The Letters In The Beer Barrel — Mary, Queen of Scots, 1587 (Queen Elizabeth I Vlog)
There is frost on the inside of my window this morning, little ferns of ice on every diamond of glass, and through the clear corners I can see the river, gray and slow, with three ships sitting on it like they have nowhere to be.
It is the fourteenth of February, 1587, and I am at Greenwich, in the house where I was born.
On the table beside me there is a barrel.
A small one, oak, with iron hoops, the kind a brewer sends to a country house every week.
It smells of old beer and wet wood.
The bung has been pulled out of the side, and there is a dark round hole where it used to be.
I keep putting my finger near the hole and taking it away again, as if something might still be inside.
Nothing is inside.
That is the point.
Bess is holding the camera.
Her hands are cold, so the picture is shaking a little, and I have decided to allow it, because today I am in a forgiving mood about almost everything except one thing.
Good morrow, my loyal subjects.
I read your comments.
Hundreds of you have asked me about my cousin.
So today I am going to tell you how we caught her.
Not the version in your schoolbooks, with the dates in a line.
The real one, with the spy who landed at Rye, the brewer who was paid twice, the little man who could read anything, the handsome boy who ran into a wood, and the paper I signed thirteen days ago.
For half a year, my cousin’s secret letters went out in a beer barrel, and my men read every one.
This barrel is not one of those barrels.
It is a cousin of those barrels.
It arrived yesterday from the house of my Secretary, Sir Francis Walsingham, who is sick in bed and still, apparently, has a sense of humor.
There was a note tied to it.
It said only, For the camera.
Stay to the end.
I will read you the letter I wrote this morning to her son.
The ink is still wet.
Nobody in England has read it except me.
And when I have read it to you, you are going to tell me something I have not been able to decide for myself.
—
## The cousin I have never been in the same room with
Her name is Mary Stuart.
Her father, the King of Scots, died when she was six days old, and so at six days old she became Mary, Queen of Scots, which is the kind of thing that happens in my family and in hers.
Her grandmother was my father’s sister, Margaret Tudor, which means that if I die without a child, a great many people believe the next head under my crown should be hers.
A great many people believe it should be hers already.
At five, they sent her to France to be raised as the bride of the French king’s son.
At fifteen she married the boy.
At sixteen, when I became queen, the French put my royal arms on her plates and her coaches, quartered with her own, as if England were already hers and I were just a lady keeping the chair warm.
At eighteen she was a widow, and France did not need her anymore, so she sailed home to a cold, wet, angry Scotland she barely remembered.
The short version of what happened there is this.
She married a tall, handsome, useless young man called Lord Darnley.
They had a son, James, in June of 1566.
Eight months later, Darnley’s house in Edinburgh blew up in the night, and Darnley was found dead in the garden.
Three months after that, Mary married the man most of Scotland believed had arranged it.
Her lords rose against her, locked her in a castle on an island in a lake, and made her give her crown to her baby.
She escaped.
She raised an army.
She lost it.
And in May of 1568, she crossed the Solway in a fishing boat, landed on my shore, and wrote to me to ask for help.
If I sent her back, I told every lord in Europe that subjects may throw out their queens.
If I sent her to France, I gave my enemies a queen with a claim to my throne.
If I gave her an army, I went to war for a woman half of Scotland believed had helped murder her husband.
So I did the only thing left.
I kept her.
Comfortably, with servants, with her cloth of state over her chair, with her little dogs and her embroidery.
And with guards.
That was eighteen years and nine months ago.
In all that time, she and I have never been in the same room.
She has seen my face only on coins.
—
## Why I gave her the dullest man in England
For fifteen years, her keeper was the Earl of Shrewsbury.
He was kind to her.
That was the problem.
A kind keeper has a large household, and a large household leaks.
Letters went in and out in laundry, in the linings of gloves, in the covers of books.
And plots grew around her like mushrooms around a damp tree.
In 1570 the Pope told the world I was a heretic and that my Catholic subjects owed me nothing.
In 1571 a Florentine banker called Ridolfi planned an invasion to put her on my throne, with a duke of mine who wanted to marry her.
The duke was executed.
She was not.
In 1583 there was a young man called Francis Throckmorton, with a list of harbors where Spanish ships could land.
Bess, keep the camera still.
Bess’s cousin.
He was executed too.
Bess does not talk about it, and I do not ask her to.
