Why You Wouldn’t Survive One Day as a Tudor Midwife (1536)
The candles had been burning since before noon, because in this room it was always night.
It was late spring of 1555, at Hampton Court Palace, a few miles up the Thames from London.
Outside, the gardens were green and the river was full of barges, and the long brick courts were crowded with lords, ladies, priests and foreign ambassadors who had been waiting for weeks.
Inside the queen’s chamber, none of that existed.
The windows had been hung over with heavy tapestry.
The walls were covered in cloth.
The air was warm and close and smelled of beeswax, of herbs strewn on the floor, of the fire that was kept going whether the day was hot or not.
There were no men.
There had been no men in this room for weeks.
A midwife stood near the door with her hands folded in front of her apron, the way she had been taught to stand when there was nothing yet to do.
She had been standing like that, on and off, for a very long time.
Across the room, on a pile of cushions on the floor, sat the Queen of England.
Mary Tudor was thirty-nine years old.
Her face was thin and pale, her eyes deep-set, her mouth pressed tight.
She sat with her knees drawn up so high that they almost touched her chin, her arms around them, and she did not move for hours.
Beside the great bed stood a cradle.
It was gilded and carved, it was hung with fine cloth, and it was empty.
The physicians had told the queen her child would come in early May.
Then they had counted again.
Then they had counted again.
Every woman in that room had seen a hundred pregnancies.
Every one of them knew what a woman near her time looked like, how she moved, how she sat, how she breathed.
So why did not one of them say anything?
Here is what makes the story of Mary I’s pregnancy so strange.
Before the queen ever went into that room, letters had been written to the kings and princes of Europe announcing the safe birth of her son.
They were written out fair, signed, ready to be sent, with only one thing missing: the date.
Some of those letters were never sent, and they are said to still exist today.
And a few days before this scene, on the last morning of April, the church bells of London had rung out all day for a royal prince who had never been born.
This is the story of how that happened, of the women who stood in that sealed room and knew what nobody dared to say, and of what the queen was really carrying.
—
## What every midwife swore to God before she touched a mother
To understand what those women knew, you have to start with who they were.
In Tudor England, a midwife was not a doctor.
She had not been to a university.
She had never studied anatomy, because almost nobody had, and the inside of a woman’s body was, to nearly everyone alive, a mystery wrapped in prayer and guesswork.
She learned by watching.
A girl or a young widow would stand in the corner of other women’s birthing rooms for years, fetching water, holding cloths, keeping the fire, watching an older midwife’s hands.
Then one day the older woman was gone, and the parish knocked on her door instead.
What she carried was simple.
A few clean cloths, if she had them.
A knife or a pair of scissors for the cord.
Small jars of oils and herbs.
Sometimes a low wooden birthing stool, shaped like a horseshoe, so a woman in labor could sit upright and let the weight of her body help.
She had no forceps, because forceps had not yet been invented.
She had nothing that could take away pain.
She had no idea, because nobody in Europe had any idea, that unwashed hands carried sickness from one bed to the next.
What she did have was the church.
As the sixteenth century went on, English bishops increasingly licensed midwives, and a licensed midwife swore an oath before churchmen.
The best-known version that survives comes from a few years after Mary’s reign, but its promises were old ones.
She swore that if a baby was dying and no priest could come in time, she would baptize it herself, with water and the proper words, so that its soul would not be lost.
She swore that she would not use charms, spells or sorcery.
She swore that she would never let a woman name the wrong man as the father of her child.
And she swore, in one form or another, to tell the truth about what she saw in the birthing room.
Think about that last promise.
It was easy enough to keep in a village cottage.
It was a very different thing in the bedchamber of a queen.
—
## The sealed room where only women were allowed
Every Tudor birth, rich or poor, happened in the same kind of place.
It was called the lying-in chamber, and sometimes, more honestly, the groaning chamber.
The windows were shut and covered.
Keyholes were stopped with cloth.
