Genghis Khan Had The Men Who Betrayed Jamukha Executed Before His Eyes In 1205, Then Granted His Blood Brother The Death He Asked For
A wooden platform, under a pale sky.
There is a picture that is meant to show the day the men who betrayed Genghis Khan’s oldest friend came to collect their reward, and this is what it shows.
The sky is the color of old parchment, empty and bright.
Across the middle of the picture runs a high platform of heavy planks, raised on crossed timbers like a stage.
On the left stands a tall commander in a coat of steel scales, with a purple sash at his waist and a helmet topped by a plume of red horsehair.
His beard is black and his face is hard.
In his right hand he holds a long sword, low at his side, its point turned down toward the boards.
Two soldiers with spears stand behind him, smaller, waiting for an order.
To his right, four thick wooden posts rise from the platform in a row.
A man is tied to each of them.
All four wear long white robes trimmed with purple, and thick coils of rope bind their arms to their sides and their backs to the wood.
None of them is looking at the commander.
All four have lifted their faces to the sky, as if they were listening for something that has not come yet.
Beyond the last post stands a great wooden machine, taller than a man, with a huge drum of timber and iron mounted on a frame, and heavy gears along its side.
Beneath the drum, a fifth man lies on his back on a long plank, his body wrapped in ropes, his hands resting on the edge of the wood.
At the far right, a soldier in red and steel stands beside the machine with both hands on the hilt of his sheathed sword.
Nobody is touching the crank.
In front of the platform, filling the bottom of the picture, a crowd of warriors stands with its back to us, in fur-trimmed hats and long braids, every head turned toward the posts.
Nobody in the picture is moving yet.
It is a picture that makes you wait for the commander to speak.
It is also an artist’s invention, and almost nothing in it comes from the record.
There was no platform, no row of posts and no machine with a drum.
No source describes white robes, an audience of braided warriors, or a man laid out under a wheel of timber.
What the oldest Mongol account does describe is stranger, and colder.
In the last months of 1205, or early in 1206, a hunted man named Jamukha was seized in the mountains by the handful of companions who were still with him.
They tied him up and brought him to the camp of the man he had once called his brother.
That man’s name was Temüjin, and within a few months the whole Mongol world would know him as Genghis Khan.
The men who had brought Jamukha in expected to be rewarded.
Temüjin had them put to death first, in front of the prisoner they had delivered.
Then he turned to Jamukha and offered him his life.
Jamukha said no.
He asked for something else, and what he asked for, and what he was given, is still argued over eight hundred years later.
—
## The book that tells the story
Almost everything we know about this afternoon comes from one book.
It is called the Secret History of the Mongols.
It was written in the Mongolian language, some time after Genghis Khan died in 1227, for the family that ruled the empire he left behind.
Nobody knows who wrote it.
It is not a chronicle in the European sense.
It is half history and half epic, full of long speeches in verse, proverbs, insults and boasts, and it tells the story of the khan’s life the way his own people wanted it remembered.
That makes it precious, and it also makes it tricky.
When the Secret History puts words in a man’s mouth, we are hearing what the Mongol court believed he had said, or thought he should have said.
There is a second great source, written in Persian about a century later, by a learned minister named Rashid al-Din, who compiled a vast history of the Mongols for their rulers in Iran.
On the death of Jamukha, the two books do not agree.
We will come to that.
First, the two boys.
—
## Two boys on the frozen Onon
Temüjin was born on the steppe of what is now northeastern Mongolia, most likely around 1162, although other dates are given.
His father, Yesügei, was a chief of the Mongol clans.
When Temüjin was about nine, his father stopped to eat with a group of Tatars on the road home, and he died soon afterward.
The family always believed he had been poisoned.
What followed was the experience that shaped everything Temüjin later became.
His father’s followers abandoned the widow and her children.
They packed up their tents and rode away, and left Hö’elün, Temüjin’s mother, alone on the steppe with seven young children.
She fed them on wild roots, berries and fish caught in the river.
