News

Her Ex-Husband Sold Her Father’s Guitar for $5 at a Yard Sale — He Didn’t Know the Man in the Baseball Cap Was Carlos Santana

The knock came at twenty minutes to four on a Saturday afternoon, and Lainey Coulter almost did not answer it.

Nobody knocked on her door.

She had lived in the ground-floor apartment on the back side of the complex for three months, and in three months the only people who had knocked were a man looking for a different unit and a boy selling candy bars for a soccer team.

She was standing at the kitchen counter in a white T-shirt and her oldest jeans, eating crackers out of the box for lunch because she had worked the morning shift at the music store and had not had time to sit down.

The knock came again.

Gentle.

Patient.

She wiped her hands on her jeans and opened the door.

A man stood on the concrete walkway between the stucco wall and the wooden fence.

He was in his late seventies, with a gray baseball cap pulled low, a pair of dark sunglasses pushed up onto the brim, a plain gray T-shirt, and a moustache going white at the edges.

He was not looking at her.

He was looking at the thing he held out in front of him with both hands, by the neck and by the body, the way you would hold out something that might break.

It was a guitar.

An old cream-white electric guitar with a rosewood fingerboard and a body worn down to bare wood along the edge where a forearm had rested on it for sixty years.

There was a round yellow sticker on the neck, just below the headstock.

It said five dollars.

Lainey’s hand came off the doorframe.

She knew that guitar better than she knew her own face.

She knew the small dent below the bridge where her father had dropped it on a studio floor in 1974.

She knew the chip in the finish shaped like the state of Ohio.

She had last seen it three months ago, leaning in the corner of a bedroom in a house she was no longer allowed to enter.

Her voice came out of her as a whisper.

“Where did you get this?”

The man did not answer right away.

He only held the guitar a little closer, so she could see the yellow sticker clearly.

And Lainey Coulter, forty-three years old, who had not cried once in front of anyone since the day the divorce was final, felt her knees begin to give way.

—

What the man in the doorway knew, and she did not yet, was that the guitar had been sitting on a folding table in her old driveway that morning, between a kitchen blender and a stack of paperback novels, under a hand-lettered sign that said EVERYTHING MUST GO.

He knew who had put it there.

He knew why.

And he knew one more thing, something her father had hidden inside that guitar a quarter of a century earlier, in a place nobody ever looks, which by the end of the year would be read out loud in a courtroom in front of the man who had priced it at five dollars.

—

## Why would a man put a price of five dollars on an entire marriage?

Grant Sutter woke up early that Saturday, and he woke up happy.

He was forty-six, a commercial real estate developer with a tan that never faded, and for twelve years he had been married to Lainey.

The divorce had been final for thirty-four days.

The judge had given Grant the house, a three-bedroom place on a quiet court in Pleasant Hill, in the East Bay hills outside San Francisco, with a pool he never used and a view of Mount Diablo he never looked at.

The judge had given Lainey thirty days to take her personal belongings.

She had taken what fit in her car.

Clothes.

A box of books.

The children’s baby pictures, which she had pulled out of the albums one by one at the kitchen table while Grant stood in the doorway with his arms folded and watched her do it.

The rest she meant to come back for.

But in the third week, her mother had a stroke in Sacramento, and Lainey spent eleven days sleeping in a plastic chair beside a hospital bed.

When she called Grant to ask for one more weekend, he did not answer.

When she drove over on day thirty-one, the locks had been changed.

Her lawyer told her they would sort it out.

Grant had a different plan.

On Friday night he carried everything she had left behind out of the house and into the garage.

Her winter coats.

Her mother’s quilt.

Two shelves of records that had belonged to her father.

Her cookbooks, her photo albums with the empty spaces where the baby pictures used to be, the blender she had bought with her first paycheck from the music store.

And, from the corner of the spare bedroom, the old white guitar she had not played in nine years.

On Saturday morning at seven he set up three folding tables at the bottom of the driveway.

He wrote the sign himself, with a black marker, in big square letters.

FIVE DOLLARS.

EVERYTHING MUST GO.

