News

The Rancher Found Her in Trouble and Chose to Help… A Story About Kindness and Compassion

They had hung her from the dead cottonwood a little after eight o’clock in the morning, and by noon three wagons had passed her on the Tombstone road and not one of them had stopped.

It was the middle of June, 1883, in the Arizona Territory, and the sky over the San Pedro valley was a hard, bleached blue with nothing in it but one red-tailed hawk turning slow circles above the tree.

The old stage station at Ocotillo Wells had been empty for two years.

Its corral had fallen in on itself, a broken wagon wheel leaned against the last good post, and the adobe walls of the station house were melting back into the ground one rain at a time.

Only the cottonwood still stood, gray and barkless, its big limbs reaching out over the road like the arms of something that had died with its hands up.

The woman hung from the lowest limb by one ankle.

They had used her own lariat, a good braided rawhide rope her father had made, and they had tied her right foot to the limb so high that her leg went straight up along the rope, and the rest of her came down sideways toward the ground.

Her other foot was bare and planted in the dust.

One hand was flat on the hard earth, holding her up, and the arm had been shaking for an hour.

Her name was Marian Caskey, and she was twenty-seven years old.

She wore a gray-blue work dress with a row of small cloth buttons down the front, a dress made for riding fence and pulling calves, not for being looked at.

Before they hauled her up, she had done the only thing they let her do.

She had buckled her own leather belt hard around her skirts, so the cloth would stay where it belonged when the world turned over.

It had held.

It was the one thing all morning that had held.

The men who did it had not hurt her face.

They had been careful about that, the way men are careful when they intend to come back and talk business.

“You’ll remember where your daddy put his papers,” the big one, Bodie Strunk, had said, while the other two laughed and tied the knot, “when the sun’s done talking to you.”

Then they had ridden off toward the Whetstone foothills, toward her own ranch, to tear it apart while she hung there.

The first wagon had come by around nine.

It was an ore wagon bound for the mills at Contention, twelve mules and a driver she had known by sight for four years.

He had looked at her.

He had looked at the tracks of three horses going south.

Then he had shaken out his whip and driven on, and she had heard him start to whistle, loud, the way a man whistles when he wants to be somewhere else.

The second wagon was a family.

A mother put her hand over a little boy’s eyes.

The father never turned his head.

After that Marian stopped calling to the wagons.

She was saving her voice for when it mattered, and she was beginning to understand that it might never matter again.

—

## The Man Who Looked Away

The rider came up the road from the north a little before noon.

He was not in a hurry.

He was a lean, weathered man somewhere near sixty, sitting a tall sorrel horse the easy way a man sits a horse when he has spent most of his life on one.

He wore a sweat-stained tan hat with a flat brim, a gray shirt with the sleeves rolled to the elbow, a dark wool vest gone soft with age, and a faded red bandana knotted at his throat against the dust.

A worn gun belt hung low on his right hip with one revolver in it.

Behind his saddle, rolled tight and tied with two thongs, was a heavy wool poncho, wine-red and brown, banded with pale stripes, much too hot for June and carried anyway, the way some men carry a thing that has been with them too long to leave behind.

His name was Anson Reece.

He ran three hundred head of cattle and a few good horses in the Sulphur Springs Valley, on the far side of the Dragoons, and he was riding into Tombstone to sell four of the horses and buy a new set of shoes for the sorrel and maybe, if the price was right, a sack of coffee that did not taste like burned beans.

He saw the tree first.

Then he saw what was hanging from it.

He reined in fifty feet off and sat there, not moving.

Out here, a man learned that a woman left hanging by the road was usually not the whole of the trouble.

Usually she was the part of it you were meant to see.

He read the ground before he read anything else.

Three horses, shod, going south toward the foothills.

One small set of boot prints dragging in a crooked line from the road to the tree, where somebody had pulled her by the arm.

The broken ends of a hemp rope that had tied her wrists, cut and thrown aside once she was up, because a woman with her wrists tied could not hold herself off the ground, and they did not want her to die before she talked.

That told him more than he wanted to know.

Then the hawk screamed overhead, a long, thin, ugly sound, and the woman lifted her face from the dust and saw him.

From where she was, he knew what he looked like.

He looked like one more weathered man with a gun and nowhere better to be.

He looked like the men who had done this, come back early.

He swung down from the sorrel and walked to the tree, slow, his hands away from his sides, and stopped beside her.

