Classical Master Mocked Carlos Santana — His Bach Performance Stunned the Professor
Boston, Massachusetts.
A cold Friday evening in December, a few minutes after seven, inside an old recital hall paneled from floor to ceiling in dark walnut.
Forty music students in black tuxedos and black evening gowns sat in rows of red velvet seats.
In the front row, a gray-haired professor in a navy suit turned around in his chair and pointed toward the very back of the hall.
“You see that gentleman back there?”
Every head turned.
In the last row, alone, sat an older man with long gray curls held back by a dark headband, wearing a loose silk shirt printed with faded paisley.
An electric guitar case leaned against the seat beside him.
The professor let the silence sit for a moment.
“That is exactly what I have been warning you about.”
A few students laughed.
Most of them did not.
The old man in the back row did not seem offended.
He seemed, if anything, curious.
Ten minutes later, he was standing on the stage of that recital hall with a battered sunburst electric guitar in his hands, his eyes closed, playing the most demanding piece of music ever written for a single string instrument.
And the professor who had mocked him was sitting in the front row with his hand pressed over his mouth.
This is the story of that evening, and of the night a man who had taught music for forty years learned that he still had something to learn.
—
## The Honors Evening
The Aldridge Conservatory of Music occupied three narrow brick buildings on a quiet street near the Fenway, connected by covered walkways that leaked every time it rained.
It was not the most famous music school in Boston.
But its guitar department had a reputation.
Students came from all over the country, and a few from all over the world, to study classical guitar there.
And the reason most of them came was a single man.
Dr. Edmund Hargrove was sixty-six years old.
He had studied in Madrid and Vienna as a young man.
He had performed in concert halls across Europe and recorded nine albums of Spanish and Baroque music for a small label that nobody outside the classical world had ever heard of.
For forty years he had taught at Aldridge, and for twenty of those years he had been the chair of guitar studies.
He was brilliant.
Everyone agreed on that.
He could hear a single wrong fingering from the back of a crowded hall.
He could take a student who played adequately and, in six months, turn them into a student who played beautifully.
He was also, according to one of his former students, the only man in Boston who could make the word “interesting” sound like a death sentence.
Professor Hargrove believed in tradition.
He believed in discipline.
He believed that there was one correct way into the great music of the past, and that it went through years of scales, years of études, years of sitting very straight on a hard chair with a footstool under your left foot and a nylon-string guitar on your knee.
And he believed, though he rarely said it out loud anymore, that the electric guitar was a toy with a plug.
Once a semester, on the last Friday before the winter break, the guitar department held what it called the Honors Evening.
It was half recital, half masterclass.
The best students in the department played in front of the faculty, their classmates, and a small audience of invited guests and parents, and Professor Hargrove stopped them, corrected them, and made them play again.
It was formal.
Black tie.
Students wore tuxedos and evening gowns.
Parents dressed up.
It was, in the opinion of every student who had ever survived it, the most terrifying night of the year.
—
## Nadia
That year, the last student on the program was a twenty-one-year-old senior named Nadia Kerr.
Nadia was from Duluth, Minnesota.
Her father drove a snowplow for the county and her mother worked in a hospital laundry, and she had paid for her first guitar lessons by shoveling her neighbors’ driveways when she was twelve.
She was the most talented student Professor Hargrove had taught in a decade.
He had told her so exactly once, in her first year.
He had not said anything kind to her since.
He believed praise made students lazy.
Nadia had chosen to play the Chaconne.
It is the last movement of a partita that Johann Sebastian Bach wrote for solo violin around 1720, and it is about fifteen minutes long.
Guitarists have been playing it in their own arrangements for more than a century.
It is one of the most difficult and most beautiful pieces of music in the world.
There is a story, never proven, that Bach wrote it after coming home from a long journey to find that his wife had died and been buried while he was gone.
Nobody knows if it is true.
But if you listen to the Chaconne, you understand why people want to believe it.
Nadia had been working on it for two years.
She could play every note.
But there was one passage, about two-thirds of the way through, a long cascade of rolling arpeggios that climb and fall like waves, where her hands always seemed to get ahead of her heart.
She played it fast.
She played it clean.
And every time she played it, Professor Hargrove stopped her.
—
## The Man in the Back Row
The man in the back row had come in about ten minutes after the Honors Evening began.
He had slipped through the side door quietly, the way people do when they know they are late, and taken the seat on the aisle in the very last row.
He was in his late seventies.
His hair was long and curly and mostly gray, with a little black still in it, and he wore a dark patterned headband to keep it off his face.
