1546: Anne Askew, the Only Woman on Record Racked in the Tower of London
The room was below the level of the yard, and it was cold in a way the rest of London was not.
Outside it was the end of June 1546.
The river was low and warm and smelled of mud, and the city above the walls was busy with summer.
Down here the air was damp and still, and the only light came from a window too high to see out of and a few candles that nobody had bothered to trim.
In the middle of the floor stood a long wooden frame, taller than a table, with a roller at each end and ropes coiled beside it.
A young woman stood in front of it.
She was about twenty-five.
She had been in prison, one way or another, for weeks, and she had already been tried and sentenced to be burned.
There was no legal reason for her to be in this room at all.
Two men in long gowns faced her.
One was Sir Thomas Wriothesley, Lord Chancellor of England, the highest legal officer in the kingdom.
The other was Sir Richard Rich, a member of the king’s Privy Council.
Neither of them needed anything more from her for her own case.
Her own case was finished.
They wanted something else.
They wanted names.
Which ladies of the court shared her beliefs?
Which great women had sent her money in prison?
Which members of the king’s own council protected her?
She said she knew of none.
They asked again.
She gave them the same answer.
The two most powerful lawyers in England looked at the frame in the middle of the room, and then at the woman, and one of them gave an order to the guard.
Why would the Lord Chancellor of England come down into a cellar himself, for the names of a few ladies?
The answer is that one of the women they were looking for, by many accounts, wore a crown.
What happened in that room over the next hour is known, unusually, from the woman herself.
She wrote it down afterward, in her own plain words, and the pages were smuggled out of England and printed abroad within a year.
She told what she was asked, what she answered, and who turned the handles.
She was the only woman on record ever to be racked in the Tower of London.
The men who did it went on to great titles and long lives.
And the question they put to her that afternoon, the question of whose names she knew, is the one this story has to answer at the end.
Her name was Anne Askew.
She had come a long way to be standing in that room, and it began with a wedding that was never meant to be hers.
—
## The girl who was married in her dead sister’s place
Anne Askew was born around 1521 in Lincolnshire, in the flat, wet country between the Wolds and the sea.
Her date of birth is not recorded; the year comes from her first publisher, who said she was twenty-five when she died.
Family tradition puts her birth at Stallingborough, near Grimsby.
Other writers say South Kelsey, where the family had its main house.
Her father was Sir William Askew, a knight and a man of some standing.
He served the king, sat on juries in great trials, and knew his way around the court.
Her mother was Elizabeth Wrottesley.
There were several brothers and sisters, and at least one of the brothers would later find a place in royal service.
Sir William had arranged a good match for his elder daughter Martha.
She was to marry Thomas Kyme, the son of a neighboring Lincolnshire family with land around Kelsey.
Then Martha died before the wedding.
The marriage contract was already made, and money had already been promised.
Rather than lose the arrangement, Sir William put his next daughter in Martha’s place.
Anne was about fifteen.
According to her first publisher, John Bale, she went against her will.
She married Thomas Kyme and became, in law, Anne Kyme.
She had two children with him.
Almost nothing else is known about the marriage from his side.
What is known is what happened to it.
Anne could read, and she read the one book that, in the England of the 1530s, was suddenly in every parish church.
In 1538 Henry VIII’s government had ordered an English Bible to be placed in every church in the kingdom.
For the first time, a young wife in a Lincolnshire village could walk into the church and read the Gospels for herself, in her own language, without a priest standing between her and the page.
Anne did.
And she did not stop at reading.
She began to argue.
—
## What the priests of Lincoln saw her reading
The quarrel at home grew.
Anne read her Bible and came to conclusions that her husband and the local clergy found shocking, above all about the Mass.
The church taught that at the moment of consecration the bread on the altar became the actual body of Christ.
Anne read the Gospels and decided it did not.
The bread was bread.
Christ was in heaven.
Whatever happened at the altar was a remembrance, not a miracle.
In the England of Henry VIII, that was not an opinion.
It was a capital crime.
In 1539 Parliament had passed the Act of Six Articles, which the king had pushed through himself.
