News

Carlos Santana and “Supernatural”: 28 Years Without a Top 10 Hit, the Record Man Who Signed Him Twice and the Night He Won 8 Grammys at 52

On the night of Wednesday, February 23, 2000, the Grammy Awards were held for the first time at the Staples Center in Los Angeles.

Rosie O’Donnell was the host, CBS carried the show, and the room was full of the biggest names of the late 1990s: Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, the Backstreet Boys, TLC, Ricky Martin, Whitney Houston.

The man who kept getting up from his seat that night was none of them.

He was a 52-year-old guitarist from Autlán, Mexico, in a hat, who had first become famous on a farm in upstate New York three decades earlier.

Carlos Santana had come into the evening with ten nominations.

By the end of it he had won eight Grammy Awards, tying the record Michael Jackson had set in 1984 for the most won by one artist in a single night.

The last of them, Album of the Year, was handed to him by Bob Dylan and Lauryn Hill.

The album was called “Supernatural.”

It had been released eight months earlier, by a man who had not had a single in the American Top 10 since the winter of 1970–71.

Twenty-eight years separated those two hits.

What happened in between, and how one record executive bet on him twice, thirty years apart, is one of the strangest comeback stories in the history of popular music.

—

## The Afternoon That Started It

The first chapter of the story is well known, and it can be told quickly.

On Saturday afternoon, August 16, 1969, an unknown San Francisco band called Santana walked onto the stage at the Woodstock festival in Bethel, New York, with no album in the shops and a 22-year-old guitarist most of the crowd had never heard of.

Their set, and above all the long instrumental “Soul Sacrifice,” became one of the most famous sequences in the “Woodstock” film.

Within two years Santana had two number-one albums, “Abraxas” and “Santana III,” and a run of singles on American radio.

The biggest of those singles was “Black Magic Woman,” the Peter Green song the band had made its own.

It reached number four on the Billboard Hot 100 in the winter of 1970–71.

Nobody could have known it at the time, but that would be Carlos Santana’s last Top 10 single for twenty-eight years.

—

## The Long Middle

The reason was not that he stopped working.

He never stopped working.

In the early 1970s, his music moved away from the radio-friendly Latin rock that had made his name.

Albums such as “Caravanserai” leaned toward jazz, long instrumentals and spiritual themes.

From 1973 he and his wife, Deborah, were followers of the Indian spiritual teacher Sri Chinmoy, who gave him the name Devadip.

They ended that relationship in 1982.

Through the late 1970s and early 1980s, Santana still toured the world and still sold albums.

There were even a couple of hits.

“Winning” and “Hold On” both reached the Top 20 in the early 1980s.

But the band’s name no longer moved radio the way it had in 1970, and through the rest of the decade the singles faded lower and lower on the charts.

His first Grammy Award came only at the 1988 ceremony, for an instrumental called “Blues for Salvador.”

It was a prize for guitar playing, not for a hit.

In 1990, after more than twenty years with Columbia Records, Carlos Santana left the label and signed with PolyGram.

The years that followed were among the hardest of his career.

In October 1991, Bill Graham, the concert promoter who had managed the band in its early years and helped put it on the bill at Woodstock, was killed in a helicopter crash in Northern California.

Santana’s next studio album, “Milagro,” came out in 1992.

A live album, “Sacred Fire,” followed in 1993, and a record with his brother Jorge and his nephew Carlos Hernandez, “Santana Brothers,” the year after.

None of them sold well.

By the middle of the decade, Carlos Santana had a famous name, a loyal concert audience and no presence at all on the radio stations that decided what was a hit.

In October 1996, he met Island Records founder Chris Blackwell and asked to be released from his contract.

Blackwell let him go without demanding compensation.

For a time, Carlos Santana, who had sold millions of albums, had no record deal.

—

## Honored for the Past

The odd thing about those years is how much praise came with them.

In 1997, Carlos Santana received a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.

In January 1998, Santana was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, along with the classic early lineup of the band.

Those are honors for what an artist has already done.

They say very little about whether anyone wants the next record.

And at that point the business had a clear idea of what an artist like Carlos Santana was supposed to be: a 1960s act who toured the old songs for people who had been young when they were new.

He did not want to be that.

In an interview with Rolling Stone in 2000, he said he had not been “at all into becoming a twilight-zone jukebox prisoner of the ’60s.”

The question was who in the music business would give a man of nearly fifty a chance to prove it.

—

## The Man Who Signed Him in 1969

The answer was the same man who had signed him the first time.

In 1969, Clive Davis was the president of Columbia Records.