Then he went to the hardware store, bought a roll of round yellow price stickers, and stuck one on every single thing.

The point was not the money.

Grant made more in one afternoon than that whole driveway would bring in a year.

The point was that by Sunday night, everything Lainey had loved would be scattered across the East Bay, in strangers’ kitchens and strangers’ closets, and there would be nothing she could do about it.

He wanted her to hear about it from a neighbor.

He wanted her to drive by and see the empty tables.

At eight-fifteen he sat down in a lawn chair beside the garage with a cup of coffee and a pair of sunglasses and watched the bargain hunters arrive.

He was having the best morning he had had in two years.

He had no idea that one of the five-dollar stickers was sitting on something worth more than the house behind him.

—

## What was a sixty-year-old guitar doing next to a kitchen blender?

To understand why that guitar mattered, you have to go back to a recording studio in Nashville, Tennessee, in the spring of 1961.

Lainey’s father was a session guitarist named Curtis Coulter.

You have almost certainly heard him play, and you have almost certainly never heard his name.

That was the job.

For thirty-five years, Curtis Coulter walked into studios at ten in the morning, listened to a song once, wrote a few numbers on a scrap of paper, and played exactly the right thing behind singers whose faces were on the record covers.

He bought the white guitar new in 1961, when he was twenty-two years old, with money he had saved from playing bars for two years.

It cost him more than his car.

He played it on almost every session for the next thirty-eight years.

By the end, the white finish had gone the color of old piano keys, and the edge of the body was worn down to the bare wood in the shape of his right arm.

Lainey grew up under that guitar.

She learned to walk holding on to the leg of the chair he practiced in.

She learned her first chord on it when she was six, sitting on his knee, with his big hand pressing her small fingers down on the strings.

At nineteen she followed him into the studios.

She was good.

Producers who had hired her father started hiring her, at first as a favor and then because she was better than the people they would have hired instead.

For fifteen years Lainey Coulter was one of the most quietly respected session players in Nashville, the kind of guitarist other guitarists asked for by name.

She played her father’s guitar on all of it.

He had given it to her in 1999, a few months before he died.

He did not make a speech.

He just carried it into her apartment in its old brown case, set it down on her kitchen table, and said, “It plays better for you now than it does for me.”

Then, eleven years later, she met Grant.

He was charming and funny and very sure of himself.

She moved to California for him.

There were two children, and then a third, and the session calls came less often because she was two thousand miles from the studios, and then they stopped coming.

She told herself it was temporary.

She told herself she would go back when the kids were older.

But somewhere along the way Grant started calling the guitar “that thing.”

“Are you going to play that thing again tonight?”

“Can you put that thing somewhere I don’t have to look at it?”

So she put it in the spare bedroom.

Then she put it in its case.

Then she stopped opening the case.

When she left the house for the last time, she told herself she would come back for it on the last weekend, when she had a place to keep it.

She had no way of knowing that by then the locks would be changed.

And she had no way of knowing who was about to pull over at the bottom of her old driveway.

—

## Why did a stranger in a gray T-shirt stop his car on a quiet court in Pleasant Hill?

He had not meant to stop.

He was on his way to see an old friend, a drummer he had known for fifty years who lived further up in the hills and who had just come home from the hospital.

He was driving himself, in an ordinary car, wearing what he always wore when he wanted the world to leave him alone for an afternoon: a gray cap, sunglasses, a plain T-shirt, and jeans.

Most of the time, it worked.

He saw the sign at the bottom of the court.

YARD SALE.

EVERYTHING MUST GO.

And he did what he had done his whole life whenever he saw a sign like that.

He pulled over.

He had loved yard sales since he was a boy in Tijuana, when the secondhand market was the only place a kid with no money could touch a real instrument.

He loved the idea that something precious could be sitting on a card table between a toaster and a box of coat hangers, waiting for somebody to notice it.

He walked up the driveway with his hands in his pockets.

There were maybe a dozen people browsing the tables.

A young couple was arguing quietly over a lamp.

An older woman in a sun hat was going through the coats.