His shirt was silk, loose, and printed with faded swirls of cream and blue and rose.
He had a gray moustache, dark eyes, and the calm, unhurried face of a man who did not have anywhere else to be.
He set a black guitar case down on the seat beside him.
It was an electric guitar case, the kind with a worn handle and old stickers peeled off in patches.
Then he folded his hands in his lap and listened.
Nobody paid any attention to him.
Some of the parents in the middle rows assumed he was somebody’s grandfather.
One of the students, glancing back at the guitar case, assumed he was a technician who had come to fix something.
He was neither.
He had come to pick up an old friend for dinner.
The friend was Eli Navarro, who had been the stage manager of the recital hall at Aldridge for thirty-eight years, and who, in another life, a very long time ago, had carried amplifiers for a band of broke kids in San Francisco.
They had been friends for more than fifty years.
They saw each other perhaps once a year, whenever one of them was in the other’s city.
That afternoon the man in the paisley shirt had picked up his favorite old guitar from a repair shop across town, and he had come straight to Aldridge to collect Eli.
Eli had told him to come in and sit in the back.
Eli had laughed on the phone.
“You’ll like it. The kids are good. The professor is a piece of work. But the kids are good.”
So the man in the paisley shirt sat in the back row and listened to the kids.
Eli had been right.
They were good.
—
## “Again”
Nadia walked onto the stage last, a little after seven, in a long black gown with thin straps, carrying her guitar by the neck.
She sat down on the hard chair in the center of the stage.
She put her left foot on the footstool.
She tuned, quickly and quietly.
Then she began the Chaconne.
The opening chords filled the hall, grave and slow and heavy, like footsteps on a stone floor.
The man in the back row closed his eyes.
Nadia played for six minutes without a single interruption.
Then she reached the arpeggios.
Her right hand began to roll across the strings, faster and faster, the notes tumbling over each other in perfect, glittering order.
“Stop.”
Professor Hargrove did not raise his voice.
He never did.
Nadia stopped.
He did not look up from his notes.
“Again. From the arpeggios.”
She played it again.
It was faster this time.
“Stop.”
She stopped.
Professor Hargrove spoke in a tone of weary patience that every student in the hall knew and dreaded.
“Miss Kerr, every note you just played was correct. And not one of them was true.”
Nadia’s face went pink.
He took off his reading glasses and rubbed the bridge of his nose.
“You are playing this like a typist. You are playing this like someone who has spent too many evenings listening to the radio. Bach is not a speed contest. This is not a rock concert. There is no applause for getting to the end first.”
A few students in the front rows shifted in their seats.
Nadia stared down at her strings.
“Again.”
She played it a third time.
Her hands were shaking now, and the shaking made her rush, and the rushing made her stumble, and halfway through the passage she simply stopped and sat there with her fingers frozen on the strings.
The hall was silent.
Professor Hargrove sighed, a long, theatrical sigh, and turned around in his front-row seat to address the room.
—
## The Example
He did not plan it.
If he had planned it, he might have thought better of it.
But he was tired, and frustrated, and he had been teaching for forty years, and for forty years he had been fighting the same battle against the same enemy, and in that moment the enemy happened to be sitting in the very last row of his recital hall, wearing a paisley shirt, with an electric guitar case on the seat beside him.
Professor Hargrove raised one hand and pointed.
“You see that gentleman back there?”
Forty heads turned.
The man in the paisley shirt looked up.
The professor’s voice rose a little, the way it did in his lectures.
“That is exactly what I have been warning you about. It is everywhere. It is on every screen in your pockets. Everyone believes that music is something you simply pick up. You plug in. You turn it up. And if it is loud enough, and if it is fast enough, people will clap.”
He gestured at the guitar case.
“I would wager a great deal of money that the gentleman back there has never played a single bar of Bach in his life. And I would wager that he has never needed to. And that, ladies and gentlemen, is precisely the problem with the world into which you are about to graduate.”
A few students laughed, nervously.
Most did not.
A girl in the third row, in a dark blue gown, looked down at her shoes.
At the side door of the hall, Eli Navarro, who had just come in from the stage-left corridor with a clipboard in his hand, stopped dead.
His mouth fell open.
He took one step forward.
In the back row, the man in the paisley shirt caught Eli’s eye from across the hall and gave him the smallest shake of the head.
Eli stopped.
He closed his mouth.
And then, very slowly, he began to smile.
—
## The Invitation
Professor Hargrove was warming to his subject now.
He had found his teaching moment, and like all great teachers, he could not resist using it.
