The Dark Reality of Raising a Baby in Tudor England (1533)
The cart did not look like anything a king would own.
It was a plain, closed wagon of the kind that carried goods along the roads out of London every day, and it was waiting in the yard at the back of the new palace of St. James’s, in the heavy heat of late July 1536.
There were no heralds beside it.
There were no black-draped horses, no banners painted with the royal arms, no torches, no choir of priests chanting the office for the dead.
There was a small group of servants who did not talk much, and a long, heavy shape that took several of them to lift.
The shape was wrapped in lead.
They slid it into the back of the cart, and then someone began to spread straw over it, the way you would cover a load of apples or a crate of glass, until nothing on the outside showed what was underneath.
Anyone who passed that wagon on the road north and east toward Norfolk would have seen a farm load, and a few tired men riding with it.
They would not have seen the seventeen-year-old inside.
He was the Duke of Richmond and Somerset, Earl of Nottingham, Lord High Admiral of England, Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, Knight of the Garter.
He had been given more titles before his tenth birthday than most noblemen collected in a lifetime.
He was, in the summer of 1536, the only son Henry VIII had.
His name was Henry FitzRoy, and the name itself was a kind of confession.
*Fitz* meant “son of.”
*Roy* meant “the king.”
Less than three months earlier, his father had wept over him and held him in his arms.
Now his father had given orders that he should leave London like a parcel nobody was supposed to notice.
Why?
That is the question this story has to answer, and it is a stranger question than it looks.
Within a few weeks of that cart leaving London, the king would be complaining that his son had been buried so poorly, and the man who had arranged the cart would be writing frightened letters to defend himself.
Somebody had decided that the king’s son should vanish quietly into the ground.
Historians still argue about who, and why.
To understand it, you have to go back to the beginning, to another closed room, seventeen years earlier, in a house in Essex with a strange name.
—
## Why was the king’s son born in a house called Jericho?
In the spring of 1519, a young woman named Elizabeth Blount was taken out of London and settled in a quiet house in the Essex countryside, at Blackmore, near the old priory of St. Laurence.
The house was known as Jericho.
It was a discreet country retreat the king used when he wanted to be out of sight of the court.
Bessie Blount, as everyone called her, was about nineteen.
She came from a Shropshire gentry family, she had served as a maid of honor to Queen Catherine of Aragon, and she was famous at court for her dancing in the costumed masques the king loved.
Now she was expecting his child.
What happened to her next followed the pattern of every respectable birth in Tudor England, and it was darker than it sounds.
Some weeks before the baby was due, Bessie would have entered her lying-in.
She was taken into a chamber prepared for the birth, and the room was closed up behind her.
The windows were covered with heavy hangings or stopped up so that no draft could get in, because fresh air was considered dangerous to a woman about to give birth.
The fire was kept burning.
Candles did the work of the sun.
The air grew close and hot and thick with the smell of smoke and herbs.
Only women came in.
No husband, and certainly no king, crossed that threshold.
The person in charge was the midwife, a woman who had learned her trade from other women, and whose skill could be excellent or almost nonexistent, depending on luck.
There was almost nothing to ease the pain.
A few herbal drinks.
Prayers.
The Church taught that pain in childbirth was the inheritance of Eve, not something a good Christian woman should try too hard to escape.
And the danger was real: something like one birth in every forty ended with the mother dead.
Bessie Blount faced it in a sealed room in Essex, carrying the child of a married man who happened to be the king of England.
Around the middle of June 1519, she gave birth to a healthy boy.
—
## Why was a bastard the most important baby in England?
To understand what that boy meant, you have to look at the cradle Henry VIII had never been able to fill.
Henry had been married to Catherine of Aragon for ten years by the summer of 1519.
In that time she had been pregnant again and again.
In 1510 she had lost a daughter before birth.
On New Year’s Day 1511 she had given him a son, Henry, Duke of Cornwall.
Bonfires were lit in the streets of London, and the king held a great tournament at Westminster in the baby’s honor, riding as “Sir Loyal Heart.”
The little prince lived for fifty-two days.
