Why You Wouldn’t Survive One Night in the Tower of London (Tudor England)
They came for her early, while the dew was still on the grass inside the Tower walls.
It was the morning of May 27, 1541.
The woman they came for had been a prisoner in the Tower for a year and a half, and under sentence of death for two years, and in all that time nobody had told her when.
Now an officer stood in front of her and told her that she would die within the hour.
She was sixty-seven years old.
She was the daughter of a royal duke, the niece of two kings, the cousin of a queen, the godmother and former governess of the king’s own daughter.
She was the last person in England who carried the name of the dynasty that had ruled the country for more than three hundred years before the Tudors.
Her name was Margaret Pole, Countess of Salisbury.
People sometimes call her the last of the Plantagenets.
She answered the officer that she did not know what crime she had committed.
She had never been tried.
She had never been allowed to answer the charges in front of anyone.
But she got up, and dressed, and walked out with them.
There was no great scaffold waiting for her, draped in black, the way there had been for Anne Boleyn five years before.
There was only a low block of wood set on the ground inside the Tower precincts, and a small crowd, perhaps a hundred and fifty people, gathered to watch in the early light.
The man who should have been waiting by the block, the regular executioner of London, was not there.
He was away in the north, busy with other prisoners.
In his place stood someone else, a young man who had never done anything like this before.
What happened in the next few minutes horrified the hardened diplomats who heard about it, and it still has the power to shock nearly five hundred years later.
But the story of Margaret Pole does not really begin on that grass.
It begins in another fortress, with another family, and a little girl whose father died inside the same walls when she was not yet five.
And it ends with a line of verse that someone, at some point, scratched into the stone of a prison wall.
Nobody knows who wrote it.
Everybody who reads it knows who it was written about.
—
## The little girl whose father died in the Tower
Margaret was born on August 14, 1473, at Farleigh Castle in Somerset.
Her father was George, Duke of Clarence, the younger brother of King Edward IV.
Her mother was Isabel Neville, daughter of the great Earl of Warwick, the man people called the Kingmaker.
On paper, she could not have been born into a grander family.
In reality, she was born into the middle of a family feud that would destroy almost everyone in it.
Her father was a charming, unstable, ambitious man who had already betrayed his brother once, joining the Kingmaker’s rebellion, and then switched sides again.
In December 1476, when Margaret was three, her mother died after giving birth to another child.
Clarence was convinced she had been poisoned by one of her servants.
He had the woman seized, tried and hanged in a matter of hours.
It was an act of private vengeance carried out with the trappings of law, and it frightened his brother the king.
By the start of 1478, Clarence himself was in the Tower of London, charged with treason against Edward IV.
On February 18, 1478, he was put to death in private inside the Tower.
How exactly he died has never been certain.
Within a few years, a story was going around that has been repeated ever since: that the duke had been drowned in a barrel of malmsey, the sweet wine he loved.
Whether that is true or a dark joke that became history, nobody knows.
Margaret was four years old.
She and her little brother Edward were now orphans, in the care of a royal uncle who had just put their father to death.
—
## The brother they kept for fourteen years
Margaret’s brother Edward was two years younger than she was.
As the son of the Duke of Clarence, he carried the title Earl of Warwick.
And as long as he lived, he was a problem for every king who sat on the throne of England.
Because of their father’s treason, the children had technically been barred from the succession.
But barriers like that could be lifted, and everyone knew it.
When Edward IV died in 1483 and his brother Richard III took the crown, little Edward of Warwick was one of the people Richard watched most carefully.
When Henry Tudor killed Richard at Bosworth in 1485, one of his very first acts was to send for the ten-year-old earl.
The boy was brought to London and put in the Tower.
He never came out again as a free man.
For fourteen years, Edward of Warwick lived inside the walls of the fortress.
He grew from a child into a young man without, apparently, ever being allowed a proper education or any real contact with the world outside.
One chronicler later wrote that he had been kept so long out of the company of men and beasts that he could hardly tell a goose from a capon.
