They Strung The Sheriff’s Daughter From The Cottonwood… One Drifter Decided He’d Seen Enough
By four o’clock the rope had stopped hurting and started doing something worse.
Thea Hartsell could no longer feel her hands.
She could feel the bark of the cottonwood limb through the rope, a slow grinding every time the wind moved the branch, and she could feel the hard Montana sun coming in low and gold across the corral, and she could feel the dust in her mouth.
But her hands were somewhere above her head, tied at the wrists and lashed to the limb, and they had stopped sending her any news at all.
Her boots touched the ground.
Barely.
If she stood on her toes, the weight came off her shoulders for a while.
If she let her heels down, the rope took her arms and pulled.
She had spent four hours choosing between those two things, and she had learned to do it without making a sound, because every sound she made was a gift to the three men sitting in the shade of the old freight barn.
It was Thursday, the twenty-third of August, 1883, at the abandoned stage corral on the Yellowstone bottom below Coulson, two miles east of the new railroad town of Billings, Montana Territory.
The barn behind her had not held a horse since the spring.
Two freight wagons and a man on a mule had come by on the river road since noon.
All of them had looked.
None of them had stopped.
She was wearing a new dress.
That was the part that shamed her, if anything did.
It was cream cotton with a tiny printed sprig and lace at the sleeves, made for the reception the town was planning when the railroad’s excursion trains came through in September, and the dressmaker had talked her into wearing it home from the last fitting so the hem would settle.
It was a dress for a ballroom.
It was hanging under a tree.
At four o’clock a man rode up out of the willows along the river and stopped his buckskin horse on the other side of the corral fence.
He did not hurry.
He looked at her for a long moment from the saddle, and then at the barn, and then at the rope where it came down from the limb and was tied off to the old snubbing post in the middle of the corral.
Then he got down, walked to the fence, and laid one gloved hand on the top of the post.
Thea lifted her chin and looked straight back at him.
“Look all you like, mister. Everybody else did.”
He did not look away and he did not smile.
“How long have you been hanging there?”
She thought about lying, and could not find the strength for it.
“Since noon. They want my father’s prisoner.”
He took that in the way some men take in weather.
Then he glanced once more at the barn, where three rifles had come up out of the shade, and back to her.
“Then I’ll wait here with you till sundown.”
And to her astonishment, and to the visible astonishment of the three men in the barn, he did not cut her down.
He climbed up and sat on the fence.
—
## Why a stranger would sit on a fence instead of cutting the rope
Here is what nobody in Billings understood until it was over.
The man on the fence was not being cautious, and he was not being a coward, and he was not waiting for help.
He had read that corral in the time it took to swing down off his horse, and he had seen the one thing the three men in the barn had built the whole afternoon around.
And before the sun went down behind the Rimrocks that evening, Thea Hartsell, still hanging from that limb, would hear something through the wall of the old barn that would turn the whole trade inside out.
Because the man who had strung her up did not want his brother back.
He wanted him dead.
To understand how a sheriff’s daughter ended up under a cottonwood in her best dress, you have to go back to a freight wagon on the Coulson road, ten weeks earlier, and a young man sitting on its seat with the reins in his hands and a dead man’s mules standing in the traces.
—
## What the sheriff found on the Coulson road in June
Billings, in the summer of 1883, was barely a year old, and already called itself the Magic City.
The Northern Pacific had laid out the town in 1882 on a flat of sagebrush two miles upriver from Coulson, and Coulson had simply started to die.
Its saloons moved upriver on wagons.
Its stores followed.
Yellowstone County had been organized that spring, with Billings as its seat, and the county had a sheriff.
His name was Winslow Hartsell.
He was fifty-eight, a widower, a slow-talking man from Missouri who had kept a store in Coulson, and he had never been known to hurry a decision.
He believed in warrants.
He believed a man was owed a trial before he was owed a rope, and that belief had gotten him shot at twice.
He had one child.
Thea had been eleven when her mother died of a fever, and she had kept her father’s books since she was fourteen.
When he pinned on the sheriff’s star, she came with it.
She copied his warrants, kept the jail ledger, and carried the prisoners their dinners from the Headquarters Hotel, because the county could not afford a cook.
On the ninth of June, a Norwegian freighter named Halvor Ostby was shot dead on the Coulson road.
