Supertramp After “Breakfast in America”: The 20-Million-Selling Album, the Spoken Deal Roger Hodgson Says Was Broken and the Royalty Fight That Reached a Federal Appeals Court
On the evening of April 14, 1993, the record business gathered at the Beverly Hilton in Beverly Hills, California, for a dinner honoring Jerry Moss, the “M” in A&M Records.
Part of the entertainment came from three musicians who had made one of the label’s biggest albums.
Rick Davies, Roger Hodgson and John Helliwell performed two songs: “The Logical Song” and “Goodbye Stranger.”
Both came from “Breakfast in America,” the 1979 Supertramp record that spent six weeks at No. 1 in the United States and has sold more than 20 million copies around the world.
It was the first time Rick Davies and Roger Hodgson had performed together in almost ten years.
No later public performance by the two of them together is on record.
How did two men whose names sit side by side on the writing credit of every Supertramp hit end up unable to share a stage?
The answer runs through a cottage in Somerset, a studio in Los Angeles, a conversation in 1983 that only one of them ever described in public, and a 1977 royalty agreement that a federal appeals court was still interpreting in August 2025.
—
## A Millionaire, an Advertisement and Two Opposites
Richard Davies was born on July 22, 1944, in Swindon, a railway town in the English county of Wiltshire.
By the late 1960s he was the keyboard player in a band called The Joint, which worked on the European continent.
The Joint had a patron: Stanley August Miesegaes, a Dutch millionaire known to his friends as Sam.
In 1969 Miesegaes, disappointed with the group, stopped backing it.
He made Rick Davies a different offer.
If Davies would put together a new band of his own, Miesegaes would pay for it.
Davies placed an advertisement in the British music weekly Melody Maker.
One of the musicians who answered was Roger Hodgson.
Charles Roger Pomfret Hodgson was born on March 21, 1950, in Portsmouth, and grew up in Oxford.
He had been educated at English boarding schools, the last of them Stowe, and he was 19 years old.
He came to audition as a guitarist.
By one account, more than ninety guitarists had been heard before him.
When another applicant, Richard Palmer, was given the guitar job the following day, Roger Hodgson agreed to learn the bass instead.
The two men at the center of the new group had little in common on paper.
Rick Davies was almost six years older, from a working-class home, and his tastes ran to blues, jazz and rhythm and blues.
Roger Hodgson was a boarding-school boy raised on 1960s pop, with a high, clear voice and a growing interest in spiritual questions.
For several years, that contrast was the band’s greatest asset.
The group first called itself Daddy, and in January 1970, after its first drummer, Keith Baker, left, it took a new name.
Richard Palmer suggested Supertramp, borrowed from “The Autobiography of a Super-Tramp,” a 1908 memoir by the Welsh writer W. H. Davies.
The debut album, titled simply “Supertramp,” came out on A&M Records in 1970.
A second, “Indelibly Stamped,” followed in 1971.
Neither sold.
Musicians came and went, and Richard Palmer left; he later wrote lyrics for King Crimson.
In October 1972, Stanley August Miesegaes withdrew his financial support.
Two years later, the album that finally made the band’s name carried a two-word dedication: “To Sam.”
—
## The Cottage in Somerset and the Classic Five
With their patron gone, Rick Davies and Roger Hodgson rebuilt the group around themselves.
Dougie Thomson, a Scottish bass player, had already joined.
In the summer of 1973 two more arrived: Bob Siebenberg, a drummer from California, and John Helliwell, an English saxophonist who would also become the band’s master of ceremonies on stage.
That five-man lineup is the one fans call the classic Supertramp.
It stayed together for ten years.
The popular version of what happened next has the band starving in a farmhouse with no money at all.
The record is a little different.
A&M Records, which had kept the group under contract, paid advances that allowed all five musicians to move into a cottage called Southcombe in Somerset.
They lived and worked there through 1973 and much of 1974.
The result was “Crime of the Century,” produced with Ken Scott and released in September 1974.
