News

Promised to the Prince, Married to His Father at 13

On the 17th of October, 1568, in France, Catherine de Medici sat down to write to her eldest daughter, the Queen of Spain. It was a scolding letter. The girl ate whenever she felt like it, several times a day. She took to her bed at the slightest headache. She did not take enough exercise. And her husband, the most powerful king in the world, spoiled her. If only he would be firmer with her, Catherine wrote, her health would improve and so would her chances of giving him a son. It was the kind of letter a worried mother writes. There was only one problem.

The daughter she was writing to had been dead for two weeks. She had died in Spain on the 3rd of October at the age of 22, a few hours after giving birth too early to a baby girl who did not survive either. The news simply had not crossed the Pyrenees yet. For a short while, in her mother’s mind, Elizabeth of Valois was still alive, still eating too much, still lying in bed with headaches, still a problem that could be fixed with good advice.

That gap between what the people around her wanted from her and what was actually happening to her runs through her whole life. She was promised to a prince and married to his father. She was handed over at a frozen mountain pass at the age of 13. Her wedding celebrations killed her own father. And within a few months of her death, a story began to spread across Europe that her husband had murdered her together with his own son because the two of them had been lovers. That story became a novel, then a famous play, then one of the grandest operas ever written. Almost none of it is true. What really happened to her is stranger and in some ways sadder.

To find it, we have to go back to a palace in the forest south of Paris and to a royal nursery where a little French princess shared her bedroom with a queen. She was born on the 2nd of April, 1546, at the Chateau of Fontainebleau. Her father was the future King Henry II of France. Her mother was Catherine de Medici, an Italian from the great Medici banking family who had married into the French royal family and spent 10 years failing to have children. When the babies finally came, they came one after another. Elizabeth was the eldest daughter and within a year of her birth, her father was king.

As a child, she was called Isabel. She was raised with her brothers and sisters in the royal nursery under a governor and governess named Jean and Francoise de Oumier. And in 1548, when she was two, a new girl arrived in the nursery who would become one of the most famous women of the century. Her name was Mary Stuart. She was already Queen of Scots. She had been crowned as a baby after her father died, and she had been sent to France to be raised alongside the boy she was meant to marry, Elizabeth’s older brother, the Dauphin Francis. Mary was about 3 and 1/2 years older than Elizabeth and because she was already a crowned queen, she outranked every French princess in the room. She walked first. She sat first.

In a court where precedence decided everything, a small Scottish girl had the place of honor in front of the King of France’s own daughters. The nursery itself was a political place. The person with real influence over how the royal children were raised was not their mother. It was their father’s mistress, Diane de Poitiers. She was almost 20 years older than the king, beautiful, clever, and the most powerful woman at the French court. Henry adored her, wore her colors, and let her decide much of what happened in his household, including the upbringing of his children. Catherine de Medici, the actual queen, had to live with this for the whole of her marriage. She was polite to Diane in public. She waited.

It is worth keeping that in mind when we look at the kind of mother Catherine became. She had spent years being sidelined in her own family and when her chance for power finally came, she held on to her children and to their marriages very tightly.

And yet, the two girls became close. They shared a bedroom. They shared lessons and games and later secrets. According to the accounts of their lives, the friendship lasted until Elizabeth died. Hold on to Mary because she will come back into this story at a strange moment with a strange idea.

From the very beginning, Elizabeth was being prepared for a single purpose. Royal daughters in 16th century France were not trained to rule. They were trained to marry. They learned to dance, to ride, to speak well, to dress well, to sit through long ceremonies without moving, and to make a good impression on foreign ambassadors. Above all, they learned that their marriage would be a treaty with a face.

The first treaty came early. In 1550, when Elizabeth was four, her father opened negotiations to marry her to the young king of England, Edward VI. Edward was 13 and a committed Protestant. The Pope was furious at the idea of a Catholic princess of France marrying a heretic king and reportedly threatened the strongest sanctions he had. Henry went ahead anyway. In July 1551, a marriage treaty was agreed with a dowry of 200,000 ecus. So, before she was old enough to read properly, Elizabeth was engaged to a king across the sea.

It never went any further. Edward fell ill and died in 1553 at the age of 15. She was seven. That might have been the end of her importance for a while, but France was at war and wars end in peace treaties and peace treaties need brides. For most of Elizabeth’s childhood, France had been fighting the Habsburgs. On one side was her father. On the other was the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V and then his son, Philip, who ruled Spain, much of Italy, the Netherlands, and a vast and growing empire in the Americas.

The fighting went badly for France. In August 1557, at the Battle of Saint Quentin, a Spanish army crushed the French. The next year brought more losses. By then, both kingdoms were exhausted and close to bankrupt. In the spring of 1559, at the little town of Cateau-Cambrésis in northern France, the two sides finally signed a peace. Like most great peace treaties of the time, it was sealed with marriages. Henry’s sister Margaret would marry the Duke of Savoy, and Henry’s eldest daughter, Elizabeth, would marry into the Spanish royal family.

