News

Ravensbrück, The Cruelest Camp Of The War: The Guards Had Answered A Job Ad. What They Did To The French Prisoners…

Signature: 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

In the spring of 1944, in a white-tiled room at the edge of a camp fifty miles north of Berlin, a nineteen-year-old French prisoner was ordered up onto a metal table.

Two people in uniform stood on either side of her.

On her left was a man in a peaked cap who looked at her the way a foreman looks at a machine that has started to make a strange noise.

On her right was a young woman, not much older than the prisoner herself, holding a clipboard against her chest.

Five years earlier, that young woman had been working in a dairy.

She had seen an advertisement, gone to an office, signed a form and taken a train.

Now she held a pencil over a list, waiting to be told what to write.

The man in the peaked cap had a simple question to settle that morning.

Was this prisoner still useful, or was she not?

How the young guard with the clipboard came to be standing in that room, and how the prisoner on the table answered the man in the peaked cap, is the story of Ravensbrück.

The prisoner in this story, whom we will call Yvonne Le Gall, is not one real person.

She is a composite, built from the documented experience of the French political prisoners who were sent to Ravensbrück in 1944, and at the end you will find exactly what is recorded and what is not.

The guards, the camp, the trials and the names in the second half of this story are real.

—

## A lake north of Berlin

Ravensbrück does not look like a place where anything terrible could happen.

It sits beside a lake called the Schwedtsee, across the water from the small town of Fürstenberg, in the flat, wooded country of northern Brandenburg.

Before the war, people from Berlin came up on the train for summer holidays.

They swam, rowed and walked under the pines.

In November 1938, prisoners from another camp were brought in to clear part of the shore and start building barracks.

In May 1939, the first inmates arrived: about nine hundred women transferred from the old fortress camp at Lichtenburg in Saxony.

Ravensbrück was the only major concentration camp the regime built specifically for women.

Over the next six years, somewhere between 130,000 and 132,000 women and girls passed through it and its subcamps.

They came from more than twenty countries.

Poles were the largest group, followed by Germans, Russians and Ukrainians, Hungarians, and several thousand French.

They were political opponents, members of resistance networks, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Roma and Sinti, Jews, women labeled “asocial,” and women who had done nothing more than say the wrong thing to the wrong neighbor.

Each one wore a colored triangle on her sleeve that told the guards which kind she was.

Red for political.

Purple for the Witnesses.

Black for the people the regime called asocial.

Green for criminals.

A few centimeters of cloth, and a whole life was reduced to a category.

The camp was built for a few thousand prisoners.

By the winter of 1944, more than forty thousand were crowded into it at once.

How many died there will never be known exactly.

Estimates run from about thirty thousand to well over fifty thousand.

—

## Wanted: healthy young applicants

Every camp needed guards, and a camp for women needed women to guard them.

The regime had a problem.

The SS was an all-male organization.

Women could not join it.

So the female guards of the camps were hired as civilian employees of the SS, with a title that meant simply “overseer”: *Aufseherin*.

Some were volunteers who believed in the cause.

Many more were recruited the way any employer finds workers.

Labor offices sent young women who were looking for jobs.

Newspapers carried advertisements for healthy young applicants willing to do light work at a “military site,” with good pay, free housing, a uniform and the chance to see something of the world.

Some guards were simply conscripted from factory jobs later in the war, when the camps grew faster than anyone could staff them.

The pay was the hook.

Hermine Braunsteiner, a young Austrian woman working in Germany in 1939, heard about the open positions from her landlord, a policeman in Fürstenberg.

The guard job paid sixty-four marks a week.

That was about four times what she had been earning.

She began her training at Ravensbrück on August 15, 1939.

Dorothea Binz, the daughter of a forester from a village in Brandenburg, was nineteen when she went to Ravensbrück in August 1939 to work in the kitchen.

The next month, she became an overseer.

Ravensbrück was not only a camp.

It was the training school.

Thousands of women learned the job there before being sent on to Auschwitz, Majdanek, Bergen-Belsen and dozens of smaller camps.

Estimates of how many passed through that training run from about 3,500 to more than 4,000.

They learned how to count a roll call.

They learned the rules and the punishments.

They learned to call the prisoners “pieces.”

Most of all, survivors later said, they learned not to see the person in front of them.

Some of the new overseers were shocked in their first days.