After that, there were more losses.
Only one child, a girl, Mary, born in 1516, had survived.
And now, at the very moment when the queen’s hopes were fading, a nineteen-year-old maid of honor had given the king exactly what his wife could not.
A boy.
Healthy.
Alive.
Recognizably his.
It is hard to overstate what that meant to a man like Henry.
His father had taken the crown on a battlefield only thirty-four years before, and England had spent most of the previous century tearing itself apart over who had the right to rule.
Henry believed, as almost everyone believed, that only a male heir could keep the peace.
The baby at Jericho could not inherit.
He had been born outside marriage.
The law and the Church were both clear on that.
But he proved something that mattered enormously to his father.
He proved, to Henry’s mind, that the fault was not his.
Henry did something unusual.
He acknowledged the child openly.
He gave him the name FitzRoy, the old Norman form used for royal sons born outside marriage, and Cardinal Thomas Wolsey, the king’s great minister, who had helped arrange Bessie’s stay at Jericho, is said to have stood as the boy’s godfather.
The baby was given his father’s own name.
Henry.
Then, almost at once, he disappeared from the record.
—
## What did they do to a royal baby in the first days of his life?
Almost nothing is written down about Henry FitzRoy’s first years.
We do not know the name of his wet nurse, or exactly which house he grew up in, or how often his mother saw him.
What we do know is what was done to every baby of his rank.
Within minutes of his birth, he would have been swaddled.
His arms were pressed flat against his sides, his legs drawn straight, and then long bands of linen were wound around and around him, from his shoulders to his feet, until he could not move a single limb.
He looked like a little parcel of cloth with a face at one end.
The physicians of the age, following the old medicine of Galen, believed a newborn’s body was soft, almost like wax, and that limbs left free would grow bent and crooked.
The tighter the wrapping, the straighter the child.
Babies could be kept bound this way for months, and in a royal or noble household there were rockers, women whose only job was to sit beside the cradle and rock it, hour after hour, day and night.
His mother would not nurse him.
Noble women almost never fed their own children, because the physicians believed that nursing delayed the next pregnancy.
The baby was handed to a wet nurse instead, a healthy young woman of good complexion and calm temper.
Some advice writers even warned against a red-haired nurse, whose hot temper was thought to spoil the milk.
None of it protected the child from the diseases that passed from nurse to infant, which nobody had the means to detect.
And then there was baptism, the most urgent thing of all.
The Church taught that an unbaptized child who died could not enter heaven, so a baby was baptized within a day or two, and if the midwife feared he would not live even that long, she could baptize him herself, there in the birth chamber.
At the font, the baby was dipped into cold water, not sprinkled.
Then there were the dangers no priest could name.
In the countryside, people feared that fairies stole healthy babies and left sickly changelings in their place, and mothers laid iron near the cradle because the fairies were said to hate it.
The child of a king was not protected from any of this by money.
What money bought was a margin.
Warmer rooms, more food, more hands, somebody always watching.
It did not buy safety.
Historians estimate that somewhere between a quarter and a third of all children born in Tudor England died before they were five years old, and the king’s own nursery had already proved that royal babies were no exception.
Henry VIII’s first son had died at seven weeks.
This son kept breathing.
He survived the swaddling, the stranger’s milk, the cold water at the font, the fevers and the coughs and the teething.
By the time he was six, he was strong enough to be the center of the most extraordinary ceremony of his father’s reign.
—
## How did a six-year-old become the greatest lord in England in a single afternoon?
On June 18, 1525, the court gathered at Bridewell Palace, the king’s new riverside house where the Fleet River ran into the Thames, just west of the city walls.
Catherine of Aragon was nearly forty and had not been pregnant for seven years, and everybody at court knew there would be no more children from that marriage.
The king sat under his cloth of estate in the tapestried great chamber, the lords of England stood around the walls in their robes, and a small boy of six was led into the room by two noblemen.
He knelt before his father.
The letters patent were read aloud, and Henry FitzRoy was created Earl of Nottingham.
He was led out again.
