News

Murdaugh Murder Timeline: Could Time of De*th Be Completely Wrong?

“Hey everyone, I’m Ann Emerson and this is Crimly Obsessed. There’s one thing I’ve learned after covering the Alec Murdaugh case over the last few years: never underestimate the defense team. They will do anything and everything to create reasonable doubt in the minds of the jurors.”

“And this time, the time of death from Maggie and Paul Murdaugh will no doubt come into play.”

“That’s strictly an estimation. That’s a guess. It could have been 8:30. Could have been 10:00. There were no witnesses there to tell me exactly what time this happened.”

“Using digital data, the prosecution presented a much narrower window, 8:50 p.m. to 9:06 p.m. But could they be wrong? And how does a coroner or a medical examiner determine the time of death? The answer may surprise you.”

“Basically, what I did is I lifted his arm up just a little bit here and I stick my hand up into the armpit. And that’s one of the central areas of your body.”

“The coroner said he did the armpit test, which is no test at all. It’s just a guesstimate. Seriously, it’s like how I knew if my kids had a fever. I’d put my hand to their head. And if you’re a parent, once you check it with a thermometer, you’re probably right about 50% of the time. Is this really how it’s done? Surely, there’s got to be something more scientific than a hand under an armpit. So, I had to bring in death investigator Joseph Scott Morgan, who helped create the national standards for determining the time of death, and he really opened my eyes.”

“Let me throw out another dirty little secret about our practice in medical legal death investigation that people don’t realize. Did you know that all of these death temperature assessments, it’s based on data that was gleaned under ideal circumstances? You know what ideal circumstances are? 72 degrees Fahrenheit. When do we ever get ideal environmental circumstances in the low country, particularly in the summertime?”

“So, how is all of this going to play into Alec Murdaugh’s next trial? Let’s get into it. Well, Joseph Scott Morgan, thank you so much for joining me. We are back speaking about a case that the two of us have covered for a long time now. We’re five years in, five years deep.”

“How are you?”

“I’m doing well. How about yourself?”

“I’m good.”

“I’m getting ready for the next round here with Alec Murdaugh. We’re going to be back in court with him on Friday. I want to talk about the time of death. You know, the prosecution explained their theory on the time of death during the first trial against Alec Murdaugh. And you know, they talked about determining the time of death between 8:30 and 10:06 using this critical sort of digital and forensic data that they had access to. That you had Paul’s cell phone video that he was recording at 8:44 at the dog kennels. You had the final phone activity where these texts and calls were locked at 8:49. You’ve got the OnStar data from Alec Murdaugh’s vehicle recording him starting his car at 9:06. The coroner’s estimate that the state of the bodies the death occurred around 9:00 p.m. in a window of 8 to 10 and then the 911 calls, of course, at 10:07 when they were explaining this theory of what happened and when it happened. Was that satisfying to you about how the prosecution set up their timeline?”

“Yeah, I think the digital evidence is more impactful here than the findings of the coroner initially. Okay. And keep in mind when you’re running all this information, you don’t necessarily have it all at one time. I’m a big fan of the medical legal community keeping separate from the police. You’re working alongside them. You’re not getting in their way. They’re not getting in your way. And there is some sharing of information, but the assessments that we make at the scene should be done so that they are not influenced at all by digital data and all that stuff that you might not necessarily have at that time anyway. So if you can do a fair assessment at the scene and what the coroner did when he did roll up on the scene, I had made note of that. So, he was notified, I think, at 22:30, he said.”

“That’s right. Yeah.”

“Yeah. And he arrived at 23:04, which, for normal human beings, those of us that have not been in law enforcement or the military, that’s 11:04 p.m. He rolls up. Right. Here’s something, and I’ve actually encountered this where if you’re waiting, particularly if you’re dealing with smaller rural law enforcement or state law enforcement, you’re the coroner representative that’s at the scene, and you get the call where they’ll say, ‘Yeah, we’re two hours out.'”

“Yeah.”