The first article declared that the bread and wine of the Mass became the real body and blood of Christ.
Anyone who denied it, by word or in writing, was to be burned as a heretic.
There was no second chance, not even for a first offense.
Anne denied it anyway.
According to her own later account, she once went to Lincoln, to the great cathedral on the hill, where English Bibles stood chained for anyone to read.
She sat and read.
The clergy of the cathedral, who knew who she was, came past her in pairs and looked.
None of them spoke to her.
She was not hiding.
That was part of the problem.
At some point the marriage broke.
By Bale’s account, Kyme drove her out of the house, under pressure from the priests she had offended.
It is often said that Anne tried to obtain a divorce, arguing from St Paul that a believing wife was not bound to an unbelieving husband.
The details are uncertain.
What is certain is that she stopped calling herself Kyme.
She went back to her father’s name.
She was Anne Askew again.
She was in her early twenties, without a husband’s house or a husband’s money, and she had decided to go where the arguments were.
She went to London.
—
## Why a young wife came to London alone
London in the mid-1540s was full of people like her.
They met in each other’s houses, read the Bible aloud, passed around little books printed abroad, and argued about the Mass.
Some were apprentices and tradesmen.
Some were very well connected indeed.
Anne had connections.
One of her brothers held a post at court.
Her family knew people who knew people.
A gentlewoman from Lincolnshire with a famous temper for Scripture was exactly the kind of guest the reforming households of London liked to have at their tables.
It was also exactly the kind of guest the bishop of London liked to hear about.
The bishop was Edmund Bonner, a heavy, energetic man who took the Six Articles seriously.
His officers had informers in the city.
And in the spring of 1545, according to some accounts, her husband had a hand in pointing them toward her.
In March 1545 Anne Askew was arrested.
She was questioned first at Saddlers’ Hall, near Cheapside, by a man named Christopher Dare, who was acting for a sworn inquest of citizens appointed to hunt out heresy.
He asked her whether she believed that the sacrament hanging above the altar was the very body of Christ.
She answered with a question of her own.
She asked him why St Stephen had been stoned to death.
He did not know.
Then, she wrote, she would not answer his vain question either.
He tried again.
She quoted Scripture back at him.
When one of her questioners pressed her on a verse she did not choose to explain, she gave the reply that her friends would repeat with delight for years.
She would not throw pearls among swine, she told him; acorns were good enough.
—
## The question about the mouse
From Saddlers’ Hall she was taken before the Lord Mayor of London.
He was a practical man, and he put to her the kind of question that practical men liked to use against the gospellers, because it seemed to have no safe answer.
Suppose, he said, that a consecrated host fell from the altar, and a mouse ate it.
Did the mouse receive God, or not?
If she said yes, she was admitting the bread was God.
If she said no, she was denying it, and that was heresy.
She did not say either.
In her own account she wrote that she had never asked such a question herself.
They had asked it of her.
And she had made them no answer.
She had smiled.
The Lord Mayor sent her to one of the city prisons, called the Counter, and for the first time she was locked up.
A priest was sent to question her there.
Then, by her account, the bishop’s chancellor, a lawyer, came to rebuke her for quoting Scripture at all.
St Paul, he told her, had forbidden women to speak of the word of God.
Anne answered that she knew Paul’s meaning as well as he did.
Paul, she said, had forbidden women to preach in the congregation by way of teaching.
Then she asked him how many women he had ever seen go up into a pulpit and preach.
He said he had never seen any.
Then, she said, he ought to find no fault in poor women, unless they had broken the law.
After about twelve days she was brought before Bishop Bonner himself.
Bonner was gentle at first, and told her to unburden her conscience.
She told him that she had nothing to confess.
“God hath given me the gifts of knowledge,” she said, according to her account, “but not of utterance.”
Bonner had a statement of faith drawn up about the sacrament and told her to sign it.
She signed.
But beside her name she added a short clause of her own, and the bishop’s men argued afterward about whether the signature counted at all.
A cousin put up the money for her release.