He had signed Janis Joplin after seeing her at the Monterey Pop Festival, and he signed Santana in the same era of San Francisco bands.

Davis left Columbia in 1973.

He went on to found Arista Records, where over the next two decades he worked with artists such as Barry Manilow, Aretha Franklin and Whitney Houston.

He was known for something many older executives had stopped doing: picking the songs.

By several accounts, it was Deborah Santana who encouraged her husband to go back to the man who had first believed in him.

In July 1997, Clive Davis went to see Santana play at Radio City Music Hall in New York.

He wanted to know whether the band could still connect with an audience.

He left convinced, and he offered Santana a deal with Arista.

Twenty years later, Carlos Santana described what Davis had to do inside his own company.

In a 2020 interview with Rolling Stone, he said Davis had to convince the people paying for the record to invest in, as he put it:

“this Mexican who hadn’t had a radio song since 1972”

The offer came with a condition.

Davis wanted a real say in the songs.

Many artists of Santana’s generation would have refused.

Santana agreed.

He told Billboard in June 1999 that he had wanted Davis to see that he “wasn’t stuck in the ’60s; I was adaptable to these times.”

There was also, as Santana has never hidden, a spiritual side to the decision.

In interviews around the album’s success, he said that during meditation he had received a message that his music would soon be back on the radio, and he attributed it to an angel he called Metatron.

He has always spoken about it as his own belief, and he has never asked anyone else to share it.

—

## The Blueprint

The plan Davis proposed was simple to describe and hard to pull off.

Half of the album would be what he called “vintage Santana”: the Latin rhythms, percussion and long, singing guitar lines of the band’s classic sound, in the spirit of “Oye Como Va.”

The other half would be collaborations with younger artists who were on the radio at that moment, with Santana’s guitar at the center of every track.

Davis was not modest about his role.

He told Rolling Stone in 2000:

“I blueprinted the architectural plan for the album.”

His goal was ambitious.

He wanted the new record to outsell “Abraxas,” which by then had sold more than four million copies in the United States.

Recording began in 1997 and continued into 1999, mostly at Fantasy Studios in Berkeley, California, and at the Hit Factory in New York.

For much of that time the album had a working title, “Mumbo Jumbo.”

It was renamed shortly before release.

The guest list grew track by track.

Lauryn Hill, who had just become one of the biggest stars in music, wrote and produced “Do You Like the Way,” with CeeLo Green also on vocals.

Dave Matthews and his drummer Carter Beauford appeared on “Love of My Life,” a song built on a melody from the third movement of Johannes Brahms’s Symphony No. 3.

Everlast sang on “Put Your Lights On.”

Eagle-Eye Cherry sang on “Wishing It Was.”

The Mexican rock band Maná joined him on “Corazón Espinado,” sung in Spanish.

And Eric Clapton, an old friend, played on the closing instrumental, “The Calling.”

Santana insisted the guest list had not been the starting point.

In a June 1999 interview, he said:

“the songs really dictated different singers and different musicians.”

Two of those songs would change everything.

—

## A Song Called “Room 17”

The first began with a New York songwriter and keyboard player named Itaal Shur.

Shur had written a track called “Room 17.”

According to later accounts, the music was well liked, but the lyrics were considered too suggestive for the project.

So the track was passed to Rob Thomas, the singer and songwriter of Matchbox 20, whose debut album “Yourself or Someone Like You” had been one of the biggest-selling rock records of the late 1990s.

Thomas was still in his twenties.

He and Shur lived about two blocks apart in New York.

Thomas wrote new verses and a new melody, the two of them reworked the chorus together, and the song was renamed “Smooth.”

He did not expect to sing it.

Thomas has said that he wrote it with George Michael in mind as the vocalist, and recorded a demo only so that Santana could hear the song.

It was Clive Davis and the producer Matt Serletic, who had produced Matchbox 20’s debut, who suggested that Thomas should simply sing it himself.

Santana was not convinced at first.

Looking back on the session two decades later, Serletic said:

“Rob was just a demo singer to him.”

That changed when they recorded it.

By Serletic’s account, the second take of the band’s performance became the master.

The finished track is a little under five minutes long: a Latin rhythm section, horns, a vocal about summer heat and desire, and Carlos Santana’s guitar answering every line and taking over the end.

It sounded like nothing else on American radio in 1999.

—

## Release Day

Clive Davis launched the album with a party at the Boathouse restaurant in New York on June 1, 1999.

“Supernatural” was released by Arista on June 15, 1999.

Carlos Santana was 51.

Arista had planned to ship 125,000 copies at first, then raised the number twice before release.

