1526: What Was It Like to Be Chosen by Henry VIII at Court
The crowd on Tower Hill had seen this many times before, but not with this man.
It was March 3, 1539, a cold, raw morning at the very start of spring.
The scaffold stood on the open ground outside the moat of the Tower of London, a wooden platform raised high enough for everyone to see.
Thousands of Londoners had come.
They had come because the man being led up the steps was famous.
For thirty years he had been one of the most glamorous figures at the court of Henry VIII.
He had ridden in the king’s tournaments in gilded armor.
He had danced in the king’s masques, carried the king’s messages to the emperor and the king of France, and run the king’s stables as master of the horse.
He wore, or had worn until a few weeks before, the blue garter of England’s highest order of knighthood.
Holbein had painted him in armor, with a feather in his cap and a baton in his hand, looking every inch the king’s champion.
And he had known Henry VIII longer than almost anyone alive.
His name was Sir Nicholas Carew.
He had been sent to grow up in Henry’s household when he was six years old.
He had been the young prince’s playmate, then the young king’s jousting partner, then one of the handful of men allowed to touch the king’s body and hand him his shirt in the morning.
Henry had given him his own tiltyard at Greenwich, a private arena for the sport they both loved.
Now Henry had sent him here.
He had been convicted of treason, on the evidence of letters and conversations, in a trial that lasted a single day.
Among the men who had sat in judgment on him was a man who knew him better than almost any of them.
His own wife’s brother.
Before he knelt, Carew spoke to the crowd.
What he said surprised everyone who had known him.
And what happened afterward to the house he loved, the garden where he had grown up, and the son who carried his name, is one of the strangest footnotes in the whole history of Henry VIII’s court.
But first, you have to understand what it meant to be chosen by Henry VIII.
—
## A six-year-old in the prince’s household
Nicholas Carew was born around 1496 at Beddington, in Surrey, south of London.
His family was old and well-connected.
His father, Sir Richard Carew, was a soldier and courtier who would later serve as lieutenant of Calais.
His mother was Malyn Oxenbridge, from a Sussex family.
The Carews had lived at Beddington for generations, in a manor house surrounded by fields and woods, close enough to London to be at court in a day’s ride.
When Nicholas was about six, his family did what ambitious families of the time did with promising sons.
They found him a place in a great household.
And the household they found was the best one possible.
He was placed in the household of the young Prince Henry, Duke of York, the second son of Henry VII.
Henry was about eleven.
His elder brother Arthur had just died, and the boy who had been raised as a spare was suddenly the heir to the throne.
The little group of boys around him shared his lessons, his games, his riding, his archery and his first attempts at the joust.
Nicholas Carew was the youngest of them, five years younger than the prince.
He grew up as the prince grew up.
He learned the same Latin, the same French, the same music, the same manners.
He learned, above all, how to be close to Henry.
That was a skill in itself.
Henry as a boy was clever, physical, demanding, charming and quick to sulk.
He liked people who could keep up with him, make him laugh, and lose to him gracefully when it mattered.
Carew, by every sign, was very good at all of this.
When the prince became King Henry VIII in 1509, at the age of seventeen, the boys who had grown up with him became the young men of his court.
Carew was thirteen.
He was not yet one of the inner circle, but he was close, and he was growing up fast.
—
## The young man who could not be knocked off a horse
The early court of Henry VIII was a court of games.
The new king was tall, strong, handsome and almost unbelievably energetic.
He hunted until he had worn out eight or ten horses in a day.
He played tennis, wrestled, shot, danced and sang.
And above all, he jousted.
The joust was the great sport of kings in the early sixteenth century.
Two armored riders charged at each other down a long lane divided by a barrier called the tilt, each trying to break his lance on the other’s body or helmet, or to knock him from the saddle.
It was spectacular, expensive and dangerous.
Men were badly hurt.
Some were killed.
Henry loved it more than anything, and he wanted to be surrounded by men who were good at it.
Carew was more than good.
He became famous for his fearlessness in the lists.
In the tournaments of Henry’s first years, he rode among the king’s own team of challengers, dressed in the costumes and colors that made every royal joust a piece of theater.
The king noticed.
By 1515, Henry had given him something no other courtier had.
His own tiltyard at Greenwich.
It was a private jousting arena, at the king’s favorite palace, for one man.
It was the Tudor equivalent of a king building his best friend a private stadium.
Greenwich was the center of that world.
The palace stood on the south bank of the Thames, downriver from London, and Henry had turned its grounds into a sporting complex.