The groom everyone had been discussing was Philip’s son, Don Carlos. He was the heir to the Spanish crown, and he was almost exactly her age. He had been born in July 1545, 9 months before her. On paper, it was the perfect match. Two royal teenagers, the future king and queen of Spain, a bond between their two countries for a generation to come.

But, Philip’s own situation had just changed. Philip was 31. He had been married twice already. His first wife, Maria Manuela of Portugal, had died in 1545, 4 days after giving birth to Don Carlos. His second wife was Queen Mary I of England, the woman history remembers as Bloody Mary. That marriage had been a political arrangement, too, and it had been an unhappy one. In November 1558, Mary died childless.

That second marriage is worth a moment, because it shows what a royal wife’s body meant in this world. Philip had married Mary in Winchester in 1554. She was 11 years older than him, and desperate for a child who would keep England Catholic. Within months, the whole country was told the queen was pregnant. Prayers were said, cradles were prepared, letters announcing the birth were written in advance, with the date left blank. And then, month after month, no baby came. The pregnancy had never existed. Philip left England not long afterward and spent most of the rest of the marriage abroad.

So, by 1559, Philip had buried one wife after childbirth and watched another wait in vain for a child that was never there. He knew, better than almost anyone, what was riding on a queen’s ability to give birth. So, Philip was a widower once again. He had one son, a sickly, difficult boy. He needed more heirs. He had already sounded out Mary’s half-sister, the new Queen Elizabeth of England, about a marriage. She had politely turned him down.

It helps to know what kind of man Philip was because he would shape the rest of Elizabeth’s life. He had been raised from childhood to rule a world empire. He was serious, deeply religious, reserved in public, and famous for working through mountains of paperwork late into the night, writing notes in the margins of every report. He did not like to be rushed. He did not like surprises. Later generations would call him the prudent king. He was also, by the standards of his time, an attentive father and a man who could be affectionate in private. His letters to his daughters, written years later, are full of small details, jokes, and tenderness. The cold, dark tyrant of the legend is only part of the picture.

Keep both sides in mind because the girl from Fontainebleau was about to meet them both. And now, on the negotiating table, there was a French princess of 13, the daughter of the king he had just defeated. The treaty, as it was finally written, did not give Elizabeth to the son. It gave her to the father.

Why exactly the switch was made is not fully recorded. The simplest explanation is the one historians usually give. Don Carlos was a boy of 13 with poor health, and his marriage could wait years. Philip was a king who needed a wife and children now. And for France, a queen of Spain today was worth more than a princess who might one day become one.

Whatever the reasons, the result was a bride who had been promised to a son and was handed to his father, a man more than 18 years older than her. She was 13, Philip was about to turn 32. Remember that the prince was not told he couldn’t have her because of anything he had done. He was simply moved aside. We’ll see later what that did and what it did not do to the way the two of them treated each other.

Now, back to Paris in the summer of 1559, where the wedding was about to begin. On the 22nd of June, 1559, Elizabeth of Valois was married in the Cathedral of Notre Dame in Paris. Her husband was not there. Kings did not usually travel to collect their brides. Instead, the marriage was performed by proxy. A trusted nobleman stood in for the groom, spoke the vows in his name, and made the marriage legally binding. Philip sent one of his most powerful men to do it, Fernando Alvarez de Toledo, the Duke of Alba. He was a hard, experienced soldier in his 50s, the same man who would later become infamous for his brutality in the Netherlands. It was Alba who stood at the altar beside the 13-year-old princess, and according to accounts of the ceremonies, he also took part in an old ritual meant to complete a proxy marriage.

In front of witnesses, he placed his leg on the marriage bed, symbolically, fully clothed, to show that the union had been made. Nothing more happened, of course. It was theater. But it was theater with a 13-year-old girl at its center and a hardened soldier playing her husband.

The peace and the weddings were celebrated with days of festivities in Paris, and the centerpiece was a tournament. Henry II loved jousting. He was 40 years old, strong and athletic, and he rode in the lists himself. On the 30th of June, 1559, at the Hôtel des Tournelles, on the Rue Saint-Antoine, he ran several courses against his own nobles. Late in the day, he insisted on one more run against a young captain of his Scottish Guard, Gabriel de Lorges, the Count of Montgomery. The two men charged. Montgomery’s lance struck the king’s helmet and shattered. A long splinter of wood went through the visor and into Henry’s face, above the eye.

The king was carried from the field. For days, the best doctors in France tried to save him. Philip of Spain sent his own physician, Andreas Vesalius, the most famous anatomist in Europe. According to the accounts of his treatment, the doctors even experimented on the heads of executed criminals, trying to understand the path the splinter had taken. Nothing worked. The wound became infected.

On the 9th of July, as the king lay dying, his sister Margaret was married to the Duke of Savoy in a quiet ceremony, close to his sickroom, because the treaty required it, and there was no time to wait. The next day, on the 10th of July, 1559, Henry II died.

