News

They Didn’t Just K*ll Custer – A Lakota Sioux Revealed the S*CKENING Truth About His Last Stand

It is late afternoon on June 25th, 1876, on a ridge above the Little Bighorn River in southern Montana. A soldier is on his knees in the dry June grass. He has already fired every round in his carbine; the barrel is hot enough to blister a palm. Somewhere above him, somewhere behind the smoke, is the officer he followed into this country—a man famous since the Civil War, a man his widow will spend the next 57 years turning into a legend.

In the next 90 minutes, every single soldier on this ridge will be dead. No one will get out. No one will be left to describe what happened. And for a century and a half, the story of what you are about to see will be told almost entirely by the people who killed them: 210 men, five full companies of the United States 7th Cavalry. In the time it takes a modern feature film to run its opening act, every one of them was cut down in a landscape of coulees and ridges that most of them had never laid eyes on until that morning.

There was no final circle of blue uniforms. There was no last bugle call. There was no heroic defense of a sacred hill. That version, the one painted on saloon walls and taught to generations of American schoolchildren, was built after the shooting stopped by people who were not there.

How did George Armstrong Custer actually die? The painting shows him upright, saber in hand, surrounded by his loyal men on a windswept hill. But not a single American soldier from his column survived to describe his last moment. Not one. Everything the public was told about Custer’s final seconds was invented by people who weren’t there.

And there is something worse. For nearly a century and a half, Lakota and Northern Cheyenne witnesses—people who were in the camp, people who fought on that ridge—have described something the United States Army did not want in its history books. They described cavalrymen in panic. They described men shooting the wrong way. They described, specifically, soldiers in blue coats shooting each other.

That is what the record actually holds: not one dramatic revelation, but a slow, patient dismantling of the myth by the people who were on the other side of the rifles. The Sun Dance vision of a Hunkpapa holy man; the warning of a Crow scout who refused to go another step; the pictographs of a Miniconjou named Red Horse drawn five years after the fight; the memory of a Cheyenne woman named Kate Bighead speaking in 1927 about a day she had carried for 51 years. Put them together, and the famous Last Stand looks nothing like the painting.

Now let us go back to the summer of 1876. George Armstrong Custer is 36 years old in the summer of 1876, and he is a man with something to prove. He graduated last in his class at West Point in 1861—dead last—and then, inside of four years, became one of the most famous cavalry officers of the Civil War: boy general, long yellow hair, a wife named Libbie back east who read every one of his dispatches in the newspapers and clipped them. By 1876, the war is 11 years gone, and so is the version of Custer that the country still remembers. He needs a victory the newspapers will carry. He is riding west looking for one.

Eight years earlier, the United States had signed a treaty at Fort Laramie. The Black Hills, the government said, would belong to the Lakota forever. Forever lasted until the gold was found. Prospectors came in; the Army did not stop them. By 1876, the policy was simple: any Lakota or Cheyenne community still living out on the open plains, following the buffalo, refusing the reservation agencies—those people were now, by federal order, hostile. That is how a woman carrying a child on a travois became an enemy of the United States.

A Hunkpapa Lakota named Sitting Bull is about 45 years old that summer. He is a holy man as much as he is a chief. He has refused the agencies. In mid-June, he performs the Sun Dance along the Rosebud. He cuts 50 small pieces of flesh from each arm and dances for a vision. The vision comes: he sees soldiers falling into camp upside down, like grasshoppers from the sky, their hats falling off. He tells the camp:

“This is what is coming.”

Days later, a column under General Crook probes north and is stopped cold by Crazy Horse at the Rosebud on June 17th. Crook retreats. Custer, riding west with the 7th Cavalry, is not told.

The camp Sitting Bull is riding with is not a war party; it is a town: 7,000 to 10,000 people—Hunkpapa, Oglala, Miniconjou, Sans Arc, Blackfoot Lakota, Northern Cheyenne, some Arapaho. Grandmothers, infants, boys of 12 who have never held a rifle. Herds of horses larger than most eastern cities’ total livestock. The men who will fight at the Little Bighorn are not professional soldiers; they are fathers, they are husbands, they are hunters who understand on June 25th that a column of bluecoats is riding directly at their children.

