News

Two Apache Women Were Abandoned… Then a Lonely Cowboy Gave Them Hope

The ravens were what made him turn off the road.

There were nine or ten of them, wheeling low over the rim of the canyon west of Lechuza Springs, New Mexico Territory, in the last week of September, 1881.

Ravens circle dead things high and patient.

These were low and loud and quarreling, the way they get when something underneath them is still moving.

Brice Laramore had ridden straight through from the Texas Panhandle with eleven dollars in his pocket, a coffeepot with a crack up one side, and a back that had started grinding somewhere around the Pecos like an axle nobody had greased since the war.

He was thirty-eight, and the last eight years had worn on him like twice as many.

He had a short dark beard, a brown hat with the brim rolled at the sides, a leather vest gone soft as an old glove, a cream-colored shirt with the sleeves shoved to the elbow, and one revolver in a brown holster on his right hip.

Behind the cantle of his saddle, rolled tight, rode a heavy wool poncho the color of dark wine, with pale geometric bands woven across it.

He had not unrolled it since spring.

The chestnut gelding under him lifted his head toward the ravens first.

His name was Cinder.

He had a white blaze down his face and firm opinions about strangers, and he had bitten two grown men that Brice knew of.

Then Brice saw the tree.

It stood alone on the bare ground at the very edge of the canyon: an old juniper with a trunk twisted like wrung-out rope and bark hanging off it in gray strips, and one long limb reaching out level over the dirt like an arm held out to stop someone.

Two pale shapes hung straight down from that limb.

For one moment, from half a mile off, he took them for feed sacks.

Then one of the shapes turned slowly on its rope, and he saw long black hair swinging loose toward the ground, and he put his heels to Cinder hard enough that the horse grunted.

—

There were seven men under the juniper, and two of them were already back in the saddle.

The women hung by their ankles, upside down, their boots lashed together and roped tight against the limb, their arms hanging past their heads so that their gloved hands swung a foot above the dirt.

Both were dressed for work and nothing else: long shirts and loose trousers of undyed cotton, brown with dust at the knees and elbows, heavy leather work gloves, laced boots.

Each had a single white feather tied into the end of her hair.

Neither one made a sound.

Near the trunk, somebody had started a hole in the hard ground and quit about two feet down.

A long-handled shovel stood in the heap of loose dirt beside it.

Next to that, driven into the earth like a stake, stood a walking staff of dark wood with a carved knob on top, the way a man marks a place he means to come back to.

Brice pulled Cinder up about thirty yards out and sat there for the space of a breath.

What he felt was not courage.

It was the bone-deep tiredness of a man who had spent eight years walking into other people’s trouble for money, and had promised himself somewhere around the Pecos that he was finished with it.

But the women were looking at him.

Not at the men.

Not at the rope.

Upside down, faces dark with the strain of it, both of them had turned their eyes on the rider at the edge of the clearing and kept them there, the way a gambler watches the last card come off the deck.

He swung down off his horse.

The first one to speak was a man with a rust-colored mustache and a deputy’s star pinned crooked on his vest.

“Keep riding, mister. This here is a lawful proceeding.”

Brice kept walking toward the tree.

He did not hurry and he did not stop.

“What’s the charge?”

“Nothing you need to hear about.”

“I’ll hear it anyway.”

The deputy shifted his weight, and his spurs rang.

A heavy man off to one side, with a baker’s apron still tied under his coat, cleared his throat.

“They’re Apache wives,” the baker said.

“Brought up from Mescalero, all legal, with a paper. Three years married, both of them, and no children. The husbands paid good money for those marriages, and the fellow they paid has run off with it. These two have got no place to go.”

Brice said nothing for a moment.

“So you hang them off a tree by their feet.”

“They ran,” the deputy said.

“Walked off in the night toward the agency like they had someplace to be. And they know where Spratt went with that money. A husband’s got rights.”

“Then show me.”

Brice looked from one face to the next.

“Show me the paper. Show me the page in any law book in this territory that lets a man hang his wife by her boots because she walked away from him in the dark.”

Nobody said a word.

“There isn’t one,” Brice said.

“What you’ve got here is seven men and a rope.”

He stopped walking, about ten feet from the deputy.