He reached up for the rope at her ankle, to take her weight before he cut it.

“Don’t,” she said.

It came out of her cracked and low, barely a sound at all.

He stopped with his hand on the rope.

“Don’t look at me. Please.”

Her eyes were wet, and she was furious that they were wet.

“Turn your face away.”

It was not a plea for her life.

He understood that, standing there in the heat.

She had been asking for her life from wagons all morning and had given it up.

This was the other thing, the thing underneath, the thing a woman has left when she has nothing else.

She was asking for her dignity.

Anson Reece turned his head.

He did not do it slowly, and he did not do it the way a man does a thing he has been told to do.

He turned his whole face to the east, toward the long red ridges of the Whetstone Mountains shimmering in the heat, and he fixed his eyes on one pale rock on the skyline and kept them there.

“I’m looking at the Whetstones, ma’am,” he said quietly.

“I’m going to keep looking at them. Hold still for me.”

With his face turned away, he took the knife from his belt, found the rope above her ankle by touch, and set his other arm under her where she would fall.

“On three. One.”

He cut on two.

The rawhide parted with a sound like a pistol shot in the silent noon, and she came down, and he caught most of her, and they both went down into the dust together beside the dead tree.

She rolled away from him at once and curled up on her side with her arms around herself.

He got up and walked three long steps off and stood with his back to her, looking at the mountains.

He unslung his canteen, uncorked it, and set it on the ground behind him without turning around.

For a long while neither of them said anything.

There was only the wind, and the hawk, and the sound of her breathing slowly coming back to her, ragged at first and then less ragged.

He heard her pick up the canteen.

He heard her drink, and choke, and drink again.

When she spoke, her voice had changed.

It was not broken anymore.

It was guarded, and it was hard, and it was a voice he was glad to hear.

“Who sent you?”

He frowned a little at the mountains.

“Nobody sent me. I ride alone.”

“Everybody in this valley is sent by somebody.”

“Then I’m the exception, ma’am. I came to sell horses.”

He heard her get to her feet.

When he finally turned around, she was standing three paces back from him with her father’s lariat coiled in one hand and his own knife in the other.

He had not felt her take it from his belt.

He thought that was a good sign.

She was small and sunburned and filthy, with brown hair coming loose from its pins and a mouth set like a closed gate.

Her wrists were raw.

She held the knife the right way, low, edge up.

“I’m obliged to you for the rope,” she said.

“I’m not obliged to you for anything else.”

“No, ma’am.”

“I’m keeping the canteen.”

“I’d count it an honor.”

She looked at him one more moment, measuring, the way a horse measures a stranger’s hand before it decides whether to bite.

Then she turned and walked, limping, into the creosote brush on the west side of the road, and the brush closed behind her, and she was gone.

Anson Reece stood by the cottonwood for a long time after that.

The cut end of the rawhide turned slowly in the hot air above his head.

He looked up at it.

Then he looked at the tree.

It was a big cottonwood, eighty years old at least, the kind that only grows where there is water close under the ground.

There was a hollow at its roots, a long shallow dip in the earth floored with cracked gray mud, and around the edges of the dip there were the dead brown stalks of watercress and cattail.

A spring had come up here once.

A good one.

The stage company had built its station here because of it.

And the tree had died standing up, all at once, the way a cottonwood dies when somebody takes its water away.

He walked around the trunk.

On the north side, nine feet up, where a man on horseback could reach, there was a square of rusty tin as big as a tally book, nailed flat to the dead wood with a dozen square nails.

The bark had grown around its edges before the tree died, so that it was half swallowed, like a coin pressed into bread.

He took it for a mileage plate left by the stage company.

He would think about that later.

He would think about it a great deal.

Right then he only noticed one more thing.

Low on the trunk, freshly cut into the dead gray wood with a knife, somebody had carved two letters.

V.T.

And below the letters, the outline of a little square, like a box, or a claim.

He looked at it for a while.

Then he went back to the sorrel, swung up with a grunt for the bad knee, and rode on toward Tombstone at a walk, the way he did everything, with his eyes on the road and his mind somewhere else entirely.

—

## What the Town Already Knew

Tombstone in the summer of 1883 was a town that had already had its famous year and was now trying to decide what came after.

The mines still ran.

The stamp mills down on the river still pounded day and night, and you could feel them in your teeth from a mile off.

