News

Why You Wouldn’t Survive the Sweating Sickness (Tudor England)

The rider came in the dark.

It was the middle of June 1528, and the King of England was not where kings were supposed to be.

He was not at Greenwich, with its gardens and its tiltyard on the Thames.

He was not at Westminster or at Wolsey’s great palace at Hampton Court.

He was in Hertfordshire, at a house called Hunsdon, some twenty-five miles north of London, with the doors watched and the gates closed to anyone who had come from the city.

He had been running for days.

The candles had burned low.

Somewhere in the house slept the queen, Catherine of Aragon, who had fled with him, because the thing they were fleeing did not care about the quarrel that was tearing their marriage apart.

The servants who were still on their feet heard the hooves in the courtyard, the challenge at the gate, the door.

The message the rider carried was for the king alone.

It came from Hever, the moated Boleyn house in Kent, deep in the countryside south of London.

And it said that the woman Henry VIII had spent more than a year trying to marry, the woman for whom he was prepared to break with the Pope himself, had fallen ill.

Not with an ordinary fever.

Not with a cold or a cough or one of the slow, lingering complaints that physicians could sit beside for weeks.

She had the sweat.

Everyone in England knew what that meant.

By this time tomorrow night, Anne Boleyn would either be recovering or she would be dead, and there was almost nothing anyone could do to choose between the two.

Henry was thirty-six years old, the most powerful man in his kingdom, and a man who loved to ride.

Hever was a long day’s hard ride away.

So what did he do?

He did not go to her.

He sat down and wrote a letter instead.

—

## The letter that ended up in the Pope’s own library

That letter still exists.

It is not in a museum in London or a country house in Kent.

It sits in the Vatican Library in Rome, bound into a volume with sixteen other letters Henry wrote to Anne in his own hand, some in English and some in French.

How the private love letters of the King of England ended up in the library of the very Pope he was trying to defy is one of the small, strange mysteries of the Tudor age.

We will come back to it.

But to understand why a king who would soon turn his whole country upside down for this woman could not bring himself to ride to her bedside, you first have to understand the thing that was in that room at Hever.

It had a name nobody liked to say out loud.

And it had already been killing the English for forty-three years.

What it did that summer would cost Anne’s family a husband and a father.

It would leave her sister a widow buried in debts.

It would hand Anne a small boy to raise.

And within a few years of the last outbreak, it would kill two brothers of the highest birth in England in a single afternoon, one an hour after the other.

Then it would disappear so completely that, five centuries later, nobody can say for certain what it was.

—

## Why London buried two lord mayors in a single autumn

The first time anyone saw it was in the late summer of 1485.

England had just come through thirty years of civil war.

On August 22, 1485, a little-known exile named Henry Tudor beat King Richard III at Bosworth Field and took the crown as Henry VII.

He came to London at the end of August with an army that had been raised partly abroad, French and Breton soldiers among them, men who had spent months in camps and on cramped ships.

Within a few weeks, Londoners began to die of something nobody recognized.

The records place the start of the outbreak in the city around September 19, 1485.

It was not the plague.

Londoners knew the plague by now, after more than a century of living with it, and they knew its marks: the swellings in the groin and armpit, the black patches, the slow decline over days.

This came with no swellings at all.

It came as dread, shivering, a headache, then a sweat that soaked the bed, and then, very often, death.

The whole thing took a day.

Sometimes much less.

A physician named Thomas Forestier, who was practicing in London that autumn, wrote one of the first accounts of it.

He described men who were well in the morning and dead before night, and he blamed foul vapors gathering around the heart and lungs.

The disease did not spare the men who ran the city.

Before the autumn was over, London had lost two lord mayors, one after the other.

Six aldermen died.

So did three sheriffs.

The government of the largest city in England was being hollowed out from the top while the new king was still learning the names of the men who served him.

Henry VII was crowned at Westminster Abbey on October 30, 1485.

By then the people who had lined the streets to watch him arrive were burying their own.

A new king had arrived, and a new disease had arrived with him.

Some people called it God’s judgment.

Others muttered that the Tudors had brought a curse with them.

The sickness burned out by the end of the year.