His death soon gathered legends of its own. A few years earlier, the astrologer Nostradamus had published the book of cryptic verses, and after the tournament, people began to point to one of them, about a young lion overcoming an old one in single combat, and piercing his eyes in a cage of gold. Whether Nostradamus meant anything of the kind is very doubtful, but the story made him famous across Europe.

What happened next at court is better documented. Catherine de Medici, the queen who had waited in the shadow of her husband’s mistress for more than 20 years, was suddenly in charge of her family. Diane de Poitiers was pushed out of court and forced to give up the beautiful Chateau of Chenonceau, which Catherine took for herself. And the Count of Montgomery, whose lance had killed the king, left France. Years later, he became a Protestant military leader in the religious wars. In 1574, he was captured and Catherine had him executed.

Think about how this looked to a girl of 13. Within 3 weeks, she had been married to a man she had never met at a ceremony he did not attend, and the celebration of that marriage had killed her father. Her brother Francis, only 15, was now king and her childhood friend Mary Stuart, his wife, was now queen of France. Her mother was a widow in black and would wear mourning for the rest of her life.

Elizabeth’s departure for Spain was delayed. There was the funeral, the new reign, the endless business of the court. She fell ill for a time as well, with what one account describes as a stomach illness. It was not until November 1559 that she finally left. According to the story of her departure, the whole court came to say goodbye, including Mary. Her mother was not there. The new king had asked Catherine to stay with him.

The journey was slow. Elizabeth traveled with a household of about 160 people and an enormous amount of luggage. Her gowns were so elaborate that they would not fit into ordinary trunks and some were sent to Spain separately by sea. She traveled south and west through France in the cold months toward the mountains and in the depths of winter, her party climbed into the Pyrenees toward the old pass of Roncevaux, where, according to legend, the hero Roland had died fighting 8 centuries before.

At the border, the French escort, headed by her cousin Antoine de Bourbon, King of Navarre, handed her over to the Spanish. Philip had sent one of the greatest nobles of Castile to receive her, the Duke of the Infantado, together with the Archbishop of Burgos, at the head of a huge escort of Spanish lords and gentlemen. Most of the French nobles who had brought her this far turned back.

We don’t have a record of what she felt standing in the snow at Roncesvalles. It would be easy to invent it, and we won’t. What we do know is what had to happen there. A French princess went up the mountain, a Spanish queen came down the other side.

She traveled on through Navarre and into Castile toward a city called Guadalajara, northeast of Madrid. There, in the palace of the Duke of the Infantado, on the 29th of January 1560, she finally met her husband. There is a famous story about that meeting. It comes from a French courtier and writer of the time named Brantôme, who visited the Spanish court and wrote admiringly about her. According to him, when the young queen first saw Philip, she stared at him so intently that he asked her, a little dryly, whether she was looking to see if he had any gray hairs. We can’t confirm that it happened, and Brantôme liked a good story, but it fits the situation perfectly. A girl of 13 face-to-face with a king of 32 in a foreign country in a language she barely spoke, trying to work out who this man was.

The wedding in Guadalajara was magnificent. Philip’s younger sister, Princess Juana, and the Duke of the Infantado acted as sponsors. Nobles came from all over Castile. Diplomats wrote home describing the luxury of it all. After months of mourning and travel, Elizabeth was finally, in every sense, the queen of Spain.

From Guadalajara, the royal couple moved on to Toledo, the old imperial city on its rock above the River Tagus, where the court was based at the time. The new queen made a formal entry into the city with processions, decorated arches, music, and crowds in the streets. For a city like Toledo, a royal entry was a show of loyalty and a show of wealth, and they spared nothing.

It is worth remembering that the Spain she arrived in did not yet have a permanent capital. The court moved between cities. It was only in 1561, the year after her arrival, that Philip settled the court permanently in Madrid, then a fairly modest town with an old fortress, the Alcazar, that had to be rebuilt as a royal palace. Elizabeth was among the very first queens to live there. The Madrid that would become one of the great capitals of Europe was being built around her.

And not far away, something even larger was about to begin. In 1563, in the hills northwest of Madrid, Philip laid the foundations of a vast building that would be a monastery, a palace, a library, and a royal burial place all at once. It was called San Lorenzo de El Escorial. It would take more than 20 years to finish, and it would become the symbol of Philip’s reign, enormous, gray, disciplined, and devout. Elizabeth watched it rise in the early years of her marriage. She would never live there. But in the end, she would lie there.

In Spain, they did not call her Elizabeth. They called her Isabel. And because her marriage had ended a war, she was soon known by another name, Isabel de la Paz, Isabel of the peace. It was a beautiful name. It was also a heavy one. She was not just a wife, she was the peace itself. As long as she was happy and honored in Spain, France and Spain were allies. If anything went wrong between her and her husband, everyone would read it as a political sign.

And there was one obvious thing that could go wrong. The whole point of the marriage was children, and the bride was 13. Here is something that surprises most people. By the standards of the time, Philip did not treat his new wife badly. In fact, ambassadors from several countries reported that he seemed delighted with her. Every account of her looks agrees that she was attractive with dark hair and dark eyes, lively and warm. Philip, who had a reputation as a cold and careful man, seems to have been genuinely taken with her. Foreign diplomats remarked on how much favor he showed her. One Italian envoy writing in 1561 described the king’s affection for his young queen as something very unusual.