He had been hauling for the railroad’s grading contractors all spring, a big, quiet man who never carried a gun.
They found him in the sagebrush half a mile from the river, and his wagon and his four good mules were gone.
Sheriff Hartsell found the wagon the next morning, eleven miles south, near the ford of the Clarks Fork.
There was a young man sitting on the seat.
He was twenty-two years old, red-eyed, with the reins in his hands and nowhere at all to go.
His name was Davy Sayle.
And when the sheriff asked him who had killed Halvor Ostby, he said nothing.
He said nothing that day.
He said nothing for ten weeks.
—
## The brother who never visited the jail
Everybody in the valley knew the Sayles.
Wilder Sayle ran cattle and horses on the Clarks Fork, south of the river, and he was the kind of man who could make a room laugh with a story and then make it go quiet with a look.
He was forty-five.
Davy was his half-brother, twenty-three years younger, sent west at sixteen to work for a brother he barely knew.
Wilder hired the best lawyer in Billings for Davy the day after the arrest.
He did not visit him once.
Thea noticed that, the way she noticed a column in the jail ledger that did not add up.
Every evening she carried a tin plate down the stone steps to the cell at the end, and every evening Davy Sayle stood up when she came in, which no other prisoner had ever done, and thanked her for his supper.
She asked him once, in July, why his brother never came.
Davy turned the tin spoon over in his fingers for a long time.
“Wilder never in his life gave me anything he didn’t want back,” he said finally.
That was all he said.
It was more than he had said to the lawyer.
In the middle of August, the county attorney went down the stone steps himself, sat on an upturned bucket outside Davy’s cell for an hour, and told him plainly what everyone in Billings suspected.
That Davy had not killed Halvor Ostby.
That somebody else had, and Davy had been told to drive the wagon away.
That the district judge would arrive on the train on Monday the twenty-seventh, and that a young man who told the truth before Monday might hang for nothing, while a young man who kept his mouth shut after Monday might hang for murder.
Davy Sayle listened to all of it.
He said he would think.
The county attorney mentioned the conversation that evening at the bar of the Headquarters Hotel, to a man he trusted.
By Wednesday night, it had reached the Clarks Fork.
On Thursday morning, Thea Hartsell rode to Coulson for the last fitting of a dress.
—
## The note pushed under the jail door at half past twelve
She never saw them clearly.
She remembered the dressmaker’s porch, and her sorrel mare picking her way along the river road under the cottonwoods with the reins loose, and the smell of the river.
Then a horse came out of the willows on her left, and another one on her right, and before she had her hand on the little pistol her father made her carry, a man the size of a woodstove had her by the arm and out of the saddle.
They did not hit her.
They were careful with her in a way that had nothing to do with kindness.
The big one held her.
A thin, quick one with a sunburned face tied her wrists in front of her with a length of new rope, laughing the whole time.
And a third one, older, in a black coat buttoned to the throat, stood watching with a little Bible in his hand and said, to nobody in particular, “Whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.”
She learned their names over the next hours, because they used them.
The big one was Ott Mullane.
The thin one was Dory Pardee.
The one with the Bible, the others called the Deacon, and his name, she found out later, was Starling Crabtree.
They took her a mile downriver to the dead stage station, threw the rope over the cottonwood limb, and hauled her up until her boots were just brushing the dirt.
Ott Mullane tied the end of the rope off to the snubbing post in the corral.
Then Dory Pardee rode off toward Billings with a folded paper in his shirt.
At half past twelve, a drunk from the Coulson saloons, who had been paid a silver dollar and told nothing, pushed that paper under the door of the sheriff’s office.
Winslow Hartsell read it standing up.
*Bring Davy to the Coulson stage corral at sundown. Alone. No deputies, no posse, no railroad men. You bring the boy, we cut her down. You don’t, she stays up there all night, and the next night, and the one after that.*
It was not signed.
It did not need to be.
—
## The man who had passed by on the other side once
The stranger sat on the top rail of the corral fence with his forearms on his knees and his gloved hands hanging loose, and for a long time he said nothing at all.
He looked to be about forty.
He wore a long canvas coat, dark olive-brown and oiled against the weather, faded at the shoulders, open over a dark shirt, and a dark brown hat with a wide brim that had been rained on more than once.
His beard was short and dark.