People hoped they had seen the last of it.

They had not.

It came back in 1508.

It came back, worse, in 1517.

And each time it came back, the English gave it the same flat, frightened name: the sweating sickness.

The sweat.

Foreigners called it something that would sting more over time.

They called it the English sweat.

—

## Breakfast, fever, sweat, and the sleep you must not take

Here is what it did, as the doctors who watched it described it.

It began with a warning so strange it was hard to put into words.

A sense of apprehension.

A feeling that something was very wrong, without any pain to say what.

Then the shivering, even on a warm summer day.

That first stage could last half an hour or a couple of hours.

It was the only warning a person got.

Then came the pain.

A crushing headache.

Aches in the neck, shoulders, and limbs, as if the body had been beaten.

Dizziness.

Sometimes vomiting.

And then came the thing that gave the disease its name.

The sweat broke out all at once and did not stop.

It ran off the skin.

It soaked the shirt, the sheets, the mattress below.

People who survived said it had a smell of its own, sour and unlike any other sweat, a smell they never forgot.

With the sweat came a raging thirst.

And here was the cruelest part.

Tudor physicians believed, with absolute conviction, that a sweating patient must not be cooled.

No cold drink.

No fresh air.

No throwing off the blankets.

A chill, they said, would drive the sweat back inside and stop the heart.

So the sick lay in sealed rooms, burning, soaked, begging for water, and the people who loved them refused it.

The last stage was the one that killed.

The heart labored.

The patient grew weaker and weaker and was gripped by an overpowering need to sleep.

And sleep, every physician agreed, was the thing to fear most.

Those who drifted off in the crisis often never woke.

So families fought to keep them awake.

They shook them, slapped their cheeks, called their names, held vinegar under their noses when their eyes began to close.

Hour after hour, somebody stood over the bed refusing to let the patient go under.

If the patient lasted about a day, they would probably live.

Probably.

Some sickened again later.

Surviving once did not seem to protect anyone.

And some people never caught it at all, even when they shared a house, or a bed, with someone who died of it.

The French ambassador who watched it tear through London in 1528 put it more bluntly than any doctor.

A little pain in the head and in the heart, he wrote, and then the sweat begins.

“Within four hours, or sometimes in two or three, one is dispatched without delay.”

—

## The cure that heated the room

If you had caught the sweat in Tudor England, the disease was not the only thing trying to kill you.

Your doctor was too.

Medicine in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries rested on a theory inherited from the ancient Greeks.

The body was governed by four humors: blood, phlegm, yellow bile, and black bile.

Health was balance.

Sickness meant one humor had grown too strong or had turned corrupt.

Looked at that way, the sweat seemed to explain itself.

A patient pouring out fluid was a body trying to drive out something corrupt.

The physician’s job was to help it along.

So they heated the room.

Windows were shut and doors were sealed.

Blankets were heaped on.

Some patients were wrapped in wool.

Some had hot stones or warming pans laid around them.

Food and drink were held back.

To a modern eye, it is hard to invent a treatment better designed to kill someone who was already losing fluid by the pint.

And then, because this was the sixteenth century, there was bleeding.

A patient already soaked and dehydrated and with a racing heart might have a vein opened in the arm to let out still more.

Some physicians added purges, strong laxatives or drinks to bring on vomiting, all to empty the body of the bad humor faster.

These were not cruel men.

They believed they were saving lives, and their patients trusted them, because there was nobody else to trust.

That was the trap.

In the space of a single day, there was no time to try something different.

The sweat came back in 1508.

It came back in 1517, harder this time, and stayed through the summer and into the next year.

It reached Oxford and Cambridge, where students scattered back to their home counties.

And in 1517, someone noticed something that made it even more frightening.

—

## Why the sweat seemed to choose the rich

It was not killing the people it was supposed to kill.

In the Tudor world, the poor died first of almost everything.

They lived crowded together, ate badly, drank foul water, and slept in damp rooms.

When plague came, it came for them.

The sweat seemed to prefer the opposite.

It struck down well-fed men in the prime of life.

It killed courtiers and merchants, lawyers and churchmen, men who ate meat every day and slept in good beds behind glass windows.