Whether that is cruel exaggeration or a real description, it tells you how people saw him.
And he was a symbol.
In 1487, a boy named Lambert Simnel was crowned in Dublin as Edward, Earl of Warwick, by Yorkist rebels.
Henry VII had to bring the real Edward out of the Tower and parade him through London to prove that the pretender was a fake.
Then he put him back.
In the 1490s, another pretender, Perkin Warbeck, claimed to be one of the lost princes in the Tower, and he, too, ended up a prisoner in the fortress.
In 1499, the two young men were accused of plotting to escape together.
It was very convenient for the king.
At that very moment, Henry VII was negotiating the marriage of his son Arthur to Catherine of Aragon, daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain.
The Spanish monarchs had made it clear that they wanted no rival claimants left alive to threaten their daughter’s future.
In November 1499, Perkin Warbeck was hanged at Tyburn.
On November 28, Edward, Earl of Warwick, twenty-four years old and the last legitimate male of the house of York, was led out and put to death on Tower Hill.
Years later, Catherine of Aragon is said to have remarked that her marriage had been made in blood.
Margaret Pole was twenty-six.
She had now lost her mother, her father and her brother to the same quarrel over the crown.
And she was about to become a close friend of the Spanish princess whose wedding her brother’s death had helped to clear.
—
## The poor widow Henry VIII made a countess
Henry VII had dealt with Margaret differently from her brother.
She was a girl, and girls could be married safely.
Around 1487 he married her to Sir Richard Pole, a loyal Welsh-border knight who happened to be a relative of the king’s own mother, Margaret Beaufort.
It was a careful match.
It gave Margaret a respectable husband and kept her firmly inside the Tudor family circle, without giving her any of the power her birth might have suggested.
The Poles had five children who survived: Henry, Geoffrey, Arthur, Reginald and a daughter, Ursula.
Sir Richard became chamberlain to Prince Arthur, and when Arthur and Catherine of Aragon went to Ludlow in 1501, the Pole family was close to the young couple.
Then, in 1502, Arthur died.
In 1504, Sir Richard Pole died too.
Margaret was in her early thirties, a widow with five children and very little money.
For a while she was so poor that she gave one of her sons, Reginald, to the church, sending him to be educated by the monks of the Charterhouse at Sheen.
It was a common enough choice for a widow with too many sons and too little money.
It would turn out to be the most important decision she ever made.
The quiet boy sent to the Carthusians would grow into the man who brought the whole house down.
She seems to have lived quietly, some of the time in a religious house.
Her fortunes changed when Henry VIII came to the throne in 1509.
The young king married Catherine of Aragon, and Catherine had not forgotten her friends from Ludlow.
Margaret became one of the new queen’s ladies.
And in 1513, Henry VIII did something remarkable.
He restored to her the great earldom of Salisbury, which had belonged to her mother’s family, and made her Countess of Salisbury in her own right.
She was one of only two women in sixteenth-century England to hold a peerage in her own right.
Overnight, the poor widow became one of the richest landowners in the country, with estates across the south and west and a great house at Warblington in Hampshire.
The king, it seems, genuinely liked and respected her.
He is said to have called her the holiest woman in England.
He made her son Henry a baron, Lord Montagu.
He paid for Reginald’s education at Oxford and in Italy.
It looked, for more than twenty years, as if the Tudors and the last of the Plantagenets had made their peace.
—
## “A second mother”
In 1516, Catherine of Aragon finally gave Henry VIII a living child.
It was a daughter, Mary.
Margaret Pole stood as one of her godmothers.
In 1520, she was appointed governess of the little princess, in charge of her household.
When Mary was sent to Ludlow in 1525 to preside over the Council of the Marches, as her uncle Arthur had once done, the countess went too.
For a girl who saw her parents only occasionally, Margaret became the steady center of her life.
The princess’s household at Ludlow was a small court in its own right, with officers, chaplains, schoolmasters and ladies.
Mary studied Latin and French, music and scripture.