But the water was rising in the deep shafts, and men who had come for silver were beginning to talk about cattle, and land, and water, which in that country was the only thing that was worth more than silver, because you could not drink silver.

Anson Reece tied the sorrel in front of Ida Pellham’s boarding house on Fremont Street and went up the steps.

Ida opened the door before he could knock.

She was a widow of fifty-odd, tall and gray and dry as a fence post, and she had been taking in his rent two nights a month for six years.

“You’ve got that look again,” she said.

“What look is that?”

“The look of a man who saw something on the road he wishes he hadn’t.”

“Usually do.”

He sat down at her kitchen table without being asked, and she poured him coffee without being asked, and it was good coffee, which was one of the reasons he stayed there.

Then he told her.

He did not tell it well.

He was not a man who told things well.

But when he got to the gray-blue dress and the belt buckled around the skirts and the girl asking him to turn his face, Ida Pellham set down the pot and sat across from him and did not say anything for a long time.

“Marian Caskey,” she said finally.

“You know her.”

“Everybody in this town knows her, Anson. That’s the shame of it.”

She told him the rest plainly, the way a woman tells a thing she has been carrying for too long and is glad to set on the table.

Marian Caskey was Nathaniel Caskey’s girl, his only one.

Nathaniel had come into the San Pedro country in 1877, before Tombstone was anything but a name on a claim notice, and he had taken up a hundred and sixty acres in the foothills of the Whetstones where a good spring came out under a cottonwood tree.

He raised horses there.

Good ones, Ida said, the best in the county, cavalry horses for Fort Huachuca and stage horses for the line.

When the stage company built its station at Ocotillo Wells, they had leased the water from Nathaniel, because it was his.

He had filed on it.

“In 1878,” Ida said, “with the recorder in Tucson, back when all of this was still Pima County. A notice of appropriation. Two hundred miner’s inches, first in time.”

“And then?”

“And then in 1881 the legislature cut Cochise County out of Pima, and all the old records for this end of the territory were copied over into new books here at the courthouse. And then a man named Prosper Vantreese came to town.”

Vantreese had money from San Francisco and a company with a big name, the San Pedro Land and Water Company.

He had bought up dry land along the foothills for nothing, because dry land was worth nothing.

Then he had driven a tunnel into the hillside a mile above Nathaniel’s spring, a long dark hole in the rock to catch the water underground before it ever reached the surface.

He said he was developing water.

What he was doing, Ida said, was stealing it.

The tunnel opened in the spring of 1881.

By that fall, Nathaniel’s spring had dropped to a trickle.

By the next summer it had stopped.

The stage company moved its station two miles east to a new well.

The big cottonwood at Ocotillo Wells died standing up.

“And then Vantreese went to the courthouse,” Ida said, “and filed on the water in his own name. Said the Caskey spring had gone dry and been abandoned. Said there was no older right on the books.”

“Was there?”

Ida looked at him a long moment.

“There was. In the copy book. Until somebody took a razor to it.”

The deputy county recorder was a thin, nervous man named Dudley Sprague who wore celluloid cuffs and bought his whiskey by the case.

The page in the Cochise transcription book where Nathaniel Caskey’s 1878 notice should have been copied was not there anymore.

It had been cut out so cleanly, along the binding, that you could only tell it was missing by counting.

The original Pima book in Tucson had been sent to San Francisco to be rebound the year before, and had come back with water damage, and nobody could read half of what was in it.

Nathaniel had not quit.

He had spent that last winter riding the hills with a compass and a pocket notebook, following the dry wash up from his spring to the mouth of Vantreese’s tunnel, measuring and writing everything down.

He told people in town that he would have his proof by spring.

In March his horse came home without him.

They found him two days later at the bottom of a rock slide in a side canyon, with his notebook gone and his compass still in his pocket.

The coroner’s jury called it an accident.

Nobody in Tombstone believed it, and nobody in Tombstone said so out loud.

“Since then,” Ida said, “it’s been Marian alone out there with twelve brood mares, a hand pump on a well that gives about a bucket an hour, and a hearing coming up in front of Judge Carrick at the district court on the first of July. If she can’t show her father’s right by then, the court will confirm Vantreese’s filing, and the Caskey place is a dry quarter section with no water on it, and she’ll have to sell to him for whatever he gives her.”

“And the sheriff?”

Ida’s mouth went thin.

