News

Vitellius — The Roman Emperor Who Vomited Between Meals So He Could Keep Eating

Nobody at the table looked up.

That was the first thing the man in the saffron tunic understood, and it frightened him more than what he was seeing.

He had come a long way to sit at this table.

He had spent money he did not have on the tunic, with its gold thread and its stiff new folds, and he had been told by three different friends exactly how to behave in the presence of the emperor of Rome.

Nobody had told him about this.

It was the summer of the year 69, on the Palatine Hill, in a dining room with painted columns and cracks already spreading through the plaster.

It was the second dinner of the day.

A roast bird lay in pieces on a silver dish among grapes and figs.

Oysters sat open on red clay plates, and wine stood in cups so thin the lamplight came through them.

And eighteen inches from his elbow, the master of the world had stopped chewing.

Aulus Vitellius was a huge man, a head taller than anyone else in the room, with a thick red face and a wreath of gilded laurel sitting crooked on his dark curls.

He wore a plain white tunic pinned at the shoulder, because the purple got in the way.

For an hour he had been eating without speaking, steadily, with both hands, the way a man shovels grain.

Now he put down what he was holding.

He laid one big hand flat against his stomach and leaned forward over the table, without any hurry at all, as you might lean forward to read something.

A slave had already slid a bowl in front of him.

Then his whole body clenched, and it came.

It came in a long, thick, dark green rope, out of his open mouth and down into the bowl, and it splashed over the rim and across the marble and in among the plates.

The man in the saffron tunic felt it spatter on his bare forearm.

He heard himself make a small noise.

His hands came up in front of his chest by themselves, and he opened his mouth to say something, and he looked down the long table for someone, anyone, to share this with.

Thirty senators and generals sat along that table, and behind them another row against the wall.

One of them reached for an oyster.

The emperor hung over the bowl and breathed.

A slave wiped his chin.

Another took the bowl away and put down a clean one, and a third dabbed at the marble with a cloth.

Vitellius sat back.

His eyes were watering and he looked, for the first time that evening, comfortable.

He belched gently.

He looked around for the roast bird.

There was still a third dinner to come tonight, and possibly a fourth.

You think you know this story.

You have probably heard that the Romans built a special room for this, called a vomitorium, where they went to empty their stomachs so they could get back to the feast.

You may have heard it from a teacher.

It is one of the things everyone knows about ancient Rome.

It is completely wrong, and in a moment you will see why.

But the truth is stranger than the legend.

The truth is that there was no special room because for a man like this one none was needed.

And within six months of that dinner, Vitellius would be dragged through the streets of Rome with a rope around his neck, while the same crowd that had cheered him screamed one particular word into his face.

It was not a word about tyranny or murder.

It was a word from the kitchen.

—

## The room that never existed

Start with the room, because it is the most famous thing about Roman dining and it never existed.

The word is real.

*Vomitorium* is genuine Latin, and it does come from the verb for vomiting.

There are hundreds of them still standing, too.

You can walk through dozens of them today, and if you have ever been to a modern football stadium, you have walked through their descendants.

A vomitorium is a doorway.

It is the wide passage in a theater or an amphitheater that lets the crowd pour out of its seats.

The earliest writer we know of who explains the word, a Roman official named Macrobius, around the year 400, describes it exactly that way.

The passages were called vomitoria because they spewed people out.

It was a joke, a piece of ordinary Roman vulgarity, the kind of nickname you might give to a crowded subway exit.

When the Colosseum let out, fifty thousand people were vomited into the streets of Rome in a few minutes, and nobody got anything on their sandals.

No Roman writer ever uses the word for a room where diners went to be sick.

Not one.

Archaeologists have dug up villas and palaces from Britain to Syria, with their kitchens and their dining rooms and their latrines, and they have not found a single room built for this purpose.

So where did the idea come from?

It seems to have crept in during the nineteenth century, when educated Victorians liked to shudder over the decadence of Rome.

There are references by the 1870s to such a chamber beside a dining room, with tour guides and travel writers pointing at some unexplained room in the ruins.

By the 1920s it had got into popular novels.

Aldous Huxley used the word that way in *Antic Hay* in 1923, and after that everyone knew it.

Here is the part that the people who enjoy correcting this myth tend to leave out.

They are right about the room.

