News

“Cut Her Down!” She Was Strung Upside Down For Horse Theft… Until A Wild Horse Refused To Pull The Wagon Without Her — Then A Nameless Gunslinger Arrived

The first thing she saw every time she opened her eyes was the horse’s face, upside down.

It was a strange face.

White, mostly, and freckled all over with small dark spots, as if somebody had flicked a paintbrush at it, with a black muzzle and a black forelock and two dark eyes that would not leave her.

It was close enough that she could feel its breath on her hair.

Behind it the street was the wrong way up, the dust on top and the blue September sky underneath, and the false fronts of Pendleton hanging down into the sky like teeth.

Her name was Linnea Vantine.

She was twenty-five years old, and she was hanging head down from the long loading pole of Alvah Bixby’s freight wagon, in the middle of Main Street, in the middle of a Thursday afternoon, in front of perhaps sixty people.

They said she was a horse thief.

Behind the spotted horse, two of Bixby’s teamsters were hauling on ropes with all their weight, their boots skidding in the dust, red in the face and shouting.

They had been trying for ten minutes to drag that horse back to the wagon and hitch him in the lead and drive him out of town.

The horse would not go.

Every time they dragged him a step, he took two steps back, and planted himself again under the pole, under her, with his head down by her face.

Across the street, a woman in a plaid dress stood on the boardwalk with both hands pressed over her mouth.

That was when a rider came up out of the south end of town, from the Canyon City road, an old man on a dusty sorrel horse, in a flat-brimmed brown hat and a wool poncho striped wine-red and brown.

He rode up Main Street at a walk until he was close enough to see the whole of it, the wagon and the pole and the woman and the men with the ropes, and he stopped, and got down, and stood in the street beside his horse with the reins in his hand, looking up at her.

Linnea saw him upside down, between the horse’s front legs.

“He won’t pull,” she said, as loud as she could, which was not very loud.

“Not while I’m up here.”

The old man looked at the horse for a long moment, and then up at her.

“Cut her down,” he said.

The foreman with the rope laughed at him.

“She’s a horse thief, grandpa.”

“Then the horse will say so,” the old man said.

Nobody in the street understood what he meant by that.

Alvah Bixby had a bill of sale for that horse in his vest pocket, signed and dated, and he had already shown it to half the town.

But before the sun went down that day, the man whose name was signed at the bottom of it would be standing in that same street, in irons.

And the spotted horse would tell all of Pendleton exactly how old he was, which was the one thing that Alvah Bixby had never thought to ask.

—

## How do you steal a horse that already belongs to you?

Lucas Vantine had been a horse trader in the Umatilla country for twenty years, and in all that time, his daughter used to say, he had only ever made one deal he was proud of.

In the autumn of 1872 he bought a spotted mare from a Cayuse horseman on the reservation east of Pendleton.

The Cayuse had been raising horses in that country since long before there was a Pendleton, and they were so famous for it that half the West used their name as a word for any tough, sure-footed little horse.

The man who sold the mare knew exactly what she was worth.

Lucas paid two good saddles, a rifle and forty dollars, and never complained about the price.

She foaled in April of 1873, on a night of hard rain when McKay Creek came up over its banks and took the footbridge out, and the foal was a leggy white colt sprinkled all over with small black spots.

Linnea was fourteen.

She sat up in the barn with him all night.

In the morning her father looked at the colt and said he looked like somebody had spilled a purse of sixpences over him, and that was his name.

Sixpence grew up wild in temper and gentle in nothing except with her.

He would not be caught by anybody else.

He would not be ridden by anybody else.

He bit two of her father’s hired men and put a horse buyer from Walla Walla over the corral fence.

But Linnea could walk out into the pasture and whistle two notes, high and low, and he would come across a quarter mile of open grass at a dead run and stop with his nose an inch from her face.

She broke him to saddle herself, at fifteen.

She never broke him to harness.

Her father tried once, and Sixpence kicked the singletree into kindling.

“Some horses pull,” Lucas Vantine said.

“That one carries.”

Lucas died in October of 1883, of his heart, in the barn, with a halter in his hand.

