“Free Her!” The Nameless Gunslinger Sneered At The Most Feared Timber Crew In Arizona… They Laughed Until The Snow Came Down
The snow in the pines that morning was so deep and so quiet that the woman between the two trees could hear her own heartbeat.
She could hear the four men breathing, too.
She could hear the creak of their leather coats and the squeak of the snow under their boots, and somewhere far off a raven, and the soft hiss of snow sliding off a branch and falling into more snow.
Her name was Viola.
She was twenty-nine years old.
Her wrists were roped to the trunks of two big ponderosa pines, high and wide, so that her arms were spread out like the arms of a scarecrow.
Her ankles were roped to the same two trunks, low down, so that she stood with her feet wide apart in the snow and could not bring them together.
She wore a dress of smoked buckskin, fringed at the shoulders and the hem, with a red leather belt, and fur-lined moccasins, and a band of dark leather laced around one leg just below the knee, and her black hair hung down over her shoulders, and every time she breathed out, her breath went up in a white cloud between the trees.
She had been standing there for an hour and a half.
The four men stood around the two pines.
The one in charge was a gray-bearded man with a black hat and a dark red scarf, and he leaned against the right-hand pine with one gloved hand flat on the bark, the way a man leans on a gatepost, and he had been asking her the same two questions since sunrise.
Where is the government man.
Where is his book.
She had not answered either one.
“The cold’ll ask you better than I can,” he said.
“I’m a patient man. The cold is more patient than me.”
That was when a man walked out of the trees behind them.
He came on foot, leading a horse, a broad-shouldered man in a long oilskin coat the color of wet bark, with a sheepskin collar turned up against the cold and a black hat pulled down, and he stopped in the snow twenty feet away and stood there, looking at the woman between the trees.
The four men turned.
The woman lifted her head and looked past them at the stranger, and her breath smoked when she spoke.
“Keep walking, mister. There are four of them.”
The stranger did not keep walking.
“Free her,” he said.
It was eight miles southwest of Flagstaff, Arizona Territory, on Thursday, the fourteenth of January, 1886, in the deepest snow anybody on the railroad had seen since the town began.
The four men laughed.
They had no way of knowing that the thing they had been trying to freeze out of her all morning had been within arm’s reach of them the whole time.
Or that by Saturday noon she would take it out, in a warm room in Flagstaff, in front of a federal commissioner and the man who had sent them, and lay it on the table where everybody could read it.
—
## Why would anyone tie a woman between two pines in January?
To understand the morning in the pines, you have to understand the stumps.
They were everywhere south of Flagstaff that winter, thousands upon thousands of them, wide and flat and pale, each one with a cap of snow on it like a tablecloth on a table.
Four years earlier, the land had been one of the largest unbroken forests of ponderosa pine on earth, mile after mile of huge, red-barked, sweet-smelling trees standing far apart in open grass, so that a rider could see a quarter mile through them in any direction.
Then the railroad came.
The Atlantic and Pacific Railroad reached Flagstaff in the summer of 1882, building west across the territory toward California, and a railroad eats timber.
It needs ties, twenty-five hundred of them for every mile of track, and bridge timbers, and station lumber, and fuel.
Mills went up along the line almost as fast as the rails did.
Crews of cutters went out into the pines with axes and crosscut saws, and teams of oxen dragged the logs out to the mills, and the mills sawed them into ties and lumber and loaded them onto flatcars.
Some of that cutting was lawful.
A great deal of it was not.
Like most of the western railroads, the Atlantic and Pacific had been granted the odd-numbered sections of land along its line, every other square mile, laid out like the black squares on a checkerboard.
The even-numbered squares in between still belonged to the United States.
The timber on the railroad’s sections was the railroad’s to sell.
The timber on the government’s sections was not anybody’s to cut.
But a section line is an invisible thing in the middle of a forest.
It exists only on paper, and on the little stone mounds and blazed trees that the government surveyors had left at each corner, years before.
And a timber crew paid by the tie does not stop to look for corner stones.
Viola knew where every one of those corner stones was.
She was Havasupai.
Her people lived at the bottom of the great canyon of Cataract Creek, west of Flagstaff, in a green place of waterfalls and peach orchards and blue-green water that very few outsiders had ever seen.
In the summers they farmed the canyon floor.