A few minutes later, he was brought back, this time in the robes of a duke, and the second patent was read.
He was now Duke of Richmond and Somerset.
The choice of titles was not an accident.
Richmond had been the earldom of Henry VIII’s own father before he took the crown.
Somerset belonged to the Beauforts, the family through whom the Tudors claimed their royal blood.
They were the two titles that defined the Tudor dynasty itself, and they had been given, together, to a child born outside marriage.
The new duke was given precedence over every other duke in England except a legitimate son of the king, and there was no legitimate son.
Other men were promoted in the same ceremony, as if to dress it up as a general celebration: the king’s cousin Henry Courtenay became Marquess of Exeter, and Thomas Boleyn, father of a young woman named Anne, was made Viscount Rochford.
But everybody in that room knew who the day was really for.
The boy was soon loaded with more offices than any child could understand: Lord High Admiral of England, warden of the borders with Scotland, and, already that spring, the Garter, along with lands that made him one of the richest men in the kingdom.
The queen did not hide her feelings.
According to a report from the Venetian ambassador, Catherine of Aragon was deeply offended by the honors given to the boy, and three of her Spanish ladies, who were thought to have encouraged her complaints, were dismissed from her household.
Her own daughter Mary was nine, and had been treated, until then, as the heir.
Now a half-brother had appeared, wearing the titles of the Tudor founder.
Within weeks, the six-year-old duke was sent north to rule.
—
## What kind of childhood comes with two hundred and forty servants?
In the summer of 1525, Henry FitzRoy left the south of England with a household of around two hundred and forty people.
His destination was Sheriff Hutton Castle, a great old fortress on a low hill in the countryside north of York, and later Pontefract Castle, further south, which had a darker history all its own.
He was going as the figurehead of the king’s government in the north.
A Council of the North was set up around him, a body of officials, lawyers and churchmen who did the real work of hearing disputes, collecting revenues and keeping order in a region that the Tudors never fully trusted.
The documents went out in the boy’s name.
The petitions came in addressed to him.
Picture a seven-year-old sitting under a cloth of estate in a cold castle hall, while men three or four times his age bowed to him and read out complaints about stolen cattle and disputed fields, which he did not understand and was not expected to.
His household was organized as if he were a small king, with a chamberlain, a chancellor, falconers, huntsmen, chaplains and a schoolroom, and his meals were carried in procession, tasted for poison, and placed before him on bended knee.
He had everything except a family.
His mother was no longer part of his daily life.
Around 1522, Bessie Blount had been married to Gilbert Tailboys, a Lincolnshire gentleman, and she had other children with him.
She seems to have kept some connection with her son, but she was a long way away, and she was the wife of somebody else.
His father was at the other end of England.
The boy wrote to the king, and to Wolsey, in careful formal phrases that his tutors helped him shape, asking for blessings and sending news of his health and his lessons.
Like every royal baby of his time, he had been raised by the people paid to raise him.
Unlike most, he never came home.
—
## Why did the boy’s teachers lose the battle to his hunting dogs?
The king wanted his son educated like a prince.
That meant Latin first, and the best Latin, read from the great classical writers, then Greek, then French, music, and all the manners of a gentleman.
His first tutor was John Palsgrave, a scholar who had once taught French to the king’s younger sister and who would later publish one of the earliest grammars of the French language written in English.
Palsgrave was ambitious for his pupil, and he did not last long.
After him came Richard Croke, one of the finest Greek scholars in England, who had taught at Cambridge.
Croke had the boy reading Caesar and Virgil and the comedies of Terence, the standard texts of a humanist schoolroom.
He also had a problem.
The duke’s household did not share his priorities.
The gentlemen around the boy were country noblemen and soldiers, and what they valued in a young lord was riding, hunting, hawking and shooting, the sports that made a man respected in the north.
According to Croke’s own complaints, the household officers kept taking the boy out of the schoolroom to hunt, and some of them encouraged him to think that so much study was not fit for a great nobleman.
The tutor wrote letters protesting that he was being undermined.
He seems to have lost.