And sitting in a lawn chair by the garage, with a cup of coffee, a big smile, and his feet up on a cooler, was a tan man in a polo shirt who looked like he was watching a ball game his team was winning.

The stranger browsed slowly.

He picked up a cookbook with handwritten notes in the margins and put it back.

He picked up a photo album, opened it, and saw that every other page had an empty space where a photograph used to be, and he put that back very gently.

Then he came to the records.

There were two cardboard boxes of them, old ones, soft at the corners, and he went through them the way he always did, one at a time, reading the backs.

Soul records.

Country records.

Gospel.

And on almost every one, on the back of the sleeve, small and neat, somebody had written the same thing in blue ballpoint pen.

C.C. — rhythm.

C.C. — lead, tracks 2, 5, 9.

C.C. — the solo.

The stranger stopped and held one of the records for a long moment.

He knew what those initials meant.

They meant somebody had played on this record, and had been proud of it, and had been the only person in the world who would ever know.

Then he looked up from the box.

And at the very end of the last folding table, leaning against the wall of the garage, half hidden behind a stack of magazines, he saw the white guitar.

—

## What did he see on that guitar that made his hands go still?

He did not run.

Later, the woman in the sun hat would say it was the way he stopped moving that made her look up.

Everything about him went quiet, like a dog that has heard something far away.

He set the record down.

He walked to the end of the table and moved the magazines aside.

He picked the guitar up by the neck and the body, both hands, and turned it toward the light.

It was dusty.

The strings were dead and dark with age.

There was a yellow sticker on the neck that said five dollars.

He turned it over and looked at the back.

He looked at the worn place on the edge of the body, and he ran his thumb along it, slowly.

Then he looked at the shape of the neck, and the color of the wood, and a few small details that would have meant nothing to anybody else on that driveway.

He had held guitars like this before.

Not many.

They were made in California in the early sixties, in a factory that turned out instruments by the thousands for working musicians, and back then nobody thought of them as anything but tools.

Today, the few that had survived in their original condition, with every part they had left the factory with, were among the most sought-after guitars in the world.

A guitar like this one, with this finish and this year and sixty years of honest work worn into its body, would sell for more money than most people make in five years.

The man in the cap stood very still for a moment, holding the most valuable thing on the whole court.

Then he walked over to the lawn chair.

“Excuse me,” he said.

“This guitar. Who does it belong to?”

Grant Sutter did not get up.

He looked at the guitar the way you look at a parking ticket.

“My ex-wife’s.”

He took a sip of coffee.

“Five bucks. Everything must go.”

“Your ex-wife’s,” the man repeated.

“Her stuff, her problem.”

He waved his cup at the tables.

“She had thirty days. She didn’t come back for it. So, you know. Five bucks and it’s yours.”

The man looked at him for a long moment.

It was a man who had been hurt and had decided that the cure was to hurt someone back, and who was enjoying it.

“Do you know what this guitar is?” the man asked.

Grant laughed.

It was a short, bored laugh.

“It’s an old guitar. She used to play it all the time, before the kids. Her dad gave it to her or something.”

He shrugged.

“Look, pal. Do you want it or not? Because there’s a guy over there who wants the lamp, and I’ve got a whole morning.”

The stranger said nothing for a moment.

Then he reached up and slowly took his sunglasses off the brim of his cap and folded them, and put them in his pocket.

Behind him, the woman in the sun hat had stopped going through the coats.

She was staring at his face.

—

## What does it cost to buy back a whole marriage, one sticker at a time?

The woman in the sun hat was named Rosalind Benavides.

She was seventy-one, a retired high school librarian, and she had lived directly across the court from the Sutters for nine years.

She had found Lainey’s mother’s quilt on the second table, with a yellow sticker on it, and she had been standing there trying to decide whether it would be meddling to buy it and give it back.

And now she was looking at the man with the guitar, and her mouth was slightly open, because her late husband had owned every one of this man’s records, and had played them loud on Sunday mornings, and she had looked at that face on album covers for forty years.

She did not say anything.

Not yet.

She wanted to see what he would do.

The man in the cap turned back to Grant.

“How much for all of it?”

Grant blinked.

“All of what?”