Then, in the summer of 1584, in the Netherlands, a man walked up to the Prince of Orange on a staircase in his own house and shot him.
They say he was the first ruler in history to be killed with a pistol.
That autumn, thousands of my subjects signed the Bond of Association.
They swore that if anyone tried to kill me, for the benefit of anyone else, they would hunt down not only the killer but the person who would benefit.
They did not write her name.
They did not need to.
The next year my Parliament made a law to match it.
If a plot against my life was made for her, and she knew of it, she could be put on trial.
So now there was a rule.
What we did not have was proof.
That is when I gave her Sir Amias Paulet.
Paulet is a Puritan.
He does not dance, he does not drink, he does not flatter, and he does not smile at Scottish queens.
He had her laundry searched.
He stopped her giving coins to the poor at the gate, because a coin can carry a message.
He read every letter that came in by the front door and every letter that went out.
In a few months, my cousin was cut off from the world completely.
And on Christmas Eve of 1585, Paulet moved her from damp, cold Tutbury to a moated manor in Staffordshire called Chartley.
A house with a brewer.
—
## A young man lands at Rye with letters in his coat
In December of 1585, a young Englishman called Gilbert Gifford stepped off a boat at Rye, on the Sussex coast.
He was a Catholic from a Staffordshire family whose house was not far from Chartley, and he had been training for the priesthood abroad.
Walsingham’s men were waiting at Rye.
I do not know exactly what was said to Gilbert Gifford in the room they took him to.
Francis has never told me, and I have never asked, which is the arrangement Francis and I prefer.
I know only that Gifford went in a seminary student and came out a messenger who worked for us.
Francis calls this kind of conversation persuasion.
I call it Francis.
Gifford went to the French ambassador in London, a gentleman called Châteauneuf, and explained that he could get letters to the Queen of Scots safely.
The embassy had been holding a bundle of her letters that could not get past Paulet.
They were handed to Gifford.
Gifford handed them to Walsingham.
Walsingham read them, copied them, sealed them up again, and handed them back.
And Gifford rode to Staffordshire.
All that remained was to find a way into a house where Paulet searched the laundry.
They found it in the cellar.
—
## The beer that went in full and came out empty
Every week, a brewer from Burton came to Chartley with beer for the household.
Your water is safe, I am told.
Ours is not, so we drink beer at breakfast, beer at dinner and beer at supper, and a big house drinks a great deal of it.
The letters to her were folded very small, wrapped in a packet of leather so the beer would not get into them, and pushed through the bung hole into a full barrel.
The barrel went down into her cellar.
Her people fished out the packet and took it upstairs.
She read it, and she wrote back.
Her answers were wrapped the same way and pushed into an empty barrel, which the brewer took away with the other empties.
In the letters, the brewer has no name.
He is only called the honest man.
I enjoy that very much.
Because the honest man was being paid by her friends to carry her letters.
He was also being paid by us to bring every one of them to Paulet first.
And after a while, he told both sides separately that the work was more dangerous than he had expected and he would need more money.
They both paid.
In this whole story, my loyal subjects, he is the only person who came out of it richer.
So every letter to her came out of the barrel in Paulet’s house before it went into the barrel for her.
Every letter from her came out of the empty barrel in Paulet’s house before it went on to London.
It was opened, copied, and sealed again so carefully that nobody could tell.
When the first packet reached her, in January, after more than a year of silence, she must have thought the world had come back to her.
It had.
But the world had to pass through my Secretary’s desk first.
—
## The small man who could read anything
Her letters were not written in plain words.
They were written in cipher.
Instead of letters of the alphabet, there were symbols.
Some stood for single letters, some for whole words, like the Pope or Spain, and some meant nothing at all and were put in only to confuse a reader.
To her, it looked like a locked box.
To Thomas Phelippes, it looked like breakfast.
Phelippes is a short, thin, short-sighted man from a family of London customs officers, and he can read Latin, French, Italian and Spanish, and also, it turns out, my cousin.
He does not work quickly because he is clever.
He works quickly because he is patient.
He counts how often each symbol appears.
Some letters turn up far more often than others in any language, so the symbol that turns up most is probably one of those, and slowly the locked box opens.
The cipher was not weak.
She simply kept using it, for months, with the same habits.
Every letter she sent made the next one easier to read.
Another man, Arthur Gregory, could lift a wax seal off a letter and put it back so cleanly that the person who sealed it could not tell.
