Robert-François Damiens, The Last Man Drawn And Quartered In France: He Scratched King Louis XV With A Penknife In 1757, And It Took 16 Executioners, 6 Horses And More Than 2 Hours To Carry Out The Sentence
A wide square, in pale daylight.
There is a picture that is meant to show the last hour of a man named Robert-François Damiens, and this is what it shows.
The sky is the color of old paper.
Under it stands a long pale building with tall chimneys, drawn in faint brown ink, and in front of the building there is a statue of a man on a horse.
Along the foot of the building runs a line of people in three-cornered hats, hundreds of them, standing still.
In the middle of the square a man sits on the bare ground.
He wears a torn white shirt and torn white breeches, and his feet are bare.
His arms are stretched out to either side, and his legs are spread in front of him.
There is a rope knotted around each of his wrists and each of his ankles.
His jaw is set, and his head is tipped back toward the sky.
On the left a man in a red coat and a black three-cornered hat sits on a chestnut horse, with the ropes from one wrist gathered in his hand.
On the right a man in a blue coat sits on a gray horse and holds the ropes from the other wrist.
In the foreground two more men stand with their backs to us, one in a red waistcoat and one in a blue, and each of them holds the rope from an ankle.
The ropes hang slack.
Nobody in the picture has begun to pull.
It is a picture that is hard to look away from.
It is also an artist’s illustration, made long afterward, and nearly everything in it is wrong.
The real square had a city hall on it, not a palace.
The man was not sitting on the ground.
No gentleman on horseback held a rope in his gloved hand.
What the records of the year 1757 describe is plainer, and it is worse.
They describe a servant, forty-two years old, who walked up to the King of France on a winter evening and struck him once in the side with a penknife.
The blade was about three inches long.
The king was wearing so many layers of winter clothing that it went in less than half an inch.
He lived for another seventeen years.
“Arrest him,” the king said, “and do him no harm.”
Eighty-two days later the highest court in France answered that scratch with a sentence it had copied, almost clause for clause, from one handed down a hundred and forty-seven years earlier.
When the servant was told what the day held for him, he is said to have made one remark.
“The day will be hard.”
He was right, and it was harder than the court intended.
The sentence called for four horses.
Sixteen executioners had been gathered from all over France, and not one of them had ever seen this done.
Late that afternoon, with the light going, the chief of them had to admit to the clerk of the court that the horses could not do what the judges had ordered.
So the clerk carried a question to the judges, who were waiting in the city hall at the edge of the square, and the question was whether the executioners might be allowed to use their knives.
To understand how a scratch came to that, we have to begin with the man who made it.
—
## A servant called Robert the Devil
He was born on the ninth of January 1715 in La Thieuloye, a village near Arras, in the flat farm country of Artois in the north of France.
He was the eighth of ten children.
His father had been a farmer and had lost his land.
After that the father worked by the day for other men, and later he kept the door of a prison.
The boy’s mother died when he was sixteen, and an uncle in the town of Béthune took him in.
His brothers and sisters had a name for him.
They called him Robert the Devil, because he could not be kept quiet.
He grew into a tall, thin, dark man with a hooked nose and a face marked by smallpox.
He was pious in a restless way, and when he had been drinking he made speeches about religion.
He is often called a peasant, and sometimes a soldier.
He was neither.
He was a servant, and he was a servant all his adult life.
At nineteen he went to the siege of Philippsburg, on the Rhine, but he went as an officer’s servant.
In Paris he found a place as a valet at Louis-le-Grand, the great college that the Jesuits kept for the sons of good families.
He had to leave it when he married, because the valets there were required to be single.
His wife was a cook.
They had one daughter, who was apprenticed to a seamstress.
After the college he went from house to house.
Many of the houses belonged to magistrates of the Parlement of Paris, the high court of the kingdom, and one of his masters was a councillor named Bèze de Lys, who was among the king’s loudest opponents on the bench.
He waited at their tables and ran their errands through the halls of the law courts, and he heard everything that was said.
In July 1756 he stole two hundred and forty gold louis from the last of his employers and ran north, to his own people around Arras.
He spent the autumn drifting between Artois and the towns across the border.