The album entered the Billboard 200 at number 19.

That was a respectable start for an artist in his position, but not a sign of what was coming.

For the next few months, the record grew the way records rarely do anymore: one radio station at a time.

“Smooth” went to radio the same day the album came out.

All summer and into the fall, it climbed.

In the week of October 23, 1999, it reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100.

It was the first number-one single of Carlos Santana’s career.

It arrived thirty years after his first appearance on the Hot 100, with “Jingo,” in 1969.

And it stayed there.

“Smooth” held the top spot for twelve consecutive weeks, through the end of 1999 and into January 2000.

It was the last number one of the 1990s and the first of the 2000s.

It spent 30 weeks in the Top 10, a record at the time, and 58 weeks on the chart.

In 2008, when Billboard ranked the biggest songs in the first fifty years of the Hot 100, “Smooth” came second, behind only Chubby Checker’s “The Twist.”

—

## The Album Catches Up

The album followed the single to the top.

In October 1999, four months after release, “Supernatural” reached number one on the Billboard 200.

It was Carlos Santana’s first number-one album since “Santana III” in 1971.

It was not a one-week visit.

The album returned to number one again and again, spending twelve weeks at the top in total.

In the last week of 1999 alone, during the holiday shopping season, it sold 527,000 copies in the United States.

The record Clive Davis had hoped to beat, “Abraxas,” was left far behind.

“Supernatural” was eventually certified 15 times platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America, and its worldwide sales are usually estimated at around 30 million copies.

It also reached number one in Australia and the United Kingdom, among other countries.

By any measure, it was the biggest album of Carlos Santana’s life, released three decades after he had first become famous.

—

## “Maria Maria”

Then there was the second single.

“Maria Maria” was produced by Wyclef Jean and his longtime partner Jerry “Wonda” Duplessis, who had come out of the Fugees camp.

The lead vocals were by The Product G&B, a duo made up of Marvin Moore and David McRae.

The song mixed hip-hop production, including a drum pattern sampled from the Headhunters’ 1975 track “God Make Me Funky,” with Spanish guitar and Santana’s soaring lead lines.

It went to urban radio in September 1999 and was released as a single in the United States in January 2000.

In April 2000 it reached number one on the Hot 100 and stayed there for ten weeks.

Between them, two singles from the same album had spent twenty-two weeks at the top of the American chart.

“Maria Maria” also topped the charts in Germany, France, Canada and several other countries, and it had a long afterlife.

In 2017, DJ Khaled built “Wild Thoughts,” with Rihanna and Bryson Tiller, around a sample of it.

—

## February 23, 2000

All of that led to the Staples Center.

Carlos Santana had ten nominations.

Before that night, he had won exactly one Grammy in his entire career.

The wins came one after another through the evening.

Best Rock Instrumental Performance, for “The Calling,” with Eric Clapton.

Best Rock Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal, for “Put Your Lights On,” with Everlast.

Best Pop Instrumental Performance, for “El Farol.”

Best Pop Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocal, for “Maria Maria.”

Best Pop Collaboration with Vocals, for “Smooth,” with Rob Thomas.

Best Rock Album, for “Supernatural.”

Record of the Year, for “Smooth.”

Album of the Year, for “Supernatural.”

The only category he lost was Best Instrumental Composition.

His dominance was so complete that it became part of the show.

When Sheryl Crow accepted her own award that night for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance, she thanked Carlos Santana “for not being in this category.”

Santana and Rob Thomas performed “Smooth” on the broadcast.

Twenty years later, Santana described the strange rhythm of the evening to Rolling Stone.

He said he had kept going up and down from the stage so often that he joked to the people around him:

“I feel like a doggy retrieving a frisbee”

He said that at one point everything around him seemed to slow down, and that among the faces he picked out in the audience were Harry Belafonte and Clive Davis.

At one point that night, by his own later account, he dedicated the moment to two musicians he had always treated as his teachers:

“I want to dedicate this to John Coltrane and John Lee Hooker.”

The final award of the night was Album of the Year.

It was presented by Bob Dylan and Lauryn Hill.

Hill was one of the album’s guests.

Dylan was one of the few artists in the building whose career went back even further than Santana’s.

As Santana later told the story, Dylan spoke to him personally that night and said:

“You’re one of the few who are carrying on the principles.”

Santana’s reaction, as he remembered it:

“Oh, my God. I’m being knighted by Bob Dylan!”

Clive Davis, who was credited among the album’s producers, shared in the Album of the Year award.

Backstage, Santana told reporters that the night proved something he had believed for a long time: that “deepness and class can be as profitable as shallowness and crass.”

