Neil Young at 80: 6 of the Greatest Guitarists He Has Praised for a Lifetime — and the Two He Has Called the Best He Ever Heard
On the night of January 15, 1992, a 46-year-old Neil Young walked to a podium in the ballroom of the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel in New York.
He was not there to collect anything.
The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame was holding its seventh induction dinner, and his own name was not yet on its list.
He had come to speak for a band whose leader had been dead for more than twenty-one years: the Jimi Hendrix Experience.
The Hall of Fame still carries one sentence from that speech on its page for the band.
“When you play guitar, you can play or you can transcend, Jimi showed me that.”
Other transcriptions of the speech word the line a little differently, but the thought is the same in all of them.
It was a striking thing for him to say.
By 1992 Neil Young had been famous for a quarter of a century for a guitar style that sounded like nobody else’s: ragged, loud and stubborn, sometimes a single note repeated until it hurt.
He was not a man anyone expected to stand up and point at somebody else.
He has gone on doing it ever since.
—
## A List He Never Wrote
Neil Young turned 80 on November 12, 2025.
There is no record of him ever publishing a ranked list of the greatest guitarists he has seen.
Videos that present such a list in his own voice, as if he had dictated it, do not match any interview he is known to have given.
What does exist is a long paper trail.
There are the long conversations behind “Shakey,” the biography by Jimmy McDonough that was published in 2002.
There are his own memoirs, “Waging Heavy Peace” in 2012 and “Special Deluxe” in 2014.
There are magazine interviews going back to the 1970s, liner notes in his own handwriting, speeches at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and remarks made from the stage.
Laid side by side, they keep returning to the same handful of players.
Six of them appear here.
The order is not his.
It roughly follows the order in which each of them entered his life, with one exception: the man he was praising at the Waldorf-Astoria is kept for last.
Two of the six he has placed above everyone else in a single sentence.
There is a pattern in the choices, and it is not speed.
Speaking to Guitar Player magazine for a cover story published in 1992, he was blunt about the fastest players of the day.
“Joe Satriani and Eddie Van Halen are genius guitar players, but I can’t relate to it.”
What he does relate to, the six names suggest, is touch, feeling and nerve.
—
## A Cold City and a Borrowed Sound
Neil Percival Young was born in Toronto on November 12, 1945.
His father, Scott Young, was a well-known Canadian sportswriter and novelist, and part of his childhood was spent in the small Ontario town of Omemee.
When his parents separated, he moved with his mother, Rassy, to Winnipeg, the capital of the prairie province of Manitoba.
It was 1960, and he was 14.
Winnipeg is one of the coldest large cities in North America, and in the early 1960s it was full of teenage bands.
They played community clubs, church basements and high school dances, and the sound many of them were chasing came from England.
The Shadows were a British instrumental group whose lead guitarist, Hank Marvin, played clean, echoing melodies on a red Fender Stratocaster.
Their records reached Canada far more easily than they reached the United States.
In 1963 Neil Young formed a band called the Squires.
Its first single, released on a local Winnipeg label that year, was an instrumental called “The Sultan,” and it sounds very much like a group of boys who had been studying Hank Marvin.
He never hid the debt.
Almost thirty years later, on the album “Harvest Moon,” he put that name into a song title: “From Hank to Hendrix.”
The title measures the distance he traveled as a listener, from the first guitarist he tried to copy to the one he came to regard as beyond copying.
In 1996 he recorded a Shadows tune, “Spring Is Nearly Here,” for a tribute album to Hank Marvin and his band.
He did not record it alone.
The other guitarist on the track was the first name on this list.
—
## 1. Randy Bachman — The Best Player in Town
Randy Bachman was born in Winnipeg on September 27, 1943, which made him two years older than Neil Young.
In a city of teenage bands, that was a large gap.
By the time the Squires were playing their first dances, Randy Bachman was already the lead guitarist of Chad Allan and the Silvertones, the most popular group in town.
The band changed its name more than once.
In 1965, as Chad Allan and the Expressions, it had a hit across Canada and in the United States with a version of “Shakin’ All Over,” and the record company’s teasing credit on the label, “Guess Who?”, became the group’s permanent name.
Five years later the Guess Who had a number-one single in the United States with “American Woman.”
Neil Young has never been vague about what that guitarist meant to him.
In “Shakey” and in other accounts of his Winnipeg years, he describes Randy Bachman as his guitar-playing hero, the biggest influence on him in the city and the best player in it.
Interviewed for a 2018 documentary about his old friend, he said that the Silvertones were the best and the biggest band in town, and that there was a good reason for it.
John Einarson, the Winnipeg historian who has written most about those years, has noted that the Squires modeled their sound on the older band.
Randy Bachman has said much the same, with some amusement: the Squires were doing what the Silvertones did.
