1536: What Was New Year’s Day Like at Henry VIII’s Court
On the first morning of 1536, a queen stood beside the King of England and smiled while the most powerful people in the country came forward, one by one, with gifts in their hands.
She was expecting a child.
She wore the crown she had waited years to win.
And she had less than five months to live.
Her name was Anne Boleyn, and nothing in that bright, crowded room gave her any warning.
The king beside her was Henry VIII, forty-four years old, broad in the shoulder and thick through the middle, but still the man who rode in tournaments and danced through the night at Christmas.
Around them, the court was deep into its twelve days of celebration.
There were fires in every hearth, candles by the hundred, music in the galleries, and a long line of courtiers holding cups of gold, embroidered shirts and little jeweled boxes.
Every one of those gifts was a message.
And within a few weeks, the person who had smiled at all of them would begin to lose everything she had built.
This is what New Year’s Day was like at the court of Henry VIII in 1536, and what happened to the people who stood in that room.
—
## Where the court kept the season
A Tudor court was never still for long.
It moved from palace to palace with the king, hundreds of people and thousands of horses and carts, and in winter it settled into whichever house the king had chosen for the holidays.
His favorite place for Christmas was Greenwich, the great riverside palace on the south bank of the Thames, a few miles downstream from London.
That winter, though, the season seems to have begun elsewhere.
After spending much of Advent at Richmond, the court moved to Eltham, an old royal palace a short ride inland from Greenwich, which in those years served mainly as a nursery for the royal children.
Henry and Anne kept Christmas Day there, walking to chapel in procession under a cloth of estate.
On the 29th of December, the king rode over to Greenwich to meet the ambassador of the Holy Roman Emperor, and through January the court’s life centered on Greenwich.
Exactly where the gifts were handed over on New Year’s morning is not recorded, because the gift roll for 1536 has not survived.
But the ceremony itself, and the palace where the rest of this story unfolds, are well known.
So picture it as the court would have known it in that January, at Greenwich.
—
## The palace by the river
Greenwich was the palace where Henry had been born, on the 28th of June, 1491.
It had a softer, older name, too: Placentia, or Pleasaunce, the pleasant place.
It stretched along the riverbank, all red brick and tall windows, with a water gate where the royal barges came and went.
Henry had poured money into it for decades.
He had added a tiltyard for jousting, with towers where spectators could watch, an armory where his own steel suits were made, and tennis courts and gardens where the court could walk.
Inside, a chain of rooms led inward toward the king.
First came the great hall, where the household ate under a high timber roof.
Then the guard chamber, full of yeomen with halberds.
Then the presence chamber, where the king’s chair stood under its canopy, the cloth of estate, a symbol that this was the seat of majesty even when the chair was empty.
Beyond that lay the privy chamber and the king’s private rooms, where only a handful of people could go without being called.
The walls were hung with tapestries woven in Flanders, many of them shot through with gold thread.
Glass came from Venice, silks and velvets from France and Italy.
At night, the candles turned the whole place into something close to a stage.
And that was the point.
Every corridor and every doorway at Greenwich was meant to lead people toward one man, and to remind them, step by step, how far below him they stood.
—
## Bigger than Christmas
To us, Christmas Day is the high point of the winter.
At the Tudor court, the day that really mattered politically was the first of January.
Christmas was a holy day, kept with long services in the chapel.
New Year’s Day was the day of gifts.
Almost everyone of importance at court gave the king a present that morning, and many people who were not very important at all.
Bishops gave, and earls, and duchesses.
So did ladies-in-waiting, household officers, physicians, the king’s musicians, and craftsmen who hoped to be remembered.
The gifts were not casual.
They were written down, name by name, on long documents called gift rolls, sheets of parchment or paper stitched end to end, so that some of them ran to several feet in length.
On one side went the gifts the king received.
On the other went what he gave back.
When the day was over, the rolls were put away among the king’s treasures.
A surviving gift roll is one of the best pictures we have of the Tudor court, because it shows, in one place, who was in favor and who was not, who could afford to give gold and who could only give needlework.
It is a map of power on a single morning.
—
## The ceremony
The exchange had its own choreography.
Gifts were carried in by servants or brought in person, presented with a bow, and handed to the officers whose job was to take charge of them.
Sir Brian Tuke, the Treasurer of the King’s Chamber, is said to have stood close by on some of these mornings, noting each offering as it came in, while the king looked on from beside a cupboard of plate.
Whether or not Henry watched every gift arrive, he knew what each one meant.
A rich gift said loyalty, and hope.
