News

1533: What Was Life Like for Mary Tudor After Henry VIII Declared Her a Bastard

It is the late summer of 1533, and a seventeen-year-old girl is sitting in a room full of things that used to mean something.

The furniture is the same.

The tapestries are the same.

The ladies who wait on her are, for now, the same.

But the word that everyone used to put in front of her name is gone.

A few months ago she was the Princess Mary, the only living child of King Henry VIII and Queen Catherine of Aragon, the girl that ambassadors bowed to and emperors had been promised.

Now nobody is quite sure what to call her.

And the man who has done this to her is her own father.

Before the year is out, she will be packed off to a house in Hertfordshire and told that her place there is to wait upon a baby, the newborn half-sister who has just been given everything that once belonged to her.

Her name is Mary Tudor.

To understand how far she was about to fall, you have to see how high she started.

—

## The greatest pearl in the kingdom

Mary was born on February 18, 1516, at the Palace of Placentia in Greenwich, the riverside palace where her father himself had been born.

Her mother, Catherine of Aragon, was a daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain, a princess who had come to England as a teenager to marry into the young Tudor dynasty.

Catherine’s road to motherhood had been brutal.

There had been stillbirths.

There had been a son, Prince Henry, who lived for less than two months in 1511 and was mourned by the whole court.

There had been other babies who did not survive.

Mary was the one who lived.

That made her precious, and not only in the way any child is precious to her parents.

She was the heir.

Henry, who would later do so much damage to her, adored her in those early years.

He showed her off to foreign envoys.

He is said to have called her the greatest pearl in his kingdom.

She was a gifted child.

When she was only four, she played the virginals for a visiting French delegation, and the visitors went home impressed.

She learned Latin young, read it well, and spoke French.

She could follow Spanish, her mother’s language, and in time she understood Italian too.

Her education was taken seriously in a way that was unusual even for princesses.

The Spanish humanist Juan Luis Vives, a scholar her mother admired, dedicated his famous book on the education of a Christian woman to Catherine in 1523, and that same year he drew up a separate plan of study for Mary herself.

It was demanding work: Latin authors, the Bible, the Church Fathers, history, moral philosophy.

Mary was bright, disciplined, and serious.

And Catherine, deeply devout and fiercely protective, raised her to understand that being a princess was not a decoration.

It was a duty.

It was also, whether anyone said it aloud or not, a bargaining chip.

—

## A piece on the chessboard

Mary was barely walking when she was first put up for sale on the marriage market of Europe.

In 1518, at the age of two, she was betrothed to the Dauphin of France, the infant son of King Francis I.

That alliance fell apart within a few years.

In 1521, when Mary was about six, a new match was agreed: she would marry her own cousin, the Emperor Charles V, who was then in his early twenties and already the most powerful ruler in Christendom.

Charles wanted the bride sent to Spain and a large dowry paid in advance.

Henry did not send her.

In 1526, Charles gave up waiting and married Isabella of Portugal, a grown woman who could give him heirs at once.

Two engagements, two disappointments, and Mary was only ten.

But even the failures proved something.

Mary Tudor was a prize that the greatest powers in Europe were willing to bargain for.

—

## The princess of the Welsh border

In 1525, when Mary was nine, Henry sent her west to Ludlow Castle, in the Welsh Marches.

It was a move heavy with meaning.

Ludlow was where the Princes of Wales had been sent to learn how to rule.

Mary’s uncle Arthur had lived there with his young bride, Catherine of Aragon, before his early death.

Now Mary went with a household of her own and a council to govern the region in her name.

She was never formally created Princess of Wales.

But that is what people called her, and that is how she was treated.

Her household was run by Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury, a woman of royal Plantagenet blood and one of the great ladies of England.

Mary came to love her almost as a second mother.

For about a year and a half, Mary lived on the border, continued her lessons, received visitors, and learned what it looked like to keep a court.

She was far from London.

And that was probably a mercy, because in London, something was changing.

—

## The king wants a son

Her father had fallen in love.