Contemporaries noticed that it seemed to fall hardest on the comfortable and the well-to-do.

The Venetian ambassador in London noticed something else in 1517.

Foreigners, he observed, seemed to catch it far less often than the English.

Nobody could explain it, and nobody can fully explain it today.

Some historians point to the rushes strewn on English floors, piled thick in wealthy homes and left for months, a damp world for mice, fleas, ticks, and lice.

It is guesswork.

What is not guesswork is how it felt to live with it.

In a society built entirely on rank, the sweat paid no attention to rank.

A lord could be dead by supper while his stable boy lived.

Money could not buy a cure, because there was none.

Status could not buy distance, except in one way.

You could run.

Cardinal Thomas Wolsey, the king’s chief minister and the most powerful man in England after Henry himself, caught the sweat in 1517 and survived it.

Henry VIII did not catch it.

He learned something from that summer that he never forgot.

When the sweat came, the safest place for the king was somewhere else.

Eleven years later, he would put that lesson to the test.

—

## The woman waiting in the tiltyard

In the spring of 1528, Anne Boleyn was living in rooms at Greenwich Palace, near the tiltyard where the king jousted.

She was not queen.

She was not even officially anything.

She was the younger daughter of Sir Thomas Boleyn, an ambitious diplomat.

She had spent years at the French court and come home with French manners, French fashions, and a sharp, quick, educated mind.

She had served in the household of Queen Catherine.

And for more than a year, the king had been in love with her.

Henry had decided that his marriage of almost nineteen years to Catherine of Aragon had never been valid in the eyes of God.

Catherine had been married first to his older brother, Arthur, who had died young.

Henry now believed, or had persuaded himself, that marrying his brother’s widow had been a sin, and that this was why he had no living son.

He wanted the Pope to agree with him.

He wanted to marry Anne.

That spring, his envoys had come back from Rome with what looked like good news.

Pope Clement VII had agreed to send a cardinal, Lorenzo Campeggio, to hear the case in England alongside Wolsey.

In May, the king sent one of the returning envoys straight to Anne’s rooms to tell her himself.

Everything seemed to be moving at last.

Then, at the end of May, people in London began to sweat.

By early June, the king’s officials were mentioning it in their letters.

By the middle of the month, it had spread across the city.

The French ambassador, Jean du Bellay, wrote home on June 18 that some two thousand people in London had caught it.

Henry stayed where he was.

For a few days.

Then the sweat walked into Anne Boleyn’s own rooms.

—

## The night one of Anne’s ladies began to sweat

Du Bellay told the story in the same letter.

One of the ladies of Anne’s chamber, he reported, had been found to be infected with the sweat.

We do not know her name.

We do not know if she lived.

She appears in the record for exactly one sentence, a young woman in the service of the king’s favorite who woke one day with a feeling of dread and began, within hours, to soak her sheets.

What we do know is what the king did.

He left.

Not slowly.

Not after consultations.

According to the ambassador, Henry departed in great haste, to a house twelve miles away.

Anne was not taken with him.

She was sent away to her father.

It is easy to read that as cowardice.

But by the standards of the time, it was what a king was supposed to do.

A king who died without a son in 1528 would leave England with a twelve-year-old daughter, Princess Mary, and a very real chance of civil war.

His father had won the crown in one.

So the court broke apart.

The king and queen, still married and still traveling together whatever they thought of each other, went first to Waltham, in Essex.

It was not far enough.

At Waltham, the sweat found them again.

Two ushers fell ill.

So did two of the grooms of the king’s chamber.

So did Anne’s brother, George Boleyn.

The king moved again, to Hunsdon in Hertfordshire.

He gave orders that nobody from infected places should come near.

He moved from room to room and house to house.

Later that summer, the French ambassador would report that the king kept changing his lodgings because of the pestilence, and that he had shut himself away, alone, to protect himself.

Meanwhile, the king wrote to Anne.

The first of his letters from that week is a strange mixture of fear and reassurance.

He had been badly frightened, he admitted, by doubts about her health.

But now that he had heard she had felt nothing so far, he hoped that the sickness would spare her.

Then he tried to comfort her with what he had heard.