She was taught to ride, to dance, to receive ambassadors and to sit through formal dinners under a canopy of state.
The governess oversaw it all.
She managed the household’s money, chose its servants, watched the girl’s health, and reported to the king and queen.
Mary later called her a second mother.
Then the king’s marriage began to fall apart.
Henry wanted a son and wanted Anne Boleyn, and by the early 1530s he had decided that his marriage to Catherine had never been lawful.
In 1533, he married Anne.
Catherine was demoted to princess dowager.
Mary was declared a bastard.
Her household was broken up, and she was sent to serve as a lady-in-waiting to her new baby half-sister, Elizabeth.
Margaret Pole was ordered to hand over Mary’s jewels and plate.
She refused.
She offered instead to go on serving the girl at her own expense, with her own servants.
It was a brave, loyal and dangerous thing to do.
The offer was rejected.
Margaret was sent away from the princess.
For the first time, Henry VIII had a reason to think of the countess as being on the other side.
—
## The book that doomed a family
The real disaster came from Margaret’s own son.
Reginald Pole was by now a brilliant scholar who had spent years in Italy, with the king’s money paying for his education.
Henry expected him to come home and support the divorce, and the break with Rome.
Reginald would not.
In 1536, from abroad, he sent the king a long Latin treatise usually known as “De Unitate,” “On the Unity of the Church.”
It was a ferocious attack.
He compared Henry to a robber and a murderer.
He called him a greater enemy to Christianity than the Turk.
He urged the princes of Europe to act against him.
The same year, Reginald was made a cardinal of the Roman Church.
When the great rebellion called the Pilgrimage of Grace broke out in the north of England in late 1536, the pope sent Reginald to the Low Countries to see if he could help it.
To Henry VIII, this was treason in its purest form, by a man he had paid for, from a family he had raised up.
He could not reach Reginald.
He tried.
He demanded that foreign rulers hand the cardinal over.
When Reginald traveled north to the Low Countries in 1537, the English government pressed the authorities there to arrest him or send him away, and he had to keep moving to stay safe.
Agents were sent abroad, and there were plots to kidnap or kill the cardinal.
None of them worked.
But the rest of the Pole family was still in England.
Margaret, it is said, told her household that she considered her son a traitor and wished he had never been born.
Whether she meant it, or whether she was saying it because she knew who was listening, it did not save anybody.
—
## The son who broke in the Tower
In August 1538, the king’s men arrested Margaret’s youngest son, Sir Geoffrey Pole.
He was taken to the Tower and questioned about his brother the cardinal, his brother Lord Montagu, his cousin the Marquess of Exeter, and anyone else he had talked to.
Geoffrey was not a strong man.
In the Tower, under questioning and in terror, he tried to kill himself.
He survived.
And then he talked.
What he said was mostly loose words: complaints about the king, sympathy for the old religion, approving remarks about his brother Reginald, hopes that things might one day change.
But in the hands of Thomas Cromwell, loose words were enough.
In November 1538, Lord Montagu, Margaret’s eldest son, was arrested, along with Henry Courtenay, Marquess of Exeter, the king’s own first cousin.
Exeter was the son of Princess Katherine of York, sister of Henry VIII’s mother.
He had grown up with the king.
Both men were accused of plotting to put Cardinal Pole and the old faith back in power.
Exeter’s wife, Gertrude, Marchioness of Exeter, was arrested too and sent to the Tower, where she stayed for a year and a half before she was released.
Their letters were searched, their servants questioned, their conversations at dinner reconstructed by informers.
Words about the king’s health, about the succession, about how things might change one day, were turned into evidence of a plot.
Historians call it the Exeter Conspiracy, and most doubt it was a real conspiracy at all.
On January 9, 1539, Lord Montagu and the Marquess of Exeter were put to death on Tower Hill.
Their friend Sir Nicholas Carew, the king’s own master of the horse and childhood companion, followed them that March.
Geoffrey Pole was pardoned.
He lived the rest of his life with the knowledge that his evidence had helped send his brother to the block.