A few asked to leave and were allowed to go.

Most stayed.

And a number of them, by the testimony of the women they guarded, became as cruel as any man in the camp system.

—

## Yvonne

Yvonne Le Gall was born in Rennes, in Brittany, in the spring of 1925.

Her father ran a small print shop near the river.

She grew up with the smell of ink and the clack of the press, and by the time she was sixteen she could set type faster than he could.

In 1943, at eighteen, she was working as a typist for a notary and running envelopes for a resistance network after work.

The envelopes went from a café near the station to a bicycle repair shop.

She never opened them.

She never asked.

That was the rule.

In November 1943, a man at the bicycle shop was arrested.

Three days later, two men in civilian coats were waiting for Yvonne in the notary’s front office.

They were polite.

They asked her to bring her coat.

She was held in the prison in Rennes for six weeks.

Then she was put on a train east, to the transit camp at Compiègne, north of Paris.

At the end of January 1944, she and nearly a thousand other French prisoners were loaded into freight cars at Compiègne.

The journey took three days.

When the doors finally slid open, there were dogs on the platform and young women in grey uniforms and capes shouting at them in German.

Yvonne remembered one thing about those first minutes all her life.

The guards were her own age.

—

## Roll call

The day at Ravensbrück began in the dark.

A siren went off before four in the morning.

The prisoners had minutes to dress, make their bunks to regulation and get a mouthful of the brown liquid the camp called coffee.

Then they ran out onto the main street of the camp, the *Lagerstrasse*, and stood in rows of ten for the roll call.

They stood until the count came out right.

Sometimes that took an hour.

Sometimes, in winter, it took three or four.

The guards walked the rows with their dogs.

A prisoner who swayed, or leaned on her neighbor, or bent down to pull a rag tighter around her feet, could be beaten where she stood.

Yvonne learned the rules quickly, because the other French women taught them to her.

Never look a guard in the eye.

Never be first in line and never be last.

Never let them learn your name.

In the barrack, at night, the older prisoners taught the younger ones a different set of lessons.

A schoolteacher from Lyon taught history in whispers.

A woman from Toulouse recited recipes, slowly and in detail, while the others lay in the dark with their eyes closed and pretended to taste them.

They called it cooking in the head.

It was not a joke.

It was a way to stay human.

In the spring of 1944, Yvonne was assigned to one of the long workshop barracks outside the camp wall, where prisoners assembled electrical parts for the Siemens company.

The work was fine and fiddly, and her fingers, trained on the type cases in her father’s shop, were good at it.

For a while, that saved her.

—

## The guard with the clipboard

There was a young overseer in Yvonne’s workshop block.

The prisoners never learned her full name.

They called her the Milkmaid, because one of the Polish women had heard her say she had worked in a dairy before the war.

She was perhaps twenty-one, with fair hair pinned up under her cap and a round, freckled face.

She was not the worst of them.

That was what made her frightening.

She did not scream like some of the others.

She did not beat prisoners for sport.

She simply did whatever she was told, completely, without hesitation, and wrote it all down.

When a prisoner fell behind at the bench, the Milkmaid wrote down her number.

When a prisoner was too sick to stand at roll call, the Milkmaid wrote down her number.

Once, Yvonne saw her hand a list to an officer and then stand smiling at the window while he read it, the way a schoolgirl waits for a teacher to praise her homework.

The French women talked about her at night.

How does a girl from a dairy end up here?

The schoolteacher from Lyon had an answer.

“Nobody comes here a monster. They come for the pay. Then they get used to it.”

—

## The infirmary

In April 1944, Yvonne fainted at her bench.

She had been running a fever for days, and she had hidden it, because every prisoner knew that being sick at Ravensbrück was dangerous.

When she came to, she was on the floor and the Milkmaid was standing over her with her pencil.

The next morning, Yvonne’s number was called after roll call.

She was marched to the infirmary block, the *Revier*.

She was taken past the crowded rooms where the sick lay two and three to a bunk, into a bright, tiled room at the end of the corridor with a tall window, a sink, glass bottles on a bench and a long metal table.

She was ordered to climb up onto the table.

She sat on it with her hands pressed flat on the cold steel.

The Milkmaid came in behind her and stood on her right with the clipboard.

Then a man in a uniform and a peaked cap came in and stood on her left.

