News

1603: The Strange Truth About Elizabeth I’s Death

The bed was made.

It had been made every night for days, the sheets turned down, the pillows plumped, the curtains drawn back so that the queen could see it was ready for her.

She would not look at it.

It was March 1603, at Richmond Palace, on the river west of London, and the Queen of England was sitting on the floor.

Not on a throne, not on a chair of state, not even on a stool.

On cushions.

Her women had piled them on the rushes of her private chamber, and she had lowered herself onto them, and there she stayed.

The fire was kept high, because she felt the cold.

The candles burned down and were replaced.

Somewhere beyond the door, men in black velvet stood whispering in the outer rooms, and every so often one of them would put his head in, look, and go away again.

She was sixty-nine years old.

She had ruled England for more than forty-four years.

She had outlived her father, her brother, her sister, almost every man who had ever courted her, and most of the friends she had grown old with.

Now she would not eat.

She would not take the medicines her physicians brought.

She would not let them examine her.

And she would not, under any persuasion, go to bed.

A small, stooped man came to the door and stood there, looking at her.

His name was Robert Cecil, and he was the most powerful minister in the kingdom.

He was also the one man in that palace who knew exactly what was at stake if the woman on the cushions died without saying one particular name.

He was not sure she was going to say it.

—

Picture the problem from where Cecil stood.

Elizabeth Tudor had no husband, no child, no brother, no sister, and no named heir.

For forty-four years she had refused to say who would wear the crown after her.

Now she was dying on the floor of her own bedchamber, and she would not even lie down.

Why?

What was she afraid of?

What did she finally say, and to whom?

And was the famous gesture she is supposed to have made in her last hours, the one that put a Scottish king on the English throne, really hers at all?

There is an answer to that last question, or at least the outline of one.

It involves a ring that had to be cut from her finger, a ring of a different kind carried four hundred miles through the night, and a group of exhausted men in a dark room who all, by a remarkable coincidence, saw exactly what they needed to see.

—

## Why the queen’s ring had to come off

The first sign was a ring.

At her coronation in January 1559, when she was twenty-five, Elizabeth had been given a ring as part of the ceremony, the ring that symbolized a monarch’s union with the realm.

She had made a great deal of that ring over the years.

When Parliament begged her to marry, she is said to have pointed to it and told them she was already married, to England, and that every one of them was her child.

Whether she said it in exactly those words or not, it was the kind of thing she said.

It fit her.

She wore that ring, by tradition, for the rest of her life.

Forty-four years is a long time to wear anything.

According to the historian William Camden, who knew the court and wrote its history within a generation, the ring in her last illness had grown so deeply into the flesh of her finger that it could not be drawn off.

It had to be filed away.

Camden saw an omen in it, and so, it seems, did the people around her.

The marriage between the queen and her kingdom, the one she had boasted of before Parliament, had been cut through with a file.

Camden does not say that the queen wept when it was done.

He does not need to.

Exactly when it happened is not clear.

Some accounts put it in the early weeks of 1603, others closer to the end; Camden himself places it as a sign that came before her final decline.

What matters is what people believed it meant.

At Richmond that winter, a ring that had held for forty-four years had finally given way.

And the woman who had worn it was beginning, very slowly, to give way too.

—

## The warm palace that could not keep her warm

Richmond was her favorite winter house.

Her grandfather, Henry VII, had built it on the site of an older royal manor that had burned, and he had built it to impress: towers capped with onion domes, galleries hung with tapestries, gardens stepping down toward the Thames.

Elizabeth called it, by one tradition, her “warm box.”

The rooms were smaller than at Whitehall and easier to heat.

The court moved there in late January 1603, in bitter weather, and the queen is said to have made the journey despite a cold, against the advice of those around her.

She had always despised being told she was unwell.

For years she had refused to admit to illness in public.

When her teeth troubled her, she had endured it.

When her eyesight began to fail, she had held letters at arm’s length rather than wear spectacles in front of ambassadors.

She was famous for her energy: hunting into her sixties, dancing for foreign visitors so that they could report home that the old queen was still vigorous.

That was deliberate.

A queen without an heir could not afford to look mortal.