So now you have the whole machine.
A spy to carry.
A brewer to hide.
A jailer to catch.
A man to open the seals.
A man to break the cipher.
And at the top, in his black clothes, in his house in Seething Lane, the man who built it.
What was I doing all this time?
Nothing.
That was my part.
I had to sit at dinner with the French ambassador and smile while his own embassy was passing her letters.
And all that spring, every few weeks, a paper came to me from Seething Lane telling me what my cousin was writing to Spain and to Paris, and I read it, and I folded it, and I went in to supper.
What we did not have yet was the one sentence that mattered.
She wrote about rescue.
She wrote about invasion.
She never wrote, in plain words, that she agreed to my death.
Francis needed someone to ask her.
And in the summer, someone did.
—
## Twenty-four, handsome, and very bad at secrets
His name was Anthony Babington.
He was twenty-four years old, from a good Catholic family in Derbyshire, with money, friends, and the kind of face that makes older women at court say, what a pity.
As a boy, he had been a page in the Earl of Shrewsbury’s household, in the years when the Queen of Scots lived there.
He had grown up in the same house as the most romantic prisoner in Europe.
In the spring of 1586, a priest called John Ballard, who went about under the false name of Captain Fortescue in a fine cloak and a soldier’s hat, came to Babington with news.
Spain was ready.
All England needed was a few brave gentlemen.
And Babington, who had always wanted to be a brave gentleman, gathered his friends.
This was the plan, as it came out later, in their own words.
Foreign soldiers would land.
Catholic gentlemen would rise.
Babington himself, with a hundred men, would ride to Chartley and rescue the Queen of Scots.
And six gentlemen, his friends, would take care of me.
They did not plan a battle.
They planned a morning.
Six young men, close to me, at court, where young men with good manners are allowed to stand close to me every day of my life.
When Francis first showed me the names, I knew some of the faces.
I do not sleep well, my loyal subjects.
That summer I slept less.
At the beginning of July, Babington wrote a long letter to the Queen of Scots, in her own cipher, telling her everything.
The landing.
The rescue.
And the six gentlemen, who would see to the dispatch of what he called the usurper.
That is me.
I am the usurper.
He asked for her approval.
He put the letter into the leather packet.
The packet went into the barrel.
And the barrel went, as every barrel did, to Paulet first.
—
## The seventeenth of July
She did not answer at once.
Her two secretaries, Nau, who was French, and Curle, who was Scottish, sat with her for days while she drafted and changed things, and then they wrote it out fair and put it into cipher.
The answer was dated the seventeenth of July, 1586, at Chartley.
She tells him to make sure of the foreign help before anyone moves.
She suggests ways to arrange her escape while she is out riding, by overturning a cart in a gateway or setting fire to the barns.
And she tells him that when everything is ready, inside the realm and outside it, it will be time to set the six gentlemen to work, and to have her carried away at the same moment.
Set them to work.
That was the sentence we had been waiting for since Christmas.
The packet went into the empty barrel.
The barrel went to Paulet.
Phelippes, who by then was staying at Chartley to be closer to the letters, broke it the same day.
And before he sent his copy to Walsingham, he drew something on the outside.
A gallows.
A little gibbet, in ink, two uprights and a crossbar.
That was the whole message.
Now, I am going to tell you the part that people in your time like to argue about in the comments.
Before the letter went on to Babington, someone added a postscript at the bottom, in the same cipher, in the same style.
It asked Babington for the names of the six gentlemen.
She did not write that.
My people did.
They wanted the names.
Did I tell them to do it?
No.
Did I tell them not to?
Also no.
I am a queen who chooses her words very carefully, and the words I chose that summer were very few.
—
## The man who left without his cloak
Babington received the letter at the end of July.
And suddenly he understood that he was not in a poem.
He actually went to Walsingham’s people to ask for a passport to France, as if the safest place in England for a traitor were the office of the man hunting him.
In the first days of August, my officers arrested Ballard, the priest in the fine cloak.
Babington was at supper in a tavern that week, as it happens, with one of Walsingham’s own men, who was there to keep an eye on him.
During supper a note came in.
Babington saw enough of it.
He stood up, smiled, said he would go and pay the bill, left his cloak and his sword on the chair, and walked out into the street.
He did not pay the bill.
He ran with a few friends into St. John’s Wood, north of the city, and they hid among the trees.