There was a great tiltyard with tall viewing towers at the side, where the queen and her ladies and the ambassadors sat to watch.
There were stables, an armory where the king’s own armorers hammered out new harnesses, and open ground for hunting and hawking just beyond the walls.
On tournament days, the whole court turned out.
Trumpets sounded.
Heralds announced the challengers and their invented romantic names.
Riders came into the lists in costumes of cloth of gold, their horses draped in embroidered trappers, their helmets crested with plumes.
Then the charges began, the thunder of hooves down the tilt, the crack of lances breaking, the roar of the crowd.
It was not a safe game.
In March 1524, the king himself rode a course against his brother-in-law, the Duke of Suffolk, and forgot to lower his visor.
Suffolk’s lance struck the king’s helmet just above the eye and shattered, filling the open helmet with splinters.
Henry was unhurt, and insisted on riding six more courses to prove it.
Everyone watching knew how close the kingdom had come to losing its king on a sunny afternoon at a sporting event.
Carew rode in those lists for years.
He was never seriously hurt.
He was very good.
Carew married well too.
Around 1514, he married Elizabeth Bryan, daughter of Sir Thomas Bryan and of Margaret Bryan, the lady who would later run the nurseries of the king’s children.
Elizabeth was one of the beauties of the court.
Her brother, Francis Bryan, was another of the king’s young companions, a reckless, witty, hard-drinking courtier who lost an eye in a jousting accident and wore a patch for the rest of his life.
The two young men were brothers-in-law and friends.
It was a small world, and everyone in it was very close to the king.
—
## The night the king’s friends threw eggs in Paris
In 1518, a group of the king’s young companions traveled to France as part of a diplomatic mission.
They were supposed to be representing England.
They seem to have treated the trip as a party.
The chronicler Edward Hall, who disapproved, later wrote that they rode through the streets of Paris in disguise with the French king, Francis I, throwing eggs, stones and other foolish trifles at the people.
When they came home, Hall says, they were all French in eating, drinking and clothing, and in French vices too.
They mocked the English court and everything English.
The king’s council had had enough.
The older men around Henry, and especially his chief minister, Cardinal Thomas Wolsey, did not like the influence these young favorites had over the king.
They were too close to him.
They whispered in his ear at cards and on horseback.
They could undo in an evening what the council had arranged over weeks.
In May 1519, the council persuaded the king to remove them.
The so-called minions were expelled from the privy chamber and sent away from court.
Carew was sent to Calais, to command a fort called Ruysbank, guarding the approach to the harbor.
It was a polite exile.
It did not last long.
The king missed his friends.
Within a few months, Carew was back.
Being close to Henry was not only about jousting.
The king’s evenings were full of music, and Henry himself was a gifted musician who played the lute, the organ and the virginals and wrote songs; the most famous of them, “Pastime with Good Company,” is still sung today.
There were masques, where the king and his friends appeared in disguise and danced with the ladies until they unmasked.
There were banquets with dozens of dishes, where sugar sculptures called subtleties were carried in between the courses: castles, ships, animals, all made of sugar paste.
The men who were good company at all of these things were the men the king wanted around him.
Carew was one of the best.
He was at the Field of the Cloth of Gold in 1520, the vast summit in northern France where Henry VIII and Francis I met in tents of golden fabric and tried to outdo each other in jousting, feasting and display.
It was there, according to a French account, that Henry challenged Francis to a wrestling match and was thrown.
The English party did not enjoy that story.
Carew rode in the English team in the great tournament held over those weeks, among the very best of the king’s jousters.
In 1522 he was appointed master of the horse, in charge of the king’s stables, studs and horses, one of the great offices of the household.
He held it for the rest of his life.
The lesson of 1519 was clear to anyone paying attention.
Henry’s council could remove his friends.
But only Henry could decide whether they stayed away.
—
## A morning in the privy chamber
To understand how much a man like Carew mattered, you have to understand the privy chamber, and the strange rules that governed it.
In 1526, Cardinal Wolsey drew up a long set of regulations for the king’s household, known as the Eltham Ordinances because they were issued at Eltham Palace.
On paper, they were about order and economy.
The king’s household had grown huge and expensive, with crowds of hangers-on following the court everywhere and eating at the king’s cost.
The ordinances set out who could serve, where they could eat, how much bread, wine, candles and firewood each person was entitled to.
But they also did something political.
They cut down the number of gentlemen allowed in the privy chamber, the king’s private rooms, and fixed exactly who they would be.