By his own later admission he told people there that he would go back to France and die there, and that the greatest man on earth would die too.
Nobody reported it.
At the very end of December he came back to Paris, and a few days later he took the road to Versailles.
—
## The quarrel he carried with him
To see what was in his head we have to look at the quarrel that had filled Paris for most of his working life.
It was a quarrel about how a Christian was allowed to die.
In 1713 the pope had issued a ruling, known by its first word, Unigenitus, which condemned the teachings of a strict Catholic movement called Jansenism.
Many French priests and a great many ordinary Parisians had never accepted it.
The Archbishop of Paris, Christophe de Beaumont, decided to make them.
He ordered that a dying person who asked for the last sacraments must first show a certificate, signed by an approved priest, proving that he had confessed to someone who accepted the ruling.
Without the certificate, the priest was to refuse.
In a city where almost everyone believed that the last sacraments opened the way to heaven, this was a terrible weapon.
People died asking for the rites and were denied them.
The Parlement of Paris took the side of the dying.
It ordered priests to give the sacraments and prosecuted those who would not.
The king, Louis XV, stood between the two.
He sent the magistrates into exile, called them back, exiled the archbishop to his country house, and settled nothing.
On the thirteenth of December 1756 he lost patience with the court and came in person to impose new rules on it.
Most of the magistrates answered by resigning their offices.
So in the first days of January 1757 the highest court of France was not sitting, and Paris talked of nothing else.
And a dismissed servant, who had spent years listening to those same magistrates at their dinner tables, was on his way to Versailles with a knife in his pocket.
He said later that he had stopped going to church three or four years before, when the refusals began.
Nobody in his own family had ever been refused.
—
## Wednesday evening at Versailles
The fifth of January 1757 was a Wednesday, and it was bitterly cold.
The court was not at Versailles that week but at the Trianon, the smaller palace in the park.
The king had driven over for the afternoon because one of his daughters, Madame Victoire, was ill in bed in the great palace.
He was forty-six years old, not forty-seven, as it is sometimes said.
Damiens had been in the town for a day or two.
He rented a sword and a hat from a shop on the square in front of the palace, so that he would pass for one of the many people who came to court hoping to be noticed.
Then he walked in among them and waited.
At about six o’clock it was dark, and the courtyard was lit by torches.
The king came down the steps toward his carriage, with his son the Dauphin and a group of officers around him and a line of guards on either side.
Damiens pushed between two of the guards.
He struck the king once, on the right side, and stepped back.
He did not run.
He did not even take off his hat, and in the presence of the king every other head was bare.
The king thought at first that someone had punched him.
Then he put his hand inside his coat, and it came out red.
An English pamphlet printed in London that winter gives his words as “I am wounded, seize him, but do not hurt him.”
The French accounts give almost the same.
“Arrest him, and do him no harm.”
When the captain of the guard asked which man had done it, the same pamphlet says, Damiens answered for himself.
“It is I.”
They found the knife on him.
It was an ordinary folding pocketknife with two blades, bought from an ironmonger.
By most accounts one blade was long and pointed and the other was the short blade used for trimming pens, and it was the short one that he had opened.
That blade measured a little over three inches.
It had entered between the fourth and fifth ribs.
But it was January, and the king was wrapped in layers of silk and velvet under a heavy outer coat.
His first surgeon probed the wound and found that no organ had been touched.
The usual figure for its depth is about a centimeter, which is less than half an inch.
—
## The guardroom, and the king’s bed
Nobody in the palace knew that yet.
A blade could be poisoned, and the king believed that he was dying.
He walked up the stairs on his own feet, went to bed, and asked for a priest.
When the queen came to his bedside he asked her to forgive him for the way he had treated her.
He handed the business of the kingdom to the Dauphin.
Downstairs, in the guardroom, the guards had the man who had done it.
They stripped him and tied him.
Then, without an order from any court, they heated a pair of tongs in the fire and used them on his feet and legs to make him name the people who had sent him.
“No,” he said, according to the French account.
“On my soul, I swear there are none.”
At last, to make them stop, he shouted something that he must have known would frighten them.
“Let them look to the Dauphin.”
It worked, and it did him great harm.