They cut off their hair.
They rubbed the juice of green walnut husks into their faces and hands, so they would look like men who worked in the fields instead of gentlemen who danced at court.
Then, hungry, they walked to Harrow and knocked at the door of a Catholic family they knew, at a house called Uxendon, and were hidden in a barn.
And somewhere in those days, somebody in that neighborhood looked at these brown, cropped, nervous laborers with their soft hands and their London voices, and said something to somebody.
They were taken in the middle of August.
When the news reached London, the bells of every church rang, and people built bonfires in the streets.
I was told that people were dancing.
For me.
I am fifty-three years old, I have been queen for twenty-eight years, and I still do not know what to do with my face when I am told that people are dancing for me.
That same week, my cousin was invited out riding.
She went gladly.
She thought perhaps it was the rescue.
Instead, a gentleman rode up with an escort and took her to another house, called Tixall, where she was kept for more than two weeks.
While she was gone, Paulet’s men went through her rooms at Chartley.
Her secretaries were taken to London.
When she came back, her rooms were bare.
In September, Babington and thirteen others were tried and found guilty of high treason.
They were executed on two days, seven men each day.
I will not describe the punishment for treason in England.
You do not want me to, and I do not want to.
I will tell you only that the first day was so cruel that the crowd, which had come to cheer, went quiet.
When I heard that, I sent an order for the second day.
They were to be dead before anything else was done.
Even a frightened queen can choose not to be a cruel one.
And that left only her.
—
## A trial in a hall that smelled of wet wool
At the end of September they moved her to Fotheringhay Castle in Northamptonshire, a big, gray, cold place on a river, with a great hall.
In the middle of October, more than thirty of my lords, judges and councillors rode there to try her.
At first she refused to come.
She said she was an anointed queen, and no subject of mine, and that no court of mine could judge her.
That is exactly what I would have said.
In the end she came, because she was told that if she did not speak, they would judge her anyway.
There was a chair with a cloth of state above it, empty, to stand for me.
She was put on a smaller chair beside it.
She had no lawyer.
She had no papers.
She had no secretaries, because both of them were in London, and both had already told my people what they knew.
For two days she argued alone with some of the cleverest men in England, in a cold hall, and she did it well.
She said she could not answer for what other men wrote to her.
She said that copies were not originals, and that a cipher can be made to say anything.
She said that she had never wanted my death.
My Secretary, Walsingham, stood up in that hall and called on God to witness that, as a private man, he had done nothing unworthy of an honest one.
He thought it needed saying.
At the end of October, my commissioners met again, at Westminster, and found her guilty.
I am told only one of them had doubts.
Then the paper came to me.
And I did nothing with it for more than three months.
—
## The paper I did not want to sign
You must understand what they were asking me to do.
Not to kill a traitor.
England kills traitors every year.
They were asking me to kill a queen.
A woman anointed with holy oil, as I was.
If I do this, what have I told the world about queens?
That they can be tried.
That a piece of paper and a few dozen lords can end them.
And what is to stop the next Parliament, in the next country, from doing the same to the next queen?
I am a queen too.
My Parliament came to me in November and begged me to sign.
I made them a speech.
I told them that we princes are set on stages, in the sight and view of all the world.
And then I sent them away without an answer.
In December, I allowed the sentence to be proclaimed in London.
The bells rang again.
Still I did not sign.
The French king sent an envoy to plead for her life.
Her son James, King of Scots, twenty years old, sent envoys too, and wrote to me himself.
He was asking for a mother he had not seen since he was ten months old.
I read his letters very carefully.
They were the letters of a young man who wanted to do his duty, and who also wanted very much to be King of England one day, and who was trying to find the sentence that would do both.
I know that kind of letter.
I have written them.
All through January I walked these galleries and could not sleep.
On the first of February, here at Greenwich, my Lord Admiral, Charles Howard, came to me in the morning and told me, kindly but very plainly, that the realm could not go on like this.
I sent for my secretary, William Davison.
—
## The first of February
Davison is a good man.
I want you to remember that I said that.
He is an honest Protestant and a careful clerk, and he had been one of my Secretaries for only a few months.
He came in with a pile of papers for me to sign.
And in that pile, somewhere in the middle, was the warrant.
I knew it was there.
I asked for it.
I read it.
I asked for ink.
I signed it.