Henry FitzRoy grew up a keen huntsman and a good rider, a boy who loved hawks and horses and the open moors around his castles.
He was, by all accounts, clever, quick and capable.
He had gowns of velvet and satin, jewels, plate and books.
None of it told him what he was for.
That question was being argued about, at a very high level, by men who barely knew him.
—
## What did the king’s men plan to do with him?
Over the next few years, Henry FitzRoy was moved around Europe like a piece on a chessboard, without ever leaving his castles.
His father’s councillors floated marriages for him with princesses of France, Denmark, Portugal and the Habsburg family, each of them a way of making a royal bastard look like a royal prince.
There were plans to send him to Ireland.
In 1529 he was made Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, a title that made him, in name at least, the king’s representative over the whole island, and there were rumors at court that Henry might even make him king there.
Then came the strangest idea of all.
In 1528, while Henry was trying to persuade the Pope to end his marriage to Catherine, the papal legate Cardinal Lorenzo Campeggio arrived in England.
In one of his reports to Rome, Campeggio mentioned that someone had suggested a way to settle the succession without a divorce at all.
The Pope could grant a dispensation, the idea went, allowing the king’s son to marry the king’s daughter, his own half-sister Mary, so that the two claims to the throne would be joined in one couple.
Campeggio himself seems to have thought the idea extraordinary.
Nothing came of it.
But it shows how seriously some people around the king were thinking about the boy at Sheriff Hutton.
He was no longer just a much-loved illegitimate son.
He was a possible answer.
By the time he was ten, the question of whether Henry FitzRoy might one day be king was being whispered in more than one embassy in Europe.
That summer, his father sent for him.
—
## Who was the friend he grew up with at Windsor?
In 1529 and 1530, Henry FitzRoy came south.
The world he returned to was transformed.
Wolsey, his godfather, had failed to get the king his annulment and had fallen.
Catherine of Aragon was being pushed aside, and Anne Boleyn was at the center of everything.
And the boy was given a companion: Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, the eldest son of the Duke of Norfolk, the most powerful nobleman in England.
Surrey was about two years older, a bright, proud, hot-tempered boy who would grow up to be one of the finest poets of the age.
The two of them were brought up together at Windsor Castle from around 1530 to 1532.
It was, by everything that survives, the happiest part of FitzRoy’s life.
The boys hunted in the forest, played tennis, practiced in the tiltyard, and lay awake in the castle talking about the future.
Years later, when Surrey was himself confined at Windsor for a quarrel, he wrote a poem about those days, remembering the place “where I in lust and joy / With a king’s son my childish years did pass.”
It is one of the most moving poems of the English Renaissance, and it is about Henry FitzRoy.
In October 1532, the two boys crossed the Channel together.
Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn were going to Calais to meet the king of France, Francis I, and the young duke went with them as part of the show.
Afterward, FitzRoy and Surrey did not come home.
They stayed in France, living at the French court with the sons of King Francis, the dauphin and his brothers, for most of the following year.
They traveled with the French court from palace to palace and were treated, at least on the surface, as princes among princes.
They were still in France, or only just home, when Anne Boleyn gave birth at Greenwich in September 1533.
The child was the girl who would become Elizabeth I.
The jousts planned for a prince were quietly cancelled.
The letters announcing the birth of a prince had already been written, and the clerks had to squeeze an extra letter onto the word to turn it into “princes.”
FitzRoy’s position had changed again.
His father had a legitimate child by the woman he had married against the whole of Europe.
It was another girl.
—
## Why were the king’s son and his bride told to live apart?
In November 1533, a few weeks after he came home from France, Henry FitzRoy was married.
His bride was Lady Mary Howard, the daughter of the Duke of Norfolk and the sister of his friend Surrey.
She was about fourteen, the same age as the groom.
The match had been promoted by Anne Boleyn, who was Mary Howard’s cousin.
It kept the king’s son inside the Howard and Boleyn family circle and away from any foreign princess who might give him ideas, and it is said that Anne made the arrangement on terms that saved her uncle Norfolk a great deal of money.
The wedding took place at Hampton Court on November 26, 1533.