On June 13, 1545, she was brought into court in London with two other suspects, charged under the Six Articles.
The law required witnesses.
None appeared.
The court acquitted all three.
She had walked into the machinery of the Six Articles, and she had walked out again.
Most people would have gone home to Lincolnshire and stayed there.
Within a year she was back in London, and the men who were looking for her this time were not city aldermen.
—
## The year the old men decided to clean the court
By 1546 Henry VIII was fifty-four, enormous, and often in pain.
His legs were ulcerated.
He was carried from room to room in a chair, and on bad days he could not climb stairs.
Everyone around him knew that his son, Prince Edward, was eight years old, and that whoever controlled the council when the king died would control England.
Two factions were waiting.
On one side were men who wanted the old religion kept as it was: the Mass in Latin, the sacrament worshipped as the body of Christ.
Their leaders were Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester, and the Lord Chancellor, Thomas Wriothesley.
Wriothesley was about forty.
He had begun as a clerk under Thomas Cromwell, learned everything Cromwell knew, and then helped bring Cromwell down in 1540.
He was quick, hardworking, and very good at reading which way the king was leaning.
On the other side were the reformers, who wanted the English church to go further from Rome.
They had friends on the council, and they had friends in the queen’s household.
The queen was Catherine Parr, Henry’s sixth wife.
She was serious, learned, and quietly sympathetic to reform.
Around her moved a circle of great ladies who read the new books and discussed them in her rooms: Katherine Willoughby, Duchess of Suffolk; Anne Stanhope, Countess of Hertford, whose husband was the prince’s uncle; Joan, Lady Denny, whose husband sat close to the king every day; and others.
If the conservatives could prove that heresy was being protected inside the queen’s own household, they could break their rivals’ grip on the court.
They might even break the queen.
In the spring of 1546 the hunt began.
By most accounts it started with a London preacher, Dr. Edward Crome, who gave a sermon in Lent that offended the conservatives.
When he was questioned, he talked, and the names he gave led to other names.
Among those swept up was a gentleman of the court named John Lascelles.
Five years earlier, it was Lascelles who had gone to Archbishop Cranmer with the story of Queen Catherine Howard’s past, the story that ended with her on the scaffold.
Now he was accused of denying the sacrament.
Another was Nicholas Shaxton, who had once been Bishop of Salisbury and had resigned rather than accept the Six Articles.
And another was Anne Askew.
She was arrested again in the late spring of 1546.
This time she was not taken before the Lord Mayor.
She was taken before the king’s council.
—
## What she told the bishop who promised to burn her
The council met at Greenwich, in the palace by the river where Henry VIII had been born.
Anne was questioned there over two days in June, before the Lord Chancellor, Bishop Gardiner, and other councillors.
Everything we know of what was said comes from her own account, so it is her side of the room.
But it is detailed, and it does not make her sound like a saint.
It makes her sound like a clever, stubborn young woman enjoying an argument with men who could have her burned.
They asked her, again and again, about the sacrament.
She would not give them the plain denial they needed.
She said she believed what Scripture said.
When they pressed her to speak plainly, she quoted the psalm about exiles who would not sing the Lord’s song in a strange land.
Gardiner lost patience.
In her account, he complained that she spoke in parables, and he called her a parrot.
At one point he told her outright that she would be burned.
She answered that she had searched all the Scriptures, and she could never find that either Christ or His apostles had put any creature to death.
It went to the heart of what the council was doing, and it was delivered to the man who was doing it.
Someone on the council asked her how she could avoid the very words of Christ: “Take, eat, this is my body.”
Anne answered, in her account, that those words had to be understood the way His other sayings were, as when He called Himself a door, or a vine.
They kept her overnight.
The next day they started again, with the Lord Chancellor and the bishop of Winchester still in the room.
She gave them nothing new.
Afterward she was not sent home.
She was kept for a time at the house of a gentlewoman, Lady Garnish, while the council decided what to do with her, and then she was sent to Newgate, the great prison by the city’s west gate.
By now she was sick.