And the record also suggests something we should state carefully. The marriage was not consummated straight away. She was too young. Historians who have worked through the dispatches of the French ambassadors note that the queen’s physical development, her health, her body was followed closely and reported back to Paris. Her mother wanted to know everything. Her mother needed to know everything. A queen who could not yet have children was a queen who could not yet secure the alliance. It is uncomfortable to read. A girl’s body was effectively state business discussed in diplomatic letters between two kingdoms.

But it also shows that in this case, the court waited. For some time after the wedding, Elizabeth was a wife in name and a teenager in fact. Not long after she arrived in Spain, she fell seriously ill. It was smallpox, one of the great killers of the age. For a young queen whose beauty was part of her political value, it was a double danger. It could kill her and if it didn’t, it could scar her for life. According to the accounts we have, Philip stayed close to her while she was ill. Her mother from France sent remedies and advice. She survived.

And by the accounts of people who saw her afterward, including Brantôme, her face was not badly marked. For a 16th century queen, that was a kind of miracle in itself. Now, there’s one more person at court we need to meet properly because for centuries he has been the most famous part of her story. He is the prince she was supposed to marry.

Don Carlos was born in Valladolid on the 8th of July, 1545. His mother died 4 days later. He was raised in large part by his father’s sisters, and he grew up as the only child of a father who was often away and always busy. His family tree was a problem from the start. His father, Philip, and his mother, Maria Manuela, were double first cousins. Their fathers were brother and sister, and so were their mothers. As a result, Don Carlos had only four great-grandparents, instead of the usual eight. One of them, on both sides of his family, was Queen Joanna of Castile, the woman known to history as Joanna the Mad.

Historians still argue about how much of what happened to Carlos had to do with that family tree. What is not in dispute is that he was unwell for much of his life. He was born with one leg shorter than the other and a curved spine. From around 1560, he suffered from repeated fevers, which may have been malaria, and from an early age, according to the reports of foreign ambassadors, he could be violent and cruel toward servants and toward animals. His grandfather, the Emperor Charles V, met him in 1556 after giving up his thrones and before retiring to a monastery in Spain. Carlos was 11. By the accounts of that meeting, the old emperor was not impressed by the boy’s manners or his temper. Even so, Carlos was the only son of the King of Spain, and in 1560, the year Elizabeth arrived, he was formally recognized by the Cortes of Castile as heir to the throne.

The boy she had once been promised to was now officially the future king, and she, his father’s wife, was the queen he would one day succeed. Then, in April 1562, at the university town of Alcalá de Henares, he fell down a staircase and hit his head badly. Within days, he was delirious, feverish, and in terrible pain. Doctors feared for his life. His father placed the relics of a local holy man, Diego of Alcalá, beside his bed. Vesalius was there, too, the same anatomist who had tried to save Elizabeth’s father. Historians still debate whether it was an operation on his skull, ointments from another doctor, or simply luck, but by late May, the prince began to recover. He survived. But according to many people who knew him, he was never the same afterward.

His rages became worse, his behavior became more erratic. And this is the young man who, according to the legend, was secretly in love with his stepmother. There is one more detail about Carlos to remember. In 1564, a new marriage was agreed for him in principle with his cousin Anna of Austria, the daughter of the emperor in Vienna. Philip kept postponing it year after year, perhaps because he already doubted that his son was fit to marry at all. Hold on to Anna’s name. She will come back into this story at the very end in a way nobody at the time would have predicted.

So, let’s look at what the evidence actually says about Elizabeth and Don Carlos. They were almost the same age. They had been engaged, at least in the diplomatic sense, before she was given to his father. They lived at the same court and the sources do agree on one thing, the relationship between them was warm and friendly. Even as Carlos became more unpredictable and aggressive toward almost everyone, he seems to have remained kind and gentle toward her. She, in turn, treated him with affection and patience. That’s it. That is what the evidence supports. A kind stepmother and a troubled stepson who were, by an accident of diplomacy, the same age.

There is no letter, no dispatch, no trustworthy witness describing a love affair. That part came later, and we’ll get to exactly where it came from. For now, it’s worth remembering how the young court looked in the early 1560s. Alongside Carlos, there were two other young men around the same age who were often in his company. One was Don Juan of Austria, Philip’s illegitimate half-brother, who would one day command the fleet at Lepanto. The other was Alexander Farnese, the future Duke of Parma, Philip’s nephew. And on the women’s side of the court was a French queen in her teens.

What did she actually do all day? We know more about this than you might expect, because Spanish historians have worked through the records of her household, the accounts of who was paid, who served her, and how she spent her time. The picture is surprisingly cheerful. Her days were filled with dressing, which took a long time, with mass, with card games and dice, with music and dancing, with comedies and masked entertainments, and with what one historian describes as endless conversations with her ladies. She loved visitors and was generous with permission to see her. She loved going out to eat in the orchards and gardens around Madrid and its monasteries, sometimes almost every day. Once or twice a year, the court moved to the royal country houses at Aranjuez, and in the woods near Segovia, and there the rules of the Spanish court were relaxed.