“The deputy who rides that end of the county takes his supper at Vantreese’s table every Sunday. You do the arithmetic.”

Anson Reece sat with his coffee going cold.

“They wanted her father’s papers this morning,” he said.

“The notebook. Or the receipt from Tucson. Something.”

“Then they don’t have them.”

“No. And she does. Or she knows where they are.”

“Then she’s in a great deal of trouble, Anson.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

He thought about the two letters cut fresh into the dead cottonwood.

V.T.

Vantreese.

And the little square cut underneath it, like a box.

Like a man marking a tree he meant to take.

—

## The Girl With the Derringer

He did not go after her.

He was too old and too sensible to go chasing a frightened woman through creosote brush with a knife in her hand.

That was a fine way to get himself cut, or shot, or talked about, and he did not want any of the three.

He stayed in Ida Pellham’s back room that night and sat by the window with the lamp out, watching Fremont Street.

A little after two in the morning, the kitchen door opened without a sound.

He did not reach for his gun.

He had been expecting her.

Marian Caskey stood in the doorway in the dark.

She had washed her face somewhere.

She had his canteen slung over one shoulder and a small, ugly, two-barreled derringer in her right hand, and the hand was not shaking much.

“I watched the house since sundown,” she said.

“I figured you might.”

“You didn’t go to the sheriff.”

“No, ma’am.”

“You didn’t go to Vantreese’s office either.”

“I don’t know where his office is.”

“It’s the brick one on Allen Street with the gold letters on the window.”

She came one step into the room.

“I wanted to know if you’d go there. You didn’t.”

“Would you like some coffee? Ida keeps a pot on the back of the stove.”

She looked at him for a long moment, over the derringer.

Then she lowered it, slowly, and put it in her pocket, and sat down on the other chair by the window with the canteen in her lap like something she meant to keep.

“Why did you turn around?” she asked.

“You asked me to.”

“Men don’t do what I ask. Not out here. Not lately.”

He thought about that.

“Then they’re poor company,” he said, “and you’ve been keeping too much of it.”

Something happened at the corner of her mouth.

It was not a smile.

It was the place where a smile would go someday, if she ever got around to one.

She told him what she had not told Ida.

Her father’s notebook was gone, taken off his body in that canyon.

But Nathaniel Caskey had been a careful man, and a stubborn one, and he had kept two of everything.

The night before he rode out for the last time, he had sat at the kitchen table and copied every measurement, every date, and every compass bearing from the tunnel mouth to the spring into a second little book, and he had given it to her and told her to hide it where nobody would think to look.

“Where?” Anson asked.

“I’m not telling you that.”

“Fair enough.”

“I’ll tell you this. They didn’t find it today. They tore the house apart. They pulled the floor up in the kitchen and cut open the mattresses and dumped the flour. They didn’t find it.”

“And the 1878 filing? The receipt from Tucson?”

Her face went still.

“That’s the part that’s gone. Pa kept the recorder’s receipt in his Bible. The Bible was in his saddlebags when he died. The saddlebags came home on the horse. The Bible didn’t.”

“So you have his measurements of the tunnel,” Anson said, “but nothing on paper to prove his right came first.”

“I have my word. And my father’s word. And a lot of people in this valley who remember that spring running for forty years before Vantreese came, and who won’t stand up in a courtroom and say so because they’re afraid of him.”

She looked out the dark window at Fremont Street.

“How much time do we have,” she said, “before they come back?”

He noticed the word.

We.

He did not remark on it.

“Not much,” he said.

—

## A Tin Plate on a Dead Tree

Before they went, he stood a long minute outside Ida Pellham’s bedroom door and spoke to her through it.

He told her that if she knew a judge in Tombstone who could be got out of bed, she might bring him out to Ocotillo Wells by mid-morning, quietly, to look at a dead tree with two fresh letters cut into it.

Then they rode out of Tombstone before first light, and he let her lead.

She rode a short-coupled bay mare with a white snip, one of her father’s horses, and she rode it the way her father must have taught her, light and straight and without any wasted motion.

She did not take him to the ranch.

The ranch, she said, was where they would be watching.

She took him instead up a dry wash into the foothills, along a trail only a horse breeder’s daughter would know, and at the top of the wash she showed him the mouth of Vantreese’s tunnel.

It was a black square hole in the side of the mountain, timbered at the entrance, with a wooden flume running out of it and down the slope to a big new tank on Vantreese’s land.