She wrote that she had never been in such pain in her life, and she asked to see Hugh Latimer, the most famous reforming preacher in England.
They would not let him come.
—
## The sentence that should have been the end
In the middle of June 1546 she was brought to the Guildhall, the great hall of the City of London, to be tried under the Six Articles.
She was not alone at the bar.
Nicholas Shaxton, the former bishop, stood there with her, along with other men accused of the same crime.
The date is usually given as June 18, from a London chronicle of the time, although some historians argue for a later date that month.
There was no need for witnesses this time.
Anne had written down what she believed, and the court had her own words.
She did not deny them.
She was condemned to be burned.
So were the others.
And then, the very next day, Nicholas Shaxton recanted.
The former bishop, who had once given up his see rather than accept the Six Articles, now accepted them, and was pardoned.
Anne did not recant.
In law, her story was now over.
She was a convicted heretic awaiting the stake.
There was nothing more the court could want from her.
But the council wanted something more.
A few days later, she was taken from Newgate to an inn called the Crown.
Waiting for her there was Sir Richard Rich.
Rich was about fifty.
He was a lawyer from a modest London family who had made himself rich in the service of the Crown, above all by managing the lands taken from the monasteries.
Eleven years earlier, in 1535, he had been the witness whose testimony sent Sir Thomas More to the block.
More, at his trial, had accused Rich to his face of perjury.
Rich had kept rising anyway.
With Rich at the Crown was Nicholas Shaxton, newly pardoned.
The two of them spent the day urging her to do what Shaxton had done.
Recant, and live.
Anne told Shaxton that it would have been better for him if he had never been born.
When persuasion failed, Rich gave another order.
She was to be taken to the Tower.
—
## Why a condemned woman was taken to the Tower
To understand how strange this was, you have to understand what the rack was for.
English common law did not allow torture.
But the Crown claimed the right, in special cases, to put a prisoner to the question when the safety of the realm was at stake.
In practice that meant traitors, warrants from the council, and the Tower.
It almost never meant women.
It almost never meant gentlewomen.
And it never needed to mean a woman who had already been condemned and had nothing left to confess about her own case.
Whatever the council wanted from Anne Askew in the Tower, it was not evidence against her.
It was evidence against someone else.
She was taken in through the gates and down, according to the later account of John Foxe, into a lower room.
Rich was there, with another councillor.
They did not ask her about the sacrament.
They asked about her friends.
She wrote down the questions afterward.
They wanted to know whether she knew any man or woman of her sect.
She said she did not.
They asked about particular ladies by name: the Duchess of Suffolk, the Countess of Sussex, the Countess of Hertford, Lady Denny, Lady Fitzwilliam.
She answered that if she said anything against them, she would not be able to prove it.
They asked how she had been kept alive in prison.
Who had sent her money?
Here she told them something, but not much.
Her maid, she said, had gone out into the streets and made her situation known to the apprentices, and they had sent her money.
She did not know their names.
And there had been two other gifts.
A man in a blue coat had brought her ten shillings and said they came from the Countess of Hertford.
A man in a violet coat had brought her eight shillings and said they came from Lady Denny.
Whether it was true or not, she told them, she could not say.
Two servants in colored coats, and two sums of money, and a woman who would not swear to where they came from.
It was not enough.
They told her there were members of the council who protected her.
She said there were not.
—
## What happened when she would not cry out
They put her on the rack.
She wrote it in one sentence, plainly, without any adjective at all.
In the modernized form in which most readers know it, she said that they did put her on the rack, because she confessed no ladies or gentlewomen to be of her opinion, and that they kept her there a long time.
That is how it began.
The man responsible for the prisoners in the Tower was its Lieutenant, Sir Anthony Knyvett, a soldier and courtier who had served the king for years.
The instruments in the lower rooms were in his charge, and so were the men who worked them.
According to Foxe, it was Knyvett who first gave the order, telling his jailer to “pinch” her with the rack.
The word was meant to be mild.
It meant enough to frighten, not enough to break.
The ropes were tied.
The roller was turned.
Picture the room as it must have been.