At Aranjuez, according to a diary of the queen’s household from her first years in Spain, she and her ladies went out on an escapade during which they milked a cow, collected the milk in the queen’s own hat, and dipped their bread into it. The queen, the diary says, enjoyed this improvised meal enormously. It was also at Aranjuez that she persuaded Philip’s sister, Princess Juana, to try riding a horse in the French style. It cost the princess more than one fall.

Among the women in her household was someone who would become famous in her own right. Her name was Sofonisba Anguissola, an Italian noblewoman and one of the very first women in European history to build an international reputation as a painter. She came to Spain as one of the Queen’s ladies and taught her to draw and paint. The two stayed together for the rest of Elizabeth’s life. Some of the best surviving portraits of the young Queen are connected to Sofonisba’s brush.

Another woman Elizabeth met at the time of her wedding would become famous in a very different way. Her name was Ana de Mendoza, the Princess of Eboli, the young wife of Ruy Gómez, one of Philip’s closest advisers. She wore a patch over one eye and she was one of the great ladies of the Spanish court. Centuries later, in Verdi’s opera, she would be turned into a jealous schemer in love with Don Carlos and plotting against the Queen. In reality, she was part of Elizabeth’s circle and the records suggest the two women remained close for the rest of the Queen’s life.

And Elizabeth loved clothes. Brantôme, who admired her, claimed that she hardly ever wore the same dress twice and that her gowns were then given away to her ladies. That may be exaggerated, but the household accounts confirm that her wardrobe, her gifts, and her generosity cost a great deal of money. She liked to give. She liked her ladies to be happy. In a court that valued restraint, that was both her charm and her problem.

So, in many ways, the girl who had been passed across a mountain like a peace treaty had built herself a small bright world inside the Spanish court. A world of French clothes, French ladies, Italian painting, card games, gardens, and milk in a hat.

But the court was watching that little world and not everyone liked it. The Spanish court had its own rules and they were among the strictest in Europe. Elizabeth, by every account, never fully adopted them. She kept French habits, French tastes, and many French servants. To understand why that mattered, you need to know what the Spanish court was like. Philip’s family had brought to Spain a system of court ceremony from Burgundy, and it was famously rigid. Who could enter which room, who could speak to the king and when, how a queen should walk, eat, and be seen, all of it was governed by rules. Royal women in particular lived a very enclosed life, surrounded by ladies and guarded by older women of rank. The French court Elizabeth had grown up in was different.

It was crowded, noisy, and far more open. Ladies mixed freely with courtiers. Dancing, flirting, and gossip were part of daily life. A French princess who had spent her childhood in that world did not easily turn into a silent Spanish queen. How much that bothered people is shown by a remarkable conversation recorded in May 1565 by the Portuguese ambassador. He was speaking with Princess Juana, Philip’s sister, the same woman Elizabeth had put on a French saddle. Juana, who was normally careful and discreet, criticized the queen openly. She said the customs of the French royal household were not just different from those of Castile and Portugal. They were completely the opposite.

Despite Philip’s continuous efforts since 1560, she said, they had still not managed to make the queen and her French officers adapt to the ways of Spain. That was 5 years into the marriage. The queen of the peace was beloved by her husband, generous to her household, and in the eyes of at least part of the court still a foreigner. And she still had not given Spain a child.

In 1564, Elizabeth was finally pregnant. She was 18. The whole court and the court of France waited. The pregnancy went badly wrong. She miscarried twin girls, and she became so ill that people feared for her life. Treatment at the time often meant bleeding the patient and purging her, methods that weakened a sick woman even further. She survived. Sit with that for a second. Since the age of 13, this young woman had been told that her purpose, her value, her very name as the queen of the peace, depended on giving her husband children.

Her first known pregnancy nearly killed her and ended with two dead daughters. She was 18 and she had already learned what every pregnancy might cost. There is one more thing that should be said about this period because it would matter later. Philip, by most accounts, did not turn away from her. On the contrary, observers reported that by around 1564, the king, who had had affairs earlier in his life, had given them up. Whatever the legend later said about this marriage, the people who actually watched it did not describe a cold or cruel husband.

Now, let’s follow the queen on a journey back home. In the summer of 1565, something happened that almost never happened to a queen who had married abroad. Elizabeth went back to see her family. Her mother, Catherine de Medici, had spent the years since Henry’s death holding France together through a growing religious civil war between Catholics and Protestants. Her son Francis II had died in 1560 after only a year and a half as king, and Mary Stuart, his young widow, had gone home to Scotland. The new king was Elizabeth’s younger brother, Charles IX. Catherine had taken him on a long tour around the kingdom and she wanted the tour to end with a meeting with Philip of Spain. Philip refused to come. Instead, he sent his queen and with her, once again, the Duke of Alba, the same man who had married her by proxy 6 years before.

