News

“Fifty Dollars for This Old Guitar. It’ll Look Nice on a Wall.” — The Auctioneer Didn’t Know the Man in the Back Row Was Carlos Santana

The auctioneer lifted the lid of the guitar case the way you lift the lid of a cooler you suspect has been left in the garage too long.

Inside, on a bed of faded orange plush, lay an old electric guitar.

Its body was the color of butterscotch candy that had been left too long in a jar, worn through to pale wood along the edges, with a black plate on the front and a long, plain, yellowed neck.

The auctioneer lifted it out by the neck with two fingers and held it up so the room could see.

“Lot twenty-three, folks.”

He made a face.

“Old guitar. Seen better days.”

Somebody laughed.

He glanced down at the front row, at a very old man in a brown corduroy jacket sitting with his hands folded on the head of a cane, and added, in the same cheerful tone:

“Kind of like its owner.”

More people laughed.

The old man in the corduroy jacket did not.

He did not do anything at all.

“All right,” the auctioneer went on, “let’s start the bidding at fifty dollars. Fifty dollars, anyone? Come on. It’ll look nice on a wall.”

Forty-seven people sat in folding chairs in the old adobe hall.

Nobody raised a hand.

The auctioneer sighed into the microphone, theatrically, and reached for the next lot, a set of handmade ceramic bowls.

And from the very back row, where a man in a dark denim jacket had been sitting alone with a pair of sunglasses tucked into the collar of his T-shirt, came a single quiet word.

“Fifty.”

—

There were two people in that adobe hall who knew exactly what was lying in that guitar case.

One of them was the man in the back row.

He had recognized it from thirty feet away, before the case was even fully open, and his heart had started to beat in a way it had not beaten in a long time.

The other one was the old man in the front row, with his hands folded on his cane.

He had known for seventy years.

And he had decided, for a reason nobody in his town would understand until that afternoon was over, to say nothing at all.

—

## Why was a ninety-one-year-old man selling the only valuable thing he owned?

Cerro Viejo, New Mexico, is not on most maps.

It is a town of eleven hundred people in the high desert north of Albuquerque, a cluster of adobe houses and a gas station and a church with a bell that is rung by hand, where the wind comes down off the mountains in the afternoon and makes the cottonwood trees along the river sound like rain.

At the center of the town, across a dirt plaza from the church, is the community hall.

It was built of adobe brick in 1938, by hand, by the grandparents of half the people who now sat in it.

It had thick, cool walls the color of the hills, wooden beams across the ceiling, deep windows, and a hand-painted banner over the front door.

And every November, on the second Saturday, it held the charity auction.

People donated whatever they could spare.

Quilts.

Firewood.

Pies.

A rocking chair.

Every dollar went to keep the hall standing.

That year, the hall needed a great deal of keeping.

The roof had been leaking for three winters.

The heating had failed twice.

And the board that ran the hall had voted, five to two, that unless the auction brought in enough to fix the roof by spring, the back room would be leased out as an event space for weddings and the program that had used it every Saturday morning since 1968 would end.

The program was a free music class for the children of Cerro Viejo.

It had been started by a twenty-four-year-old music teacher named Abelardo Trujillo, with three borrowed guitars and an upright piano missing two keys.

Everybody in town called him Abe.

He taught at the school for forty-one years.

And for fifty-seven years, every Saturday morning, rain or shine, he unlocked the back room of the hall at nine o’clock and taught any child who walked through the door, for free, on instruments he paid for out of his own small salary.

Half the people in the folding chairs that afternoon had learned their first chord from Abe Trujillo.

Abe was ninety-one now.

His hands shook.

He walked with a cane.

He had not taught a class in two years.

But when he heard about the board’s vote, he did something nobody in town had expected.

He drove himself to the hall, in his thirty-year-old pickup truck, carrying an old brown guitar case.

He set it down on the table in front of the volunteers.

“For the roof,” he said.

“Start it wherever you like.”

Then he drove home.

The volunteer who took the case from him that morning was a woman named Inés Montoya.