The men who lost their places were, not by coincidence, men whose influence with the king Wolsey could not control.
Inside the privy chamber, life ran to a strict routine.
Pages rose early, around seven, to light the fire and sweep the rooms.
The gentlemen had to be in place before the king woke.
Only a small group of named gentlemen were allowed to touch the king’s body to dress him, and the ordinances specified that they should put on his clothes reverently and discreetly.
Others could warm a garment by the fire or hand it to them, but nothing more.
The king’s barber had to be present every morning, with his water, his cloths and his instruments ready.
Gentlemen slept in the room next to the king’s bedchamber.
Two of them sat at his feet while he ate.
They carried his cloak, held his basin, read to him, played cards with him and listened to him.
And at the center of it all was the groom of the stool.
The title sounds like a joke, and in a way it was one.
The groom of the stool attended the king in his privy, his close stool, the padded box that served as his toilet.
But because he was with the king at his most private moments, and because he controlled access to the king’s innermost rooms, his papers and his private money, he became one of the most powerful men at court.
In 1526, the groom of the stool was Sir Henry Norris, a quiet, charming man who was trusted by almost everyone.
To be one of those few men was to have something more valuable than land or titles.
It was access.
Every petition, every complaint, every bribe and every request in the kingdom ultimately needed to reach the king’s ear, and the men of the privy chamber were the ones standing next to it.
Carew had lived in that world since he was a boy.
He understood its rules better than almost anyone.
He also understood its dangers.
Every man in the privy chamber knew that the king’s favor was personal.
It could be given in a morning.
It could be taken away just as fast.
—
## The man in Holbein’s armor
By the early 1530s, Carew was at the height of his career.
He was master of the horse.
He was sent abroad as an ambassador, to the court of Francis I in France and to the emperor Charles V, and in 1530 he was in Bologna when the pope crowned Charles as Holy Roman Emperor.
He was rich, admired, and close to the king.
Around 1532 or 1533, Hans Holbein the Younger, the German painter who was becoming the great portraitist of the English court, painted him.
The portrait still exists.
It shows Carew at about thirty-six, in a full suit of dark, gleaming armor.
He wears a black cap with a large white feather and a jewel, over a gold-embroidered coif that covers his hair.
His beard is reddish brown and neatly trimmed.
His face is long, thin and alert, the eyes looking off to the side as if he is watching something across a tiltyard.
In one hand he holds a long baton, the symbol of command.
His other hand rests on the hilt of his sword.
It is the image of a man who expects to be remembered as a soldier and a champion.
Holbein also made a chalk drawing of him, preparing for the painting.
In the drawing, without the armor and the color, he looks a little older and more tired.
Both images are of a man who had spent thirty years winning the king’s games.
He did not know that the most dangerous game of all was just beginning.
—
## The friend who chose a side
In the late 1520s, Henry VIII fell in love with Anne Boleyn and decided that his marriage to Catherine of Aragon had never been valid.
The court split.
Some men backed Anne, and rose with her.
Others stayed loyal, quietly or openly, to Catherine and to her daughter Mary.
Nicholas Carew was one of the second group.
He was conservative in religion, attached to the old church, and he seems to have felt real loyalty to Catherine and real affection for Princess Mary.
He did not oppose the king openly.
Nobody who wanted to live did that.
But he did not love Anne Boleyn, and Anne did not love him.
By the start of 1536, everything had changed.
Catherine of Aragon died in January.
Anne miscarried a son the same month.
And the king’s eye had fallen on one of Anne’s ladies, a quiet, fair young woman named Jane Seymour.
The imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, who reported everything, wrote that Jane was being carefully advised by the people at court who hated Anne.
One of the men he named as her adviser was Carew.
According to these reports, Carew and others coached Jane on how to behave with the king: to be modest, to refuse his gifts of money, to speak well of Princess Mary, and to say nothing that could be held against her.
Whether Carew was really pulling strings, or Chapuys was exaggerating his friends’ influence, it is clear which side he was on.
In April 1536, the Order of the Garter met to fill a vacant place among its knights.
Anne Boleyn’s brother George was a candidate.
The king chose Nicholas Carew instead.
Everyone at court understood what it meant.
The Boleyns were falling.
Within weeks, Anne was arrested.
So were five men accused with her: her brother George, the musician Mark Smeaton, Sir Francis Weston, William Brereton, and Henry Norris, the king’s groom of the stool.
Most historians today believe the charges were invented.
Carew knew all of them.
