How Carlos Santana’s Band Gave Birth to Journey: The 16-Year-Old Eric Clapton Wanted, the Organist Who Quit for a Restaurant and the Reunion 45 Years Later
In November 1970, Eric Clapton was in the San Francisco Bay Area with his new band, Derek and the Dominos.
Before their show in Berkeley, a jam session was arranged with members of Santana, the Latin rock band that had become famous at Woodstock the summer before.
One of the players who got the nod to join in was a 16-year-old guitarist from the suburbs south of San Francisco.
His name was Neal Schon.
By his own account, Eric Clapton liked what he heard so much that he made him an offer: come and join Derek and the Dominos.
There was a catch.
He would have to move to England.
Word of the offer reached the Santana camp quickly, and Santana made an offer of its own.
The teenager chose Santana.
Two years later, the band he joined had broken apart.
Out of its pieces came one of the biggest American rock bands of all time.
This is the story of how Santana, without ever meaning to, gave the world Journey.
—
## A Tomato Patch in 1966
To understand why the split hurt, it helps to know how the band began.
Gregg Rolie was a keyboard player from the San Francisco Peninsula, born the same summer as Carlos Santana, when the two of them first crossed paths in the mid-1960s.
He has told the story of that first night with obvious delight.
As he remembered it, the evening ended with the police arriving, and the two young musicians running.
He said he was talking to the back of Carlos Santana’s head as they fled, and that they hid in a tomato patch until the police left.
“That’s how I met him,” he said.
They started playing together.
Gregg Rolie said he had to make a choice between school and music, and chose music.
The band took its name the way blues bands of the day did, after one player, like the Paul Butterfield Blues Band.
At first it was the Santana Blues Band.
As the music moved beyond the blues, with congas and timbales added to the guitar and organ, the name was shortened to Santana.
“We did something nobody had ever done,” Gregg Rolie said.
In August 1969, the band played Woodstock, and its long instrumental “Soul Sacrifice” made it famous across America.
Gregg Rolie was the singer on its early hits, including “Black Magic Woman.”
—
## The Kid in the Quad
Neal Schon was born on February 27, 1954, at Tinker Air Force Base in Oklahoma.
His family later settled on the San Francisco Peninsula, and by his early teens he was already a remarkable guitarist.
Gregg Rolie, Santana’s organist and lead singer, remembered him clearly.
In a long podcast interview, Gregg Rolie said he used to pick Neal Schon up from high school.
He said the teenager was technically at school, but spent his time in the quad playing his guitar, because that was what he was going to do forever.
“So yeah, it became true,” Rolie said.
Gregg Rolie started bringing him along to Wally Heider’s studio in San Francisco, where Santana was recording its second album, “Abraxas,” in 1970.
Neal Schon came in and jammed with the band.
—
## “What a Great Idea”
Gregg Rolie wanted him in the band.
But he did not want to be the one to say so.
As he explained it, going to Carlos Santana and announcing that the band needed another guitarist would have been bad form.
So he kept quiet and let the music do the talking.
It worked.
In Gregg Rolie’s telling, Carlos Santana eventually turned to him and asked what he thought about having this guy in the band.
“I said what a great idea,” Rolie recalled, laughing.
Neal Schon’s parents had to agree.
Gregg Rolie said he sat down with them and promised that their son would be close by, that he could stay with him, and that he would keep an eye on him.
Rolie, who was about seven years older, admitted later with a laugh that the arrangement did not work out quite as planned.
—
## Clapton or Santana
The Eric Clapton offer is the part of the story that rock fans still argue about.
Neal Schon has told it many times.
After the jam, he has said, Eric Clapton made him an offer back at his hotel to join Derek and the Dominos, on the condition that he move to England.
Gregg Rolie confirmed the choice in his own interview: at the time, he said, Neal Schon had the option of playing with Eric Clapton or going with Santana.
The teenager stayed home.
It is worth remembering what Derek and the Dominos were at that moment.
Their album “Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs” had just come out.
It would later be recognized as one of the great rock albums, but the band itself would fall apart within a year.
Santana, on the other hand, was about to have a number-one album.
—
## Two Guitars on “Santana III”
“Abraxas” was released in September 1970 and went to number one.
It gave the band “Black Magic Woman” and “Oye Como Va,” and made Santana one of the biggest groups in America.
Neal Schon was not on it.
His first album with the band was the next one, generally known as “Santana III,” released in September 1971.
He was 17 when it came out.
It also went to number one.