Every rumor of weakness was a signal to every faction in England, and in Scotland, and in Spain, that the time to start moving pieces had arrived.

So she painted her face white, wore her red wigs, and kept up the performance.

By the winter of 1603, the performance was costing her more than it used to.

The people who loved her had been dying for years.

Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester, the man she had loved more than any other, had died in 1588.

Francis Walsingham, her spymaster, in 1590.

William Cecil, Lord Burghley, Robert’s father, her chief minister for forty years, in 1598.

And Robert Devereux, Earl of Essex, the young favorite who had tried to raise London against her in 1601, had gone to the block at the Tower on her own warrant.

She had signed it.

People who saw her afterward said she was never quite the same.

In February 1603, at Richmond, she lost one more.

—

## The friend whose death broke something

Katherine Howard, Countess of Nottingham, had served the queen for more than forty years.

She was the queen’s cousin, one of the many children of Henry Carey, Lord Hunsdon, the son of Anne Boleyn’s sister Mary.

That made Katherine family in the only way Elizabeth had family left: through her mother’s side, the Boleyn side, the side that had been through the fire with her.

Katherine was married to Charles Howard, Earl of Nottingham, the Lord Admiral of England, the man who had commanded the English fleet against the Spanish Armada in 1588.

She was one of the queen’s closest women, a fixture of the Privy Chamber, there in the mornings and there at night.

She died in late February 1603.

The queen’s grief, by every account, was out of all proportion to what anyone expected.

She withdrew.

She stopped appearing.

She sat for long periods without speaking.

It is here that the most famous legend of Elizabeth’s death begins, and it is worth telling, as long as it is understood as a legend.

The story goes that years earlier, the Earl of Essex had been given a ring by the queen, with a promise that if he were ever in danger, he could send it back to her and she would forgive him.

When he was condemned in 1601, he tried to send it.

According to the legend, the ring went by mistake to the Countess of Nottingham, whose husband was no friend of Essex, and the countess kept it.

On her deathbed, the story says, the countess confessed, and the queen, seizing her by the shoulders, cried that God might forgive her, but she never could.

It is a wonderful story.

It is almost certainly not true.

It first appears in print decades after the events, it has the shape of a romance rather than a record, and no one who was actually in the room at Richmond in February 1603 ever wrote it down.

What is true is simpler and in its way sadder.

A woman who had been at the queen’s side since they were both young died, and the queen did not recover from it.

The man who did write down what happened next was Katherine’s brother.

—

## “No, Robin, I am not well”

Sir Robert Carey was in his early forties that winter, a younger son of Lord Hunsdon, a soldier and courtier who had spent much of his career on the wild border between England and Scotland as a warden of the marches.

He was also, by blood, the queen’s cousin.

He came south to court in March 1603, and he went straight to see her.

Years later, as an old man, he wrote a memoir, and the pages about those weeks at Richmond are among the most precious we have.

They are plain, unliterary, and very close to the bone.

He found her, he wrote, “in one of her withdrawing chambers, sitting low upon her cushions.”

She called him to her.

He kissed her hand and told her it was his chief happiness to see her in safety and in health.

She took his hand and held it hard.

“No, Robin, I am not well.”

Then she began to talk about her sadness, and as she talked, she sighed.

Carey counted.

She “fetched not so few as forty or fifty great sighs,” he wrote.

That number has stayed with readers for four hundred years, because of what Carey said next.

In all his life, he wrote, he had never known her to sigh like that except once, when the Queen of Scots was put to death in 1587.

Mary Stuart, the cousin Elizabeth had kept prisoner for nineteen years and finally sent to the block at Fotheringhay.

The mother of the man in Edinburgh who was waiting, as every Englishman with any sense understood, to inherit everything.

Carey did his best to cheer her.

He failed.

He had his own reasons for being at Richmond, and he did not hide them in his memoir.

He was a younger son with no great fortune, and he had already been in contact with the King of Scots.

If the queen died, he meant to be the first man to tell James.

He was not the only one making plans in that palace.

He was simply the only one honest enough to write it down later.

—

## The woman on the cushions

What happened next is the part people remember.

The queen would not go to bed.