His face was weathered in the particular way of a man who had spent more nights outdoors than in.
Whatever gun he carried was somewhere under that long coat, and he made no move to show it.
Behind the saddle of the buckskin, rolled tight and tied with a thong, was a wool poncho the color of old moss.
Dory Pardee came out of the barn first, rifle in the crook of his arm.
“You can ride on, mister. This here’s private business.”
The stranger looked at him with mild interest.
“Doesn’t look private. Looks like it’s out in the sun where anybody on the road can see it.”
“That’s the idea,” Pardee said, and grinned.
“Then I’m doing what you want. I’m seeing it.”
Pardee did not have an answer for that.
He looked back at the barn.
Ott Mullane had come out too and was standing by the snubbing post with one huge hand resting on the rope, the way a man rests his hand on a dog.
The Deacon stayed in the shade of the doorway, his rifle across his knees and his little Bible open on top of it.
“Go on,” the Deacon called out.
His voice was soft and dry. “‘And by chance there came down a certain priest that way: and when he saw him, he passed by on the other side.’ Be that priest, friend. The Lord won’t hold it against you. Nobody else has.”
For the first time, something moved in the stranger’s face.
“I’ve been that priest,” he said.
“Once. I didn’t care for it.”
He took the canteen off his saddle horn, climbed down inside the corral, and walked to the cottonwood.
Ott Mullane’s hand tightened on the rope.
Three rifles came up.
The stranger did not look at any of them.
He lifted the canteen to Thea’s mouth, slowly, so that she could drink without choking, and he held it there until she turned her head away.
Then he stepped back exactly as far as he had come and looked up at the knot on her wrists, and then across at the snubbing post, and then at Ott Mullane’s hand.
“That post’s the whole game, isn’t it,” he said quietly, to no one.
Thea did not understand him.
She would.
He climbed back up and sat on the fence, and by the end of that first half hour the three men in the barn had begun to look at one another the way men do when a plan has run into something it was not built for.
—
## Why a dead woman was worth nothing to anybody
At half past four, the stranger spoke to Ott Mullane.
He did it conversationally, the way a man might mention the price of oats.
“Your boss wants a trade at sundown. Is that right?”
Mullane looked at Pardee.
Pardee shrugged.
“That’s right.”
“The sheriff brings his prisoner, you cut her down.”
“That’s right.”
“Then you’d better let out about a foot of that rope,” the stranger said.
“Because she’s been on her toes four hours, and her color’s gone, and if she faints with her arms up like that she can stop breathing. And then the sheriff rides in at sundown and finds you standing under a dead woman, and he doesn’t hand you anybody. He just starts shooting. And your boss is going to want to know whose hand was on the rope.”
The silence after that went on for a long time.
Ott Mullane’s face slowly took on the look of somebody who has just been shown a hole in the floor he was about to step into.
He looked at the Deacon.
The Deacon closed his Bible on one finger and considered the sky.
“Let it out,” the Deacon said at last.
“A foot. No more.”
Mullane untied the rope from the snubbing post, let it slide through his hands, and tied it off again.
Thea’s heels came down onto the dirt.
The weight was gone from her shoulders, and the blood came back into her arms like hot needles, and she pressed her lips together until they went white, and did not make a sound.
The stranger watched her do it.
“Good,” he said, very low, so that only she could hear.
“Don’t give them a thing.”
“Who are you?” she whispered.
“Somebody waiting for sundown.”
“That’s not a name.”
“No,” he agreed.
“It isn’t.”
He told her later that his name was Zeb Ashlock.
What he did tell her then, in a voice so low it barely carried past the cottonwood, was a string of questions about the three men in the barn.
How many horses.
Which way Pardee had ridden.
Whether she had heard the name Wilder.
She had.
“He said Wilder wouldn’t come down off the bluff till the boy was in sight,” she said.
“The thin one. He said it like a joke.”
Zeb Ashlock nodded slowly, as if a piece had gone into a place he had already measured for it.
His eyes went once, briefly, to Dory Pardee’s horse, standing hipshot in the shade at the end of the barn, with a bedroll behind the cantle and, tied along the near side of the saddle, a long-handled spade with a new ash handle and a blade that had never touched dirt.
He did not say anything about it.
But he looked at it for a long time.