The two teenagers shared more than a repertoire.
Both loved the big orange Gretsch 6120, the hollow-body electric guitar associated with Chet Atkins and Eddie Cochran, and both have recalled admiring one in a Winnipeg music store window.
Both eventually bought one.
Neil Young played his with the Squires.
Then, in 1965, with the band finished and folk music pulling at him, he sold it in Toronto and bought an acoustic guitar.
He explained the decision to an audience in Burnaby, British Columbia, in 2025.
“I was gonna be a folk singer, so I didn’t need this anymore.”
Randy Bachman’s own Gretsch had a stranger history.
It was stolen in the Toronto area in 1976, and he spent more than four decades looking for it.
In 2021 an amateur sleuth named William Long found it by comparing the pattern of the wood grain in old photographs with pictures of guitars posted online.
The instrument had ended up with a musician in Japan who knew nothing of its past, and it was handed back to its first owner in Tokyo in 2022.
That is where the two stories meet.
According to Guitar Player magazine, Randy Bachman put his old friend in touch with the same man.
William Long matched the grain of a surviving 6120 to a photograph taken in Winnipeg in the 1960s.
In 2025, on tour with his band the Chrome Hearts, Neil Young walked on stage with the guitar he had sold sixty years earlier.
Randy Bachman also likes to tell a story about a postcard.
By his account, he wrote to the younger guitarist to say that he had to get out of Winnipeg if he wanted to get anywhere.
Neil Young did leave, and in a club in northern Ontario he met the second name on this list.
—
## 2. Stephen Stills — The One Who Pushed Back
Stephen Stills was born in Dallas on January 3, 1945, ten months before Neil Young.
In the spring of 1965 he was touring Canada with a folk group called the Company.
The Squires were working in Fort William, Ontario, a port on Lake Superior that is now part of the city of Thunder Bay.
The two met at a coffeehouse there called the Fourth Dimension, and each remembered the other.
A year later Neil Young drove to Los Angeles in a secondhand hearse with the bassist Bruce Palmer, hoping to find him.
In early April 1966, in a traffic jam on Sunset Boulevard, Stephen Stills and the singer Richie Furay noticed a hearse with Ontario license plates going the other way.
They turned around.
Within days the four of them, with the drummer Dewey Martin, were a band called Buffalo Springfield.
It lasted barely two years, made three albums and gave the 1960s one of its defining singles, “For What It’s Worth,” written and sung by Stephen Stills.
On stage it was something else: a group with two lead guitarists who did not like to give way.
A song such as “Bluebird,” a few minutes long on record, could stretch far beyond that in concert as the two traded phrases.
The pattern repeated itself for decades.
Buffalo Springfield broke up in May 1968.
In 1969 Stephen Stills, by then one-third of Crosby, Stills & Nash, brought his old bandmate into the group, and the quartet’s live album “4 Way Street” preserves guitar exchanges that run past thirteen minutes.
In 1976 the two made an album together, “Long May You Run,” and set off on tour as the Stills-Young Band.
A few weeks into the tour, Neil Young went home and sent a telegram that has been quoted ever since.
“Dear Stephen, funny how some things that start spontaneously end that way. Eat a peach. Neil.”
It is the kind of message that ends most partnerships.
This one did not end.
In “Waging Heavy Peace,” thirty-six years later, he compared his own bond with Stephen Stills to the one their bandmates David Crosby and Graham Nash had with him.
“I think I respect Stephen’s talent and genius in a way that they don’t.”
In October 2010, at the Bridge School Benefit concerts in Northern California, the surviving members of Buffalo Springfield played together for the first time in forty-two years.
A short tour followed in 2011.
For a few nights, the songs were played again with both guitars.
—
## 3. Danny Whitten — The Key
Danny Whitten was born in Columbus, Georgia, on May 8, 1943, and grew up partly in Ohio.
By 1968 he was the singer and guitarist of a Los Angeles band called the Rockets, with Billy Talbot on bass and Ralph Molina on drums.
Neil Young, newly solo, sat in with them at the Whisky a Go Go on the Sunset Strip that year.
He liked what he heard so much that he took the three of them for himself and renamed them Crazy Horse.
The album they made together, “Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere,” was released in May 1969.
Three of its songs, “Cinnamon Girl,” “Down by the River” and “Cowgirl in the Sand,” were written in a single day.
In the notes he wrote for his 1977 compilation “Decade,” Neil Young said he had been in bed at home in Topanga Canyon with a fever of 103 degrees.
Two of those songs run nine and ten minutes on the record, and most of that time is guitar.
Listeners tend to remember the solos.
He has said the secret was the other guitar.
In “Shakey” he told Jimmy McDonough that nobody ever played guitar with him the way Danny Whitten did.