The 7th Cavalry on June 25th, 1876, is 12 companies strong: on paper roughly 700 men, in practice closer to 600 in the saddle, plus Crow and Arikara scouts, interpreters, civilian packers, and a reporter from the Bismarck Tribune who will never file his story. The men carry single-shot Springfield carbines, Model 1873, trapdoor action, along with Colt revolvers. The Springfield fires a heavy .45-caliber round—accurate, powerful, and prone to jamming when the copper cartridge case swells in a hot chamber. Every soldier knows this; every soldier is about to be reminded.

Marcus Reno is 39, West Point class of 1857, Civil War veteran, Major by brevet, professional soldier with a drinking problem the regiment knows about. He is not loved, he is not hated; he is, until this afternoon, simply the second-ranking officer in the column. Within 48 hours, his name will be the most argued-over name in the United States Army.

Frederick Benteen is also 39, born in Petersburg, Virginia, a Union man from a Confederate family—his own father disowned him for putting on blue. Blunt, white-haired, he already hates Custer openly and has written letters saying so. He commands three companies. When the regiment is divided this afternoon, Benteen will be sent off to the south, away from the village, away from Custer, into country where he will see almost nothing of what is coming.

In the camp on the river, the leadership is not a chain of command; it is reputation. Sitting Bull is the spiritual center. Crazy Horse, an Oglala in his mid-30s, is the war leader of warriors who have followed him before and will follow him again. Gall, a Hunkpapa roughly Custer’s age, has already buried two of his wives and three of his children, killed in an earlier Army attack on a Lakota village. He has a specific reason to be in the field this summer; he will do more than any single person to organize the destruction of Custer’s command.

The Little Bighorn is not a flat prairie; it is a river winding north through a valley of cottonwood timber, and the ground on the east side rises in a tangle of coulees, bluffs, and ridges: Medicine Tail Coulee, Deep Ravine, Calhoun Hill, Last Stand Hill, Weir Point. A man standing on one ridge cannot see a man standing in the coulee below him. This terrain is not a feature of the battle; it is the battle. It is what will separate Custer from Benteen by four miles that may as well be forty.

Here is what you need to understand before anything else happens: Custer that morning believes he is attacking a camp of about 800 warriors. The actual figure is somewhere between 1,500 and 3,000. He is not outnumbered two to one; he is outnumbered closer to ten to one in the sector he personally rides into. And no one—not Reno, not Benteen, not Custer himself—has any idea.

The Crow scouts know. They have been reading signs for two days: pony droppings, lodge pole tracks, the width of a trail only an enormous village could leave. On the morning of June 25th, from a high point called the Crow’s Nest, they look west into the valley, and they see something that stops them.

From the Crow’s Nest in the early morning, the four Crow scouts—White Man Runs Him, Curley, Goes Ahead, Hairy Moccasin—look down into the valley of the Little Bighorn. They see the pony herd first. The herd is so vast it looks, in the half-light before sunrise, like the ground itself is moving. Then they see the smoke: not a dozen cook fires, hundreds. White Man Runs Him turns to Custer when the officers come up, and he tells him through the interpreter Mitch Bouyer that there are more Sioux in that valley than the 7th Cavalry has bullets.

Custer looks. He does not have the scouts’ eyes. He says he cannot see any village. He says they will attack today, because if they wait, the village will scatter.

The scouts step back. They put on their best clothing. Among the Crow, this is what a warrior does when he expects to die. White Man Runs Him speaks the words that have survived in slightly different forms through a dozen later interviews:

“We have gone far enough. We will go no farther. The soldiers will not come back from down there.”

Whether the exact phrasing is what he said that morning or what he refined through years of retelling is beyond proving; the emotional truth of it is not. Four men who had followed Custer for weeks looked at that valley, understood what the officers did not, and refused to ride into it. And Custer rode in anyway.