A fire was lit and kept burning, because people believed that drafts, cold air and bright daylight were dangerous to a woman giving birth, and that the room had to be dark and warm, like a nest.
The husband was sent away.
The room filled instead with the mother’s gossips, a word that came from “god-sibs,” the women who would stand as spiritual kin to her child.
They held her hands.
They prayed.
They passed around caudle, a warm, spiced drink of ale or wine thickened with bread or oatmeal, to keep up her strength.
When fear set in, the midwife reached for the things her world believed in.
She might tie an eagle stone to the mother’s thigh, a hollow stone with a smaller stone rattling inside it, which was believed to draw the baby down the way the big stone held the little one.
She might wrap a birth girdle around her belly, a long strip of cloth or parchment covered in prayers and the names of saints.
She lit candles that had been blessed, and she prayed to Saint Margaret, the saint women called on in childbirth.
For a royal birth, everything was the same, only larger.
Holy girdles were borrowed from great abbeys.
Elizabeth of York, Mary’s grandmother, had once paid a monk to bring her one.
A woman near her time often set her affairs in order and made her peace with God, the way a soldier might before a battle.
And everyone at Mary’s court remembered what had happened in this very palace eighteen years before.
In October 1537, at Hampton Court, Queen Jane Seymour had given Henry VIII the son he had torn the country apart to get.
Twelve days later, Jane was dead, most likely from the fever that so often followed childbirth.
Mary had been there.
She had been twenty-one years old, and she had stood as godmother to the baby prince.
Now she was the queen, and the birthing room was hers.
—
## The daughter of a woman who buried her babies
There was another story behind Mary’s pregnancy, older and sadder than Jane’s.
It was her mother’s.
Catherine of Aragon married Henry VIII in 1509, and for most of the next decade she was pregnant or grieving.
Her first child, a daughter, was born dead in January 1510.
Then, strangely, Catherine’s belly stayed swollen, and her physicians told her that she was still carrying a second child.
She is said to have gone into her lying-in chamber that spring and waited.
Nothing came.
Her first son, Prince Henry, was born on New Year’s Day 1511, and the whole kingdom celebrated with tournaments and bonfires.
He lived for less than two months.
More pregnancies followed, and more losses: children born too early, children born dead, a son who lived only hours.
Only one child survived.
She was born at Greenwich on February 18, 1516, and they named her Mary.
For years, Mary was the jewel of her father’s court, a small, red-haired girl who played the virginals for foreign ambassadors.
Then Henry decided that Catherine’s lost sons were God’s punishment for marrying his brother’s widow, and he set out to end the marriage.
Mary was about seventeen when her father married Anne Boleyn and declared that his first marriage had never been valid.
That made Mary illegitimate.
She was stripped of the title of princess, sent to serve as a lady-in-waiting to her own baby half-sister, Elizabeth, and forbidden to see her mother.
Catherine died in January 1536 without being allowed to say goodbye to her daughter.
In the months after Anne Boleyn’s fall that same year, Mary was finally made to sign a paper accepting that her mother’s marriage had been unlawful and that she herself was a bastard.
She is said never to have forgiven herself.
Through all of it, she was often ill.
Her letters and the reports of ambassadors mention headaches, palpitations, long bouts of depression, and painful and irregular monthly courses that troubled her from her teens.
Keep that detail in mind.
The women who would later stand in her birthing chamber knew about it too.
—
## Why a queen of thirty-seven needed a son by next spring
In July 1553, against every expectation, Mary became Queen of England.
Her half-brother, Edward VI, had died at fifteen, and his councilors had tried to put his Protestant cousin, Lady Jane Grey, on the throne instead.
Mary rode out of East Anglia at the head of a growing army of ordinary people who thought the crown was hers by right, and within days the plot collapsed.
She rode into London as the first queen to rule England in her own name.
She was thirty-seven.
And she had one problem that no army could solve.
If she died without a child, the throne would pass to her half-sister, Elizabeth, the daughter of Anne Boleyn, the woman Mary blamed for her mother’s ruin.