From that moment nobody could believe that he had acted alone.
The Keeper of the Seals, a minister named Machault, arrived in the guardroom, and he is reported to have called for a bundle of firewood and threatened to have the prisoner thrown into the flames.
The officer who was responsible for justice inside the royal household stopped it and took the man into his own custody.
This is worth being clear about, because the story is often told otherwise.
The hot iron at Versailles was not the legal torture that French law then allowed.
It was done by frightened soldiers in the first hour.
The legal torture came later, on the last morning, and it was a different thing.
Upstairs the surgeons told the king that he was in no danger.
The wound had closed in little more than a week.
He stayed in his room for ten days all the same.
Someone tried to cheer him by saying that the cut was not deep, and he is reported to have answered with a sentence that went around the court.
“It is deeper than you think, because it goes to the heart.”
He let it be known at once that he forgave the man.
For some days the court expected him to send away Madame de Pompadour, who had been his mistress and was now his closest adviser, and she prepared to leave.
He did not.
On the first of February he dismissed two of his ministers instead, and one of them was Machault.
The forgiveness went no further than words.
The man himself was left to the law.
—
## Eighty-two days
While he was still held at Versailles, Damiens dictated a letter to the king.
As Voltaire later summarized it, he wrote that he was sorry to have had the misfortune to come near him, but that if the king did not take the side of his people, he and the Dauphin and others would be dead within a few years.
On the night of the seventeenth of January he was moved to Paris under a heavy escort.
They put him in the Conciergerie, the old prison beside the law courts, in the place where the killer of King Henri IV had been held.
He was not kept in a cage, as it is sometimes said.
He was tied to his bed with leather straps that ran to iron rings in the floor, because his keepers were afraid that he would kill himself before the court was ready for him.
Two doctors eventually obtained permission for him to walk about his room for a while each day.
His wife and his daughter were taken to the Bastille.
His father, his brothers and his sisters were arrested as well, and all of them were held in secret.
On the fifteenth of January the king had signed an order naming the court that would try him.
It was to be the senior chamber of the Parlement, sitting together with the princes of the royal blood and the dukes.
So the king chose the judges.
The judges chose the sentence.
They questioned the prisoner more than fifty times, and what they wanted to know was always the same.
Who sent you?
His answers went in circles, but they went around the same few points.
He said that the idea had first come to him three years earlier, because of the archbishop.
He said that no priest had put him up to it, but that he had heard churchmen say dangerous things.
He said that the plot, if there was one, came from the archbishop, who had begun everything by refusing the sacraments.
He said that he had seen the misery of the people.
He said that nobody had paid him.
And he said, many times, that he had no accomplices.
On the question of what he had meant to do, he was not consistent.
In some sessions the record has him speaking of a design against the king’s life.
In others he insisted that he had never meant to kill.
The printed record of the trial runs to hundreds of pages, and we have not read it.
As Voltaire reports it, and Voltaire had the record in front of him, his explanation ran in substance like this.
“I never meant to kill the king.”
“I could have, if I had wanted.”
“I did it so God might touch the king and set things right.”
“And bring peace back to his kingdom.”
To touch the king was his own expression.
He seems to have meant something between a warning and a wound, a blow that would wake a man up.
The judges did not believe that a servant could have thought of this by himself.
They spent ten weeks looking for the gentleman behind him, the priest or the magistrate.
They never found one.
Historians who have gone through the whole file since have mostly concluded that there was nobody to find.
He once said something else to his judges that came closer to the truth than any of their theories.
“If I had never set foot in the halls of the Palace.”
He meant the law courts, where he had carried his masters’ papers and listened to them talk.
The trial opened on the twelfth of February.
There were ten sittings, and Damiens himself was brought before the full court only at the last of them, on the twenty-sixth of March.
That same day the court gave its judgment.
—
## A sentence copied from 1610
There was no doubt about the verdict.
The only question was the punishment, and for that the judges looked backward.
On the fourteenth of May 1610 a man named François Ravaillac had climbed onto the wheel of a carriage stuck in a narrow Paris street and stabbed King Henri IV to death.
Thirteen days later the same court, the Parlement of Paris, had sent him to die on the Place de Grève.