They are wrong if they tell you that the Romans did not do it.

They did.

—

## What the Romans actually did

The best witness is a man who hated it.

Lucius Annaeus Seneca was a philosopher, a millionaire and the tutor of Nero, which made him an authority on the subject from several directions.

In a letter of consolation to his mother, written from exile, he stopped to attack the rich men of his day, the sort who sent to the ends of the earth for delicacies they could not even digest.

He summed them up in four Latin words so neat that people have been quoting them for two thousand years.

*Vomunt ut edant, edunt ut vomant.*

They vomit so they can eat, and they eat so they can vomit.

Seneca was making a point, and moralists exaggerate.

But he also gives us the details that nobody invents.

In another letter he describes the slaves at a rich man’s dinner, and one of them is a wretch whose job is to crouch beneath the table and clean up what the drunken guests have left there.

It is a passing remark, thrown off in a letter on another subject, and it tells you it was a normal thing to see.

And there is much better evidence than Seneca.

There is Cicero, the great orator, who wrote to his friend Atticus about the day Julius Caesar came to dinner at his villa near Puteoli in December of the year 45 BC.

It was a stressful occasion, since Caesar had just won the civil war in which Cicero had been on the other side.

But it went well, and Cicero noted with relief that his guest had taken an emetic after his bath and so had eaten and drunk without fear, and had plainly enjoyed himself.

He mentions it like a detail about the weather.

Caesar was preparing for dinner the way you might stretch before a run.

There is the Emperor Claudius, who according to Suetonius seldom left the dining room until he was stuffed and soaked, and who would then fall asleep on his back with his mouth open, whereupon a feather was put down his throat to bring it all up again.

He had a slave whose job this was.

A feather would figure in his own death too, if you believe the stories about the poisoned mushrooms.

And then there is Mark Antony, Caesar’s right-hand man, whom Cicero attacked in a speech for having drunk so much at a wedding that he threw up the next morning in front of the Roman people, in the middle of official business, into his own lap.

For Cicero that was a scandal.

But notice what the scandal was.

It was doing it in the Forum.

Nobody was scandalized about doing it at dinner.

Doctors did not think it was shocking at all.

A regular emetic was ordinary medicine.

Celsus, the great Roman medical writer, recommends it for some patients, though he warns sharply against people who make a daily habit of it to indulge their appetites.

So nobody needed a special room.

A bowl and a slave would do.

And it was not a mass ritual of the sort you find in the legend, either, with whole dinner parties lining up to be sick for their host’s prestige.

It was a habit of some greedy, rich and powerful men.

Most Romans never did it in their lives.

Most Romans were happy to have enough bread.

But if you are looking for the man who took that habit further than anyone else in the history of Rome, you do not have to look far.

His own biographer wrote it down in one flat sentence.

He held three or four banquets a day, and he managed them all by making himself throw up.

How did such a man get to be emperor?

He got there by being the last person anyone would worry about.

—

## A family that knew how to please

He was born in September of the year 15, in the reign of Tiberius, into a family that had risen fast and meant to stay risen.

His father, Lucius Vitellius, was one of the great survivors of the age.

He held the consulship three times and governed Syria, and he got through the reigns of three of the most dangerous men in the history of Rome by an unbroken program of flattery.

When Caligula declared himself a god, Lucius Vitellius came into his presence with his head covered and threw himself on his face.

He carried around one of the slippers of the Empress Messalina and kissed it.

People laughed at him, and his career went on and on.

The son learned the family trade.

He was a charming companion, by every account, and he had a talent for finding out what the man at the top enjoyed and then enjoying it with him.

Caligula loved chariot racing, so young Vitellius drove chariots for him, and he got a smashed leg in a crash that left him with a limp for the rest of his life.

Claudius loved dice, so Vitellius played dice.

Nero loved to sing in public, so at one of the great festivals, when the crowd was calling for the emperor to perform and Nero was pretending to be shy, it was Vitellius, in charge of the games, who ran after him and begged him to come back on behalf of the people.

Three emperors in a row found him delightful.

Each one gave him offices and money.

He was consul in the year 48.

He governed Africa and did it, surprisingly, quite well.

He also ate.

Everyone noticed it, even in that company.

Over the years he had grown to a tremendous size, very tall and thick around the middle, and his face had turned a permanent red from the wine.