He stood up and turned fully around to face the back of the hall.
He called out across the rows.
“Sir, forgive me for making an example of you. It is nothing personal.”
The man in the back row nodded politely, as if to say that he understood.
The professor smiled thinly.
“But since you are here, perhaps you would be willing to help my students. Would you care to come up and show them how you play? Let them hear, side by side, the difference between four years of serious study and whatever it is that you do.”
Now nobody laughed at all.
Some of the students turned to look at the professor with something close to horror.
Nadia, on the stage, still holding her guitar, looked out at the old man in the back row and silently willed him to say no, to get up, to leave, to spare himself.
The man in the paisley shirt did not leave.
He sat for a moment, looking at the professor with an expression that nobody could quite read.
It was not anger.
It was something more like patience.
Then he stood up, picked up the black guitar case, and began to walk down the long center aisle toward the stage.
—
## Down the Aisle
He walked slowly.
He was not a young man anymore, and the aisle sloped down toward the stage, and he took it one careful step at a time.
As he passed the rows, the students turned to watch him.
A tall young man in the fourth row named Theo Marsh, who was a classical guitar major but who played in a jazz trio on weekends without telling anyone in the department, watched the man’s right hand as he passed.
There were rings on it.
Turquoise.
Old silver.
And there was something about the way he carried the guitar case, close against his leg, the way a mother carries a sleeping child, that made Theo frown.
The man reached the foot of the stage.
Nadia stood up from her chair, holding her guitar against her chest.
She leaned toward him as he climbed the three steps and whispered.
“You don’t have to. He does this. You don’t have to.”
The man smiled at her.
His eyes were very dark and very kind.
“What is your name?”
She swallowed.
“Nadia.”
He repeated her name softly.
“Nadia. Which part are you afraid of?”
She stared at him.
Nobody had ever asked her that.
Not once, in four years.
Her answer was barely a whisper.
“The arpeggios.”
He nodded, as though that was exactly the answer he had expected.
He pointed gently at her chair.
“Sit down. Please. Stay here. I want you to hear something.”
—
## “Play Whatever It Is You Play”
Eli Navarro was already wheeling a small amplifier onto the stage from the wings.
It belonged to the conservatory’s jazz ensemble, and it lived in a storage closet behind the stage, and Eli had never moved anything so fast in thirty-eight years.
He set it down beside the man in the paisley shirt, plugged it in, and put a cable into his old friend’s hand.
He did not say a word.
He just squeezed his friend’s shoulder, once, and walked back into the wings, shaking his head and smiling to himself.
The man opened the case.
Inside was an old three-tone sunburst electric guitar with a maple neck.
It was not beautiful.
It was battered.
The finish on the body had worn away to bare wood in a dozen places, around the edges and under the strings and along the top where a forearm had rested on it for decades.
The maple neck had gone the color of strong tea.
It looked like it had been played every day of its life by somebody who loved it and did not care at all what it looked like.
He slipped the strap over his head and plugged in.
From the front row, Professor Hargrove made a small, dry gesture with his hand.
His voice was dry.
“Please. By all means. Play whatever it is you play.”
The man turned the volume knob on the guitar down almost to nothing.
Then he turned it up, just a little.
Just a fingertip.
He closed his eyes.
—
## The First Note
He did not start with Bach.
He started with something of his own.
Something nobody in the hall knew.
It was slow, and it was simple, and it began with a single long note that rose out of the little jazz amplifier and climbed and climbed and did not seem to want to end.
It hung in the air of that walnut hall as if the guitar were breathing.
Then a second note.
Then a third, bent slowly upward until it sounded like a human voice trying not to cry.
In the fourth row, Theo Marsh sat up very straight.
In the third row, the girl in the blue gown lifted her eyes from her shoes.
The melody was not fast.
It was not loud.
It did not show off.
It was full of space, and every phrase seemed to end in a question, and every question seemed to be answered by the silence that came after it.
Professor Hargrove’s hand, which had been resting on his knee, slowly closed into a loose fist.
The piece lasted perhaps three minutes.
When it ended, the hall was so quiet that you could hear the old radiators ticking along the walls.
Nobody clapped.
Nobody knew if they were allowed to.
The man opened his eyes and looked down at the professor in the front row.
His voice was quiet.
“You mentioned Bach.”
Professor Hargrove did not answer.
He glanced at Nadia, then back at the professor.
“Would you mind if I tried the part she is afraid of?”
—
## The Chaconne
The professor found his voice.
It was not quite the voice he had used ten minutes earlier.