In all the years since then, nobody had raised a hand against a King of France.
So in 1757 the magistrates had their clerks bring out the papers of 1610, and they wrote the sentence over again.
It deserves to be stated once, plainly.
He was to be taken in a cart, wearing only a shirt and holding a burning torch of two pounds of wax, to the main door of the cathedral, and there he was to kneel and ask pardon of God, of the king and of the law.
He was then to be taken to the Place de Grève.
On a scaffold, his right hand, holding the knife, was to be burned with sulfur.
His arms, his chest and his legs were to be torn with heated pincers, and molten lead, boiling oil and burning resin and wax were to be poured on the places.
He was to be pulled apart by four horses.
What was left was to be burned and the ashes thrown to the wind.
Before any of that, he was to be put to the question one last time, to make him name his accomplices.
The sentence did not stop with him.
The house where he was born was to be pulled down, and nothing was ever to be built on the ground.
His father, his wife and his daughter were to leave the kingdom and never return, on pain of death.
His brothers and sisters were to give up the name Damiens.
None of them was accused of anything.
The judgment was not written by ignorant men.
These were the most learned lawyers in France, in the same decade in which the great Encyclopedia of the philosophers was being published in the same city.
And the knife had not killed anyone.
The crime that the court named was parricide against the person of the king, the father of his people, and in law the attempt was the same as the act.
Now the sentence had to be carried out, and that was a practical problem.
The office of executioner of Paris had belonged to one family, the Sansons, since 1688.
In 1757 the holder of the office was Charles-Jean-Baptiste Sanson, and he could not work.
A stroke had left him partly paralyzed some years before.
His son, Charles-Henri, was doing the job in his place.
Charles-Henri Sanson had turned eighteen in February.
So the family sent to Reims for his uncle, Nicolas-Charles-Gabriel Sanson, who was executioner of that city, to take charge.
Executioners were called in from other towns as well, until there were sixteen of them.
Not one had ever seen the punishment that the court had ordered.
Nobody living had.
—
## The twenty-eighth of March
The twenty-eighth of March 1757 was a Monday.
Somewhere in the hours after the judgment, Damiens made the remark that is always quoted.
Some accounts say that it was when the sentence was read to him, and others that it was when they came to wake him on the last morning.
“The day will be hard.”
The day began in the prison, with the question.
In Paris that meant the boots.
The prisoner’s legs were bound between boards, and wooden wedges were driven in, one after another, between the boards and the legs.
A clerk sat beside him and wrote down everything he said.
Doctors stood by to say when it must stop.
Later accounts give the number of wedges as eight.
According to Voltaire, he gave one name that morning.
It was the name of a steward in the household of one of the magistrates, a man named Gautier, who he said had once remarked in his hearing that to strike the king would be a good deed.
Gautier was arrested, confronted with him, and denied it.
He was later released.
If that is right, it was the only name that ten weeks of questioning ever produced, and it was not the name of a plotter.
It was the name of a man who had talked too freely in front of a servant.
In the afternoon they put him in the cart.
He had the torch in his hand.
At the great door of Notre-Dame he was lifted down, and he knelt, and said the words.
Then the cart went on through the crowd to the Place de Grève.
The Grève was the old execution ground of Paris, an open space that sloped down to the River Seine in front of the Hôtel de Ville, the city hall.
It is still there, under another name, and that day it was full to the walls.
Every window that looked onto it had been rented, and the best of them are said to have gone for as much as a hundred livres.
There were people on the roofs.
At one window stood an Italian of thirty-one who had arrived in Paris, by pure chance, on the very day of the attack at Versailles.
His name was Giacomo Casanova.
He had paid three louis for the window, and he had brought a friend and three ladies.
In the middle of the square, inside a fence guarded by soldiers, stood a low wooden platform.
Damiens was laid on it and fastened down.
The clerk of the court, a man named Le Breton, bent over him and asked whether he had anything to say.
He asked more than once during what followed.
The record gives the answers in reported speech, and they are always the same.
Turned into direct speech, they run like this.
“I have nothing more to say.”
“I had no accomplices, none.”