Norris had been the king’s groom of the stool for ten years, the man who slept nearest the king and kept the keys to his private rooms.
Weston was a young gentleman of the privy chamber, a favorite tennis partner of the king, barely twenty-five.
Brereton was a groom of the privy chamber with great power in the Welsh borders.
Smeaton was a musician who had played for the king and queen in the evenings.
The men Carew had dressed the king beside, ridden beside, played cards with, were now prisoners in the Tower, accused of adultery with the queen.
Only Smeaton confessed, very probably after being threatened or tortured.
The others denied everything.
Weston, on the scaffold, is said to have warned the crowd not to trust in the vanities of the world, and especially in the flattery of the court.
It was advice that every man in the privy chamber should have heard.
On May 17, 1536, the five men were put to death on Tower Hill.
Two days later, Anne Boleyn died inside the Tower.
And eleven days after that, the king married Jane Seymour.
Carew had chosen the winning side.
He had watched five men he had known for years, men who had stood beside him in the privy chamber and the tiltyard, die on the hill outside the Tower.
He was now one of the most trusted knights in England.
He would be dead on the same hill in less than three years.
—
## Words at dinner
The fall of Carew did not begin with anything he did.
It began with whom he knew.
His closest friends at court were men of the old blood and the old faith.
The most important was Henry Courtenay, Marquess of Exeter, the king’s own first cousin.
Exeter’s mother was a princess, a daughter of Edward IV, sister of Henry VIII’s mother.
He had grown up with the king, just as Carew had.
Around Exeter there was a circle of conservative nobles and gentlemen who disliked the king’s break with Rome, mourned the destruction of the monasteries, and sympathized with Princess Mary.
Some of them were related to Cardinal Reginald Pole, the king’s cousin and bitter enemy, who was living abroad and writing furiously against Henry.
Pole’s brother, Henry Pole, Lord Montagu, was part of the same circle.
His mother was Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury.
In 1538, Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister, began to pull on the threads of that circle.
Cromwell had reasons.
He had enemies among the conservatives, and he needed to show the king that the threat from Cardinal Pole was real.
In August, Pole’s youngest brother, Sir Geoffrey Pole, was arrested.
Under questioning in the Tower, he broke down and began to talk.
He described conversations, complaints, jokes, hopes.
His brother Montagu had said things about the king’s health.
Exeter had said things about the future.
All of it was loose talk.
All of it could be turned into treason.
In November 1538, Exeter and Montagu were arrested.
On January 9, 1539, they were put to death on Tower Hill.
Exeter’s young son, Edward Courtenay, was taken to the Tower and kept there.
He would grow up inside its walls, alongside Montagu’s son and the old Countess of Salisbury, Margaret Pole, who was arrested in the same sweep and would follow her son to the block in 1541.
The king was clearing away the old royal blood, family by family.
And by then, the king’s men had come for Carew too.
—
## The letters
The case against Carew rested on his friendship with Exeter.
The two men had exchanged letters.
They had talked, at dinner and on horseback, about the state of the realm, the king’s marriages, the old religion.
The government alleged that Carew had known of Exeter’s treasonable intentions and not reported them, and that he had shared in them.
The indictment talked about letters and conversations, and about Carew’s knowledge of plans that, if they existed at all, were never carried out.
There was a story, later, that Carew had received letters from the Marchioness of Exeter, Exeter’s wife, and had destroyed them.
There was a story that Exeter’s servants had been questioned about what passed between the two houses.
Little of it amounted to proof of a plot.
But under the treason laws Henry VIII had passed in the 1530s, words could be treason, and so could knowing of other men’s words and keeping quiet.
Carew was taken to the Tower.
As a knight but not a peer, he was tried not by the House of Lords but in the ordinary way, before royal commissioners and a jury, in Westminster Hall.
It was the same vast hall where Thomas More had been tried in 1535 and Henry Norris and the others in 1536.
Under the great hammerbeam roof, under the gaze of the carved angels, the accused stood at the bar without a lawyer and answered the evidence as best he could.
In treason trials of this period, the verdict was almost never in doubt.
The crown chose the charges, the evidence and, in practice, the jury.
On February 14, 1539, he was tried for high treason.
He was found guilty.
And among the men chosen to sit in judgment on him was Sir Francis Bryan.
Bryan was Carew’s brother-in-law, the brother of his wife Elizabeth.
He was also a man who had survived at Henry’s court for decades by knowing exactly which way the wind was blowing.
Thomas Cromwell had a nickname for him.