Water ran in the flume.

Clear, cold water, more of it than Anson had seen in one place since the San Pedro.

It ran away to the east, toward the company’s land, in a straight wooden channel.

It did not run anywhere near the cottonwood at Ocotillo Wells.

“That’s my father’s spring,” Marian said quietly.

“They just reached up under the ground and took it before it ever got there.”

Anson sat the sorrel and looked at the flume for a long time.

Then he looked back down the wash, the way they had come, toward the dead tree a mile and a half below, gray against the brown flat of the valley.

“Your father filed his notice in 1878,” he said slowly.

“Yes.”

“Where did he post it?”

She frowned at him.

“What do you mean, post it?”

“The law in this territory, back in ’78, the same as in California and Nevada, said a man taking up water had to do two things. He had to record a notice with the county. And before that, he had to post a copy of the same notice in writing at the point where he meant to take the water. Right there on the ground. Where anybody coming along could read it.”

He looked at her.

“Where did your father take his water?”

Marian Caskey sat very still on the bay mare.

“At the cottonwood,” she said.

“The spring came up at the roots of the cottonwood.”

“There’s a square of tin nailed to the north side of that tree,” Anson said.

“Nine feet up. About as high as a man could reach from horseback. I took it for a mileage plate yesterday. The bark grew around the edges before the tree died.”

“Pa used to nail tin over things to keep the weather off,” she whispered.

“Brand notices. Survey marks. He said paper lasts a hundred years under tin if you tar the edges.”

They looked at each other.

Then they both looked down the wash, at the dead tree.

“And this morning,” Anson said, “somebody cut V.T. into that tree, with a box drawn under it.”

“That’s a timber mark,” she said.

“That’s how the company marks a tree they mean to cut down.”

Below them, far off on the Tombstone road, a plume of dust was coming south.

A wagon.

Four riders around it.

And in the bed of the wagon, catching the low morning sun, something long and bright that might have been a crosscut saw.

—

## That’s Far Enough

They came down the wash faster than was safe, and the bay mare and the sorrel came out onto the flat at Ocotillo Wells three minutes before the wagon.

Anson swung down under the cottonwood.

He did not try to hide.

There was nowhere to hide, and he was too old to want to.

He looked up at the tin plate on the north side of the trunk.

Rust had eaten it brown, and dust had packed into the nail holes, but he could see now that the edges had been sealed with something black that had gone hard as stone.

Tar.

“Get up on the sorrel,” he told Marian.

“Stand in the saddle. He won’t move.”

“What are you going to do?”

“I’m going to stand here.”

The wagon pulled in off the road and stopped thirty feet from the tree.

It was a heavy freight wagon with the San Pedro Land and Water Company painted on its side in gold letters.

There were two big axes and a crosscut saw in the bed.

Bodie Strunk drove it.

He was a big, soft-looking man with a heavy jaw and small pale eyes, and he had a way of grinning that never reached anything above his mouth.

Behind him rode two of the men who had been with him the day before, and beside the wagon, on a tall black horse with a silver-mounted saddle, rode a slim man of forty in a gray suit and a gray hat and the cleanest boots in Cochise County.

That was Prosper Vantreese.

He looked at the cut rawhide hanging from the limb.

He looked at the woman standing up in the saddle of a sorrel horse with her hands on the dead tree.

Then he looked at the old man standing in front of the trunk, and he smiled, pleasant and patient, the way a man smiles at a dog he has not yet decided whether to kick.

“Miss Caskey,” he said.

“I’m relieved to see you on your feet. I heard you’d had some trouble on the road yesterday. Terrible thing. My men were out looking for you all evening.”

Marian said nothing.

She was working the point of Anson’s knife under the edge of the tin.

“And you are?” Vantreese asked Anson.

“Passing through.”

“Then I’ll ask you to pass on through, friend. This tree is dead. It’s a danger to the stage road. A limb comes down on a coach, somebody’s killed. The county’s asked my company to take it down as a public service.”

“That right?”

“That’s right. Bodie.”

Strunk climbed down from the wagon with one of the axes in his hand.

The two riders swung down behind him.

None of them drew.

They did not think they needed to.

Strunk walked up to the trunk, grinning, and spat on his palms, and set his feet wide, and lifted the axe back over his shoulder.

He was standing two feet from the old man.

He was standing exactly below the tin plate.

“Mister,” Strunk said, “you’re in my swing.”