Some time later, rivals from the Tayichi’ud clan captured the boy and kept him with a heavy wooden collar locked around his neck, a cangue, so that he could not lift his hands to his own mouth.
He escaped at night, with the help of a family who hid him in a cart loaded with wool.
He never forgot who had helped him, and he never forgot who had left him.
It was in these hard years that he met Jamukha.
Jamukha was a boy of the Jadaran, another Mongol clan, and he seems to have come from a more comfortable family.
According to the Secret History, the two boys first swore friendship when Temüjin was eleven, playing on the ice of the frozen Onon River.
Jamukha gave Temüjin a knucklebone from a roe deer, used in the game the boys played.
Temüjin gave him one cast in copper.
The next spring they swore again, and exchanged arrows.
They became anda.
—
## Anda
The word has no good translation in English.
It is usually rendered as “sworn brother” or “blood brother,” but it meant something more than a promise between friends.
Two men who became anda were bound for life, more closely than brothers by birth.
They were expected to defend each other, to share what they had, and never to raise a hand against one another.
Among the people of the steppe, it was one of the most sacred ties a man could have.
Years later, when they were grown men, Temüjin and Jamukha swore it a third time.
That oath came after the worst day of Temüjin’s young life.
—
## The rescue of Börte
Temüjin had married a girl named Börte, from the Onggirat people, who had been promised to him as a child.
Not long after the wedding, Merkit raiders swept down on his camp at dawn.
Temüjin escaped into the mountains.
Börte was carried off.
He had almost no men of his own.
So he went to two powerful allies for help.
One was Toghrul, the khan of the Kereit, who had once been his father’s anda.
The other was Jamukha, who by now was a leader in his own right, with warriors of his own.
Jamukha agreed at once, and he commanded the expedition.
The allied army fell on the Merkit camps by night, and in the confusion Temüjin found his wife among the people fleeing in the dark.
It was the first great victory of his life, and he owed it in large part to Jamukha.
The two young men renewed their oath beneath a spreading tree.
This time they exchanged golden belts and horses.
The Secret History says they feasted together and slept under one blanket, and for a year and a half they moved their camps together across the steppe.
—
## The parting
Then, one day, it ended.
The Secret History tells it as a riddle.
The two anda were riding at the head of their moving camps when Jamukha said something that Temüjin did not understand.
If we pitch our tents by the mountain, Jamukha said, the herders of horses will have a place to live.
If we pitch them by the stream, the herders of sheep and lambs will have enough to eat.
Temüjin did not answer.
He rode back and asked his mother what it meant.
Before Hö’elün could reply, Börte answered for her.
Jamukha was tired of them, she said, and the words were a warning.
They should not stop where Jamukha stopped.
They should keep moving, through the night.
They did, and by morning a number of families from Jamukha’s camp had followed them.
Nobody today can be sure what Jamukha meant.
Some historians read the riddle as a hint about two kinds of people, the herders of horses and the herders of sheep, the great families and the humble ones, and about which side each man would stand on.
What is certain is that from that night on, the two anda were rivals.
—
## The battle of the Thirteen Sides
Around 1189, by most reckonings, Temüjin was raised up as khan by a group of Mongol clans.
Jamukha did not like it.
The quarrel that broke them came over horses.
Jamukha’s younger brother, Taichar, rode out and drove off a herd belonging to one of Temüjin’s followers.
The owner chased him down and shot him dead.
Jamukha answered with an army.
The Secret History says he came with thirty thousand men from thirteen clans, and that Temüjin met him with his own followers gathered in thirteen camps.
It is remembered as the battle of Dalan Baljut, or the battle of the Thirteen Sides.
Jamukha won.
Temüjin was driven back into a narrow gorge.
What Jamukha did next is the darkest thing the Secret History records of him.
He took young men of a clan that had sided with Temüjin and had them boiled alive in seventy cauldrons.
The book tells it in a single line.
It was a victory, but it cost him.
The cruelty of that day horrified many of the men who had fought beside him.