“In this distemper few or no women have been taken ill,” he wrote, and “no person of our court, and few elsewhere, have died of it.”

He told her that George and the others were quite well again, that nobody at Hunsdon was sick, and that she should move away from the danger, as he had.

He signed with a pun on his own initials, as if it were an ordinary week.

He was wrong about almost everything in it.

Women did catch the sweat.

People at court were about to die of it.

And the woman he was writing to was about to fall ill herself.

—

## The day at Hever

Hever Castle sits low in the Kent countryside, a small, square, honey-colored house inside a moat, more like a fortified manor than a castle.

The Boleyns had owned it for two generations.

Anne had spent part of her childhood there.

Now she was back, sent home in a hurry from a palace where she had been the most watched woman in England.

We do not know exactly which day the sickness came for her.

Henry’s letters, which are not dated, suggest it was within a few days of that cheerful note from Hunsdon.

What we do know is that she was not alone.

Her father, Sir Thomas Boleyn, fell ill as well.

Father and daughter, in the same house, at the same time, both with the disease that killed in a day.

No one sat in that room and wrote down what happened in it.

There is no diary, no letter from a servant, no account of Anne’s own.

But the sweat did not vary much from patient to patient, and the physicians of the time described it in detail.

We can stand at the edge of the room and know, roughly, what it must have been.

It would have started with the dread.

A young woman who had been reading, or writing, or walking by the moat, would have felt suddenly, unaccountably afraid.

Then cold.

Then the shivering would have come, the kind that rattles the teeth, in a June that was warm outside the walls.

Someone would have recognized it.

Every household in England knew those first signs by now.

There would have been a moment, a terrible quiet moment, when the women attending her looked at each other and understood.

Then they would have done what everyone did.

They put her to bed.

They closed the windows.

They drew the bed curtains.

They heaped on the coverlets.

They kept the fire in.

If a room in June can feel like an oven, hers would have.

Within a few hours, the pain would have come.

The headache, pressing behind the eyes.

The ache in the neck and shoulders.

And then the sweat, breaking all at once, soaking the linen until the women had to change it and change it again, careful even then not to let cold air touch her skin.

She would have been desperate for a drink.

They would have refused her anything cold.

Somewhere in that same house, her father was going through the same thing.

Two Boleyns, in two beds, and a household divided between them.

Out on the roads, a man was riding toward Hever.

Back at Hunsdon, the news had reached the king in the night.

And the letter he wrote then is the one that sits in Rome today.

“There came to me suddenly in the night the most afflicting news that could have arrived.”

Three things grieved him, he wrote.

The first was to hear of the sickness of his mistress, “whom I esteem more than all the world, and whose health I desire as I do my own, so that I would gladly bear half your illness to make you well.”

The second was the fear that he would have to go on suffering what he called his enemy, Absence, for even longer.

The third was that the physician he trusted most was away, at the very moment he was needed.

So, the king wrote, “for want of him I send you my second, and hope that he will soon make you well.”

That second physician was Dr. William Butts.

Butts was in his forties, a Cambridge man, careful and well regarded.

In a few months he would be named one of the king’s own physicians, and he would serve Henry for the rest of his life.

He would later become one of the few men at court whom Anne trusted completely.

But on the road to Hever, he was simply the best the king could send, carrying the king’s letter and the king’s instructions.

Henry begged Anne to be guided by his advice.

“In so doing,” he wrote, “I hope soon to see you again, which will be to me a greater comfort than all the precious jewels in the world.”

He signed it with their initials together: H, then A and B, then R.

He did not come himself.

At Hever, the hours went by.

The worst of the sweat would not have lasted long, but every hour of it was dangerous.

Somewhere in that day, the exhaustion would have come, the heavy, drowning pull toward sleep.

That was the moment every physician warned of.

Let the patient sleep, and she may not wake.

So someone would have stayed beside her bed.

Someone would have spoken to her, kept her talking, said her name.

Someone would have taken her hand and held it, tight, every time her eyes began to close.

The women of the household had all heard what to do.

Keep her warm.

Keep her still.

Keep her awake.

Whatever Butts did when he arrived, he did it in a room like that.