The low ceiling.
The candles.
Rich and the Lord Chancellor standing in their gowns.
The jailer at the handles.
The Lieutenant watching, a man who had run the Tower long enough to know what the frame could do.
And on it, a woman of twenty-five who had been condemned already, had nothing more to lose in law, and had decided before she came in what she was going to say.
They asked her for names.
She gave them none.
The jailer turned again.
Every account agrees on one thing about her behavior on the rack, and it is the thing she herself chose to record.
She did not scream.
She did not beg.
She did not cry out at all.
She lay still.
To the men standing over her, it must have been unbearable.
The whole purpose of the rack was the sound.
Pain was supposed to become words: a cry, then a plea, then a name.
Silence meant the machine was not working.
Knyvett, by Foxe’s account, decided it had gone far enough.
He thought she had been given as much as the occasion required.
He ordered his man to take her down.
Wriothesley stopped him.
The Lord Chancellor, Foxe says, was not content that she had been loosed so soon when she had confessed nothing.
He ordered the Lieutenant to strain her on the rack again.
Knyvett refused.
It is worth pausing on that refusal, because it was not a small thing.
Sir Anthony Knyvett was a subordinate officer refusing a direct order from the Lord Chancellor of England, in the king’s own fortress, in the last year of a reign in which men had gone to the block for much less.
Foxe says he refused out of pity for the weakness of the woman.
Whatever his reasons, he would not do it.
Wriothesley threatened him.
He told the Lieutenant that he would report his disobedience to the king.
Knyvett still would not do it.
And then the two councillors did something no one in that room could have expected.
They took off their gowns.
The Lord Chancellor of England and Sir Richard Rich laid aside the long robes of their office, stepped up to the frame, and took the handles themselves.
Foxe adds one more detail.
Before they began, he says, one of them asked her whether she was with child.
She answered, in his version, that they need not spare her for that, and should do their will.
Here her own account and Foxe’s come together.
She did not mention the Lieutenant’s refusal; perhaps she never knew of it, or perhaps she did not care to spend words on it.
But she was entirely clear about who did what next.
Because she lay still and did not cry, she wrote, “my lord Chancellor and master Rich took pains to rack me with their own hands, till I was nigh dead.”
Took pains.
It is an old phrase.
In her time it meant they made an effort, they went to trouble.
The two most senior lawyers in the kingdom, men who signed their names to the laws of England, went to trouble.
How long it lasted, nobody recorded.
A long time, she said, and that is all she said.
What they wanted was a sentence.
One name would have done.
The Duchess of Suffolk.
The Countess of Hertford.
Lady Denny.
Any of them.
A single name spoken on the rack, written down by a clerk, and carried to the king, and the queen’s circle would have been in the council’s hands.
The jailer stood aside.
The Lieutenant stood aside.
The two councillors worked the frame between them, and asked, and listened.
She lay still.
She did not give them one.
Finally the Lieutenant, as she put it, caused her to be loosed from the rack.
Whether Wriothesley and Rich had given up or Knyvett simply stepped in, she did not say.
When the ropes came off, she fainted.
They brought her round again.
Somewhere around this time, if Foxe is right, Sir Anthony Knyvett left the room.
He did not wait to see what the Lord Chancellor would say to the king.
He went out of the Tower, took a boat on the river, and went straight to the court to tell the king himself before anyone else could.
Foxe says Henry VIII heard him out, did not much like what he heard about the extreme handling of the woman, and granted the Lieutenant his pardon.
Then he sent him back to his charge.
There is no record that the king said anything to Wriothesley or Rich.
—
## Two hours on the bare floor
What happened next is perhaps the strangest passage in her whole account, and she told it in two sentences.
After she came round, she wrote, she sat two long hours reasoning with the Lord Chancellor upon the bare floor.
Hold that scene for a moment.
The rack behind her.
The woman unable to stand, sitting on the stones.
And the Lord Chancellor of England, who a few minutes earlier had been working the ropes with his own hands, now sitting or standing over her, talking.
Talking for two hours.