And he had no sense about money at all.

By the time he was in his fifties he had spent everything he had and quite a lot that he did not.

When Nero fell and the old general Galba took the throne in the year 68, Vitellius was broke and out of favor, and it looked like his career was over.

Then, in the final weeks of that year, Galba needed someone to take command of the armies on the lower Rhine.

Those legions were the most dangerous in the empire.

They were angry and restless, and Galba wanted someone in charge who would not put ideas into their heads, or have any of his own.

He looked over the list and picked Vitellius.

His reasoning, according to Suetonius, was that a man who thinks of nothing but his dinner is the least frightening kind of man in the world, and that the provinces should have enough food to keep him busy.

It may have been the worst decision in the history of the Roman Empire.

Vitellius did not even have money for the trip.

He had to rent out his house, put his wife and children in a garret, and pawn a pearl out of his mother’s earring to pay his way.

Six weeks later he was emperor.

—

## How a pawned pearl turned into a crown

He arrived in the camps on the Rhine at the end of November, and he did exactly what he had always done.

He made them like him.

He kissed the ordinary soldiers when he met them on the road.

He stopped to chat with muleteers and travelers at the inns, asking them in the morning whether they had had their breakfast yet, and then belching to show that he had.

He reversed punishments, handed out favors, and let anyone do as he pleased.

It was how you got on with Caligula, and it worked just as well on twenty thousand frustrated legionaries who had not been paid.

On the first of January, 69, the legions at Mainz refused to swear loyalty to Galba.

On the second, one evening at Cologne, the troops came to the house of their new commander.

They pulled him out, still in his indoor clothes, with no idea what was going on, and hoisted him on their shoulders.

They carried him around the town and hailed him as emperor.

Someone had taken the sword of Julius Caesar from a shrine of Mars, and they put it into his hand.

He did not make any plans.

He did not have to.

He had two ambitious generals, Fabius Valens and Aulus Caecina, who started immediately for Italy with their armies while he stayed behind to organize a banquet.

By then Galba was already dead, murdered in the Forum by the men of a new claimant, Otho.

So the two armies from the Rhine came down over the Alps in the snow to fight Otho.

In the middle of April, on the flat plain outside Cremona near a place called Bedriacum, they met, and for a day Roman soldiers slaughtered Roman soldiers in the vineyards.

Otho’s side lost.

Otho killed himself two days later, to spare the country more of it.

And Vitellius, a long way behind, on the road, feasting at every stop, received the news that he was master of the world.

He had still not been near a battle.

So he went to look at one.

—

## What he said on the battlefield

He reached the plain outside Cremona about forty days after the fighting.

Nobody had cleaned it up.

It was late May or early June in the Po valley.

The vines had been trampled and the trees cut down, and the ground was littered with broken weapons and dead horses, and thousands upon thousands of men still lay where they had fallen.

The people of Cremona had spread laurel and roses along the road for the new emperor, and built altars and killed victims, as if for a festival, right next to all of that.

Tacitus, who was a boy at the time and heard about it from the men who were there, says that some of those who rode with Vitellius were shaken.

Veterans wept.

They looked at the heaps of bodies and they remembered that the dead were Roman citizens, the men they had trained beside.

Vitellius looked at it all with interest and did not turn away.

Some of the people around him were covering their noses, and they said so.

They were overcome by the smell.

And the emperor of Rome, who had recently finished a good lunch, gave the answer that has followed him through every history book since.

Suetonius wrote it down.

“The odor of a dead enemy was sweet, and that of a fellow citizen sweeter still.”

Then, as Suetonius notes, he called for a large drink of unmixed wine, to help with the stench, and he handed it around.

Then he got back on the road to Rome, because Rome had kitchens.

—

## The army that ate Italy

He took about two months to get from the Alps to Rome.

It was not a military advance.

It was the slow passage of an enormous appetite.

Sixty thousand armed men came with him, plus an even larger number of camp followers, cooks, actors, charioteers and hangers-on, and he stopped wherever someone could afford to feed him.

Tacitus describes it with a kind of awe.

Italy, he says, was drained.

The roads in both directions, from the Tyrrhenian Sea and from the Adriatic, were noisy with the wagons bringing delicacies up for the emperor’s table.