—
## What was done on the Place de Grève
We know what happened next in unusual detail, because two accounts of it were written within days.
One was printed in a Dutch newspaper, the Gazette d’Amsterdam, on the first of April.
The other was set down by a man named Bouton, an officer of the watch, who stood close to the platform from the beginning to the end.
There is no need to follow him line by line.
The sentence was carried out in the order in which it was written.
The right hand was burned.
The pincers were used, and the hot liquids were poured.
Bouton and the newspaper agree about how the man on the platform behaved.
He cried out at each thing that was done.
He did not curse.
The newspaper noted that he had been known all his life as a great swearer, and that not one blasphemy passed his lips.
What he said, over and over, was a prayer.
“Pardon, my God.”
“Pardon, Lord.”
Two priests stayed beside him.
One of them was the old parish priest of Saint-Paul.
The other, a man named Marsilly, ducked under one of the ropes at a certain moment and kissed him on the forehead.
Then the horses were brought.
There were four, and each was harnessed to one of his limbs and driven by one of the executioners’ men.
Here the punishment failed, and it failed in front of all Paris.
The horses pulled, and nothing gave way.
They were stopped and started again.
The Dutch newspaper said that they were not animals trained to pull together.
A French account says that the men handling them had been drinking.
After a quarter of an hour the direction of the pull was changed, and after that two more horses were added, so that there were six.
It made no difference.
One count says that the horses were set to it about sixty times.
One of them fell on the stones.
This is the moment in the picture, or the moment that the picture is trying to imagine.
The executioner, whom Bouton calls Samson, went to the clerk and told him that there was no hope of doing it this way.
He asked the clerk to find out from the judges whether they wished the prisoner to be cut.
The clerk went to the city hall and came back.
The answer was no.
They were to try again.
The judges had ordered a particular death, and they wanted that one.
Only after further attempts, when the light was going and the surgeons had given their opinion that it could not be done, was the permission sent down.
Then the executioners took out their knives and cut through the joints, and the horses were able to finish.
That is the whole of it, and it is enough.
It had taken about two hours and a quarter.
He died as the daylight went.
One of the executioners said afterward that he had still been alive at the very end.
Bouton, who was watching, thought so too.
The fire was lit on the square, as the sentence required.
It burned for some four hours, and Bouton, who had stayed, noted that the last of it was still glowing at about half past ten that night.
—
## The people at the windows
Casanova wrote down his memory of that afternoon more than thirty years later.
He says that his party watched for four hours.
“I was several times obliged to turn away my face and to stop my ears.”
He was not a squeamish man.
What stayed with him was that two of the ladies beside him did not turn away at all.
When he asked them about it afterward, they told him that their horror at the man’s wickedness had left no room in them for pity.
The French accounts also say that some of the fashionable women at the windows treated the afternoon as an entertainment.
The crowd below was different.
The French accounts say that it grew restless as the horses failed, and that it began to mutter against the executioners.
It had come to see a regicide punished.
It was watching a government that did not know how to do what it had decreed.
Two members of the Sanson family never forgot it either.
The uncle from Reims, who had been in charge, went home and gave up his office.
He never carried out another execution.
The nephew, the boy of eighteen, stayed in the trade.
There is a famous sentence that is often quoted as his, to the effect that no punishment had ever been so long or so terrible.
It comes from memoirs that his grandson published under the family’s name in 1862, more than a century later, and no diary by Charles-Henri has ever been found.
We have left the sentence out.
—
## What became of the name
The rest of the judgment was carried out in the following weeks.
The cottage at La Thieuloye was pulled down.
The father, the wife and the daughter were sent out of the kingdom.
The brothers and sisters chose new names.
It is fair to add something that is usually left out.
The king, who had not saved the man, quietly gave the three exiles a pension to live on.
And when the Revolution came, more than thirty years later, several branches of the family took back the name Damiens.
By then it had become a word.
In the 1790s the enemies of Maximilien Robespierre, who came from Arras, put about the story that he was the regicide’s nephew.
It was not true.
It was only the worst thing that they could think of to say.
The king recovered completely in his body.
For a few weeks after the attack he was a changed man, serious and devout, and he kept away from his mistress.
It did not last.