In the winters, for longer than anybody could remember, they had climbed up onto the high plateau above it to hunt deer and gather piñon nuts among the trees.
The plateau had been theirs.
In 1882, a stroke of a pen in Washington had drawn a new line around the Havasupai, and the line ran around the canyon floor and nothing else.
The plateau went to the government, and the railroad, and anybody who could get a deed.
Viola’s family still went up to the plateau in winter.
Nobody had told the deer about the line.
When she was a girl, her father had packed supplies for the government survey crews who came through the country to lay out the section lines, and Viola had gone with him, three summers running, and carried chains and stakes and water, and watched the surveyors set their corner stones and cut their marks into the bearing trees.
She had a memory for country that her father said came from her grandmother.
Once she had seen a place, she did not lose it.
The traders in Flagstaff called her Viola.
Her own name was in her own language, and she did not give it to men who would only say it wrong.
She spoke good English, better Spanish, and enough Hopi and Navajo to trade.
She guided for surveyors and land men in winter, when the canyon farms were quiet, for a dollar and a half a day, which was more than most men in Flagstaff were paid.
And in December of 1885, she had been hired by the one man in Arizona that the Coconino Tie and Timber Company most wanted to see dead.
—
## The government man who counted stumps
His name was Gilman Toller.
He was sixty-one years old, thin and stooped, with a white mustache and steel spectacles and a cough he had brought with him from Washington, and he did not look like the most dangerous man in the territory.
He was a special agent of the General Land Office.
In 1885, a new commissioner of the Land Office in Washington had decided that the timber thieves on the public lands of the West had been getting away with it for too long, and he had begun sending special agents out to count what had been taken.
Toller had been sent to Flagstaff.
He arrived on the train in the first week of December, took a room at the hotel, asked a great many polite questions at the mills, and then went to the trading store and asked who in the country knew the old corner stones.
They sent him to Viola.
“I need to know where the section lines are,” he told her, through the steam of a cup of coffee in the back of the store.
“Not on the map. On the ground. And then I need to count every stump on the wrong side of them.”
“All of them?”
“Every one.”
She looked at him for a while.
“It’s going to snow soon,” she said.
“Big snow. You’re not a young man.”
“No,” Gilman Toller agreed.
“Which is why I should like to start tomorrow.”
They started the next day.
For five weeks, through December and into January, the two of them worked their way across the cutover land south and west of Flagstaff, on horseback and on foot.
Viola found the corners.
Some of them were still where the surveyors had left them: a mound of stones, a stake, a pine blazed with numbers.
Some had been knocked down or buried.
Some of the bearing trees had been cut, and she found those corners by the stumps, and by the lay of the land, and by her memory of a summer when she was eleven.
At each corner, Toller wrote down what she showed him.
Then they walked the section, back and forth, in lines thirty paces apart, and counted stumps.
He kept the tallies in a small black field book with a leather cover.
He signed and dated every page.
At night, in whatever shelter they could find, he copied the totals into a fair hand, section by section, page by page, coughing over his pencil by the light of the fire.
By the first week of January, the field book held the numbers.
Four thousand, one hundred and eighteen stumps of ponderosa pine on the government’s sections.
Every one of them cut by crews of the Coconino Tie and Timber Company.
Every one of them sawn into railroad ties and sold to the railroad at forty cents a tie, by a man named Pierce Ludlam, who had come to Flagstaff from Albuquerque in 1882 with a sawmill on two flatcars and owned, by 1886, a great deal of the town.
“It’s enough,” Toller said, on the night of the ninth of January, folding his spectacles.
“It’s more than enough. Two more sections, to be sure of the boundary on the west side, and I’ll go down to Prescott and swear it out before the court.”
Viola was looking at the sky.
“Tomorrow,” she said, “we don’t go anywhere.”
But they did.
—
## What happened at the stone cabin on Cedar Tank
The storm came in on the tenth, out of the southwest, and it snowed for two days and two nights without stopping.
They were caught in the open on the west side, eleven miles from Flagstaff, when it began.
Viola turned them toward a sheepherder’s cabin she knew of, a little stone hut with a brush roof beside a rock tank called Cedar Tank, and they were within a quarter mile of it when Toller’s horse went down on the ice at the edge of a draw and rolled.
It rolled over the old man’s leg.