We know almost nothing about his treatment.

We know only the result.

Anne Boleyn did not fall asleep and fail to wake.

Her father did not either.

Sometime in the next day or two, the sweat broke and did not return.

Anne was weak, wrung out, probably barely able to sit up.

But she was alive.

The king’s next letters are full of relief.

He was soon writing about ordinary things again, and sending her venison he had killed himself, joking that it was “hart flesh for Henry.”

He had his Anne back.

But the sweat had not finished with the Boleyns.

Not far from Hever, it was already in the bed of a man named William Carey.

—

## The man who did not wake up

William Carey was thirty-three years old.

He was one of the king’s favorites, a gentleman of the Privy Chamber, one of the small circle of men who spent their days in Henry’s private rooms.

He collected art, and he is credited with bringing the miniature painter Lucas Horenbout to England.

And he was married to Anne Boleyn’s older sister, Mary.

That made him part of one of the most awkward family situations at the Tudor court.

Before the king fell for Anne, he had had an affair with Mary.

Mary had married Carey in 1520, and by 1528 the couple had two small children, a daughter named Catherine and a son named Henry, then two years old.

Rumor has always whispered that one or both of those children might have been the king’s.

Nobody has proved it.

What is certain is that on June 22, 1528, William Carey died of the sweating sickness.

He was not the only one.

Within days, the sweat killed Sir William Compton, one of the king’s closest friends since boyhood, a man who had been Groom of the Stool and had once held the most intimate post in Henry’s household.

It killed Sir Francis Poyntz, a courtier and diplomat.

On June 30, the French ambassador listed the dead among the king’s own people: Poyntz, Carey, and Compton.

So much for the king’s promise that nobody at court had died of it.

Du Bellay also gave the numbers.

Of more than forty thousand people in London who had caught the sweat, he wrote, fewer than two thousand had died.

Two thousand funerals in one city in a few weeks, and nobody knew, on any given morning, whose turn it would be.

For Mary Boleyn, the death of her husband was a disaster in more than one way.

Carey had died deep in debt.

Mary was left a widow with two small children and very little money, and her father, Sir Thomas Boleyn, seems to have been in no hurry to help her.

It was Anne who stepped in.

And it was Henry, writing to Anne that summer, who settled it.

He had had one of his gentlemen, Walter Walsh, write to her father to make his wishes known.

A father, the king insisted, could not in honor refuse to take in his own daughter, “now in her extreme necessity.”

Then there was the boy.

Little Henry Carey, two years old, was now the heir of a dead courtier, and under the law of the time the king could grant his wardship to someone else.

It went to Anne.

The child of her sister and the man the sweat had just killed would grow up under the care of the woman who was about to become queen.

Hold on to that boy.

He will come back.

The sweat left one more piece of family business behind.

Carey had a sister, Eleanor, who was a nun at Wilton Abbey in Wiltshire.

With the abbess’s post falling vacant, the Boleyns had been pushing for Eleanor to get it.

Now, with her brother dead, Wolsey had the nuns examined.

What came out ended her chances for good.

Henry wrote to Anne to explain why he would not appoint her.

Eleanor, he had been told, had confessed “to have had two children by two sundry priests.”

He would not, he said, “for all the gold in the world,” make such a woman ruler of a house.

Even in a plague summer, the business of the court went on.

—

## A king who changed beds every few nights

While the Boleyns buried their dead, the king was still on the move.

He went from Waltham to Hunsdon, and later in the summer to Tittenhanger, near St Albans, a house belonging to Wolsey.

Everywhere he went, his household was cut to the bone.

The sweat kept finding them anyway.

In early July, the king wrote to Anne that a handful of men in his own household had fallen ill in the house where he was staying, among them his apothecary.

All of them, he added, had recovered.

“The rest of us yet be well,” he wrote, “and I trust shall pass it, either not to have it, or, at the least, as easily as the rest have done.”

You can hear the fear under the bravado.

Henry feared illness all his life.

He liked to mix his own plasters and remedies, and a book of recipes credited to him and his physicians survives in the British Library.

In a postscript to one of Anne’s letters to Wolsey, the king added a few lines of his own.