He called him the Vicar of Hell.
Bryan had already been useful to the king once before, in 1536, when he had been sent to bring the news of Anne Boleyn’s condemnation to Jane Seymour.
Now he was useful again.
The verdict meant that his sister would lose her husband, her house and her income.
There is no record that Bryan said a word on his brother-in-law’s behalf.
—
## Tower Hill, March 3, 1539
Nicholas Carew had nearly three weeks between his trial and his death.
He spent them in the Tower.
And something happened to him there that nobody had expected.
The man who had stood by the old church all his life, who had supported Catherine of Aragon and Princess Mary and the conservative nobles, began to read the Bible.
The reformers had been pushing for an English Bible for years, and by 1539 one had been approved by the king and was being placed in churches across the country.
Carew had never paid much attention to it.
Now, in his cell, with time and fear on his hands, he read it.
On the morning of March 3, he was led out of the Tower, across the moat and up onto Tower Hill.
The scaffold stood on the rising ground just outside the fortress.
It was the same place where he had watched Henry Norris and the others die three years before.
It was the same place where Exeter and Montagu had died two months earlier.
There was a large crowd.
People had come out from the city in the cold, because a man this famous did not go to the block every week.
Picture what the crowd saw.
A tall man of about forty-two, still with the bearing of the tiltyard, walking slowly up the wooden steps.
No armor now.
No feather in his cap.
No garter.
His blue ribbon of the Garter had been taken from him when he was condemned, and his arms would soon be taken down from his stall in St. George’s Chapel at Windsor.
The official on the scaffold would have read out the sentence.
Then the prisoner was allowed to speak.
It was the custom for condemned men to make a short speech, admitting that they deserved to die under the law, asking forgiveness of the king and of the people, and urging the crowd to be obedient.
Most men stuck to the formula, because their families’ fate might depend on it.
Carew did something more.
According to a letter written soon afterward by a reformer named John Butler, Carew told the crowd that he had fallen because he had hated the Gospel.
He urged them to study the evangelical books, the reformed scriptures, as he had come to do in prison.
The chronicler Edward Hall, who had once written so sourly about the egg-throwing young courtiers in Paris, reported that Carew made a good and godly confession on the scaffold, and that he thanked God he had ever come into the prison of the Tower, because there he had first tasted the sweetness of God’s word.
It was an astonishing thing to hear from a man who had been condemned, in part, as a supporter of the old faith.
The crowd would have gone very quiet.
Here was the king’s champion, the man of the feather and the armor, telling them that he had found something in a stone cell that he had never found in thirty years at court.
It was cold.
The wind off the river would have pulled at his clothes and carried his words away from the edges of the crowd.
Behind him, across the moat, rose the walls of the Tower, where he had spent the last weeks of his life, and beyond them the White Tower itself, pale against the grey sky.
Below him were the faces of people who had cheered him in the lists.
Some of them had probably come for exactly that reason, to see the famous jouster one last time.
Some of them had come because a death on Tower Hill was a free spectacle.
Somewhere in the city, the king was going about his day.
He had not commuted the sentence to a quieter death, or delayed it, or sent a last-minute pardon.
The friend who had grown up beside him was on his own.
Then he knelt.
He laid his head on the block.
The executioner did his work, by every account quickly.
The king’s oldest friend was dead.
He was about forty-two.
His body was taken away and buried, according to tradition, in the church of St. Botolph without Aldgate, in the eastern part of the City.
The ground he died on is now a small paved garden in Trinity Square, just across the road from the Tower, ringed with low stone posts and iron chains.
A plaque there says that more than a hundred and twenty-five people were put to death on that spot.
Not all of their names fit on the stones, but Nicholas Carew was one of them.
—
## What happened to Beddington
When a man was attainted for treason, his property went to the crown.
Carew’s beloved house at Beddington, the manor where he had been born, with its fields and gardens and its great hall, was taken.
Within a short time, the Beddington estates were granted away to new owners.
Carew’s widow, Elizabeth, was left with very little.
The woman who had been one of the beauties of the young king’s court, the sister of the Vicar of Hell and the daughter of the lady mistress of the royal nurseries, was suddenly poor.
She lived on, quietly, for many years.
Her brother, the Vicar of Hell, prospered.
Francis Bryan stayed in favor through the rest of Henry’s reign and into the next, and ended his life in Ireland as one of the king’s chief officers there, dying at Clonmel in 1550.
Whether he ever helped his sister is not recorded.