It reached No. 4 in Britain and No. 38 in the United States.
“Dreamer,” sung by Roger Hodgson, became a hit single at home, and “Bloody Well Right,” sung by Rick Davies, found its way onto American radio.
“Crisis? What Crisis?” followed in November 1975 and reached the top 20 in Britain.
By then the band had begun shifting its base to California.
“Even in the Quietest Moments…,” released in April 1977, climbed to No. 16 in the United States and No. 1 in Canada, and “Give a Little Bit” gave the group an American hit single.
—
## One Credit, Two Writers
From “Crime of the Century” onward, every Supertramp song carried the same credit: written by Rick Davies and Roger Hodgson.
In the earliest days, with Richard Palmer supplying words, the two had composed together.
After he left, they mostly wrote apart.
Each man brought in finished or nearly finished songs, and each sang lead on his own.
A listener can tell them apart in seconds.
The high tenor over a bright piano or a twelve-string guitar is Roger Hodgson.
The rougher, bluesier voice over a Wurlitzer electric piano is Rick Davies.
According to accounts of the band’s publishing arrangements, the paperwork behind the joint credit records which of the two actually wrote each song.
The shared credit had one more consequence.
Songwriting income, known in the business as publishing, went to the two writers.
The other three members were paid from record royalties, and in the mid-1970s those royalties were still going toward repaying the label’s advances.
In 1977 the group addressed the imbalance with a written agreement.
Under it, a share of the songwriting and publishing royalties would be divided among the other band members and their manager.
Decades later, it would be the document a court had to read line by line.
—
## Los Angeles, 1978: “Hello Stranger”
In the spring of 1978 the band recorded eight-track demos at a rehearsal studio in Burbank that carried a familiar name: Southcombe.
In May it moved into Studio B at the Village Recorder in Los Angeles.
It stayed until December.
The album was produced by Supertramp and Peter Henderson, a young English engineer.
By published accounts, the first week went on testing sound setups and produced nothing usable.
At the other end, the mixing took more than two months and stopped only because the deadline had arrived.
The record the two writers first had in mind was not the one they made.
The working idea was an album called “Hello Stranger,” built around their own conflicting ideals: two men looking at the same world and disagreeing about it.
That concept was dropped in favor of a lighter collection of songs.
Rick Davies is reported to have wanted to keep the original title.
Roger Hodgson persuaded him to change it.
Years later, in a book about the band published in 1986, Roger Hodgson explained the choice.
“We chose the title because it was a fun title. It suited the fun feeling of the album.”
How tense were the sessions?
The accounts do not agree.
Roger Hodgson has said that he and Rick Davies were by then living very different lives, and that his partner disliked many of his songs but kept quiet about it.
Peter Henderson, who worked with both men throughout the sessions, remembered the two getting along very well.
A third view came from outside.
Harry Doherty, a journalist for Melody Maker, spent three days with the band and wrote that in all that time he never saw the two songwriters hold a conversation beyond a greeting.
—
## A Song Written at 19
The song that gave the album its name was the oldest thing on it.
Roger Hodgson has said he wrote it when he was 19, around the time he joined the band, and that the words came in about an hour.
He described the moment to Prog magazine in 2023.
“I was dreaming and having fun one day and this song just flowed out.”
It is a daydream about a country he knew only from a distance: a young Englishman imagining the girls, the food and the easy life on the other side of the Atlantic.
It waited almost ten years to be recorded.
According to Roger Hodgson, speaking in 2010, Rick Davies at first hated the song, and he believed his partner did not play on the finished track at all.
That is one man’s recollection, and it should be read as such.
No statement from Rick Davies about the song was found for this article.
What is documented is that Rick Davies did leave a mark on it.
Roger Hodgson himself credits him with the short sung reply that answers the opening lines.
The album’s inner sleeve mistakenly listed Rick Davies alone as the song’s composer and lyricist, while the label on the single credited both men.