A modest gift from a great lord could look like a slight.
And what the king gave back mattered even more.
His return gifts were usually pieces of gilt plate, cups, bowls and goblets, and they were measured not by beauty but by weight, in ounces.
There was a scale for it.
Dukes and archbishops received heavier plate than earls and bishops, and earls more than knights.
People of the same rank expected gifts of about the same weight, and everybody noticed when someone’s cup was a little heavier, or a little lighter, than their neighbor’s.
Generosity, at Henry’s court, came with a formula.
—
## The gift that was sent back
No one at court in 1536 needed to be told how dangerous the exchange could be.
They remembered New Year’s Day, 1532.
At that point, Henry was still legally married to Catherine of Aragon, his queen of more than twenty years, but he had been trying for years to have the marriage annulled so that he could marry Anne Boleyn.
That New Year’s morning, Anne gave him a set of richly decorated hunting spears in the Biscayan style, from the Basque country of northern Spain.
Henry was delighted.
In return he gave her magnificent hangings for a room, cloth of gold and cloth of silver, with crimson satin heavily embroidered.
Catherine, who by then had been sent away from court, also sent him a gift that day, a gold cup.
Henry refused it.
He sent it back to her, and the whole court heard about it.
The imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, wrote it up for the Emperor Charles V, Catherine’s nephew.
Within eighteen months, Anne had married Henry and been crowned queen in Westminster Abbey.
So when the courtiers lined up four years later, they understood exactly what the ritual meant.
The gift you brought was your loyalty, made visible.
The gift you received was the king’s verdict on what you were worth.
—
## What people gave
The presents ranged from the deeply personal to the staggeringly expensive.
Ladies of the court often gave the king shirts they had sewn themselves, with fine blackwork or gold and silver thread at the collars and cuffs.
It was a small, intimate gift, the kind a wife or mother might make.
Anne’s own mother, Elizabeth, Countess of Wiltshire, gave Henry needlework in the years after her husband was made an earl, including collars for his shirts, some worked in gold and some in silver.
She was giving to the man who was now her son-in-law, and the father of her granddaughter, the little Princess Elizabeth.
The men tended to aim for display.
Gifts recorded in the king’s reign include a gold ball made to hold perfume, which suited a king who loved sweet scents, and a doublet of purple satin worked with gold.
In the days of his power, Cardinal Thomas Wolsey had given the king splendid gold plate, the kind of gift only a man of his wealth could make.
Behind all of this stood the goldsmiths of London.
Men such as Robert Amadas, Cornelius Hayes and Morgan Wolf supplied the king’s plate over the years, and the weeks before New Year were their busiest of all.
They had to have dozens of cups and bowls ready, each one weighed and marked, so that the king could give back exactly what each guest’s rank deserved.
—
## The queen’s own exchange
Anne was not just standing at Henry’s side to watch.
A queen had her own household, and she held her own exchange.
Her ladies, her officers and her chaplains gave her gifts, and she gave gifts back.
People who wanted her favor thought hard about what she might like.
That winter, Lady Lisle, the wife of the king’s deputy at Calais, sent an agent to find out what present would please the queen.
The answer came back from one of Anne’s ladies, Margery Horsman, that the queen “setteth much store by a pretty dog.”
Whether Lady Lisle sent one, nobody knows.
Anne herself had given Henry some of the most remarkable gifts of his reign.
At New Year, 1534, she presented him with a table fountain of gilded metal.
It was recorded as a great gilt basin, with a rail of gold set with rubies, pearls and diamonds, and a fountain standing in the middle.
At its foot stood three small female figures, and water ran out from them, so that guests at the table could rinse their fingers.
Historians have long connected it with a surviving design for a table fountain drawn by Hans Holbein the Younger, the great painter of Henry’s court, though nobody can prove the drawing is that exact piece.
Either way, it was art and engineering together, and a statement of wealth and taste that very few people in England could have matched.
—
## A child on the way
In January 1536, Anne had something better than any gift to think about.
She was pregnant.
The child had probably been conceived in the autumn, and by New Year she was about three months along.
That mattered more than anything else in her life.
In September 1533 she had given Henry a daughter, Elizabeth, when everyone, the king above all, had expected a son.
Since then there had been at least one more pregnancy that did not end in a living child, though the details of what happened in 1534 are still unclear.
This pregnancy felt like her chance.
Henry had turned his whole kingdom upside down to marry her.
He had broken with the Pope, made himself Supreme Head of the Church in England, and put aside a queen who had the Emperor for a nephew.