“That’s far enough,” Anson Reece said.

He did not raise his voice.

He did not move his hand.

But something in the way he said it went through the hot noon like cold water, and the two riders behind Strunk both stopped where they were.

Strunk laughed.

“Old man, you don’t…”

He swung.

The shot came so fast that later none of them could swear they had seen Anson Reece’s hand move.

There was only the flat hard crack of the revolver, the bright ringing scream of a bullet striking steel, and the axe head tearing loose from the top of its swing and spinning end over end into the dirt twenty feet away.

Bodie Strunk stood under the tree holding three feet of empty hickory handle.

He looked at it.

He looked at his hands, which were whole, and stinging, and shaking.

The hawk went up off the far ridge in a long, alarmed spiral.

Nobody else moved.

“The next one,” Anson said, very quietly, “goes nowhere at all. I’d like it to stay that way.”

The revolver was back in its holster.

He had not looked at it.

He had not looked away from Strunk’s face the whole time.

Prosper Vantreese sat very still on the black horse.

His smile had not changed, exactly.

But it had stopped moving, the way water stops moving when it begins to freeze.

“You’ve just made a serious mistake, friend,” he said softly.

“You don’t know who I am.”

“I know what you are,” Anson said.

“I’ve met a dozen of you. You all have nice boots.”

And above them, standing in the saddle of the sorrel, Marian Caskey pried the last nail loose and pulled the square of rusted tin away from the dead tree.

—

## What Was Under the Tin

Under the tin there was paper.

It was a single sheet of heavy ledger paper, folded once, gone the color of weak tea, and it had been tacked to the living bark six years before with four brass upholstery tacks.

The tar her father had run around the edges of the tin had kept out the rain and the dust and the sun.

The paper was soft as cloth and as dry as the day it was written.

Marian stood in the saddle and held it in both hands.

They could see her lips moving.

“Read it,” Anson said.

She shook her head.

Her eyes were wet again, and this time she did not seem to mind.

“Read it out loud,” he said.

“All of it. You’re the one it belongs to.”

And she did.

She read it standing in the saddle of a borrowed horse under a dead tree with four armed men looking up at her, and her voice was hoarse from yesterday, but it carried all the way to the road.

“Notice is hereby given that the undersigned, Nathaniel Caskey, a citizen of the United States, has this day located and appropriated two hundred inches of the waters of the spring rising at the root of this cottonwood tree, measured under a four-inch pressure, to be used for watering stock and for irrigation and domestic purposes on the land adjoining. Posted this third day of April, 1878.”

She stopped and swallowed.

“Signed, N. Caskey. Witnessed, Juan Ybarra, and Thomas Clay, agent of the stage line.”

There was a long silence under the cottonwood.

“Eighteen seventy-eight,” Anson said, to nobody in particular.

“Posted at the point of diversion. Three years before your company’s filing, Mr. Vantreese. Three years before Cochise County was even a county.”

“A piece of paper on a tree,” Vantreese said.

His voice was still pleasant.

“Anybody could have nailed that up there yesterday.”

“Under tin that the bark grew around?” Anson said.

“On a tree that died two summers ago? Bark doesn’t grow on a dead tree, Mr. Vantreese. That tin’s been there as long as the tree’s been dying. Every man in that courtroom on the first of July will know it. Half of them have nailed a notice to a tree themselves.”

Vantreese looked at the tree for a long moment.

Then he looked at the axe head lying in the dirt.

And then he did a thing that Anson Reece had seen men like him do before, many times, in many places.

He decided that the old man in the vest was nobody.

He decided that the woman was nothing.

And he decided that out here, thirty feet from the road, with no one to hear him but his own men, he could afford to say what he thought.

“Your father was a stubborn man, Miss Caskey,” he said softly.

“I offered him the easy road. I offered him a fair price for the place. He wanted to go up into those hills with his little notebook instead.”

He smiled at her.

“Things didn’t work out for him.”

Marian Caskey stood very still in the saddle.

And from the creosote brush on the west side of the road, where nobody had been looking, a dry, old, courtroom voice said:

“No, Mr. Vantreese. I don’t suppose they did.”

—

## The Witness in the Brush

Judge Weldon Carrick of the district court of the Arizona Territory was sixty-eight years old, and he had ridden out from Tombstone at five o’clock that morning in a hired buggy with Ida Pellham beside him, because Ida Pellham had come to his house at three and stood on his front porch in her nightdress and a shawl and told him that if he did not come and see what was happening at Ocotillo Wells with his own eyes, she would never cook him another Christmas goose as long as she lived.