When Viola got to him, the horse was dead at the bottom of the draw with its neck broken, and Gilman Toller’s left leg was broken below the knee, and his saddlebags were under the horse, in the bottom of a ravine filling up with snow.
His field book was in the saddlebags.
She got him to the cabin.
She never could explain afterward exactly how she did it, in the dark, in a blizzard, with a man who could not stand.
She splinted the leg with two pieces of a broken chair and strips of her own blanket.
She got a fire going in the stone chimney.
She went back out into the storm twice for wood, and once, with a rope, down into the ravine, where she dug for an hour in the drifts under the dead horse until her hands would not work, and found nothing.
The field book was gone under the snow.
When she came back, Toller was sitting up against the wall by the fire, gray-faced, with his coat open, and something in his hands.
It was a sheaf of papers, folded once.
“My fair copies,” he said.
“The totals. Every section. I keep them in my coat.”
He tried to smile.
“Old clerk’s habit. Never carry the original and the copy in the same bag.”
There were twenty-two pages, in his small neat hand, each one signed and dated.
“These are enough?” she asked.
“With my testimony, they’re enough. Without me—” He coughed, and it went on for a long time.
“Without me, they’re a list of numbers in a dead man’s handwriting, and a good lawyer will say I made them up in a hotel room.”
“You’re not going to die.”
“I would prefer not to,” Gilman Toller said.
“But I have enough wood for three days, and one leg, and Mr. Ludlam’s crews have been looking for me since the week before Christmas. One of the clerks at his mill saw me counting. If they find me before anybody else does, I believe I will have an accident in the snow. And if they find these,” he held up the pages, “I believe the pages will have an accident in the stove.”
He put them in her hands.
“Get them to Flagstaff,” he said.
“There is a United States commissioner there named Pomfret who can take a sworn complaint. Wire Prescott for a deputy marshal. And send somebody back for me, if you can.”
Viola looked at the pages for a long time.
Then she did something he did not expect.
She sat down by the fire, unlaced the band of dark leather she wore on her left leg below the knee, and took it off.
Under it was a strip of old, soft flannel.
She had worn the band since she was nineteen, when she had fallen on the rocks in the canyon and torn something in the knee that never quite healed, and every trader in Flagstaff had seen it, and nobody had ever given it a second look.
She folded the twenty-two pages flat, in two thin packets, and wrapped them around her leg over the flannel, and laced the leather band back on over them, tight.
“Men search bags,” she said.
“They search saddles. They search blankets. A man doesn’t search an old woman’s sore knee.”
“You’re not an old woman.”
“I will be,” Viola said, “by the time I get to Flagstaff.”
—
## Why she let them tie her
The storm blew out on the morning of the twelfth.
She left Toller with wood for two more days, all the food they had, and a promise, and she walked six miles through drifts to her family’s winter camp on the rim of a side canyon, where her brother Charley and two of her cousins were hunting deer.
She told them where the cabin was.
She told them to take the sled at first light on Thursday and bring the old man down to the camp, slowly, by the long way round, through the rocks where no horse could follow, and keep him warm, and keep him hidden, and not let any white man near him until she came back with a federal officer.
Then, at dawn on Thursday, she rode out alone on her brother’s pony for Flagstaff, with twenty-two pages laced against her knee.
The company men were waiting on the Flagstaff road.
There were four of them: Duff Hallam, the woods boss, gray-bearded, in a red scarf; a big, slow Swede named Ivar Lundgren, who drove the ox teams; a sharp-faced cutter named Jett Kibbe; and a young sawyer named Shep Sallee in a green scarf, who had come out from Missouri the year before and was learning the business.
They knew who she was.
Everybody in Flagstaff knew who had been guiding the government man.
They pulled her off the pony.
They went through her saddlebags and her blanket roll and the pony’s saddle blanket, and slit the lining of her coat, and found two pounds of jerked venison, a knife, a tin cup, a box of matches, and nothing else.
“Where is he?” Duff Hallam asked her.
She did not answer.
“Where’s the book?”
She did not answer that either.
Hallam was not, by the standards of Flagstaff, a cruel man.
He had never killed anybody.
He did not, then or later, lay a hand on her in anger.
He was simply a man who had been told by the man who paid him that if the government’s agent came out of the snow alive with his numbers, the Coconino Tie and Timber Company was finished, and Duff Hallam’s job with it.