Alba’s real task was political. He was there to press the French royal family to take a harder line against the Protestants. The meeting took place at Bayonne on the French side of the border in June and July 1565. There were entertainments, banquets, and water festivals. Elizabeth’s own household spent a fortune on gifts and celebrations. Spanish officials later estimated her presence at Bayonne alone at around 20,000 ducats.

And then there was the moment between mother and daughter that historians have quoted ever since. According to the account of the meeting, Catherine looked at her daughter and said, in effect, you have come back very Spanish. For a long time, that line was read as proof that Elizabeth had been transformed into a Spaniard. But one modern historian, Maria Jose Rodriguez Salgado, has pointed out that Catherine was talking about politics, not clothes or manners. Elizabeth had argued for the Spanish position, a firm Catholic alliance against the Protestants. That was what her mother meant. And Elizabeth’s answer is recorded, too. “Yes,” she said, she was, because she had good reason to be. But she was the same daughter Catherine had sent to Spain.

Which was she then, French or Spanish? The truth is, she was being asked to be both by two families, two courts, and two kingdoms that each expected her to serve them first. A few months later, back in Madrid, she told the French ambassador, Fourquevaux, that she had begun to forget many things about France after so long away. But the meeting at Bayonne, she said, had warmed and strengthened her love for her own blood again, and for the rest of her life she would never fail to serve it. Fourquevaux reported this with obvious satisfaction. It may well be his language more than hers, but the effect of the meeting seems real. She came back from Bayonne, as he put it, more French than ever.

The meeting at Bayonne would have a strange afterlife of its own. Seven years later, in August 1572, thousands of French Protestants were murdered in Paris and across France in what became known as the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre. Many Protestants became convinced that it had been planned years in advance at Bayonne by Catherine de Medici and the Duke of Alba with the Queen of Spain sitting in the room. Most modern historians do not believe that. The talks at Bayonne seem to have produced very little that was concrete, and Catherine was still trying to keep a fragile peace with the Protestants for years afterwards. But the story stuck, just like another story about Elizabeth would stick.

Again and again, people who never met her would decide what she had done. That might sound like a small thing. In the Spanish court, it wasn’t. And yet the next 2 years would be the happiest of her life. In 1566, she was pregnant again. This time, she had brought help of the kind her century trusted most. She had arranged for relics of St. Eugene, an early bishop of Toledo, to be brought from the Abbey of St. Denis in France to Toledo. She believed the saint was watching over her.

On the 12th of August, 1566, at the royal country house of Valsaín near Segovia, she gave birth to a healthy daughter. They named her Isabella Clara Eugenia. Isabella for her mother, Clara for the saint whose feast day it was, and Eugenia for the saint whose relics she credited with the safe birth. Philip, who had lost a wife in childbirth, who had a difficult son and no other children, adored this baby. That is not legend. Of all his children, Isabella Clara Eugenia would become the one he loved most and trusted most until the end of his life. A daughter was not the son that Spain needed, but she was alive, and her mother was alive, and the queen had proved she could carry a child to term.

14 months later on the 10th of October 1567, Elizabeth gave birth to a second daughter, Catalina Micaela. Around this time, Mary Stuart reappears in the story just as we said she would. Elizabeth’s childhood friend was by now the embattled Queen of Scotland. Her own son, the baby who would later become King James VI of Scotland and James I of England, was born in 1566, 2 months before Elizabeth’s first daughter. Mary, facing enemies on all sides, came up with an extraordinary idea. Her infant son, she suggested, could be taken secretly out of Scotland and raised in Spain where one day he might marry one of Elizabeth’s daughters.

It never happened. Within a year, Mary had been forced to give up her crown and her son was raised by Protestant lords in Scotland. But think about the two girls who had shared a bedroom at the French court. Now two queens in two different kingdoms imagining a future in which their children might marry. It is one of the few moments in this story where we can see the friendship from the nursery still alive in adult life.

By the end of 1567, Elizabeth was 21. She had two healthy daughters, a husband who by every report cared for her and a household she loved. If you had stopped the story there, it might almost look like a happy ending. But the same year had been going very badly for someone else in the palace.

Don Carlos was now 22 and he was coming apart. According to the reports of the period, his outbursts became more frequent and more violent. He was named to his father’s Council of State but showed little interest in its work. He talked repeatedly about escaping from Spain to the Netherlands which were on the edge of revolt against his father. He was furious when Philip gave the government of the Netherlands not to him but to the Duke of Alba. When Alba came to take his leave, Carlos reportedly attacked him with a dagger and had to be restrained. In the autumn of 1567, he tried to shoot his own uncle, Don Juan of Austria. A servant had secretly unloaded the gun. Carlos then attacked Don Juan with his bare hands.

Philip, by now, had come to the conclusion that his only son, the heir to the largest empire in the world, could not be allowed to remain free. Just before midnight on the 17th of January, 1568, the king, wearing armor, entered his son’s room in the Alcazar of Madrid, accompanied by four of his counselors. They told the prince he was under arrest. They took his weapons and his papers. The windows of the room were nailed shut. Don Carlos would never walk free again.