Elizabeth was twenty, clever, popular and, Mary was sure, a Protestant at heart.
Everything Mary hoped to do, above all to bring England back to the Catholic Church, would last only as long as she lived, unless she had an heir.
So she needed a husband, and she needed one quickly.
She chose her cousin’s son, Philip, the heir of the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V and the future King of Spain.
Many English people were horrified.
They feared that England would become a province of Spain.
In January 1554, Sir Thomas Wyatt raised an army in Kent and marched on London to stop the marriage.
Mary refused to leave the city, went to the Guildhall and spoke to the people herself, and London held.
Wyatt’s rebellion failed.
In the weeks after it, Lady Jane Grey was put to death, and Wyatt soon followed.
Elizabeth was arrested and taken to the Tower of London through the river gate, on a rainy Palm Sunday, convinced that she was going to die.
She did not.
There was not enough evidence against her, and in May she was sent to the old royal lodge at Woodstock, in Oxfordshire, under guard.
But the lesson was clear to everyone.
As long as Mary had no child, Elizabeth was the future, and the future was dangerous.
—
## The wedding at Winchester
Philip landed at Southampton in July 1554.
He was twenty-seven years old, slim, fair-haired and very correct, and he had come to marry a woman eleven years older than himself whom he had never met.
They were married on Wednesday, July 25, 1554, the feast of Saint James, in Winchester Cathedral.
Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester and Lord Chancellor of England, performed the ceremony.
To make the groom equal in rank to his bride, the emperor had made his son King of Naples, and the heralds proclaimed the couple King and Queen of England, France, Naples, Jerusalem and Ireland.
Mary, by every account, was in love.
Philip was polite.
The men around him were less polite in their letters home.
One of his closest advisers, Ruy Gómez, is said to have written that the queen was a good woman but older than they had been told, and that the king understood perfectly well that the marriage had been made for political reasons.
What mattered, to Philip, to his father and to Mary’s council, was a child.
A son would join England to the vast inheritance of the Habsburgs.
A son would keep Elizabeth from the throne.
A son would make Mary’s return to Rome permanent.
And by the end of September 1554, two months after the wedding, the queen’s women had noticed that her courses had stopped.
—
## Autumn 1554: the signs every woman in England knew
The signs came one after another, and they were the signs every woman knew.
Her monthly courses ceased.
She was sick in the mornings.
Her belly began to swell, and so, ambassadors reported, did her breasts.
The royal physicians examined her and agreed.
The queen was with child.
To Mary, it was the answer to a lifetime of prayer.
She had lost her mother, her title, her faith and her dignity, and now, at thirty-eight, God was giving her everything back.
Her council began to plan.
In November, Cardinal Reginald Pole arrived in England.
He was Mary’s cousin, a grandson of the Duke of Clarence, and he had spent twenty years in exile in Italy because he had refused to support Henry VIII’s divorce.
Now he came home as the pope’s legate, to bring England back to the Roman Church.
When Pole was brought before the queen, Mary is said to have felt the child move inside her for the first time.
Her household drew the obvious comparison.
In the Gospel of Luke, when the Virgin Mary greets her cousin Elizabeth, the baby in Elizabeth’s womb leaps for joy.
Here was a Mary, greeted by a messenger of the Church, and a baby who leapt at his words.
The news of the quickening was announced to the court and to the city.
At the end of November, a Te Deum, the great hymn of thanksgiving, was sung at St. Paul’s Cathedral, and churches across England were ordered to pray for the queen’s safe delivery.
On November 30, in the great chamber at Whitehall, Pole formally absolved England of its break with Rome, while the king, the queen and both houses of Parliament knelt before him.
Soon afterward, Parliament passed an act providing that if the queen died leaving a child under age, Philip would govern the realm as its guardian until the child was grown.
But in the dispatches that foreign ambassadors were sending home, a different tone was beginning to creep in.
The French ambassador, Antoine de Noailles, whose king had every reason to hope the pregnancy would fail, wrote that many people at court did not believe it.
He was not wrong.