The woman was Anne Boleyn, one of Queen Catherine’s own ladies-in-waiting, clever, sharp-tongued, and in no hurry to become just another royal mistress.

When Mary came back to court, the air had changed.

Henry wanted a son.

He had always wanted a son.

The Tudor claim to the throne was barely two generations old.

It had been won on a battlefield by Henry’s father in 1485, and to Henry the whole dynasty felt fragile without a male heir to carry it on.

By the late 1520s, Catherine was past forty, and it was clear that there would be no more children.

She had been pregnant at least six times.

Only Mary had survived.

For Henry, one daughter was not enough.

He talked himself into believing that his marriage was cursed.

Catherine had been married, briefly, to his older brother Arthur before Arthur died at fifteen.

A verse in the Book of Leviticus warned that a man who took his brother’s wife would be childless.

Henry decided that this was what had happened to him.

The dead babies, he told himself, were God’s verdict.

He wanted the pope to declare the marriage void so that he could marry Anne, who was young and might give him the son he was desperate for.

The pope would not do it.

Catherine’s nephew was Charles V, the same emperor who had once been engaged to Mary, and in those years the pope was in no position to humiliate the emperor’s aunt.

So Henry did something that would change England forever.

He began to break with Rome.

—

## The ruling at Dunstable

It happened in stages.

In early 1533, Parliament passed an act that stopped appeals in cases like Henry’s from going to Rome.

That spring, Thomas Cranmer, a scholar Henry trusted to give him the answer he wanted, was consecrated as Archbishop of Canterbury.

Cranmer gave him exactly that answer.

On May 23, 1533, sitting in a special court at Dunstable, he declared that Henry’s marriage to Catherine had never been valid.

A few days later, he declared Henry’s marriage to Anne Boleyn good.

Henry had already married Anne in secret earlier that year.

She was pregnant.

On June 1, 1533, she was crowned Queen of England in Westminster Abbey.

The full legal machinery came after.

The Act of Succession, which settled the crown on Anne’s children and required people to swear an oath to it, passed in the spring of 1534.

The Act of Supremacy, which declared Henry Supreme Head of the Church of England, followed late that same year.

But the damage was done in that summer of 1533.

Catherine of Aragon was now, officially, only the Princess Dowager, the widow of Prince Arthur.

She refused the title.

She would go on calling herself queen and signing her letters as queen until the day she died.

And Mary, the daughter of a marriage that had just been declared invalid, was no longer legitimate.

She was the Lady Mary now.

In the language of the age, she was the king’s bastard.

She was seventeen years old.

Think about that for a moment.

For seventeen years, this girl had been raised to rule.

She had been taught as a future queen, bowed to, and betrothed to princes and emperors.

And then, because her father wanted a different wife, all of it was taken away.

Not gradually.

Not gently.

And the cruelest part had not even begun.

—

## A sister in the cradle

On September 7, 1533, at Greenwich, the palace where Mary herself had been born, Anne Boleyn gave birth to a daughter.

The baby was named Elizabeth.

She was proclaimed princess at once, the heir to the throne.

Henry had wanted a son, and the disappointment was bitter.

But the child was still his heir, and the position Mary had held her whole life now belonged to a baby in a cradle.

Mary was ordered to stop calling herself princess.

She refused.

Then the king went further.

In December 1533, Mary’s own household was broken up.

Her servants were dismissed.

Margaret Pole, the countess who had been her governess and her second mother, was sent away.

According to the imperial ambassador, the countess offered to go on serving Mary at her own expense, and was refused.

Then came the order that must have felt like a blade.

Mary was sent to Hatfield, in Hertfordshire, where the baby Elizabeth had just been settled with a royal household of her own.

Mary was not going as a guest.

She was going as part of her sister’s household, to wait on the princess.

A baby who, in Mary’s eyes, was the child of the woman who had wrecked her mother’s marriage and stolen her own inheritance.

—

## The Sheltons of Hatfield

The household at Hatfield was run by Sir John Shelton and his wife, Lady Anne Shelton.

Lady Shelton was Anne Boleyn’s aunt, the sister of the queen’s father.