He straightened his tie.
“That passage requires years of study. It requires a level of discipline and understanding that cannot be improvised on an electric guitar.”
The man nodded.
“You are right. It requires all of that.”
He turned and looked at Nadia, sitting on her hard chair with her guitar on her knee.
He looked over at Nadia again.
“But she already has all of that. She has the discipline. She has the years. She has every note. What she does not have is permission.”
Then he began to play the Chaconne.
He did not begin at the beginning.
He began with the grave, heavy chords of the opening, but he played them slowly, much more slowly than anyone in that hall had ever heard them played, so that every chord rang out and faded completely before the next one began.
Like footsteps.
Like a man walking very slowly up a stone path toward a house where nobody was waiting for him anymore.
Then he went straight to the arpeggios.
And he did not play them fast.
He played them as if every single note were a person, and he could not bear to rush past any of them.
They rose.
They fell.
They rose again, a little higher, the electric guitar singing each note with a long, warm sustain that a nylon string could never hold, so that each one bled softly into the next, like watercolor on wet paper.
It was not a performance.
It was a conversation.
And in the middle of it, the sound changed in that walnut room in a way that nobody there would ever be able to describe properly.
People would try.
The girl in the blue gown would say later that it was like the whole hall leaned forward at once.
Theo Marsh would say it sounded like the music was crying, but in a way that made you feel better instead of worse.
Eli Navarro, in the wings, would say only that he had heard his friend play in front of three hundred thousand people, and that this was better.
—
## The Professor
Edmund Hargrove sat in the front row with his hands on his knees.
For the first minute of the Chaconne, his face did not move.
He was listening the way he always listened, coldly and precisely, hunting for the wrong fingering, the clumsy shift, the place where the player’s hands betrayed him.
He did not find one.
For the second minute, his eyebrows came down.
He was confused.
The tempo was wrong.
Far too slow.
Nobody played it this slowly.
It should not have worked.
It worked.
In the third minute, the man on the stage reached the very top of the long climbing passage, the place where Nadia always rushed, and he did the opposite of rushing.
He stopped.
Just for a breath.
A single silent breath, right at the top of the climb, like a man standing at the edge of a cliff looking down at the sea.
And then he let the next note fall.
Professor Hargrove’s right hand came up slowly from his knee and pressed against his mouth.
He did not know he was doing it.
He sat there in his navy suit with his blue tie and his reading glasses, in the front row of the hall where he had been the most feared man in the building for twenty years, with his hand over his mouth, and his eyes behind the glasses were wet.
Behind him, in the second row, a young woman in a black gown pressed a tissue to the corner of her eye.
A young man beside her, in a tuxedo with a crooked bow tie, was smiling and did not know why.
All down the rows, students in their formal black were sitting perfectly still, the way people sit in church when something has happened that they do not have words for.
—
## The Name
It was Theo Marsh who figured it out.
Theo, who played in a jazz trio on weekends.
Theo, whose father had a record collection that took up an entire wall of the family’s living room in Providence.
He had been staring at the man’s hands for five minutes.
At the turquoise rings.
At the way the left hand did not so much press the strings as sing through them.
And at the tone.
That tone.
That long, crying, unmistakable tone, which Theo had heard thousands of times through the speakers in his father’s living room, though never, ever like this.
He leaned over to the girl beside him and whispered a name.
She shook her head.
He whispered it again.
She looked at the stage.
She looked at the long gray curls, the headband, the paisley silk, the rings.
Then she grabbed his arm so hard that he would have bruises the next day.
The name went down the row like a breeze moving through tall grass.
One whisper.
Then another.
Then another.
Nobody said it out loud.
Nobody wanted to break whatever was happening on that stage.
But by the time the man reached the end of the passage and let the last note ring out and die, every student in the hall knew who he was.
Except Nadia.
Nadia was sitting three feet away from him with her guitar on her knee and tears running down her face, and she had not looked at his face once.
She had only been looking at his hands.
—
## Permission
The last note faded.
The hall stayed silent for five long seconds.
Then the man on the stage opened his eyes, turned to Nadia, and nodded toward the guitar on her knee.
His voice was soft.
“Now you.”
She shook her head.
“I can’t. Not after that.”
He smiled at her.
“Yes, you can. From the arpeggios. Not fast. As slow as you want. Take as long as you need. Nobody here is in a hurry.”
He glanced down at the front row.
“Are we, Professor?”
Edmund Hargrove lowered his hand from his mouth.
He looked at the man on the stage for a long moment.
Then he looked at his student.
