1543: Henry VIII Chose a Baby Queen as His Son’s Bride. When Scotland Backed Out, He Sent an Army
The nursery at Linlithgow Palace was kept warm that March, the way every royal nursery was kept warm in 1543, with a fire that was never allowed to go out and windows that were never allowed to open.
Outside, the loch beneath the palace walls was gray and still, and the wind off it was cold enough to make the guards stamp their feet.
Inside, an Englishman stood beside a cradle and waited.
His name was Ralph Sadler.
He was thirty-five years old, a careful, clever man who had learned his trade in the household of Thomas Cromwell, and he had been sent north by King Henry VIII with one task above all others.
He was to find out the truth about a baby.
The baby in the cradle was a little over three months old.
She was already a queen.
Her mother, a tall Frenchwoman named Mary of Guise, stood on the other side of the cradle, still in mourning black for the husband she had lost before the child was a week old.
For weeks, stories had been running between Edinburgh and London that the little queen was weak.
That she was sickly.
That she would not live long, and that any plan built on her was a plan built on sand.
Mary of Guise did not argue with the stories.
She turned to the baby’s nurse, a woman named Jean Sinclair, and asked her to unwrap the child.
The nurse began to undo the swaddling bands, one long strip of linen after another, while the English ambassador watched.
To unwrap one in front of a stranger, in March, in Scotland, was not a small thing.
It was a statement.
Here she is, the mother was saying.
Look for yourself.
Then tell your master what you saw.
Sadler looked.
That night, or soon after, he sat down and wrote to the King of England.
As his letter is usually quoted, he told Henry VIII that the child was “as goodly a child as I have seen of her age, and as like to live.”
It was a strange sentence for a diplomat to send to a king.
Why would the most powerful man in England need to know, in writing, whether a three-month-old girl in Scotland was healthy enough to grow up?
—
The answer was simple, and it would cost Scotland dearly.
Henry VIII had already decided that this baby was going to marry his son.
When the Scots agreed, and then changed their minds, he did not write angry letters.
He sent fleets and armies.
He ordered the capital of Scotland burned.
His soldiers would chase the child from palace to castle to a tiny island in the middle of a lake.
And forty-four years later, the daughter he had once declared illegitimate would sign the paper that ended the baby’s life.
But this story has one more thread running through it, and it is the strangest of all.
The Englishman who stood beside that cradle in 1543, the man who looked at the unwrapped baby and wrote “as like to live,” would see her again.
Not once, but over many months, four decades later.
And when he did, he would not be her guest.
—
## How did a baby become a queen at six days old?
The baby’s name was Mary Stewart, and she had been born at Linlithgow on December 8, 1542.
Her father was James V, King of Scots.
Her grandmother was an English princess.
That grandmother was Margaret Tudor, the elder sister of Henry VIII, who had been sent north at thirteen to marry James IV of Scotland and seal a peace between the two kingdoms.
The peace had not lasted.
Margaret’s husband had died fighting her brother’s army at Flodden in 1513.
So the baby in the Linlithgow nursery was Henry VIII’s great-niece.
She was also, after Henry’s own three children, one of the nearest living relatives to the English throne.
And by the time she was a week old, she had no father.
The year before, James had failed to come south to meet his uncle at York, and Henry had waited there for days, humiliated.
By the autumn of 1542, the two kings had drifted into war.
English raids had followed, and Scottish raids in answer.
On November 24, 1542, a Scottish army that had crossed the border near the Solway Firth was trapped between the river and a bog at a place called Solway Moss.
Hundreds of Scottish gentlemen and lords were taken prisoner, many of them without much of a fight.
James V was not on the field.
He took the news badly.
He withdrew to Falkland Palace in Fife, and there, in the first days of December, he took to his bed.
What exactly he died of is still argued over.
He was thirty.
According to a story told by the Scottish chronicler Robert Lindsay of Pitscottie, who wrote decades later, a messenger reached him at Falkland with the news that his wife had given birth to a daughter, not a son.
James is supposed to have turned his face to the wall and said that the crown of Scotland had come with a girl and would go with a girl.