For the first time, Santana had two lead guitarists.
Carlos Santana’s long, singing lines now had a second voice beside them: faster, harder, closer to British blues-rock.
On songs like “Everybody’s Everything” and the album’s heavier tracks, the two guitars traded and doubled parts.
For a moment, the band looked unstoppable.
—
## The Band That Could Not Hold Together
It wasn’t.
The original Santana band had been formed on the streets and in the clubs of San Francisco.
Its members were young, suddenly rich and famous, and pulling in different directions.
Carlos Santana was being drawn toward jazz and toward spirituality.
He was listening to John Coltrane and Miles Davis, and he wanted the band’s music to follow.
Others, Gregg Rolie among them, wanted to stay closer to the hard, song-based rock that had made them famous.
There were personal problems too, and drugs were part of the life of many bands of that era.
The tension came to a head on tour in 1971.
—
## “That’s Not Carlos Santana”
Gregg Rolie has described one episode from that period in detail.
According to his account, at one stage Carlos Santana did not go out on a run of dates the band had already contracted to play.
Gregg Rolie said he believed the band had made a deal and should honor it, and he talked the others into going on without their leader.
So the band played a series of shows without Carlos Santana.
Neal Schon played the solos.
At one of the shows, which Rolie remembered as being in Washington, D.C., someone in the audience realized that the guitarist was not Carlos Santana, and the night almost turned into a riot.
Gregg Rolie said Neal Schon could play anything.
But the teenager came to him afterward and told him he could not keep doing this.
They needed Carlos Santana back.
In Gregg Rolie’s words, after that “the whole thing kind of imploded.”
Members started to leave.
He remembered one show at Madison Square Garden where the band played with no percussion at all, until he found a conga player and took him backstage to try him out.
This is Gregg Rolie’s version of events.
Carlos Santana has told his own story of those years in his 2014 memoir, “The Universal Tone,” and in many interviews, describing it as the period when he turned toward a spiritual path.
What both sides agree on is that the band of Woodstock and “Abraxas” did not survive 1972.
—
## “Caravanserai”
The fourth Santana album, “Caravanserai,” was released in October 1972.
It was a largely instrumental, jazz-influenced record, built as one long flowing piece, opening with the sound of crickets.
It made the new direction unmistakable.
It was also the end of an era.
Gregg Rolie said he had already quit by the time it was made.
He agreed to do one last album, and that was it.
Neal Schon also played on parts of “Caravanserai.”
It was the last Santana album of the period to include either of them.
After it, Carlos Santana went on with a new band and a new sound, and Santana became, more than ever, his band.
—
## A Restaurant in Seattle
Gregg Rolie did not go straight into another band.
He went into the restaurant business.
His father had a restaurant in Seattle, and Rolie went to work with him.
He said later that it made the music business look like child’s play.
In a restaurant, he explained, the customers have to come back again and again, every night, just to keep the doors open; the margins are thin, and it is a cash business.
He also said he truly did not think he would play music again.
Then the phone rang.
—
## The Man Who Drove the Truck
The call came from two people.
One was Neal Schon.
The other was Herbie Herbert.
Walter “Herbie” Herbert had worked with Santana for years, behind the scenes.
Gregg Rolie described him as the band’s stage manager, truck driver and equipment man; he even built amplifiers.
He knew every member of the old band, and he knew exactly what Neal Schon could do.
In 1973 Herbie Herbert and Neal Schon put together a new group in San Francisco.
The original idea, as Gregg Rolie remembered it, was something like a house band: a group of top players called the Golden Gate Rhythm Section that could back artists who came to San Francisco and needed a band.
But the musicians started writing songs.
And Neal Schon and Herbie Herbert wanted Gregg Rolie to come home and sing and play keyboards.
He came back to California.
—
## A Name From the Road Crew
The new band soon needed a real name.
It was suggested by a member of the crew, a roadie named John Villanueva.
The name was Journey.
The early line-up brought together Neal Schon and Gregg Rolie from Santana, the bassist Ross Valory, the guitarist George Tickner and, after a search for the right drummer, the English drummer Aynsley Dunbar, who had played with Frank Zappa and David Bowie.
Gregg Rolie said the first drummer they wanted was Prairie Prince, who was playing with the San Francisco band the Tubes and did not want to leave.
Herbie Herbert became the band’s manager.
He would stay in that role for about twenty years.
Journey signed with Columbia, the same label as Santana.
—
## Three Albums and a Problem
Journey’s first album, simply called “Journey,” was released in 1975.