Soon afterward, whole clans left Jamukha’s camp and rode over to Temüjin.
He had lost the battle and won the men.
—
## The universal khan
The rivalry went on for more than a decade.
In 1201, a coalition of peoples who feared Temüjin’s rise gathered on the banks of the Ergüne River.
They swore an oath together, and they raised Jamukha up as their leader, with the title Gür Khan.
It meant something like universal khan.
It was the highest point of his life.
It did not last.
Temüjin and his ally Toghrul met the coalition and broke it.
Jamukha’s allies scattered, and the Secret History says that as he fled he plundered the very people who had chosen him.
Then he did something that would become a habit.
He went over to the other side.
He joined Toghrul, the khan of the Kereit, Temüjin’s ally and protector, and began whispering against Temüjin in Toghrul’s tent.
In 1203 Toghrul and his son turned on Temüjin and tried to destroy him.
Temüjin survived with only a few thousand men, by the shore of a muddy lake called Baljuna.
That autumn he came back and destroyed the Kereit.
Jamukha slipped away again.
This time he went west, to the most powerful people left on the steppe, the Naiman.
—
## The law of the rightful lord
By now Temüjin had become something the steppe had not seen before.
He promoted men for their ability and their loyalty, not only for their birth.
Some of his best generals were the sons of herdsmen and blacksmiths.
And he had made one rule so clear that everyone on the steppe came to know it.
The Secret History tells a story about it.
After Temüjin defeated the Tayichi’ud, the clan that had once locked the wooden collar on his neck, their chief, a man named Targhutai, fled into the woods.
An old man named Shirgü’etü and his two sons, Alaq and Naya’a, found him and seized him.
Targhutai was so fat that he could not ride a horse, so they loaded him into a cart and set off toward Temüjin, expecting to be rewarded for bringing in his old enemy.
On the way, the younger son, Naya’a, stopped them.
If we bring him in, he said, Temüjin will say that we laid hands on our own rightful lord.
He will say that men like that cannot be trusted, and he will put us to death.
So they let Targhutai go.
They rode on to Temüjin empty-handed and told him exactly what they had done.
Temüjin’s answer was the opposite of what most men would have expected.
If you had laid hands on your own khan, he told them, I would have put you to death, and your kin with you.
Because you could not bring yourselves to betray your rightful lord, you did well.
He rewarded Naya’a, who later became one of his commanders.
There is another story like it.
In one of the battles of 1201, an archer on the enemy side shot Temüjin’s horse out from under him.
When the fighting was over, Temüjin asked the prisoners who had done it.
A young man stepped forward and said that he had.
Temüjin said that an enemy who hides what he has done is not worth keeping, but a man who tells the truth about it is worth having as a companion.
He gave the archer a new name, Jebe, which means “arrow,” and Jebe became one of the greatest generals of the age.
Temüjin could forgive an enemy who had fought him openly.
What he would not forgive was a man who turned on his own lord.
Jamukha’s last companions had either never heard these stories, or they did not believe them.
—
## The cliffs of Chakirmaut
In the spring of 1204, Temüjin marched west against the Naiman.
Their ruler, Tayang Khan, met him near a mountain called Naqu, at a place the sources call Chakirmaut.
Jamukha was in the Naiman camp.
The Secret History gives him a famous scene on the eve of the battle.
As Temüjin’s army came on, Tayang Khan stood on the high ground and asked Jamukha who these men were.
Jamukha told him.
He described Temüjin’s generals one after another, as hounds fed on human flesh, chained up and straining to be let loose.
He described Temüjin himself as a hawk hungry for prey, in armor of bronze, so that there was no gap for an awl to pierce.
Each time, Tayang Khan was more frightened, and each time he pulled his army farther up the mountain.
Then Jamukha left.
He took his own men and rode away from the Naiman before the fighting began.
According to the Secret History, he even sent a messenger to Temüjin, to tell his anda that Tayang Khan had lost his nerve and that the Naiman were retreating up the slope.