I will tell you something I have never told anyone, because you are not here and you cannot tell anyone either.
My hand was steady.
I was surprised.
Then I told Davison to take it to the Lord Chancellor for the Great Seal.
And I made a little joke, about how the news would be the death of Walsingham, who was sick at home.
Davison did not laugh.
Davison never laughs.
And then I said something else.
I said that perhaps there was a way to do this that did not need a queen’s name on a paper.
I said that perhaps Paulet, who had sworn the Bond of Association like everyone else, might find his own way to protect me, quietly, at Fotheringhay.
Davison did not like that either.
But a letter went to Paulet that evening, saying it for me, in politer words.
Paulet wrote back the very next day.
He said that his life and his goods were at my service.
And then he said God forbid that he should make so foul a shipwreck of his conscience as to shed blood without law or warrant.
So foul a shipwreck of his conscience.
The dullest man in England.
The man I chose because nothing could move him.
And nothing did.
Not even me.
I also respect him more than almost any man in this kingdom, and I will deny I said so.
The next morning I sent for Davison and asked him whether the warrant had been sealed.
He said yes.
I asked him what the hurry was.
He did not know what to say.
He went to Lord Burghley.
Burghley called the council together, ten of them, in his rooms.
And those ten men decided, among themselves, to send the warrant to Fotheringhay at once and not trouble me with it again, because if they asked me again, I might say no.
They knew me very well.
A clerk called Robert Beale, Walsingham’s brother-in-law, who has no love for her at all, rode north with it.
Nobody told me.
On the fourth, I told Davison that I had dreamed she was dead.
I do not know why I said that.
I do not know if I was asking him something.
On the seventh, I told him again that something ought to be done.
The paper was already at Fotheringhay.
—
## Fotheringhay, eight o’clock in the morning
I was not there.
I will tell you what I have been told, by men who were, and I will not tell you more than they told me.
On the evening of the seventh of February, the Earls of Shrewsbury and Kent arrived at Fotheringhay and asked to see her.
They read the warrant to her.
They told her it would be the next morning.
She thanked them for the news.
They say she was very calm.
She asked for her own chaplain and was refused.
She ate her supper.
She drank to her servants and asked them to forgive her if she had ever been unkind.
She divided her money and her rings and her clothes among them, writing it all down herself so there would be no quarrels.
And at two o’clock in the morning she sat down and wrote a letter, in French, to her brother-in-law, the King of France, asking him to pay her servants’ wages and to have Masses said for her soul.
Then she lay down on her bed in her clothes, and did not sleep, and her women read to her.
At about eight o’clock, they came to her door.
She went down to the great hall.
There were about three hundred people in it.
There was a fire burning at one end of the hall, because it was February.
There was a low platform in the middle, hung with black cloth, and a chair, and a cushion.
She came in slowly, because her legs had been bad for years, leaning on two of Paulet’s men.
She was dressed all in black satin, with a long white veil, and she carried a crucifix and a little book of prayers.
They say she looked tired, and older than forty-four.
They also say she looked like a queen.
The Dean of Peterborough began to preach at her, and she told him she did not want to hear him, and when he went on anyway, she turned away and prayed louder, in Latin, so that his voice and hers filled the hall together.
Then she prayed in English, for the Church, for her son, and for me.
For me.
I have been told that more than once now, and every time I hear it I find something to look at in the corner of the room.
Then her two women helped her take off the black.
And underneath, everything was red.
A bodice and petticoat of deep red, and red sleeves.
She had chosen it.
Of course she had chosen it.
In her faith, red is the color of the martyrs, and she wanted three hundred people to remember that color for the rest of their lives.
They will.
Her women were weeping.
She told them not to.
She told them she was glad, because her troubles were ending.
One of them tied a white cloth embroidered with gold over her eyes.
She knelt.
And she was executed.
That is all I am going to say about that part, now or ever.
I will tell you one more thing, because it is the thing my people keep telling me, as if they cannot stop.
Afterward, they found that her little dog had followed her in, hidden in her skirts, and would not leave her, and had to be carried away.
Her motto, which she stitched into her embroidery during those eighteen years, was that in her end was her beginning.
I used to think it was a pretty thing to sew.
Now I think it was a promise.
And I think I do not like it.
—
## When the bells started, I was the last to know
The Earl of Shrewsbury’s son rode south with the news.
It reached London on the ninth.
And the bells began.
Every church in London.