Philip never publicly explained what exactly his son had done or how ill he truly was. The silence would cost him dearly, as we’ll see. And Elizabeth, according to the accounts of the court, when Carlos was locked away, she cried for days. This is one of the details that would later be twisted into the legend. But read it as it is. A young woman whose husband had just imprisoned his own son, a young man her own age who had always been gentle with her. It would be stranger if she hadn’t cried.

Even in the middle of this crisis, the queen’s habits did not entirely fit the mood of the court. In February 1568, when festivities had been canceled because of the prince’s imprisonment, an exception was made for the wedding of one of her ladies. The celebrations were kept small and quiet, but the queen arrived dressed in full color and splendor, as she would have for any wedding. According to the records, many people at court were scandalized. It’s a small moment, but it tells us something. Eight years after crossing the Pyrenees, she still did not quite read the room in Madrid. Or perhaps she simply refused to put her ladies’ happiness in mourning for the troubles of the king’s son.

Through the spring and summer of 1568, Don Carlos remained locked in his room. He went on hunger strikes, then he would gorge himself. According to some accounts, he drank enormous quantities of iced water and slept on ice in the summer heat. He threatened to kill himself, and he was no longer allowed knives or forks. On the 24th of July, 1568, Don Carlos died in his room in the Alcazar. He was 23. The most likely explanation, given his self-starvation and the state he was in, is that his body simply gave out.

At about the same time, Elizabeth was pregnant again. It was her fourth known pregnancy in four years. She was 22. The pregnancy was difficult from the start, and on the 3rd of October, 1568, she went into labor far too early. The baby was a girl. She was born dead or died almost at once. A few hours later on the same day, the queen died, too. Most accounts place her death at court in Madrid, though some modern references give the Palace of Aranjuez. On the day she died, she added a codicil to her will, a final set of instructions, including provisions for the women who had served her.

She was 22 years old, and she had been Queen of Spain for less than nine years. The French ambassador, Fourquevaux, was at court in those final hours, and he reported to Catherine what her daughter said. According to his account, the queen asked him to tell her mother and her brother, the King of France, to remain at peace and in friendship with Spain and to protect the Catholic faith. She spoke of her daughters. She spoke of her husband with affection. Whether every word in that report was hers or partly the polished language of a diplomat writing to a grieving queen mother, we can’t be certain. But it means that in the last account we have of her, the queen of the peace was still doing the job she had been given at 13. She was trying to hold two kingdoms together.

Let’s add it up. She was married at 13. She was pregnant at least four times between the ages of 18 and 22. She lost twin daughters, and then a third daughter, and then her own life. Two children survived. In the 9 years between her wedding and her death, the girl from Fontainebleau had lost her father, her eldest brother, her closest friend to exile and prison, and the young man she had once been promised to. And she had done it all in a foreign country, in a foreign language, at an age when most people today are still in school.

According to the reports that reached France, Philip was devastated. His only son had died in July. His young wife died in October. In a little over 2 months, the king had lost the heir to his empire and the woman who had given him his two little daughters, the elder of whom had just turned 2.

Back in France, Catherine de Medici was still writing her letters. On the 17th of October, 2 weeks after her daughter’s death, she wrote that letter we heard at the very beginning, urging Philip to take a firmer hand with his wife so that her health would improve and she could give him more children. She did not yet know that there was no one left to advise.

And she did not wait long to try again. Once the news arrived, Catherine offered Philip her younger daughter, Margaret, Elizabeth’s own sister, as his next wife. Philip declined. Elizabeth was laid to rest in Madrid, in the convent of the Descalzas Reales, founded by Philip’s sister, Juana. Years later, her remains were moved to the great monastery palace that Philip was building at El Escorial, where she still lies today.

Two deaths within 10 weeks. A prince who had been locked away by his own father, a young queen who had once been promised to that prince. It was almost inevitable that someone would draw a line between them. The person who drew it most effectively was Philip’s greatest enemy.

In 1581, William of Orange, the leader of the Dutch revolt against Spanish rule, published a long defense of himself known as his apology. Philip had just declared him an outlaw and put a price on his head. William struck back with everything he had. Among his accusations, he claimed that Philip had murdered his own son, Don Carlos, and that he had poisoned his own wife, Elizabeth of Valois. He hinted that there had been something between the prince and the queen and that Philip had punished it.

It was propaganda written in the middle of a war by a man fighting for his life. But it spread. Protestant Europe, which already saw Philip as a fanatical tyrant, believed it. Over the following centuries, it became part of what is often called the black legend, a darkly exaggerated picture of Spain and its kings.

Then the novelists took over. In 1672, a French writer known as the Abbé de Saint-Réal, published a historical novel called Don Carlos. It told the story of a doomed love between the prince and his young stepmother, crushed by a jealous, cold, old king. It was hugely popular. An English playwright, Thomas Otway, turned it into a tragedy. And in 1787, the German poet Friedrich Schiller wrote his great play Don Carlos, built on the same tale.