The leading men of each town wrecked themselves to give him a suitable dinner.

Then, when he had moved on, the town itself had been eaten out, and the farmers were looking at their stripped fields in the middle of the growing season as though an enemy had crossed them.

His soldiers, meanwhile, got out of hand.

They looted.

They killed townspeople in brawls.

They were starting to go soft too, Tacitus adds, on rich food and on the heat of the Italian summer.

Nobody was training them.

Nobody was keeping order.

He entered Rome in July, in a general’s cloak with his sword at his side, among the eagles and the standards, and the people came out into the streets to cheer him, because they always did.

He was now the most powerful man on earth, with a treasury, a fleet, and thirty legions.

He had a real choice to make.

A careful man could have held the throne.

Everyone was tired of war.

The Senate would have accepted almost anyone who left them alone.

All he had to do was pay the armies, keep an eye on the East, where a blunt old general named Vespasian was fighting the Jews, and stay sober enough to read his mail.

He looked over what he had inherited, and he asked what was for dinner.

—

## Seven thousand birds

We know the menu.

It is rare to know such a thing, and we know it because people found it hard to believe at the time.

To welcome him to the city, his brother Lucius gave a dinner, and Suetonius says that two thousand of the choicest fish were served at it, and seven thousand birds.

That was only the opening.

The emperor made his own contribution soon afterward.

He had a platter made so large that no existing furnace could handle it, and a special one had to be built in the open air.

He named it the Shield of Minerva, Defender of the City, after the goddess who protected Rome.

Everything about it was a piece of insolence.

Onto this one gigantic dish went pike livers, the brains of pheasants and peacocks, the tongues of flamingos, and the milt of lampreys, brought in by Roman warships from as far off as Parthia and the Strait of Gibraltar.

Stop and consider what that means.

These were the ships that were supposed to be guarding the empire, in the middle of a civil war.

They were being sent to the ends of the known world for fish parts.

Each of his meals cost at least four hundred thousand sesterces, says Suetonius, at a time when a legionary soldier earned nine hundred a year.

It was never less, because he invited himself to the houses of other people and they knew better than to skimp.

He would breakfast with one great man, lunch with another, dine with a third and take his drinking session with a fourth, all in a single day.

His hosts ruined themselves.

Nobody could refuse.

Tacitus reckons that he went through nine hundred million sesterces in the space of a few months.

And he could do it, every single day, for one reason.

Suetonius is flat about it.

He got through all those meals because of his habit of vomiting.

So, picture it from the kitchen’s side.

Somewhere in the palace, cooks stood from before dawn with their fires going, turning out course after course for a stomach that they knew was going to be emptied into a bowl within the hour.

All the livers.

All the tongues.

The ships and the rowers and the nets in distant seas.

They had all been brought here for this, and the end of the whole great system was a slave with a cloth.

But even that was not enough.

He could not stop, even between meals.

Suetonius says that at public sacrifices he would snatch pieces of meat and cake straight off the altar, in front of the priests, almost out of the fire, and eat them.

And when he was traveling, he would stop at the cheap cookshops along the road and eat whatever they had, steaming food or leftovers from the day before, half gnawed.

That detail tells you more than the seven thousand birds.

A man showing off his wealth does not eat other people’s leftovers at a roadside stall.

This was not a display of power.

It had nothing to do with power.

By that point it was just something that was happening to him.

And a man who eats like that cannot be trusted with anybody’s life.

—

## The guests who did not get a second invitation

The jovial companion of three emperors now had nothing left to fear from anyone, and it turned out that underneath the charm there was something very nasty.

He began to enjoy killing people.

He would invite old friends and schoolmates to court with promises of a share in his good fortune, and then have them executed.

One of them was given poison by his own hand, in cold water, during a fever.

He went after the moneylenders and tax collectors who had once dunned him for his debts.

It was a good way to clear the books.

One man who came to pay his respects at the morning reception was led off to be killed on the spot.

Then, when the order had hardly been carried out, the emperor called him back, and everyone thought for a moment that there had been a mercy.

It turned out that he only wanted to feast his eyes, as he put it, on the man’s dying.

That was exactly the phrase he liked.

He used it again, according to Tacitus, about a nobleman named Junius Blaesus.