And Margaret?
Margaret had been arrested in November too.
—
## Three days of questions at Cowdray
They did not take the countess to the Tower at first.
She was held at her house at Warblington, and then taken to Cowdray, in Sussex, the grand house of William FitzWilliam, Earl of Southampton, one of the king’s most trusted councillors.
There, Southampton and Thomas Goodrich, Bishop of Ely, questioned her for days.
They went over everything.
Her letters.
Her servants.
Her sons.
What she knew of Reginald, what she had said about him, whether she had sent him money or messages.
What she thought of the king’s marriage, the break with Rome, the destruction of the monasteries.
Her household was questioned too.
Her chaplain, her servants, the gentlemen who managed her estates: each was asked who had come to Warblington, who had carried letters, what had been said at dinner about the king’s new laws.
Her son Geoffrey’s confessions were read to her, and she was asked to explain things he had said about her.
At one point, it was alleged that she had forbidden her tenants to read the new English Bible, or had burned letters before they could be found.
She denied what she could and explained what she could not deny.
She was a woman of sixty-five who had lost almost everything already.
She did not break.
The two men wrote to Cromwell in frustration.
They had dealt with her, they said, in every way they could think of, gently and harshly, and they could get nothing from her.
They said she was more like a strong and constant man than a woman.
They meant it as a complaint.
It reads, five centuries later, as one of the finest compliments any Tudor woman ever received.
—
## The tunic in the chest
When questions did not work, evidence was found.
In the spring of 1539, while the countess was still a prisoner at Cowdray, Thomas Cromwell stood up in the House of Lords and produced an object.
It was a tunic of white silk, embroidered on the front with the arms of England and on the back with the Five Wounds of Christ.
The Five Wounds had been the badge of the rebels of the Pilgrimage of Grace.
The tunic, Cromwell said, had been found among the countess’s belongings at Warblington.
It proved, he argued, that she sympathized with rebellion and with the cause of her son the cardinal.
Many historians have doubted it.
The tunic was found months after her house had first been searched.
The connection between a piece of embroidery and an actual plot was never shown.
But it did not need to be.
In May 1539, Parliament passed an act of attainder against Margaret Pole.
An attainder was a law aimed at named people.
It declared them guilty of treason, condemned them to death and seized their property, all without a trial.
She was never brought before a court.
She was never allowed to see the evidence or answer it.
Her titles were taken from her.
She was no longer the Countess of Salisbury.
She was simply Lady Margaret Pole, a condemned traitor.
And then, for reasons nobody has ever fully explained, nothing happened.
The king did not sign the order for her death.
Instead, in November 1539, she was moved to the Tower of London.
—
## Two winters in the Tower
The Tower was not new to her family.
Her father had died there.
Her brother had spent fourteen years there.
Now she arrived as a prisoner in her own right.
What that meant depended, as everything in Tudor England did, on who you were.
The Tower was a royal palace, an armory, a mint, a zoo and a prison, all at once.
For prisoners of rank, imprisonment usually meant a set of rooms in one of the towers along the walls.
They had beds, chairs, a table, perhaps a few books.
They could have servants, if they or their families paid for them.
They paid for their own food, fuel and candles, and the lieutenant of the Tower made money from supplying them.
Some famous prisoners lived in the Tower for years in this way; much later, Sir Walter Raleigh would write a whole history of the world during his long confinement there.
For ordinary prisoners, it could be very different.
The lower chambers of the fortress were cold stone rooms with little light and less comfort.
Damp came up from the river.
Rats came up with it, through drains and gaps in the masonry.
In winter, the cold got into everything: the walls, the floor, the straw, the bones.
And there was the other side of the Tower, the side that gave it its terrible reputation.
Torture was not part of English common law.
But the king’s council could issue a special warrant allowing prisoners to be questioned under pain, and in the reigns of Henry VIII and his children, such warrants were signed.
The most notorious instrument was the rack, which stretched a prisoner’s body until joints gave way.
There were manacles that hung prisoners by their wrists from the wall.