“I’ve got eight years behind me I don’t talk about. I’d rather not start talking about them out here today.”

Nobody moved for a long moment.

Then the baker took one step backward, and another.

The deputy’s hand, which had drifted toward his belt, drifted away again.

One of the mounted men turned his horse’s head toward town without being told.

“Ride home,” Brice said.

“All of you. I’ll see to them.”

The deputy looked at him a while longer, then laughed, short and ugly, and went to his horse.

“Shovel’s right there, mister,” he said from the saddle, and nodded at the hole.

“Save us a trip.”

They rode off toward Lechuza Springs in a loose bunch, not looking back, and the ravens lifted off the canyon rim in a black cloud and settled again behind them.

—

Then it was only Brice, and his horse, and the tree.

He walked over, pulled the shovel out of the dirt, and stood there with it in his hand, looking up at them.

The limb was a good nine feet up.

If he cut them loose from below, they would come down head first onto hardpan and broken caliche, and a fall like that could finish what the rope had started.

So he dug.

He drove the shovel into the loose earth they had thrown up for a grave and carried it, shovelful after shovelful, and piled it under the two women until there was a soft mound of fresh dirt beneath each of them.

He worked fast and did not look at the hole.

Then he set the shovel blade in the ground beside him, wiped his face on his sleeve, and looked up at the older of the two, the one who hung farther out along the limb.

“Hold still. I’m bringing you both down.”

He took the lariat off his saddle, went up the twisted trunk with his back complaining at every reach, and worked his way out along the limb on his knees.

He took two turns of rope around the limb, passed the end around the woman’s bound ankles, and took her weight on the line before he touched the knife.

The knife came out of his left boot, where he had carried it for eight years out of a habit he did not explain to anybody.

He sawed at the cord that tied her boots to the limb.

It was new hemp and tight as wire.

The lariat bit into his palm and burned across it as her weight came onto it, and the last strand parted under the blade, and all of her weight came down onto the line he held, and he let it run through his hands, slow, slower, until her gloved hands touched the mound of dirt, and then her shoulders, and then she rolled onto her side on the soft earth and lay still, breathing.

He moved along the limb to the second woman, nearer the trunk, and did it all again.

Her knot was worse.

When she came down, she came down softly, and she was shaking so hard he could see it from the branch.

He climbed down and went to them.

The older woman was already trying to stand.

She made it halfway before her legs gave out, and he caught her by the elbow.

She looked at his hand on her arm the way you look at something you did not expect to find in your pocket.

Not with fear.

Only surprise.

“You’re all right,” he said.

It was a fool thing to say to a woman who had just been cut out of a tree, and he knew it as it left his mouth.

He took his hand away.

She sat down on the mound of dirt under the limb, slowly and on purpose, as if sitting were her own idea.

The younger one sat beside her.

Above them, the cut ends of rope still swung a little against the gray bark.

He brought his canteen, and they drank, a little at a time, the way he told them to.

The younger woman looked past him at the hole, and the shovel standing upright in the dirt, and the carved staff driven into the ground.

Her voice was hoarse, but every word came out clear and exact, like someone setting plates down one at a time.

“They left the shovel for whoever came to bury us.”

Brice looked at the shovel for a long moment.

“Nobody’s burying anybody. Not today.”

The older woman said something then, low, in her own language, without taking her eyes off him.

The younger one listened, and something very nearly a smile came and went at the corner of her mouth.

“She says you smell like a wet horse.”

“That’s fair.”

“She means it kindly,” the younger woman said.

“A ghost would not smell like anything.”

—

## Room For Someone

They were off the canyon rim before sundown.

Cinder could not carry three, so the older woman rode, and the younger walked beside Brice while he led the horse.

Before they left, he tied the shovel and the carved staff across the back of his saddle, on top of the rolled poncho.

He could not have said why.

They went south, because south looked emptiest.

Her name, the younger one told him, was Rafaela.

She was twenty years old, from a Jicarilla Apache band up north, and she had learned her English out of a schoolteacher’s books, which was why it came out so careful.

The older one was Soledad.

She was twenty-six, Mescalero, and she knew maybe forty words of English and had so far decided to spend none of them on him.

Two miles out, with nothing ahead but sage going purple in the evening, Rafaela spoke up.

