News

Why You Wouldn’t Survive One Day As Henry VIII’s Wife in Tudor England

Six women married Henry VIII.

Two of them saw their marriages declared void.

Two of them died by the sword or the axe inside the walls of the Tower of London.

One died less than two weeks after giving him the son he had wanted for almost thirty years.

And one was still his wife on the night he died, which is the only reason anyone calls her the survivor.

Schoolchildren learn it as a rhyme.

Divorced, beheaded, died.

Divorced, beheaded, survived.

It sounds almost cheerful when you say it fast.

But try saying it slowly, and imagine that you are the next name on the list.

Because the day you became Henry’s queen, your body stopped being your own.

It became a matter of state.

Your letters could be opened.

Your servants could be paid to report on you.

The woman who laced your gown in the morning might be the woman who testified against you in the spring.

And a single careless sentence over supper, repeated in the wrong ear, could carry you down the river to the Tower.

So forget the fairy tale of gowns and castles for a moment.

Step into the real thing.

—

## A kingdom of smoke and sewage

The England you would be ruling beside him was not the England of the costume dramas.

The banquets and jousts were real, but they were only the bright half of the picture.

The other half was dirt, fear and disease.

London at the start of Henry’s reign held perhaps fifty thousand people, and it grew fast as the century went on.

They lived packed into narrow lanes where waste ran down open channels in the street.

Plague came back again and again, sometimes killing thousands in a single season.

Then there was the sweat.

The sweating sickness was a fever nobody understood, and it could take a healthy man at breakfast and bury him before supper.

In the summer of 1528 it struck so hard that Henry himself fled London, moving from house to house with a small household.

—

## The palace was no shelter

The royal palaces looked magnificent from the outside.

Hampton Court, the great house Henry took from Cardinal Thomas Wolsey, grew into a vast warren often said to hold around a thousand rooms.

Those rooms were heated by open fires, and stone does not warm easily.

Rushes and sweet herbs were strewn across the floors to soften the damp and cover the smells.

The kitchens alone employed around two hundred people.

This was the setting.

Now picture yourself dropped into the middle of it.

As the most watched, most discussed and most politically exposed person in the entire kingdom.

—

## The spare who became king

The story begins with a man who was never meant to wear the crown.

Henry was the second son of Henry VII.

The heir was his older brother, Arthur, Prince of Wales.

In November 1501, at Old St Paul’s Cathedral in London, Arthur married a Spanish princess, Catherine of Aragon, the daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella.

He was fifteen.

She was a few weeks short of her sixteenth birthday.

Then, less than five months later, in April 1502, Arthur was dead at Ludlow Castle on the Welsh border.

Suddenly the spare was the heir.

And along with the title, he was in line to inherit something else: his brother’s widow.

Henry VII did not want to lose the Spanish alliance, or the rest of Catherine’s dowry.

Catherine would marry the younger brother instead.

Church law forbade a man to marry his brother’s widow, and the prohibition was rooted in the Book of Leviticus.

A special dispensation from the Pope was needed.

It was granted, and Catherine always swore, to the end of her life, that her marriage to Arthur had never been consummated.

Years went by, the old king died, and in June 1509 the new king, Henry VIII, finally married her.

He was seventeen.

She was twenty-three.

And for a long time, it worked.

—

## The queen who ran a war

Catherine of Aragon was nobody’s ornament.

She was clever, well educated, deeply devout and politically skilled.

When Henry crossed to France to make war in 1513, he left her as regent of England.

While he was away, the King of Scots, James IV, invaded from the north.

Catherine threw herself into organizing the defense, raising men and supplies and sending them north.

On the 9th of September 1513, an English army under the Earl of Surrey met the Scots at Flodden.

Something like ten thousand Scots died, and the dead included King James himself.

Catherine wrote to Henry and sent him a piece of the dead king’s bloodstained coat as a trophy of the victory.

But none of it counted for much in the end.

Because in Tudor England, the one task that truly mattered for a queen was to give the king a living son.

—

## The birthing chamber

Catherine was pregnant at least six times between 1509 and 1518.