—
## What she heard through the barn wall at five o’clock
At five o’clock, the stranger got down off the fence, walked his buckskin to the river, and let it drink.
He was gone perhaps twenty minutes, and he did not take everything with him.
He had untied the moss-green poncho from his saddle before he went, and hung it on the corner post of the corral, where all three of them could see it.
The Deacon looked at that poncho for a long time.
Then the two of them, Pardee and the Deacon, went around the back of the barn where the old harness room was, out of the sun, to smoke.
The harness room had a plank wall, and the plank wall was ten feet from the cottonwood, and between two of the planks there was a crack the width of a finger where a knot had fallen out years ago.
Thea did not try to listen.
She did not have to.
“…soon as we’re across the river,” Pardee was saying.
“That’s what he said. Soon as we’re past the Clarks Fork ford and nobody’s looking back.”
“I heard what he said.”
“Boy talked to the county attorney a whole hour, Deacon. A whole hour. You think he sat there an hour saying nothing?”
“I think,” the Deacon said slowly, “that a man who’ll hang a woman to get his brother back and then put that same brother in the ground at the ford is a man the Lord has His eye on.”
He was quiet a moment.
“But Wilder pays in gold. And the Lord pays in promises.”
Pardee laughed.
“That’s why I brought the shovel.”
Thea stood very still under the cottonwood, with her heels in the dust and her arms over her head, and the whole afternoon turned over inside her like a card on a table.
It had never been a rescue.
Wilder Sayle did not want his brother out of jail because he loved him.
He wanted him out of the stone building where the county attorney could sit on a bucket and talk to him, and away from Monday’s train and the district judge, and down to the Clarks Fork ford in the dark, where a young man who had decided to tell the truth could be put somewhere he would never tell anything at all.
And afterward, everybody in Billings would say that the boy had run, and that it was a shame.
Her father would believe it, too.
She looked toward the river.
Zeb Ashlock was coming back up through the willows, leading the buckskin, and he did not look at her at all.
But when he got to the fence, he hung his hat on the post next to the poncho, ran a hand over his face in the heat, and said to the air, in that same low voice:
“Well?”
“They’re going to kill him,” she whispered.
“At the ford. After.”
He nodded once.
“I know,” he said.
“Now somebody’s got to tell Davy.”
—
## The quiet that follows a man who rides past
They had two hours and a little more until sundown, and for most of it he talked to her.
Not about the men in the barn.
Not about the trade.
He talked, she realized much later, the way you talk to someone to keep them awake on a cold night, steadily and about nothing, so that she would have something to hold on to besides the rope.
He talked about horses, and the Gallatin valley in October.
And once, when the sun had gone orange and the shadows of the cottonwood had stretched across the corral to the barn, he told her why he had stopped.
“Six years ago I rode shotgun for the stage line on the Bozeman road,” he said.
“Strongbox on the floor between my feet. Company rule was simple. You do not stop the coach. Not for a man in the road, not for a fire, not for a woman waving her apron. Bandits had used all of those.”
She waited.
“We came around a bend on Dry Creek, and there was a man tied to a wagon wheel by the side of the road, out in the sun. Six or seven riders sitting their horses around him. One of them had a little Bible. He waved us on. Said they’d caught a horse thief and were teaching him a lesson.”
The stranger was looking at the river, not at her.
“The driver looked at me. I looked at the strongbox. And we drove on by.”
“What happened to him?”
“He wasn’t a horse thief. They found that out three days later, when the real thief sold the horse in Bozeman.”
He was quiet a while.
“By then it didn’t matter to him anymore.”
Thea looked at the rolled hat on the fence post, the green poncho, the gloved hands.
“So you quit,” she said.
“I quit the stage line. I went back to Dry Creek and found the men who’d been sitting their horses around that wheel, one at a time, and brought them in front of a judge. Took me two years. The Helena papers wanted my name for the stories. I didn’t give it to them.”
He shrugged.
“So they made one up.”
“What did they call you?”
He did not answer that.
“There’s a particular kind of quiet,” he said instead, “that follows a man who rides past something he shouldn’t have. You hear it at night. You hear it in the morning when you’re shaving. I got tired of it, Miss Hartsell. I’d rather carry a bullet than carry that.”
In the doorway of the barn, the Deacon had stopped reading.