Carey says that she “remained upon her cushions four days and nights at the least.”

Other reports, some written at the time and some years later, stretch it further, and the details shift from one to another.

But the core is the same in all of them.

She sat on the floor, propped on cushions, and refused to move.

She would not eat, or ate almost nothing.

She refused the medicines her physicians offered and would not let them touch her.

According to one account sent home by a foreign diplomat, she sat for long hours with her eyes fixed on the floor, hardly speaking.

The rooms were kept warm.

Her ladies moved around her quietly, on their knees when they came close.

Outside the privy chamber, the court held its breath.

Why would she not lie down?

People at the time had their own answers.

The simplest was that she was afraid.

One later story claims she believed that if she once lay down in that bed, she would never get up from it again.

That may be true, or it may be what people decided she must have felt.

But it does not take a mystic to understand.

For forty-four years, being seen upright had been part of the job.

A queen in bed was a queen who was dying.

A queen on her cushions was still, in some stubborn sense, receiving.

There were stranger stories.

Lady Elizabeth Southwell, who was a young maid of honour in the queen’s household that spring, wrote an account of those weeks several years later, after she had left England and become a Catholic.

In her version, a playing card, the queen of hearts, was found nailed beneath the seat of the queen’s chair, as if someone had worked a curse.

In her version, the queen told a lady she had seen herself, one night, looking thin and terrible in a light of fire.

Historians treat Southwell’s account with great caution.

She wrote it at a distance, with clear sympathies, and some of what she says cannot be squared with other witnesses.

But it shows what the court whispered, and the court whispered a great deal.

Then there is the line everyone quotes.

The story, told in later accounts, is that Robert Cecil came to her and told her that, to content the people, she must go to bed.

And the queen, from the floor, looked up at the little hunched man whom she had sometimes called her pygmy and said something like this:

“Little man, little man, the word must is not to be used to princes.”

Some versions add a sharper sting, that if his father had been alive, he would not have dared to say so much.

Did she say it?

It is not in Carey’s memoir.

It comes from later tellings, and it may have been polished in the retelling, as famous last words always are.

But it sounds like her.

It sounds like a woman who had spent her whole life being told what she must do by men who expected to outlive her, and who was not going to start obeying now.

Cecil did not argue.

He went away.

And the question he had come to ask her, the one that mattered more than the bed, was still unanswered.

—

## The name she would never say

Almost from the day she was crowned, Elizabeth had been begged to name her successor.

Parliament begged her.

Her council begged her.

Foreign ambassadors fished for it.

She refused every time.

She had been the heir herself, under her sister, and she knew exactly what an heir became: a magnet for every discontented man in the kingdom.

Early in her reign, she is said to have told a Scottish envoy that she would not have her winding-sheet held up before her eyes.

To name an heir was to start the countdown to her own funeral, in public, with everyone watching.

So the question was simply forbidden.

People who discussed it too openly ended up in trouble.

A member of Parliament who wrote a pamphlet urging her to settle the succession died in the Tower.

Everyone knew who the likely answer was.

James VI of Scotland, the son of Mary Queen of Scots, the great-great-grandson of Henry VII through Henry VIII’s sister Margaret.

He was Protestant.

He was a man, which most of the political class still preferred.

He had sons.

And he wanted it very badly.

What almost nobody knew was that Robert Cecil had been writing to him in secret for about two years.

After the fall of Essex, Cecil had opened a private channel to Edinburgh, carefully coded, to prepare the ground.

James was told to be patient, to stop pestering the old queen, to trust that when the moment came, it would be handled.

The moment was now.

And the queen, sitting on her cushions, had still never said his name.

If she died without a word, England would be legally leaderless.

There were other claimants, distant ones, and there were men in the kingdom who might prefer them.

A clean transfer of power needed something, anything, that could be presented to the country as the dying queen’s wish.

Cecil needed her to lie down, and he needed her to speak.

She would not do either.

So he sent for the one man she might still obey.

—

## The admiral who carried her to bed

Charles Howard, Earl of Nottingham, Lord Admiral of England, had not been at court for about two weeks.

His wife had just died.

He was mourning her at home.

The council sent for him anyway, and he came.