There was no doubt where her loyalty lay.

Mary had one constant friend in these years, and he was not English.

Eustace Chapuys was the ambassador of the Emperor Charles V in London, and he wrote long, frank dispatches home about everything that happened to the emperor’s young cousin.

Much of what we know about Mary at Hatfield comes from him.

According to what Chapuys heard, when Anne Boleyn learned that Mary still refused to give Elizabeth the title of princess, she told Lady Shelton to box Mary’s ears, as the cursed bastard she was, if she went on using the name herself.

Mary answered with the kind of defiance that would define these years.

She said she knew of no princess in England but herself.

That one line tells you who Mary Tudor was at seventeen.

Proud.

Stubborn.

Completely certain she was right.

And that certainty made her life very much harder.

Because Henry VIII did not tolerate defiance.

Not from bishops.

Not from ministers.

Not from his own child.

—

## The rooms below

Life at Hatfield seemed designed to wear her down.

The baby lived in the best rooms.

One modern historian of the royal palaces has suggested that Mary was lodged in lesser rooms, either beneath her sister’s apartments or in a range set aside for guests of lower rank.

The exact rooms cannot be proven, but the message was plain to everyone.

The child who had replaced her slept in state.

Mary did not.

At meals, the fight went on.

Mary refused to give way to her little sister in the order of precedence, and the household made sure she understood her place in it.

She could not move freely.

Her letters were watched.

The people who might have comforted her were kept away.

When Henry himself came to Hatfield to visit Elizabeth, Mary was kept out of his sight.

There is a story, reported at the time, that on one of those visits Mary went up onto a terrace at the top of the house and watched her father prepare to ride away.

She knelt there, with her hands together.

Henry looked up, saw her, bowed, and touched his hat.

His gentlemen did the same.

That was all.

A bow from a distance, from the father who had once carried her in his arms to show her off to ambassadors.

Every time the household moved from one house to another, which royal households did all the time, there was a new battle over whether Mary would ride ahead of her sister, or behind, and whether she would give the baby the honors due to a princess.

Mary would not bend.

She would not call Elizabeth princess.

She would not call Anne Boleyn queen.

She would not say her mother’s marriage had been false.

—

## The cost of saying no

The price of that refusal was paid in her body.

Mary fell ill again and again.

She suffered from headaches, from pains in her stomach, from what her contemporaries called melancholy, a deep low sadness that would follow her for the rest of her life.

Her physicians believed her suffering was made worse by the way she was being treated.

At one point she became so ill that there were whispers at court that she was being poisoned.

There is no proof of that.

But the fear was real enough that Chapuys reported it, and the king allowed her to be moved and cared for until she recovered.

The pattern repeated itself.

Illness.

A slow, partial recovery.

Then another blow.

Some at court were afraid she would not survive Hatfield, and there were dark whispers that, if she did not, it might not be an accident.

Through all of it, Henry would not see her.

Mary wrote to him.

She asked for his blessing.

She asked to be allowed to come to him.

The answer was always the same.

She could come back into his favor on one condition: that she accept she was not his lawful daughter, and that her mother had never been his wife.

That was the one thing she would not do.

—

## A sieve on the sea

Chapuys became her adviser, her advocate, and in many ways her only friend.

He pressed her case with the king’s council.

He wrote to Thomas Cromwell, Henry’s chief minister.

He sent blunt, alarmed reports to the emperor.

In one dispatch he described how desperately Mary wanted to get out of England.

He wrote that her longing to escape was so great that if he told her to cross the sea in a sieve, she would do it.

By 1535 the ambassador was worried enough to start planning exactly that.

The scheme, as it was discussed, was to give the women who watched Mary a sleeping draught, slip her out of the house at night, and carry her to the coast, where a ship would take her across the Channel to the emperor’s lands.

Mary, by every account, was willing.

But Charles V would not commit to it.

He would write firm letters.

He would let his ambassador protest.

He would not risk open war with England over a cousin.

So Mary stayed.

Trapped in a country that had declared her a bastard, watched by people loyal to the woman she blamed for all of it.