He left his daughter a quarter section on Wildhorse Creek, nine good horses, a stack of debts and a reputation, and Linnea set out to pay off the debts the only way she knew.

She broke horses for other people.

She was the best hand with a bad horse in Umatilla County, and everybody said so, even the men who did not like to.

One of the men she broke horses for was Alvah Bixby.

Bixby owned the biggest freight outfit in Pendleton, sixty mules and forty horses and eleven wagons, hauling sacked wheat from the farms to the railroad and freight from the railroad south over the Blue Mountains to the John Day country.

He was a round, pink, cheerful man with a gold watch chain and a laugh you could hear across the street, and he paid on time.

He had also, more than once, offered to buy Sixpence.

He offered a hundred dollars, and then two hundred, and then four.

“That’s a lot of horse to be standing in a pasture eating,” he said.

“A horse like that ought to work.”

“He works,” Linnea said.

“He carries me.”

In July of 1884, somebody came onto the Vantine place on Wildhorse Creek in the dark of the moon and cut the pasture fence and took seven horses.

Sixpence was one of them.

—

## The brand on his hip that wasn’t there in July

Horse stealing was the plague of eastern Oregon in those years.

Gangs worked the whole country from the Snake River to the Cascades, and they were good at it.

They would run a bunch of horses off a ranch in Umatilla County and have them across the Blue Mountains and in a corral in Baker or Idaho within four days, with the brands burned over and a bill of sale for every one of them.

Sheriff Lafayette Purvis rode out after the Wildhorse Creek horses the morning Linnea reported them.

He came back eight days later, sunburned and empty-handed.

He was a decent, worn-out man with too much county and too few deputies, and he told her the truth.

“They’re gone, Miss Vantine,” he said.

“I’m sorry. You’ll never see that spotted horse again.”

She saw him again on the tenth of September, at about six in the evening.

She was walking back up Main Street from the depot, where she had been delivering a pair of broke mules, and she passed the gate of Bixby’s freight yard.

The yard was full of dust and noise, a wagon being loaded, mules braying.

And at the back, in the round corral by the blacksmith’s shed, with his head over the top rail and his ears pricked toward her, stood Sixpence.

She knew him from a hundred yards.

She would have known him from a mile.

She walked into the yard and straight back to the corral, and he came across it to her at a trot and pushed his nose into her chest so hard he nearly knocked her down.

And when she ran her hand back along his neck and over his shoulder to his hip, she found it there, under her fingers, raw and new and peeling.

A brand.

An A and a B, joined.

Burned right over the spots.

Alvah Bixby came out of his office with his napkin still tucked in his collar.

He was very kind about it.

He said he could see how she might be confused.

Spotted horses all looked alike to most people.

But this one was his, bought fair and square, and he had the paper to prove it, and he took a folded bill of sale out of his vest pocket and held it up for her to read, without letting go of it.

She read it.

It said that on the thirtieth of July, 1884, at Baker City, Alvah Bixby had bought of J. D. Stidham one spotted stud horse, four years old, no brand, for the sum of forty dollars.

It was signed and witnessed.

“Forty dollars,” Linnea said.

“You offered me four hundred.”

Bixby’s smile did not change at all.

“I offered you four hundred for a horse that was yours,” he said.

“This one belongs to me. I’d advise you to go home, Miss Vantine, before somebody misunderstands why you’re standing in my corral.”

She went to the sheriff’s office.

It was locked.

A note on the door said that the sheriff and two deputies had ridden into the Blue Mountains after a band of horse thieves and would be back on Thursday evening.

She went home.

She did not sleep.

She sat on the porch of her father’s house on Wildhorse Creek with his old coat around her shoulders and the empty pasture in front of her in the moonlight, and she did the arithmetic that every horse owner in that country could do in her sleep.

The sheriff would be back Thursday evening.

The two o’clock freight left for Canyon City on Thursday afternoon.

Bixby’s teamsters had been talking about it in the yard while she stood at the corral, the load, the route, the team.

A horse that went south on that wagon would be over the Blue Mountains before the sheriff got his boots off, and sold to a stranger in another county by Saturday, with a new name and a forty-dollar bill of sale, and she would never find him twice.