They were both, he wrote, “joyous to hear that you have escaped this plague so well.”

The government of England, meanwhile, simply stopped.

The law courts did not sit.

Du Bellay wrote in June that there would be neither summons nor law term, because everyone was so terribly afraid.

Courtiers scattered to their country houses.

The great men who ran the kingdom sat behind locked gates and waited.

It was the summer of 1528, in the middle of the most important legal fight of Henry’s reign, and the most powerful man in England was hiding from something he could not see.

Then, as always, the sweat burned out.

By late summer, the court was coming back together.

The legate Campeggio was on his way.

Anne came back to court that autumn, and the king’s great case against his own marriage finally went forward.

It would take five more years, a break with Rome, and the remaking of the English church before Anne Boleyn became queen.

The sweat did not stay in England to watch.

It went abroad.

—

## How the English sweat crossed the sea

In July 1529, a ship from England docked at Hamburg.

Within weeks, the sweat was killing in the city.

It had never been seen outside England before.

Now it moved along the trade routes as fast as the ships and wagons that carried it, along the Baltic coast and up into Scandinavia, south and west into the cities of Germany and the Low Countries: Strasbourg, Frankfurt, Cologne, Marburg, Göttingen.

On September 27, 1529, it appeared on the same day in Antwerp and Amsterdam.

The Germans called it the English sweat, and their physicians rushed out pamphlets telling people how to protect themselves.

One of those pamphlets, by the German physician Euricius Cordus, printed in 1529, carried a woodcut on its title page: two sick people lying together in a bed, while a cluster of anxious attendants, one of them bearded and hooded like a physician, crowds around them.

It is about as close as we will ever get to a picture of the sweat drawn in its own time.

The panic was enormous, but brief.

By the end of 1529 the disease had faded from most of the continent, lingering only in eastern Switzerland into the next year.

In England, too, the sweat left marks that would only matter later.

Around 1528 and 1529, a rising lawyer named Thomas Cromwell lost his wife and two young daughters, very likely to the sweat.

Cromwell would go on to become the most powerful minister in England, the man who helped Henry marry Anne and then helped him destroy her.

Then the sweat went quiet in England for more than twenty years.

The king married Anne.

Anne gave him a daughter, Elizabeth.

Henry had Anne put to death in 1536, married three more times, and died in January 1547.

And in 1551, in the reign of his young son Edward VI, the sweat came back for one last time.

—

## Why two young dukes died an hour apart

It started in Shrewsbury in April 1551.

That outbreak killed around a thousand people in the town and the surrounding country.

Then it spread.

It reached London in early July.

It reached Cambridge.

At Cambridge, in St John’s College, were two boys who carried one of the greatest names in England.

They were Henry and Charles Brandon, sons of Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, Henry VIII’s oldest friend, and his fourth wife, Katherine Willoughby.

Their father had died in 1545, and at fifteen, Henry was Duke of Suffolk.

Charles was thirteen or fourteen.

Their mother had sent them to Cambridge in 1549 to study.

When the sweat reached Cambridge, the boys were moved out of the town, to the Bishop of Lincoln’s palace at Buckden, in what is now Cambridgeshire.

It was meant to save them.

It was too late.

On July 14, 1551, Henry Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, died of the sweat at Buckden.

His younger brother became Duke of Suffolk in that instant.

He held the title for about an hour.

Then Charles died too.

Their mother had been ill herself, at her own house.

Some accounts say she reached Buckden in time to see her younger son before he died.

Both boys were buried quietly, there at Buckden.

There is a detail that stays with people who read about the Brandon brothers.

The London diarist Henry Machyn, who recorded the deaths of the great with an undertaker’s eye, wrote that the two dukes had died of the sweat “in one bed.”

Two brothers, the heirs to one of the great fortunes of England, lying side by side, and nothing that wealth or rank or the best physicians in the country could do about it.

It was in this last outbreak that a doctor finally sat down to write the disease down properly.

—

## The doctor who watched it and wrote it down

His name was John Caius.

A Norwich man trained at Cambridge and at Padua, one of the great medical schools of Europe, he was practicing in Shrewsbury when the sweat broke out there in 1551.