He looked at the two big pines beside the road, standing eight feet apart in the snow.
“Tie her between those,” he said.
And Viola, who could have lied to them, and sent them off in the wrong direction, and been let go, let them do it.
She understood, as they roped her wrists and ankles to the two trunks, exactly what she was doing.
Every hour she stood between those pines was an hour in which four of Ludlam’s best men were standing around in the snow on the Flagstaff road, and not up on the west side, looking for a stone cabin by Cedar Tank.
Every hour was another mile for Charley’s sled.
She had done the arithmetic before they finished the first knot.
She thought she could last until about two in the afternoon.
At half past ten, the man in the oilskin coat walked out of the trees.
—
## The two words he would not say twice
“Free her,” the stranger said.
Duff Hallam took his hand off the pine.
He looked the stranger up and down: the long, worn coat, the sheepskin collar, the hat, the revolver in a plain holster on the right hip, the ordinary brown horse with a bedroll and a rolled-up poncho tied behind the saddle.
He did not look like a lawman.
He did not look like anything in particular.
He looked like a man who had been walking through snow for a long time.
“Friend,” Hallam said, almost kindly, “you’re a long way from wherever you’re from. This is company business.”
The stranger did not answer.
“She stole from the company,” Hallam went on.
“We’re waiting for her to tell us where she put it. That’s all. Nobody’s hurting her.”
The stranger did not answer that either.
He did not say it again.
That was what all four of them remembered afterward, and what Shep Sallee told the commissioner, and what people in Flagstaff told each other for years.
He did not say it again.
He just stood there, in the silence where the words had been, and let the silence say it for him.
Ivar Lundgren, who was a head taller than any man in the company and had never in his life been told what to do by a man on foot, laughed out loud.
“You hear that, Duff?” he said.
“He says free her.”
Jett Kibbe laughed too.
Shep Sallee laughed because the others did.
Duff Hallam did not laugh.
He was watching the stranger’s eyes, and the stranger’s eyes were not on any of them.
They were on the branches above them.
The big pines on that stretch of the road were old trees, a hundred feet tall, and their lower limbs reached out over the road in long dark arms, and two days of snow had built up on every one of those limbs, a foot deep, two feet deep, packed and heavy and leaning.
Viola saw where he was looking.
So did Hallam, a second too late.
“Ivar—” he said.
Lundgren had started forward across the snow toward the stranger, big and slow and grinning, pulling off his gloves.
“Mister,” he said, “you want her loose? You come and loose her.”
“Hold still, ma’am,” the stranger said quietly, to Viola.
Then his right hand moved.
Viola said afterward that she never saw him draw.
One moment his hand was hanging empty at his side and the next there was a single flat, enormous crack that rolled away through the forest and came back off the hills, and thirty feet above the heads of the four company men, a pine limb as thick as a man’s thigh, which had been holding up half a ton of snow, split at the trunk.
It did not fall at once.
It sagged.
It groaned.
Ivar Lundgren stopped walking and looked up, with his mouth open.
Then the limb let go, and the snow on it let go, and the snow on every limb below it, knocked loose as the big branch came down through them, let go too.
It came down on the four men like a wall falling.
For a moment there was nothing on that side of the road but a roaring white cloud, rolling outward through the trees, glittering in the sun.
When it settled, Ivar Lundgren was buried to the chest.
Jett Kibbe was sitting in it, spitting snow.
Shep Sallee had vanished completely except for one green-scarfed arm waving above the drift.
And Duff Hallam, who had been standing against the trunk and had caught the least of it, was on his knees with snow down his collar and his hat gone, and when he looked up, the stranger’s revolver was back in its holster, and the stranger was already walking past him to the two pines.
Their horses were gone, all four, bolting down the Flagstaff road at a dead run with their stirrups flying.
The stranger took a knife from his coat.
He held it low, and in plain sight, and he cut the rope at Viola’s right wrist, and then at her left, and caught her by the arm while her own arms came down and the blood came back into them so painfully she could not stop the sound she made.
He cut the ropes at her ankles.
He did not look at anything but the rope.
She spoke through her teeth.
“They want the government man. They won’t get him.”
“No,” the stranger agreed.
“I don’t believe they will.”