Then the two of them were sent their separate ways.
The king decided that the couple were too young to set up a household together, and they were never allowed to live as husband and wife.
Mary went on living among the queen’s ladies, FitzRoy in his own household.
They were a married couple on paper, and two teenagers in practice, which would matter a great deal to Mary Howard later.
Meanwhile, the world around them was getting more dangerous.
In 1534, an Act of Parliament made Elizabeth the heir to the throne and required every adult subject to swear to it.
Men who refused were sent to the Tower, and some were put to death.
In 1535, the king’s son, now sixteen, is reported to have been among the lords who watched the deaths of the Carthusian monks who refused to accept the king as head of the Church, and later that year he could hardly have avoided the news of Sir Thomas More and Bishop John Fisher dying on the scaffold on Tower Hill.
He was growing up inside a court that punished people for the wrong words.
He may already have been unwell, though nobody yet knew how serious it was.
The real shock came the next spring.
It was the night his father came to say goodnight.
—
## What did Henry VIII say to his son on the night Anne Boleyn fell?
On May 2, 1536, Anne Boleyn was arrested at Greenwich and taken by barge to the Tower of London.
That evening, the young Duke of Richmond went, as he usually did, to wish his father goodnight and ask his blessing.
What happened next comes to us from the imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, who had a network of informants at court and wrote it down in a dispatch to the emperor a few days later.
According to Chapuys, when the boy knelt for his blessing, the king began to weep.
He took his son in his arms.
And he told him that he and his sister, the Princess Mary, should thank God for having escaped the hands of that cursed woman, who, he said, had been planning to poison them both.
It is not clear how much of this Henry believed.
It is not clear how much of it Chapuys heard correctly, or reported fairly.
But if the story is true, it was the most open sign of love from Henry to FitzRoy that survives anywhere.
A weeping father, holding his son, telling him he was safe.
Seventeen days later, on the morning of May 19, the son stood on Tower Green and watched his stepmother die.
He was there among the great men of the realm, the dukes and the councillors, the Lord Chancellor and the Lord Mayor of London, crowded into the little enclosure inside the Tower walls, while Anne Boleyn climbed the steps of a low scaffold, spoke a few careful words about the king, and knelt.
He was not quite seventeen.
He had known Anne for most of his life.
She had arranged his marriage.
Her cousin was his wife.
Her uncle was his father-in-law.
Whatever he felt, he was expected to stand there without showing it.
Within days, his father had married Jane Seymour.
And within weeks, Parliament had opened a door that some people thought was meant for him.
—
## What was the law that left a door open?
In June 1536, a new Act of Succession went before Parliament.
It did something that had never been done before in English law.
It declared that both of the king’s daughters, Mary and now Elizabeth too, were illegitimate, and therefore not heirs.
Then, in case Jane Seymour gave the king no son, it gave Henry the power to name his own successor, by letters patent or by his last will.
He could choose anyone.
The obvious question at court was who.
And there, at the heart of the court, stood a tall, handsome seventeen-year-old who had his father’s name, his father’s coloring, the founding titles of the dynasty, a duke’s rank, and the love of the king, who had wept over him in May.
Chapuys suspected that the new law was meant to clear the way for the Duke of Richmond, and he was not the only one.
If Henry had named FitzRoy, there would have been an enormous fight, because many, in England and abroad, still regarded Mary as the rightful heir.
It is possible, too, that Henry intended nothing of the kind.
He was forty-five, newly married to a young wife, and the new law may have been nothing more than a safety net.
We cannot know, because by the time anyone could have tested it, there was nothing left to test.
The young man who might have been named was coughing in his rooms at St. James’s.
—
## How did the last summer of the king’s son end?
The summer of 1536 was hot, and London was dangerous in the heat.
Every few years, the plague came up the river with the warm weather.
Every few years, the sweating sickness, the terrifying fever that could kill a healthy man between breakfast and dinner, came with it.
The court usually ran from the city in July.
That year, the Parliament that had passed the new Act of Succession sat until the middle of the month, and Henry FitzRoy, Duke of Richmond, was in London for it.