And then came the blow that nearly broke her.

—

## The mother she could not see

On January 7, 1536, Catherine of Aragon died at Kimbolton Castle, in Huntingdonshire, on the edge of the fen country.

She was fifty years old.

She had spent her last years moved from one damp, remote house to another, with a reduced household, still refusing any title but queen.

She had been seriously ill for weeks.

She could barely eat.

She could barely sleep.

At the turn of the year, Chapuys was finally allowed to ride to Kimbolton.

He stayed several days, and sat with her every afternoon, talking with her for hours, trying to lift her spirits.

The woman he found was a shadow of the proud queen he had served for years.

She died at about two o’clock in the afternoon, on a Friday.

When her body was prepared for burial, the man who did the work reported that everything inside her looked healthy except her heart, which he found black and hideous to see.

Chapuys believed she had been poisoned.

Modern doctors who have looked at the description think a cancer of the heart is far more likely.

But for Mary, there was a worse fact than any rumor.

She had not been there.

Mary had begged to be allowed to visit her mother during her illness.

Henry refused.

He had kept mother and daughter apart since 1531, when Mary was fifteen.

In almost five years, they never saw each other again.

Catherine died without her daughter at her bedside.

The news reached Mary at Hatfield.

She was devastated.

Whatever had held her together through the years of isolation, this tore it.

The person she loved most in the world was gone, and she had not even been allowed to say goodbye.

—

## The fall of Anne Boleyn

You might expect Catherine’s death to soften Henry toward his daughter.

With Catherine gone, there was no rival queen anymore, no argument about which wife was the real one.

Henry did not soften.

And then, four months later, the world turned upside down.

On May 2, 1536, Anne Boleyn was arrested and taken to the Tower of London.

The charges were staggering: adultery with five men, one of them her own brother, and plotting against the king’s life.

Whether any of it was true is still argued over by historians.

Most think it was not.

But the trials were fast, and the verdicts were never in doubt.

On May 19, 1536, Anne Boleyn was beheaded within the Tower.

She was in her early-to-middle thirties.

The woman Mary had blamed for every misery of the last three years was gone.

Mary let herself hope.

Surely, now, her father would take her back.

She wrote to Thomas Cromwell, asking him to speak for her.

She asked permission to write to the king.

She wanted, more than anything, to be his daughter again.

On May 30, eleven days after Anne’s death, Henry married Jane Seymour.

Jane was gentle, Catholic in her sympathies, and kind to Mary.

She seems to have pleaded for her.

Things seemed to be turning.

But Henry was not finished.

—

## The two conditions

Even with Anne Boleyn dead, the king had not changed his mind about one thing.

Before he would receive his daughter, she had to accept two things.

She had to acknowledge that her parents’ marriage had been unlawful from the beginning.

And she had to accept him as Supreme Head of the Church of England, rejecting the authority of the pope.

For Mary, these were not small requests.

For three years she had refused exactly this.

She had endured isolation, illness, and the death of her mother rather than betray Catherine’s memory.

To sign would mean saying that her mother had been wrong all her life, that her own birth was shameful, and that her faith came second to her father’s politics.

She refused again.

This time, the danger was real.

—

## The visit in June

In mid-June 1536, a deputation from the king’s council came to see her.

Among them were Thomas Howard, Duke of Norfolk, Robert Radcliffe, Earl of Sussex, and Richard Sampson, Bishop of Chichester.

They did not come to persuade.

They came to frighten her.

The scene is known from the dispatch that Chapuys sent to the emperor at the beginning of July.

He wrote that the councillors told Mary she was an unnatural daughter, so disobedient that one of them said he could hardly believe she was the king’s child at all.

And then one of them went further.

The ambassador’s report has him saying that were she his daughter, or any other man’s, he would beat her to death, or strike her head against the wall until he made it as soft as a boiled apple.

They called her a traitress.

They said she would be punished as one.

Chapuys does not say which of the men spoke those words.

Later writers have often put them in Norfolk’s mouth, but the ambassador wrote only that it was one of them.

This was not idle talk from a minor official.