All of it had been done, in large part, for one reason: a son.
If Anne gave him a prince, her place would be safe, and every risk he had taken would look justified.
So on that winter morning, Anne Boleyn had every reason to think that 1536 would be her best year.
It was her last.
—
## Twelve days of feasting
The gift exchange came in the middle of the long Christmas season, the twelve days that ran from Christmas Day to Twelfth Night and the feast of the Epiphany at the start of January.
Henry was famous for keeping that season in style.
In his grandest years, the court fed well over a thousand people, and the royal kitchens sometimes had to put up temporary kitchens in the grounds to cope.
Twelfth Night was the climax, with a feast of a great many dishes.
The food read like an inventory of the whole country.
There were roast swans and peacocks, sometimes served with their feathers put back on for show, venison from the royal parks, and a boar’s head carried in on a platter.
There were huge pies filled with game birds, and pastries and jellies colored with saffron and sanders.
Spices came from the other side of the world: pepper, cinnamon, ginger, cloves, nutmeg and mace, used in quantities that would startle a modern cook.
Sugar was a luxury, and the confectioners shaped it into sculptures called subtleties, castles and beasts and scenes from scripture and legend, set out to be admired before anyone ate them.
Wine came in casks from Gascony and the Rhineland.
Ale and beer were made in such quantities that they were counted by the barrel.
The halls were dressed with holly, ivy and bay, and a great log burned in the hearth.
Musicians played through the meals, mixing carols with dances and love songs.
And after supper came the entertainments.
The Master of the Revels arranged masks and plays and disguisings, in which courtiers put on costumes and acted out stories from myth and scripture.
Henry had loved this kind of thing since he was young.
Early in his reign, in 1510, he and a band of his friends had burst into the queen’s chamber dressed as Robin Hood and his men, to the delighted alarm of the ladies.
In some Christmases he had appointed a Lord of Misrule to run the revels.
There is no record of one for this season, but the court was not quiet.
There would have been dancing, cards and dice, and plenty of wine.
—
## The men at the king’s side
Among the people close to Henry that winter were two men who seemed as secure as anyone at court could be.
The first was Henry Norris.
He was Groom of the Stool, the chief gentleman of the king’s privy chamber.
The title sounds humble, because the groom attended the king in his most private moments, but the job made him one of the most powerful men in England.
Norris decided who got into the king’s private rooms and who waited outside.
He handled the king’s private money.
He was a friend as much as a servant, and in the New Year exchanges of those years he received generous plate from the king.
The second was George Boleyn, Viscount Rochford, Anne’s younger brother.
He was clever, well read, a poet and a diplomat, who had been sent on missions to France and was a fixture of the king’s inner circle.
In earlier exchanges, George had given Henry fine clothes, including a black velvet bonnet trimmed with gold aglets and buttons.
He was family.
He was trusted.
Within five months, both men would be dead, condemned for treason, accused of adultery with the queen, and in George’s case, with his own sister.
But on New Year’s morning, none of that had happened yet.
There was only the cold outside, the warmth inside, the glitter of the gifts, and a pregnant queen who believed the future was hers.
—
## Seven days later
On the 7th of January, 1536, Catherine of Aragon died.
Henry’s first wife had been living for nearly two years at Kimbolton Castle in Huntingdonshire, a damp, old house far from London.
She had never accepted the end of her marriage.
She refused to use the title she had been given, Dowager Princess of Wales, and insisted to the last that she was the true Queen of England.
She had been kept apart from her daughter, the Lady Mary, for years.
She was fifty years old.
In the last days of her life, Catherine is said to have written to Henry one final time.
The letter, as it has come down to us, begins “My most dear lord, king and husband.”
In it she tells him that the hour of her death is near, forgives him everything, and asks him to be a good father to Mary.
Historians have long debated whether the letter is genuine, or at least whether it was written down later in this exact form.
But its tone fits the woman exactly.
After her death, the man who prepared her body found her heart black and misshapen, with a dark growth attached to it.
Her household whispered about poison.
Modern doctors who have looked at the description think a cancer is far more likely.
The daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain, who had sailed to England as a girl of fifteen to marry a prince, died with only a few loyal servants around her.
—
## Yellow
When the news reached Henry, the next day, his reaction shocked even people who knew him well.
According to Chapuys, he cried out “God be praised that we are free from all suspicion of war.”
He had reason, of a kind.
As long as Catherine lived, the Emperor Charles V might one day decide to fight for his aunt’s honor.
With her gone, that danger faded.