Think about that for a moment: the men who had lived on this land, who had read the ground since boyhood, who knew the Lakota by sight and by scar—those men said no. The man who said yes was the man whose portrait would hang in American classrooms for a hundred years.

It is early afternoon, June 25th. The sun is high. The men and horses have been moving since before dawn. Custer makes the decision that will be argued about for the next 150 years: he divides the 7th Cavalry into four pieces. Benteen gets three companies and is sent south and west, away from the river, to scout for other camps and prevent escape. Captain McDougall gets one company, Company B, and stays with the pack train—the ammunition, the spare rations, the slow-moving mules. Reno gets three companies—A, G, and M—and is ordered to cross the river and attack the village from the south. Custer himself keeps five companies—C, E, F, I, and L—about 210 men. He turns north along the bluffs. The regiment that rode in together will never be in one piece again.

Reno crosses the Little Bighorn at a shallow ford a little before 3:00 in the afternoon. The water is cold; the horses balk and then push through. On the far side, the valley opens, and the village opens with it. Reno has been told he will have Custer’s support. He will not. He does not know this yet. He forms a line—three companies abreast—and advances at a trot through the grass toward the first lodges. The sound of the hoofbeats carries. In the camp, children are playing, women are tanning hides, a Hunkpapa warrior named Good Bear Boy is sleeping off a long night. The first anyone knows of the attack is dust on the horizon.

Here is a detail that should stop you: the village is roughly three miles long—three miles end to end. If you walked from one end of this camp to the other at a normal pace, it would take you most of an hour. Reno is attacking one corner of it, and he still has no idea what the other end even looks like.

While Reno is forming his line in the valley, Custer and his five companies are riding north along the high ground above the river. They are hidden from the village by the bluffs. Somewhere along this ride, Custer sees the lower end of the camp for the first time and realizes what he has committed to. He turns to his adjutant, Lieutenant William W. Cooke, and he dictates a message. Cooke writes it on a scrap of paper torn from an order book. He hands it to a trumpeter named Giovanni Martini, the regiment’s lone Italian, who speaks poor English and understands orders more by tone than by content.

The message, as Martini carried it back down the bluffs toward Benteen, read:

“Benteen, come on. Big village. Be quick. Bring packs.”

Four lines, seventeen words. The original paper has not survived; everything historians know about the exact phrasing comes from Benteen’s testimony and the copies made later. What that message says, if you read it twice, is a man asking for help. What it does not say is where to go. There is no map, no landmark, no “I am on the ridge north of the ford.” Just come on. Just be quick.

Giovanni Martini is the last American who will see George Custer alive and come back to describe him. Martini will later say Custer was still full of fight when he rode away. That is all we have.

Back in the valley, Reno’s line has stopped. The warriors are not fleeing before him the way Custer promised they would. They are coming at him from the trees, from the lodges, from behind the dust the horses are kicking up—hundreds, then more. Reno orders the men to dismount and form a skirmish line in the timber along the river. One in every four troopers holds the horses; the rest take knees in the grass and begin to fire.

The Springfield carbines start to jam in the heat, with the copper cases swelling. Soldiers are prying stuck shells out with knives. The weapon that was supposed to give the United States Army its advantage over any indigenous force on the continent is in this moment failing. The soldier is on his knees; his carbine is jammed; he is reaching for his knife to dig a shell out of a chamber that is too hot to touch. The Lakota rider 60 yards in front of him has a Winchester repeater—16 shots without reloading—that he or a relative purchased from a white trader.

Reno’s attack has hit the southern end of the village where the Hunkpapa lodges are. These are Sitting Bull’s people; Gall’s family lives here. In the first minutes of the attack, two of Gall’s wives and three of his children are killed. Gall will later tell interviewers that this is when something inside him turned. He stops thinking of the fight as defense; he starts thinking of it as something else.

Years later, Gall described the moment plainly:

“It made my heart bad. After that, I killed all my enemies with the hatchet.”