Duff Hallam got to his feet in the snow.
“You don’t know what you’re doing,” he said hoarsely.
“You don’t know who you’re crossing.”
The stranger looked at him for a moment.
He said it without raising his voice.
“I said it once. I don’t repeat myself.”
Then he turned his back on Duff Hallam, which was the most insulting thing he could have done, and helped Viola up onto her brother’s pony, which had not bolted, because it was a Havasupai pony and had been raised among rockfalls.
“Unbuckle your gun belts,” he said over his shoulder.
“Leave them on the stump there. You can get them back from the commissioner in Flagstaff.”
They unbuckled their gun belts.
“It’s eight miles to town,” the stranger said.
“If you start now, you’ll be there before dark. Walk single file. It’s easier.”
—
## Where she led him, and who was waiting
She did not ride toward Flagstaff.
“West,” she said, as soon as they were out of sight of the road.
“The government man. They’ll have another crew out looking. I need to know my brother got him.”
“Toller,” the stranger said.
She turned in the saddle and stared at him.
“You know him.”
“He wired me in December,” the stranger said.
“From Flagstaff. One line. *If you have not heard from me by the tenth of January, come.*” He shrugged inside the oilskin coat.
“I didn’t hear from him. I came. Got off the train from Albuquerque on Tuesday into the worst snow I ever saw, and found his hotel room paid up and empty and half of Ludlam’s crews out riding the country. Followed four of them out this morning. They led me to you.”
“And who are you?”
“Brannigan,” he said.
“Cyprian Brannigan. Toller and I go back.”
“How far back?”
He was quiet for a while, riding through the deep snow under the pines, his breath smoking.
“Canyon Diablo,” he said finally.
She knew the name.
Everybody on the railroad did.
In 1881, the Atlantic and Pacific had built as far as the great gorge of Canyon Diablo, east of Flagstaff, and then stopped for the better part of a year while the bridge was built across it, and a town of tents and shacks had grown up at the end of the track that was said to be the worst place on the whole line.
She did not ask anything else.
They reached the family’s winter camp at four in the afternoon, as the light went orange on the snow.
There was a fire going outside the brush shelter.
Charley was sitting beside it with a rifle across his knees, and when he saw his sister riding in with a strange white man, he stood up fast and brought the rifle up.
Then he saw her face and lowered it.
Inside the shelter, on a pile of deer hides, wrapped in blankets, with his leg splinted and his spectacles crooked, lay Gilman Toller, alive.
He opened his eyes when the stranger stooped in through the doorway.
He looked at Cyprian Brannigan for a long moment, and then at Viola, and then back at Brannigan.
“You took your time,” he said.
“Snow,” said Brannigan.
“I was told you were a man who didn’t let snow stop him.”
“You were told a lot of things,” Brannigan said, and sat down on his heels by the hides, and took the old man’s hand, and held on to it.
—
## The book that Ludlam burned
Pierce Ludlam did not wait for his woods boss to finish walking back to town.
By the time Duff Hallam and his three men stumbled into Flagstaff after dark on Thursday, frozen and furious and without their guns, Ludlam had already heard from the riders who caught the bolting horses, and he had already been to see his lawyer, and he had already been to see the United States commissioner.
He had also, though nobody knew it yet, already received a package.
On Wednesday, one of his crews searching the west side for the government man had found a dead horse in a ravine near Cedar Tank, under the drifts, with a pair of saddlebags still buckled to it.
In the saddlebags was a small black field book with a leather cover.
They brought it to Ludlam.
Ludlam read it through once in his office at the mill, page by page, every section, every corner, every count, in Gilman Toller’s small, neat, signed hand.
Then he opened the door of his office stove and put it in.
He told his lawyer about it on Thursday night, because he believed it was over.
“No book,” he said.
“No case. The old man’s lying in the snow somewhere with a fever, and if he ever comes down, it’ll be his word, and he’s a sick old clerk from Washington who’s been out in the woods with an Indian woman for five weeks. Who’s going to believe a list of numbers he can’t produce?”
“And the woman?”
“Is a thief,” Pierce Ludlam said.
“And so is the man who took her. I want them both charged.”
On Friday morning, he filed a complaint before Commissioner Edgar Pomfret, charging that a Havasupai woman known as Viola had stolen company property, and that an unknown armed man had assaulted four employees of the Coconino Tie and Timber Company on the Flagstaff road, taken their weapons, and stolen their horses.