She was thirty-seven, a nurse at the clinic in Española, and she had walked into the back room of the hall for the first time when she was seven years old, holding her older brother’s hand, because her mother could not afford lessons and had heard there was a teacher who did not charge.

She remembered that first Saturday the way you remember a birthday.

The room smelled of dust and old wood and the oil Abe rubbed into the floorboards every spring.

There was a bucket in the corner under the place where the roof leaked, even then.

Abe sat on a metal folding chair in front of a semicircle of children on the floor, with the butterscotch guitar across his knees, and before he taught anybody anything, he played them one song.

He always played one song first.

He said it was so they would know where they were going.

Inés remembered that the guitar looked old to her even then, and that Abe held it the way her grandmother held the baby Jesus from the church nativity set when she took it down every January, carefully, with both hands, as if it might wake up.

She learned three chords that first morning.

She came back every Saturday for nine years.

Now she stood at the volunteers’ table with Abe’s guitar case in her arms, watching his old pickup bump away across the dirt plaza, and she had the strangest feeling that she should open it.

She did not.

It was not hers to open.

She carried it to the back of the hall and set it down carefully among the quilts and the firewood and the pies, and wrote LOT 23 on a strip of masking tape, and stuck it on the handle.

Nobody had ever seen Abe without that guitar.

Nobody thought to ask what it was worth.

And the man who was going to auction it off had his own reasons for not caring at all.

—

## Why did the auctioneer want the music program to fail?

Neal Catterall had been the volunteer auctioneer at the Cerro Viejo hall for twelve years.

He was sixty-one, a retired insurance agent with gray hair, steel-rimmed glasses, and a blue button-down shirt he wore to every public occasion, and he was very good at it.

He knew how to work a room.

He knew how to make people laugh, how to make them feel generous, how to get a pie up to forty dollars by pretending to be scandalized when someone bid twenty.

He was also the chairman of the board.

He was one of the five votes.

Neal did not dislike children, and he did not dislike music.

What he disliked was arithmetic that did not work.

For years he had watched the back room of the hall sit empty six days a week so that a handful of kids could bang on guitars for two hours on Saturday morning, while a wedding planner from Española kept calling to ask whether she could rent it.

He had made the proposal himself.

He had won the vote.

And then Abe Trujillo had walked in with a guitar case, and suddenly half the town was talking about saving the Saturday program, as if it were a sacred thing and not a line item.

Neal did not say anything against it.

He was too smart for that.

He just listed it as Lot 23, near the end, after the people with money had usually gone home.

That afternoon, he was in excellent form.

He sold a hand-stitched quilt for ninety dollars by telling the room that the woman who made it had once sewn a button back onto his jacket during a funeral without him noticing.

He sold a cord of firewood twice, to two brothers who were not speaking to each other, and got both of them to laugh about it.

He got a green chile apple pie up to forty-five dollars, which was a record, and pretended to faint.

The room loved him.

That was the thing about Neal Catterall.

He could make forty-seven people feel like a family, and all the while he was steering them, very gently, exactly where he wanted them to go.

He had written out the card for Lot 23 himself, the night before.

Vintage guitar.

Starting price fifty dollars.

He did not open the case until he was standing at the table with the microphone in his hand.

And when he saw what was inside, a worn, yellowed, old-fashioned thing that looked like it had been through a fire, he felt a small, private satisfaction.

It was exactly what he had expected.

Old Abe’s guitar.

Fifty dollars, if they were lucky.

He did not see the man in the back row take the sunglasses out of his collar and put them in his pocket.

He was already reaching for the ceramic bowls.

—

## What was a man like that doing in the back row of a small-town auction?

He had come to Cerro Viejo by accident.

An old friend of his, a painter who had lived in the mountains above the town for thirty years, had a show opening at a little gallery on the road to Taos, and he had promised to come.

He arrived the night before.

On Saturday afternoon he was walking across the plaza looking for lunch when he saw the hand-painted banner over the door of the adobe hall.

He liked hand-painted things.

He liked small towns, and folding chairs, and pies with prices written on masking tape.

So he went in and sat down in the back row, in a dark denim jacket over a black T-shirt, his long hair pulled back, his sunglasses hooked into his collar.