Vitellius was lying sick in a garden pavilion one night, the story goes, when he looked out and saw a house nearby lit up with lamps and heard a party going on.

It was Blaesus entertaining friends.

Vitellius’s brother Lucius told him, in effect, that some people seemed awfully cheerful about his illness, and that Blaesus had ancestors good enough to be a threat.

Blaesus was a decent man, and he had never done anything except be well born and give dinner to his friends.

A dose of poison was brought to him.

Vitellius went over to see the result, and he was heard to say that he had feasted his eyes upon the death of an enemy.

Then there was his mother.

Sextilia was a respectable woman of the old school.

Tacitus says that when she heard that her son had been named emperor, she remarked that she had given birth to a Vitellius, and not to a Germanicus.

She died within the year.

Suetonius reports the rumor that he had her starved to death, because a prophetess had told him that he would rule for a long time only if he outlived his mother.

In another version she was ill and asked for poison, and he gave it to her.

Nobody can say if either story is true.

It is telling that people found them so easy to believe.

Meanwhile, on the first of July, far away in Egypt, the legions had declared for Vespasian.

The news reached Rome in the middle of all the banquets.

—

## The animal that lies still when it is fed

Tacitus, who is a very great writer and who loathed this man, found the phrase for what happened next.

He says that the emperor was like one of those sluggish animals that, if you give them food, lie still and do not stir.

The Danube legions went over to Vespasian.

They came down into Italy under a fast-moving, unscrupulous general named Antonius Primus, without even waiting for orders.

Vitellius’s own commander, Caecina, tried to betray him.

His army was fat and sick from the summer in Rome, and many of its men had been struck down with fevers from camping by the Tiber.

In the last days of October, on the same plain outside Cremona where he had once made his little joke, the two armies fought again, all through a night, under a rising moon.

Vitellius’s men were broken.

Cremona was burned and sacked for four days.

He got the news in the gardens, with his dinner, and he forbade anyone to talk about it.

A centurion who came back from the front and told him the truth was not believed.

So the man said he would prove it, and he killed himself in front of the emperor.

By December the Flavian army was coming down the Flaminian Way, and Vitellius was finally frightened.

He did something that nobody in the entire history of the Roman Empire had ever done.

He tried to resign.

He negotiated with Vespasian’s brother, the city prefect Flavius Sabinus, and they agreed that he should get his life and a hundred million sesterces and retire.

On the eighteenth of December, dressed in mourning and surrounded by his weeping household, he came down from the palace to the Forum and made a speech and tried to hand his dagger to the consul.

The consul would not take it.

He offered it to the other officials, and none of them would take it either.

So he tried to go to the Temple of Concord to lay down his power there, and the crowd, drunk on loyalty or just drunk, blocked the road and shouted that he himself was Concord, and pushed him back up to the palace.

He went.

He could not even manage to quit.

There was fighting the next day.

Sabinus and his men retreated up onto the Capitol, and Vitellius’s soldiers went up after them, and in the chaos the great Temple of Jupiter caught fire, the holiest building in the Roman world, which had stood there for centuries.

Suetonius tells us where the emperor was as it burned.

He was in the old palace of Tiberius, with a fine view, and he was at dinner.

He had one day left.

—

## The baker and the cook

The morning of the twentieth of December, the year 69, was cold, and the fighting had reached the edge of the city.

The Flavian columns were coming in from the north, in three bodies.

By midmorning, scouts were running back to tell the palace that the enemy was at the gates.

It had been a long time since anyone had told Vitellius something he could not eat his way through.

He looked around.

He called for a litter.

Suetonius records who went with him.

Eight months earlier, sixty thousand soldiers had marched behind him.

He had been cheered down the length of Italy and had held the greatest dinners in the history of the world.

The ones who now stood by the emperor of Rome as he was hauled out the back of his own palace, by Suetonius’s account, were two men.

One was his baker and the other was his cook.

They carried him over the hill toward the Aventine, to his father’s old house.

The idea was to slip away from there, down into Campania, where his brother still had some troops.

It might have worked.

But when he got there, a rumor came through the streets that peace had been arranged after all.

And so he turned around and had himself carried back.

That was the decision that killed him, and it is hard to resist the idea that part of it was that the kitchens were at the palace.

The palace was empty.

He had never seen it that way.

He had never seen it without slaves.