He was not well.
He had been sickening, it seems, since the spring.
He was losing weight.
He was tired, and he had a cough that did not go away.
The doctors of the time would have called it a consumption, a wasting disease of the lungs.
Today, most historians think it was probably tuberculosis, or a severe infection of the lungs that his body could no longer fight.
He was lodged at St. James’s, a new red-brick palace his father had been building beside the fields to the west of Whitehall, on the site of an old hospital for women with leprosy.
It was a quieter place than the vast, crowded palace of Whitehall nearby.
The rooms smelled of new plaster and fresh timber.
The windows looked out over open park.
At the end of the long, cold childhood his father had arranged for him, the boy who had been bound in linen and handed to a stranger’s breast was being nursed again by people who were paid to do it.
His mother was not there.
There is no record that she came.
His wife was not there either, as far as anyone knows.
They had never been allowed to live together, and there was no reason now to change the rules.
The physicians came and went.
They had the same tools they had always had.
Purges, to drive the bad humors out of the body.
Bleeding, to restore the balance of the blood.
Syrups and cordials and possets of milk and spices and wine.
All of it rested on the medicine of Galen, which had already been thirteen hundred years old when the boy was born.
None of it could touch what was happening in his lungs.
By the third week of July, the court knew he was dying.
The rumors began at once, the way they always did in that court.
Chapuys reported that people were saying the young duke had been slowly poisoned by Anne Boleyn and her brother, Lord Rochford, before they died, and that his decline was the last revenge of the fallen queen.
It was almost certainly not true.
But it shows how deeply the king’s own story about Anne, the one he had told his son in tears in May, had spread through the court.
On July 18, Parliament was dissolved.
The lords went home.
The young duke did not.
He grew weaker.
His breathing grew harder.
The servants who sat with him kept the fire going in the hot summer rooms, the way the women had kept the fire going in a sealed chamber at Jericho seventeen years earlier, because the old medicine said a sick body must be kept warm.
Somewhere in those last days, a priest would have come with the oil and the bread of the last rites.
Somewhere, someone would have written to the king.
On Sunday, July 23, 1536, Henry FitzRoy died.
He was seventeen years and about five weeks old.
He had survived every danger the Tudor nursery could throw at a baby.
He had survived his father’s dead sons and his father’s dead marriages.
He had survived the plans to make him a prince of Ireland and the plans to make him a husband to his own sister.
He had stood on Tower Green and watched a queen die and walked away.
What he could not survive was his own lungs.
And now the question was what to do with him.
He was the king’s only son.
He was a duke, a Knight of the Garter, the Lord High Admiral.
By every rule of Tudor ceremony, his funeral should have been a huge public event.
There should have been a lying-in-state, his body under a black velvet pall surrounded by candles, his banners and his Garter stall in St. George’s Chapel, a long procession with heralds in their coats of arms, hundreds of mourners in black gowns paid for by the crown, a requiem in a great church, and alms handed out to the poor of every parish he passed through.
None of that happened.
The task of burying him fell to his father-in-law, Thomas Howard, Duke of Norfolk, the Earl Marshal of England, the man who presided over the great ceremonies of the kingdom.
Norfolk understood his instructions to be that the boy was to be buried quietly, and out of sight.
The body was wrapped in lead, as the bodies of the great always were, to hold back the effects of the July heat on the long journey.
It was not laid out under a velvet pall.
It was not carried in a hearse with plumes.
It was put into a closed cart, and covered with straw.
Very few people went with it, only a handful of servants, according to the accounts that survive.
The cart left London and made its slow way along the summer roads into East Anglia, past fields where the harvest was just beginning, through little towns where nobody knew that the dusty load going by was the king’s son.
Its destination was Thetford, in Norfolk, more than seventy miles away.
There, in the old Cluniac priory where the Howard family buried their dead, Henry FitzRoy was laid in the ground among his wife’s ancestors.
There was no state funeral.
There was no grand procession.
The bells of London did not ring for him.
His father did not come.
And then, very soon, his father noticed.