He used, she wrote, many flattering words.
He tried to persuade her to leave her opinions.
He had failed with the rack, and now he tried with reason and kindness, as if the one thing had not just happened and the other could still work.
She argued back.
For two hours a condemned woman who could no longer walk debated theology with the highest lawyer in the land, on the floor of the room where he had just racked her, and gave him nothing.
Afterward she was carried to a house and laid in a bed.
She compared herself, in her account, to Job, the man in the Bible whom God allowed to lose everything, and wrote that her bones were as weary and painful as ever his had been.
Then a message came from the Lord Chancellor.
If she would leave her opinion, she would want for nothing.
If she would not, she would go back to Newgate, and then to the fire.
She sent back her answer.
She would rather die than break her faith.
The rack had not given Wriothesley his names.
But it had given the council something else, though they did not know it yet.
It had given Anne Askew a story to tell, and she was going to tell it.
—
## The ballad from Newgate
She was carried back to Newgate.
She would never walk on her own again.
Whatever the frame had done to her, it had done it thoroughly, and she spent the last weeks of her life unable to stand.
She spent them writing.
She wrote down her examinations, the questions and her answers, with dry precision.
She wrote a confession of her faith.
She wrote a letter to the king, explaining what she believed about the sacrament, which nobody seems to have delivered to him in a form he read.
In one passage of her writings, she put her view of the Mass in words that would shock her enemies more than anything she had said aloud: that what they called their God was a piece of bread, and if they doubted it, they could leave it in the box for three months and see what became of it.
She signed one of her papers in a way that has been quoted ever since.
It is usually given like this: written by Anne Askew, that neither wisheth death nor yet feareth his might, and as merry as one that is bound towards heaven.
Somehow the pages got out.
Friends visited.
Servants came and went.
Somebody carried her papers out of Newgate, and out of England.
There is also a poem.
It was printed soon after her death under the title “The Ballad which Anne Askew made and sang when she was in Newgate,” and it is traditionally attributed to her.
Nobody can prove she wrote it, but it sounds like her.
It begins with a soldier going out to battle:
“Like as the armed knight, appointed to the field.”
In the ballad, the knight’s armor is faith, and he is going out to fight the world.
The real woman could not stand up.
The date had already been set.
July 16, 1546.
—
## The chair at Smithfield
Smithfield was a broad open space just outside the city wall, northwest of St Paul’s.
On ordinary days it was a market for horses and cattle.
On days like this one, it was where London burned its heretics.
The crowd came early.
Foxe says it was very great.
People pressed into the open ground and climbed onto anything that would give them a view.
Railings had been put up around the place where the stakes stood.
Along one side of the field was the church of St Bartholomew the Great, and in front of it the authorities had put a bench.
On that bench sat the men responsible.
The Lord Chancellor, Thomas Wriothesley, was there.
So was the Duke of Norfolk, the most powerful nobleman in England.
So was Lord Russell, the Lord Privy Seal, who would later be Earl of Bedford.
So was the Lord Mayor of London, with the aldermen and sheriffs of the city.
There were four prisoners.
One was John Lascelles, the courtier who had first carried the secret of Catherine Howard’s past to Archbishop Cranmer.
One was John Adams, a tailor.
One was Nicholas Belenian, a priest from Shropshire.
And one was Anne Askew.
She could not walk to the stake.
They carried her into Smithfield sitting in a chair.
When they set her at the post, she could not stand, so they fastened a chain around her waist to hold her upright.
Then the sermon began.
The preacher was Nicholas Shaxton.
The former bishop who had stood beside her at the Guildhall, recanted the next day, and spent a day at the Crown begging her to do the same, now climbed into a pulpit to preach to the four people who had refused.
Anne listened.
According to Foxe, when he said something she agreed with, she said so aloud.
When he said something she thought was false, she said that too.
“There he misseth,” she said, “and speaketh without the book.”
Up on the bench, the lords had a different worry.
Small bags of gunpowder had been tied to the prisoners, a common mercy, meant to end the suffering sooner when the fire reached it.