Finally, in 1867, Giuseppe Verdi turned Schiller’s play into the opera Don Carlos. In Verdi’s version, Elizabeth and Carlos meet in a forest in France, fall instantly in love, and learn moments later that she is to marry his father instead. It is one of the most beautiful operas ever written. It is still performed around the world, and for many people, it is the only version of Elizabeth of Valois they have ever met.

So, let’s be absolutely clear about what the evidence supports. There is no reliable evidence that Elizabeth and Carlos were lovers. The sources describe a warm, kind relationship between stepmother and stepson, and nothing more. There is no reliable evidence that Philip poisoned his wife. She died a few hours after a premature delivery during her fourth known pregnancy in 4 years, having nearly died during her first. That is a tragically common death for a young woman in the 16th century, and it needs no poisoner to explain it. And while Philip did imprison his son, and the circumstances of that imprisonment were grim, most historians believe that Carlos died as a result of his own illness, his hunger strikes, and the conditions he was kept in, not from poison.

The real story doesn’t need the legend. A 13-year-old was married to a stranger to end a war. Her wedding cost her father his life. She was carried across a frozen mountain pass and told that her whole value lay in children. She lost twin daughters at 18 and almost died. She gave birth to two girls she adored, and at 22, she died giving birth to a third. Nobody had to murder her for that to be a tragedy.

Philip did not stay a widower for long. Like every king without a male heir, he could not afford to. In 1570, he married for the fourth time. His new bride was Anna of Austria, the daughter of his own sister Maria and of the Emperor Maximilian II. She was his niece, and she was 21.

Remember Anna? She was the cousin who had been chosen as Don Carlos’s bride in 1564, the marriage Philip kept postponing. So, for the second time in his life, Philip married the young woman who had been intended for his son. Anna gave Philip the sons he wanted. Only one of them survived childhood, and he would become King Philip III. Anna herself died in 1580 at only 30, pregnant once again.

But what about Elizabeth’s two little girls? Catalina Micaela, the younger, grew up to marry the Duke of Savoy in 1585. She had 10 children. In 1597, at the age of 30, she died shortly after giving birth. The pattern, once again, a royal daughter married for alliance, pregnancy after pregnancy, and an early grave.

The elder, Isabella Clara Eugenia, the baby her mother had credited to the relics of Saint Eugene, had a very different life. She stayed at her father’s side for decades. She helped him with his papers. She was, by every account, the person he trusted most. And here comes the twist that her mother could never have imagined.

In the 1590s, France was torn apart by the last and bloodiest phase of its religious wars. Elizabeth’s brothers had all died without legitimate sons, and the Valois line had ended. The closest heir to the throne was a Protestant, Henry of Navarre, the son of the same Antoine de Bourbon who had escorted Elizabeth to the border at Roncesvalles. Philip saw an opportunity. If the French would not accept a Protestant king, why not a Catholic queen? And who had a better claim than Isabella Clara Eugenia, granddaughter of Henry II of France, daughter of a French princess?

In 1593, the Catholic Party in France seriously debated making her their queen. The obstacle was an old French principle called the Salic Law, which said the crown of France could never pass to a woman or through one. In June 1593, the Parlement of Paris formally upheld it. Elizabeth’s daughter could not inherit the throne of her mother’s country because she had inherited her claim from her mother.

Henry of Navarre converted to Catholicism and became King Henry IV. The girl whose marriage had once sealed the peace between France and Spain had given Spain a daughter who almost became Queen of France. Almost. Instead, in 1598, shortly before he died, Philip gave Isabella Clara Eugenia and her husband the government of the Spanish Netherlands. She ruled there for over three decades and died in Brussels in 1633 at the age of 67. Of all the women in this story, she was the one who lived the longest and the only one who truly ruled.

Sofonisba Anguissola, the painter who had taught the young queen to draw, also outlived almost everyone. After Elizabeth’s death, Philip arranged a dowry and a marriage for her, and she left the Spanish court for Sicily and later Genoa. She kept painting for decades. In 1624, when she was in her 90s and nearly blind, a young Flemish painter named Anthony van Dyck visited her in Palermo and sketched her. He wrote that her mind was still sharp and that she gave him advice on painting. She remembered a world almost no one else alive could remember, including a French teenager in a Spanish palace holding a brush for the first time.

The rest of the family scattered across the map of Europe. Mary Stuart, the girl from the nursery, was executed in England in 1587. Catherine de Medici died in 1589 having outlived almost all of her children, and Elizabeth lies in the Escorial, the vast granite monastery of the husband who, whatever the opera says, seems to have genuinely grieved for her.

Today, if you walk into the Prado in Madrid, you can stand in front of portraits of her, a young woman in rich dark Spanish dress, pale face, dark eyes, painted in the circle of Sofonisba Anguissola, the Italian woman who taught her to draw. She looks composed, serious, older than her years, a queen.

But the documents remember someone else, a teenager who ran out into the gardens of Aranjuez with her ladies, milked a cow, and drank from her own hat. And a mother in France, two weeks too late, still writing to tell her how to live.

You Might Also Enjoy