The horses, at the time, were in Ludlam’s own stable.
Commissioner Pomfret, a cautious, white-whiskered man who had been a schoolteacher in Ohio and had never got used to the West, set a hearing for Saturday at noon.
At ten o’clock on Saturday morning, a deputy United States marshal named Sam Avila came into Flagstaff on a lathered horse, having ridden ninety miles up from Prescott through the snow since Thursday noon, because somebody had wired him on Thursday at dawn.
Nobody at the telegraph office could remember who.
Only that he had worn a long oilskin coat, and had paid in coin, and had sent only one line.
*Toller missing in snow. Ludlam crews hunting him. Come Flagstaff. Bring irons.*
—
## Saturday noon in Commissioner Pomfret’s office
The hearing was held in the front room of the commissioner’s house on Railroad Avenue, because it was the only room in Flagstaff with a stove big enough to heat it.
By a quarter to twelve, every chair was taken and men were standing three deep along the walls.
Pierce Ludlam sat at the front, beside his lawyer.
He was a big, smooth, well-fed man of forty-five in a beaver coat, with a diamond in his tie and a pleasant, easy, reasonable face, and he nodded to the people he knew, which was most of them.
Behind him sat Duff Hallam, Ivar Lundgren, Jett Kibbe, and Shep Sallee, scrubbed and sullen, in their Sunday coats.
Deputy Marshal Avila stood by the door with his arms folded.
At noon exactly, Commissioner Pomfret came in, sat down at his table, put on his spectacles, and looked at the complaint.
“The respondents,” he said.
“Are they present?”
The door opened.
Cold air came in, and snow, and four Havasupai men carrying a stretcher made of two lodgepoles and a deer hide, and on the stretcher, wrapped in blankets, gray and thin and wide awake, lay Gilman Toller.
Behind them came Viola.
Behind her came the man in the oilskin coat, and he closed the door, and leaned against the wall beside it, next to Deputy Avila, and did not say a word.
The room had gone completely silent.
Pierce Ludlam’s pleasant face did not change at all.
Only his hands moved, a little, on the head of his walking stick.
The Havasupai men set the stretcher down in front of the commissioner’s table.
Toller raised himself on one elbow.
“Gilman Toller,” he said, in a thin, clear voice.
“Special Agent, General Land Office. I wish to swear out a complaint, Mr. Commissioner, against Pierce Ludlam and the Coconino Tie and Timber Company, for the cutting and removal of timber from the public lands of the United States. Four thousand, one hundred and eighteen trees.”
Ludlam’s lawyer was on his feet.
“Mr. Commissioner, this is irregular. My client has filed a complaint, and this—”
“I’ll take both,” said Commissioner Pomfret, who was looking at the old man on the stretcher with an expression nobody in Flagstaff had ever seen on him before.
“Mr. Toller. What is your evidence?”
“My field book,” Toller said.
Pierce Ludlam smiled.
It was a small smile, and he hid it at once, but half the room saw it.
“I’m told,” said Ludlam’s lawyer smoothly, “that Mr. Toller had an accident in the storm. That his horse was killed. That he lost his saddlebags. Is that correct, Mr. Toller? Can you produce this field book?”
Toller lay back on the stretcher.
“No,” he said.
“I cannot.”
There was a murmur all along the walls.
Ludlam’s lawyer spread his hands.
“Then, Mr. Commissioner, what we have is the word of a sick man who has been lying in an Indian camp with a fever for four days, and some numbers he says he wrote down in a book nobody can find. And we have, on the other side, my client’s complaint against this woman—”
“I can produce the numbers,” Viola said.
Everybody turned.
She was standing beside the stretcher in her buckskin dress and her fur-lined moccasins, with her black hair braided now, and the rope marks still dark on both her wrists.
Her voice was not loud.
It did not need to be.
The room had gone so quiet that the snow could be heard ticking against the windows.
“Your men searched me, Mr. Ludlam,” she said.
“On the Flagstaff road. They searched my saddlebags and my blanket and my coat. They slit the lining. They didn’t find anything, and so they tied me between two pines and waited for the cold to make me talk.”
She looked at Duff Hallam.