“It came with a lass, and it will pass with a lass.”
It is a famous line, and it may never have been spoken.
But it captures how the news felt.
On December 14, 1542, James V died.
His daughter was six days old.
She was now Mary, Queen of Scots.
In London, Henry VIII heard the news and saw, at once, an opportunity that might never come again.
His own son, Prince Edward, was five years old.
The new Queen of Scots was a baby.
If the two of them married, the crowns of England and Scotland would one day sit on the heads of a husband and wife, and their children would rule the whole island.
Henry had the prisoners of Solway Moss in his hands.
He did not ransom them in the ordinary way.
Instead, many of them were sent home on a promise: that they would work in Scotland for the marriage, and for the king’s other wishes.
He was also, as everyone around him knew, a man who did not take no for an answer.
The question was what exactly he was going to ask for.
—
## What did the King of England really want?
Scotland in early 1543 was a kingdom without a grown ruler.
Someone had to govern for the baby, and the man who seized that role was James Hamilton, Earl of Arran.
Arran was the baby’s cousin and, after her, the next heir to the Scottish throne.
His great rival was Cardinal David Beaton, Archbishop of St Andrews, the most powerful churchman in Scotland and the strongest friend France had there.
Beaton was arrested in the first weeks of the regency.
Into this situation, Henry sent Ralph Sadler.
Sadler’s instructions, and the king’s letters that followed them, made Henry’s demands very clear.
He wanted the marriage.
But he did not want to wait.
He wanted the baby queen handed over and brought up in England.
The Scots who listened to these demands understood exactly what they meant.
The marriage was the polite word.
The thing underneath it was a takeover.
Sadler sent home report after report of what he heard in Edinburgh.
One of the most remarkable came from a conversation with Sir Adam Otterburn, a Scottish lawyer and diplomat, who spoke to the Englishman with unusual frankness.
As Sadler reported it, Otterburn asked him a question that went straight to the point.
If the English lad were a Scottish lass, and the Scottish lass an English lad, would England be quite so eager for this match?
And then, as Sadler’s letter is usually quoted, Otterburn warned him that the Scots were “a stout nation” that would never agree to have an Englishman as king of Scotland.
Even if every noble in the realm consented, he said, the common people, and “the stones in the street,” would rise against it.
Henry did not change his demands.
Still, the Scottish government needed peace, and in the summer of 1543 a compromise was reached.
On July 1, 1543, at Greenwich, English and Scottish commissioners signed two treaties.
One was a treaty of peace.
The other was a treaty of marriage.
Mary would marry Prince Edward.
She would stay in Scotland until she was ten.
Then she would go to England.
The two kingdoms would remain legally separate, and if the marriage produced no children, the union would end.
But it was, on paper, the thing he had wanted most.
His son would marry the Queen of Scots.
The ink on the treaties was barely dry when the baby was moved.
—
## Why was the baby moved in the middle of the summer?
Linlithgow Palace stood in open country between Edinburgh and Stirling.
It was not a fortress.
That summer, the people around Mary of Guise began to fear that the child might simply be taken: by English agents, by the “assured” lords, or by the governor himself, who had his own reasons to want the infant queen under his control.
On July 27, 1543, the Earl of Lennox rode to Linlithgow with a force of about 3,500 armed men.
They escorted Mary and her mother out of the palace and along the road to Stirling Castle.
Stirling stood on a great rock above the plain, with cliffs on three sides.
It was the safest place in Scotland to keep a child.
The baby was seven months old.
She would spend most of the next four years behind those walls.
On August 10, Sadler wrote again to Henry, this time from Stirling, describing a visit to the queen mother and the child there.
On September 9, 1543, the anniversary of the battle of Flodden, Mary was crowned Queen of Scots in the chapel of Stirling Castle.
She was nine months old.
The crown, the scepter, and the sword of state were held over and around her by the great lords of the realm, because there was no way for a baby to hold them herself.
An English report sent south afterward described the ceremony with a certain sniff.
It had been done with such solemnity, the writer said, “as they do use in this country, which is not very costly.”