Her first child, a daughter, was stillborn.

Then, on New Year’s Day 1511, she gave birth to a boy.

He was named Henry, and the country went wild with joy.

He lived for fifty-two days.

After him came more losses, one after another, a long, cruel cycle of hope and grief.

There was no understanding of infection.

There was nothing a physician could do if a baby was turned the wrong way, or if bleeding would not stop.

Modern estimates suggest that a woman might die in something like one or two births in every hundred, and every pregnancy rolled those dice again.

A queen’s confinement followed strict ritual.

Weeks before the birth she “took her chamber,” withdrawing into rooms hung thick with tapestries.

The windows were covered.

Fresh air and daylight were kept out.

Only women attended her: midwives, ladies of her household, armed with prayers, herbs and holy relics believed to ease the labor.

When things went wrong, and they often did, there was very little anyone could do but pray.

—

## A daughter was not enough

Only one of Catherine’s children lived to grow up.

Her name was Mary, and she was born in February 1516.

To Henry, a daughter was not a solution.

England had not had a reigning queen since the troubled days of Matilda, four centuries earlier, and that experiment had ended in civil war.

The Tudors themselves had come to the throne on a battlefield.

The Wars of the Roses, the long struggle between the houses of York and Lancaster, had been settled at Bosworth in 1485, just twenty-four years before Henry’s coronation.

Without a son to follow him, Henry feared it would all come back.

By the late 1520s Catherine was in her forties.

They had been married for nearly twenty years.

There would be no prince.

And Henry had already found someone else.

—

## The woman who said no

Anne Boleyn was nothing like the simple seductress of popular legend.

She had spent years abroad, first at the court of Margaret of Austria in the Low Countries and then in France, at one of the most polished courts in Europe.

She spoke excellent French.

Her sister, Mary Boleyn, had already been Henry’s mistress, and Henry had moved on from her.

Anne would not repeat that story.

She refused to become his mistress.

She would be queen, or nothing.

For years Henry argued that by marrying his brother’s widow he had broken God’s law, and that the dead children were God’s judgment on it.

The Pope would not give him what he wanted.

So Henry broke with Rome.

In 1534 the Act of Supremacy declared the king Supreme Head of the Church of England.

A thousand years of tradition, more or less, set aside so that one man could change wives.

—

## Cross the king and you die

Refusing to accept the new order could cost you your life.

Thomas More had been Lord Chancellor of England and one of the most admired scholars in Europe.

He had resigned the office rather than support the king’s course, and then he refused to swear the oath the new laws demanded.

He was tried for treason in July 1535.

The trial took a single day.

More himself said that the key testimony against him, from the king’s solicitor Richard Rich, was false.

He was beheaded on Tower Hill.

Bishop John Fisher of Rochester had refused as well.

He went to the same block two weeks before More.

The message to everyone at court was simple.

It did not matter whether you were a stranger in the street, the king’s old friend, or his former chancellor.

Cross Henry, and you would die.

—

## The queen in exile

And what of Catherine of Aragon?

In the summer of 1531 Henry rode away from Windsor and left her behind, and she never saw him again.

She was moved from one house to another, each one smaller and more remote, until she ended up at Kimbolton Castle, in what was then Huntingdonshire.

She was forbidden to see her daughter, Mary.

She was stripped of the title of queen and was supposed to be called only the Princess Dowager, as Arthur’s widow.

She died at Kimbolton on the 7th of January 1536.

She was fifty years old.

Rumors of poison followed her death for years, but the embalmer reported a dark growth on her heart, and most historians now think she died of cancer.

She had served Henry faithfully for more than two decades.

He had not seen her in four and a half years.

—

## A girl, again

Anne married Henry in secret in January 1533, and she was already pregnant.

The marriage to Catherine was declared void that spring.

Anne was crowned in June, heavily pregnant, in a great ceremony at Westminster.

Then, on the 7th of September 1533, at Greenwich Palace, Anne gave birth.

It was a girl.

Her name was Elizabeth, and she would one day become one of the greatest monarchs England ever had.

But at that moment she was a disappointment.