Some of the great men were afraid that when the powder caught, burning wood would come flying at them across the field.
Lord Russell reassured them.
The gunpowder, he said, was not laid under the faggots.
It was only on the prisoners’ bodies.
The lords were in no danger.
The lords stayed where they were.
Then the Lord Chancellor sent one last thing down from the bench.
It was a letter of pardon, from the king.
If she would recant, here and now, she could go free.
She would be carried out of Smithfield in her chair and taken somewhere to heal.
They brought it to her at the stake.
Foxe says she would not even look at it.
She told them she had not come there to deny her Lord and Master.
The pardon was offered to the three men.
Each of them refused it too.
On the bench, the Lord Mayor gave the order.
Foxe records his words in Latin: “Fiat justitia.”
Let justice be done.
The torches went down into the wood.
Some in the crowd had come to see heretics burn.
Some had come because they believed what Anne believed and wanted her to see them there.
Among them, Bale later said, were Dutch merchants, who went home and told what they had seen.
The smoke rose over the market and the church and the bench where the Lord Chancellor sat.
Anne Askew was about twenty-five years old.
—
## The names she kept
So here is the answer to the question the Lord Chancellor asked in that room in the Tower.
She did not give him a single name.
Not the Duchess of Suffolk.
Not the Countess of Hertford.
Not Lady Denny.
Not Lady Fitzwilliam.
Not the Countess of Sussex.
The only things she told her questioners were what she could not stop them from guessing: that strangers had sent her money, and that two servants had used the names of two great ladies, and that she could not say whether it was true.
No lady of the court was arrested because of anything Anne Askew said.
And the woman who sat above all of them, the queen, was safe for the moment.
A few weeks after Smithfield, the same men tried to reach Catherine Parr another way, with a warrant for her arrest that the king himself signed.
They failed, and the queen outlived the king.
Whatever had happened in that cellar, the conservatives had lost the race they were running.
Within six months Henry VIII was dead.
The council that ruled for his young son was led by the Earl of Hertford, the husband of the Countess whose name the Lord Chancellor had wanted so badly.
He made himself Duke of Somerset and Lord Protector of England, and under him the English church moved further from Rome in a few years than it had in the whole of Henry’s reign.
In 1549 the old Latin Mass, the ceremony whose bread Anne Askew had refused to call the body of Christ, was replaced by law with a new English service.
The ladies she would not name did well.
The Countess of Hertford became the Duchess of Somerset, the first lady of the realm, for a while.
The Duchess of Suffolk lived to flee abroad in the reign of Mary I and came home again under Elizabeth.
Lady Denny’s husband, Sir Anthony Denny, was one of the men at Henry’s bedside the night he died.
None of them, as far as anyone knows, ever wrote down a word about the woman who kept their names to herself.
—
## What became of the men who turned the wheel
Thomas Wriothesley got everything he had worked for, and then lost most of it almost at once.
In February 1547, in the new reign, he was created Earl of Southampton.
Within weeks he was stripped of the Great Seal, accused of exceeding his powers as Lord Chancellor, and pushed off the council by the very men he had tried to bring down.
He worked his way back, helped bring down the Duke of Somerset in 1549, and was shut out again by his own allies.
He died in July 1550, not yet fifty.
His title passed to his son.
His grandson, the third Earl of Southampton, became the young patron to whom William Shakespeare dedicated his first published poems.
Sir Richard Rich did even better.
In 1547 he was made Baron Rich.
Before the year was out he was Lord Chancellor himself, holding the office that Wriothesley had just lost.
He served under Edward VI, kept his place under the Catholic Mary I, survived again under the Protestant Elizabeth I, and died in his bed in 1567, in his seventies, one of the richest men in England.
He founded a school at Felsted in Essex, which still exists.
Nobody, under any of the four monarchs he served, ever called him to account for what he did in the Tower.
Of Sir Anthony Knyvett, the Lieutenant who would not turn the rack again, much less is known.
His refusal survives because Foxe told it, and because it was so unusual.
He is remembered, if at all, as the man in charge of the Tower who said no.