And he spoke in a voice that nobody in the department had ever heard him use, a voice that was almost gentle.
“Take as long as you need, Miss Kerr.”
Nadia lifted her right hand to the strings.
The man in the paisley shirt turned the volume on his electric guitar down to a whisper and laid one long, low note underneath her, like a floor, and held it there.
And Nadia Kerr played the arpeggios.
She played them slowly.
She played them as if every note were a person.
She stopped, just for a breath, at the top of the climb.
And then she let the next note fall.
When she finished, the whole hall stood up.
Forty students in tuxedos and gowns, the parents in the middle rows, the faculty in the side seats, Eli Navarro in the wings, all on their feet, clapping so hard the old walnut walls rang with it.
The man in the paisley shirt did not stand.
He sat on the edge of the stage with his battered guitar across his knees and pointed at Nadia, and kept pointing, until every eye in the room was on her.
—
## “I Was Wrong”
When the applause finally faded, Professor Hargrove stood up in the front row.
He turned to face his students.
He took off his reading glasses and folded them, slowly, and put them in the breast pocket of his navy suit.
He cleared his throat.
“I have taught at this school for forty years.”
His voice was steady, but only just.
“For forty years I have told my students that there is one door into this music. One door, and I have been standing in front of it with a key, deciding who gets in.”
He looked up at the stage.
“Ten minutes ago I told you that the gentleman on that stage had never played a bar of Bach in his life. I was wrong about that.”
He paused.
“And I have been wrong about a great many other things for a great many years. I would like to apologize to him. And I would like to apologize to Miss Kerr. And to the rest of you.”
Then Edmund Hargrove turned to the man on the stage, and he said the name out loud for the first time.
His voice was quiet.
“Mr. Santana, I am very sorry.”
Carlos Santana climbed carefully down the three steps from the stage, walked over to the professor, and held out his hand.
The professor took it.
Carlos Santana kept hold of his hand.
“You were not wrong about everything. You were right that she has to work. You were right that it takes years. You just forgot to tell her why she is doing it.”
He nodded back toward the stage, where Nadia was still sitting with her guitar, laughing and crying at the same time.
He let go of the professor’s hand.
“She is not doing it for you. She is doing it for the man who wrote it. And for whoever he lost.”
—
## After
Carlos Santana and Eli Navarro went to dinner that night at a small Portuguese restaurant around the corner, exactly as they had planned.
They were an hour late.
The students had surrounded him in the lobby, and he had stayed until every one of them had asked their question, and he had answered every question as though it were the most important one he had ever heard.
Theo Marsh asked him how he got that tone.
He held up his hands.
He laughed.
“These. And forty years of listening to people cry.”
The girl in the blue gown asked him if he had ever been afraid of a piece of music.
He did not even have to think.
“Every day. That is how you know it is worth playing.”
Nadia was the last one.
She waited until everyone else had gone, and then she asked him the question she had been holding all night.
“Why did you say yes? When he made fun of you. Why didn’t you just leave?”
Carlos Santana thought about it.
He looked at her for a long moment.
“Because when he made fun of me, he was really talking to you. I thought you should hear the answer.”
—
## The Open Chair
The following spring, the Aldridge Conservatory changed its Honors Evening.
Professor Hargrove did it himself.
He added something new to the end of the program.
He called it the Open Chair.
At the end of every Honors Evening now, any student in the conservatory, on any instrument, in any style, may walk up onto the stage and play one piece, without being stopped, without being corrected, without being graded.
A saxophone player has done it.
A drummer has done it.
A young woman once played a folk song on a banjo her grandfather built.
Professor Hargrove sits in the front row and listens to every one of them all the way to the end.
He does not say “Again.”
He still teaches.
He is still demanding.
Students still find him terrifying.
But they say he has started asking a new question before every lesson, a question none of his students had ever heard from him before that December night.
“Which part are you afraid of?”
Nadia Kerr graduated in May.
At her senior recital, she played the Chaconne all the way through, from the first heavy chord to the last, without a single mistake that anybody noticed.
She played the arpeggios slowly.
She stopped, just for a breath, at the top of the climb.
In the program, under her name, she had printed a single line of dedication.
For the man who gave me permission.
Professor Hargrove was in the front row.
He did not stop her once.
And at the very back of the hall, in the last seat on the aisle, the stage manager Eli Navarro sat with his arms folded and his eyes closed, smiling, because a long time ago, in a little club in San Francisco, he had carried an amplifier for a young guitarist nobody had heard of yet, and he had always known exactly how this kind of story ends.