There was a cramped cell called Little Ease, too small to stand or lie down in.
And there was an iron device, invented in Henry VIII’s reign by a lieutenant of the Tower named Skeffington, that crushed a prisoner into a ball; with grim humor, it was called Skeffington’s daughter, which turned in common speech into the scavenger’s daughter.
These things were real.
But they were used on far fewer people than legend suggests, almost always men of humble rank suspected of plots, and only with written authority.
There is no evidence at all that they were ever used on Margaret Pole.
What was done to her was quieter.
She was left to wait.
She was not alone.
Held in the Tower with her were two boys: her grandson Henry, the young son of the executed Lord Montagu, and Edward Courtenay, the son of the executed Marquess of Exeter.
The boys were in their early teens.
Their fathers had been put to death.
Their only crime was their blood.
They seem to have been allowed some lessons and some exercise.
There are records of a tutor for at least one of them.
But they lived as prisoners, growing up within sight of the place where their fathers had died.
For the old woman, they must have been both a comfort and a constant grief: two boys who reminded her every day of the sons and the nephew she had lost.
The months went by.
Thomas Cromwell, the man who had produced the tunic, fell from power in June 1540 and was brought to the Tower himself.
In July he was put to death on Tower Hill.
The countess was still there.
The Tower in winter was bitterly cold.
The old woman did not have enough clothes.
In March 1541, someone at court noticed.
Records show that warm clothing was ordered for her that spring: a nightgown furred, a kirtle, a petticoat, hose, shoes and slippers, and bonnets.
Some historians believe the order came from the new young queen, Catherine Howard.
Others say it was the king’s own decision.
Either way, it suggests that someone at the top still thought of her as a person who might live a while longer.
They were wrong.
In April 1541, a new rising broke out in Yorkshire.
It was small and quickly put down, but it frightened the king badly, coming only five years after the Pilgrimage of Grace.
Rebels in the north had always looked to the old families.
The Poles were the oldest of them all.
Henry VIII was planning to travel north that summer, the first time in his reign he would go there.
He did not intend to leave the last Plantagenet behind him in London, alive.
—
## The morning of May 27, 1541
It was early, perhaps seven o’clock.
The sun was up but the air still had the chill of the river.
Margaret Pole was told she would die within the hour.
According to the imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, who wrote the most detailed account, she found the news very strange.
She said she did not know what crime she was accused of, nor how she had deserved such a death.
But she did not resist.
She came out of her lodgings and was taken to the place inside the Tower precincts where it would be done.
There was no high scaffold.
There was only a low block of wood on the ground.
It was a small affair by royal standards.
About a hundred and fifty people were there, Chapuys says, including the Lord Mayor of London.
They stood back on the grass and watched an old woman in a plain gown being led toward them.
She was tall for a woman of her age, if the later evidence of her bones is right.
She walked without help.
She said her prayers.
And then, according to the reports that reached the ambassadors, she did something that tells you everything about who she was.
It is worth pausing on the people in that crowd.
They were not a mob.
They were officials of the city and the Tower, servants, guards, a few curious onlookers who had heard there would be an execution that morning.
Some of them would have been old enough to remember her father’s death in 1478, or her brother’s on Tower Hill in 1499.
To them she was not just a condemned prisoner.
She was the last living link to a whole vanished world, the world of Edward IV and the house of York, of the Kingmaker and the Wars of the Roses.
They were watching the end of it.
She asked those standing there to pray for the king.
For the queen.
For Prince Edward.
And for the Princess Mary, her goddaughter, the girl she had raised.
She commended her soul to God.
Then she knelt, or was made to kneel, at the low block.
The young man who had been sent to do the work stepped forward.
He had, it seems, no idea what he was doing.
The regular executioner was in the north, dealing with the prisoners from the Yorkshire rising.
The Tower had sent for someone else, and the someone else was, in Chapuys’s words, a wretched and blundering youth.
What followed was not quick.
Chapuys, who did not see it himself but heard it from people who had, wrote that the young man hacked at her head and shoulders in the most pitiful manner.