“What do you do? Well, the problem is this from a medical legal perspective: tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock. So, that biological clock doesn’t give two hoots in hell about what your ETA is if you’re on call. The body is going to continue to change. So, he’s presented the coroner, that is, with an interesting set of circumstances, right? Do I go ahead and begin to do my post-mortem assessment on the bodies relative to their time since death? So, let me just kind of break this down for you real quick. Most bodies cool after death. Well, what happens is for the first hour, your body is going to lose about two degrees of temperature. Okay? So, we’re 98.6. After the first hour, there’s a high probability you’re going to be in that 96-degree range. Then for every hour after that you lose one to 1.5 degrees of body temperature until the 12th hour. So at the 12th hour we essentially assume what they call room temperature. But there’s this is kind of complex in the sense that people have been looking for a magic bullet for this assessment for years and years and years. And contrary to what you see on television, we can’t give you a specific time.”

“The coroner said, I think, and forgive me if I misspeak here, but he had said that it’s a 2-hour estimate, you know, that he could frame it down. I never like tying myself down that way. Absent other circumstantial information, I generally say three to four hours about as best I can do.”

“Okay. And one of the other things that he’s dealing with is that he’s doing what’s called an axillary temp. So, what you have is a thermometer. And we’ll pretend my pen here is a thermometer. Now, he says that his assessment, initial assessment, was he went into the axillary area, which is our armpit, and stuck his hand in here. And right now, all you’re trying to do is to say the body is either warm to the touch or cool to the touch. Okay? Now, if everybody at home is sitting around, do this right now. And you can feel that this area is warmer than the rest of your body. Well, why is that? Well, it’s closer to your center mass. You’re retaining energy. You get out here to your fingertips and we all know, when it’s cold weather outside, we’ll feel it in our fingertips first or top of our head. Mom says, ‘Put a hat on when you go outside, right? You’re losing.’ But the closer we can get to the core and without being invasive at the crime scene, which believe it or not, there are agencies out there that will do an incision into the body at the crime scene and insert a thermometer into the liver because it is the densest organ in the body. I’m not a fan of that. And I help create the national standards. That’s something that I stay away from. I don’t like traumatizing the dead at a scene.”

“Right. So, the best that he can do is this axillary temp.”

“The trick to this is, and to be clear, you’re saying you’re not saying a thermometer. It’s not like he’s sticking a thermometer under their arm. He’s sticking his hand under the arm. And that’s it.”

“This has been something that Dick Harpootlian, the defense attorney for Alec Murdaugh, has brought up multiple times, that he has a massive problem with time of death, you know, sticking his hand under his armpit because the coroner who, by the way, I have gone out on many a call as an investigative reporter, as a reporter in this area, Coroner Harvey has been doing this for 30 years. I mean, this guy is solid as far as coroners go. So, I just want to make sure everybody knows who we’re talking about because this guy’s been around the block on these rural calls for a long time. But Harpootlian is coming after the time of death, saying there’s no way you are going to be able to tell me when he died within minutes to say that it’s a 9:00 death.”

“Well, you know what the thing about it is for me and I’ve always held this as this is kind of a little personal aside. There’s so many variables. This is the reason we can’t come up with a magic bullet for it. There are so many biological and environmentally dependent variables in this assessment. It comes to the point where it’s almost like worthless data. So Dick can go down this road and he can argue until he is blue in the face and settle on what this gentleman has done at the scene and he can beat his chest and he can go down this road, but when you look at it, it’s not settled science. I hate to use that term, but you know what I’m saying? It’s just not. It’s one of these things that has so many variables to it that you cannot quantitatively hang your hat on it and say this is the absolute scientific truth.”

“Yeah, but it makes for great theater in court.”

“Well, it adds to the noise, right?”

“Oh, of course it does. Yeah, it adds to the noise of what’s going on. But I mean, scientifically, what you’re saying is trying to give an accurate determination of the time of death based on going underneath the armpit. And I don’t think Dick’s honestly, I don’t think Dick’s arguing with you about that for Paul and Maggie. I think honestly I think we’re making his argument for him in some ways, right?”

“Well, you know, the thing about it is when you do just a touch assessment, there’s only two ways you can do this. You can say either the body’s warm to the touch or cool to the touch. Okay? And I got to tell you, if you and I had a series of bodies that we were examining, your assessment of warm to the touch, cool to touch is going to be different than mine. That’s not science. That’s highly subjective. I mean, it’s an initial qualifier, right? But it’s not quantifying. You can’t hang a numerical value on it necessarily. ‘Oh, the body’s cool to the touch.’ Okay, what does that mean? How cool is cool? Well, it’s all relative to my perception of cool.”