The next year, he published a book about it.

Its title is a mouthful: *A Boke or Counseill Against the Disease Commonly Called the Sweate, or Sweatyng Sicknesse.*

It was written in English, so that ordinary people could read it, and it remains one of the best descriptions of the sweat we have.

Caius was still a man of his time.

He believed in the humors and blamed filth and corruption, and his advice, gentler than the heaped blankets of earlier doctors, was still not going to cure anyone.

But he watched closely.

He noted that the disease came mostly in summer and early autumn.

He noted how fast it moved, and how the crucial hours were the first ones.

Like his predecessors, he warned that the patient must be kept still and moderately warm, not exposed to cold air, and not allowed to drift into sleep in the crisis.

He was, in a small way, doing what we would now call epidemiology, three hundred years before the word existed.

And then, just as he had finished describing it, the thing he had described vanished.

—

## A killer that simply walked away

After 1551, the English sweat was never reliably seen again.

It did not fade slowly, or retreat into some remote corner of the country, the way other epidemics did.

It came five times in sixty-six years, killed thousands, and then stopped.

That is the most unsettling part of the story.

Diseases do not usually just leave.

The plague came back to Europe for centuries.

Influenza reinvents itself every winter.

The sweat came, killed for two generations, and walked away.

Much later, from the early eighteenth century until around the First World War, France saw repeated outbreaks of a disease called the Picardy sweat, with fever, heavy sweating, and a rash.

Some historians have wondered whether it was a cousin of the English sweat.

But it was far less deadly, and nobody has shown that the two were the same thing.

So what was it?

Nobody knows for sure.

But there are suspects.

The leading theory, for many researchers, is a hantavirus.

Hantaviruses are carried by rodents, and some of them can cause a sudden, devastating illness that attacks the lungs and the heart and can kill within a day or two.

The seasonal pattern of the sweat, its summer outbreaks, and its link to rural houses full of mice all fit.

If the sweat was caused by a hantavirus living in a particular rodent population, then a change in that population could have made the disease vanish with it.

There are problems with that idea.

Modern hantaviruses rarely pass from one person to another, and they do not usually disappear the way the sweat did.

Others point to relapsing fever, carried by ticks and lice that could have thrived in those damp rushes.

But it usually comes with symptoms the Tudor accounts never mention.

To settle it, scientists would need the disease itself.

That means finding its genetic traces in the remains of people known to have died of it, and Tudor burial records rarely gave a cause of death.

Ancient DNA has confirmed what caused the Black Death.

It has not yet solved this one.

—

## The letters that ended up in Rome

Which brings us back to that letter written in the night at Hunsdon.

Seventeen of Henry’s letters to Anne survive, some in English, some in French.

Some are courtly.

Some are short, impatient, and frankly physical, the letters of a man used to getting what he wants who cannot have it.

They should have stayed in Anne’s possession, or been burned.

Instead, all but a couple of them ended up in the Vatican Library, catalogued as part of the papal collection.

They have been there for nearly five hundred years.

How did they get there?

Nobody knows for certain.

The most common explanation is that the letters were taken, by someone in Anne’s household or close to the papal legate, Cardinal Campeggio, who arrived in England in the autumn of 1528 to hear the king’s case.

Letters proving how passionately the king wanted Anne would have been very useful to anyone arguing that Henry’s sudden scruples about his first marriage had more to do with desire than with conscience.

It was never proved.

But Rome kept them.

And so the most private words Henry VIII ever wrote, including his frightened midnight note to a sick woman at Hever, ended up in the archive of the Pope he was about to break with forever.

They are there still, in the hand of the king who ran.

—

## What happened to everyone the sweat left behind

Anne Boleyn recovered completely.

She came back to court that autumn and spent the next four years fighting, alongside Henry, for a marriage the Pope would not allow.

In January 1533 she married the king in secret.

She was crowned queen that summer, pregnant with Elizabeth.

Three years later, in May 1536, she was arrested, tried on charges almost certainly false, and put to death at the Tower of London.

Her brother George, who had sweated at Waltham and survived, died on the scaffold two days before her.

Her father, Thomas Boleyn, who had sweated beside her at Hever, outlived both of his younger children by three years.