No record survives of what was said in rooms like that one.

The scene below is a reconstruction.

It is not a transcript.

The man did not introduce himself.

He took Yvonne’s hand by the wrist, turned it palm up and then palm down, looked at her fingers, and let it drop back onto the steel.

He looked at her hands, not her face, and spoke as if he were reading a label.

“Your hands still work. That is all we need from you.”

Yvonne was shaking.

She did not know whether it was the fever or the fear.

But something in her straightened, and she lifted her chin and looked at him.

“I am not your hands. I have a name.”

The Milkmaid’s pencil stopped.

The man glanced at her, then back at Yvonne, and smiled a little, as if a machine had made a joke.

He nodded toward the clipboard without looking at it.

“Here you have a number. She will write it down.”

The Milkmaid wrote.

Yvonne could hear the pencil scratching.

She turned her head and looked straight at the young guard, at the freckles and the pinned-up hair and the pencil, until the Milkmaid had to look up.

“Write it down, then. My mother still knows my name.”

For a moment, nobody in the room moved.

Then the man said one word in German to the guard, turned and left.

The Milkmaid tore the top sheet off her clipboard, folded it and put it in her pocket.

She did not look at Yvonne again.

Yvonne was sent back to the workshop that afternoon.

She never found out what was written on that sheet, or why she was sent back instead of somewhere else.

—

## What the table meant

Yvonne was lucky, and she knew it.

In Ravensbrück, the infirmary was not a place where prisoners went to get well.

It was a place where they were sorted.

From the summer of 1942, the camp’s SS doctors used it for medical experiments.

Seventy-four young Polish political prisoners, most of them students and girl guides, were operated on to test sulfonamide drugs and bone and muscle regeneration.

Their legs were deliberately cut open and infected, or had bone and muscle removed.

Five of them died from the operations.

Six more were shot after their wounds had healed.

The survivors limped through the camp, and the other prisoners named them *the rabbits*.

Later, the doctors in Ravensbrück carried out forced sterilizations on Roma and Sinti prisoners, among them very young girls, by injections and by X-rays.

And the infirmary was where the weak were selected.

From 1942, prisoners judged unfit for work were put on what the camp called “black transports.”

Some went to a so-called euthanasia center at Bernburg, where they were gassed.

Others were sent to camps in the East.

From the end of 1944, a selection in the infirmary could mean the gas chamber the SS built in a hut beside the crematorium inside Ravensbrück itself.

In that system, a typist’s fingers that could still assemble switches for Siemens were worth something.

A prisoner who could no longer work was worth nothing.

That was the whole meaning of the man’s first sentence.

—

## The operetta in the packing crate

Not every act of resistance at Ravensbrück involved a gun or a secret message.

Some involved a pencil.

Germaine Tillion was a French ethnologist who had spent years studying the Berber people of the Aurès mountains in Algeria.

In Paris during the occupation, she helped organize one of the earliest resistance networks.

She was betrayed by a priest who had worked his way into the group’s confidence, and arrested on August 13, 1942.

At the end of October 1943, she arrived at Ravensbrück.

Her mother, Émilie, also a member of the resistance, was later deported there too.

In the camp, Tillion did what an ethnologist does.

She observed.

She studied how the camp worked, who decided what, how many prisoners came in and how many went out, and taught the other prisoners what she learned, because she believed that understanding the system was itself a kind of defense.

And in the winter of 1944, while she was sick and hiding from a work detail, her friends hid her in a packing crate.

There, she wrote an operetta.

It was called *Le Verfügbar aux Enfers*, roughly “The Available One in the Underworld.”

The *Verfügbar* were the prisoners with no fixed work assignment, the ones who could be sent to any job at any moment, and who spent their days trying to hide from the guards.

Tillion was one of them.

Her operetta mocked the camp, the guards, the hunger and the prisoners themselves, set to the tunes of popular songs and operettas every French woman knew.

It was full of jokes.

That was the point.

If you could laugh at the camp, it did not own all of you.

The manuscript survived.

It was performed for the first time on a real stage in Paris in 2007, at the Théâtre du Châtelet.

Tillion was a hundred years old.

—

## Milena

Another prisoner in the camp in those years was a Czech journalist named Milena Jesenská.

Before the war, she had been one of the best-known writers in Prague.