It took more than one stroke.
It took several.
We do not need to imagine it in detail, and it would be wrong to.
What matters is what the witnesses felt, and what the reports say they felt was horror.
The crowd watched an old woman die slowly and badly on the grass because the king had not troubled to send for a man who knew his trade.
Many in that crowd must have turned their faces away.
The Lord Mayor of London was among them.
When it was over, the body was taken into the little church of St. Peter ad Vincula, a few steps away, and buried.
She was sixty-seven years old.
Her father had died inside these walls.
Her brother had died outside them.
Her son had died on the hill beyond the moat two years earlier.
Now it was her turn, and with her death, there was no one left in England who could call themselves a Plantagenet of the old royal line in the direct sense that she could.
The grandson who had shared her imprisonment, young Henry Pole, stayed behind in the Tower.
He was last mentioned in the records some time after his grandmother’s death.
Then he disappeared.
No one knows what became of him.
The other boy, Edward Courtenay, was kept in the Tower for fifteen years, until Mary I set him free in 1553.
—
## The women who died inside the walls
Most people put to death for treason in Tudor London died in public, on Tower Hill outside the fortress, in front of thousands.
A few were spared the crowd.
Within the Tower precincts, out of sight of the city, only a handful of people were ever put to death, and most of them were women.
Anne Boleyn, in May 1536.
Margaret Pole, in May 1541.
Catherine Howard and Jane Boleyn, Lady Rochford, in February 1542.
Lady Jane Grey, in February 1554.
The privacy was presented as a courtesy to rank.
It was also a precaution.
A queen or a great lady dying in front of a London crowd could stir up sympathy, and sympathy could turn into something else.
Inside the walls, the crown controlled who saw and who heard.
In Margaret Pole’s case, it did not entirely work.
The story of what happened on the grass that morning was all over London within days, and within weeks it was in the dispatches of ambassadors to the courts of Europe.
Within months, the woman who may have ordered the countess’s warm clothes would be under arrest herself.
That summer, Henry VIII set out on his great progress to the north, taking his young queen with him.
It was on that journey that some of Catherine Howard’s secret meetings with Thomas Culpeper took place.
By February 1542, she too was buried in the chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula, a few feet from the old countess.
—
## The countess who would not kneel
Over the next century, the story of Margaret Pole’s death grew.
In 1649, the historian Lord Herbert of Cherbury published a life of Henry VIII that included a version of her final moments that has been repeated ever since.
In Herbert’s story, the old countess refused to put her head on the block.
She told the executioner that so should traitors do, and she was none.
She turned her head every way.
And the executioner, the story goes, had to strike at her where he could, and some versions have her running, and him chasing her around the block.
It is a powerful image: the last Plantagenet, defiant to the end, refusing to cooperate in her own death.
It is almost certainly not what happened.
The closest contemporary accounts, including Chapuys’s, describe her praying and asking for prayers for the royal family.
They describe an incompetent executioner, not a running prisoner.
The defiant countess seems to belong to the next century, not to the grass of May 1541.
There is another legend too.
On the wall of one of the Tower’s prison chambers, there is said to have been a short verse, carved into the stone and attributed to her:
“For traitors on the block should die;
I am no traitor, no, not I!
My faithfulness stands fast and so,
Towards the block I shall not go!”
Whether she ever wrote it, or anyone in the sixteenth century wrote it, is very doubtful.
But it says something important.
People who heard her story wanted her to have refused.
They wanted her to have said no to the king at least once.
—
## “The son of a martyr”
Far away, in Italy, Cardinal Reginald Pole heard the news of his mother’s death.
His response was recorded.
He said that until then he had thought himself the son of one of the best and most honored ladies in England, and that now he was the son of a martyr.
He shut himself away to pray.
He never forgave Henry VIII, and he never stopped working against the religious changes the king had made.
He outlived the king.
When Mary I, the girl his mother had raised, became queen in 1553, she brought him home.