“Everything that belongs to her. Everything on these tables.”

Grant looked at him, then at the tables, then back at him, and a slow grin spread across his face.

He could not believe his luck.

“Five bucks apiece,” he said.

“That’s the sign. Five bucks apiece.”

“All right.”

The man walked to the first table and began to pick things up.

He did it slowly and carefully, one item at a time, and he made a pile on the hood of his car.

The quilt.

He nodded to Rosalind as he lifted it, and she found that her eyes had filled up, and she could not have said why.

The cookbooks.

The photo albums with the empty spaces.

Both boxes of records.

The winter coats.

The blender.

The other shoppers had stopped shopping and stood back to watch a stranger carry an entire life, piece by piece, down a driveway to his car.

When he was done, the tables were bare except for a lamp, a set of golf clubs, and a broken exercise bike that had obviously belonged to Grant.

The man came back up the driveway.

“Thirty-seven things,” he said.

“One hundred eighty-five dollars.”

He counted it out of his wallet in twenties and fives and laid it on the cooler beside Grant’s feet.

Then he came back for the last thing.

He picked up the white guitar.

Grant was laughing now.

“Man, you just bought a whole lot of junk.”

“Maybe,” said the man.

He tucked one more five-dollar bill under the coffee cup.

“That’s for the guitar.”

And that was when Rosalind Benavides could not stand it anymore.

She took two steps forward and said the name out loud, not loud, not a shout, just the way you might say the name of someone you used to know.

“Carlos Santana.”

Every head on the driveway turned.

Grant Sutter did not move.

He looked up at the man holding the guitar, and the grin was still on his face, but it had stopped meaning anything, like a sign left up after a store has closed.

Carlos Santana looked down at him.

His voice was very quiet.

“You asked if I wanted it,” he said.

“Now I will tell you what you sold me. This guitar was made in 1961. It has every part it was born with. It has been played every day of its life by people who loved it, and it shows. There are maybe a few hundred like it left in the world, and collectors would empty their bank accounts for it.”

He let that sit for one second.

“It is worth more than your house.”

Grant’s coffee cup stopped halfway to his mouth.

For a long moment, nothing on his face moved at all.

Then everything moved at once.

“Wait,” he said.

“Wait, wait. Hold on.”

He stood up so fast the lawn chair went over backward.

“The sale’s off. I didn’t know what it was. That’s, that’s not a five-dollar item, obviously that was a mistake, I’ll give you your money back, I’ll give you double…”

Carlos Santana did not raise his voice.

He did not need to.

“You wrote the sign yourself,” he said.

“Five dollars. Everything must go.”

He looked at the bare tables.

“Everything went.”

Then he turned and walked down the driveway with Lainey Coulter’s father’s guitar held carefully against his chest, and put it on the passenger seat of his car, and fastened the seat belt around it.

Grant stood at the top of the driveway with a twenty-dollar bill in his hand that nobody was going to take.

Behind him, across the court, a teenage boy who had been filming the whole thing on his phone from his grandmother’s front porch pressed stop.

It was Rosalind Benavides’s grandson.

By Sunday night, that video would have been watched in every house on the court.

By Monday, it would have been watched by Grant Sutter’s biggest client.

But Carlos Santana was not thinking about Grant Sutter anymore.

He was thinking about a much harder question.

Where do you look for a woman who left with only what fit in her car?

—

## How do you find someone who does not want to be found?

He started with the only person on that driveway who had looked sad.

Rosalind Benavides had followed him down to the curb.

She stood beside the car with her sun hat in her hands, turning the brim around and around.

“You’re going to give it back to her,” she said.

It was not a question.

“Yes,” he said.

“If someone will tell me where she is.”

Rosalind looked back at the house, at Grant, who was on his phone now, walking in circles on the lawn.

She made up her mind.

“She sent me a Christmas card,” she said.

“Last year, from her new place. She sends everybody cards. She’s that kind of person.”

She told him what she remembered.

A town about fifteen minutes north, on the water.

An apartment complex behind a carwash.

The back building, ground floor, a door with a dead plant beside it that Lainey kept meaning to replace.