He was looking at the stranger’s back, and at the green poncho on the post, and his lips were moving very slightly, the way a man’s lips move when he is trying to remember a face.
—
## Why somebody ties a new shovel to a saddle on a hot day
At a quarter past seven, a rider came down off the Rimrocks.
The rider stopped where the trail met the bottom and sat his horse in the last of the sun, a tall man in a pale hat, with two more men behind him.
“That’s him,” Thea said.
“That’s Wilder.”
“I know.”
“How do you know?”
“Because he’s the only man in this whole valley,” Zeb Ashlock said, “who’s sitting where he can see the trade, and the ford, and the road to town, all at the same time.”
At half past seven, her father came.
He rode in from the west along the river road, alone, with a shotgun across his saddle and a led horse behind him, and on the led horse sat Davy Sayle, his hands cuffed in front of him.
He had done exactly what they told him, because they had his daughter, and Thea saw from forty yards away what it had cost him, and it nearly undid her when seven hours of rope had not.
He saw her.
He saw the stranger on the fence.
He reined in at the corral gate, and for a moment the two men looked at one another, the sheriff with the shotgun and the stranger in the long coat, and something passed between them that Thea did not understand.
“Who are you?” her father said.
“Just a man waiting on the sundown,” said the stranger.
“Same as you.”
Down on the bottom, Wilder Sayle had started his horse forward at a walk.
—
## Sundown at the Coulson corral
The sun touched the long sandstone rim of the Rimrocks to the west at seventeen minutes before eight.
Afterward, Thea could remember every second of what followed, and she could remember it the way you remember a dream, too bright and too slow, every sound by itself.
Wilder Sayle rode up to the far side of the corral with his two riders behind him and stopped thirty feet from the gate.
Up close he was handsomer than she had expected, sunburned and easy in the saddle, with a pale hat and pale eyes and a good gray suit coat over a cartridge belt.
He did not look at his brother.
He looked at the sheriff, and then at the stranger on the fence, and his smile did not change at all.
“Who’s that?”
“Says he’s waiting on the sundown,” Dory Pardee called from the barn.
“Well, it’s here.”
Wilder touched his hat to the sheriff.
“Evening, Win. Send the boy across.”
Winslow Hartsell did not move.
“Cut her down first.”
“Boy first. Then her. That was the deal.”
“There wasn’t any deal. There was a note.”
“Then read it again,” Wilder said pleasantly.
“Ott?”
Ott Mullane put both of his huge hands on the rope at the snubbing post.
Thea felt it before she saw it, the rope going tight again above her head, her heels lifting from the dust, the weight pulling at her shoulders.
She did not cry out.
She had decided hours ago that she would never cry out in front of these men.
But her father saw her heels come up off the ground, and his face went gray, and he reached across without a word and unlocked the cuffs on Davy Sayle’s wrists.
“Go on, son,” he said, and his voice had nothing left in it at all.
Davy Sayle slid down off the led horse.
He stood for a moment in the corral gate, rubbing his wrists, looking at the brother who had never once come down the stone steps to see him.
Wilder smiled at him and held out a hand, and nodded toward the spare horse one of his riders was leading.
“Come on, Davy. Let’s go home.”
Davy took one step.
“Davy.”
It was Thea who said it.
Her voice came out cracked and hoarse from the dust and the hours, but it carried across that corral like a bell, and everybody in it turned to look at the woman hanging from the cottonwood.
“Davy, don’t go with him.”
Wilder laughed.
“She’d say anything, son. Her daddy’s got a case to make.”
“I heard them,” Thea said.
She was looking only at Davy.
“At five o’clock. Through the barn wall. Dory Pardee and the Deacon. They said as soon as you’re past the Clarks Fork ford. They said nobody would be looking back.”
Davy Sayle stopped.
“That’s a lie,” Wilder said, and for the first time his voice had an edge in it.
“You told me something once,” Thea said.
“In July. When I brought your supper. You said your brother never in his life gave you anything he didn’t want back.”
Nobody spoke.
The wind came up the river and moved the leaves of the cottonwood, and the limb above her head creaked, and somewhere in the willows a bird called once and stopped.
Davy turned and looked at her, and then at his brother, and his face was the face of a man standing at the edge of a cliff in the dark, feeling for the ground with one foot.
Then the stranger spoke, from the fence, in the same quiet voice he had used all afternoon.