He had himself put down and he walked, on the bad leg, huge and short of breath, through room after room of painted columns, and his footsteps came back to him from the walls.

The doors stood open.

The couches were still in the dining rooms.

People who had been there that morning had simply gone, taking what they could carry.

When he tried a door and found it locked, he stood and shook it.

Tacitus, who could write about such things like nobody else who has ever lived, says that the very loneliness and the silent rooms terrified him.

He tried closed doors and shivered at the empty ones.

Now he could hear something from outside, a long way off and coming closer.

He looked for somewhere to hide.

He tied a belt full of gold coins around that enormous waist.

He found the doorkeeper’s lodge, a little cubbyhole of a room by a side entrance, the kind of place where a slave slept on a shelf.

He went in.

A dog was tied up outside the door, and he left it there, as a guard or as a disguise.

He dragged a couch and a mattress up against the door from the inside, and he crouched down in the dark and he stayed perfectly still.

The largest appetite in the Roman Empire was sitting on the floor of a closet with its breath going in and out.

The soldiers came through the palace in small groups, looting as they went.

They were in no hurry.

They broke open the storerooms, and they went through the dining rooms, and sooner or later somebody noticed the lodge and a dog barking in front of it.

They pushed against the door and it pushed back.

They pulled him out by the arms.

He was covered in dust.

They did not know who he was.

It seems extraordinary, but he had changed his clothes, and they were young men from the Danube who had never seen him.

So they asked him where Vitellius was.

He lied.

He told them he had no idea.

Then, when somebody recognized him at last, he asked to be kept under guard, even in prison, saying that he had things to tell them about Vespasian’s safety.

Anything to get another hour.

They did not bother.

They tied his hands behind his back.

They put a noose around his neck.

They tore his tunic down off his shoulders, and they led him out through the palace gates and down the Sacred Way, the road where the triumphs ran, the same road on which he had ridden in the summer, with his eagles.

The whole city had come out to see him.

Suetonius gives the details, and he gives them with relish.

A soldier held a sword under his chin to keep his head up, so that everyone could see his face.

They pulled his hair back the way they did with common criminals.

And the people of Rome, who had applauded him in July, were throwing things now.

Dung.

Handfuls of filth from the gutter.

They laughed at his height and at his limp, at the great red face and the belly swinging in front of him, which were all now out in the cold December air for anyone to look at.

And they yelled at him.

It was two words, and they went on yelling them all the way down the hill.

The first was *incendiarius*, arsonist, for the Temple of Jupiter.

The second was *patinarius*.

It is not a word you will find in many places.

It comes from *patina*, a cooking dish.

Dish man.

The man of the plate.

Plate licker.

They had every other reason in the world to hate him.

There were the dead at Cremona, and the plundered towns, and a hundred murdered friends.

But when it came to the end, in the street, with a rope around his neck, that was what the people of Rome wanted him to hear.

They were not screaming about a tyrant.

They had watched their city go hungry for eight months while the warships went to fetch flamingo tongues, and they screamed at him the name of a dish.

A tribune in the crowd shouted some insult into his face, and there came from Vitellius the only thing that anyone ever recorded him saying that sounds as if it came from a man.

Tacitus preserved it.

“Yet I was your emperor.”

Nobody answered.

They took him on to the Gemonian Stairs, the place where the bodies of traitors were thrown, and there they finished it, and it was neither quick nor kind.

A hook was put into what was left, and it was dragged to the Tiber.

He was somewhere in his fifties.

He had ruled for eight months.

—

## Who wrote all this, and why you should be careful

Now comes the part that the moralists leave out.

Every word we have about Aulus Vitellius was written by people who had a reason to despise him.

The man who beat him, Vespasian, founded a new dynasty, and that dynasty needed everyone to agree that it had saved Rome from a monster.

Tacitus and Suetonius were writing decades later, under emperors who had every reason to like that version.

The histories of his reign written by his own supporters have disappeared, if they ever existed.

That matters.

The Flavian side wanted a glutton, so they got one.

Were there really seven thousand birds?

We have no way to count them.

Was it really the Shield of Minerva, with the flamingo tongues?

It sounds like the kind of story that gets better every time it is told at dinner.

He was certainly not a complete fool.

Tacitus admits that he behaved politely in the Senate and that there was a certain open-handed simplicity about him.