On the following day, a Sunday, the king appeared dressed in yellow from head to foot, with a white feather in his cap, Chapuys reported.
Little Elizabeth, two years old, was carried to mass with trumpets sounding and great ceremony.
The chronicler Edward Hall gave a different picture.
He wrote that it was Queen Anne who wore yellow, and that she wore it for mourning.
Historians still argue about what the color meant.
Some point out that yellow could be a color of mourning in Spain, others that the king’s behavior looked very much like a celebration.
What nobody at court could miss was the message.
The last obstacle to Anne’s position seemed to be gone.
—
## Why Catherine’s death mattered to Anne
While Catherine lived, Anne’s enemies had a simple argument.
If Henry’s first marriage was still valid, his second was not.
That would make Anne nothing more than a mistress, and Elizabeth illegitimate.
Catherine’s death did not end every doubt, but it took away the living woman at the center of that argument.
And Anne was carrying a child.
If it was a boy, the dynasty had its heir, and Anne had kept the promise that had pulled England away from Rome.
For a little over two weeks, it looked as if everything was falling into place.
Then came the 24th of January.
—
## The fall in the tiltyard
Henry was forty-four, heavier than he had been, and still determined to joust.
The tiltyard at Greenwich was one of the finest in England.
Two riders in armor charged at each other along a wooden barrier, the tilt, each trying to break his lance against the other man.
The lances were long and heavy, the horses were big warhorses, and at full gallop a clean strike landed with tremendous force.
Henry wore a full suit of tournament armor made for his large body, and his horse was armored too.
He had jousted since he was a young man, and he had been very good at it: strong, aggressive and fearless.
But he was no longer twenty.
That day, the king and his horse went down together, hard.
Accounts differ about what happened next.
Chapuys wrote that it was thought a miracle the king had not been killed.
Other English reports played the fall down.
A report that reached Rome through the Emperor’s ambassador there, Dr. Pedro Ortiz, said that the French had heard the king lay for two hours without speaking.
Whether he really was unconscious for so long, nobody can be sure, and the story came at second or third hand.
But the historian Suzannah Lipscomb has argued that the weight of the armored man, the weight of the armored horse, and the speed of the charge would have made it a very serious accident.
Henry did not joust in a tournament again.
The sport he had loved all his adult life was over for him.
Some historians have wondered whether the fall, perhaps through a head injury or the worsening of his leg wounds, changed him in other ways too.
That idea is a theory, not a fact, but many people who study his life take it seriously.
—
## The 29th of January
Five days later, in her rooms at Greenwich, Anne Boleyn miscarried.
The child was a boy.
Chapuys wrote that it had seemed to be a male child of about three and a half months, and that the queen had lost it with some danger to herself.
Anne is reported to have blamed the shock of hearing about the king’s fall.
There is a detail in this story that almost seems too cruel to be true, but it is.
On the very same day, the 29th of January, Catherine of Aragon was buried in Peterborough Abbey.
The old queen went into the ground on the day the new queen lost the son who would have made her untouchable.
Henry’s response, as Chapuys heard it, was cold.
He is reported to have told Anne, in one version, that he could see God did not wish to give him male children, and in another, that she would have no more boys by him.
The words differ, but their meaning does not.
He had said much the same about Catherine before he discarded her.
Anne knew what that meant.
—
## A quiet rival
There is another story about that miscarriage, though it comes from a much later source.
Jane Dormer, who served Henry’s daughter Mary and later became Duchess of Feria, passed down a tale that Anne had walked into a room and found one of her own ladies sitting on the king’s knee.
The lady was Jane Seymour.
The story was written down decades afterward, by people who had good reason to dislike Anne, and it may be no more than gossip.
But the rivalry was real.
Jane was the daughter of Sir John Seymour of Wolf Hall in Wiltshire, from a large gentry family.
She was in her late twenties.
She had served Catherine of Aragon and then Anne, and she had watched from inside the queen’s household as one queen replaced another.
She was quiet where Anne was quick, gentle where Anne was sharp, and deferential where Anne argued.
Her family and their friends, among them her brother Edward Seymour and the courtier Sir Nicholas Carew, encouraged her and advised her.
By February, Chapuys was reporting that the king had been sending her gifts.
Later that spring, when Henry sent Jane a purse of money and a letter, she is said to have kissed the letter, returned it unopened, and knelt to ask the messenger to tell the king she was a gentlewoman of good family, and that her honor was the greatest treasure she had.
If he wanted to give her money, she said, let him do it when God sent her a good marriage.