There is a tradition, repeated in many books, that the baby cried through the whole ceremony.
Whether by chance or by design, the date carried a heavy meaning.
Thirty years earlier, on that same day, her grandfather James IV had fallen at Flodden, fighting an English army sent by Henry VIII’s government.
Now the Scots were crowning his granddaughter on the anniversary, under the protection of a cardinal who had just been released from captivity and a governor who had just changed sides.
Because in the days around the coronation, Arran had done something that stunned the English.
He had gone over to Cardinal Beaton.
In London, Henry VIII began to understand that his marriage was slipping away.
—
## How long did the promise last?
Five and a half months.
That was the lifetime of the Treaty of Greenwich.
Through the autumn of 1543, tension grew along the border and at sea.
English ships seized Scottish merchant vessels.
Sadler, the man who had once watched the baby being unwrapped, now found himself living in a city where he was hated, and he wrote home that he did not feel safe.
On December 15, 1543, the Parliament of Scotland formally renounced the treaties with England.
The reason given was the seizure of the Scottish ships.
The same Parliament renewed Scotland’s old alliance with France.
Five days later, on December 20, an English herald named Henry Ray, Berwick Pursuivant, rode into Edinburgh and declared war.
The baby queen was a year and twelve days old.
Henry VIII was fifty-two.
He was heavy, he was in pain from the ulcer on his leg, and he was furious.
He had been promised a daughter-in-law, and the promise had been broken in public.
When it came, it was written down.
—
## What exactly did the king order his army to do?
On April 10, 1544, Henry’s Privy Council sent instructions to the commander of the army being gathered for Scotland.
That commander was Edward Seymour, Earl of Hertford, the brother of the king’s late wife Jane Seymour and the uncle of Prince Edward, the boy the baby queen was supposed to marry.
The army was to go to Edinburgh and burn it.
As the order is usually quoted, the town was to be “razed and defaced” after it had been sacked, so that there might remain “a perpetual memory of the vengeance of God” upon the Scots for their falsehood and disloyalty.
Leith, the port of Edinburgh, was to be sacked and burned as well.
Holyrood, the abbey and palace at the foot of the town, was to be destroyed.
There were further orders, harsh ones, about anyone who resisted.
The king also wanted St Andrews, the cardinal’s city, treated the same way, but Hertford argued that it was too far, and on that point he got his way.
In the first days of May 1544, a great English fleet appeared in the Firth of Forth.
On May 3 and 4, the army began to come ashore at Granton, just west of Leith.
Leith fell quickly, and the English made it their base.
Then they marched on Edinburgh.
The castle on its rock, with its heavy guns, held out, and the English could not take it.
But the town below the castle could not hold out at all.
The army broke into the streets, took what could be carried, and then set the houses on fire.
According to the English accounts of the campaign, all the houses within the walls and in the suburbs were burned, including the palace of Holyroodhouse and the abbey beside it, where Scottish kings were buried and Scottish queens had been crowned.
The fire burned for days.
When the army finally withdrew, it went south overland, burning as it went.
Thirty miles to the northwest, in Stirling Castle, the Queen of Scots was seventeen months old.
Her household would have watched the sky toward Edinburgh, and the riders coming in with news, and counted how many miles of road lay between the English army and the rock where the child was kept.
The army did not come to Stirling that spring.
But nobody in that castle could have known it would not.
—
## Who called it a “wooing”?
Later historians gave this war a name that sounds almost like a joke.
They called it the Rough Wooing.
The phrase grew out of a remark attributed to George Gordon, Earl of Huntly, one of the great lords of the Scottish north.
In an old French account of the war, later translated into English, Huntly is reported to have said that the Scots “liked not the manner of the wooing.”
What they could not tolerate was a suitor who came to propose with fire.
Writers in later centuries, Sir Walter Scott among them, made the idea famous, and by the middle of the 1800s “the Rough Wooing” had become the standard name in history books.
Behind it were burned towns, ruined abbeys, and years of misery on both sides of the border.
And the war was only beginning.