—
## The fires that began the same winter
There is another thing that happened in England that winter, and it cannot be left out.
In the same Parliament that prayed for the queen’s child, the old laws against heresy were brought back.
On Monday, February 4, 1555, a preacher named John Rogers, who had helped prepare an English Bible, was burned at Smithfield, in London, before a large crowd, among them his wife and children.
Within the next week, three more Protestant clergymen were burned, in Coventry, in Gloucester and in the Suffolk town of Hadleigh.
It was the beginning of the persecution that would make Mary’s name a byword for centuries.
By the end of her reign, by the usual count, around two hundred and eighty people had been burned for their faith.
At the time, the two stories ran side by side.
The same parish churches that were ordered to pray for the safe birth of a Catholic heir were watching their neighbors arrested.
To Mary, the burnings and the baby were part of one great work: the return of England to God.
To many of her Protestant subjects, a child would mean that the fires would never stop.
Both sides were waiting for the same day.
And when spring came, the queen went to Hampton Court to wait for it.
—
## Taking her chamber
The rules for how an English queen gave birth had been written down two generations earlier, in the household ordinances drawn up for Henry VII’s court by his mother, Lady Margaret Beaufort.
They had been followed for Elizabeth of York, for Catherine of Aragon and for Jane Seymour, and now they were followed for Mary.
About a month before the birth was expected, the queen would “take her chamber.”
It was a ceremony as solemn as any in the court calendar.
The queen heard Mass in her chapel.
Then she was led in procession to her great chamber, where her lords and officers were gathered, and she was served with spiced wine and comfits.
A senior officer asked everyone present to pray that God would grant her a good hour, a safe delivery.
Then she passed through the doors into the inner rooms, and the men stopped at the threshold.
From that moment, by custom, only women would serve her.
Women would take the places of her chamberlain, her butlers and her ushers.
Messages from the king and the council would be passed to a woman at the door.
The rooms themselves had been prepared like a sanctuary.
The walls, the ceiling and even the floor were covered with rich hangings.
The windows were blocked, though one might be left so that it could be uncovered for a little light.
The old ordinances advised against tapestries with figures of people or animals, perhaps for fear that strange images might frighten the mother or mark the child, and plain cloth was preferred.
There was a great bed of state, and a smaller pallet bed beside it for the birth itself.
And there was the cradle.
Mary’s cradle, according to later writers, was magnificent, richly carved and gilded and hung with fine cloth.
On it, they say, someone had inscribed a short verse in English, a prayer that God would preserve in health the child He had sent to Mary, “to England’s joy.”
Around it, the household was ready.
Midwives had been engaged.
Wet nurses had been chosen.
There were nurses for the child, and women called rockers whose only job would be to rock the royal cradle.
In April 1555, Queen Mary went into that room.
She would not come out again for more than three months.
—
## The letters with the date left blank
Somewhere outside the chamber, in the offices of the queen’s secretaries, clerks were at work on another part of the preparations.
When a royal child was born, the news had to go out at once, to the pope, to the emperor, to the kings of France and Portugal, to the doge of Venice, to the great cities and courts of Europe.
There was no time to write dozens of formal letters by hand after the birth.
So they were written beforehand.
The letters announced, in the name of King Philip and Queen Mary, that it had pleased Almighty God to deliver the queen of a prince, and they asked the recipient to give thanks with them.
Each was copied out in a fine secretary’s hand.
Each was ready to be signed and sealed.
And in each, there was a gap where the date should have been, to be filled in on the happy day.
Historians who have studied the surviving letters have noticed something else about them.
The word for the child was written as “prince,” but, by some accounts, a little space seems to have been left after it, so that a clerk could add the letters that would turn “prince” into “princess” if God chose to send a daughter instead.
Nobody in that office could have imagined that the date would never be filled in at all.
The letters stayed in their pile.
The weeks went by.
And then, on the last morning of April, someone in London decided that he could not wait any longer.
—
## April 30, 1555: the morning London rang its bells
Nobody knows exactly where the rumor started.