The album was split evenly.
Five songs were Roger Hodgson’s, including “The Logical Song,” “Take the Long Way Home” and the title track.
Five were Rick Davies’s, including “Goodbye Stranger” and the opener, “Gone Hollywood.”
The closing track, “Child of Vision,” has often been described as one partner’s open letter to the other.
Roger Hodgson’s own explanation is more careful.
He has said he wrote it as a companion to “Gone Hollywood,” a look at how Americans lived, and that he may have had Rick Davies in mind without being fully aware of it.
—
## The Waitress, the Orange Juice and Six Weeks at No. 1
“Breakfast in America” was released by A&M Records in March 1979.
Its cover became one of the most recognizable of the decade.
Designed by Mike Doud and Mick Haggerty, it shows Lower Manhattan as seen through an airplane window.
The skyline is built from diner crockery, cutlery, boxes and condiment bottles.
In the foreground stands a cheerful waitress named Libby, played by the actress Kate Murtagh, posed as the Statue of Liberty.
Instead of a torch she holds up a glass of orange juice on a small plate, and instead of a tablet she carries a menu.
The photograph on the back was taken at a diner in Hollywood.
“The Logical Song” reached No. 6 in the United States and No. 7 in Britain.
“Take the Long Way Home” reached No. 10 in America, and “Goodbye Stranger” No. 15.
The title track became a top-ten single in Britain, peaking at No. 9.
The album itself went to No. 1 on the Billboard 200 and stayed there for six weeks.
It also topped the charts in Canada, Australia, France, West Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, Austria and Spain, and reached No. 3 in Britain.
In the United States it has been certified four times platinum.
In France, where it is reported to have sold more than three million copies, it remains one of the best-selling albums in the country’s history.
The worldwide figure usually given is more than 20 million.
—
## Two Grammys, and Who Took Them Home
The album is often said to have won the band two Grammy Awards.
That is true of the record and not quite true of the musicians.
At the 22nd Grammy Awards, early in 1980, “Breakfast in America” was nominated for Album of the Year and for best pop vocal performance by a duo or group.
It won neither.
Album of the Year went to Billy Joel’s “52nd Street.”
The two awards it did win were for Best Recording Package and for Best Engineered Recording, Non-Classical.
The first honored the cover, the work of Mike Doud and Mick Haggerty.
The second honored the sound, the work of Peter Henderson.
The five members of Supertramp did not take one home for the biggest album of their lives.
There was a different kind of recognition for the writing.
“The Logical Song” earned Roger Hodgson one of Britain’s Ivor Novello Awards, which are given to songwriters rather than performers.
—
## The Distance
The band toured the album through 1979.
A live double album, “Paris,” recorded at the Pavillon de Paris late that year, followed in 1980.
In 1981 Roger Hodgson moved his family out of Los Angeles to the mountains of northern California, where he built a home and a studio.
The rest of the band stayed in the south.
By every later account, including his own, the geographical distance widened the personal one.
The next album, “…Famous Last Words…,” came out in October 1982.
It contained a Roger Hodgson hit, “It’s Raining Again,” and a Rick Davies favorite, “My Kind of Lady.”
It also showed how hard the two writers now found it to fit their ideas on the same record, and the others in the group could see that Roger Hodgson wanted out.
He announced his decision during the 1983 world tour.
The tour ended that September.
His stated reasons were plain: he wanted more time with his family, and he wanted to make records on his own.
He denied, then, that there were any real personal or professional problems between him and Rick Davies.
It was four years after the six weeks at No. 1.
—
## What Was Agreed in 1983: Two Versions
When Roger Hodgson left, the name Supertramp stayed with Rick Davies.
On that point nobody disagrees.
What else was settled is the heart of the quarrel.
Roger Hodgson’s account has been consistent for decades.
He says the two men reached a spoken agreement: Rick Davies would keep the band’s name and carry on, and Roger Hodgson would keep the songs he had written and sung for his own concerts.