She thought about her father, who had always said that a woman alone with a horse trade had to be twice as right as a man to be believed half as much.

She thought about the two notes, high and low.

At three o’clock on Thursday morning she walked back into Pendleton in the dark, climbed into Bixby’s yard over the back fence, and whistled two notes, high and low.

—

## Why they hung her from the freight wagon instead of a tree

She got him as far as the street.

That was all.

She had a halter on him and the corral gate open and him walking quietly out beside her in the dark, and then a lantern came around the corner of the blacksmith’s shed, and Jace Dunning was standing in the gateway with a shotgun.

Dunning was Bixby’s wagon boss.

He was a lean, black-haired man of thirty-five with a black hat and a gray shirt and a leather vest, and he slept in the yard because somebody had to.

He did not raise the shotgun.

He did not need to.

He only shouted, and lights came on all down the street.

By seven o’clock that morning half of Pendleton knew that Linnea Vantine had been caught stealing a horse out of Bixby’s yard.

By noon the other half knew it too.

The town’s mood that summer was ugly.

Ranchers had lost horses all over the county.

Two men had been hanged by a mob on the Snake River in June for horse theft, and some of the men in Pendleton thought that was a fine example.

Bixby knew that.

He let them talk all morning.

And at about one o’clock, when the street was full of farmers in town to sell wheat, he came out onto the boardwalk in front of his office with his gold watch chain and his bill of sale and made a speech.

He said he would not press charges against a woman.

He said Lucas Vantine had been a friend of his.

He said nobody would ever say that Alvah Bixby had sent a woman to the penitentiary.

But he said that seven horses had gone off Wildhorse Creek in July, and the only person in the county who claimed to have lost them was the same person who had just been caught in his corral at three in the morning, and he would leave it to the town to work out what that meant.

He said he only wanted to know where the other six had gone.

“She can tell us,” he said.

“Or she can think about it a while.”

It was Dunning who did it.

Bixby only nodded.

The lead wagon of the two o’clock freight stood in the street in front of the yard, loaded and tarped, with a long timber loading pole lashed out over the street from its front standards for swinging barrels up onto the high load.

Dunning took a lariat off the wagon.

He tied her ankles together with it, quickly and well, the way he would have tied a calf’s, and threw the other end up over the pole.

Two of the teamsters hauled on it.

It took about four seconds.

Linnea felt the street fall away underneath her and the sky swing over, and then she was hanging head down in the air with the blood roaring in her ears and her hair hanging down toward the dust and the whole of Main Street the wrong way up.

Then Dunning climbed up on the load and lashed her wrists up to the pole too, with two short turns of rope at each wrist, so that she hung folded beneath it with her arms up and her head down and could not reach the knot.

There was a noise from the crowd.

Not a cheer.

Something lower.

Across the street, a woman in a plaid dress came off the boardwalk at a run.

It was Philippa Rennick, who kept the boarding house opposite the freight yard and had known Linnea since she was a child.

She did not say a word to anybody.

She took a leather strap off her own waist and bound Linnea’s skirts close at the knees, with her own hands, so that the dress would stay where it belonged, and then she went back across the street and stood on her boardwalk with both hands over her mouth, and nobody dared tell her to stop looking.

“Where are the other six, Miss Vantine?” Bixby called from the boardwalk.

“Ask your bill of sale,” Linnea said.

It came out as a whisper.

—

## The horse that would not pull

Bixby’s plan for the horse was simple, and he had made it the night before.

The two o’clock freight was going south over the Blue Mountains to Canyon City, in Grant County, a hundred and twenty miles away and out of Sheriff Purvis’s reach.

The spotted horse would go with it, in the lead of the team, and he would be sold in Canyon City to somebody who had never heard of Wildhorse Creek, and by the time the sheriff rode back into Pendleton there would be nothing left to argue about but a woman’s word against a signed bill of sale.

Dunning had told him the horse had never been in harness.

Bixby had said that was what whips were for.