The letters announcing the birth had already been written to say “prince,” and an extra letter “s” had to be squeezed in to make it “princess.”

And from that day on, Anne’s queenship became a kind of horror story played out in slow motion.

—

## Watched every hour

Once you were Henry’s wife, you were not simply a wife any more.

You were watched.

The man who mattered most in those years was Thomas Cromwell, the king’s chief minister.

Cromwell ran a remarkable web of informants and correspondents.

Letters were intercepted and copied.

Some of the people around a queen owed their places to men who wanted to know what she was doing.

And the law made all of this deadly.

For almost two hundred years, it had been treason in England to “compass or imagine” the death of the king.

In 1534, a new Treason Act went further.

Now it was treason to wish or desire harm to the king by words or by writing, or to call him a heretic or a tyrant.

You did not have to plot anything at all.

If someone swore that you had spoken, even idly, about what might happen when the king died, that could be enough to kill you.

—

## Spring 1536

So put yourself in Anne Boleyn’s place at the beginning of 1536.

You have given the king a daughter, not a son.

You have lost at least one pregnancy since, and in January, just days after Catherine of Aragon’s death, you miscarry again.

The child, people whisper, would have been a boy.

Your husband is paying open attention to one of your own ladies-in-waiting, a quiet young woman named Jane Seymour.

And Thomas Cromwell, the man who helped you rise, has decided you are in his way.

The two of you have clashed over foreign policy, and over the money pouring in from the closing of the monasteries, which you wanted spent on education and charity rather than on the crown.

What happened next looks less like justice and more like a carefully staged destruction.

On the 2nd of May 1536, Anne was arrested at Greenwich and taken by barge up the Thames to the Tower of London.

She was accused of adultery with five men.

One of them was her own brother, George Boleyn, Lord Rochford.

She was accused of plotting the king’s death with her supposed lovers.

You will often read that she was charged with witchcraft too, but that was not part of the indictment.

The rumor grew from a remark Henry was reported to have made, that he had been seduced into the marriage by charms and spells.

—

## A trial with only one possible ending

The evidence was very thin, and much of it may have been invented.

Historians who have checked the dates in the indictment have found that on many of the days named, Anne was somewhere else entirely.

Only one of the men confessed.

He was Mark Smeaton, a young musician of humble birth, questioned at Cromwell’s house in Stepney.

Whether he was tortured or only threatened is still argued about, but nobody believes his confession came freely.

The other four men denied everything to the end.

It made no difference.

Anne was tried by a court of her fellow peers, with her own uncle, the Duke of Norfolk, presiding as Lord High Steward.

The verdict was guilty.

On the 19th of May 1536, she was brought out to a scaffold inside the walls of the Tower.

She made a short speech in which she praised the king.

Her daughter was still alive, and criticizing Henry in her last moments could have harmed the people she was leaving behind.

An expert swordsman had been brought over from Calais, so that she would die by a single stroke of a sword rather than the English axe.

She was around thirty-five years old, though her exact birth year is uncertain.

She had been queen for a little over three years.

No coffin had been prepared.

Her body was laid in an old elm chest and buried in the chapel of St Peter ad Vincula, inside the Tower.

—

## Eleven days

Henry was not at the Tower that morning.

There is a famous story that he was out hunting, waiting to hear the guns that would tell him it was done, but that is a later legend.

On the day after Anne’s death, he was formally betrothed to Jane Seymour.

On the 30th of May, eleven days after the execution, he married her.

Whatever Henry privately believed about the charges against Anne, that gap tells you exactly what a queen was to him.

You were useful.

When you stopped being useful, you could be replaced.

And your replacement was usually already standing in the room.

—

## Bound to obey and serve

Jane Seymour is often called the wife Henry loved most.

Where Anne had been bold, Jane was quiet.

Where Anne had argued, Jane deferred.

Her chosen motto said it all: “Bound to obey and serve.”

She had watched what happened to the woman before her, and she seems to have decided that silence was the only safe strategy.

She did try, once, to plead with Henry on behalf of the monasteries during the great northern rising of 1536.