She had translated Franz Kafka into Czech, and his letters to her were later published as one of the great love letters of the century.

When the Germans occupied Prague in 1939, she helped Jews and political refugees escape the country.

She was arrested that November and sent to Ravensbrück in 1940.

Survivors remembered her as fearless and generous.

She shared what little food she had.

She talked to the frightened new arrivals.

She refused to be made small.

Milena Jesenská died in the camp on May 17, 1944, of kidney disease that went untreated.

She was forty-seven.

—

## The winter of the last year

By the autumn of 1944, Ravensbrück was collapsing under its own numbers.

Camps in the East were being emptied ahead of the Red Army, and their prisoners were sent west.

After the Warsaw Uprising failed, thousands of women from Warsaw arrived at once.

A huge tent was put up to hold the overflow.

Women lay in the mud under the canvas, without blankets, through the start of winter.

Typhus spread from block to block.

Rations shrank to a bowl of turnip soup and a piece of bread a day.

At roll call, women died standing up.

In the first weeks of 1945, the SS converted a hut near the crematorium into a gas chamber.

Over the next three months, several thousand prisoners were murdered there.

Estimates range from about 2,200 to more than 5,000.

The sick and the old were selected first.

So were women with white hair, swollen legs or any sign that they could no longer work.

Germaine Tillion’s mother, Émilie, was in her late sixties.

In March 1945, she was taken in one of those selections.

Her daughter was still in the camp.

Yvonne, in our story, survived that winter because of a sock.

In January 1945, her fever came back and her feet swelled so badly that she could not get her shoes on.

A Polish prisoner from the rabbits’ block gave her a pair of wool socks she had knitted from unraveled sweaters, and showed her how to stand at roll call with her weight on the side of her feet so that the swelling did not show.

She never learned the woman’s last name.

—

## The last days

In April 1945, the camp began to come apart.

On April 22 and 23, white buses with red crosses painted on their roofs drove through the gate.

They were part of an operation organized by Count Folke Bernadotte of the Swedish Red Cross, who had negotiated with Heinrich Himmler to release prisoners from the Western countries.

Thousands of French, Belgian, Dutch, Polish and Scandinavian women were taken north to Denmark and Sweden.

Germaine Tillion was among them.

Yvonne was not.

She was in the infirmary again that week, with typhus.

At the end of April, the SS marched most of the remaining prisoners out of the camp toward the northwest, more than twenty thousand of them, in columns that stretched for miles.

The guards went with them.

Those who could not walk were left behind.

On the night of April 29 to 30, 1945, soldiers of the Red Army reached the camp.

They found fewer than 3,500 prisoners still inside, most of them too sick to stand.

Yvonne was one of them.

She weighed less than eighty pounds.

She did not remember the soldiers coming in.

She remembered waking up a day later to a woman she did not know, in a Russian army tunic, spooning warm milk into her mouth.

—

## The guards after the war

When the war ended, the Allies went looking for the people who had run the camps.

Many of the overseers simply went home.

They took off their uniforms, burned their papers and went back to farms and factories and kitchens.

Some were never found.

Others were.

The British tried the Ravensbrück staff in a series of trials in Hamburg between December 1946 and 1948.

Survivors came to testify.

Germaine Tillion, who had spent the months since the war gathering evidence about the camp, followed the first trial closely.

Dorothea Binz, who had gone from the kitchen to the punishment block to deputy head overseer, was captured by the British in Hamburg in May 1945.

At her trial, survivors described her walking through the camp with a whip and a dog, and choosing which prisoners to punish.

She was sentenced to death.

On May 2, 1947, she was hanged at Hamelin prison in Lower Saxony.

She was twenty-seven.

She reportedly said to the executioner: “I hope you will not think we are all evil people.”

Irma Grese had trained at Ravensbrück as an eighteen-year-old in 1942 before being sent to Auschwitz and Bergen-Belsen.

She was tried by the British at the Belsen trial and hanged at Hamelin on December 13, 1945, at twenty-two.

Maria Mandl, who had been chief overseer at Ravensbrück in 1942 before running the women’s camp at Auschwitz-Birkenau, was tried in Kraków and hanged in January 1948.

Of the thousands of women who had worked as overseers in the camp system, only a small number were ever tried.

—

## The housewife in Queens

One of them was found nearly twenty years later, in New York.