They brought Sixpence out of the corral on two lead ropes, Dunning on one and a big young teamster named Billy Gannon on the other, at about twenty minutes past one.

He came out of the yard dancing and blowing, his eyes rolling white, fighting the ropes every step.

They had a harness ready for him on the wagon tongue.

And then he saw her.

Everybody in the street saw it happen.

The horse stopped dead.

His head came up, high, and his ears went forward, and he looked at the woman hanging from the loading pole, and he made a sound that Philippa Rennick said afterward she had never heard a horse make before or since, not a whinny and not a scream but something in between.

Then he went to her.

He went straight through Dunning and Gannon as if they were made of straw.

He tore both lead ropes through their hands, and Gannon sat down hard in the dust, and the horse crossed the twenty yards to the wagon at a trot and stopped under the loading pole, directly under her, and put his head down beside her face.

And he planted himself.

That was the word everybody used afterward.

Planted.

All four feet spread and braced in the dust of Main Street as if they had grown roots there, his head low, his body between her and the crowd.

Linnea opened her eyes and saw his face upside down an inch from hers.

“Hello, boy,” she whispered.

His breath came warm on her face.

He blew softly through his nose, the way he used to when she came out to the pasture, and she began to cry, which was a strange thing to do upside down, because the tears ran up into her hair instead of down.

Dunning got up and got hold of a lead rope again, and so did Gannon, and the two of them leaned back on the ropes with all their weight and hauled.

The horse did not move.

They dragged his head around, and he let his head go, but his feet stayed where they were.

They hauled until the veins stood out on their necks and their boots skidded and threw dust, and he gave them one step, grudgingly, and then took it back, and stood under her again.

The crowd had gone quiet.

Linnea could hear everything now, upside down.

The scrape of the men’s boots.

The horse’s breathing.

The creak of the loading pole over her head.

Somebody’s dog barking down the street.

The blood roaring in her ears, louder and louder, and the edges of everything going gray.

She knew how long a person could hang head down.

Her father had told her once, about a man he had seen hung by his heels in a mining camp in Idaho.

Not long, he had said.

Half an hour.

Less, for some.

She had been up there twelve minutes.

“Get the whip,” Bixby called from the boardwalk.

Billy Gannon let go of his rope and went and got a long bull whip off the wagon seat and came back with it and shook it out in the dust.

And the horse saw it, and swung his hindquarters around between the whip and the woman, and laid his ears flat back, and showed Billy Gannon the whites of his eyes and every one of his teeth.

Gannon stopped.

He was a big young man and he was not, as it turned out, a stupid one.

He stood there with the whip in his hand and looked at the spotted horse standing guard under the hanging woman, and something in his face changed.

“Mr. Bixby,” he called, “I don’t believe that horse has ever seen you before in his life.”

Nobody laughed.

The woman in the plaid dress took her hands down from her mouth.

Up and down Main Street, people were looking at each other.

Farmers who had come in that morning to sell wheat and had heard all morning that the Vantine girl was a horse thief.

Ranchers who had lost horses that summer themselves.

Men who knew horses, because everybody in that country knew horses.

They had all just watched a horse that nobody could handle walk through two grown men to get to the woman who was supposed to have stolen him.

“Gannon,” Bixby said, very pleasantly, “use the whip or draw your time.”

Gannon looked at the whip in his hand.

Then he looked at Linnea, hanging there with her eyes closed and her face dark red.

He dropped the whip in the dust.

Dunning swore and went for it himself.

And that was when the old man on the sorrel horse came riding up the middle of Main Street from the south end of town.

—

## The rider who came up the Canyon City road

He was a lean, weathered man in his late fifties, with gray stubble on his jaw and pale eyes squinted half shut against the sun.

His flat-brimmed brown hat was sweat-stained, and his heavy wool poncho was striped dark wine-red and brown with pale geometric bands, and under it he wore a faded shirt and a worn gun belt with one holstered revolver.

His sorrel horse was dusty to the knees.

It had come a long way in a hurry, and then slowed down at the edge of town, and walked the rest.

He rode up the street until he was close enough to see the whole of it, and he stopped, and swung down, and stood in the dust beside the sorrel with the reins in his left hand.