Whether that message is history, or a later touch added to make Jamukha look like a reluctant enemy, nobody can say.
The battle was a slaughter.
In the night many Naiman tried to escape down the cliffs and fell to their deaths.
Tayang Khan was mortally wounded.
His people were scattered.
Jamukha had escaped again.
But this time there was nowhere left to go.
—
## Five men in the mountains
Most of Jamukha’s own people surrendered to Temüjin after Chakirmaut.
Jamukha did not.
The Secret History says that he was left with only five companions, and that he lived with them like a bandit in the mountains, on the slopes it calls the Tanglu.
Every great alliance he had ever led was gone.
The Jadaran, the coalition of the Gür Khan, the Kereit, the Naiman, all of them had either been destroyed or had come over to the other side.
He was a man who had once been raised up as universal khan, and now he was living on what five men could hunt.
One day they killed a wild mountain sheep, an argali, and roasted it over a fire.
While they were eating it, the five companions seized Jamukha and tied him up.
The Secret History does not say why.
It does not need to.
Five men were starving in the mountains with a hunted leader, and every valley below them belonged to Temüjin.
Their leader had abandoned allies before.
The men who had made the right choice years earlier were now rich in horses and cattle in Temüjin’s camp.
The companions could count.
The Secret History does not give their names.
—
## Black crows
They rode down out of the mountains with Jamukha bound between them, toward the camp of the man they were sure would pay them.
It is one of the strangest journeys in the history of the steppe.
The five men holding the reins believed they were riding to their reward.
The man in the ropes was the only one who seems to have understood where they were all going.
When they reached Temüjin, Jamukha sent a message to his anda.
The Secret History gives it as a little verse.
Black crows, it says, have caught a duck.
Common servants have laid hands on their own lord.
My khan, my anda, will you see that for what it is?
It was not a plea for his own life.
It was a reminder of the law.
—
## The reward
Temüjin understood it at once.
His answer, as the Secret History gives it, was short.
How can men who have laid hands on their own rightful khan be allowed to live?
Whose companions could such men ever be?
He ordered them to be put to death.
The Secret History says it was done in front of Jamukha, so that he would see it.
Some translations add that the order reached past the five men themselves, to their families.
We do not know how they died, and the Secret History does not say.
It only records the order and the reason for it.
Think for a moment about what that afternoon must have looked like from the place where those five men stood.
They had made what looked like the smartest choice on the steppe.
They had left the losing side at the last possible moment and brought the winner his last great enemy, alive.
Up to the moment their own hands were bound, they believed they were about to be given horses, cattle and a place in the new order.
What they had misunderstood was the very thing that order was built on.
Temüjin did not reward men for switching to the winning side.
He rewarded men who would not betray their own lord, even a beaten one.
A man who would hand over his own khan for a price would one day hand over the next one.
The five companions had proved, in a single afternoon, that they were exactly the kind of men he could never keep.
Nobody in the Mongol camp could have missed the lesson.
The Secret History made sure that nobody reading it afterward could miss it either.
The five men who solved Temüjin’s greatest problem are not even remembered by name.
—
## The offer
Then Temüjin turned to Jamukha.
What he said next is the part of the story that has always surprised readers.
He did not gloat.
He asked his old anda to come back.
In the Secret History, Temüjin reminds Jamukha of everything that had once bound them.
Now we are together again, he says.
Let us be companions.
When one of us forgets something, let the other remind him.
When one of us falls asleep, let the other wake him.
He reminds Jamukha that even while they were enemies, Jamukha had sent him warnings, once about the plans of the Kereit, and once on the eve of the battle with the Naiman.
He calls him his lucky anda.
It is an offer of life, and of a place at Temüjin’s side.
No other great rival of Temüjin’s, in the whole of the Secret History, is offered anything like it.
—
## The louse in the collar
Jamukha’s answer is one of the longest speeches in the book.
He remembers the two boys on the ice of the Onon, and the food they shared that could never be digested, and the words they spoke that could never be forgotten.
He says that other men came between them and turned them against each other.