Bonfires in the streets.
I heard the bells before anyone told me why.
When they told me, I was quiet.
And the next morning, I sent for Sir Christopher Hatton, and I told him that I had never ordered this.
I told him I had signed the paper so it would be ready if there were ever an invasion or a rising, and that it was never to have left Davison’s hands without my word.
I told him that my council had done this behind my back.
All of that is true.
It is also not the whole truth.
You may decide which part matters more.
Lord Burghley, who has served me for twenty-eight years, is not allowed into my presence.
He writes to me.
I do not answer.
I put the letters in a pile.
The pile is getting tall.
And Davison.
Davison is sick, they tell me, with palsy, and shaking.
This morning, while I was writing my letter, they took him to the Tower.
Bess, do not look at me like that.
Someone has to be seen to have done this without my word.
If it is not Davison, then it is the council.
If it is the council, then every king in Europe will say that the Queen of England’s ministers kill queens when they please.
I do not like that sentence.
So Davison goes to the Tower.
Today.
On a day that in your time, I am told, belongs to lovers.
You send each other flowers and little red hearts.
I send my secretary to the Tower.
We have different traditions.
—
## The letter to her son
Now.
I promised you.
You stayed.
Bess, come closer.
Hold it so they can see the paper but not the bottom of it.
This is the letter I wrote this morning, before the sun was up, to James, King of Scots, her son.
I wrote it with my own hand, because some things must not be written by a clerk.
My cousin Hunsdon’s youngest son, Robert Carey, is waiting downstairs in his riding boots to carry it north.
He does not know what is in it.
I will read you the beginning.
My dear brother, I would you knew, though not felt, the extreme dolor that overwhelms my mind for that miserable accident which, far contrary to my meaning, hath befallen.
That is how it begins.
That miserable accident.
Far contrary to my meaning.
I tell him that God and many others know how innocent I am in this.
I tell him that no fear of any living creature or prince would make me afraid to do what was just, or to deny it once it was done.
And then I tell him the sentence I have been turning over all morning.
I tell him that if I had meant it, I would never have laid it on other people’s shoulders.
There.
Now you know what I have written.
And now you must help me with the part I have not been able to decide.
Is it true?
I signed it with a steady hand and asked for the seal.
I also asked, the same day, whether Paulet could spare me the signature.
I also told Davison, after it was sealed, that he had been too quick.
I also told him, a few days later, that something ought to be done.
I meant every one of those things when I said it.
That is the trouble with being a queen.
Every sentence you say is an order, and you say a great many sentences in a day.
Some of you say this letter is the biggest lie I ever told.
Some of you say it is the truest thing I ever wrote, because I never wanted it to end the way it ended, on a cold morning, without my word.
You do not agree.
Neither do I.
Here is what I know.
She and I were the only two women in this island who knew what it is to wear a crown and be hated for it.
We wrote to each other for nearly twenty years.
We never once sat in the same room.
And this morning, for the first time in my life, I wrote to her son as the woman who ended her.
The letter will go into Robert Carey’s coat.
Not into a barrel.
I am told that when he reaches the border, the Scots will not let him in, and he will have to give it to men sent out to meet him, and wait in the cold to learn whether the king will even read it.
James will read it.
He will be angry, and then he will think about his pension from me, and about my crown, and he will decide, I think, that his mother would want him to be King of England more than she would want him to be angry with me.
And he will be right.
That is the worst part.
He will be right.
—
## Before you go
So that is how we caught her.
A spy, a brewer, a jailer, a man who could read anything, a boy who ran away from his supper, and a queen who did nothing for six months and then signed a paper in the middle of a pile.
Your comments tell me some things about what happens next, and I am going to say them out loud so that I know I have heard them.
You tell me that next month Davison will be fined ten thousand marks in the Star Chamber, that he will stay in the Tower until 1589, and that he will die poor, still saying he did nothing wrong.
He did nothing wrong.
You tell me that this summer she will be buried at Peterborough, with a royal funeral that I will pay for.
You tell me that her son will one day be King of England after all, and that the young man downstairs in his riding boots, Robert Carey, will be the one who rides to Scotland to tell him that I am dead, in less than three days, and that he will be very proud of it.
And you tell me that King James will bring his mother from Peterborough to Westminster Abbey, and lay her in my grandfather’s chapel, in a great white tomb.
And that he will put me in the same chapel.
On the other side.