It came down the river from Hampton Court in the early hours of Tuesday, April 30, 1555, or it seemed to.
It moved the way news always moved in London, from the watermen at the stairs to the taverns by the river, from the taverns to the shops on Cheapside, from the shops to the churches.
The queen had been delivered.
It was a son.
It had been an easy birth, people said, with little pain, and the child was healthy and fair.
Picture the city that morning.
It was spring.
The days were getting long, the streets were muddy from April rain, and London was packed with something like seventy or eighty thousand people living almost on top of one another, inside and outside the old walls.
For months, every one of them had been ordered to pray for this moment.
And now, apparently, it had come.
Somewhere a parish clerk climbed his tower and began to pull on the bell rope.
Then another church took it up, and another.
London had more than a hundred parish churches, and on that morning, one after another, their bells began to ring.
The sound rolled out over the rooftops, over the river and the bridge, over the meadows beyond the walls.
People came out of their houses to find out what had happened.
In some churches, priests led their congregations in the Te Deum, the same hymn of thanksgiving that had been sung at St. Paul’s when the queen’s quickening was announced.
A later story, repeated by the Protestant writer John Foxe, claimed that one preacher had gone further still and described the newborn prince to his flock, how beautiful he was, how well formed, as if he had seen the child with his own eyes.
Whether that is true or not, the mood in the city was real.
By the afternoon, bonfires had been built in the streets.
Householders carried out tables and set them with food and wine for their neighbors, as Londoners did for a coronation or a great victory.
Protestants who had dreaded this day stayed indoors, or joined in the cheering because it was dangerous not to.
The news did not stay in London.
It crossed the Channel with the merchants and the couriers and reached the great trading city of Antwerp, in the Low Countries, where Philip’s family ruled.
There, too, bells were rung, and the English merchants celebrated, and the news began to travel toward the emperor himself.
Back at Hampton Court, none of it was true.
The queen was still sitting in her chamber.
Her belly was still large.
There was no prince.
There had been no labor, no birth, not even a false alarm that anyone could point to.
Messengers rode out to correct the story.
The bells stopped, one church at a time.
The bonfires burned down.
Somewhere, someone began quietly taking the tables back inside.
Nobody was ever able to say for certain who had started it, and the court never explained it.
Perhaps a servant had mistaken a busy morning at the palace for something more.
Perhaps a messenger had been too eager.
But the people of London had now celebrated the birth of a child who did not exist, and they would not easily forget it.
From that day, the whispers in the city changed.
They were no longer about whether the baby would be a boy or a girl.
They were about whether there was a baby at all.
—
## The prisoner brought to Hampton Court
Around the same time, a small group of riders arrived at Hampton Court from the west, escorting a young woman who had been a prisoner for more than a year.
It was Elizabeth.
She had been brought from Woodstock on the queen’s orders.
If Mary died in childbirth, which every woman knew she might, Elizabeth would be the next queen, and it was far safer to have her within reach than a hundred miles away in Oxfordshire.
If Mary lived and the child lived, Elizabeth would be a guest at her half-sister’s triumph.
Either way, she was installed in rooms of her own at the palace, and for weeks she waited to be called.
The meeting finally came, according to the most famous account, late one night in May.
Elizabeth was summoned at about ten o’clock and taken by torchlight through the gardens and up a back stair into the queen’s bedchamber.
She knelt.
She told Mary that she was, and always had been, the queen’s true and loyal subject.
Mary is said to have answered coldly, and at one point to have murmured in Spanish that God alone knew the truth.
The story, told decades later by Foxe, adds one more detail: that King Philip was hidden behind a tapestry, listening to every word.
It may be a legend.
But there is something true in it.
Philip had every reason to want to know Elizabeth.
His advisers were already thinking about what would happen if the queen had no child, and whether Elizabeth, rather than some French-backed claimant, might have to be the one who came next.
In the sealed room at Hampton Court, the two daughters of Henry VIII faced each other across a few feet of carpet.