“Where are we going?”

“Still working that out.”

“Do you have a home?”

He turned that over for a while.

“I’ve got a piece of land. Guadalupe foothills. Nobody’s lived on it for two years. Roof’s probably half gone.”

“Why does nobody live there?”

He did not answer right away.

It had been his father’s place, and his father had died, and Brice had kept moving ever since, because moving was easier than standing still in a house with an empty chair in it.

“It just worked out that way,” he said.

Soledad said something from up on Cinder’s back.

Rafaela listened, then gave Brice a long sideways look.

“She asks whether you make a habit of this. Riding up to trees and cutting women out of them.”

“First time.”

Soledad spoke again.

“She says that explains why you were so nervous.”

“I wasn’t nervous.”

Rafaela only looked at him.

“I was being careful,” he said.

Soledad made a sound then that he would spend weeks learning to catch: one short breath out through her nose, her eyes going flat and bright for an instant.

It was as close as she came to laughing, and if you blinked, you missed it.

—

They camped that night at the foot of a dry wash.

The cracked pot made coffee that could have stripped paint off a wagon.

He gave the women his spare blanket and put himself on bare ground by the horse, and around the fire, Rafaela told him how they had come to be hanging from a juniper on the rim of a canyon.

She and Soledad were not related.

Three years before, a man named Spratt had come through both their bands in a black wagon, wearing a government coat he had no right to and carrying a paper he said was from Washington.

He told the families their daughters would be taken to a school and given work for wages.

Then he drove them to Lechuza Springs, where a justice of the peace married each of them, the same afternoon, to a man who had paid Spratt in cash.

Soledad’s husband was Wilbur Gentry, a freighter of fifty-four, mostly gone on the road.

Rafaela’s was a harness maker of twenty-eight, cruel in a quiet, careful way: not one great wrong, but a hundred small ones, every day.

Neither man wanted a wife so much as a pair of hands.

The women worked the freight yard and the harness shop in men’s clothes and men’s gloves from first light, and that was the marriage.

When three years passed without children, the husbands decided they had made a bad bargain and went looking for Spratt to get their money back.

Spratt was gone.

Somebody in the saloon said the women must know where, and somebody else said there was one way to find out, and the next morning the deputy, Rollo Tillman, rode out with the husbands and their friends and the baker, Purcell, who came along because he came along to everything.

“We did not know where Spratt went,” Rafaela said.

“We told them. Then they stopped asking, and dug the hole.”

She said it as plainly as someone reading out a price.

After a while, he asked whether there was somewhere they were trying to get to.

“Soledad has a cousin, maybe, in the Sacramento Mountains,” Rafaela said at last.

“Maybe.”

She paused.

“My family, I do not know. A woman who has been sent away once is a trouble to everyone if she comes back.”

The plainness of it was worse than tears would have been.

Brice looked into the fire.

“You could come to the land. For a while.”

Soledad looked up.

In the firelight, she was something to look at, though not in any way a painter would have chosen.

Hers was a face that did not pretend.

Whatever crossed it was true, and not very much crossed it.

She said something to Rafaela.

“She wants to know what you get out of this.”

He turned the coffeepot around in his hands, his thumb on the crack he had been meaning to seal for months.

“Somebody to argue with about the coffee, maybe,” he said.

“It’s a quiet place. Quieter than a man ought to live in.”

Soledad studied him across the fire the way a woman reads a contract after she has been cheated by one already, line by line, looking for the place where the trick is hidden.

Then she nodded, once, and that was the end of the discussion.

—

It took them five more days to reach the Guadalupe land, five days of Brice learning all over again how to live near other people.

Rafaela asked him careful, specific questions, and he answered, and she told him something back, and slowly, like two people lighting a stove with wet kindling, they got to know each other.

Soledad still spoke to him only through Rafaela.

It was not shyness.

She was watching.

On the fourth morning, he woke in the gray before dawn and found her already up, sitting on a boulder above the camp with her knees drawn up, facing east.

He did not say anything.

He climbed up and sat on a rock nearby.

Neither of them spoke while the light came up over the flats.

When it was full day, she went down and built up the fire, and after that, without anyone deciding it, the two of them met on whatever rock was handy every morning for the rest of the way.