In a slightly smaller one.
I am choosing not to have an opinion about the size of the tombs.
But in your time, she and I are finally under the same roof.
We just do not have to talk to each other.
That seems about right.
Now.
Your turn.
Tell me in the comments who should have gone to the Tower today.
Davison, who carried the paper?
Burghley, who sent it?
Or me, who signed it?
I read them all.
Follow this page, because I command it, and because next time I will show you something happier.
Probably.
And the barrel stays.
Francis will want it back.
He is not getting it.
Farewell, my loyal subjects.
—
## The Real History
This vlog is a first-person retelling: the camera, the comments, the barrel on the table and the queen’s jokes are invented, while the plot, the people, the letters and the dates come from the historical record.
**The day.** Elizabeth signed the warrant at Greenwich on 1 February 1587 after an audience with the Lord Admiral; William Davison’s later account is the main source for what she said that day and in the week after, including the dream on 4 February and the joke about the sick Walsingham (paraphrased here).
That she was still at Greenwich on 14 February is our assumption.
**Mary.** Mary Stuart became queen at six days old in December 1542, married the Dauphin in 1558, was widowed in 1560, lost Darnley at Kirk o’ Field in February 1567, married Bothwell, was forced to abdicate, and crossed the Solway into England in May 1568.
She and Elizabeth never met.
**The trap.** The Bond of Association (1584) and the Act for the Queen’s Safety (1585) followed the Throckmorton Plot and the killing of William of Orange.
Sir Amias Paulet became Mary’s keeper in 1585 and moved her to Chartley at Christmas.
Gilbert Gifford, intercepted on his return in December 1585, worked for Walsingham; letters went in and out in a waterproof packet through the bung of beer barrels from a Burton brewer called “the honest man” in the correspondence, who is reported to have raised his price with both sides.
Thomas Phelippes deciphered them; Arthur Gregory is traditionally named as the man who opened the seals.
**The letters.** Babington, a former page in the Shrewsbury household, wrote in early July 1586 of an invasion, a rescue and the “dispatch of the usurper” by six gentlemen.
Mary’s reply of 17 July 1586 approved the scheme; the article paraphrases its wording.
Phelippes drew a gallows on the deciphered copy, and a forged postscript asking for the six names was added before it went on (British Library, “the gallows letter”).
**The arrests.** Babington fled a supper with one of Walsingham’s men leaving his cloak and sword, hid in St. John’s Wood, cut his hair, stained his skin with walnut juice, and was taken near Harrow in mid-August; London rang bells and lit bonfires.
Mary was held at Tixall while her papers were seized.
Fourteen conspirators were executed on 20 and 21 September 1586, and Elizabeth ordered the second group spared the worst of the sentence.
**The trial.** Mary was tried at Fotheringhay on 14–15 October 1586, and sentenced at Westminster on 25 October; Lord Zouche is usually named as the one doubter.
“We princes… are set on stages” is from Elizabeth’s reply to Parliament in November 1586.
**The warrant.** Walsingham drafted, and Davison signed, the letter to Paulet and Sir Drue Drury suggesting a private solution; Paulet’s refusal of 2 February, with “so foul a shipwreck of my conscience,” is widely quoted.
The council under Burghley sent the warrant north with Robert Beale without telling her.
**The execution.** Mary was executed at Fotheringhay on 8 February 1587.
Her last letter, to Henri III, written about two in the morning, survives in the National Library of Scotland.
Witnesses describe the black gown removed to show red, her prayers for Elizabeth, the Dean of Peterborough, and the little dog; her motto “In my end is my beginning” is linked to her embroidery.
**Afterward.** Elizabeth blamed her council and kept Burghley from her presence for some weeks.
Davison was in the Tower by 14 February, fined ten thousand marks on 28 March 1587, released in 1589, and died in 1608.
Mary was buried at Peterborough in 1587 and moved to Westminster Abbey by James in 1612; Elizabeth lies in the north aisle of the Henry VII Chapel, Mary in the south.
**The letter to James.** Elizabeth’s letter of 14 February 1587 survives; its opening words are quoted above and the rest is paraphrased.
It was carried by her kinsman Robert Carey (one editor names his father, Lord Hunsdon), who was at first refused entry to Scotland.
**What is invented.** The barrel and Walsingham’s note, Bess, the frost, the reading of the letter on camera, and every line the queen speaks are our dramatization.