a dead boy and a woman who had already sworn.

And she never changed her answer, not once, for the rest of her life.

—

## Why did the court never reach a verdict?

The legatine court never ruled.

On July 23, 1529, everyone came to hear the judgment.

Campeggio stood up and announced that, under the rules of the Roman courts, the summer vacation had begun, and the case was adjourned until October.

It was never resumed.

The Pope had already decided to call the case to Rome, where Catherine’s nephew, the Emperor Charles V, held great power.

Cavendish says that the Duke of Suffolk, Henry’s oldest friend, slammed his hand on the table and declared that it had never been merry in England while there were cardinals among them.

Wolsey fell within months.

He died at Leicester in November 1530, on his way south to face charges of treason.

Henry gave up on Rome.

Over the next four years, Parliament cut, one by one, the threads that tied the English Church to the Pope.

In January 1533, Henry secretly married Anne Boleyn.

In May 1533, in a court at Dunstable, his new Archbishop of Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer, declared that the marriage to Catherine had never been valid.

The verdict that Blackfriars would not give, Cranmer gave in a few days.

He did not settle the question of the winter of 1501.

He did not need to.

The king’s new Church simply ruled that the Pope’s permission had never counted.

And Catherine was given a new title.

From then on, by order, she was to be called the Princess Dowager.

It meant the widow of a prince.

It meant, specifically, Arthur’s widow.

After twenty-four years as Queen of England, she had been sent back, on paper, to the winter of 1502.

She refused it.

She signed her letters as queen until the end.

—

## What happened to all of them?

Catherine of Aragon was moved from house to house, each one smaller and colder than the last, and kept apart from her daughter.

She died at Kimbolton Castle in Huntingdonshire on January 7, 1536.

She was buried in Peterborough Abbey, now Peterborough Cathedral, with the honors of a Princess Dowager.

To the end she was buried as Arthur’s widow, the one thing she had always denied being.

Henry VIII married four more times after Anne Boleyn.

He finally had a son, Edward, by Jane Seymour in 1537.

He died in January 1547 and was buried at Windsor.

He never ruled on the question of his brother’s wedding night himself, and as far as the record shows, he never answered his first wife’s appeal to his conscience.

Their daughter Mary came to the throne in 1553.

Her first Parliament declared that the marriage of her father and mother had been lawful from the beginning.

It was the last official word on the matter, and it was given by the person who had the most to lose from the other answer.

Thomas Howard, the Earl of Surrey who walked behind Arthur’s coffin in the rain, became Duke of Norfolk after Flodden and died in 1524, before the trial began.

Sir Richard Croft, the steward who rode ahead to Worcester, died a few years after his prince and lies in the church at Croft beside his castle in Herefordshire.

George Cavendish finished his book about Wolsey in the 1550s.

It is the reason we can still stand, in our minds, in the hall at Blackfriars.

Ludlow Castle is a ruin today, roofless and red, above the river.

Visitors are shown the remains of the lodgings where the prince and princess are said to have lived that winter.

And at Worcester, about two years after the funeral, a chantry was built over Arthur’s grave.

It is still there, to the right of the high altar.

It is a small chapel of carved stone, like a cage of lace, built so that priests could sing Masses for his soul forever.

Inside its walls are the badges of the family he was born to lead.

Nearby lies King John, who died almost three centuries before Arthur was born.

In April 2002, five hundred years after the funeral, the cathedral marked the anniversary with a commemoration of the boy who would have been King Arthur of England.

—

## What was left in the grave at Worcester?

Go back for a moment to that wet April day in 1502.

The coffin.

The torches.

The broken white staves going down into the dark one after another, because the men who held them no longer had a master.

The officers broke them because the household was over.

The boy was dead, the service he had commanded was ended, and everything he had owned and ruled would pass to someone else.

All of it did.

His title went to his brother.

His crown went to his brother.

His wife went to his brother.

The only thing that did not pass on was what he knew.

For twenty-seven years, that knowledge lay under the floor at Worcester while kings, cardinals, and Popes argued over it.

They sent for his old servants.

They read out his supposed words.

They made his name into evidence.

And in the end, the one person who had been there stood up in a hall full of the most powerful men in England, said what she had to say, and walked out without looking back.

“I put it to your conscience.”

The question was never answered.

It is still in the grave at Worcester, with the boy who would have been King Arthur.

—

## What The Record Actually Says

Arthur was born at St Swithun’s Priory, Winchester, in the early hours of September 20, 1486, and died at Ludlow Castle on April 2, 1502, aged fifteen; he married Catherine of Aragon at St Paul’s Cathedral on November 14, 1501, less than five months before his death.

Catherine was born in December 1485 and was fifteen at the wedding.

The cause of Arthur’s death is unknown; sweating sickness, tuberculosis, plague, and influenza have all been suggested.

The phrase “a malign vapour which proceeded from the air” is quoted from a later account.

The scene of the confessor waking Henry VII, and Elizabeth of York’s words, come from a contemporary herald’s account and are paraphrased here.

The funeral details (the bad weather, oxen hauling the carriage, Surrey as chief mourner, the herald’s coat laid on the coffin, the broken staves) also come from heraldic records; the exact dates of the arrival at Worcester and the burial vary between accounts (from April 25 to April 27, 1502).

The tradition that Arthur’s heart was buried at Ludlow, and the black litter sent for Catherine, are traditions and should be treated with caution.

The papal bull of December 26, 1503, used the word “forsan” (“perhaps”) about consummation; the separate “Spanish brief” was challenged by Henry’s lawyers as a forgery.

Catherine’s statement to Campeggio in 1528 is known from Campeggio’s own report.

The Blackfriars scene of June 21, 1529, including all of Catherine’s and Henry’s words quoted here, comes from George Cavendish’s *Life of Wolsey*, written years later from memory; other chroniclers tell it slightly differently.

The 1529 depositions survive in the state papers; the Earl of Shrewsbury’s was taken at Coldharbour on June 28, 1529.

Sir Anthony Willoughby’s remembered remark is the most famous piece of testimony, and most historians treat it as a teenage boast that proves nothing.

The Spanish accounts are equally interested.

Whether the marriage of Arthur and Catherine was ever consummated is not known, and cannot be known.

Scenes inside Worcester Cathedral and Blackfriars are reconstructed from these sources; no dialogue has been invented for any named person.

You Might Also Enjoy