“She works at the music store downtown,” Rosalind added.

“Selling beginner guitars to kids. She doesn’t play anymore. I asked her once. She said she’d forgotten how.”

Carlos Santana was quiet for a moment.

“People do not forget how,” he said.

“They forget that they are allowed.”

He thanked her.

He put the quilt in her arms, because it had been Lainey’s mother’s and Rosalind would see that it got home safely, and Rosalind cried a little and laughed at herself for crying.

Then he called his friend the drummer, apologized, and said he would be late.

It took him forty minutes to find the carwash.

It took him another ten to find the right building, the back one, past a swimming pool with a cover on it and a row of mailboxes, and the door on the ground floor with the dead plant beside it in a terra-cotta pot.

He stood on the walkway for a moment.

He was holding the guitar.

He had walked out in front of stadiums full of people, and he had been less nervous than he was right then.

Because he knew what it meant to open a door and see something you thought you had lost forever.

He knocked.

Nothing.

He knocked again, gently.

And the door opened, and a woman in a white T-shirt with crackers in one hand and her hair pulled back from her face looked out at him, and then down at what he was holding.

—

## What happens to a person in the three seconds it takes to recognize her father’s guitar?

The first thing that happened was nothing at all.

Lainey Coulter stood perfectly still in her doorway.

The crackers slid out of her hand onto the floor, and she did not notice.

Her eyes went to the guitar and stayed there.

To the worn place on the edge of the body.

To the dent below the bridge.

To the chip shaped like Ohio.

Then to the round yellow sticker on the neck.

Five dollars.

Her face did something complicated, and then it crumpled.

Her voice was a whisper.

“Where did you get this?”

He did not answer right away.

He did not know how to say it gently, and he did not want to say it any other way.

So he only held the guitar a little closer, so she could see the sticker clearly, and let her understand it herself.

She understood it.

He watched her understand it.

He watched her see the yellow sticker and the price written on it, and see the driveway, and the folding tables, and Grant in his lawn chair with his coffee, all of it, in one second, without anybody saying a single word.

“He sold it?”

Her voice broke in the middle.

“For five dollars?”

He nodded once.

Lainey put her hand over her mouth.

Her other hand came up, slowly, and reached for the guitar, and stopped an inch away, as if she were afraid it would disappear if she touched it.

Her eyes filled.

Her chin was shaking.

And then she said it, very quietly, to the guitar and not to him.

“This was my father’s guitar.”

That was when her legs went.

He saw it coming and caught her elbow with one hand, and somehow kept the guitar steady with the other, and for a moment the two of them stood in the narrow doorway like people in a slow dance, a sixty-year-old guitar between them.

Then she sank down onto the step and sat there, and he crouched in front of her, and he put the guitar in her arms.

She held it the way you hold a child who has been lost in a crowd.

She pressed her face against the worn wood of the body and her shoulders began to shake, and the sound she made was not quite crying and not quite anything else.

He did not say anything.

He knew there was nothing useful to say yet.

He crouched on the concrete walkway with his knees complaining and waited.

A minute passed.

Two.

Finally, Lainey lifted her head.

She wiped her face with the back of her wrist.

She looked at the man in front of her properly for the first time.

The gray cap.

The moustache.

The eyes, very dark and very kind, which she had seen before, many times, on the cover of an album her father used to keep on the top shelf, next to the records he had played on.

She stared at him.

He watched her try to put it together, the way he had watched hundreds of people try to put it together over the years, and he waited for it to land.

It landed.

“Oh,” she said.

“Oh, no. No. You’re…”

“Carlos,” he said.

“Just Carlos.”

She laughed.

It came out of her like a hiccup, wet and helpless, and then she was laughing and crying at the same time, the guitar clutched to her chest, sitting on a concrete step behind a carwash, in front of the most famous guitarist she had ever seen, with cracker crumbs all over her jeans.

“I’m sorry,” she said.

“I’m so sorry. I’m a mess.”

“You are not a mess,” he said.

“You just got your father back.”

Then he reached out with one finger and touched the yellow sticker on the neck.

“May I?”

She nodded.