Nobody looked at him twice.

For twenty minutes he watched the town of Cerro Viejo buy quilts and firewood from itself, and he was happy.

He noticed the old man in the front row early on.

It was hard not to.

Every person who came into the hall stopped at the end of the first row on their way to a seat, bent down, and said something to him.

A big rancher in a sheepskin coat took off his hat to do it.

Two teenage girls kissed him on the cheek, one on each side, at the same time, and he laughed and pretended to be scandalized.

A woman in a nurse’s scrubs crouched beside his chair and held his hand for a whole minute without saying anything at all.

The old man sat through all of it with his hands folded on the head of his cane and a look on his face that the man in the back row recognized, because he had seen it before, on the faces of old musicians at the end of very long careers.

It was the look of a man who is being thanked for his whole life, and is trying very hard to enjoy it, and is also, very quietly, saying goodbye.

The man in the back row did not know who he was.

He only knew that the whole room was turned toward him like flowers toward a window.

Then a volunteer carried in an old brown guitar case and laid it on the table.

He knew the case first.

That was the strange thing.

He had not even seen the guitar, and his heart was already going.

It was the shape of the case, the stitched leather on the corners, the faded brown covering, the particular style of latch.

There were not many cases like that left in the world.

They had come with a very particular guitar, made in a very particular place, in the very early years of the 1950s, when a few men in a small California workshop were building the first solid-body electric guitars anyone had ever sold to the public, and nobody yet knew that they were changing music forever.

Then the auctioneer opened the lid.

And the man in the back row saw the butterscotch body, and the black plate, and the plain yellowed neck, and every hair on his arms stood up.

He knew exactly what it was.

He had held one before, once, decades ago, in the back room of a collector’s house, and he had been almost afraid to play it.

There were very few left.

Most had been played to pieces in bars and dance halls in the fifties and thrown away when newer models came out.

The ones that survived with all their original parts were among the most valuable guitars on earth.

And the man with the microphone had just offered it to forty-seven people for fifty dollars, to hang on a wall.

He waited.

He waited to see if anyone in the room knew.

Nobody raised a hand.

So he did.

—

## What did he see when he held it in his hands?

“Fifty!”

Neal Catterall said it into the microphone with real relief, and a little surprise.

“We have fifty dollars from the gentleman in the back. Thank you, sir. Do I hear sixty? Sixty for a fine old wall decoration?”

Nobody bid sixty.

The man in the denim jacket was already standing up.

He walked down the center aisle between the folding chairs, unhurried, and stopped at the auction table.

“Excuse me,” he said politely.

“Before the bidding goes on, may I look at it? If that is permitted.”

Neal shrugged, still smiling for the room.

“Sure, sure. Take a look. Fair warning, it’s in pretty rough shape. But it’s got, uh, character.”

A few people chuckled.

The man took the guitar from him with both hands.

He did not hold it the way Neal had held it, by the neck, with two fingers.

He held it the way you hold something that is older than you are.

He turned it to the light from the deep windows and looked at the body.

He ran his thumb along the worn edge.

He turned it over.

On the back, the finish had been worn away completely in a broad oval where seventy years of a belt buckle and a stomach had rubbed against it, and the bare wood underneath had gone dark and smooth as a river stone.

He tilted the neck and sighted down it, one eye closed, the way a carpenter sights down a board.

He looked at the small metal plate where the neck met the body.

He looked at the screws.

He looked at the pickups and the bridge, and at the way the black plate on the front had shrunk very slightly with age and pulled away from one screw.

Every detail was right.

Every single one.

Neal Catterall watched him do this for about forty-five seconds, still smiling, and then the smile began to thin.

There were ceramic bowls waiting.

There were people at the back who wanted to go home.

He leaned in toward the stranger, close, his glasses catching the light, and spoke under his breath, not quite under enough.

“Sir, it’s a fifty-dollar guitar.”

The man did not look up.

He was looking at the headstock now, very closely, and his lips were pressed together under his moustache.

Neal tried again, a little louder, with a little laugh for the room.

“It’s not a museum piece, friend.”

The man in the denim jacket said nothing.