In February 1545, at Ancrum Moor near Jedburgh, a Scottish force caught an English raiding army off guard and defeated it.
Later that year, Hertford came north again, and this time it was the Borders that suffered.
The great abbeys of the region, centers of prayer and learning for centuries, were raided and burned, and their ruins still stand today in the green valleys of the Tweed.
In May 1546, Cardinal Beaton was murdered in his own castle at St Andrews by a group of Fife lairds.
In the summer of 1547, a French fleet arrived, battered the castle into surrender, and carried the defenders off to France.
Among the men taken was a preacher named John Knox, who would spend the next months rowing in a French galley.
He would meet the little queen again, many years later, and he would not be kind to her.
But by the time the French guns fell silent at St Andrews, the man who had started this war was dead.
—
## Why didn’t the war end when the king did?
Henry VIII died in the early hours of January 28, 1547, at the Palace of Whitehall.
He had not lived to see his son marry the Queen of Scots.
His son, Edward VI, was nine years old.
The boy’s uncle, the Earl of Hertford, the same man who had burned Edinburgh, made himself Lord Protector of England and Duke of Somerset.
And Somerset did not give up the marriage.
In the late summer of 1547, he led a new English army north along the coast, with a fleet sailing beside it.
On September 10, 1547, near Musselburgh, east of Edinburgh, the English met a large Scottish army at a place called Pinkie Cleugh.
Exposed to English cavalry, artillery, and the guns of the ships offshore, the Scottish army broke.
What followed was a disaster for Scotland.
Thousands of Scots lost their lives that day, and many more were taken prisoner.
But the battle was remembered in Scotland as “Black Saturday.”
It was the last great pitched battle ever fought between the armies of Scotland and England.
And it left a very practical question hanging over the people who guarded the queen.
The English army was now inside Scotland, close to Edinburgh, with no Scottish army left in front of it.
Stirling was strong.
But was it strong enough?
The queen was four years and nine months old.
Within days of Pinkie, her guardians decided that she could not stay where everyone knew she was.
She had to disappear.
—
## Where do you hide a queen?
Twenty miles west of Stirling, among low wooded hills, lies a small, quiet stretch of water called the Lake of Menteith.
In the middle of it is an island, and on the island, in 1547, stood a small priory of Augustinian canons.
The priory was called Inchmahome.
It had a church with tall pointed windows, a cloister, a chapter house, a few buildings for the canons, and gardens running down toward the water.
It could be reached only by boat.
There was no bridge.
Anyone who wanted to cross the water would have to come in plain sight across the lake, and the island was close enough to the Highland edge that a party could slip away northward if they had to.
Sometime in September 1547, the little queen was brought there.
Her mother came with her, according to most accounts.
So, very probably, did the small group of children who would be her companions for most of her childhood.
There were four of them, and every one of them was called Mary: Mary Beaton, Mary Seton, Mary Fleming, and Mary Livingston.
History would remember them as the Four Marys.
Picture the crossing.
A boat pushed off from the shore in the early autumn, with the trees on the hillsides just beginning to turn.
The water was still and dark.
The children sat low in the boat, wrapped in cloaks against the cold coming off the lake.
Ahead of them, the gray stone of the priory church came slowly closer, its windows catching the light.
On the shore behind them, men watched the road.
She had been a queen for as long as she could remember, which meant that she had been bowed to, dressed in silk, and surrounded by adults who spoke in low voices about things she was not told.
She would not have known that the boy she was supposed to marry was nine years old and living in London, or that the army hunting for her belonged to his uncle.
The canons of Inchmahome took the royal party in.
Later generations told stories about her time there.
A small garden on the island, laid out with box hedges, came to be called Queen Mary’s Bower, and visitors were told that the child queen had played there and planted it herself.
There is no evidence for that, and the garden as it exists today is much later.
But the stories show how strongly people wanted to picture her there: a little girl running among hedges on an island, while her country burned on the far side of the hills.
She did not stay long.
Most historians agree she was on the island for no more than about three weeks.
The English army, after Pinkie, did not march on Stirling.
It occupied places along the coast and in the Borders instead, and began building forts to hold the country down.