His government in Africa had been praised, and the Roman mob seems to have liked him right up until the moment it stopped.

As with the vomitorium itself, we have to be honest about how much of this is story.

But here is what is hard to explain away.

Too many people who had no reason to agree do agree.

Seneca’s line about those who vomit to eat was written years before Vitellius mattered at all, and it describes his class.

Cicero’s letter proves that Julius Caesar did exactly the same thing, without a hint of embarrassment, and that was more than a century earlier.

And Suetonius, who is a gossip but not a stupid man, wrote the sentence about the emetics in the plain tone that he used for facts.

No, they did not build a special room for it.

The legend gives them too much credit.

A special room would have implied that someone found it worth hiding.

—

## The bowl

Back to that table on the Palatine, on a warm evening in the summer of the year 69.

The man in the saffron tunic is still sitting there with his hands in front of his chest and his mouth open, and the green drying on his arm.

He has understood by now that nobody is going to look up.

If he has any sense, he will close his mouth.

He will reach for an oyster.

He will go home in the morning and tell no one, or perhaps tell everyone, and in a few months he will stand somewhere in the crowd on the Sacred Way.

We do not know his name.

He may be one of the thousands who stood there.

His hands may have come up again.

Next to him, the huge man in the white tunic is leaning back and looking around for the roast bird.

The slave takes away the bowl and brings a fresh one.

There is no special room.

There never was.

There is only the table, and the long row of men who have learned to keep their eyes on their plates.

Six months from now, the crowd will find the word for him.

Tonight, nobody is looking up.

—

## What the record actually says, and what is legend

**The vomitorium:** A vomitorium is the exit passage of a theater or amphitheater.

The earliest explanation of the word that survives is in Macrobius (around AD 400), who says the passages “spew” people out to their seats.

No ancient author uses it to mean a room for vomiting after meals, and no such room has been found.

References to such a chamber appear by the 1870s, and the novel *Antic Hay* (1923) helped to spread the idea.

**The habit:** Vomiting during or after a dinner is really attested.

Seneca’s “they vomit so they can eat, and eat so they can vomit” is from his consolation to his mother Helvia, and it is moral writing, so allow for exaggeration.

Cicero’s letter to Atticus (13.52) records Caesar taking an emetic before dining with him in 45 BC.

Suetonius describes Claudius and the feather.

Celsus discusses emetics as medicine and warns against daily use.

It was a habit of some of the rich, never a universal ritual, and there is no good evidence for the idea that guests were forced into it to honor a host.

**Vitellius’s dining:** The three or four banquets a day, the emetics, the cost of each meal, the 2,000 fish and 7,000 birds, the Shield of Minerva, the snatching of meat from the altars and the cookshops are all from Suetonius, *Vitellius* 13.

The total of 900 million sesterces is from Tacitus and Dio.

Every one of these writers was hostile.

**His rise and fall:** The pawned pearl, the remark on the battlefield, the fall of the Capitol, the failed abdication, the flight with his baker and cook, the doorkeeper’s lodge with the dog, and the death on the Gemonian Stairs are from Suetonius 7, 10, 15, 16, 17, and Tacitus, *Histories* books 2 and 3.

Suetonius gives the shouted insults as “incendiarius” and “patinarius.”

“Yet I was your emperor” is from Tacitus.

The story about Junius Blaesus is from Tacitus.

Suetonius gives his age at death as 57, while the birth date he also gives makes him 54.

**What is ours:** The opening scene, the man in the saffron tunic and the moment at the table are invented, built to match the illustration.

Nobody recorded this specific dinner.

Vitellius’s habit is real.

His public vomiting into a bowl at table in this exact way is our dramatization, and so are small touches like his footsteps in the empty palace, though Tacitus does describe the silent rooms and the closed doors.

The picture shows a green stream to make the point at a glance, and that is an artist’s exaggeration.

So is the painted hall, which is not a reconstruction of any real room on the Palatine.

**The poor eating the leftovers:** You may read elsewhere that the poor of Rome lined up at back doors to eat what the rich had vomited up.

There is no evidence of this in any ancient source, and we have left it out.

**About the image:** The picture with this story is a modern AI illustration in the style of an old painting, not a historical image.

You Might Also Enjoy