“You stood beside me for an hour and a half,” she said.
“You leaned your hand on the tree. You could have reached out and touched it.”
Duff Hallam’s face had gone a dull red.
Viola sat down on the commissioner’s bench.
She bent, and unlaced the band of dark leather below her left knee, slowly, one crossing at a time, while the whole room watched, and took it off, and unwound from her leg two thin, flat packets of paper, folded once, slightly curved from the shape of the leg they had been wrapped around for four days.
She stood up and put them on the commissioner’s table.
“Twenty-two pages,” she said.
“Mr. Toller’s fair copies. Every section. Every corner. Every stump. He signed every page.”
Commissioner Pomfret unfolded the first page and held it to the window, and read it, and turned it over, and read the second.
Nobody in the room breathed.
“These are copies,” Ludlam’s lawyer said.
“Copies of a book that no longer exists. Anybody could have written—”
“Then we’ll go and count them again,” Viola said.
She turned around and looked at Pierce Ludlam.
“The stumps are still there, Mr. Ludlam. They’re under the snow, but the snow will melt. And I know where every corner is. I carried the chain for the men who set them, when I was eleven years old. I can walk the commissioner to every stone and every bearing tree you thought you’d cut down, and stand him at every stump on the wrong side of every line. All four thousand, one hundred and eighteen. It’ll take till June. I don’t mind. I have time.”
She paused.
“Do you?”
Pierce Ludlam stood up.
He did it slowly, leaning on his walking stick, and he buttoned his beaver coat, and he said, in his pleasant, reasonable voice, to nobody in particular, “I don’t believe I need to listen to any more of this.”
And he walked toward the door.
The man in the oilskin coat was leaning against the wall beside it.
He did not move to block the door.
He did not touch his gun.
He simply looked at Pierce Ludlam as the big man came toward him, and said, quietly, two words.
“Sit down.”
Ludlam stopped.
He looked at the stranger for the first time, really looked, at the long coat and the weathered face and the black hat, and something happened behind his eyes that he could not quite keep off his face.
And behind him, from the bench where the company men sat, Duff Hallam’s voice said, low and hoarse, “Mr. Ludlam. I’d do what he says.”
Ludlam turned his head.
“I didn’t know him on the road,” Hallam said.
“Not till he shot the branch. I was at Canyon Diablo, in eighty-one, on the grading crew. I saw him once before.”
He swallowed.
“That’s him, Mr. Ludlam. That’s the man they called the nameless gunslinger.”
Pierce Ludlam sat down.
—
## What happened at Canyon Diablo, and why he only said it once
Deputy Marshal Sam Avila told the rest of it, that night, to a room full of men at the hotel bar, because he had been at Canyon Diablo too.
In the summer of 1881, when the end of the track sat at the edge of the gorge for months waiting for the bridge, the railroad’s paymaster came out from Albuquerque with the monthly payroll for six hundred men, and he was a month late, and the money was short.
The graders did not believe the money was short.
They believed the paymaster had stolen it.
Two hundred of them, drunk on Canyon Diablo whiskey, dragged him out of the pay car and down to the half-built bridge, with a rope, meaning to hang him from the first timber span over the gorge.
The paymaster, years before he ever went to work for the Land Office, was a thin, stooped, bespectacled clerk named Gilman Toller.
A stranger in an oilskin coat, who had come in on the supply train that morning and had been sitting on a keg in the shade, got up and walked out onto the bridge timbers, and stood between Toller and the two hundred men, and said, “Let him go.”
That was all he said.
He stood there, with the gorge underneath him, and two hundred men in front of him, and he did not say it again, and he did not draw his gun, and after a while the men in front began to feel foolish, and the ones behind began to drift away, and the ones in the middle let go of the rope.
Toller had found the missing payroll a week later, in Albuquerque, stolen by a clerk in the railroad’s own office.
The railroad offered the stranger a reward.
He would not take it, and he would not give his name, and the men on the grading crews who had been there that day gave him the only name they had.
“He told me once why he never says a thing twice,” Avila said.
“He said if a man has to say a thing twice, he didn’t mean it the first time.”
—
## What the four thousand stumps were worth
Pierce Ludlam was charged before Commissioner Pomfret that afternoon, with the cutting and removal of timber from the public lands, and with conspiracy, and with the false imprisonment of a woman named Viola on the Flagstaff road.