He looked at the wagon.

He looked at the loading pole and the lariat and the woman hanging from it with her skirts strapped at the knee by a stranger’s belt.

He looked at the spotted horse planted under her, ears back, and the big young teamster standing empty-handed, and the whip in the dust, and Jace Dunning bending to pick it up.

Then he looked at the woman’s face, upside down, and her eyes opened and found him.

“He won’t pull,” Linnea said, as loud as she could.

“Not while I’m up here.”

The old man looked at the horse for a long moment.

Then he looked up at the loading pole.

“Cut her down,” he said.

Dunning straightened up with the whip in his hand and laughed at him.

“She’s a horse thief, grandpa,” he said.

“Mind your business and ride on through.”

“Then the horse will say so,” the old man said.

Dunning shook out the whip.

The old man’s hand moved under the poncho.

There was one shot, flat and hard, and a fountain of dust jumped up out of the street a foot in front of Dunning’s boots, between him and the horse, and Dunning went back two steps without meaning to and nearly fell over the wagon tongue.

The revolver was already back under the poncho.

The sorrel horse had not even flinched.

The spotted horse had not moved either.

Not one foot.

“I said cut her down,” the old man said, in the same quiet voice.

“I’m not going to say it a third time.”

Nobody moved.

Then Billy Gannon, the teamster who had dropped the whip, walked over to the front of the wagon where the lariat was made fast around the brake post, and he looked at the old man.

“She’ll fall on her head, mister,” he said.

“No, she won’t,” the old man said.

“Ease it out slow. The horse knows what to do.”

He was right.

Philippa Rennick told it for the rest of her life.

Gannon climbed up onto the load and cut the turns at her wrists, and then he paid the lariat out a few inches at a time, and Linnea came down out of the air, slowly, and the spotted horse stood under her like a stone.

Her hands found his neck first.

Then her shoulders came down onto his withers, and she slid her arms around his neck and held on, and the old man took a knife out of his boot and cut the lariat at her ankles.

She came down onto her feet in the dust of Main Street with both arms around the horse’s neck, and her legs would not hold her, and she did not need them to.

The horse held her up.

The old man stood beside them, not touching her.

“Breathe,” he said.

“Slow. Your head’s going to pound for an hour. Then it’ll stop.”

She breathed.

After a while she looked at him.

“Who are you?” she said.

“Thurlow Beckwith,” the old man said.

“I’ve been looking for that horse for six weeks, ma’am. And six others.”

She stared at him.

Around them the street had begun to move again, people coming down off the boardwalks, somebody bringing a dipper of water from the trough, Philippa Rennick hurrying across with her arms out.

Linnea did not let go of the horse.

“You said the horse would say so,” she said.

“What did you mean?”

Beckwith looked at the spotted horse, who was watching him with one dark eye over her shoulder, ears still half back, not yet sure about him.

“Ma’am,” he said, “a horse can’t sign his name and he can’t swear on the Book. But he can’t lie, either. Not about who he loves, and not about how old he is. A bill of sale can lie about both.”

He nodded toward the boardwalk, where Alvah Bixby was coming down the steps.

“He’s already told this street the first thing. I believe he’s about to tell it the second.”

—

## What a horse’s teeth can tell a whole town

Alvah Bixby came down off his boardwalk.

He came slowly, smiling, with his gold watch chain and his bill of sale, because he was not a man who lost his temper in front of people, and because he thought he still held the only card that mattered.

“Mister,” he said, “I don’t know who you are, and I won’t ask why you’ve fired a gun in the street of a peaceable town. But that animal belongs to me, and here’s the paper that says so, signed and witnessed. A horse can’t read, and neither, I expect, can you.”

He held out the bill of sale.

Beckwith took it and read it twice.

“One spotted stud horse,” Beckwith read aloud.

“Four years old. No brand. Forty dollars.”

He looked up.

“Is that the horse?”

“It is.”

“Four years old?”

“That’s what it says.”

Beckwith handed the paper back.

Then he turned to the spotted horse, who was standing with his head over Linnea’s shoulder, and he said, “Ma’am, would you hold his head for me?”