After the war, Hermine Braunsteiner, who had trained at Ravensbrück in 1939, served at the Majdanek camp in occupied Poland and then returned to Ravensbrück’s subcamps, was convicted in Austria in 1949 for abusing prisoners at Ravensbrück.

She served a few months.

In the 1950s, she met an American, Russell Ryan, in Austria.

They married, moved to Canada and then to the United States.

In 1963, she became an American citizen.

The couple lived in a quiet neighborhood in Maspeth, Queens.

The neighbors knew her as a friendly housewife who kept a tidy home.

In 1964, the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal tipped off *The New York Times* that a former camp guard might be living in Queens.

The paper sent a young reporter, Joseph Lelyveld, to find “Mrs. Ryan.”

He found her at the second doorbell he rang.

When he explained why he was there, she said: “My God, I knew this would happen. You’ve come.”

Her husband told the reporter there was no more decent person on earth.

It took the United States nine more years to send her back.

In 1973, she became the first suspected Nazi war criminal extradited from the United States to West Germany.

She was tried in Düsseldorf in the long Majdanek trial, which lasted from 1975 to 1981.

She was sentenced to life in prison.

She was released in 1996 because of her failing health and died in 1999.

—

## What Really Happened

Yvonne Le Gall did not exist.

Neither did the guard the prisoners called the Milkmaid, the schoolteacher from Lyon or the man in the peaked cap.

They are composite characters, built from the documented experience of the French political prisoners at Ravensbrück, so that this story could follow one prisoner from beginning to end without putting invented words into the mouths of real survivors.

The scene in the infirmary is a reconstruction, and every word spoken in it is imagined.

Here is what is documented.

Ravensbrück, on the Schwedtsee near Fürstenberg, about fifty miles north of Berlin, received its first prisoners in May 1939, when around nine hundred women were transferred from Lichtenburg.

Between about 130,000 and 132,000 women and girls passed through the camp and its subcamps before the end of the war.

The camp was also the main training center for the female overseers of the camp system; estimates of how many were trained there run from about 3,500 to more than 4,000.

Overseers were civilian employees of the SS.

Many were recruited through labor offices and advertisements promising good pay; some were later conscripted from industrial jobs.

Hermine Braunsteiner’s pay of sixty-four marks a week, about four times her previous wage, and the landlord who told her about the job, are recorded in the account of her life.

Siemens & Halske used Ravensbrück prisoners as forced laborers in workshops built next to the camp from 1942.

The medical experiments on seventy-four Polish prisoners, the forced sterilizations of Roma and Sinti prisoners, and the gas chamber built near the crematorium at the start of 1945 are documented in the postwar trials and in the camp’s history.

Germaine Tillion, arrested on August 13, 1942, arrived at Ravensbrück at the end of October 1943, wrote *Le Verfügbar aux Enfers* in the camp, lost her mother there in March 1945, and left with the Swedish Red Cross in April 1945; the operetta premiered at the Théâtre du Châtelet in 2007, and she died in 2008 at the age of one hundred.

Milena Jesenská died in Ravensbrück on May 17, 1944.

The Red Army reached the camp on April 29 and 30, 1945, and found fewer than 3,500 prisoners still there.

Dorothea Binz was hanged on May 2, 1947; Irma Grese on December 13, 1945; Maria Mandl in January 1948.

Hermine Braunsteiner Ryan was found in Queens by *The New York Times* in 1964, extradited in 1973, sentenced to life in Düsseldorf in 1981, released in 1996 and died in 1999.

Online videos that describe Ravensbrück as a place of “depravity” often mix real events with invented ones.

This story keeps only what the record supports.

—

## A name, not a number

Yvonne went home to Rennes in June 1945.

Her mother was waiting at the station.

She had been told twice that her daughter was dead, and she had refused to believe it both times.

Yvonne went back to setting type in her father’s shop.

She married late, had two sons, and almost never talked about the camp.

But every year, on the day the Red Army came, she did one small thing.

She took a pencil and a sheet of paper and wrote her own name at the top in careful capital letters.

Then she wrote the names of every French prisoner she could remember from her block, one by one, down the page.

Her sons once asked her why.

She said that in the camp, a girl not much older than she was had stood beside a metal table with a clipboard and turned people into numbers.

“So I turn them back.”

You Might Also Enjoy