“We already know that the bodies were covered up with plastic. It was the weather was god awful that night. It had been raining, and it was summertime heat. I mean, it’s a low country. I mean, we’re talking 100% humidity if you’re lucky, you know, like. And it is wet and humid. How does a coroner handle those kind of circumstances?”

“Let me throw out another dirty little secret about our practice in medical legal death investigation that people don’t realize. Did you know that all of these death temperature assessments, it’s based on data that was gleaned under ideal circumstances? You know what ideal circumstances are? 72 degrees Fahrenheit.”

“Now I’ve been to the low country.”

“When do we ever get ideal environmental circumstances in the low country, particularly in the summertime?”

“No. Never. Never. Ever.”

“Those are controlled. These have been controlled tests that are assessments that have been done over the years. And you’ll see these numbers fly wildly. I always sit in total amazement anytime I hear somebody try to hang their hat on this as definitive science. And it’s really not. We teach it. We talk about it because people always ask the question. You’re a lot safer to say that the body is warm to the touch or cool to the touch than you are to give a numerical value. So that brings us back to you do an initial assessment and then afterwards and you’ve made note of this which I’m sure that he did very thoroughly because this man’s a pro. Like you said, he’s been at it for 30 odd years.”

“Yeah. You think about that and you think about, well, at this point, suddenly this man who has been highly regarded all these years as the medical legal representative in that area, suddenly everything else he’s done in the past doesn’t have value because he’s demonstrated, first off, he’s electable and secondly, he’s maintained his position in this county and he’s a pro. You know, when you see him on the stand, he’s having a conversation, if you’ll call it that.”

“He’s very, yeah, he is. He’s rock steady, man.”

“So, we have last known alive time that they are looking at, which would be 8:49 when these phones locked and everything locked and they knew they were active on what they were using. So, how dangerous is it going to be for a jury to confuse that last known alive time that they’re able to pinpoint with some of this digital evidence versus a time of death?”

“I don’t know if I’d use the term danger or dangerous. I think that the waters could be muddied significantly. And that’s I believe that that’s what the groundwork what’s being laid here. Okay? Because you want to, again, it goes back to this formula that attorneys have for formulating reasonable doubt. They’re looking at it. I just don’t think you can look at that post-mortem assessment as a static thing out there because it’s so highly subjective and it’s so dependent upon environmental data. I don’t know if you can, without both these bits of data being collected in one central location, you say, ‘Okay, well, we know the phone went off at this point in time. Mr. Coroner, what do you think about how this marries up with what you were seeing at the scene?’ It’s at that point in time that you can kind of integrate some of this data together. Now, it’ll be real easy to blur these lines, right? And make it sound very conspiratorial or make the coroner’s assessment seem to be something less than it was or maybe if he wants to go down this road I guess and I’m talking about defense attorney even imply that there’s something negligent on his part. I hope he doesn’t do that but that could certainly be implied here if you’re trying to create reasonable doubt.”

“One of the things that the coroner talked about on the stand was that he chose not to use a rectal thermometer because of the family that was around. They were covered up with a sheet that it was just it felt inappropriate, I guess. And I don’t know if that’s something that they’re digging into. What do you do on the scene when it comes to that?”

“One of the last things you want to do is adopt something like rectal temperature as your standard operating procedure because I don’t know what in the hell happened when I show up at the scene and you’re putting so much value on this data that it trumps evidentiary integrity. So, if you have to do this every single time, yeah, I’m going to pull down the underwear, pull down the pants, pull up the skirt, and yeah, I’m going to do a rectal temp. Okay. What about if you have a sexual assault case? You’re going to do that, too. Well, if you deviate from that standard, you’re going to get eaten alive by a defense attorney. You don’t adopt that standard to begin with because it’s bad practice. It really, really is because you can have a defense attorney that will come in and they might have a case where they’ll say, ‘Boy, you did rectal temperature on this case, but my client’s case that he’s accused of, you didn’t do it here. Why not?’ So, you stay away from that. Anything that is anything in my estimation that causes you to disrupt the body in any way because the body is a central piece of evidence, nothing trumps that. Even body temperature. If my assessment is cold or warm to the touch, that’s as far as that’s as much as you’re going to get out of me. If you don’t like that, I’m sorry, but I’m not going to compromise the body. I’m not going to pull down the pants. I’m not going to change the clothing in any way. You don’t know what in hell happened before you got there. You don’t know if you’re going to compromise evidence in that space. Is that data really worth it at that point in time if you’re talking about points of contact, long body, DNA, anything? Because you don’t have a crystal ball at the scene. You can’t do that.”