The exact wording comes through interpreters, through time, through the choices of the men writing it down. But the fact of what happened in those first minutes—that is not disputed. The United States Army, by charging into the southern end of a camp containing families, had just given the Lakota a reason to make sure not one of Custer’s 210 men got out alive.

Reno’s line in the timber begins to collapse. Warriors are getting around his flanks. A scout standing next to him, Bloody Knife, is shot in the head, and Reno is spattered with blood and brain matter. Something in him breaks. He orders the men to mount. He orders them to charge. Then he orders them to retreat. The three orders come inside of 30 seconds.

The result is not a withdrawal; it is a rout. The companies pour out of the timber and ride for the river, and the Lakota ride with them, through them, among them. Men are shot off their horses. Men who make the river crossing lose their mounts in the current. Soldiers claw their way up the far bluff on foot, under fire, bleeding. By the time Reno’s survivors reach the top of the bluff that will later carry his name, 40 of his men are dead. He has been in the fight less than an hour. He is finished. And four miles to the north, hidden by the ridges, Custer and the five companies are still alive for a few more minutes.

The men who make it up the bluff are not an army anymore; they are survivors—faces streaked with blood and dust, carbines fouled, some having lost pistols, hats, canteens, memory of what the order even was. Reno is at the top, hatless, his handkerchief tied around his head, shouting at men who are not listening. Of the roughly 175 men who went down into the valley with him, around 40 are dead and another dozen are wounded. The horses that survive are lathered to the shoulders and shaking.

Then Benteen rides in from the south—three fresh companies. For a moment, the men on the hill believe they are saved. Benteen looks at Reno—the handkerchief, the blood, the panic—and understands immediately that whatever Custer had planned is no longer happening. Giovanni Martini has given him Custer’s note: “Big village, be quick, bring packs.” But Benteen can see Reno’s men. He can see the state of them. And he can hear, now, from somewhere to the north, heavy firing on the ridges.

Benteen will later testify:

“I had no idea where Custer was. I could hear firing in the distance, but I did not know whether it was Custer attacking the village or being attacked.”

That sentence, delivered in a courtroom three years later, is why the question of whether Benteen could have saved Custer has never been settled. He did not know, and by the time he knew, it was already over.

But then the firing to the north begins to swell—not fade, swell. For a few minutes, it is the loudest sound on the battlefield. While Reno is being driven up the bluff, Gall has done something that will determine the rest of the day: he has turned his warriors away from Reno, who is already beaten, and ridden north through the length of the village toward the sound of new rifle fire.

Custer, moving along the ridges, has been spotted. The lower end of the camp, the Cheyenne end, is already being probed. Gall rides through the lodges at speed. Women are pulling down teepee covers; boys are running out horses. He is gathering warriors as he goes: Hunkpapa, Miniconjou, Sans Arc. By the time he reaches the ford at Medicine Tail Coulee, where Custer’s command is attempting to descend toward the river, he has a mounted force of hundreds behind him.

Custer’s lead company, under Captain George Yates, is at the water. It is here at Medicine Tail Ford that one of the most argued-over moments in American military history happens. Some Native accounts say the soldiers tried to cross; others say they were already turning back. Archaeology—the pattern of cartridge cases in the ravine—supports a fight at the ford itself, intense enough to leave the ground littered with brass.

What is certain is this: Gall’s warriors drive Custer’s command back from the river, up the slopes, onto the ridges. The retreat is not an organized maneuver; it is a push. The five companies are being herded. Picture it this way: the man who had chosen to attack, who had divided his regiment, who had ridden past four scouts begging him not to go, is no longer attacking anything. He is being driven uphill, away from the only water for miles, by a force he never saw coming.

Crazy Horse enters the field now from the north, having ridden across the river at the lower end of the village with a second large force of Oglala and Cheyenne. Custer’s five companies are now being pressed from two directions: Gall from the south, Crazy Horse from the north. Native accounts repeatedly describe this as a pincer, though not one that was planned by any council; it happened because two leaders independently saw the same opening at the same time.