On “Cowgirl in the Sand,” he explained, the rhythm part never settles: the second guitarist plays an idea once or twice and moves on to another, pulling the bass and drums into a new groove each time.
That, he said, is why the long solos do not feel long.
His verdict in the same conversations was four words.
“Danny was the key.”
Danny Whitten was also a songwriter.
His ballad “I Don’t Want to Talk About It,” from the first Crazy Horse album in 1971, later became a hit for Rod Stewart.
By then he was struggling with heroin.
Neil Young wrote “The Needle and the Damage Done” with him in mind, and was performing it in concert by early 1971.
His note on the song in “Decade” is one of the plainest things he has ever written.
“I am not a preacher, but drugs killed a lot of great men.”
In the fall of 1972 he invited Danny Whitten to his ranch in Northern California to rehearse for a major tour.
It did not work.
By his own account the guitarist could not remember the songs, and on November 18, 1972, he was sent back to Los Angeles.
He died there that night of an overdose, at the age of 29.
Neil Young spoke about it to Cameron Crowe of Rolling Stone in 1975.
“I loved Danny. I felt responsible.”
The album “Tonight’s the Night,” recorded in 1973 and released in 1975, is dedicated to Danny Whitten and to Bruce Berry, a member of the road crew who died a few months after him.
In the middle of it is a concert recording from the Fillmore East in New York in March 1970.
The voice singing lead on it is Danny Whitten’s.
—
## 4. Bert Jansch — The Acoustic Player He Put Beside the Greatest
The fourth name is the least known of the six in the United States.
Bert Jansch was born in Glasgow, Scotland, on November 3, 1943.
In 1965, in London, he recorded his first album on a borrowed guitar in the home of an engineer named Bill Leader.
It was sold to a record label for a flat fee of one hundred pounds.
That album, titled simply “Bert Jansch,” became one of the most studied acoustic guitar records ever made in Britain.
Its fingerpicking is dense and blues-inflected, the thumb keeping a bass line moving while the fingers play melody above it.
Neil Young heard it as a young man and never forgot it.
His best-known statement on the subject was quoted around the world in the obituaries when the Scottish guitarist died.
“As much of a great guitar player as Jimi was, Bert Jansch is the same thing for acoustic guitar … and my favorite.”
He did not stop at words.
One of the songs on that first album is “Needle of Death,” a quiet lament for a friend lost to heroin.
In 1974 Neil Young closed his album “On the Beach” with a song of nearly nine minutes called “Ambulance Blues.”
He later acknowledged that its melody follows “Needle of Death,” and said he had not realized it while he was writing.
In 2010 he went out on a solo tour of North American theaters and asked Bert Jansch to open the shows.
Night after night, audiences who had come for one man with a guitar first heard the man he had called his favorite.
Bert Jansch died in London on October 5, 2011, at the age of 67, after a long illness.
In 2014 Neil Young recorded “Needle of Death” himself for the album “A Letter Home.”
He recorded it in a refurbished 1947 Voice-o-Graph, a coin-operated recording booth the size of a telephone box, at Third Man Records in Nashville.
He was not the only famous guitarist with that debt.
Jimmy Page of Led Zeppelin has spoken for years about how much he took from the same records.
—
## 5. J.J. Cale — The Quiet Man from Tulsa
John Weldon Cale was born in Oklahoma City on December 5, 1938, and grew up in Tulsa.
He recorded as J.J. Cale, and for most of his life he was better known to other musicians than to the public.
Eric Clapton turned two of his songs, “After Midnight” and “Cocaine,” into hits.
Lynyrd Skynyrd did the same with “Call Me the Breeze.”
His own records were made quietly, often at home, sometimes with a drum machine keeping time.
His first album, “Naturally,” came out in the early 1970s and set the pattern: murmured vocals, a shuffling beat, and short guitar phrases that seem to arrive half a second late and land exactly where they should.
It is hard to think of a guitar style further from Neil Young’s.
That did not stop him.
In “Shakey,” talking about guitarists, he gave Jimmy McDonough the closest thing to a ranking he has ever put on the record.
“Of all the players I ever heard, it’s gotta be Hendrix and J.J. Cale who are the best electric guitar players.”
He went on to explain what he heard.
J.J. Cale, he said, did not play very loud, and he liked that about him.
What mattered was the touch.
The two men were never bandmates, and there was no rivalry to complicate the opinion.
One made some of the loudest records of the rock era, and the other could barely be persuaded to turn up.
In 2006 J.J. Cale made an album with Eric Clapton, “The Road to Escondido,” which won a Grammy Award.
He died in La Jolla, California, on July 26, 2013, after a heart attack.
He was 74.
The other half of that sentence in “Shakey” is the name everybody expects.