He was sixty-six, the old sea commander of 1588, and he was also, through his dead wife, part of the queen’s family.

If anyone had standing to tell her what to do, it was him.

Carey, who was there, records what happened in one short, extraordinary sentence.

The Lord Admiral was sent for, and “what by fair means, what by force, he got her to bed.”

Carey does not say more, and that silence is eloquent.

We do not know whether the admiral coaxed her, or argued, or simply lifted her.

We know only that the queen of England, who had refused for days to lie down, was finally put into her bed by an old man in mourning for his wife, her friend.

She did not get up again.

—

## The last night at Richmond

It was Wednesday, March 23, 1603.

The days before had blurred into one another: the cushions, the bed, the fire, the doctors sent away, the councillors at the door.

That Wednesday, she lost her voice.

“On Wednesday, the 23d of March, she grew speechless,” Carey wrote.

It is one of the simplest sentences in his memoir.

Elizabeth Tudor had spoken in Latin to the scholars of Oxford, in Italian to Venetian envoys, in French to her suitors, in English to her troops at Tilbury in the year of the Armada.

She had talked her way out of danger under her sister, talked down Parliaments, talked across the table at kings.

Now there was nothing.

She could hear.

She could see.

She could move her hands.

But she could not make a word.

That afternoon, according to Carey, she made signs for her council to come to her.

They came.

Picture the room as it must have been.

A great bed, hung with heavy curtains, in a chamber kept hot and close.

Candles, because March afternoons at Richmond darken early.

Her women at the edges of the room, some of them kneeling.

Lady Scrope, Philadelphia Carey, Robert’s sister and the dead countess’s sister, close at the bedside, because she understood the queen’s signs better than anyone.

And the councillors in their dark gowns, crowding in near the foot of the bed: Robert Cecil, the Lord Admiral, the Lord Keeper, others whose names the accounts give in different orders.

They had come to ask the question.

Not in so many words, perhaps, but the meaning would have been plain to everyone.

Who should rule after her?

Carey was not in the room for this moment.

He was waiting nearby and heard it from those who were.

His account is short.

It was by “putting her hand to her head, when the King of Scots was named to succeed her,” that they all knew he was the man she desired should reign after her.

A hand to the head.

Later versions dressed the gesture up.

In some tellings, she drew a circle above her brow, a crown in the air.

In others, the councillors named the King of France and she did nothing, then the King of Scots and she lifted her hand.

In others still, she managed a few words earlier in the week, asking who should succeed her but a king, and who should that be but her cousin of Scotland.

Each telling is a little more convenient than the last.

But the version that Carey heard, on the evening it happened, is the simplest.

A dying woman, unable to speak, raised her hand to her head.

Was it a crown?

Was it pain?

Was it a woman with a raging fever pushing her hair from her face?

Nobody in that room was going to ask.

The councillors had what they had come for.

As the light went outside, the queen made signs again, this time for her archbishop.

John Whitgift, Archbishop of Canterbury, was in his seventies, one of the oldest men at court, and one of the very few she had trusted for decades.

He came and knelt by her bed.

Carey, who was by then in the room himself, describes what followed in some of the most moving lines in his memoir.

The archbishop questioned her first about her faith.

She could not answer in words, so she answered with her eyes and her hand, lifting them at each question to show her assent.

Then he began to pray.

He prayed for a long time.

The old man’s knees grew weary on the floor.

He gave her his blessing and made to rise.

The queen made a sign with her hand.

Lady Scrope, who knew what it meant, told the archbishop that the queen wished him to go on praying.

He knelt again.

He prayed for another half hour, perhaps more.

Again he tried to rise.

Again the queen’s hand moved.

Again he stayed.

He prayed, Carey says, with such fervor and such earnest crying to God for her soul that the queen, to the sight of everyone there, seemed to take great comfort from it.

It went on late into the evening.

Imagine the sound of it: one old man’s voice in a hot room, going on and on, the words of the prayer book that Elizabeth’s own Parliament had restored in 1559, the women answering under their breath, the candles guttering.

Imagine the queen listening.

The woman who would not lie down was lying down now, and the one thing she still asked for, with the only power she had left, was that the voice should not stop.