—

## What The Shovel Dug

The adobe house was worse than he had let himself remember.

Part of the roof had fallen in.

Mice had moved into the bedding.

The well rope had rotted through and taken the bucket down with it, and something had come in through the broken shutters and torn apart the chair his father used to sit in by the door.

Brice stood in the doorway and felt every one of the two years he had stayed away land on his shoulders at once.

Soledad stepped around him and picked up the first slab of fallen roof and carried it out.

“You don’t have to—” he began.

She gave him a look.

He picked up an armload of rubble and carried it out after her.

Rafaela had hands and a head made for broken things.

She crouched by the well, peered down into it, and stood up again.

“It is not only the rope,” she said.

“It has filled with sand. Someone has to go down and dig it out. Then I need good rope, and a bucket, or something that will do the work of one.”

“Town’s fourteen miles,” Brice said.

“Seven Rivers.”

“Then tomorrow I will take your horse.”

Nobody had asked him.

He found he did not mind.

Before she rode out, they lowered Brice into the well on the lariat, and he dug it out with the only shovel on the place, the one from the canyon rim.

He filled a bucket they rigged from an old lard tin, Rafaela hauled, and Soledad dumped the wet sand along the south wall, where it would do for a garden.

It took them two days.

On the evening of the second day, clean water seeped up into the bottom of the well, cold and clear, and Rafaela leaned over the edge and looked down at it for a long time.

“They brought that shovel to bury us,” she said.

“It digs a good well.”

Brice cleaned the blade and hung the shovel on two pegs beside the door, and it stayed there.

—

That first month was hard.

Three people who did not know one another’s habits, crowded into a small house with too much work and not enough tools or money.

Brice’s temper did not shout.

It went silent, which was worse to live with.

He burned the cornmeal twice the first week.

He walked straight through Rafaela’s seedlings along the south wall without noticing, until she pointed at his boot.

“Those were tomatoes.”

She said it the way someone announces a death in the family, and he would have crawled under the porch if the house had had one.

But there were things he had not seen coming, too.

Soledad had a way with animals that was closer to conversation than handling.

On her second day, she walked straight up to Cinder, the horse who had bitten two grown men, and stood with her forehead against his neck, and after that he followed her around the yard like a dog.

She came back from a neighbor’s place with a rooster and a hen, paid for with a day of fence work, and set them down in the yard without ceremony.

Rafaela patched the south wall where the adobe had crumbled.

Then she pulled the carved staff from behind the door, drove it into the ground at the end of her new garden row, and tied the first tomato vine to it with a strip of rag.

“That was a grave marker,” Brice said.

“Now it holds tomatoes,” Rafaela said, and kept tying.

After that she started building something along the east fence without announcing it.

When he finally asked what it was going to be, she said, “A proper kitchen,” as if he had asked what the sky was for.

Brice fixed the roof and the shutters and tried hard not to step on anything that mattered.

In the evenings they sat outside in the last of the light, and those evenings were unlike anything he had known in years.

Around the third week, Soledad began to speak to him directly.

Her English was rough, and she did not mind.

She said exactly what she meant, without the coat of pretending most people wrap around their meaning.

At first it unsettled him.

Before long, he could not get enough of it.

One evening she asked him, straight out, whether he had been lonely before they came.

“Yes,” he said.

She asked whether he had always been lonely, or only lately.

He told her, honestly, that he no longer knew the difference.

She sat with that a while.

The light went down behind the ridge.

“Lonely is not a bad thing,” she said slowly, finding each word.

“It is a room you keep empty. Someone is supposed to come and live in it.”

Then she went inside.

He sat out there a long time after.

—

## The Poncho Behind The Saddle

The men from Lechuza Springs came back in the first week of November.

It was the first real cold of the year, and for the first time since spring Brice had untied the wine-red poncho from behind his saddle and pulled it on before he walked out to check the far fence line.

By the time he was walking back, they were already in the yard.

There were three of them.

Rollo Tillman, with the rust-colored mustache and the crooked star.

A gray, heavy man leaning on his saddle horn, whom Brice had never seen and knew at once: Wilbur Gentry, Soledad’s husband on paper.

And a thin-necked young rider of about twenty whom the other two called Hutch.