He became Archbishop of Canterbury, the head of the Catholic Church in England, in 1556.
He died on November 17, 1558, the same day as Mary herself.
For a moment, at the very end, the Poles and the Tudors went to their graves together.
Mary did what she could for her governess’s memory.
She restored some of the family’s lands and honors to Margaret’s surviving relatives.
She released Edward Courtenay from the Tower.
But nothing could change what had happened on the grass.
Three centuries later, the Catholic Church gave its own verdict.
In 1886, Pope Leo XIII beatified Margaret Pole as a martyr.
She is known in the Catholic Church as Blessed Margaret Pole, and her feast is kept on May 28.
—
## What they found under the chapel floor
There was one more chapter.
In 1876, Queen Victoria ordered the restoration of the chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula, where so many of the Tower’s victims had been buried.
When the floor of the chancel was lifted, the workmen found the remains of many people, jumbled together after centuries of burials and rebuilding.
A committee of experts, including a doctor, examined the bones.
Among them, they believed, were the remains of a tall, elderly woman with strong bones.
They concluded, cautiously, that these might be the bones of Margaret Pole.
Like the identifications made for Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard at the same time, it could not be proved.
The remains were placed back under the floor, in a new arrangement, with their names marked on the marble above.
If you visit the chapel today, you can see her name there, among the queens.
—
## No traitor, no, not I
Go back to that first scene.
An officer at the door, early in the morning.
An old woman being told she will die within the hour, and answering that she does not know what she has done.
Her father had died in the Tower without a public trial.
Her brother had died on Tower Hill so that a Spanish princess could marry an English prince.
Two of her sons and her cousin had been destroyed because of words.
And she herself had been condemned by an act of Parliament, on the strength of an embroidered tunic, without ever being allowed to say a word in her own defense.
Whether or not she ever carved a line of verse into a prison wall, the verse says what the record says.
She was never shown to be a traitor.
She was simply the last of a family that Henry VIII could not bear to leave alive.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Margaret Pole was born on August 14, 1473, and died inside the precincts of the Tower of London on May 27, 1541, at the age of sixty-seven.
Her father, George, Duke of Clarence, died in the Tower in 1478; the story that he was drowned in a butt of malmsey wine is a contemporary rumor, not a proven fact.
Her brother Edward, Earl of Warwick, was held in the Tower from 1485 and put to death on November 28, 1499.
Her creation as Countess of Salisbury in her own right in 1513, her role as governess to Princess Mary, and Mary’s description of her as a second mother are well documented.
Henry VIII’s reported remark that she was the holiest woman in England comes from later accounts and cannot be confirmed in his own words.
Her questioning at Cowdray by the Earl of Southampton and the Bishop of Ely, and their report that she was “rather a strong and constant man, than a woman,” come from their letters to Cromwell.
The silk tunic with the Five Wounds was presented by Cromwell as evidence; its discovery and significance have been doubted by historians.
She was attainted by act of Parliament in May 1539 and never tried.
The order for warm clothing in March 1541 is recorded in the royal accounts; who instigated it is unclear.
The details of her death come mainly from the dispatches of the imperial ambassador Eustace Chapuys, who wrote that she was killed by “a wretched and blundering youth” who “hacked her head and shoulders to pieces in the most pitiful manner.”
Chapuys was not an eyewitness.
The story that she refused to kneel and ran from the executioner comes from Lord Herbert of Cherbury’s history of 1649 and is considered a legend.
The verse beginning “For traitors on the block should die” is traditionally attributed to her but there is no reliable evidence that she wrote it.
Reginald Pole’s words about being “the son of a martyr” are recorded in his letters.
The identification of her remains during the 1876 restoration of St. Peter ad Vincula was tentative.
The fate of her grandson Henry Pole after about 1542 is unknown.
The general account of conditions in the Tower draws on what is known of high-ranking prisoners in the period; the instruments of torture described by some popular histories were used on a much smaller number of prisoners than legend suggests, and there is no record of Margaret Pole being tortured.