—
## 6. Jimi Hendrix — The One He Says No One Came Near
Jimi Hendrix was born in Seattle on November 27, 1942.
He was three years older than Neil Young, and his rise was far quicker.
“Are You Experienced,” the first album by the Jimi Hendrix Experience, reached American record stores in the summer of 1967, while Buffalo Springfield was still at work on its second album.
Two summers later the two men were on the same bill.
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young played their first concert in Chicago on August 16, 1969.
Their second was the Woodstock festival.
Neil Young has told the story of how he got there several times, and it involves a third person nobody would have predicted: Melvin Belli, one of the most famous trial lawyers in America.
By his account, he and Jimi Hendrix were stranded at a small airport near the festival, with the roads jammed for miles.
The lawyer, he has said, took a pickup truck that was parked there, and the three of them drove to the site in it.
He has called the ride one of the high points of his life.
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young went on in the small hours of Monday, August 18.
Jimi Hendrix closed the festival later that morning, in daylight, in front of a crowd that had shrunk to a fraction of its size.
Neil Young, famously, refused to be filmed that weekend and is almost invisible in the movie.
Thirteen months later, on September 18, 1970, Jimi Hendrix died in London at the age of 27.
The praise never cooled.
In the 1992 speech at the Waldorf-Astoria, Neil Young said he had learned from him that a guitar could be played or could be transcended.
In “Shakey” he named him, with J.J. Cale, as the best he ever heard.
In an interview in 2005 he said that among the guitarists of the 1960s, Jimi Hendrix was number one at taking the instrument to another place, and that no other player came near him at leading a rock trio.
What he took from him, to judge by the records, was not technique.
It was permission.
The feedback, the sustained notes and the long solos that wander away from the tune are all there in “Down by the River” in 1969, and they are still there in the records he made with Crazy Horse two decades later.
Nine months after the Waldorf-Astoria speech, on October 16, 1992, he walked on stage at Madison Square Garden for a concert marking Bob Dylan’s thirty years as a recording artist.
He played “All Along the Watchtower,” the Bob Dylan song that Jimi Hendrix had made his own.
Three years later he wrote the name into another song.
“Downtown,” from the 1995 album “Mirror Ball,” imagines a club where the dead and the living share a bill, with Jimi Hendrix playing in a back room.
The band on the main stage in that song is Led Zeppelin.
—
## The Names People Expect
Two more guitarists turn up on almost every version of this list that circulates online: Jimmy Page and Keith Richards.
The first-person tributes attached to them, with their talk of being a hack by comparison or of offering to tour for nothing, could not be traced to any interview, memoir or speech.
What can be documented is the shared history.
On September 14, 1974, Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young headlined Wembley Stadium in London.
Led Zeppelin chronologies record that members of that band were in the audience, and that a late-night jam followed at a London restaurant with Jimmy Page and the drummer John Bonham.
On January 12, 1995, Neil Young was finally inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as a solo artist, again at the Waldorf-Astoria.
Led Zeppelin was inducted the same night.
At the end of the evening he joined the surviving members, with John Bonham’s son Jason on drums, for a loose, roughly eight-minute version of “When the Levee Breaks.”
Within weeks he was in a Seattle studio with Pearl Jam, recording “Mirror Ball,” the album that carries “Downtown.”
That song is as close as he has come to a public salute to Jimmy Page, and he made it in music, not in an interview.
The trail for Keith Richards is thinner.
The two were in the same room on that night in 1992: Keith Richards was at the Waldorf-Astoria to induct the guitar maker Leo Fender, and Jimmy Page was there as a former member of the Yardbirds.
Accounts of the evening put all three of them on stage together for the closing jam.
Neil Young may well admire both men.
On the available record, though, he has never said about either of them what he has said about the six.
—
## What the Six Have in Common
Seen together, the six do not look like a ranking.
They look like a map of one musician’s ears.
Randy Bachman showed a teenager in a cold city that the sounds on the records could be made by someone standing ten feet away.
Stephen Stills pushed back, and has gone on pushing back for sixty years.
Danny Whitten made the long solos possible by never playing the same thing under them twice.
Bert Jansch gave him an idea of what one acoustic guitar could hold, and a melody he carried without knowing it.
J.J. Cale proved that the quietest player in the room could be the best one.
Jimi Hendrix showed him that an electric guitar was not a thing to be played correctly.
None of the six is a speed merchant.
Not one of them is praised, anywhere in the record, for how many notes he could play.
That is consistent with everything Neil Young has said about his own playing, which he has described more than once in unflattering terms.
It is also consistent with the instrument he was holding in 2025.
On tour that year, in his eightieth year, he was playing an orange Gretsch 6120 that he had sold in Toronto at 19 because he thought he would not need it.
The friend who helped him find it was the first guitar hero he ever had.