Duff Hallam testified against him.
So did Shep Sallee, who had laughed on the road because the others did, and who had lain awake every night since, he told the commissioner, thinking about her breath smoking between the pines.
The federal government sued the Coconino Tie and Timber Company for the value of four thousand, one hundred and eighteen trees, and won, and the company did not survive the judgment.
Its mill was sold at auction in the spring.
Pierce Ludlam was convicted the following year and sent to the territorial prison at Yuma for two years.
Duff Hallam, Ivar Lundgren, and Jett Kibbe got six months each for the business on the road.
Shep Sallee got thirty days and went home to Missouri.
Gilman Toller’s leg healed crooked.
He limped for the rest of his life.
He went back to Washington in the summer and wrote a long report, which was printed, and which said, on its fourth page, that the evidence in the Flagstaff case had been preserved through the courage and intelligence of his guide, a Havasupai woman, and that the government of the United States owed her a debt.
The government did not pay it.
The plateau stayed on the wrong side of the line.
But in June, when the snow had gone off the cutover land south of Flagstaff, Viola walked Commissioner Pomfret and two government surveyors across every section in Gilman Toller’s twenty-two pages, from corner to corner, and stood them at every stump, and they counted, and the count came out the same.
Four thousand, one hundred and eighteen.
Her family went up onto the plateau that winter, and the winter after that, and every winter for as long as she lived.
Nobody told them they could not.
The men who might have told them had learned that she knew where every line in that country was, and exactly whose side of it they were standing on.
The man in the oilskin coat left Flagstaff on the eastbound train on the Monday after the hearing.
She went down to the depot to see him off.
He was standing on the platform in the snow, with his horse already loaded and his rolled poncho under his arm, and she stood beside him for a while without saying anything.
“Why did you look at the branches?” she asked him finally.
“On the road. Before you did it. Why not just shoot the big one?”
“Because you were standing between the trees,” Cyprian Brannigan said.
“And I’d sooner bury four men in snow than one in the ground.”
The train came in.
He picked up his bag.
“You only said it once,” she said.
“On the road. You never said it again.”
“Once was enough.”
“How did you know it would be?”
He looked at her, and for the first and last time she saw him almost smile.
“I didn’t,” he said.
“But you did. You’d been standing there an hour and a half, telling those men no without saying a word. I figured if you could do that, I could manage two.”
He got on the train.
Years later, when she was an old woman in the canyon, and her grandchildren asked her about the winter of the big snow, Viola would tell them about the government man and the twenty-two pages and the four thousand stumps.
But she always began the same way.
With the snow in the pines, so deep and so quiet she could hear her own heartbeat, and her breath going up white between the trees, and a stranger in a long coat walking out of the forest and saying two words.
“Free her,” she would say, “and then he never had to say anything again.”
—
## What is real in this story, and what is told
The people in this story are invented.
There was no Viola, no Gilman Toller, no Cyprian Brannigan, no Pierce Ludlam, and no Coconino Tie and Timber Company, and the hearing, the twenty-two pages, and the snow on the Flagstaff road belong to the story.
The setting is real.
The Atlantic and Pacific Railroad reached Flagstaff in 1882, and the great ponderosa pine forest around the San Francisco Peaks was logged heavily to supply ties, bridge timbers, and lumber; for a long stretch in 1881 and 1882 the end of the track stood at Canyon Diablo, east of Flagstaff, while a bridge was built across the gorge, and the camp that grew up there had a reputation as one of the roughest on the line.
Like other western land-grant railroads, the Atlantic and Pacific received alternate odd-numbered sections in a checkerboard pattern, and the even-numbered sections in between remained public land.
Cutting timber on public land without authority was illegal, and in the mid-1880s the General Land Office did send special agents west to investigate timber depredations.
The Havasupai are real, and so is their history: their homeland is in and around the canyon of Cataract Creek, a side canyon of the Grand Canyon; they traditionally farmed the canyon floor in summer and moved up onto the plateau in winter; a reservation set aside for them in 1880 was cut down in 1882 to a small area on the canyon floor; and much of the plateau was returned to the tribe by Congress in 1975.
Viola’s story is not their story.
It is a tale told against the backdrop of it.
The canyon and the plateau belong to the Havasupai.