—
## Why was the king angry about a burial he had ordered?
The story might have ended there, with a quiet grave in a Norfolk priory.
Instead, within weeks, Henry VIII seems to have decided that his son had not been buried with proper honor, and he blamed the man who had organized it.
Norfolk was frightened, and he had good reason to be.
That summer, his half-brother, Lord Thomas Howard, had just been sent to the Tower for secretly promising to marry the king’s niece, and the Howards had lost their niece Anne Boleyn in May.
Norfolk wrote to Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, to defend himself.
In his letter, he insisted that he had done nothing except what he understood the king’s own wishes to be, and that the secret, quiet burial had been the king’s command, not his invention.
He seems to have feared that his enemies at court were using the funeral to turn the king against him, and he asked Cromwell to stand up for him.
The king was angry that it had been done, and the man who did it swore that the king had ordered it.
So why would a king hide his own son’s funeral?
There are three answers, and historians disagree about which one is right.
The first answer is politics.
In July 1536, the succession was the most dangerous subject in England, and people across Europe were wondering whether the heir would be the Duke of Richmond.
A huge public funeral for the young man would have drawn every eye in the kingdom to the question of who would rule after Henry, and would have shown the world, in the most public way possible, that the king had no son.
A quiet burial kept the subject quiet.
Perhaps the last thing Henry wanted was a national ceremony reminding everyone that his only son had just died, and that his dynasty now hung on a woman he had married eleven days after the scaffold.
The second answer is Henry himself.
Henry VIII had a lifelong horror of sickness and death.
When the sweating sickness reached his household in 1528, he fled from house to house, and left Anne Boleyn, whom he adored, to recover from it without him.
He avoided deathbeds.
Like other kings of his time, he did not attend funerals, and when Jane Seymour died a year later, in October 1537, he would not go to hers either.
A man who could not bear to look at death might have given an order that amounted to: take him away quietly, and do not let me see it.
Then, later, when the grief arrived, he might have been horrified by what that order looked like on paper.
The third answer is a mistake.
Norfolk may simply have taken a sentence spoken in grief, keep it quiet, as a command to bury the boy without any ceremony at all, when the king meant only that he wanted no great public display.
Or Norfolk, who was always careful with money, may have chosen the most modest reading of his instructions on purpose.
The records that survive do not settle it.
What they show is a grieving father who ordered silence, and then could not stand the silence once it came.
—
## Where does the king’s son lie now?
The priory at Thetford did not last.
When Henry VIII closed the monasteries of England, Thetford Priory went too, around 1540.
Norfolk petitioned to turn it into a college of priests, so that the tombs of his family, and of the king’s son, would still have someone to pray over them.
He failed, the roofs came off, and the Howards moved their dead.
The remains of Henry FitzRoy, along with members of the Howard family, were taken from the ruins of Thetford and brought to the parish church of St. Michael the Archangel in Framlingham, in Suffolk, near the great Howard castle there.
In the chancel of that church, a tomb chest was raised over him, and it is still there, its pale stone frieze carved with scenes from the Old Testament.
Around it lie the people he grew up with.
Thomas Howard, the Duke of Norfolk who arranged the cart, lies in a magnificent tomb only a few feet away.
The friend of his boyhood at Windsor, Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, has a painted monument nearby, raised by his son long after his own death.
Surrey’s story is a separate one, and it ended even worse than FitzRoy’s.
For the rest of his short life, he would remember the king’s son he had grown up with.
Mary Howard, the girl FitzRoy married at fourteen, outlived him by about twenty years.
She was a widow at seventeen, and she spent years trying to get the lands and income that a duke’s widow was owed.
The king resisted.
His argument was that because the couple had never been allowed to live together as husband and wife, the marriage had never become a full marriage, and so she was not entitled to all of a widow’s rights.
The very rule he had made to protect them as children was used against her.
Eventually, after a long struggle, she was given part of what she asked for.
She never married again.
Bessie Blount, his mother, remarried after Gilbert Tailboys died and lived only until around 1540.
Whether anyone told her how her son was taken from London is not recorded.