And now, he says, Temüjin has gathered all the peoples of the steppe under him.
What use would Jamukha be to him now, as a companion?
He would be a trouble to Temüjin’s dreams at night and a worry to his heart by day.
He would be like a louse in Temüjin’s collar, and like a splinter in the lining of his coat.
His own parents had died young, he says, and he has no younger brothers to stand behind him.
Temüjin has a wise mother and able brothers, and companions beyond counting.
Jamukha had wanted to be first, and he had lost.
Then he makes his request.
If you want to do me a kindness, anda, he says, let me die quickly, so that your heart will be at peace.
When you put me to death, let it be done without shedding my blood.
Lay my bones in a high place.
And then, he promises, his spirit will watch over Temüjin’s children and grandchildren for ever.
—
## A death without blood
To a modern reader the request sounds strange.
To the people of the steppe, it was the most important thing he could have asked.
The Mongols believed that a person’s spirit lived in the blood.
To spill the blood of a man of high birth on the ground was a dishonor to him, and it could be dangerous for those who did it.
So when a prince or a great lord had to be put to death, the custom was to do it without letting any blood be shed.
Half a century later, when the Mongols took Baghdad in 1258, the last Abbasid caliph is said by many accounts to have been killed in that way, wrapped in a carpet so that none of his royal blood would touch the earth.
The Secret History says that Temüjin did not want to grant the request.
He told his people that he could find no just reason to put his anda to death.
Then he pointed to the old quarrel, to the horse raid and the battle of the Thirteen Sides, and he gave the order.
Let him be put to death without his blood being shed, he said, and let his bones not be left out in the open.
Bury them properly.
That is all the Secret History says.
It does not describe the method.
Later writers, and many modern ones, say that Jamukha’s back was broken, because that was a common way of carrying out a bloodless death on the steppe.
That may be right.
But it is not in the oldest account.
—
## The other version
The second version is much darker.
It comes from the Persian history compiled by Rashid al-Din, around a hundred years after the event.
In that version there is no gentle ending at all.
Temüjin hands Jamukha over to one of his young kinsmen, a nephew named Eljigidei, and Jamukha is cut apart, limb by limb.
The two accounts cannot both be true.
It is tempting to say that the Mongol version must be the softer story, polished by the court to make the founding of the empire look honorable.
It is just as possible that the Persian version is the distorted one, written far away and long afterward, by a man who did not share the steppe’s horror of royal blood spilled on the ground.
Rashid al-Din worked for Mongol rulers too, and his history had its own loyalties.
Historians have weighed the two for a long time, and most lean toward the Secret History, because it is older, because it comes from inside the Mongol world, and because the bloodless death fits everything we know about how the Mongols treated men of high birth.
But nobody can prove it.
Both books agree on what matters most.
Jamukha died, and the men who had betrayed him died before him.
—
## The khan with a new name
With Jamukha gone, there was no one left on the steppe who could claim to be Temüjin’s equal.
In the spring of 1206, a great assembly of the clans gathered near the source of the Onon River, not far from the place where two boys had once played on the ice.
A white banner with nine tails was raised.
And Temüjin was proclaimed ruler of all the peoples who lived in felt tents, under the title by which the world remembers him.
He became Chinggis Khan, written in English as Genghis Khan.
Nobody is quite sure what the name meant.
Some scholars connect it with the ocean, and with a ruler as wide as the sea, and others with a word meaning firm or fierce.
He was somewhere in his forties.
The boy who had been abandoned on the steppe with his mother now ruled every Mongol clan.
Over the next twenty years his armies would conquer northern China, Central Asia and Persia, and his sons and grandsons would build the largest land empire the world has ever seen.
—
## The gate at Otrar
The law of the rightful lord went with him.
Fifteen years after Jamukha died, it was tested again, in a city far to the west.
In 1218 a caravan of merchants sent by Genghis Khan arrived at Otrar, a trading town on the Syr Darya River, in what is now Kazakhstan, on the frontier of the Khwarazmian Empire.