Companies L and I, under Captains Myles Keogh and James Calhoun, dismount on a long ridge and attempt to form a line. They are the first to be swept away. Keogh’s company is found later in a tight cluster of bodies around his own. It is one of the few places on the battlefield where the Last Stand image holds up: a small group of men dying together where they fell.

What happens over the next 40 to 60 minutes on the ridges above the Little Bighorn cannot be reconstructed exactly. No American witness survives. Every account comes from the other side—Lakota, Cheyenne—recorded in the days, years, and decades that followed. But the archaeology confirms the broad shape: the five companies do not die in one circle. They die in pieces. Calhoun’s company first on the south ridge, then Keogh’s, torn apart as warriors ride through the gaps. Yates’s company and the headquarters element, with Custer at its center, pull back toward the highest point on the ridge, the knob that will later be called Last Stand Hill.

By the time they get there, perhaps 50 men are left out of 210. They shoot their horses. This is documented by both Native testimony and archaeology: dead horses pulled into a rough semicircle make a breastwork. Behind this low wall of their own mounts, the last of Custer’s command fires outward. The Lakota and Cheyenne, drawing in close now, fire from the grass, from behind horses of their own, from the lip of the ridge.

Red Horse, the Miniconjou leader who would draw the battle in 1881, later said:

“The soldiers became foolish. Many threw away their guns and raised their hands, saying, ‘Sioux, pity us, take us prisoner.'”

The Sioux did not take a single soldier prisoner. Whether that is literally what happened at Last Stand Hill or at one of the earlier company positions is not clear from the account itself, but it reframes the entire famous image. Red Horse, a man who was there, who fought there, described not a defiant last stand, but something closer to men at the end of courage.

And here is the piece the United States Army did not want in its history books: multiple Cheyenne witnesses in the years after the battle said that in the last minutes on that hill, as the smoke thickened and the men’s weapons jammed and the end became visible, some of the cavalrymen in blue coats shot each other. Whether these were final acts of men who could not face capture, or whether they were accidents of panic—men firing blind through the smoke and hitting their own—the witnesses did not always agree. The Army did not want the question asked at all, because the painting on the wall shows men dying with their faces to the enemy. The record on the ground is not so clean.

The archaeological record supports the chaos. Cartridge cases from Springfield carbines are not concentrated at the hilltop; they are spread in clusters and scatters across more than a half-mile of ground. Soldiers were firing, moving, falling, firing again, over a far wider area than any single last stand could occupy.

Where exactly Custer himself fell, no one is sure. His body was found near the crest of the hill, with a wound in the left temple and another in the left chest. Either could have been fatal. His hair, famously long, had been cut short before the campaign. In death, no Lakota or Cheyenne witness is known to have identified him as Custer at the moment of his killing; he was, in the final minutes, just another soldier in a blue coat.

Four miles south on Reno Hill, Captain Thomas Weir is listening to the firing to the north, and he cannot bear it anymore. Without clear orders from Reno, he mounts his company, Company D, and rides north along the bluffs toward the sound. Benteen eventually follows with the rest of the command. They reach a high point now called Weir Point and look north. What they see through the dust and smoke is a landscape covered with mounted warriors. The firing is thinning. It is not Custer attacking; it is the end of something.

Weir’s advance is turned back. Lakota and Cheyenne, having finished with Custer, are now riding south toward him. Weir retreats to Reno Hill. The combined command—now about 350 men with wounded—digs in: shallow rifle pits, dead horses for breastworks, saddles stacked into cover.

The siege lasts through the afternoon of the 25th, all through that night, and most of the 26th. Men who are wounded get no water. The river is in sight; the river is 400 yards down a bluff under rifle fire. Nineteen men volunteer to run water parties down to the river that night and the next day. Four are killed; the rest return with hats full of water, canteens strapped to their chests, moving between rocks under fire. Try to hold the image: men crawling down a cliff face in the dark in June heat, wounded, filling canteens from the same river their comrades had drowned in that afternoon, climbing back under rifle fire so a man with a stomach wound might live another hour.