One of them was thirty-nine, unwell, and waiting for a child who was already weeks late.
The other was twenty-one, healthy, and waiting for nothing.
Both of them, surely, were counting.
—
## The weeks the doctors kept recounting
By the middle of May, the court had settled into a strange and anxious routine.
Every morning, the great people waiting in the outer rooms asked for news, and every morning the answer was the same.
Not yet.
The physicians had expected the birth in early May.
When May passed, they recalculated.
Perhaps the queen had conceived later than they had thought.
Perhaps she had miscounted her weeks.
They moved the date to the end of May, and then into June.
Processions went around the courtyards of the palace, with priests and choirs singing prayers for a safe delivery, and the queen is said to have shown herself at a window so that the crowd could see she was well.
In London, the churches kept praying.
There were more processions through the city streets, with the clergy, the lord mayor and the guilds in their liveries, all pleading with God to send the child.
And inside the chamber, the queen sat on the floor.
The Venetian ambassador, Giovanni Michieli, reported the scene in his dispatches home, and his description is the one historians always come back to.
He wrote, in effect, that the queen spent hour after hour sitting on cushions on the floor, with her knees drawn up to her chin, and that no woman truly near her time could have sat like that without great pain.
It is a small detail.
It is also devastating.
Michieli had not been inside the room.
He must have heard it from someone who had, one of the women who served the queen, or someone who had spoken to them.
Which means that the women in that chamber had noticed.
Think about what they saw, day after day.
They were experienced women.
The midwives had sat with dozens, perhaps hundreds, of mothers through the last weeks of pregnancy.
They knew how a woman near her time moved, heavily and carefully.
They knew how she breathed, how she slept, how she could not bend.
They knew where a baby should sit in the body at nine months, and what it felt like to lay a hand on a belly and feel a child turn under it.
And the queen sat with her knees under her chin.
Some reports said that her belly was not growing any larger, and that by the summer it had begun to go down.
The midwives had been sworn to tell the truth about what they saw.
But this was the Queen of England.
Her pregnancy had been announced in every church in the kingdom.
It had been celebrated with a Te Deum at St. Paul’s.
It had been written into an act of Parliament.
The king was waiting in the next rooms, and the ambassadors of Europe were waiting in the courtyards, and every one of them was watching the women who came out of that door.
To say what they saw would not just be bad news.
It would be to tell the queen, and her husband, and the world, that God had not answered her prayers.
For Mary, who believed with her whole heart that God had chosen her to save England, that might have been the cruelest thing anyone could say.
So the midwives said what midwives everywhere say when a birth is late.
Be patient.
The time will come.
Perhaps the queen has counted wrong.
One of the women who had been with Mary longest, her old friend and attendant Susan Clarencius, is said to have encouraged the queen’s belief for as long as she could, and then, as the weeks dragged on, to have grown silent.
Outside the palace, people were less careful.
The rumors became wild.
Some said the queen was dead and her death was being kept secret.
The French ambassador gleefully passed on whatever he heard.
People who said out loud that there was no child risked arrest.
And Foxe later printed a story that a woman named Isabel Malt, who gave birth to a son in London in June, had been approached by men from the court and asked to hand over her newborn baby, so that it could be passed off as the queen’s.
There is no reliable evidence for that story, and many historians think it was simply the kind of tale people tell when a palace stops telling the truth.
But it tells us what London had begun to believe.
June turned into July.
The doctors counted again.
It was now nearly ten months since the queen’s courses had stopped.
In her prayer book, there was a prayer for a woman with child.
A story told long afterward claims that the page was worn and stained, as if someone had wept over it again and again.
Nobody can prove that either.
But it is not hard to imagine her there, in the candlelight, in the hot and airless room, turning to that page.
In the corner, the cradle waited.
The rockers had nothing to rock.
The wet nurses had nothing to feed.
The letters to the princes of Europe lay in their pile, with the date still blank.
And the midwives, who had sworn to God that they would tell the truth, stood by the door with their hands folded and said nothing at all.