According to one report from court, he told her not to meddle in his affairs and reminded her of what had happened to her predecessor.

And then Jane did the one thing that mattered.

On the 12th of October 1537, at Hampton Court, she gave birth to a son.

His name was Edward, and he would become Edward VI.

—

## A son, and a funeral

The celebrations were enormous.

Bonfires were lit across London.

But the birth had been terrible.

Jane had been in labor for two days and three nights.

A story later spread that Henry had told the doctors to save the child at the mother’s expense.

It is not supported by the evidence.

At first Jane seemed to recover.

But within days she had a fever.

It was very probably an infection picked up during the long delivery, the kind of childbed fever that nobody in the sixteenth century could explain or cure.

She died on the 24th of October 1537, twelve days after her son was born.

She was about twenty-eight years old.

At the end of his life he asked to be buried beside her in St George’s Chapel at Windsor, and he was.

Jane did not die because queens had a special danger in childbirth.

She died because childbirth was dangerous for every woman in England.

The queen’s rooms had finer tapestries and more expensive candles than a merchant’s wife in London or a farmer’s wife in Yorkshire.

The medicine was essentially the same.

—

## Nobody you could trust

A Tudor queen was almost never alone, yet almost none of the people around her could be fully trusted.

Your ladies served you, but they had been placed in your household by families and patrons with interests of their own.

Your closest companion might be the person whose words were read out at your trial.

The case against Anne Boleyn was, by most accounts, set in motion by gossip among her own ladies.

Her sister-in-law, Jane Boleyn, Lady Rochford, is widely believed to have given evidence that was used against her husband, George.

Five years later, the ladies of another queen would give the testimony that destroyed her too.

Friendship at Henry’s court was always provisional.

—

## The wife who walked away

After Jane, Henry married three more times, and each marriage shows a different way he could wreck a woman’s life.

The fourth wife was Anne of Cleves, the sister of the Duke of Cleves, whose lands lay along the lower Rhine.

The match was Cromwell’s idea.

France and the Holy Roman Emperor had just made peace, and England looked dangerously alone.

A marriage to a German duke’s sister promised friends on the Continent.

Henry had never met Anne.

He had seen a portrait by Hans Holbein the Younger, and reports from his envoys praising her.

On New Year’s Day 1540, he burst into her room at Rochester in disguise, as a sort of courtly game.

She did not recognize him, and he did not like what he saw.

According to Cromwell’s later account, the king told him bluntly afterwards, “I like her not.”

The famous insult about a “Flanders mare” comes from a writer more than a century later, not from Henry.

The wedding went ahead on the 6th of January 1540, because cancelling it would have caused a diplomatic disaster.

The marriage, by every account, was never consummated, and Henry complained to his advisers about her in very unkind terms.

That turned out to be Anne’s great good fortune.

When Henry wanted out, a little over six months later, she did not fight.

She agreed that the marriage had never been completed, and in July 1540 it was annulled.

—

## The best deal anyone got

In return, Anne of Cleves received one of the most generous settlements in Tudor history.

She was given Richmond Palace and Hever Castle in Kent, the old Boleyn family home, among other houses, and an income of around four thousand pounds a year.

She was to be honored as “the King’s beloved sister,” ranking above every lady in England except the queen and the king’s own children.

She stayed in England for the rest of her life, by most accounts enjoying herself.

She died at Chelsea in July 1557, at the age of forty-one.

She outlived Henry by ten years.

In fact, she outlived every one of his wives.

She had looked at what happened to Catherine, to Anne and to Jane.

She understood the game, and she quietly left the table.

Just a calm, sensible surrender that saved her life.

—

## The minister who paid for it

Thomas Cromwell was not so lucky.

The Cleves marriage had been his project, and its failure gave his enemies at court the opening they had been waiting for.

On the 10th of June 1540 he was arrested at a council meeting and charged with treason and heresy.

He was beheaded on Tower Hill on the 28th of July 1540.

One chronicler described the man who wielded the axe as a clumsy butcher, and the execution as a bungled one.