On the afternoon of June 26th, the Lakota and Cheyenne camp begins to move. Fires are left burning to disguise the departure; travois are loaded; the great village—three miles of lodges—picks itself up and goes south up the valley, out of sight.

The reasons they left are debated. The approach of General Terry’s column from the north was one factor; the need to protect women and children and horse herds was another. The warriors were tired, ammunition was uneven. Some accounts emphasize that leaders, including Sitting Bull, understood that whatever had happened at the ridge, more soldiers were coming. The United States Army was not going to stop because of one defeat.

Reno and Benteen on their hill do not know the camp is leaving. They see fires; they assume an attack is coming at dawn; they dig deeper.

Dawn comes on the 27th. Terry’s column arrives. The scouts ride north along the ridges. They find horses, they find scattered equipment, then they find the men. One of the first officers to reach Custer’s Hill, Lieutenant Edward Godfrey, later wrote:

“I could not help but think of the strange and silent battlefield. The entire command had been annihilated, not one left.”

That sentence is where the American version of this story begins: the men who wrote the first reports were men who arrived two days after the shooting stopped. The men of Terry’s column who walk up the ridges on the morning of June 27th will not forget what they see for the rest of their lives. The bodies are everywhere—not clustered, everywhere: in the coulees, on the slopes, along the ridges, down toward the ravine. Most are naked; clothing had been taken, which was standard practice in the aftermath of a battle on the plains. Many are mutilated. Horses lie among them in the posture of animals shot where they stood.

Two hundred and ten men: every soldier of the five companies Custer took north, every officer, his two brothers Thomas Custer and Boston Custer, his nephew Henry Armstrong Reed who was 18 and had been brought along for the summer as a lark, his brother-in-law James Calhoun, the newspaperman from Bismarck Mark Kellogg who had wanted a story. Giovanni Martini, who had carried the last message, is not among the dead because he had already been dismissed back toward Benteen. Martini will live into the 20th century; he is, in the strictest sense, the only American who rode with Custer that afternoon and lived.

Custer himself is found near the top of the hill. His body is not mutilated the way most of the others are, which later generations of historians have interpreted in several ways: some suggesting the Lakota and Cheyenne did not recognize him, others suggesting a form of respect for a man they had identified. He has two wounds, either of which could have killed him: one in the left chest, one in the left temple. Which came first is impossible to determine.

The famous image—Custer standing, saber raised, long hair blowing—is false in every detail. There were no sabers on the ridge; the regiment had left its sabers at the Powder River depot weeks earlier. His hair was short. He was not standing. He died somewhere in the collapse—when and how, no American eye ever saw.

The painting lies about everything: the saber, the hair, the posture, the circle of loyal men, the final cry. Every element the public would come to know was invented after the fact by people who were not there, to comfort a country that could not accept what had actually happened, which is that the United States Army was defeated by families defending their home.

In 1881, five years after the battle, a Miniconjou Lakota leader named Red Horse sat down on the Cheyenne River Reservation and did something no American officer had done: he drew the battle—dozens of pictographs: soldiers falling, horses running, Lakota warriors on horseback, dead men laid out in rows. He also narrated. His account describes the battle from inside: the warriors mounting up, the direction of the attacks, the collapse of the soldiers at the end. His drawings are not perfectly consistent with every archaeological finding, but they existed. They existed in 1881. For a century, American history books acted as if the Native side of this battle had left no record; Red Horse’s drawings were sitting in an archive the entire time.

In 1927, a Northern Cheyenne woman named Kate Bighead gave a long interview about what she had seen that day as a young woman in the camp. She described the panic, the children running, the old people trying to find their relatives. She described warriors returning from the ridge in the afternoon with the news that every soldier was dead. She was speaking 51 years after the fact through an interpreter, but her account is one of the few that preserves what a civilian in that camp—a woman, a non-combatant—saw and felt. The Lakota and Cheyenne had been there in their thousands; historians just had to be willing to listen.