He peeled it off, very slowly, so it would not take any of the old finish with it.

He looked at it for a moment.

Then he put it in her hand.

“Keep this,” he said.

“Someday, you will want to remember what he thought it was worth.”

—

## What had her father written where nobody would ever look?

They sat at her kitchen table for an hour.

He told her about the driveway.

He told her everything, the sign, the stickers, the lawn chair, the thirty-seven things on the hood of his car, the quilt in Rosalind’s arms.

When he got to the part where he told Grant what the guitar was worth, and Grant’s coffee stopped halfway to his mouth, Lainey put her head down on the table and laughed until she had to wipe her eyes again.

“He always hated it,” she said.

“He called it that thing. For ten years. That thing.”

“I know,” said Carlos Santana.

“He told me it was an old guitar. He said, her dad gave it to her or something.”

Lainey stopped laughing.

“Or something,” she repeated.

She looked at the guitar, lying on its back across the other end of the table.

“Do you want to know something stupid?” she said.

“I’ve never even taken it apart. In twenty-five years. Dad told me not to. He said, ‘Don’t you open her up till you need to, Lainey. She’ll tell you when.'”

Carlos Santana looked at the guitar for a while.

“The strings are dead,” he said.

“She needs new ones. And a cleaning. Somebody has to open her up today, I think.”

Lainey looked at him.

Then she got up, opened the drawer by the stove, and came back with a screwdriver and a pack of strings that had been sitting in that drawer, unopened, for nine years.

He let her do it.

It was hers to do.

She took the old strings off first, one at a time.

Then she began to unscrew the white plastic plate that covers the front of the body, the one that holds the pickups and the knobs, which on her father’s guitar had never once been removed.

Eleven small screws.

Her hands were shaking on the last two.

She lifted the plate.

Underneath was raw wood, the bare body of the guitar, routed out in channels for the wires.

And written on the wood, in pencil, in the small square handwriting she had seen on the back of a thousand record sleeves, were words.

There was a date at the top.

March 1999.

It was the month her father had found out he was sick.

It was eight months before he died.

Below it, he had written a list.

It was a list of records.

Dozens of them, in tiny letters, filling every inch of bare wood around the wiring channels, every session he had ever played on that guitar, with the year beside each one.

The first one was from 1961.

The last ten were in different ink, and they were not his sessions.

They were hers.

Every session Lainey had played on that guitar, from the first one at nineteen until the spring of 1999, he had added to the list, in pencil, in secret, when she was not looking.

And at the very bottom, squeezed into the last corner of the wood, he had written four lines.

Lainey read them silently.

Then she read them out loud, because she could not help it.

“For my daughter Lainey, who plays her better than I ever did. This guitar is hers and nobody else’s. If she ever puts it down, somebody please hand it back to her. And tell her the list isn’t finished.”

She did not cry this time.

She just sat there with her hand flat on the wood, over the place where her father had written her name, for a very long time.

Carlos Santana did not move.

When she finally looked up, he said only one thing.

“Somebody handed it back.”

—

## What did the most famous guitarist in the world ask her to do next?

He put the new strings on himself.

When he was done, he played for about a minute.

Not loud.

There was no amplifier in the apartment, and an electric guitar played without one makes a small, thin, private sound, like someone talking in the next room.

But Lainey had grown up with that sound.

She had fallen asleep to it as a child, her father practicing in the kitchen with the amp turned off so he would not wake her.

And now the same guitar was making it again, at her kitchen table, under the fingers of a man whose records her father had kept on the top shelf.

He played a slow little blues phrase, then another, bending one note very gently until it seemed to sigh.

Then he stopped, and turned the guitar around, and held it out to her across the table.

“Now you.”

Lainey shook her head immediately.

“No. No, I can’t. I haven’t played in nine years. My hands…”

“Your hands remember.”

“You don’t understand. I’m not being modest. I really can’t. I’ve forgotten.”

He kept holding the guitar out.

“Your neighbor told me the same thing this morning,” he said gently.

“She said, Lainey doesn’t play anymore, she forgot how. I told her people do not forget how. They forget that they are allowed.”