Within a year, Henry was complaining that he had been tricked by his councilors into destroying the most faithful servant he ever had.

—

## A girl in a dangerous place

On the same day that Cromwell died, Henry married his fifth wife.

Her name was Catherine Howard.

She was a first cousin of Anne Boleyn and a member of the Howard family, one of the greatest noble houses in England.

Nobody recorded her birth, so her age is uncertain, but she was probably somewhere between fifteen and nineteen when the king noticed her.

Henry was forty-nine.

He was very heavy by now, his armor from these years has an enormous waist, and he was in pain from an ulcer on his leg that would not heal.

The ulcer had troubled him since the late 1520s and grew much worse after his fall at the tilt in 1536.

Catherine had grown up in the household of her step-grandmother, Agnes Howard, the Dowager Duchess of Norfolk, at Horsham in Sussex and at Lambeth.

It was a crowded and poorly supervised house, where many girls of good family slept together in a common chamber.

There, while she was still very young, two older men had pursued her.

One was Henry Manox, the music teacher hired to teach her the virginals.

The other was Francis Dereham, a gentleman of the household.

Older writers treated this as a story of a “wanton” girl.

Many historians today see it very differently, as adult men taking advantage of a young girl with no one to protect her.

—

## The rose without a thorn

Henry was infatuated.

He is said to have called her his “rose without a thorn.”

For about a year, it looked as if Catherine Howard might be the lucky one.

But she was a young woman married to an old, sick, unpredictable man who had already put two wives aside and sent another to the scaffold.

And at some point she began meeting secretly with Thomas Culpeper, a handsome young gentleman of the king’s privy chamber, close to her own age.

One letter she wrote to him survives.

It ends, “Yours as long as life endures, Katheryn.”

Whether their relationship was physical or not is still debated.

A queen did not need to be proven guilty of adultery to be destroyed.

She only needed to look as though she might have threatened the royal line.

—

## The letter in the chapel

In the autumn of 1541, Henry returned from a long royal progress to the north of England.

On All Saints’ Day, the 1st of November, at Hampton Court, he gave thanks in his chapel for the good life he was leading with his wife.

The next day, Thomas Cranmer, the Archbishop of Canterbury, left a letter in the king’s place in the chapel.

He was too frightened to say it to the king’s face.

Then the questioning began, and it was relentless.

Manox and Dereham were questioned, and then the trail led to Culpeper.

There is a famous story that Catherine broke away from her guards and ran screaming along a gallery at Hampton Court towards the chapel, hoping to beg Henry for mercy.

That passage is still called the Haunted Gallery, and visitors have claimed for centuries to hear screams there.

It is a powerful tale, but there is no contemporary record of it, so treat it as legend.

Catherine was confined to her rooms, then sent to Syon House in Middlesex.

She was stripped of the title of queen.

—

## Tower Green, February 1542

Culpeper and Dereham were executed at Tyburn in December 1541.

Culpeper, as a gentleman and a former favorite, was granted the quicker death of beheading.

Dereham was not spared, and he suffered the full traitor’s death of hanging, drawing and quartering.

Parliament then passed an act of attainder against Catherine, condemning her without a trial.

On the 10th of February 1542, she was taken by barge to the Tower.

According to the reports of foreign ambassadors, she asked on the night before her death for the block to be brought to her, so that she could practice laying her head on it.

On the 13th of February 1542, she was beheaded inside the Tower.

She was probably no more than nineteen.

Immediately afterwards, the same scaffold was used for Jane Boleyn, Lady Rochford, who had helped arrange Catherine’s secret meetings.

The woman whose words had been used against her own husband six years earlier now died beside the queen she had served.

—

## The survivor

And then came the sixth wife, Catherine Parr.

Surviving Henry took charm, brains, friends and luck, all at once.

Catherine Parr was about thirty-one when she married Henry at Hampton Court in July 1543.

She had already been widowed twice.

She was intelligent, well read and drawn to the new reforming ideas in religion, and she loved serious discussion.

She learned Latin as an adult and wrote and published religious works, and she is often described as the first woman in England to publish an original book in English under her own name.