Marcus Reno survived the siege and lived another 13 years. He was court-martialed twice on unrelated charges. In 1879, a formal court of inquiry examined his conduct at the Little Bighorn and did not convict him of cowardice or dereliction. In law, he was cleared; in public memory, he was not. He died in 1889, 44 years old by one count, poor, alcoholic, and unforgiven by the country that had decided it needed a villain in order to keep Custer a hero.

Benteen stayed in the Army, defended his conduct for the rest of his life, and died in 1898. He was never charged, never censured. He said in writing and in testimony that he had done what the message he received allowed him to do. The men who hated Custer agreed; the men who loved Custer never did.

For the Lakota and the Northern Cheyenne, the victory on the Little Bighorn was both complete and catastrophic: complete because the 7th Cavalry had been shattered; catastrophic because the United States’ response was immediate and overwhelming. By the following summer, Crazy Horse had surrendered. By 1881, Sitting Bull had surrendered. The Black Hills were already lost. The reservation system closed around the people who had defended their village that afternoon. The victory on the river bought nothing but time, and not much of that.

But the Battle of the Little Bighorn did not end on June 27th, 1876. The real battle, the one that lasted a century, had barely begun. And it would be fought with paintings, with books, with monuments, and with the words a widow in New York refused to let anyone else write.

Elizabeth Custer outlived her husband by 57 years. She died in 1933, four days short of her 91st birthday. In those 57 years, she published three books about her husband, gave countless lectures, met with historians, and corresponded with artists, generals, and politicians. She made it her life’s work to ensure that no one who had served with her husband dared criticize him in print while she lived. Many waited; Benteen’s most pointed criticisms sat in private letters that were only published after her death. The Last Stand that most Americans picture—Custer upright, defiant, surrounded by his loyal men—is in large part the Last Stand that Libbie Custer protected into existence.

Crazy Horse surrendered at Camp Robinson in May of 1877. On September 5th of that year, he was taken into custody, and during a struggle at the guardhouse, was fatally wounded by a soldier’s bayonet. He was approximately 35 years old.

Sitting Bull surrendered in 1881, eventually settling at Standing Rock, briefly touring with Buffalo Bill Cody’s Wild West Show, and was killed by Indian police on December 15th, 1890, during an attempt to arrest him amid the tensions of the Ghost Dance movement.

Gall surrendered with Sitting Bull, later became a judge at Standing Rock, and died in 1894.

The leaders of the greatest indigenous victory in American history died one by one inside the system they had tried to stay outside of.

Here is the fact that most people watching have never been told: for 105 years, the battlefield itself was named for one man—Custer Battlefield National Monument. The signage, the exhibits, the orientation, the stones, all centered on him. The Lakota, the Cheyenne, the Arapaho, who had defended their village and won the fight, were visitors to a park named after the officer they had killed. In 1991, after decades of pressure, Congress changed the name to Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument. It took 115 years—115 years to put the river back into the name of the battle fought on it.

Beginning in the 1980s, after a grass fire exposed the ground, archaeologists began recovering cartridge cases, bullets, buttons, and bone from the battlefield at a scale never attempted before. What they found did not match the painting. The cartridge cases told a story of a battle spread across ridges, not concentrated on one hill. The bullet patterns suggested fighting at varying ranges from varying positions. The ground, read carefully, agreed with Red Horse’s drawings and with Kate Bighead’s memory. The soldiers who told the story first were the ones who had arrived last; the people who had been there on both sides of the rifles had been telling a different story the entire time.

Return now to the ridge above the Little Bighorn on the afternoon of June 25th, 1876: the soldier on his knees, the jammed carbine, the officer whose portrait would hang in a thousand American classrooms, the 210 men who would be gone before the light changed. For a century, the country they died for told itself a story about a last stand on a windswept hill. The people who had been there told a different one from the beginning, and no one listened.

The sickening truth about Custer’s Last Stand was never a single secret revealed by a single witness. It was that the truth had been spoken carefully and consistently by the people who were on that ridge, and the country simply decided it preferred the painting.

You Might Also Enjoy