He set the guitar down in front of her.

“You are allowed.”

The apartment was very quiet.

Lainey looked at the guitar for a long time.

Then she pulled it into her lap.

Her left hand found the neck, and it found the place where her father had pressed her six-year-old fingers down for the first time.

She played one chord.

It was clumsy and a little out of time, and one string buzzed.

She winced.

“See?”

“Again,” he said.

She played it again.

It was better.

She played another, and another, and then a little run of notes, and her right hand started to remember the rhythm before her head did, and she was not looking at her fingers anymore, she was looking at the window, at the light, at nothing.

She played for six minutes.

She played a part she had recorded in 2006, for a song about a woman leaving a town in the rain, a part the producer had said was the best thing she ever did.

She missed a few notes.

She did not stop.

When she finished, her face was wet again, and she was smiling, and her fingertips were red and stinging from the new strings, and she looked down at them as if they belonged to somebody she used to know.

Carlos Santana nodded slowly.

“There she is,” he said.

Before he left, he wrote a phone number on the back of the five-dollar sticker she had put on the counter.

It was the number of a producer in Nashville he had known for thirty years.

“Call him on Monday,” he said.

“Tell him I said you are ready. If he does not believe you, tell him to call me.”

At the door he turned around one last time.

“And Lainey,” he said.

“Your husband will call his lawyer before the week is over. Don’t be afraid of him. Your father already took care of that.”

She did not understand what he meant.

She would understand it on a Tuesday afternoon nine months later, in a courtroom in Martinez, California.

—

## Why did Grant Sutter hire a lawyer on Monday morning?

He hired one on Sunday night, actually.

By then the video from the Benavides porch had been watched in every house on the court and a good number of houses beyond it.

On Monday morning, Grant’s biggest client, a developer he had been courting for two years, sent him a one-line email.

It said he had seen the video, and that they would be taking the project in a different direction.

By Monday afternoon, Grant had decided that the problem was not the video.

The problem was that he had been robbed.

He told an expensive lawyer the guitar was his, and the lawyer wrote a long, angry letter.

The judge had awarded him the house and its contents, he said.

Lainey had had thirty days.

She had not taken it.

Therefore it was his, and he had sold it by mistake, without knowing its value, to a man who had taken advantage of him, and he wanted it back.

Lainey’s lawyer, a tired woman named Dana Whitcombe who worked out of a strip mall in Concord, read that letter twice, then called Lainey and asked her one question.

“Do you have anything, anything at all, that shows the guitar was yours before you got married?”

Lainey looked at the guitar, which was lying on her couch, where it had lived every night since that Saturday.

“I think so,” she said.

“My father wrote something.”

The hearing was nine months later.

His lawyer argued for forty minutes.

The house and its contents.

The thirty days.

A good-faith mistake.

An unfair sale to a celebrity who should have known better.

Then Dana Whitcombe stood up, and opened a guitar case on the table in front of the judge, and lifted out an old white guitar with its front plate already unscrewed.

She asked permission to approach.

She held the guitar up so the judge could see the bare wood under the plate.

She read the date at the top out loud.

March 1999.

She pointed out that Lainey Coulter had married Grant Sutter in 2011.

Then she read the four lines at the bottom, slowly, in her flat, tired, strip-mall voice.

“This guitar is hers and nobody else’s.”

The courtroom was very quiet.

Dana Whitcombe was not finished.

She had brought the forty-second video.

She had brought a sworn statement from Rosalind Benavides about the changed locks and the thirty-seven stickers.

She had brought a hospital record showing that Lainey Coulter had spent eleven of her thirty days beside her mother’s bed.

And she had brought one more sworn statement, two pages long, signed in neat handwriting by a guitarist who had stopped at a yard sale on his way to visit a friend, and who described, as plainly as a weather report, a man in a lawn chair saying the words “her stuff, her problem.”

The judge did not take long.

The guitar, the judge ruled, had never been part of the marriage at all.

It had been Lainey’s property since 1999, a gift from her father, and the words he had written inside it said so in his own hand.

Grant had never owned it.

He had sold something that did not belong to him.