He had left the buggy behind the old station house and walked up through the brush with the county attorney and two deputies he trusted.

They had been standing there since before the wagon pulled in.

They had seen the axe.

They had seen the shot.

They had heard every word.

The judge came out of the brush now, slow and stiff, a small man in a black coat white with dust, and he looked up at the paper in Marian Caskey’s hands, and he looked at the dead tree, and then he looked at Prosper Vantreese for a long time over the top of his spectacles.

“I believe,” he said finally, “that the hearing on the San Pedro Land and Water Company’s application will not be necessary on the first of July.”

“Judge,” Vantreese said.

His voice was still smooth, but there was something underneath it now, like a horse’s hoof on thin ice.

“I don’t know what you think you heard.”

“I heard a man who has a water right filed on a dry spring,” the judge said, “admit that he offered a dead man a price for it. I heard him say that things did not work out for that dead man. I saw his foreman try to cut down a tree with a legal notice nailed to it, the morning after a young woman was hung by the ankle from that same tree in front of three wagons on a public road.”

He turned to the county attorney.

“And I recall that the page of the Cochise County transcription book that ought to contain Nathaniel Caskey’s notice was cut out with a razor sometime last year, and that the only man with a key to that book is Mr. Dudley Sprague.”

The county attorney, a red-faced young man named Quaid, nodded slowly.

“Sprague’s drinking at the Oriental most nights, judge. I expect he’ll talk by Thursday.”

“I expect he will.”

Bodie Strunk dropped the axe handle in the dirt.

One of the two riders behind him took a slow step backward toward his horse.

And then Strunk, looking hard at the old man in the gray shirt and the dark vest, said something nobody expected.

“I know you.”

Anson Reece said nothing.

“I know you,” Strunk said again, and his face had gone the color of old cheese.

“Lincoln County. Seventy-nine. The cattlemen’s association brought in a range detective after the war down there. Never gave the papers his name. Never signed his reports. Just sent ’em in with a little drawing of a poncho at the bottom.”

He swallowed.

“They wrote him up in the dime books back East. The nameless gunslinger of the Pecos. He ran half the rustlers in that country into Mexico without firing a shot.”

“I fired a few,” Anson said mildly.

“He ran me out,” Strunk said.

“Me and my brother. He came into our camp one night and sat down by our fire and drank our coffee and told us we’d be leaving in the morning. And we did.”

He looked at the wine-red poncho rolled behind the sorrel’s saddle.

“I never saw his face. I only saw that blanket.”

Anson Reece looked back at him.

“You were younger then,” he said.

“So was I. You should have stayed in Mexico, Bodie.”

—

## Water Runs Downhill

The rest of it happened in a courtroom, the way the rest of these things usually do, and it was not as exciting as an axe head spinning through the air.

But it was more satisfying.

Dudley Sprague talked on Wednesday, a day ahead of schedule.

He had cut the page out of the transcription book in September of 1881, he said, for two hundred dollars in gold, and he had burned it in the stove of the recorder’s office, and he had been sorry every day since.

That was the part about being sorry that Judge Carrick did not believe, and said so.

Marian Caskey produced her father’s second notebook on the first of July, in open court.

She had kept it in the one place nobody tearing apart a horse ranch would ever look.

She had sewn it, wrapped in oilcloth, inside the padded collar of the old stallion’s harness that hung on the wall of the barn, a collar that horse had not worn in four years and that no hired man would ever bother to touch.

It held every measurement her father had taken that last winter.

Every compass bearing from the mouth of the tunnel down the dry wash to the cottonwood.

Every date on which he had found the spring lower than the week before.

And on the last page, in his careful hand, a sketch of the tunnel and the flume, with a line drawn straight from the tunnel’s back wall down through the rock to the roots of the tree, and beside it four words.

Same water.

They know.

A hydraulic engineer came down from the University of California at the territory’s expense, walked the wash for three days with a level and a chain, and testified on the fifteenth of August that the San Pedro Land and Water Company’s tunnel had been driven directly into the underground source of the Caskey spring, and that if the tunnel were plugged, the water would come back to the cottonwood within a season.

The court ordered it plugged.

The company’s filing was struck.