They had brought two extra horses on a lead, and Tillman was telling the women to get on them.

Soledad stood in the kitchen doorway with a knife in her hand.

She had been cutting onions when they rode in and had not put it down, but Tillman did not know that, and he looked uneasy.

Rafaela had gone completely still, the way she did when she was running through every possible move in her head.

Brice came around the corner of the house with his rifle held low across his body, the muzzle pointed at the dirt.

“Tillman.”

The deputy turned.

The two men behind him shifted in their saddles.

“Laramore.”

He had picked up the name somewhere along the road.

“These two are runaways. They’re wanted back in Lechuza Springs.”

“Wanted for what?”

“Running off from their lawful husbands.”

“You left them hanging off a tree by their boots with a grave dug under them,” Brice said.

“A man doesn’t get to call that a marriage, and you don’t get to call it the law.”

He let that settle.

“You want to bring a charge? Good. We’ll ride to Santa Fe today and put it in front of a federal judge. I’d be real interested to hear what a federal judge makes of hanging two women off a juniper because their husbands wanted their money back.”

Tillman’s jaw worked.

“I’d be curious which newspapers pick it up, too,” Brice went on.

“Albuquerque, I expect. Then Texas. You want to walk that road, Deputy, I’ll walk it beside you all the way to Washington. I’ve got time, and I’ve got a horse.”

It was then that the young one, Hutch, made a small strange noise in his throat.

He was not looking at the rifle.

He was staring at the poncho: the heavy wine-red wool, the pale bands woven across the chest, the way it hung square off a pair of shoulders that did not move.

“Rollo,” he said.

“Rollo, look at that.”

“Shut up, Hutch.”

“No, look at it. That’s him.”

The boy’s voice cracked.

“That’s the poncho off the yellow-back books. The ones at the depot. Red poncho, never gives a name, never draws first. The nameless gunslinger. Every one of those stories has that poncho on the cover.”

Nobody in the yard said anything.

Wilbur Gentry slowly took his hand off the saddle horn and laid it on his thigh, where everybody could see it.

“I don’t read those,” Brice said.

“You don’t have to read them,” Hutch said, “if you’re in them.”

Brice did not answer him.

He kept his eyes on Tillman, and the rifle muzzle stayed on the dirt.

“Or,” he said, “you ride back to Lechuza Springs, and we never cross trails again. That’s your other choice. Make it quick, Deputy. I’ve got coffee on, and it boils over.”

Tillman looked at the women.

He looked at Brice.

He looked at the poncho, and at the boy beside him, who had gone white as flour, and at the women again.

Then he pulled his horse around and rode out of the yard without a word.

Gentry followed him.

Hutch went last, twisting around in the saddle twice to look back.

When Brice finally turned around, Soledad was watching him from the kitchen doorway, reading him line by line.

She said something in her own language.

“She says your hand is dancing,” Rafaela said.

Brice looked down.

His left hand was trembling against the rifle stock.

“It’s cold out,” he said.

“It is not that cold,” Rafaela said.

Soledad let out that single short breath through her nose and went back inside to finish the onions.

—

That night, by the stove, he told them about the eight years.

Not all of it.

Enough.

He had hired his gun to cattle companies and railroads in Kansas and Colorado from the time he was thirty, and he had never given anyone his name, because a name was something people could come looking for.

Somebody back east had heard about the poncho and started writing dime books about a man who wore one.

“I quit the day I figured out I didn’t much care for the man in them,” he said.

Rafaela was quiet for a while.

“The man in the books would have shot the deputy,” she said finally.

“You talked about newspapers. I do not think you are the man in the books.”

—

## Nobody Going Anywhere

Rafaela wrote the letters the next week, in her careful schoolbook hand.

One went to the federal court in Santa Fe and one to a newspaper in Albuquerque.

Both women signed, and Brice signed underneath as a witness, with his real name, for the first time in eight years, on a piece of paper anybody could read.

The Albuquerque paper printed it in January, names and all.

By March, the county commissioners had taken back Rollo Tillman’s star.

Spratt was wanted in two territories for taking money for marriages nobody had agreed to.

Wilbur Gentry and the harness maker never saw a dollar of theirs again, and in Lechuza Springs, people learned to change the subject when either of them walked in.