At last it did.

The archbishop was allowed to go.

The councillors went out.

Most of the women withdrew, leaving only those whose turn it was to watch.

Robert Carey went to a room nearby, the cofferer’s chamber, and arranged that a man should come to him the moment there was news.

He did not take off his boots.

The queen fell asleep.

She did not wake.

Sometime in the small hours of Thursday, March 24, the women by the bed realized she had stopped breathing.

There was no cry, no struggle, no last speech.

A young law student named John Manningham, who heard the news that same morning from people close to the court, wrote in his diary that she died about three o’clock, “mildly like a lamb, easily like a ripe apple from the tree.”

Manningham had been talking with her chaplain, Dr. Henry Parry, in the days before, and it is often said that the phrase, or the comfort behind it, came from Parry.

Either way, it is the epitaph that has stuck.

The last Tudor monarch, the daughter of Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn, was dead.

She had reigned for forty-four years and four months.

She had never named an heir out loud.

And the man in the cofferer’s chamber was already pulling on his gloves.

—

## The gesture that solved everything

So what happened in that room on Wednesday afternoon?

Here is the uncomfortable answer.

We have only the word of the men who most needed it to have happened.

Carey was not present for the moment itself; he passed on what the councillors told him.

The councillors had spent months, and in Cecil’s case years, preparing for James.

They had every reason to see a hand raised to the head and call it a crown.

And there is no surviving record of the queen saying, in her own voice, in front of independent witnesses, that she wanted James to succeed her.

That does not mean it did not happen.

It is entirely possible that Elizabeth, knowing perfectly well that James was the only sensible choice, gave her council the sign they asked for.

She was a politician to the end.

She had spent four decades keeping England out of civil war, and she may have wanted that last act to keep it out of one more.

But it is equally possible that a dying, voiceless, feverish woman moved her hand, and that a roomful of exhausted men who had already decided what they would do saw in it what they wanted.

The answer to the question at the start of this story is not a single word.

It is that the most famous royal gesture of the age survives only in the accounts of the people who benefited from it.

And that may be the most Elizabethan thing about it.

She had never said the name.

They said it for her.

Within hours, they were proclaiming it from the gates of Whitehall.

But one man was not waiting for the proclamation.

—

## Four hundred miles and a blue ring

Robert Carey had made his arrangements long before.

He had a fast horse ready, and fresh ones planned along the Great North Road.

He also had a token.

By the story that has come down in his family, and in his own memoir, James had sent a ring to Carey’s sister, Lady Scrope, sometime before, with the understanding that when the queen died it would come back to him as proof.

In Carey’s account it is simply a blue ring from a fair lady.

Tradition makes it a sapphire, and tradition adds a dramatic touch: that Lady Scrope, unable to leave the queen’s rooms, dropped it from a window to her brother waiting below.

That window scene appears in later tellings and should be read as one.

What Carey himself tells is dramatic enough.

On the morning of March 24, the council at first tried to keep everyone at Richmond until the proclamation was ready, and the gates were shut.

Carey had to talk his way out.

Between nine and ten that morning, he was on the road.

He rode north all day and reached Doncaster that night.

The next day he rode on into Northumberland, to his own house at Widdrington.

On the third day, Saturday, March 26, he crossed into Scotland.

Somewhere along the way he had a heavy fall, and his horse struck him on the head with a hoof, “a great blow on the head,” as he put it, which bled badly and forced him to ride the last stretch at a slower pace.

It was late at night when he reached Holyrood Palace in Edinburgh.

The king had already gone to bed.

Carey, filthy, bloodied, barely able to stand, was brought to James’s chamber.

He knelt and saluted him as King of England, Scotland, France, and Ireland.

James asked what letters he brought from the council.

Carey had none.

The council had not sent him.

He had come on his own.

What he had instead was the blue ring.

James looked at it.

“It is enough,” he said, according to Carey.

“I know by this you are a true messenger.”

The king of a poor northern kingdom had just become the ruler of three.

He had learned it from a bruised courtier in the middle of the night, well before any official messenger from the council arrived.

James promised Carey that he would be a good master and would reward him.