It was a performance, and a brilliant one.
It made her everything Henry no longer associated with Anne.
Think how fast it had all moved.
On New Year’s Day, Anne was queen, pregnant, and presiding over one of the richest gift exchanges in Europe.
By the end of January, she had lost her son, lost much of her husband’s warmth, and gained a rival who was already receiving presents from the king.
Four weeks.
That was all it took for the ground to shift under her feet.
—
## Spring
Once the fall began, it did not stop.
In April, Chapuys found himself maneuvered into publicly bowing to Anne at mass, an act that looked like the Emperor’s recognition of her as queen, at the very moment her power was slipping away.
On the 30th of April, a young court musician, Mark Smeaton, was arrested.
He confessed to adultery with the queen, possibly under threat or torture; we do not know what was done to him.
On the 1st of May, Henry watched the May Day jousts at Greenwich with Anne.
In the middle of the day, he got up and left without warning.
He rode back toward London with a small company, and on the way he questioned Henry Norris.
Over the next days, the arrests spread through the court.
Anne was arrested at Greenwich on the 2nd of May and taken by barge up the Thames to the Tower of London.
Her brother George was arrested the same day.
Norris was already a prisoner.
Sir Francis Weston and William Brereton followed.
The poet Sir Thomas Wyatt, who may once have admired Anne himself, was also sent to the Tower, though he was later released.
The charges named dates and places for each supposed meeting.
Most modern historians reject them as invented, put together to give the king a legal way out of a marriage that had not produced a son.
Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, is usually seen as the man who assembled the case, though historians still argue about who drove it, and why.
In May 1536, the truth did not matter.
The machinery needed only the accusation.
On the 12th of May, Norris, Weston, Brereton and Smeaton were tried and condemned.
On the 15th of May, Anne and George were tried inside the Tower, before a court of peers.
On the 17th of May, George Boleyn and the four other men were beheaded on Tower Hill.
On the 19th of May, Anne Boleyn was put to death inside the walls of the Tower, by an expert swordsman brought over from Calais, the one concession Henry made to the woman who had once been the center of his world.
On the 30th of May, eleven days later, Henry married Jane Seymour.
—
## A roll that reads like a list of the dead
The gift roll for New Year’s Day, 1536, is lost.
If it had survived, it would read like a list of the condemned.
Henry Norris, who gave and received gifts that season, beheaded.
George Boleyn, the queen’s brother, beheaded.
Anne Boleyn, who presided over her own exchange as queen, beheaded.
Mark Smeaton, who may well have played for the court through those twelve days, beheaded.
Francis Weston and William Brereton, both familiar faces in the king’s rooms, beheaded.
Only the king went on.
He moved on, as he always did, to a new wife, a new set of hopes, and a new version of the future, one that required erasing the woman who had stood beside him that morning.
The following winter, the Thames froze so hard that Henry and his new queen, Jane, rode across the ice to keep Christmas at Greenwich.
The palace was the same.
The queen was not.
—
## The face of the king
Look at the portraits that Hans Holbein painted of Henry around 1536 and 1537, and you see a man who has already changed.
He is broader.
His face is harder.
He stands with his legs planted wide, his hands at his belt, and he stares straight out of the picture.
The athletic young prince who had charged down the tiltyard at Greenwich is gone.
In his place is the Henry most people picture today: the wide stance, the cold eyes, and the wives who keep disappearing.
But on New Year’s Day, 1536, that change was not complete.
For one morning, at least, the candles were burning, the gifts were being carried in, and a queen who had fought for years to wear her crown was still wearing it.
She had about twenty weeks left.
—
## What the gifts were worth
Almost all of those gifts are gone now.
The gilt cups were melted down for their metal.
The embroidered shirts wore out.
The perfume balls were emptied, and the gold basins were reworked into something else for someone else.
But the gift rolls that do survive, from other years of Henry’s reign, still tell us who was in the room, what they brought, and what the king thought they were worth.
They are one of the most detailed records of power, and of fear, that the Tudor age left behind.
In 1536, every name on that roll was a wager.
It was a bet on which side of the king’s favor you would land on by the end of the year.
Some of those bets paid off.
The people who moved toward Jane Seymour early, who saw which way the wind was turning, rose with her family.
The people who stayed loyal to Anne, or who simply stood too close to her, paid with their lives.
New Year’s Day at the court of Henry VIII was never just a party.
It was a performance, a negotiation and a gamble, wrapped in velvet and served on gold plate.
And in 1536, the stakes were higher than anyone in that room could have known.