He has said it was never written down, and has described it as a handshake between two men looking each other in the eye.
In an interview published by Prog magazine, he was direct about why he gave up the name.
“That’s the only reason I agreed to give him the name.”
The other side is harder to set down, because it is mostly silence.
Rick Davies gave few interviews and never publicly confirmed or described any such agreement.
Roger Hodgson has said the other members witnessed it.
Dougie Thomson, the bass player, has been quoted as seeing it differently.
“Nobody except Rick and Roger were privy to that conversation.”
Even press reports of Roger Hodgson’s version differ in the detail.
Some describe a promise that neither man would perform the other’s material.
Others describe a condition that the name be used only as a vehicle for Rick Davies’s own songs.
One fact does support the idea that some understanding existed.
When Supertramp returned in 1985 with “Brother Where You Bound,” an album that featured a guest appearance by David Gilmour of Pink Floyd, the tour that followed contained only Rick Davies’s songs.
—
## Five Years Later, the Songs Come Back
Supertramp released “Free as a Bird” in 1987.
The following year the band went on the road again, including its first tour of South America.
This time a handful of Roger Hodgson’s songs were back in the set, sung by another member of the touring band.
The explanation usually given is pressure from audiences, who had bought tickets expecting to hear the hits.
To Roger Hodgson, it was the breaking of a promise.
He put it this way in the Prog interview.
“The difficult part came when he broke that agreement and started playing my songs five years later.”
He added a shorter sentence.
“I felt betrayed.”
From Rick Davies’s side there is, again, no public statement about the decision.
There is only the plain legal position, which nobody has disputed: his name is on the credit of every one of those songs.
After the 1988 tour, Supertramp went quiet for years, and Dougie Thomson left the group.
Roger Hodgson has said the question of his songs was part of the reason.
His first solo album, “In the Eye of the Storm,” appeared in 1984.
In 1987, just before the release of his second, “Hai Hai,” he fell from a loft at his home and broke both wrists.
Doctors reportedly told him he might never play again.
He was playing within about a year and a half.
—
## 1993: Two Songs in Beverly Hills
That is the background to the dinner for Jerry Moss on April 14, 1993.
Afterward, the two songwriters began working together again and recorded demos of two songs, “You Win, I Lose” and “And the Light.”
Then it fell apart.
The reason reported is a disagreement over management.
Both songs later appeared on a Supertramp album, “Some Things Never Change,” released in 1997 after Rick Davies re-formed the band.
Roger Hodgson was not on it.
The re-formed Supertramp continued to play several of his songs in concert.
A last studio album, “Slow Motion,” followed in 2002.
—
## 2010: The Tour and the Offer
The argument became public in the spring of 2010.
On April 21, Supertramp announced 35 concerts in Europe for that autumn, a tour marking forty years since the first album.
Roger Hodgson, who was in the middle of his own world tour, objected in the press to his songs being used to sell it.
After a campaign by fans, he offered to join the band for selected dates that fit between his own bookings.
The offer was declined through Rick Davies’s agent.
This time, the Davies camp did put something in writing.
A statement posted on the band’s website that year gave its version of the months before the tour.
“In June of 2008 Rick Davies went to meet with Roger Hodgson to discuss the possibility of a reunion with him.”
It went on to say how the talks had ended.
“After fifteen months of discussions, last fall Rick and Roger did not come to an agreement as was hoped.”
The statement did not address the 1983 conversation at all.
One man said a promise had been broken.
The other said, through his office, that a reunion had been tried in good faith and had not worked out.
Speaking about a possible reunion the year before, Roger Hodgson had left the door open.
“I would never say never.”
It did not happen.
Supertramp announced another European tour for late 2015, to begin in Portugal that November.
On August 4, 2015, it was canceled.
Rick Davies had been diagnosed with multiple myeloma, a cancer of the blood, and needed to begin treatment.
Supertramp never toured again.
In later years, according to the band, he performed with hometown friends under the name Ricky and the Rockets.