He also said he could not sleep afterward.

—

## Eight or Nine?

The numbers from that night are often quoted in two different ways, and both are right.

Carlos Santana personally won eight Grammy Awards on February 23, 2000.

That tied the record set by Michael Jackson, who won eight on February 28, 1984, at the height of “Thriller.”

But “Supernatural” and its songs collected nine Grammys that night.

The ninth was Song of the Year, for “Smooth.”

Song of the Year is a songwriting award.

It goes to the people who wrote the song, not to the artist who recorded it.

“Smooth” was written by Itaal Shur and Rob Thomas, so the trophy went to them.

That is why some sources say “Supernatural” won nine Grammys, while Santana himself is credited with eight.

Rob Thomas went home with three: Song of the Year, Record of the Year and Best Pop Collaboration with Vocals.

Shur later remembered how quickly the spotlight moved on that evening.

Jennifer Lopez, a presenter that night, wore the green Versace dress that dominated the next day’s coverage, and in the press room, he said, nobody could compete with her.

“Even with the Song of the Year award, you can’t follow Jennifer Lopez!”

For Carlos Santana, there was more to come.

On September 13, 2000, at the first Latin Grammy Awards, held in the same building, he won three more, including Record of the Year for “Corazón Espinado,” his song with Maná.

—

## What the Critics Said

Not everyone loved the record.

Some longtime fans felt the guest tracks pulled the album away from Santana’s own sound.

One prominent review complained that there hardly seemed to be a track without a guest star.

Another critic argued that Santana’s old fans were precisely the audience the album had not been designed for.

That was, in a sense, the point.

Clive Davis had not set out to make a record for people who already owned “Abraxas.”

He had set out to put Carlos Santana’s guitar in front of listeners who had been born long after Woodstock.

It worked.

Millions of listeners who had never heard “Black Magic Woman” bought “Supernatural” for “Smooth” and “Maria Maria,” and heard Carlos Santana’s guitar for the first time.

—

## Thirty Years Between the Peaks

It is worth stepping back to see how unusual the story is.

Rock history is full of artists who had their biggest success early and spent the rest of their careers living up to it.

It has very few who had their biggest success thirty years after they started.

In 1969, Carlos Santana was a 22-year-old unknown at Woodstock.

In 1970 and 1971, he had number-one albums and Top 10 singles.

From early 1971 until the summer of 1999, he did not have a single in the Top 10, even while he kept recording, touring and winning the respect of other musicians.

At 49, he had no record deal.

At 52, he had the biggest-selling album of his career, two number-one singles and a share of one of the most famous records in Grammy history.

The partnership behind it was just as unusual.

The same executive had signed him at the start of his career and at its turning point, thirty years apart.

Later in 2000, after a widely reported dispute with Arista’s parent company, BMG, Clive Davis left the label he had founded and started a new one, J Records.

—

## After “Supernatural”

Carlos Santana never went back to being an artist the radio ignored.

His next album, “Shaman,” released in 2002, followed the same approach, and its single “The Game of Love,” sung by Michelle Branch, won another Grammy.

He continued to record with younger artists for years.

In December 2013, he received the Kennedy Center Honors in Washington.

His memoir, “The Universal Tone,” was published in 2014.

In 2016, he reunited with several members of the early band for the album “Santana IV.”

In 2025, “Supernatural” was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.

Carlos Santana turned 79 in July 2026, and he is still on the road.

In August 2025, he played to a packed festival crowd in Jerez de la Frontera, Spain.

Asked by Rolling Stone, twenty years after the Grammy night, how he saw himself, he did not talk about records or trophies:

“I still see myself as the dishwasher who came from Tijuana who made a commitment”

He had washed dishes in San Francisco as a teenager, before anyone outside the city’s clubs knew his name.

—

## The Comeback Nobody Planned For

When people talk about “Supernatural” today, they usually start with “Smooth,” the song that seemed to play everywhere for a year.

But the more remarkable story is what came before it.

A guitarist who had been famous since 1969 spent almost three decades without a Top 10 hit.

He changed labels, lost his mentor, sold fewer records each time and, for a while, had no contract at all.

The industry honored his past with stars and Hall of Fame inductions while showing little interest in his future.

Then a record executive he had first met as a young man came to a concert in New York, liked what he heard, and drew up a plan.

Carlos Santana accepted the plan, kept his guitar at the center of it and, at 52, kept walking back to the stage at the Staples Center until the last envelope of the night had his name in it.

The last time, Bob Dylan was waiting for him.

You Might Also Enjoy