Linnea held his head.

Beckwith put his thumb in the corner of the horse’s mouth, gently, and the horse let him, because she was holding him, and Beckwith turned the lip back and showed the street the teeth.

“Any man here know horses?” he asked.

Most of them did.

A rancher from Wildhorse Creek came forward, and a farmer from Pilot Rock, and the blacksmith from Bixby’s own yard, wiping his hands on his apron.

They looked at the teeth for a long time.

“That’s no four-year-old,” the blacksmith said finally.

“The cups are long gone. Look at the angle on them. That’s an old horse. Ten, anyhow.”

“Eleven,” Linnea said, from the horse’s shoulder.

“He was born in April of seventy-three. The night McKay Creek took the footbridge out.”

“That’s so,” somebody said in the crowd.

“I remember that night. Rained like the end of the world.”

“I sat up with him in the barn,” Linnea said.

“I was fourteen.”

Beckwith let go of the horse’s lip.

“There’s your bill of sale, Mr. Bixby,” he said.

“It was written for a four-year-old horse by a man who’d never looked in his mouth. You paid forty dollars for him. You offered this lady four hundred for him in the spring. I believe you knew precisely what he was when you paid it.”

Bixby’s smile stayed where it was.

But his eyes had gone flat.

“That’s a question for the sheriff,” he said.

“And the sheriff isn’t here.”

“No,” Beckwith agreed.

“He’s about an hour behind me.”

—

## The man whose name was on the bill of sale

Sheriff Lafayette Purvis rode into Pendleton at ten minutes to four, from the south, from the Canyon City road.

He had two deputies with him, and between the two deputies rode a thin, yellow-bearded man on a mule with his hands chained to the saddle horn.

The man’s name was John D. Stidham.

He was thirty-eight years old, and for three years he had been the head of a horse-stealing ring that worked from the Columbia River to the Owyhee country, and on the eighth of September he had been arrested in a cabin on the headwaters of the John Day River with fourteen stolen horses in his corral and a pocket ledger in his coat.

He had been arrested by Thurlow Beckwith, who had been following him since July for the horse breeders of the Grande Ronde Valley, and who had ridden ahead of the sheriff’s party that morning because, he said afterward, he had a bad feeling about a spotted horse.

Purvis got down in front of Bixby’s freight yard and looked at the wagon and the loading pole and the cut lariat lying in the dust.

He looked at Linnea, sitting on Philippa Rennick’s front step with a wet cloth on the back of her neck and the spotted horse standing over her like a dog.

He listened to the whole of it, from four or five people at once.

Then he took a small greasy book out of his own coat.

“This was in Stidham’s pocket,” he said.

“He kept accounts. Most of them don’t.”

He opened it and read aloud, in the flat voice of a man reading a grocery list.

“July the twenty-ninth. Wildhorse Creek. Seven head, Vantine place. One spotted stud, the one A. B. asked for particular. Delivered A. B. at Pendleton, ten September, after the brand’s healed. Two hundred eighty dollars, cash. Bill of sale to show, forty.”

He closed the book.

“A. B.,” he said, and looked at Alvah Bixby.

Bixby said that anybody could write initials in a book.

Stidham, on his mule, laughed out loud for the first time since the John Day.

He said he had been stealing horses for three years and selling them to respectable men for three years, and he was not going to the penitentiary alone, and he said a great many other things, very loudly, in front of most of Pendleton.

The other six horses were found two weeks later on a ranch outside Canyon City, which Bixby leased in his brother-in-law’s name.

It was Jace Dunning who said the last thing anybody remembered from that afternoon.

He had been standing by the wagon the whole time with the whip still in his hand, forgotten, staring at the old man in the poncho.

And when the sheriff came to take the whip away from him, he gave it up without a word, and then said, to nobody in particular, “Owyhee. Eighty-one. The Jordan Valley gang.”

Everybody looked at him.

“Somebody took the whole Jordan Valley gang alone,” Dunning said slowly.

“Five of them. Walked them into Silver City at the end of a rope like a string of mules. Wouldn’t give his name to the newspaper. The miners called him the nameless gunslinger.”