—

## The warrant in the corridor

Her love of debate almost killed her.

In 1546, the conservatives at court, led by Bishop Stephen Gardiner and the Lord Chancellor, Thomas Wriothesley, decided to strike at the reformers through the queen herself.

That summer, the reformer Anne Askew had been racked in the Tower and burned for heresy.

Catherine had been discussing scripture openly in her rooms and even arguing points of religion with the king.

Her enemies persuaded Henry to allow articles against her to be drawn up.

What happened next comes to us mainly from the Protestant writer John Foxe, years later, so some details may have been polished.

According to Foxe, a copy of the document was dropped, by accident or perhaps deliberately, and it was found and carried to Catherine.

She collapsed into terror and weeping so loud that Henry sent his own physician to see what was wrong.

She pulled herself together and went to the king.

She told him that she had only argued with him to take his mind off the pain in his leg, and to learn from him.

A woman, she said, should be taught by her husband, and she would always submit to his wisdom in matters of faith.

It was exactly what Henry wanted to hear, at exactly the moment he needed to hear it.

“And is it even so, sweetheart?” the king replied, according to Foxe.

“Then perfect friends we are now again.”

The next day, Wriothesley arrived in the palace garden with around forty guards to take the queen away.

He found Henry sitting with her.

The king turned on him, called him a knave, a beast and a fool, and sent him packing.

Catherine Parr survived.

—

## The king’s last days

Henry VIII died at Whitehall Palace in the early hours of the 28th of January 1547.

He was fifty-five.

In his last months he was carried from room to room in chairs, and some kind of device is said to have been used to get him up and down the stairs.

His body was taken in a great procession towards Windsor, resting overnight at Syon, the very house where Catherine Howard had been held.

A grim story later grew up that the coffin burst open there in the night and that dogs were found licking at the remains.

It appears in an account written long afterwards, as the fulfillment of a friar’s curse, and there is no reliable contemporary evidence for it.

Catherine Parr was the wife who was still at his side when he died.

Anne of Cleves, in her comfortable house, outlived him too.

The other four had not.

—

## One ordinary day

So what would an ordinary day have looked like, if you were the queen?

A queen’s gown was built in layers, from the linen smock to the heavy outer gown of velvet or cloth of gold, with sleeves pinned on separately and a gable or French hood on top.

It took several pairs of skilled hands and a long stretch of the morning to put it all together.

Then came prayers in the chapel.

Then dining, often in the semi-public setting of the court, where people watched you eat.

Your food was tasted before it reached you, because poison was a real fear.

In 1531, a cook named Richard Roose was accused of poisoning the household of Bishop John Fisher, and Henry had a law passed to make poisoning a form of treason.

The punishment was boiling alive, and Roose was boiled to death at Smithfield.

If you smiled too warmly at a young courtier, it might be whispered about as something worse.

If you were too cool towards the king, that might be read as contempt.

The space between acceptable behavior and treason was very narrow, and there were always people waiting for you to slip.

And if you did slip, there was nowhere to appeal.

The judges, the juries, the Church, the soldiers and the executioner all answered, in the end, to the man you had married.

If his government could send Thomas More, the former Lord Chancellor of England, to the block after a one-day trial, what chance did a queen have once the king himself wanted her gone?

—

## A rigged game

The six wives of Henry VIII are more than a rhyme.

Each of them walked into that marriage believing she could manage it.

Catherine of Aragon trusted her royal blood, her piety and her right.

Anne Boleyn trusted her intelligence, her nerve and the force of her personality.

Jane Seymour trusted silence and obedience.

Anne of Cleves saw the truth, cut her losses and lived.

Catherine Howard, barely more than a girl, never really had a chance.

And Catherine Parr survived by becoming exactly what Henry needed, at exactly the moment he needed it, and by a measure of pure luck.

You would not survive one day as Henry’s wife for the same reason nobody survives a rigged game for long.

The rules changed whenever the man in charge felt like changing them.

The referees all worked for the other side.

And the only winning move, as Anne of Cleves understood before anyone else, was to stop playing.

You Might Also Enjoy