Carey, who wrote his memoir knowing how long that reward took to arrive, recorded the promise with a certain dryness.

Back in England, the queen lay in her bed at Richmond, and the strangest part of her story was about to begin.

—

## What one maid of honour claimed she heard

Elizabeth, by one account, had made a last wish about her body.

She did not want it opened.

Royal bodies were normally embalmed, which meant the physicians and surgeons would need to handle and open them.

Elizabeth Southwell later wrote that the queen had expressly forbidden it, and that Cecil quietly overrode her.

Other accounts say her wish was honored.

The truth is not clear, and Southwell, again, had reasons to make Cecil look bad.

The body was taken down the river by night, in a barge lit with torches, from Richmond to Whitehall, where it lay in state for weeks.

Ladies took turns to watch over it through the nights, as custom required.

It is from one of those nights that Southwell’s most notorious story comes.

She claimed that while she and others were keeping watch, the coffin gave a sudden loud crack, splitting the wood and the lead.

Historians regard the tale as highly doubtful, a piece of gossip that sounds more like a judgment from heaven than a record of anything observed.

It is told here only because it was told then, and because it shows how quickly the old queen, even dead, became a story.

The real ceremony was still to come.

—

## The day London wept

On April 28, 1603, Elizabeth I was carried to Westminster Abbey.

The funeral was enormous.

By most accounts more than a thousand mourners walked in procession, dressed in black, from the poor women of the household to the great officers of state.

The coffin was covered in purple velvet and drawn by four horses hung with black.

And on top of it, in full royal robes, crown on its head and scepter in its hand, lay a life-size painted figure of the queen.

It was a funeral effigy, carved and painted to look like her, the custom for English monarchs.

For the first time in weeks, the people of London saw their queen.

She was lying down.

The chronicler John Stow, who was there, described the reaction of the crowd as the effigy passed.

There was, he wrote, “such a general sighing, groaning and weeping as the like hath not been seen or known in the memory of man.”

People climbed onto roofs, onto gutters, into windows, to see her.

Some of them had never known any other ruler.

A woman of fifty that day had been five years old when Elizabeth was crowned.

James did not come.

He was still in Scotland, beginning his slow, celebratory journey south, and it was not thought fitting for the new king to attend.

The queen was laid in the vault of her grandfather, Henry VII, beneath his tomb in the chapel he had built.

That was not to be her final place.

—

## Partners in throne and grave

Three years later, in 1606, King James moved her.

He had ordered a grand white marble monument for her, carved by the sculptor Maximilian Colt, with her effigy lying on top under a canopy, crowned, holding orb and scepter.

He placed it in the north aisle of Henry VII’s Chapel.

And underneath it, he had her coffin set in a vault on top of another coffin.

It belonged to her half sister, Mary I, the queen whose reign had nearly ended Elizabeth’s life before it began, the sister who had once sent her to the Tower.

The two women, who had spent their lives on opposite sides of every question that mattered, would share one grave.

On the base of the monument, James had a Latin line carved.

The Abbey translates it this way:

“Partners in throne and grave, here we sleep Elizabeth and Mary, sisters, in hope of the Resurrection.”

It is a beautiful sentence, and a political one.

James was descended from neither of them.

By honoring both, he presented himself as the heir to the whole Tudor line, Catholic and Protestant alike.

He also, a few years later, built a far grander tomb nearby for his own mother, Mary Queen of Scots, whose death had made Elizabeth sigh in 1587.

Visitors to the Abbey today can stand at both.

Elizabeth’s marble figure lies there still, on her back, hands folded around the symbols of her power.

—

## What became of the people in that room

Robert Cecil kept his power under the new king.

James made him Earl of Salisbury in 1605, and he remained the king’s chief minister until his death in 1612, still small, still stooped, still working.

He was the man who had made the transfer of power in 1603 look effortless, and that was exactly what he had intended.

Robert Carey waited a long time for his reward.

He was given posts in the household of James’s younger son, Prince Charles, and much later, in 1626, he was made Earl of Monmouth.

He wrote his memoir in old age and died in 1639, the last voice of that night at Richmond.

His sister, Philadelphia, Lady Scrope, the woman who had read the queen’s signs at her deathbed, lived on for many years, out of the spotlight.