When it became clear the danger had shifted, the queen was taken off the island and moved again.
But the English were now staying.
They had taken the town of Haddington, east of Edinburgh, and were turning it into a fortress.
Every month the queen remained in Scotland, she was a prize within reach.
Her guardians made a choice that changed the rest of her life.
They would send her out of the country.
Not to England.
To France.
—
## How did Henry’s war send her the other way?
The French had their own price.
In the summer of 1548, a French army landed at Leith.
On June 16, about ten thousand French troops came ashore and began to besiege the English fortress at Haddington with heavy guns.
In early July, in the nunnery outside Haddington, the Scottish lords agreed to a new marriage for their queen.
She would not marry Edward of England.
She would marry Francis, the Dauphin, the eldest son of King Henry II of France.
And she would go to France at once, to be brought up at the French court.
It was precisely what Henry VIII had demanded for England in 1543: the child handed over, raised abroad, married to a foreign heir.
The Scots had refused it to the English king who demanded it with armies.
They gave it to the French king who came to help them.
The queen was moved to Dumbarton Castle, on a great rock beside the River Clyde, on the west coast, far from the English fleet in the Forth.
French ships came round the north of Scotland to fetch her, under the command of a French captain named Nicolas de Villegagnon.
On August 7, 1548, Mary, Queen of Scots, sailed from Dumbarton.
She was five years old.
The Four Marys went with her.
So did her governess, Lady Fleming, the mother of Mary Fleming and a half-sister of the queen’s own father.
Her mother stayed behind.
Mary of Guise would govern Scotland in the years to come, first beside Arran and later in her own right, and she would see her daughter only once more, during a long visit to France.
About a week or more after leaving Dumbarton, they reached the coast of Brittany, at Roscoff or nearby Saint-Pol-de-Léon.
The little queen stepped ashore in France.
She would not see Scotland again for thirteen years.
The war her great-uncle had started went on without her.
The English fortress at Haddington held out until September 1549, and then the English abandoned it.
Peace between England and France in the spring of 1550 brought the fighting close to an end, and on June 10, 1551, the Treaty of Norham formally closed the war between England and Scotland.
Eight years of burning, raiding, and fighting had begun with a marriage contract.
They ended with the bride living in France, engaged to someone else.
Henry VIII had wanted the Queen of Scots in England.
His war had done more than anything else to send her to his enemies.
And yet he would get her in England in the end.
Just not in the way he had imagined.
—
## What happened to the bride and the groom?
Edward VI never married anyone.
He died at Greenwich in the summer of 1553, at fifteen.
By 1558, Henry’s younger daughter, Elizabeth, the child of Anne Boleyn, was Queen of England.
In France, the little Queen of Scots grew up to be tall, graceful, and greatly admired.
On April 24, 1558, in the cathedral of Notre-Dame in Paris, she married the Dauphin Francis.
Little more than a year later he was King of France, and she was Queen of France as well as Queen of Scots.
Because she was the granddaughter of Margaret Tudor, she also had a strong claim to the English throne, and to many Catholics in Europe, who did not accept that Henry’s marriage to Anne Boleyn had ever been lawful, she had a better claim than Elizabeth.
Then, in December 1560, Francis died.
At eighteen, the Queen of Scots was a widow with no husband and no mother, and in August 1561 she sailed home to a kingdom that had turned Protestant while she was away.
John Knox, the preacher who had been taken from St Andrews in chains, was now its loudest voice.
Her years as an adult queen in Scotland lasted less than seven.
They included a second marriage, to her cousin Henry Stuart, Lord Darnley, the son of Henry VIII’s niece Margaret Douglas.
They included the birth of a son, James, in 1566.
In 1567 she was forced to give up her crown to her baby son.
In May 1568, after a last defeat at Langside, she rode south and crossed the Solway Firth in a fishing boat, into England.
She was twenty-five.
She expected her cousin Elizabeth to help her.
Instead, on May 18, 1568, she was taken into custody at Carlisle Castle.
She had finally come to England.
She would never leave it.