“I can think of a million reasons why disrupting or disturbing a body would be awful. So, this is like the standard operating procedure is what you’re telling me. Like you do as little as you can to impact that crime scene, which means you are just checking to see if they’re cold or hot. I mean, that’s pretty much where we’re at.”

“You know, for me, in my simple mind, I’ve always preferred postmortem lividity. Why? Because it is singularly dependent upon the one constant force in the universe that impacts each and every one of us and that’s gravity. It’s not temperature dependent at all. So if I’m sitting on my rear end right now, if sweet Lord Jesus called me home right now and I’m sitting here, guess where lividity is going to be distributed? Well, once my heart stops thumping, blood is going to pool because it’s no longer circulating and it’s going to go to my backside. I can tell you that before those bodies were removed at the scene, dollars to donuts, you could appreciate postmortem lividity out there and the distribution of it. Another thing that that post-mortem lividity will tell is if anybody has disrupted the body. Like if you have a person that goes down, right, and they’re in one specific position and blood begins to settle in that area. If a perpetrator comes back, I’ve had this happen many times, and they’ll move the body and they rearrange the body so that now the body’s no longer on the back, it’s on the side, you can get a separate presentation on the side in addition to being on the back. And that’s a big tell for us at the scene to try to see if anybody has been up to any tomfoolery before we get there.”

“That’s very interesting. And so do you know if Harvey was able to do that lividity test with these bodies?”

“I would assume that he did, but you know what they say about assume. Because that would be that that’s medical legal death investigation 101. I mean that’s something that we do. That is part of our postmortem assessment that we do.”

“If you took away all the digital evidence and you stripped the phones, the step counts, the car records, the kennel video, and you just went to the forensic pathologist and only the bodies and the crime scene information, could a pathologist independently land on a specific timeline, let’s say 8:49 to 9:07 p.m.?”

“No, not absent the digital data. I mean, it’s not like we have a clock in our heart that says, ‘Okay, you died at 9:03.’ I know that everybody wishes we did. I guess defense can say, ‘We want something more specific.’ Again, you can scream to the top of your lungs, but if you read Spitz and Fisher, which is the benchmark for all medical legal death investigation, the textbook that we use to train out of, you can read that and you can actually say that they cannot give you a definitive time of death. It’s just it’s not scientifically plausible.”

“For this second jury to listen to all this information of time of death, how do you want them to approach it? What would be your advice to them on this blank slate?”

“I hate the term open-minded. Many times I find that people that say they’re open-minded, their brains fell out of their head a long time ago. But you have to have a blank slate non-prejudiced view of the data because moving forward with it, it’s where the court system is set up. Listen, actively listen, take as many notes as you possibly can, and then you’ll be able to make a decision, hopefully, because look, lawyers would hate that I was saying this, but this is a sales job. You’ve got one group that’s trying to sell you this narrative. You got this group that’s trying to sell you this narrative. You have to have a discerning way about you to assess this data as it’s coming in. Because the end of the day, it does matter what prosecution and defense say, what they argue, and everything. But at the end of the day, the only thing that really matters is those determinations that are going to be made back there in that jury room.”

“There’s a hearing on the Murdaugh case on Friday. Judge McCasslin is going to be possibly deciding where this retrial is going to be held along with some other motions. Now, we’re going to be live streaming it at Crimly Obsessed. I will be on that live stream along with our legal expert, South Carolina’s former attorney general, Charlie Condon. Look forward to seeing you tomorrow.”

You Might Also Enjoy