“Davy. Look behind Dory Pardee’s saddle.”
Davy looked.
Everyone looked.
The spade hung along the near side of Pardee’s saddle in the last red light of the sun, its new ash handle pale as bone, its blade clean and bright, a long-handled shovel tied to a horse on a hot August evening ten miles from the nearest ditch.
“Nobody’s digging a well tonight,” Zeb Ashlock said.
“Ask him whose grave that’s for.”
The silence that followed was the longest Thea Hartsell had ever heard.
She watched it go into Davy Sayle’s face.
She watched him understand it the way she had understood it at five o’clock, all at once and all the way down, and she watched his hands, the hands that had held Halvor Ostby’s reins all night on the Clarks Fork road ten weeks before, begin very slightly to shake.
“Wilder,” he said.
“Wilder, what’s the shovel for?”
Wilder Sayle stopped smiling.
“Ott,” he said.
“Haul her up.”
Several things happened in the next two seconds, and Thea would spend the rest of her life telling them in the right order.
Ott Mullane set his feet and heaved on the rope.
The stranger’s right hand went under his long coat and came out, and there was one shot, flat and enormous in the evening, and the rope parted with a crack an inch above Ott Mullane’s fists, and Ott went over backward into the dirt with six feet of loose rope in his hands and a look of pure astonishment on his face.
The rope above Thea went slack.
Her arms came down.
She did not fall.
She would always be proud of that.
Her knees wanted to go and she did not let them.
She stood under the cottonwood with her tied wrists against her chest and the cut rope hanging from them like a bell pull, and she stayed standing.
By then the stranger’s revolver was resting on the top rail of the fence, perfectly still, and it was pointed at nobody at all, and everybody in that corral understood that it could be pointed at any one of them before they had time to blink.
Wilder Sayle’s hand was on the butt of his own gun.
It stayed there.
“Draw it if you like, Wilder,” the stranger said.
“Your brother will see you do it.”
In the doorway of the barn, the Deacon stood up.
His rifle was in his hands, and his little Bible had fallen in the dirt, and he was staring at the stranger the way a man stares at someone he has seen once, years ago, at the worst moment of his life.
“Dry Creek,” the Deacon said.
His voice had gone thin.
“The Bozeman road. ‘Seventy-seven. You were on the coach.”
He took a step back.
“You’re the one who came after. You’re the nameless gunslinger.”
The words went around the corral like wind through grass.
The Deacon laid his rifle down on the ground.
He did it slowly, the way a man lays down something heavy he has been carrying for a long time, and then he stepped away from it, and put his hands up, and did not say another word.
Dory Pardee looked at the Deacon, and at the rifle on the ground, and at the revolver on the fence rail.
He put his own rifle down beside it.
The two riders behind Wilder Sayle had already turned their horses and gone down the river road at a lope, and they did not look back.
Which left Wilder Sayle alone at the corral gate, with his hand on his gun, his brother six feet away from him, and the sheriff’s shotgun leveled at the middle of his good gray coat.
He took his hand off the gun.
“You can’t prove a thing,” he said to the sheriff.
“Not one thing.”
And Davy Sayle, who had not said one word to anybody about the ninth of June in ten weeks, turned to Winslow Hartsell and said, in a voice that was steady for the first time since he had climbed down off that freight wagon:
“He shot Halvor Ostby on the Coulson road. I held the horses. I’ll say so on Monday. I’ll say it to the judge.”
—
## The words Davy Sayle had been keeping in a stone cell
The district court sat in Billings that week in a rented hall over a hardware store, and there were more people trying to get up the stairs than the hall would hold.
Davy Sayle testified for two days.
He told it plainly.
That Halvor Ostby had seen Wilder’s men selling railroad mules with the contractor’s brand burned over, and had said he would tell.
That Wilder had waited for him on the Coulson road, and then handed Davy the reins and told him to drive the wagon south and burn it, and that Davy had driven all night and could not set the fire.
That he had kept quiet for ten weeks because some part of him believed his brother would come down those stone steps one day and explain.
His brother never had.
The only time he had come for him was with a shovel.
Thea Hartsell testified after him.