By the end of July, even Mary must have known.
She never said so.
Nobody said so.
Instead, at the beginning of August, the court simply packed up and left.
—
## The morning the court left for Oatlands
There was no announcement.
There was no statement from the council, no proclamation, no word sent to the churches that had been praying for four months.
In the first days of August 1555, the queen came out of her chamber, and the royal household moved from Hampton Court to the much smaller palace of Oatlands, a few miles away in Surrey.
The official reason was that Hampton Court needed to be cleaned.
After months of hundreds of courtiers living on top of one another in summer heat, that was probably true.
But everybody understood what it meant.
Oatlands did not have the rooms for a royal lying-in.
Nobody moves a queen in the last days of her pregnancy to a house that cannot hold her midwives.
The pregnancy was over, and it had ended in nothing.
There was no birth to report, so there was nothing to report.
The lords and ladies who had been waiting since spring went home.
The ambassadors wrote their dispatches.
The letters with the blank dates went back into a chest.
Mary returned to public life as if nothing had happened.
She was, by all accounts, thinner and more drawn than ever, and her ladies noticed that she wept often when she thought no one could see.
What she could not do was keep her husband.
Philip had stayed in England for more than a year, far longer than he had wanted, waiting for a son.
His father, Charles V, was exhausted and preparing to give up his crowns.
There was war with France to manage.
At the end of August 1555, Philip left.
Mary went with him down the river to Greenwich, and there, according to the reports, she said goodbye to him and then stood at a window and watched as he went on toward the coast, until she could not see him anymore.
She told everyone he would be back soon.
He did not come back for a year and a half.
—
## The second time, and the will she wrote for the dangers of childbirth
Philip returned to England in March 1557.
He was King of Spain now, and he needed English money and English soldiers for his war with France.
He stayed for about four months, and then he was gone again, and this time he never came back.
Within a few months, Mary believed that she was pregnant once more.
She wrote to Philip with the news early in 1558.
This time, almost nobody at court believed her.
That January, the French had captured Calais, England’s last possession on the continent, held for more than two hundred years.
It was a humiliation that the queen took personally, and a chronicler later claimed she said that when she was dead and opened, they would find Calais lying in her heart.
In March 1558, Mary made her will.
In it, she wrote that she was making her arrangements because of the great danger that, by God’s ordinance, awaits all women in their travail of children.
She was forty-two years old, and she still believed, or tried to believe, that a child was coming.
She left instructions for the guardianship of the heir she hoped to bear.
Once again, there was no child.
By the autumn of 1558, the queen was seriously ill, and an epidemic of fever was sweeping through England.
In early November, her council pressed her to name her successor, and at last she accepted that it would be Elizabeth.
She died early in the morning on Thursday, November 17, 1558, at St. James’s Palace in London.
She was forty-two.
A few hours later, across the river at Lambeth, Cardinal Pole, the man whose arrival had once made her feel her baby leap, died too.
Elizabeth was at Hatfield when the news reached her.
The story goes that she was sitting under an oak tree in the park when the lords arrived, and that she knelt and quoted a psalm: this is the Lord’s doing, and it is marvelous in our eyes.
That evening, the bells of London rang, and the people lit bonfires in the streets.
Some of them may have remembered the last time they had done it.
—
## What the midwives knew
So what was the queen really carrying?
We will never know for certain.
No examination was ever recorded, and no royal body in the sixteenth century was described in the kind of detail a modern doctor would need.
But historians and doctors who have studied the evidence have made a few suggestions.
The most common is that Mary suffered from what is now called pseudocyesis, or phantom pregnancy.
It is a real condition, still seen today, in which a woman who desperately wants a child develops many of the signs of pregnancy: the stopping of her monthly cycle, nausea, a swollen belly, enlarged breasts, and even the sensation of a baby moving inside her.
It is most often found in women under terrible pressure to conceive, and few women in history were under more pressure than Mary.
Others have suggested a physical cause.
Some have pointed to a tumor in the pituitary gland, which can stop a woman’s cycle and cause her body to behave as if she were pregnant.