He reigned for seventeen more years and died of smallpox in May 1774.
The Dauphin who had walked beside him to the carriage died before him and never reigned.
The throne went to the Dauphin’s son.
On the evening of the fifth of January 1757 that boy was two years old.
He became Louis XVI.
—
## Why it was the last
It is often said that after 1757 the French courts were too ashamed ever to pass such a sentence again.
That is not quite what happened.
The sentence belonged to one crime only, an attack on the king’s own body, and in the thirty-two years that the old monarchy had left, nobody committed that crime again.
So the punishment was never called for.
It simply stayed on the books, unused, until the books themselves were thrown away.
But something had changed, and the change can be dated.
Seven years after the Place de Grève, a young man from Milan named Cesare Beccaria published a short book called On Crimes and Punishments.
It argued that torture proved nothing and that cruel spectacles taught cruelty.
In 1780 the king’s government abolished the torture that was used to force a confession.
In 1788 it abolished the torture that came before execution, the one that had been used on Damiens on his last morning.
In 1791 the first penal code of the Revolution reduced every death sentence in France to one sentence.
Every person condemned to death was to have his head cut off, and nothing else was to be done to him.
In that same year the Englishman Thomas Paine, defending the Revolution in his book Rights of Man, pointed back to the death of Damiens.
Governments that stage such scenes, he argued, teach the people who watch them how to be cruel.
Then the wheel came all the way around.
It is sometimes said that the same court that had condemned Damiens later condemned the king’s grandson.
It did not.
The Parlement of Paris had been abolished by then.
Louis XVI was tried by an elected assembly, the National Convention, and he died on the twenty-first of January 1793, under the guillotine, in a square on the other side of the city.
But one man was present at both.
The executioner who stood on the platform that morning in 1793 was Charles-Henri Sanson.
It is sometimes said that he was the son of the man who had dealt with Damiens.
He was the same man.
He had been eighteen on the Place de Grève, and he was fifty-three now.
The death of Damiens had one more life, in a book.
In 1975 the French philosopher Michel Foucault published a history of the prison, known in English as Discipline and Punish.
He opened it with the sentence of 1757, the report from the Gazette d’Amsterdam and the notes of the officer Bouton, with hardly a word of comment.
Foucault’s first line gives the date of the judgment as the second of March.
It was the twenty-sixth.
Then he set beside those pages a document written eighty years later, a timetable for a house of young prisoners in Paris, with the hour for rising and the hours for work, school and prayer.
His argument was not that the scaffold had been better.
It was that punishment had not simply grown kinder between the one document and the other.
It had changed its target, he said, from the body of the condemned to his time, his habits and his mind.
Whether or not he was right, it is because of him that students all over the world still read what Bouton wrote down.
—
## The picture, once more
Look at it one last time.
The paper sky, the pale building, the line of hats.
The man on the ground, the two riders, the two men in waistcoats, and the slack ropes.
Now it is possible to say what is true in it.
The four ropes are true.
There was one for each limb.
The horses are true, although there were four of them, and then six.
The crowd is true, and so are the three-cornered hats.
The rest is invented.
The Place de Grève had a city hall on it, built in the style of the Renaissance, and not a palace with a horseman on a pedestal.
The man was not sitting on the paving.
He was fastened to a low wooden platform inside a fence.
Nobody held a rope in his hand.
The ropes ran to the harness of the horses, and the horses were driven by the executioners’ men.
There were no gentlemen in laced coats.
There were sixteen working executioners, an eighteen-year-old among them.
And the man in the middle was not young and strong, as he is drawn.
He was forty-two, thin, and marked by smallpox.
His legs had been burned in January and crushed that same morning, and he could not stand.
What the picture leaves out is everything that made the day what it was.
It leaves out the clerk bending down with his question, and the priest who went under the rope.
It leaves out the windows.
Above all it leaves out the judges in the city hall, sending down their answer.
What the records give us in place of the picture is a servant who had listened too long to his masters’ quarrels.
He had a small knife, and he chose the smaller blade.
When he was asked for names, at the price of everything that was done to him, he gave none that mattered.
And at the end he was asked one more time whether he had anything to say.
He said that he had not.