—
## Who was waiting for her in the castle?
For the next nineteen years, the Queen of Scots lived as a prisoner of Henry VIII’s daughter.
She had servants, furniture, embroidery, and a small court of her own.
She had no freedom.
Elizabeth’s ministers watched her with growing fear.
For most of those years, her keeper was the Earl of Shrewsbury.
But in 1584, the earl was finally allowed to step down, and the queen needed a new guardian.
The man chosen was old by the standards of the age.
He was seventy-seven.
He had served Henry VIII, Edward VI, and Elizabeth.
He had sat in Parliament, ridden with the English army to Pinkie, and held high office.
His name was Sir Ralph Sadler.
Forty-one years earlier, he had stood beside a cradle at Linlithgow and watched a nurse unwind the swaddling bands from a three-month-old queen.
Now that queen was a woman of forty-one, troubled by pain in her limbs, and he was her jailer.
Sadler took charge of her at Wingfield Manor in Derbyshire in 1584 and moved her to Tutbury Castle in Staffordshire, a cold, damp place she hated.
By the usual account, he was not a harsh keeper.
He was a reluctant one.
He is said to have let her ride out with hawks, and he was rebuked by Elizabeth’s secretary, Sir Francis Walsingham, for giving her too much liberty.
In April 1585, he was finally replaced by Sir Amias Paulet, a stern Puritan who kept the queen far more strictly.
Whether Sadler and Mary ever spoke of Linlithgow, nobody recorded.
But both of them knew.
He had been sent, at the very beginning, to see whether she would live.
At the end, he had been sent to make sure she stayed where she was.
Under Paulet, the queen’s letters were secretly intercepted, read, copied, and passed to Walsingham.
In 1586, a young Catholic gentleman named Anthony Babington wrote to her about a plan to free her and to put Elizabeth to death.
Mary wrote back.
Walsingham’s men had the reply in their hands within days.
In September 1586, the Queen of Scots was moved to Fotheringhay Castle in Northamptonshire.
In October, she was put on trial there before a commission of English lords and officials.
She denied that they had any right to judge an anointed queen.
“Look to your consciences,” she told them, “and remember that the theatre of the whole world is wider than the kingdom of England.”
On October 25, 1586, she was found guilty.
All that remained was a signature.
—
## What happened in the last eight days?
For more than three months, Elizabeth did not sign.
She was being pressed from every side.
Parliament wanted the sentence carried out.
Her council wanted it carried out.
Her ministers warned her that as long as the Queen of Scots lived, there would be plots, and one of them might succeed.
But Elizabeth knew what it meant for one anointed queen to put another to death.
And she was being asked to do it to her cousin, the granddaughter of her father’s sister.
On February 1, 1587, at Greenwich, the queen finally sent for the warrant.
The man who brought it to her was William Davison, one of her secretaries.
She signed it.
According to Davison’s later account, she spoke to him about it in a way that was not quite an order and not quite a refusal, and she let him take the signed paper away.
He took it to have the Great Seal attached.
What Elizabeth meant to happen next has been argued about for more than four hundred years.
What is known is what her council did.
On February 3, ten members of the Privy Council met, summoned by Lord Burghley, without telling the queen.
They agreed that the warrant should be sent at once and the sentence carried out before she could change her mind.
The clerk of the council, Robert Beale, rode north with the paper.
Forty-four years earlier, Henry VIII had wanted the baby at Linlithgow as a bride for his son.
Now a paper signed by Henry VIII’s daughter was on its way to Fotheringhay.
On the afternoon of Tuesday, February 7, 1587, two earls arrived at the castle: George Talbot, Earl of Shrewsbury, her keeper for so many years, and Henry Grey, Earl of Kent.
They asked to see the Queen of Scots.
She received them in her chamber.
The warrant was read aloud to her.
She was to die the next morning.
According to the accounts of the people in the room, she listened calmly.
She crossed herself.
She said that she was glad to leave a world in which she had suffered so much, and that she was ready to die for her faith.
She asked for her own chaplain, and was refused, and offered a Protestant clergyman instead, whom she refused in turn.