Others have suggested a growth in the womb or the ovaries, which could explain the swelling, the illness of her final years, and perhaps even her death.
What the midwives in that sealed room knew was simpler.
They knew that the queen did not move like a woman near her time.
They knew that a woman nine months gone could not sit for hours with her knees beneath her chin.
They knew, by the end of June, that the dates were not just late but impossible.
And they knew that nobody in England had the power to say so out loud, not the physicians, not the ladies, not the council, and certainly not the women who had been brought into the chamber to deliver the heir to the throne.
Every one of them had sworn to God to tell the truth about what happened in a birthing room.
In the end, they told it the only way they could.
They let the summer pass.
They let the court move to Oatlands.
They let the silence say it for them.
And the letters?
The letters with the blank dates were never sent.
They went into the files of the queen’s government, and from there into the great collection of state papers that became, over the centuries, part of England’s national archives.
By most accounts, some of them are still there today: formal letters in a clerk’s careful hand, announcing to the princes of Europe the joyful birth of an English prince, with a gap where the day should be.
They are the only birth announcements ever written for Mary’s child.
—
## A cradle with no child in it
Go back, one last time, to that room at Hampton Court.
The tapestry over the windows.
The fire burning in the summer heat.
The smell of beeswax and herbs.
A midwife by the door, her hands folded in her apron, waiting for a birth she already knew would not come.
The queen on her cushions on the floor, with her knees drawn up to her chin.
And beside the bed, the gilded cradle, with its little verse asking God to keep the child He had sent to Mary, to England’s joy.
Mary had spent her childhood watching her mother lose one baby after another.
She had spent her youth being told that she herself should never have been born.
She had won a throne no one expected her to win, and she had believed with all her heart that God would give her one more miracle.
London rang its bells for that miracle on a spring morning in 1555.
It never arrived.
The cradle was never used.
The letters were never dated.
And the women who stood in that sealed room, who had promised God they would always tell the truth about what they saw, are the only people who knew it from the beginning.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Mary I was born on February 18, 1516, became queen in July 1553, married Philip of Spain at Winchester on July 25, 1554, and died at St. James’s Palace on November 17, 1558.
Her pregnancy was believed in from the autumn of 1554, celebrated publicly that November, and provided for in an act of Parliament naming Philip guardian of any child who survived her; the quickening at Pole’s arrival comes from contemporary reports.
She withdrew to her chamber at Hampton Court in April 1555; the exact day varies between accounts.
The false report of a birth on April 30, 1555, with bells, bonfires and celebrations in London and as far as Antwerp, is recorded at the time; the preacher who described the baby comes from later Protestant writing.
The prepared birth announcements with blank dates are reported to survive among the English state papers; the space left to turn “prince” into “princess” is given as usually told and has not been checked against the documents here.
Elizabeth’s late-night meeting with Mary comes mainly from John Foxe, and Philip hidden behind a tapestry may be legend.
Michieli’s description of the queen on her cushions is paraphrased; Susan Clarencius’s role, the story of Isabel Malt, the tear-stained prayer book, the queen at the window and the wording of the cradle verse are later or uncertain traditions.
The move to Oatlands in early August 1555, Philip’s departure at the end of that month, the second pregnancy of 1557 and 1558 and the will of March 1558 are documented; the Calais remark comes from a chronicle.
The suggested causes of her false pregnancies, pseudocyesis, a pituitary tumor or a growth in the womb or ovaries, are modern speculation.
The burnings began with John Rogers at Smithfield on February 4, 1555; around two hundred and eighty is the commonly cited total.
The midwife’s training, tools, beliefs and oath come from general evidence about Tudor childbirth; the best-known surviving English midwife’s oath dates from 1567, and the ceremony of taking the chamber follows the household ordinances of Henry VII’s court.
The midwife in the opening scene is a reconstruction; the names of Mary’s midwives are not well recorded, and the image with this story is an artistic reconstruction, not a portrait from life.