Stephen Gardiner, the bishop who told her she would be burned, was struck out of Henry VIII’s will at the end of 1546 and spent much of the next reign as a prisoner in the Tower himself.
Under Mary I he was freed, made Lord Chancellor, and became one of the leaders of the burning of Protestants in the 1550s.
He died in 1555.
Nicholas Shaxton, the preacher at Smithfield, went back into the church.
Under Mary I, it is said, he sat in judgment on heretics himself.
And the pages Anne wrote in Newgate reached a man named John Bale.
Bale was a former friar turned fierce Protestant writer, living in exile in Germany.
He printed her account in two parts, The First Examination in late 1546 and The Latter Examination early in 1547, wrapped in long commentaries of his own.
Copies were smuggled into England, banned, and passed from hand to hand.
In 1563 John Foxe put her story into his huge book of the Protestant martyrs, the Acts and Monuments.
He reprinted her words, added what he had learned from people who had been there, including the Lieutenant’s refusal, and printed a woodcut of the burning at Smithfield: the stakes, the crowd, the pulpit, and the great men on their bench.
For generations of English readers, that picture was what Anne Askew looked like.
Smithfield is still an open space in the City of London, with a meat market on its north side and the church of St Bartholomew the Great still standing at its edge.
A plaque on the wall of St Bartholomew’s Hospital remembers the Protestants who were burned nearby.
The Tower is now one of the most visited places in Britain.
Visitors can see a replica of a rack.
—
## She lay still
Go back once more to that room under the Tower at the end of June 1546.
The candles.
The low ceiling.
The frame in the middle of the floor.
The Lord Chancellor and Sir Richard Rich in their gowns, asking for names.
A young woman from Lincolnshire who had already been sentenced to death, who had nothing to gain by silence and everything to lose by it.
They took off their gowns.
They took the handles in their own hands.
They went, as she put it, to trouble.
Everything the rack was built for depended on one thing: that, sooner or later, the person on it would make a sound.
She did not.
She lay still.
She did not cry out.
And when they finally let her down, and she came round on the bare floor, and the Lord Chancellor of England sat down beside her and talked for two hours, she still had every one of their names.
She took them with her to Smithfield.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Most of what is known about Anne Askew comes from her own accounts of her examinations, published by John Bale (1546 and 1547) and reprinted by John Foxe in the Acts and Monuments (1563).
Both men were committed Protestants who edited and framed her words.
Quotations here follow her account in modernized form; some are paraphrased.
Her birth year (around 1521) comes from Bale’s statement that she was twenty-five when she died; her birthplace is uncertain.
Her marriage to Thomas Kyme in place of her dead sister and her expulsion from his house come from Bale; whether she formally sought a divorce is not certain.
The 1545 examinations and her acquittal on June 13, 1545, follow her own account.
The date of her trial at the Guildhall is given as June 18, 1546, in a contemporary London chronicle; some historians argue for later in June.
The exact date of the racking is not recorded; it took place after her condemnation, in the last days of June.
That Wriothesley and Rich racked her “with their own hands” because she “lay still and did not cry” is in her own account.
The Lieutenant’s refusal, his journey by water to the king, the king’s pardon, the jailer told to “pinch” her, and the question about whether she was with child come from Foxe and other later accounts, and cannot be confirmed by a witness writing at the time.
She is often described as the only woman known to have been racked in the Tower.
Some writers also name Margaret Cheyne (Lady Bulmer), burned in 1537, as a woman who may have been harshly questioned there, but there is no record that she was put on the rack.
The ladies’ names and the men in the blue and violet coats are from her own account.
How far the queen herself was a target is a matter of interpretation; many historians connect the racking to the attempt against Catherine Parr shortly afterward.
The ballad “Like as the armed knight” is traditionally attributed to her.
The burning at Smithfield on July 16, 1546, with the chair, the chain, Shaxton’s sermon, the gunpowder, the refused pardon and the Lord Mayor’s “Fiat justitia,” comes from Foxe.
The rooms in the Tower and the weather are reconstructed.