John Whitgift, the archbishop who prayed until his knees gave out, crowned James at Westminster in July 1603 and died early the following year.

Charles Howard, Earl of Nottingham, the admiral who put the queen to bed, did not stay in mourning long.

Later in 1603 he married a young Scottish noblewoman connected to the new king’s court, and he lived into his eighties, dying in 1624.

Dr. Henry Parry, the chaplain, rose in the church and became a bishop under James.

Elizabeth Southwell left England in 1605 in a scandalous elopement with Sir Robert Dudley, the son of the Earl of Leicester, and lived the rest of her life in Italy.

Her account of the queen’s death, written there, became one of the most controversial sources on the subject.

James VI of Scotland, James I of England, reigned over both kingdoms until 1625.

The union of the two crowns that began with a dying woman’s hand, or with what a roomful of men said about it, became in time the foundation of Great Britain.

As for Richmond Palace, little is left.

After the English Civil War, it was sold off and mostly pulled down for its materials.

The gatehouse on Richmond Green survives, with the arms of Henry VII still over the arch, and a few fragments of the old walls stand among later houses.

The room where the cushions lay is gone.

—

## The cushions

It is easy to read the last weeks of Elizabeth I as a story about decline.

An old woman, grieving, frightened, refusing food, sitting on the floor.

But look again at what she was doing.

For more than forty years she had held a kingdom together largely by refusing.

She had refused to marry.

She had refused to name an heir.

She had refused to let anyone see her weak.

And at the very end, when her body was failing and her friends were gone and the men in the outer rooms were already writing to Edinburgh, she did the only thing left to her.

She refused to lie down.

For four days and nights at least, she sat on her cushions and made them wait.

In the end, it took an old sailor in mourning to put her to bed, and a roomful of councillors to decide what her hand had meant.

Then they carried her to Westminster with her painted likeness lying flat on top of the coffin, for all of London to see.

And they carved her in marble, lying down, forever.

She would not have liked it.

—

## What The Record Actually Says

Elizabeth I died at Richmond Palace in the early hours of March 24, 1603, at the age of sixty-nine.

The account of her sitting “low upon her cushions,” of her words “No, Robin, I am not well,” of her forty or fifty sighs, of her remaining on the cushions “four days and nights at the least,” of the Lord Admiral getting her to bed “what by fair means, what by force,” of her losing her speech on March 23, of the sign for the King of Scots, and of Archbishop Whitgift’s long prayers comes from the memoirs of Sir Robert Carey, later Earl of Monmouth, written many years afterward.

Carey was not present when the council asked about the succession; he reports what he was told.

Other accounts of the length of time she spent on the cushions differ, and some later ones make it longer.

The words “mildly like a lamb, easily like a ripe apple from the tree” are from the diary of John Manningham; their link to Dr. Henry Parry is often suggested but not certain.

The filing-off of the coronation ring is recorded by William Camden, whose history was written some years later; the exact date is not certain.

The Countess of Nottingham died in late February 1603, and the queen’s grief is widely reported; the story of the Earl of Essex’s ring withheld by the countess is a legend that first appears long afterward and is not supported by contemporary evidence.

The words “the word must is not to be used to princes,” spoken to Robert Cecil, come from later accounts, not from Carey, and the exact wording varies.

The account of Lady Elizabeth Southwell, written years later abroad, is the source for the playing card under the chair, the queen’s vision of herself, the claim that she forbade embalming, and the story of the coffin cracking at Whitehall; historians regard much of it as doubtful.

The details of Carey’s ride, the fall, the blue ring, and James’s words “It is enough” are Carey’s own; the scene of Lady Scrope dropping the ring from a window is a later embellishment.

The funeral on April 28, 1603, the effigy on the coffin, Stow’s description of the weeping crowd, and the removal of the coffin in 1606 to a vault shared with Mary I beneath a monument by Maximilian Colt are recorded by Westminster Abbey.

The opening scene, the room around the cushions, and the descriptions of the deathbed are reconstructions built on these sources; what the queen thought and felt is not recorded and is inferred here only from what witnesses said she did.

You Might Also Enjoy