He turned the guitar slightly in his hands, and his eyes went, for just a moment, to the front row.

To the old man in the corduroy jacket with his hands folded on his cane.

Abe Trujillo was looking straight back at him.

Neal’s patience ran out.

He straightened up, tapped the microphone, and said, loudly enough for the whole hall to hear:

“Either bid on it or sit down.”

—

## Why did the stranger stop the auction?

The man in the denim jacket raised his head.

He took one slow breath.

Then he looked at Neal Catterall, and his face was calm, but his voice, when it came, carried to every corner of the adobe hall without his raising it at all.

“Stop this auction.”

Neal blinked.

“Excuse me?”

“Please,” the man said.

“Stop the auction. Right now.”

The hall went quiet.

Not a polite quiet.

The real kind, the kind where you can hear the wind in the cottonwoods outside and the tick of the old radiator under the windows.

“I’m sorry,” Neal said, with a laugh that did not come off.

“Who are you, exactly?”

The man did not answer that.

He turned to face the forty-seven people in folding chairs, holding the butterscotch guitar at his chest so they could all see it.

“Nobody in this room,” he said, “including you, sir, knows what this guitar is. If I let the bidding go on at fifty dollars, something wrong is going to happen in this hall today. Not a crime. Something worse. A thing nobody can take back.”

A woman in the third row put her hand on her husband’s arm.

“This guitar,” the man went on, “was made more than seventy years ago, in California, by a small group of men who were inventing something. It is one of the very first solid-body electric guitars ever sold. Almost all the others were played to pieces or thrown away. This one has every part it was born with. It has been played, and loved, and taken care of, every day, for longer than most of you have been alive.”

He looked down at the guitar in his hands.

“It is not a wall decoration. It is a piece of history. And a dealer in any big city would tell you it is worth more than this building.”

For a second, nobody understood.

Then a man in a baseball cap in the fifth row said, out loud, “More than the hall?”

“More than the hall,” the stranger said.

“Much more.”

The silence that followed was the kind that seems to change the temperature of a room.

Neal Catterall stood behind the table with the microphone hanging at his side.

He had stopped smiling.

He had sold a great many things in twelve years.

He had never been wrong about the price of anything by that much.

And then, from the middle of the hall, a woman’s voice broke the silence.

It was not a shout.

It was barely a whisper, the kind of whisper you make when you are not sure you are allowed to say a thing out loud.

“Is that Carlos Santana?”

It was Inés Montoya.

She had been standing at the side of the hall with the other volunteers, near the table where the lots were waiting, and she had been watching the man in the denim jacket from the moment he walked down the aisle.

She had not recognized his face.

She had recognized his hands.

When she was fourteen, Abe had brought a cassette tape into the Saturday class and played them a single long guitar solo, over and over, stopping it every few seconds, and said, “Listen. Listen to how he bends that note. He is not playing the guitar. He is singing through it.”

Then he had shown them a photograph from the cassette’s paper sleeve, a young man with a moustache and a mop of dark hair, his eyes closed, his left hand high on the neck of a guitar, his wrist tilted at a strange, particular angle.

“Hold your wrist like that,” Abe had said.

“Like him.”

Inés had practiced that tilt of the wrist for a whole summer.

And a minute ago, she had watched the stranger in the denim jacket sight down the neck of Abe’s guitar and wrap his left hand around it, and his wrist had tilted in exactly that way.

—

## What happens to a small town when it recognizes a face?

It went through the room like wind through the cottonwoods.

Heads turned.

People leaned toward each other.

A teenage boy at the end of a row said, “No,” and then, after a second look, “Oh my God, yes,” and his grandmother hit him on the arm for saying God in the hall.

Somebody near the back stood up to see better, and then everybody was standing.

Carlos Santana did not seem to notice.

He was not looking at the room anymore.

He had walked around the end of the auction table, carrying the guitar, and he was crouching down in front of the front row.

In front of Abe Trujillo.

The old man had not stood up.

He was sitting exactly as he had been sitting all afternoon, his hands folded on the head of his cane, his brown corduroy jacket buttoned to the top.

But his eyes were wet.