—
## The 1977 Agreement Goes to Court
The last chapter of the dispute was not about who may sing which song.
It was about the agreement the band had made in 1977.
John Helliwell, Bob Siebenberg and Dougie Thomson received their share of the songwriting and publishing income year after year.
In 2018 the payments stopped.
In 2021 the three former members filed suit in federal court in California against Roger Hodgson and Rick Davies.
Rick Davies settled out of court in 2023.
Roger Hodgson and his publishing company contested the claim.
Their argument was that an agreement with no end date could be ended by either side after a reasonable time.
The trial judge agreed with the legal principle and left the factual question to a jury.
In February 2024 the jury was asked whether 41 years was a reasonable time.
It decided that it was, and Roger Hodgson won.
The three plaintiffs appealed.
On August 20, 2025, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the verdict.
The judges reasoned that the agreement did have a built-in duration after all.
It was a promise to share royalties from songs, and those royalties last as long as the copyrights do.
When the copyrights eventually expire, the obligation ends with them, and not before.
The opinion said the defendants had a continuing duty to share the income under the percentages set in 1977, and it stated for how long.
“So long as such royalties continue to exist.”
The appeals court ordered that judgment be entered for the three former members on the question of liability.
What followed in the lower court, including any question of amounts, is beyond what this account has been able to confirm.
It is worth being exact about what the ruling was.
It was a decision about how to read a contract.
It was not a finding about anyone’s character.
—
## August and September 2025
The weeks around that ruling were heavy ones for the people who had made “Breakfast in America.”
Two days after the decision, on August 22, 2025, Dave Margereson died at the age of 79.
He was the A&M Records executive who had believed in the group in the early 1970s and then managed it through its greatest success.
On September 6, 2025, seventeen days after the ruling, Rick Davies died at his home on Long Island, New York.
He was 81.
The band announced his death two days later.
Its statement said he had lived with multiple myeloma for more than ten years.
It remembered him as the voice and the pianist behind many of Supertramp’s best-known songs, and it singled out his playing on the Wurlitzer electric piano as the heartbeat of the band’s sound.
It also spoke of the man: his warmth, his resilience and his devotion to his wife, Sue, with whom he had shared more than fifty years.
Other names from the band’s early history are gone as well.
Frank Farrell, who played bass on “Indelibly Stamped,” died in 1997.
Robert Millar, the drummer on the first album, died on July 22, 2024.
As far as could be confirmed for this article, the four other members of the classic lineup, Roger Hodgson, John Helliwell, Dougie Thomson and Bob Siebenberg, are living.
Roger Hodgson went on performing his Supertramp songs under his own name for decades, including a tour in 2019 and 2020 that marked the album’s fortieth anniversary.
—
## What the Record Shows
Neither songwriter is on record saying that success ruined Supertramp, and the facts point to something slower and more ordinary.
The differences between Rick Davies and Roger Hodgson were there in 1969, when a blues player from Swindon auditioned a 19-year-old from a boarding school.
For ten years those differences made the music.
What the biggest record changed was the scale.
Before 1979, the question of who owned a song, who could sing it and who shared in its income was a private matter among five friends.
After 20 million copies, it was a matter for managers, agents, juries and appeals judges.
Three questions were left behind, and they have three different kinds of answer.
Who wrote the songs?
That one is settled: each man wrote his own, and both names are on all of them.
Who shares in the income from them?
A federal appeals court answered that in August 2025, by reading the paper the band signed in 1977.
Who was entitled to sing them on stage after 1983?
That depends on a conversation between two men, one of whom described it for the rest of his career, and one of whom never did.
What remains is the part nobody disputes.
In 1978, in a studio in Los Angeles, two writers who could barely find anything to say to each other each brought in five songs.
Together they made an album that reached No. 1 around the world.
In March 2026 the album was reissued once more, on a newly mastered LP.
Forty-seven years on, the waitress on the cover is still holding up her glass of orange juice.