Henry VIII got his legitimate son at last.
On October 12, 1537, just over a year after the cart left St. James’s, Jane Seymour gave birth to Prince Edward, and twelve days later Jane was dead.
Edward grew up in the most carefully guarded nursery in English history, became king at nine, and died at fifteen, also of a disease of the lungs.
The only son of Henry VIII to live past his fifteenth birthday was the one who could never inherit.
—
## What did the closed room and the closed cart have in common?
Go back to the beginning.
To a house in Essex in the summer of 1519, where a young woman lay in a chamber with the windows blocked and the light shut out, and a baby was born in the dark and wrapped up tight so that he could not move.
He was hidden from the world in the first days of his life, because that was what the medicine of his age demanded.
Then, for a while, he was shown to everyone.
A six-year-old kneeling before his father in the great chamber at Bridewell while the titles of the Tudor kings were read over his head.
A boy riding out from Sheriff Hutton with two hundred servants behind him.
A young duke dancing at the court of France.
A son held in his weeping father’s arms.
And at the end, he was hidden again.
Wrapped up tight once more, in lead instead of linen.
Laid in a closed cart instead of a sealed room.
Covered with straw so that nobody on the road would know who he was.
He came into the world in a room where no one was allowed to see in.
He left it the same way.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Henry FitzRoy was born in June 1519 (usually dated June 15) at Blackmore, Essex, in the house called Jericho near the priory of St. Laurence, the son of Henry VIII and Elizabeth “Bessie” Blount, a former maid of honor to Catherine of Aragon; the tradition that Wolsey was his godfather is widely repeated.
Almost nothing is recorded about his first six years: the scenes of the lying-in, swaddling, wet nurse and baptism follow what was normal for a high-ranking child of the period, as described in the source video, not documents about FitzRoy himself, and the infant-mortality figures are historians’ estimates.
He was created Earl of Nottingham and Duke of Richmond and Somerset at Bridewell on June 18, 1525, alongside other promotions including Henry Courtenay and Thomas Boleyn; Catherine of Aragon’s anger and the dismissal of some of her Spanish ladies come from ambassadors’ reports.
His northern household, based at Sheriff Hutton and Pontefract, numbered roughly 245 people; his tutors John Palsgrave and Richard Croke are documented, and Croke’s complaints are paraphrased here.
The foreign marriage plans, the Irish plans and Cardinal Campeggio’s report of a suggested marriage to his half-sister Mary appear in the diplomatic correspondence; the last was a passing idea, not a serious plan.
He and Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, grew up together at Windsor around 1530–32 and spent much of 1532–33 at the French court; the quoted line is from Surrey’s poem about Windsor.
He married Lady Mary Howard at Hampton Court on November 26, 1533; the couple, both about fourteen, were not allowed to live together.
The scene of Henry weeping on the night of Anne Boleyn’s arrest, and saying that his son and Princess Mary had escaped Anne’s plans to poison them, comes only from a dispatch by the imperial ambassador Eustace Chapuys; FitzRoy’s presence at Anne’s death on May 19, 1536, is recorded.
The Second Act of Succession (1536) declared Mary and Elizabeth illegitimate and let the king name his successor; the idea that it was aimed at FitzRoy is a contemporary suspicion and a modern debate.
He died at St. James’s Palace on July 23, 1536, most likely of tuberculosis or another lung illness; the rumor that Anne and her brother had poisoned him has no support.
The secret burial, the body wrapped in lead and taken to Thetford Priory in a closed cart covered with straw with very few attendants, is described in the period sources, and Norfolk’s letter to Cromwell defending himself survives; its wording is paraphrased here, and the scenes in the palace yard and on the road are reconstructions.
The three explanations for the secret burial are the main ones historians have offered; none is proven.
After Thetford Priory was dissolved, his remains were moved to St. Michael’s Church, Framlingham, where his carved tomb chest survives near the tombs of the third Duke of Norfolk and the Earl of Surrey; Mary Howard’s long fight for her widow’s rights is documented.
The source video’s mention of laudanum for Tudor babies is anachronistic and is not used here.