Carlos Santana held the guitar out to him, not as a gift, but the way you might show somebody a photograph of a person you both know.

“This is yours,” he said quietly.

Abe nodded.

“Since 1952.”

“You know what it is.”

It was not a question.

Abe looked at the guitar for a long time.

Then he smiled, a small, crooked, old man’s smile.

“I’ve known for seventy years,” he said.

Behind the auction table, Neal Catterall heard that and felt the floor of the old hall move under his feet.

—

## Why did an old man who knew its value let it go for fifty dollars?

The story came out slowly, there in the front row, while the whole town of Cerro Viejo stood around him and listened, and the light through the deep windows went from white to gold.

In the summer of 1952, Abelardo Trujillo was eighteen years old.

He had never been farther from Cerro Viejo than Albuquerque.

That summer he rode a bus to California with his cousin to pick fruit in the Central Valley, because a man could make in three months there what he made in a year at home.

He worked fourteen hours a day.

He slept in a bunkhouse with forty other men.

And on his one free Sunday in August, he took another bus into a town he had never heard of, and walked past the window of a music store, and stopped.

In the window was the strangest guitar he had ever seen.

It had no hole in it.

It was a solid slab of blond wood with a black plate and a plain neck, and it looked less like a guitar than like a tool, or a weapon, or something from the future.

The man in the store let him plug it in.

Abe played it for one minute.

He walked out of the store, walked around the block twice, and walked back in.

He paid one hundred eighty-nine dollars and fifty cents for it.

It was every dollar he had earned that summer.

He rode the bus back to New Mexico with the guitar on his knees for two days and two nights, and when he got home his father did not speak to him for a week.

He played it at every wedding and every dance and every funeral in Cerro Viejo for seventy years.

He played it in the hall at the first Saturday class in 1968.

He taught three generations of children their first chords on it.

And in 1994, a dealer from Santa Fe who had heard about the old teacher with the early electric guitar drove all the way up to Cerro Viejo and knocked on his door and offered him forty thousand dollars for it, cash, on the spot.

Abe said no.

The dealer came back two years later and offered seventy.

Abe said no again.

“It isn’t for sale,” he told him.

“It’s for the kids.”

So he knew.

He had always known.

“Then why,” Carlos Santana asked him, very gently, “fifty dollars?”

Abe Trujillo looked up past him, at the room.

At Neal Catterall behind the table.

At the forty-seven people who had sat in silence while their old teacher’s guitar was offered up as a joke.

“Because I didn’t set the price,” he said.

“I told them, start it wherever you like. I wanted to see what this town thought it was worth. My whole life. The Saturdays. I wanted to see if anybody here would raise a hand for an old guitar.”

His voice cracked.

“Nobody did.”

He looked back at the man crouched in front of him.

“Until you.”

There was not a sound in the adobe hall.

Somewhere in the middle of the room, a grown man who had learned his first chord from Abe Trujillo in 1979 put his face in his hands.

Carlos Santana stayed crouched on the old wooden floor for a long moment, holding the butterscotch guitar.

Then he stood up, and his knees cracked, and he turned to the auction table.

“Mr. Catterall,” he said.

“I would like to restart this auction. With your permission.”

Neal Catterall nodded.

He did not seem able to speak.

—

## What is an old guitar worth when a whole town finally raises its hand?

Carlos Santana laid the guitar back in its orange-lined case, on the table, very gently, with the lid open.

Then he faced the hall.

“My name is Carlos,” he said.

“I am going to bid on this guitar. But first I want everybody here to understand something.”

He put one hand flat on the edge of the case.

“This guitar was bought with one summer of picking fruit, by an eighteen-year-old boy who had never seen anything like it. It has been played at your weddings, and your parents’ weddings, and your grandparents’ funerals. Half of you learned to play music on it, in the room behind that wall. Every dollar it brings today goes to keep that room open.”

He looked at Neal.

“So let us give this guitar the auction it deserves.”

He turned back to the room.

“I bid fifty thousand dollars.”

A sound went through the hall that was not quite a gasp and not quite a cry.

For a second, nobody moved.