He had always known which way the wind was blowing.
But the story does not end there.
Carew’s son, Francis, was a child when his father died.
He grew up under the shadow of the attainder.
When he came of age, he managed to get the attainder reversed, clearing his father’s name in law.
It did not give him back the house.
So Francis Carew did something patient and stubborn.
He bought it back.
Over the following years, he acquired Beddington from the man who then held it, and settled down to rebuild the place his father had lost.
He became famous for his garden.
He was one of the first men in England to grow orange trees, sheltering them in winter in wooden houses warmed by stoves, and for generations people came to Beddington to see them.
In 1599, Queen Elizabeth I, Henry VIII’s daughter, came to visit him.
The story told about that visit is one of the most charming of her reign.
Sir Francis wanted to serve the queen cherries, but the cherries in his garden would be ripe too soon.
So he covered a whole cherry tree with a tent of canvas, keeping the sun off it, so that the fruit would ripen slowly and be perfect on the very day she arrived.
The daughter of the king who had sent Nicholas Carew to the block sat in Nicholas Carew’s garden and ate his son’s cherries.
—
## The story of the game of bowls
Over the following century, people tried to explain why Henry VIII turned on his oldest friend.
Treason charges based on dinner conversation did not seem like enough.
So a story grew up.
According to a later tradition, the king and Carew were playing at bowls one day, and the king insulted his friend with a rude word.
Carew, the story goes, answered back sharply, and the king never forgave him.
It is the kind of story people like, because it makes the king’s cruelty personal and simple.
It is almost certainly not true, or at least there is no contemporary evidence for it.
The real reasons were bigger and colder.
Carew was a conservative in a court that was being pulled toward reform.
He was the close friend of the king’s cousin Exeter, at a moment when the king had decided that his royal cousins were a danger.
And he was caught up in Thomas Cromwell’s campaign against the circle around the Pole family and the old blood of the Plantagenets.
It was not one sharp word at a bowling green that destroyed him.
It was the slow, grinding logic of a reign in which being close to the king was the most valuable thing in the world, and the most deadly.
Cromwell himself, the man who had built the case, would die on the same hill sixteen months later.
—
## The tiltyard and the hill
Go back to that morning on Tower Hill, to the tall man walking up the wooden steps.
Thirty-seven years earlier, a little boy from Beddington had been brought into the household of an eleven-year-old prince.
They had learned their Latin together.
They had learned to ride together.
They had charged at each other down the lists with lances in their hands, the boy who would be king and the boy who would be his champion.
Henry had given him a tiltyard of his own.
In the end, he gave him a different kind of open ground, on the hill outside the Tower, where the crowds gathered not to watch a joust, but to watch the king’s friends die.
The tiltyard at Greenwich is long gone.
The scaffold site on Tower Hill is still there.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Sir Nicholas Carew was born around 1496 at Beddington, Surrey, and was placed in the household of the future Henry VIII at about the age of six.
He was given his own tiltyard at Greenwich by 1515, was removed from court to Ruysbank near Calais in 1519, became master of the horse in 1522, and was made a knight of the Garter in 1536.
His marriage to Elizabeth Bryan, sister of Sir Francis Bryan, is documented; Bryan served on the commission that tried him, and the verdict left Elizabeth impoverished.
Edward Hall’s description of the young courtiers in Paris throwing eggs and stones comes from his chronicle.
Chapuys’s reports name Carew among those advising Jane Seymour in 1536; how great his role was is uncertain.
Carew was tried on February 14, 1539, and put to death on Tower Hill on March 3, 1539, accused of involvement in the so-called Exeter Conspiracy, which most historians regard as largely the creation of Thomas Cromwell’s investigation.
The exact contents of the letters and conversations used against him are known only in outline from the indictment.
His speech on the scaffold, urging the study of the “evangelical books,” is recorded in a letter by John Butler; Hall’s report of his godly confession in the Tower is in his chronicle; the exact wording is paraphrased here.
His burial at St. Botolph without Aldgate is traditional.
The Holbein portrait of Carew in armor, painted around 1532–33, and Holbein’s chalk drawing of him survive.
His son Sir Francis Carew obtained the reversal of the attainder and later bought back Beddington; his orange trees and the story of the cherry tree covered for Elizabeth I’s visit in 1599 are recorded in accounts of the period, though the cherry story may have been improved in the telling.
The story of the quarrel at bowls is a later tradition without contemporary support.
The description of daily life in the privy chamber follows the Eltham Ordinances of 1526.