Mary Boleyn, the widow left in debt in 1528, married again for love in 1534, to a man of no great rank, and was banished from court for it.

She lived quietly until her death in 1543.

And the little boy whose wardship was handed to Anne after his father’s death?

Henry Carey grew up to become one of the most trusted men at the court of his first cousin, Queen Elizabeth I, Anne’s daughter.

She made him Baron Hunsdon, named after the very house where King Henry had hidden from the sweat in the summer his father died.

He served her as Lord Chamberlain, and among the companies of actors he patronized was one called the Lord Chamberlain’s Men.

One of its leading playwrights was William Shakespeare.

Dr. William Butts served Henry VIII until his own death in 1545.

John Caius refounded his old Cambridge college, still called Gonville and Caius today.

And Henry VIII, who ran from the sweat in 1517, in 1528, and every time it came near him, never caught it.

He died in his bed at Whitehall in 1547, at fifty-five, of a slow decline that had nothing to do with it.

—

## The king who ran

Go back, one last time, to Hunsdon on that June night in 1528.

The candles burned low.

The rider’s boots were muddy from the road.

Somewhere in the house, the queen Henry was trying to set aside lay asleep.

And in his hand the king held the news that the woman he loved had the sweat.

He wrote that he would gladly bear half her illness to make her well.

He did not ride to Hever.

He sent his second-best doctor, and stayed behind his locked gates.

In fairness, it may have been the wisest thing he could do.

A king at a sickbed was a king at risk.

But the people of Tudor England understood something about the sweat that Henry’s letter tries hard not to say.

You could not fight it.

You could not buy it off.

You could not argue it into submission, imprison it, or send it to the scaffold.

It did not care who you were.

All you could do was sit beside the bed, through the longest day of your life, holding someone’s hand and saying their name, so that they would not fall asleep.

At Hever that June, somebody did that for Anne Boleyn.

It was not the king.

—

## What the record actually says

**The 1528 timeline.** The French ambassador Jean du Bellay’s letter of June 18, 1528, reports that one of the ladies of Anne Boleyn’s chamber had caught the sweat, that the king left in great haste, and that Anne was sent to her father.

His letter of June 30 lists Poyntz, Carey, and Compton among the dead and gives the figure of more than 40,000 infected in London with fewer than 2,000 deaths.

**The night at Hunsdon.** The opening scene is reconstructed.

The king’s own letter says only that the news came to him “suddenly in the night”; the rider, the candles, and the sleeping queen are our setting, though Catherine of Aragon did travel with him that June.

**Henry’s letters.** All quotations from the king’s letters come from the standard English translations of his letters to Anne, most of which are held in the Vatican Library.

The letters are not dated; the order used here (the reassuring letter first, then the news “in the night,” then the letters about Mary Boleyn and Wilton Abbey) follows the arrangement most historians accept, but the exact days are estimates.

**Anne’s illness.** Henry’s own letter confirms that Anne fell ill and that he sent his “second” physician, generally identified as Dr. William Butts.

Thomas Boleyn’s illness at the same time is reported in the standard Boleyn histories.

The scene in Anne’s room is a reconstruction from how contemporaries described the disease; no eyewitness account of her illness survives.

**William Carey.** He died of the sweat on June 22, 1528.

The wardship of his son Henry was granted to Anne.

Whether Henry VIII fathered either of Mary Boleyn’s children has never been proved.

**The sweat itself.** The stages, the bans on cold drinks and sleep, and the heated sickrooms come from Tudor medical descriptions, including Caius’s book of 1552.

The claim that the sweat favored the rich and the English comes from contemporary observers, including the Venetian ambassador in 1517.

Modern theories about its cause, including hantavirus and relapsing fever, are unproven.

**The Brandon brothers.** Henry and Charles Brandon died at Buckden on July 14, 1551, about an hour apart.

Henry Machyn’s diary gives a slightly different date and says they died “in one bed.”

**The Vatican letters.** How Henry’s letters reached Rome is unknown.

The theory that they were taken for the use of the papal side in the king’s annulment case is the most common explanation, not an established fact.

You Might Also Enjoy