The court confirmed Nathaniel Caskey’s appropriation of 1878, first in time and first in right, two hundred miner’s inches, to Marian Caskey, his heir, and to nobody else.

Prosper Vantreese was tried in November for conspiracy to defraud, for procuring the destruction of a public record, and for the assault on Marian Caskey at Ocotillo Wells, which Bodie Strunk, to save himself a year, swore had been done on Vantreese’s direct order.

He was sentenced to seven years in the territorial prison at Yuma.

Strunk got five.

Sprague got three, and the county got a new deputy recorder, and the new one kept the transcription books in an iron safe.

The coroner’s verdict on Nathaniel Caskey was reopened and sent to the grand jury in the spring.

What the grand jury did with it is not part of this story.

But the people of Tombstone, who had not said anything out loud for a year and a half, began to say a great deal, and most of it was about Prosper Vantreese and the rock slide in that side canyon, and none of it was kind.

—

## The Green Shoot

Anson Reece stayed longer than he meant to.

He sold his four horses in Tombstone, for a fair price.

He bought the shoes for the sorrel and the coffee.

And then, because the Caskey place had no man on it and twelve mares in it and a hand pump that gave a bucket an hour, he rode out into the Whetstone foothills and stayed through the rest of that summer.

He fixed the corral where Strunk’s men had pulled the rails down.

He put the kitchen floor back.

He did the kind of slow, steady, unremarkable work that does not announce itself, and Marian Caskey worked beside him.

Not behind him.

Not in his shadow.

Beside him, at the same pace, and when she disagreed with how he was hanging a gate, she said so, and she was usually right.

In the evenings they sat on the porch and did not say very much.

Neither of them found the silence uncomfortable.

Once, near the end of August, she asked him why he had never put his name on those reports in Lincoln County.

He thought about it a long time.

“A name’s a thing men can buy,” he said finally.

“Or scare. Or hang up on a tree. I didn’t want anybody holding mine.”

She thought about that.

“You told me yours the first day,” she said.

“At Ida’s.”

“I did.”

“Why?”

He looked out at the dark hills.

“You asked me to turn my face away,” he said.

“Nobody had asked me for anything that hard in twenty years. Seemed like the least I owed you was my name.”

The company’s tunnel was plugged with rock and concrete in October.

The spring did not come back that fall.

It did not come back that winter, either, and Marian began to say, in a flat voice, that perhaps the engineer had been wrong, and Anson said nothing, and went on mending fence.

And then in April of 1884, almost six years to the day after her father had nailed his notice to the tree, Marian Caskey rode down to Ocotillo Wells at sunrise and found the long hollow at the roots of the dead cottonwood full to its edges with clear, cold water.

It was running out over the lip of the hollow in a little stream no wider than her hand, and the stream was finding its own old way across the flat toward the road, the way water always finds its way back to where it belongs.

She sat on the bay mare and looked at it for a long time.

Then she got down and knelt beside the water and put both her hands in it.

The big cottonwood stayed dead.

A tree that old does not come back from a thing like that.

But in June, at the foot of the gray trunk, out of the wet ground at its roots, there came up a single green shoot of new cottonwood, no taller than a boot, with five bright leaves on it shaking in the wind.

Marian Caskey put a fence around it.

Anson Reece rode north to the Sulphur Springs Valley a week later.

He had cattle of his own, and a man can only fix another man’s corral for so long before he begins to forget the way to his own.

She did not ask him to stay.

She was not that kind of woman, and he would have been a little disappointed in her if she had been.

She walked out to the gate with him in the early morning and stood there with her arms folded.

“You’ll be back to buy horses,” she said.

“I expect I will.”

“I’ll charge you the full price.”

“I’d be insulted if you didn’t.”

He swung up into the saddle with a grunt for the knee, and she reached up and handed him something.

It was his canteen.

She had kept it a year.

He looked down at it, and then at her, and then he handed it back.

“Keep it,” he said.

“You might need it the next time somebody’s in trouble on the road.”

She held it against her chest.

“I won’t drive past,” she said.

“No,” Anson Reece said.

“I didn’t think you would.”

Then he touched his hat to her and turned the sorrel north, and rode away at a walk, with the wine-red poncho rolled tight behind his saddle, and he did not look back.

Behind him, at the bottom of the hill, under a dead tree on the Tombstone road, a little stream of water was running out into the sun.

You Might Also Enjoy