He looked at Beckwith.

“That was you.”

Beckwith did not answer.

He was watching Linnea Vantine get up off Philippa Rennick’s step, slowly, with one hand on the spotted horse’s shoulder, and walk out into the middle of Main Street to the wagon where she had been hanging three hours before.

She looked up at the loading pole for a long time.

Then she turned to Alvah Bixby, who was standing between two deputies with his watch chain glinting.

“You wanted to know where the other six went,” she said.

“Now you know.”

—

## What became of the horse that would not pull

Alvah Bixby was tried in Pendleton in November of 1884 for receiving stolen property.

Stidham’s ledger was read into evidence, and so was the bill of sale, and three horsemen testified about the teeth.

Bixby got three years in the state penitentiary at Salem.

His freight outfit was sold to pay his lawyers.

John D. Stidham got eight years.

Jace Dunning got one year for his part in the hanging, and Linnea testified for his sentence to be light, because, she said, he had tied the knots well and they had not cut.

Billy Gannon was not charged.

He went to work for the Vantine place that winter and stayed eleven years.

Thurlow Beckwith stayed in Pendleton until the trial was over.

He was a quiet boarder at Philippa Rennick’s house, and he paid in advance, and he spent most of his afternoons out at the Vantine place on Wildhorse Creek, leaning on the corral fence, watching Linnea work the horses.

She asked him once why he had ridden ahead of the sheriff that morning.

“Stidham’s book said A. B. asked for a spotted stud particular,” he said.

“A man doesn’t ask for a horse particular unless he’s wanted him a long time. And a man who’s wanted a horse a long time usually knows who loves it.”

He shrugged.

“I thought somebody might get hurt.”

After the trial he rode back to the Grande Ronde.

He came back to Wildhorse Creek in the spring to buy a horse.

He came back in the summer to buy another one.

Philippa Rennick said she had never known a man buy so many horses he did not need.

Linnea Vantine bred spotted horses on Wildhorse Creek for the next forty years.

Most of the spotted horses in that end of Umatilla County for half a century traced back to Sixpence.

He lived to be twenty-nine.

He was ridden by one person his whole life.

And he never pulled a wagon.

Not once.

Not for anybody.

When she was an old woman, people used to ask Linnea Vantine about the day she was hung from Bixby’s wagon, and she always told it the same way.

She did not talk much about the rope, or the crowd, or the old man in the poncho.

She talked about the moment she opened her eyes, upside down, and saw a white face freckled with black spots an inch from her own, breathing on her hair.

“Everybody in that street had made up their minds about me,” she said.

“Sixty people. And the only one who knew the truth couldn’t say a word.”

She would smile then.

“He didn’t need to. He just wouldn’t pull.”

—

## What is real in this story, and what is told

The people in this story are invented.

There was no Linnea or Lucas Vantine, no Sixpence, no Alvah Bixby, no Thurlow Beckwith, no John D. Stidham, and no hanging from a freight wagon on Main Street, and the night of the McKay Creek flood, the ledger, and the Jordan Valley gang belong to the story.

The setting is real.

Pendleton became the county seat of Umatilla County in the 1860s and grew into a wheat and freighting town, and the railroad reached it in the early 1880s.

The Umatilla Indian Reservation, home of the Cayuse, Umatilla, and Walla Walla peoples, lies just east of the town.

The Cayuse were renowned horse breeders, so much so that “cayuse” became a common Western word for a hardy horse, and spotted horses of the type later called Appaloosa were bred by the Nez Perce and other peoples of the Columbia Plateau.

Horse theft was a serious and widespread problem in eastern Oregon and Idaho in the 1870s and 1880s, and organized rings did move stolen horses across the Blue Mountains with altered brands and forged bills of sale.

Reading a horse’s age from the shape and wear of its teeth is an old and real horseman’s skill, though after the early teens it becomes an estimate rather than a certainty.

The Oregon State Penitentiary was at Salem.

Canyon City was the seat of Grant County.

Everything else that happened on Main Street that Thursday afternoon is told, not recorded.

You Might Also Enjoy