Then a thin man in a tweed jacket near the side wall, who had come up from Santa Fe that morning to look at a rocking chair, slowly raised his hand.

He was a dealer.

He was, it turned out, the son of the dealer who had knocked on Abe’s door in 1994.

“Sixty,” he said.

Neal Catterall stood frozen behind the table.

Carlos Santana nodded at him encouragingly, like a teacher waiting for a nervous student.

Neal swallowed.

He lifted the microphone.

His voice came out shaky, and then it found its old rhythm, the rhythm of twelve years of pies and quilts, and something in the room caught fire.

“Sixty thousand dollars. I have sixty. Do I hear…”

“Seventy-five,” said Carlos Santana.

The dealer from Santa Fe made a phone call.

He came back.

“A hundred.”

Somebody in the fifth row whooped and was shushed.

“A hundred and twenty-five,” said Carlos Santana.

“A hundred and forty,” said the dealer.

The room was on its feet.

People were holding each other’s arms.

The grown man who had cried was standing on his folding chair.

Abe Trujillo sat in the front row with both hands on his cane, and tears running openly down his lined brown face, and he did not wipe them away.

“One hundred and seventy-five thousand dollars,” said Carlos Santana.

The dealer from Santa Fe looked at him for a long moment.

Then he smiled, and shook his head, and sat down, and began to clap.

Neal Catterall raised the gavel.

His hand was shaking.

“Going once,” he said.

“Going twice.”

He looked down at the old man in the front row.

“Sold,” said Neal Catterall, and his voice broke on the word, “to the gentleman from the back row.”

The adobe hall erupted.

It was the loudest sound those thick walls had held since they were built in 1938.

People were crying and hugging and stamping on the wooden floor.

The ceramic bowls fell off the side table and nobody cared.

Carlos Santana walked to the auction table, lifted the butterscotch guitar out of its case, and carried it back to the front row.

He crouched down in front of Abe Trujillo again.

And he put the guitar in the old man’s lap.

Abe looked at it.

Then he looked up.

“I don’t understand.”

“I bought it,” Carlos Santana said.

“So it is mine. And I am giving it to the Saturday program, to stay in the room behind that wall, for as long as this hall is standing.”

He smiled.

“On one condition. You play it first.”

Abe laughed through his tears.

“I’m ninety-one. My hands shake.”

“So do mine,” said Carlos Santana.

“Play anyway.”

—

## What did a ninety-one-year-old man play in front of the whole town?

Somebody brought an amplifier from the back room.

It was the same small, scratched practice amplifier that Abe had bought in 1971 for the Saturday class and that three generations of children had kicked and dropped and loved.

Carlos Santana plugged in the cord himself and turned the volume down to two.

The hall went silent again.

Abe Trujillo held his guitar across his knees in the front row of the adobe hall.

His fingers found the neck.

They shook.

He closed his eyes.

And then he played a song that every person over fifty in that room knew without being told.

It was an old wedding waltz, a song from these mountains that was older than the hall, older than the church bell, a song his mother had sung to him in the kitchen and that he had played at four hundred weddings in Cerro Viejo, slow and sweet and a little sad.

It was not perfect.

His hands were ninety-one years old, and they missed notes, and twice he had to stop and start a phrase again.

It did not matter.

Halfway through the second verse, a woman in the third row began to sing the words very softly.

Then the man beside her.

Then the whole room, forty-seven people and more who had crowded in from the plaza when they heard the shouting, singing an old song together in an old adobe hall, while their old teacher played it on the guitar he had carried home on a bus in 1952.

Carlos Santana stood off to one side with his hands in the pockets of his denim jacket.

He did not play.

He did not sing.

He just listened, with his head bowed, the way you listen in church.

When it was over, Abe opened his eyes and looked at him.

“That’s all I know how to play anymore,” he said.

Carlos Santana shook his head.

“That is everything,” he said.

—

## What did Neal Catterall do on Monday morning?

He went to see Abe Trujillo.

He drove out to the little adobe house by the river in his clean pickup and knocked on the door, and when the old man opened it, Neal stood on the step with his hat in his hands and did not know where to start.

Abe let him in.

He made coffee.