The governor of Otrar, a man named Inalchuq, accused the merchants of spying and had them killed and their goods seized.
When Genghis Khan sent envoys to demand justice, the Khwarazmian ruler, Shah Muhammad II, had one of them put to death and the others humiliated.
Genghis Khan answered with war.
In the autumn of 1219 his army arrived at Otrar, and the siege lasted about five months.
One of the commanders inside the city was a man named Qaracha.
The Persian historians say that, as the siege dragged on, he decided that the city could not be held.
One night he opened a gate and came out to the Mongols with his men, to surrender.
The Mongol princes in charge of the siege did not thank him.
They said that a man who had betrayed his own master would betray them too, and they had Qaracha and his men put to death.
Otrar fell.
Inalchuq held out in the citadel for about another month, until he was taken.
He was put to death later, and a famous story says that molten silver was poured into his eyes and ears, as a punishment for his greed.
That story may be a legend.
The fate of Qaracha is not.
Fifteen years apart and two thousand miles apart, the same rule had been applied in almost the same way.
—
## A rule, not a myth
It would be too simple to say that Genghis Khan killed every man who changed sides.
He did not.
His empire was built in large part on people who came over to him.
Whole clans that had fought for Jamukha rode into Temüjin’s camp and were welcomed.
Jebe had shot his horse, and was made a general.
Generals of the Jin dynasty in northern China, engineers, scribes and merchants entered his service and rose high in it.
The line that he drew was narrower, and harder.
A man could surrender.
A man could come over in the open, with his people and his herds.
What he could not do was lay hands on his own lord and bring him in as the price of a welcome.
That was the one bargain Genghis Khan would never accept.
The five men in the mountains did not understand the difference.
Neither did Qaracha at the gate of Otrar.
And Shirgü’etü’s son Naya’a, who let his old lord go free in the woods, understood it better than any of them.
—
## The words nobody wrote down
Nobody recorded what Temüjin said to the five men as they stood waiting for their reward, beyond the few lines of the Secret History.
Nobody recorded the look on Jamukha’s face as he watched.
The lines below are imagined, a way of hearing that afternoon in the voice of the man who would soon be Genghis Khan.
Only the second and the last of them follow the Secret History, and only in substance.
He stands with his sword held low, and looks at the men who brought Jamukha in.
“They tied up their own khan and brought him to me for a reward.”
His eyes do not leave them.
“Men who lay hands on their own lord, who could ever trust them again?”
He does not raise his voice.
“Let Jamukha see what they have earned.”
Then he turns toward his anda, and for a moment his voice is the voice of the boy on the frozen river.
“Jamukha, my anda. Ride beside me again.”
—
## The picture, once more
Look at the picture one last time.
The parchment sky.
The high platform of planks.
The commander in steel scales, with the red plume on his helmet and his sword held low.
The four men in white robes, roped to their posts, their faces turned up to the sky.
The great machine with its drum of timber and iron, the fifth man lying bound on the plank beneath it, and the soldier beside it with his hands on his sword.
The crowd of braided warriors with their backs to us.
Now it is possible to say what is true in it.
The bound men are true.
The men who brought Jamukha in expected a reward, and they were tied up and put to death, in public, in front of the man they had betrayed.
The crowd is true, in its way.
The whole point of what Temüjin did that day was that people should see it and remember it.
Almost everything else is invented.
The picture happens to show five bound men, four at the posts and one under the drum, and the Secret History does say there were five companions.
But the book gives them no posts, no platform and no stage.
The long white robes trimmed with purple look more like the dress of a Chinese court than the felt and leather of men who had been living wild in the mountains, and nothing like the machine with the drum appears in any source.
Nobody knows exactly how the five men died.
And Jamukha himself, if the oldest account is right, was given the one thing the picture cannot show.
Not a machine and not a spectacle, but a death without blood, at the request of the man who received it, from the anda who did not want to give it.
The men who betrayed him were given nothing at all.
Not a horse, not a reward, not even their names.