These were some of the most powerful men in England, speaking for the king.

Mary was twenty years old.

—

## The night she broke

The danger did not stop at words.

At court, the men who had spoken up for Mary found themselves questioned and threatened.

Judges were asked whether she could be proceeded against if she continued to refuse.

There was real fear that Henry might go all the way.

Chapuys heard the rumors and was terrified for her.

He sent Mary his advice.

Sign, he told her.

Save your life.

God looks more at the intention than at the deed.

Cromwell, too, wrote to her, half angry and half desperate, warning her that she was ruining herself and anyone who had tried to help her.

He sent her a document to copy.

Around June 22, 1536, after three years of holding out, Mary gave in.

She signed.

The submission had been drafted for her, carefully worded to cover every point the king demanded.

In it she acknowledged her father as Supreme Head of the Church of England under Christ.

She rejected what it called the pretended authority of the Bishop of Rome.

And she acknowledged that the marriage between her father and her mother had been, by God’s law and man’s law, incestuous and unlawful.

Later accounts say she signed without reading it through.

Whether that is true or not, the words were never hers.

She had put her name to the opposite of everything her mother had died believing.

It must have felt like swallowing poison.

But the alternative may well have been the Tower.

—

## Coming home

The submission worked.

In early July 1536, Mary was brought to see her father and his new queen.

For the first time in about five years, she stood in front of the king.

Henry was warm.

Jane Seymour was kind.

Mary was given gifts, money, a household of her own, and a place again near the court.

It was not the same as being called princess.

It would never be that again in her father’s lifetime.

But after years at Hatfield, it was something close to a family.

And then Mary did something remarkable.

Elizabeth, not yet three, had now been declared illegitimate too, after her mother’s fall.

She was motherless, demoted, and in the very same position Mary had been in three years before.

A different person might have enjoyed that reversal.

Mary chose kindness.

In a letter to her father that July, she wrote that her sister Elizabeth was in good health, and such a child toward as she did not doubt the king would have cause to rejoice of in time to come.

It is one of the most generous lines in all of Tudor history, written by a young woman who had every reason to hate the child she had been made to serve.

Whatever Mary felt about Anne Boleyn, she did not take it out on Anne’s daughter.

—

## She never forgot

But Mary never forgot.

She never forgave the people who had put her through those years, and she never truly accepted what she had been forced to sign.

When she became Queen Mary I in 1553, one of the first acts of her first Parliament declared that her parents’ marriage had been valid all along.

She undid what her father had forced her to say.

She restored the Catholic Church in England.

And Thomas Cranmer, the archbishop who had ruled her parents’ marriage void at Dunstable, was tried for heresy and burned at Oxford in March 1556, almost twenty-three years after that ruling.

That burning, and the hundreds of Protestants who went to the fire during her reign, are why later Protestant writers gave her the name Bloody Mary.

The name stuck.

But if you have followed her story from the beginning, from the greatest pearl in the kingdom to the teenager made to serve her baby sister at Hatfield, through the years of silence and sickness, the death of her mother without a goodbye, the threat about the wall and the boiled apple, and the submission that broke something inside her, then you see the woman who took the throne in 1553 a little differently.

She was not simply cruel.

She was someone who had spent twenty years watching her world taken apart piece by piece, by people who told her it was all for the best.

The years between 1533 and 1536 made Mary Tudor who she became.

They taught her that power could be taken away in an afternoon.

They taught her that even a father’s love came with conditions.

And they taught her that the only thing she could control was whether or not she would break.

She broke once, on paper, because they left her no other choice.

She carried the memory of it for the rest of her life.

A line often attributed to her, though its exact origin is hard to trace, has her calling herself the most unhappy lady in Christendom.

Whoever first wrote those words down, in the years at Hatfield they were probably true.

She was a princess living as a servant, a daughter whose father would not see her, a Catholic in a country that had just turned its back on Rome, and a young woman whose only crime was being born to the wrong wife at the wrong time.

History mostly remembers her for what she did with power.

But the years that made her were the years when she had none at all.

You Might Also Enjoy