She told the court what she had heard through the harness-room wall, word for word, and she told it in a clear, even voice with her chin up, the way she had looked back at the people on the Coulson road, and when Wilder Sayle’s lawyer asked her whether a young woman who had been hanging from a tree for seven hours could really be trusted to remember a conversation exactly, she looked at him for a long moment.
“I had nothing else to do,” she said.
The courtroom laughed.
Even the judge smiled.
Starling Crabtree, the Deacon, testified for the territory.
He said he had waved a stagecoach past a wagon wheel on Dry Creek in 1877, and had been waiting six years for the man on that coach to come for him.
He got two years.
Ott Mullane and Dory Pardee got five years apiece for the kidnapping, and the spade was entered into evidence with a paper tag tied to its new ash handle.
Wilder Sayle was convicted of the murder of Halvor Ostby and sentenced to the territorial penitentiary at Deer Lodge for the rest of his natural life.
He did not look at his brother when the sentence was read.
Davy Sayle pleaded guilty as an accessory after the fact and got eighteen months.
—
## Where the rope ended up
Zeb Ashlock stayed in Billings through the trial, because the county attorney asked him to, and because, he said, he had nowhere he particularly needed to be.
He testified for less than ten minutes.
He said that any man who rode in shooting would have killed her before he killed anybody else, so he had waited until he could see the whole game.
When Wilder Sayle’s lawyer asked him his occupation, he thought about it for a moment.
“Mostly I wait,” he said.
In the first days of September, the railroad’s excursion trains came through Billings on their way to the last-spike ceremony in the mountains, and that night there was a reception in the new hotel.
Thea Hartsell went to it in the cream dress.
She had thought about burning it, and decided she would not let three men and a cottonwood take one more thing from her.
She danced once, very late, with her father, who had not danced since her mother died.
The stranger was not there.
She had not really expected him to be.
He had come by the sheriff’s office that afternoon, before the trains, with the buckskin saddled and the green poncho rolled behind the cantle, and he had stood in the doorway with his hat in his hand.
“Trail runs west,” he had said.
“Always does.”
“You could stay. My father needs a deputy. He said so.”
“Your father needs a deputy who doesn’t have a story attached to him.”
He turned the hat in his gloved hands.
“This town’s going to be a good town, Miss Hartsell. It doesn’t need me standing in the middle of it, reminding everybody of an afternoon at Coulson.”
“What do I tell people, when they ask who you were?”
He thought about that.
“Tell them a man stopped,” he said.
“That’s the only part that matters.”
Then he put on his hat, and he went.
She never saw him again.
Now and then, over the years, she heard a story somebody’s cousin told about a stranger in a long coat in Dakota, or on the Musselshell, who had stopped his horse on a road where everybody else rode past.
She kept the rope.
Not all of it.
Just the end that had been around her wrists, the piece that had hung from them when the shot cut it, with the strands still frayed where the bullet had gone through an inch above Ott Mullane’s hands.
She kept it in the drawer of her desk in the county clerk’s office, where she worked for twenty-two years, and when young deputies came in and asked her about it, she told them.
She always told it the same way.
She told them about the people who had ridden by on the Coulson road and looked and kept riding, and about the priest who passed by on the other side.
And then she told them about a man in a long coat who rode up out of the willows at four o’clock and looked at her and did not look away.
“He didn’t cut me down,” she would say.
“Not right away. That’s the part people never understand.”
“Why not?” the young deputies always asked.
And Thea Hartsell would take the frayed piece of rope out of the drawer and lay it on the desk between them.
“Because cutting me down was the easy part,” she would say.
“Anybody could have done that. He waited to find out who else was going to hang.”
—
## What is real in this story, and what is told
The people in this story are invented, and so is the crime at its center.
There was no Sheriff Winslow Hartsell, no Wilder Sayle, no freighter named Halvor Ostby, and no stranger called Zeb Ashlock, and none of them should be confused with the real officers and settlers of Yellowstone County.
The country is real.
Coulson was a genuine river town on the Yellowstone that faded almost to nothing after the Northern Pacific laid out Billings two miles upriver in 1882, and Billings really did call itself the Magic City.
Yellowstone County was created in 1883, and the Northern Pacific completed its line across Montana that September.
The territorial penitentiary at Deer Lodge was real, too.
The parable the Deacon quotes is the Good Samaritan, from the tenth chapter of Luke.
The tree, and the rope, and the man who waited, belong to the story.