Then the earls left her, and she had one night.
She did not sleep much of it.
She ate a light supper with her household and drank to them, and they knelt and drank to her.
She went through her belongings, the clothes, the jewels, the little things she still owned after nineteen years of captivity, and set aside what each servant was to receive.
She wrote her will.
And in the small hours of the morning, she wrote a letter to King Henry III of France, the brother of the young husband she had lost in 1560.
In that letter, she told him that she was to die the next day, that she had been condemned for her religion, and she commended her servants to his care.
She asked him to pay their wages and to have prayers said for her soul.
The letter still survives in Scotland.
Toward dawn, she lay down on her bed fully dressed.
Her women watched over her.
Some of them later said that she did not sleep, but lay with her eyes closed, her lips moving in prayer.
The morning of Wednesday, February 8, was cold.
Below her rooms, in the great hall of Fotheringhay, men had been working since the night before.
At one end of the hall a wooden platform had been built, about two feet high, and draped in black cloth.
On it stood three stools, one for the queen and one each for the Earls of Shrewsbury and Kent, and a cushion on which she would kneel.
A fire burned in the great hearth.
Gentlemen from the surrounding counties had been allowed in to watch, and they stood in the body of the hall behind a rail.
Sometime around eight o’clock, a messenger came to her door.
She was ready.
She had chosen her clothes with great care.
Over a petticoat and sleeves of deep crimson-brown velvet, the color of martyrdom in the Catholic Church, she wore a gown of black satin trimmed in black, with a long white veil that fell to the floor behind her.
She carried a crucifix and a prayer book.
A rosary hung from her girdle.
She was too lame by then to walk easily on her own, and she leaned on the arms of two of Paulet’s men as she went down.
At the foot of the stairs, she met her steward, Andrew Melville, a Scotsman who had served her for years.
He knelt and wept.
She told him not to grieve, but to rejoice, because the troubles of the Queen of Scots were coming to an end.
She asked him to carry a message to her son: that she had done nothing against the kingdom of Scotland, and that she died in her faith.
Then she asked the earls to let her women come with her.
They hesitated.
She insisted.
Two of them were allowed: Jane Kennedy and Elizabeth Curle.
The doors of the great hall opened.
The Queen of Scots walked in.
A hall full of English gentlemen turned to look at her, and many of them, by their own later accounts, did not know where to look.
She crossed the floor slowly, with her head up.
She climbed the steps and sat on the stool set out for her.
The warrant was read aloud once more, the long legal words echoing in the hall.
She listened as if it concerned someone else.
The Dean of Peterborough tried to preach to her, and she told him she would not hear him, and she prayed in Latin aloud while he prayed in English, the two voices rising together until his gave way.
She forgave, aloud, everyone who had brought her to this place.
Then her women helped her prepare, and they wept, and she told them in French not to weep, because she had promised for them that they would be brave.
Jane Kennedy took a white veil embroidered with gold and tied it over her eyes.
The queen knelt on the cushion.
She spoke her last words in Latin, the words of the psalm she had chosen.
“In manus tuas, Domine, commendo spiritum meum.”
Into your hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit.
The hall was silent.
Before the morning was over, Mary, Queen of Scots, was dead.
She was forty-four years old.
—
## What did Henry’s daughter do when she heard?
The news reached Elizabeth within days.
London rang its bells and lit bonfires in the streets.
The queen did not celebrate.
When she was told, she is said to have broken down, and then turned, in fury, on the men who had done it.
She insisted she had never meant the warrant to leave Davison’s hands.
She said her council had acted without her authority.
William Davison was arrested and sent to the Tower of London.
He was tried before the Star Chamber, found guilty of misprision, and fined a huge sum.
He was released about nineteen months later, after Burghley and Walsingham spoke for him, but his career was finished.
To the end of her life, Elizabeth would insist that the death of the Queen of Scots had happened against her will.
Whether she believed it, nobody knows.
And Ralph Sadler?
The man who had stood beside the cradle in 1543 did not live long after the hall at Fotheringhay.