That winter was not easy.

In December, Rafaela came down with something deep in her chest, and for ten days the whole house went quiet with a fear nobody named.

She pulled through.

But those ten days broke something open in him: watching her breathe too carefully under two blankets, learning to boil the roots Soledad showed him without scorching them.

For two years he had told himself that being tied to nobody was a kind of freedom.

Sitting by her cot in the dark, he saw it for what it was: a story he told so the loneliness would feel like his own idea.

—

By spring, his father would have had to look twice to know the place.

Rafaela’s kitchen was finished, and better than anything that had stood there before.

Soledad had built a proper chicken pen and come home with two more hens whose history nobody asked about.

The garden along the south wall, in the sand they had dug out of the well, had gone from three trampled tomato plants to something that actually fed them.

And Brice had changed, though he was the last to notice.

For two years, his mornings had pointed one way: get through it.

Now he woke up wanting to see what the day would bring, with three people in it instead of one.

He was not a man who spoke easily about what he felt, and he very nearly fumbled what came next.

It was a warm evening near the end of April.

Rafaela had gone to bed early.

Brice and Soledad sat outside in the two chairs he had built over the winter, watching the sky go dark.

For months something had been growing between them that he had been careful to walk around, the way you walk around a sleeping horse.

She stood up to go in.

“Soledad.”

She stopped.

He had no idea what was about to come out of his mouth.

Some part of him had started the sentence without asking the rest.

“I want you to stay,” he said.

“Not until you find somewhere else. I want this to be your home. Yours. The place you think of when you think of where you belong.”

He stared down at his hands.

“I want you to stay because of you. Because of who you are, and the way you—”

He stopped.

“Let me start over. I’m no good at this.”

“I know,” Soledad said.

“You are very bad at it.”

He looked up.

“I will stay,” she said.

She went inside.

He sat out there in the dark a long while and let his heart do whatever it needed to do.

—

The next morning, while Soledad was out with the horse, he found Rafaela in her kitchen and asked her, quietly, whether she would stay too.

He told her she owed nobody anything, and that wherever she wanted to go, he would help her get there.

She looked at him for a long moment.

“When we were hanging from that tree,” she said, “do you know what I was thinking?”

“No.”

“I was thinking that no place had ever been glad to see me wake up in it.”

She looked out the door at the yard, the garden, the pen Soledad had built, the shovel hanging on its two pegs.

“This one is,” she said.

She looked back at him.

“So, yes. I will stay.”

He nodded.

He did not quite trust his voice.

“Good,” he said finally.

“Also,” Rafaela said, “I am not finished with the kitchen. I want a second shelf.”

“Build all the shelves you want.”

“Then I will,” she said, and went back to work.

—

Summer came.

The tomatoes came in red and heavy on the vines tied to the old carved staff, and Soledad cooked them down with dried chilies into something Brice ate three plates of without looking up.

Rafaela started drawing plans for a third shelf.

Brice began, for the first time, to think about a few head of cattle.

One Sunday evening in July, the three of them sat outside in the last of the light.

Soledad leaned against his side the way she had started doing that spring, simply, as if that were where she fit.

Rafaela sat with her knees drawn up, watching the first stars, and told them a story her grandmother had told her about one of the constellations: a different name than the one in Brice’s almanac, and a different story laid over the very same stars.

Brice had his arm around Soledad’s shoulders.

Cinder stood at the trough.

The chickens were settling for the night.

The quiet over the land was a full quiet now, not an empty one.

He thought about a juniper on the rim of a canyon, and a rope turning slowly in the wind, and two women hanging above a hole somebody had started to dig.

He thought about the moment they had looked past the men and the rope and everything else and fixed their eyes on him, the one rider who had not yet made up his mind.

And he thought that a man can ride a long way looking for his life, and find it already going on without him, under a tree, waiting for him to get down off his horse.

Rafaela finished her story.

The quiet after it was the kind three people only share once they have stopped asking whether they belong together.

“Tell us another one,” Brice said.

And she did.

The stars came out thick over the Guadalupe foothills, and the warm night settled around the little adobe and its three chairs, and nobody moved to go in.

For the first time in more years than he could count, not one of them was waiting to leave.

You Might Also Enjoy