They sat at the kitchen table for an hour.

Nobody in town knows everything that was said, and neither man ever told.

But years later, Neal admitted one part of it to Inés Montoya, after a board meeting, when the two of them were stacking folding chairs.

He had been in the Saturday class himself.

For one year, in 1972, when he was eight.

He had loved it.

He had been good at it, Abe told him once, better than good, and he had practiced on a borrowed guitar every night in his room.

Then his father, who sold insurance and believed in things that could be counted, had come to pick him up one Saturday, and had stood in the doorway of the back room watching a semicircle of children strumming the same chord out of time, and had said, loudly enough for the whole room to hear, “This is a waste of a Saturday.”

Neal never went back.

He became very good at things that could be counted.

“I think I’ve been mad at that room for fifty years,” he told Inés, stacking chairs.

“I didn’t even know it. Not till I was standing there holding his guitar like a dead fish and making jokes about it.”

He did not say anything else.

Inés did not ask.

But the following Thursday, the board of the Cerro Viejo community hall met again, and Neal Catterall, chairman, made the first motion.

He moved to reverse the vote on the back room.

Then he moved that the room be renamed.

Both motions passed seven to nothing.

The roof was fixed by Christmas.

The heating was replaced.

And the rest of the money, nearly all of it, went into a fund for the Saturday program, enough to pay a teacher and buy instruments for every child in Cerro Viejo who wanted one, for as long as anybody now alive could imagine.

It is called the Abe Trujillo Saturday School.

The sign over the door of the back room was painted by hand, by Inés Montoya, who had learned her first chord in that room when she was seven, and who now teaches the beginners’ class on the first Saturday of every month.

Abe taught one more class.

Just one, on the first Saturday after the roof was fixed.

He sat in a chair in the front of the room with the butterscotch guitar across his knees, and eleven children sat on the floor in front of him, and he showed each one of them, one at a time, how to make a single chord.

Then he handed the guitar to the new teacher and went home and took a nap.

He lived another two years.

He went to every Saturday class he could, and sat in the back, and listened.

—

## What does it say on the card behind the auction table?

The butterscotch guitar hangs in the back room of the Cerro Viejo hall now, in a glass case on the adobe wall.

Every Saturday morning, the teacher takes it out, plays one song on it to start the class, and puts it back.

The children call it Abe.

Carlos Santana never spoke publicly about that afternoon.

The dealer from Santa Fe, when a reporter called, said only that he had been outbid by a man who knew exactly what he was doing, and that he did not mind at all.

But Carlos Santana came back.

He came the next November, for the auction, and sat in the back row in a denim jacket, and bought a pie.

He has come back most Novembers since.

And Neal Catterall still runs the auction.

He still wears the blue shirt.

He still tells jokes, and gets pies up to forty dollars, and pretends to be scandalized.

But behind the auction table now, on the adobe wall, there is a small frame.

Inside it is a white index card, the one Neal wrote out himself the night before the auction, in his own handwriting.

Lot 23.

Vintage guitar.

Starting price fifty dollars.

Underneath, in different ink, he has added one line.

Sold for $175,000 to a man in the back row.

The day this town learned what its teacher was worth.

And every year, when the volunteers carry in the very last item of the afternoon, whatever it is, a quilt or a toolbox or a rocking chair, Neal Catterall lifts the microphone and looks out at the folding chairs, and says the same thing he said on the day he was wrong.

“Let’s start the bidding at fifty dollars. Anyone?”

And the whole room raises its hand.

—

*About this story: this is a dramatized, fictional tribute, written for entertainment. Cerro Viejo, its community hall, Abe Trujillo, Neal Catterall, the Saturday School, the dealer from Santa Fe and everything that happens at that auction are invented, and Carlos Santana never made the visit described here. What is true is the background: the first commercially sold solid-body electric guitars were made in Southern California in the early 1950s, early examples in original condition are among the most valuable guitars collectors buy, and Carlos Santana has been one of the world’s most celebrated guitarists for more than half a century. No real song is named or quoted. The rest is a story about a town, a teacher, and the price of a raised hand.*

You Might Also Enjoy