He had done it on purpose, to hurt her, after locking her out of the house while her mother was in the hospital.

The judge ordered Grant Sutter to pay Lainey Coulter for every one of her belongings he had sold to other people before Carlos Santana arrived, at their real value, which an appraiser later put at a little over nine thousand dollars, much of it for a set of her mother’s silver that a stranger had carried off for five dollars at eight-thirty in the morning.

Then the judge ordered him to pay her legal fees.

All of them.

Including the letter.

On the courthouse steps afterward, Grant’s lawyer shook Dana Whitcombe’s hand and said, not unkindly, “Hell of a piece of evidence.”

Dana shrugged.

“Her father wrote it,” she said.

“I just read it out loud.”

—

## Where does a five-dollar sticker end up?

Lainey Coulter went back to Nashville the following spring.

She went with the three children and a U-Haul trailer and her father’s guitar on the passenger seat, fastened in with the seat belt.

The producer whose number had been written on the back of a yellow sticker called her the week after the yard sale.

He did not call to be polite.

He called because a friend of fifty years had phoned him and said, “Listen to her, and then tell me I’m wrong.”

He listened to her.

He did not tell anyone they were wrong.

Her first session back was nine weeks after she arrived.

By some joke of the universe that she still does not entirely believe, it was for a country singer recording a song about a woman starting over after a divorce.

Lainey played the solo.

One take.

When it was finished, the producer pressed the talkback button and said nothing for a while.

Then he said, “Where have you been?”

Lainey said, “In a spare bedroom.”

She has played on a great many records since.

And inside her father’s guitar, under the white plate, the list is no longer finished.

She adds to it in pencil, after every session, in tiny letters, in the last bits of bare wood, the way he did, so that someday someone she loves can unscrew eleven screws and read it.

Rosalind Benavides still lives across the court from the house in Pleasant Hill.

She keeps Lainey’s Christmas cards in a drawer, and every year there is a new one, from Nashville, with a photograph of a woman in a recording studio holding an old white guitar.

Every year it says the same thing on the back.

“Still allowed.”

Carlos Santana never spoke publicly about the afternoon in Pleasant Hill.

When a local reporter tracked him down the following week, he said only that he had stopped at a yard sale, which he had done his whole life, and had found something that belonged to somebody else, and had taken it home.

He did not say whose home.

He did not mention the man in the lawn chair.

He has never mentioned him once.

—

## What does she say when someone asks?

Lainey Coulter teaches now, too, on Sunday afternoons, in a back room at a music store in East Nashville where kids come to try guitars they cannot afford yet.

She keeps her father’s guitar in its old brown case in the corner.

Sometimes she takes it out to show them.

And sometimes a student notices the thing taped to the inside of the case lid, under a strip of clear tape gone yellow with age.

It is a small round sticker.

It says five dollars.

On the back, faded but still readable, is a phone number in Nashville.

“What’s that?” they ask.

“That’s what somebody once thought this guitar was worth,” she tells them.

They always look at the guitar, and then at the sticker, and then back at the guitar, trying to work it out.

And sooner or later one of them always asks the question she asked herself, standing in a doorway behind a carwash with cracker crumbs on her jeans, on the afternoon her life started over.

“Where did you get this?”

Lainey Coulter smiles, and closes the case very gently, and tells them the truth.

“A man in a baseball cap bought it back for me,” she says.

“For five dollars.”

—

*About this story: this is a dramatized, fictional tribute, written for entertainment. Lainey and Curtis Coulter, Grant Sutter, Rosalind Benavides, Dana Whitcombe, the yard sale in Pleasant Hill, the court case in Martinez and everything that happens in these pages are invented, and Carlos Santana never made the visit described here. Pleasant Hill and Martinez are real towns in Contra Costa County, California, used only as settings. What is true is the background: Carlos Santana grew up partly in Tijuana before his family moved to San Francisco, he has spent more than half a century playing guitar, and early-1960s solid-body electric guitars in original condition really are among the most valuable instruments collectors buy. The rest is a story about what a single price sticker can and cannot measure.*

You Might Also Enjoy