He died at his home in Standon, in Hertfordshire, on March 30, 1587, about seven weeks after the woman he had first seen as a baby being unwrapped by her nurse.
He was nearly eighty.
He was one of the very few people in England who had known the Queen of Scots at the beginning of her life and at the end of it.
His letter of 1543, the one that told Henry VIII the child was “as like to live,” survives among his papers.
She had lived.
She had lived for forty-four years, nineteen of them as a prisoner of England.
And the plan Henry VIII had started a war to achieve was about to come true anyway.
—
## Did Henry VIII get what he wanted in the end?
On March 24, 1603, Elizabeth I died at Richmond Palace.
She had never married, and she had no children.
The heir to the throne of England was the son of the Queen of Scots.
James VI of Scotland rode south and became James I of England.
It was exactly the union Henry VIII had wanted when he demanded the baby at Linlithgow as a bride for his son.
It had come not through the marriage he fought for, but through the woman he had tried to take by force, and through the son she had with a different husband.
Henry’s own children all died without heirs.
Hers would rule England, Scotland, and later Great Britain, and every monarch since 1603 descends from her.
In 1612, James had his mother’s body taken from Peterborough Cathedral, where she had been buried in the summer of 1587, and carried to Westminster Abbey.
He built her a magnificent tomb in the Lady Chapel of Henry VII, Henry VIII’s father, a few yards from the tomb of Elizabeth.
The two queens never met in life.
They are closer to each other now than they ever were.
As for the places in this story, they have gone very different ways.
Linlithgow Palace, where she was born, was gutted by fire in 1746 and stands roofless today, though its great courtyard fountain has been restored.
Fotheringhay Castle was abandoned and pulled down within a few generations, and today only a grassy mound and a few fragments of stone mark the place by the River Nene where the great hall once stood.
And the island priory of Inchmahome is still there, in the middle of the Lake of Menteith.
Its church has no roof now.
In summer, a small ferry crosses from the shore, and visitors walk among the ruins, past the box hedges of the garden people still call Queen Mary’s Bower.
It is hard to believe that a whole war once ended up at that small island, carried by a frightened household and a four-year-old girl.
At Linlithgow, in March 1543, a nurse unwrapped a baby, and an Englishman wrote that she looked as like to live as any child he had seen.
He was right.
She lived.
Henry VIII simply could not make her live the life he had chosen for her.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
This is a true story, told from the historical record; some scenes are described with details of setting and weather, but the events, dates, and people are real.
**Documented:** Mary’s birth at Linlithgow on December 8, 1542, and her father’s death on December 14.
Sadler’s visit in March 1543, when the nurse Jean Sinclair unwrapped the baby at Mary of Guise’s request.
The Treaties of Greenwich (July 1, 1543), their renunciation by the Scottish Parliament (December 15, 1543), and the declaration of war (December 20).
The move to Stirling on July 27, 1543, and the coronation on September 9.
The Privy Council’s instructions of April 10, 1544, and the burning of Edinburgh, Leith, and Holyroodhouse in May.
Pinkie (September 10, 1547), the weeks at Inchmahome, the sailing from Dumbarton (August 7, 1548), and the Treaty of Norham (1551).
Sadler’s time as Mary’s keeper in 1584–85 and his death on March 30, 1587.
The warrant signed on February 1, 1587, the council meeting of February 3, and the death of the Queen of Scots on February 8, 1587.
**Wording that varies:** Sadler’s “as goodly a child … and as like to live,” Otterburn’s “stones in the street,” and the “perpetual memory of the vengeance of God” are given as they are usually quoted; printed editions differ slightly.
**Tradition or legend:** James V’s “It came with a lass” (from Pitscottie, written decades later).
The baby crying at her coronation.
Huntly’s “manner of the wooing” (reported in a later French history).
“Queen Mary’s Bower” at Inchmahome.
Sadler letting her go hawking comes from secondary accounts.
**Uncertain:** exactly what Elizabeth meant Davison to do with the warrant; the exact times and numbers of people at Fotheringhay; whether Sadler and Mary ever spoke of their first meeting.
This article deliberately does not describe the execution itself.