It was followed by “Look Into the Future” in 1976 and “Next” in 1977.
The music was ambitious, built on long instrumental passages and Neal Schon’s guitar, closer to jazz-rock than to radio pop.
The albums found an audience, but they did not sell in the numbers Columbia wanted.
The label had a clear idea of what was missing.
According to Gregg Rolie, the message was that the band needed a lead singer, a frontman.
Neal Schon’s reaction, as Rolie told it, was simple: he thought they already had one.
Gregg Rolie himself did not mind at all.
He was singing lead while playing several keyboards and a harmonica, and he later said he welcomed a singer who could take some of the weight.
—
## The Voice on the Tape
The first new singer was Robert Fleischman, who toured with the band in 1977 and co-wrote some of their early songs.
It did not last.
Herbie Herbert had heard about another singer, from people at Columbia and from a tape someone handed him.
As Gregg Rolie put it, from the very start Herbie Herbert wanted that man to be Journey’s singer.
His name was Steve Perry.
He joined in 1977.
Gregg Rolie said that the first song Steve Perry wrote with Neal Schon, “Patiently,” made it obvious that something big was about to happen.
The album “Infinity,” released in 1978, was Journey’s commercial breakthrough.
It included “Lights” and “Wheel in the Sky,” and it was the band’s first album to go platinum.
Journey had become a different band: tighter songs, big harmonies, a singer out front.
Gregg Rolie said that for him it was the opposite of everything he had done in Santana, where the band wrote music and sang over it, rather than writing songs built for a vocalist.
—
## Leaving Again
By 1980, Journey was one of the biggest touring bands in America.
The albums “Evolution” in 1979 and “Departure” in 1980 kept the run going.
And Gregg Rolie walked away again.
He was about 33.
He wanted to start a family and get off the road.
He said he had built two bands and had been touring for about fourteen years, and he did not want to do it anymore.
Over the years, he has heard many theories about why he left, including the idea that he resented Steve Perry taking over.
He has rejected them.
He said he had heard many stories about why he quit, and none of them were true.
He welcomed Steve Perry, he said, and simply had enough of the road.
His replacement on keyboards was Jonathan Cain.
The next album, “Escape,” released in 1981, went to number one and included “Don’t Stop Believin’.”
—
## Twice in the Hall of Fame
The two bands’ stories stayed linked.
In 1998 Santana was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
The musicians named were Carlos Santana and the core of the early band, including Gregg Rolie.
In 2017 Journey was inducted too.
The inductees included Neal Schon and Gregg Rolie, along with Steve Perry, Jonathan Cain, Ross Valory, Aynsley Dunbar and Steve Smith.
That made Gregg Rolie one of the few musicians to be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame twice, with two different bands that he helped found.
In between, there had been other reunions of a kind.
In the late 1990s, Gregg Rolie and Neal Schon joined several other members of the early Santana band, without Carlos Santana, in a group called Abraxas Pool, which made one album.
But the original guitarist was missing.
—
## “Santana IV”
The last chapter began with Neal Schon.
According to the published history of the project, it was he who suggested that he and Carlos Santana make music together again.
Carlos Santana liked the idea, and proposed going further: bring back Gregg Rolie, the drummer Michael Shrieve and the conga player Michael Carabello as well.
Gregg Rolie was on tour with Ringo Starr at the time.
He later said he got a call from Neal Schon about doing Santana again, waited until he got home, and then called Carlos Santana to ask if it was true.
It was.
Writing sessions and rehearsals began in 2013.
The album was recorded over 2014 and 2015, in studios in Nevada, California and Texas.
The name explained itself.
The original band’s story had stopped with “Santana III,” so this would be “Santana IV.”
It was released on April 15, 2016.
It debuted at number five on the Billboard 200, Santana’s fourteenth top-ten album in the United States.
Carlos Santana described the sessions in one line.
“It was magical, we didn’t have to try to force the vibe – it was immense.”
—
## A Short Encore
The reunited band also played live.
A concert at the House of Blues in Las Vegas in March 2016 was filmed and released.
But the shows did not turn into a long tour.
Gregg Rolie has said that the reunion ended sooner than he wanted, and that he told Carlos Santana that all they needed to do was go out for thirty days and show the fans they meant it.
He said the audiences went crazy for it.
He did not claim to know all the reasons it stopped, and he did not try to settle them in public.
“The point is it didn’t happen,” he said.
—
## The Man Behind It All
Herbie Herbert, the road manager who had driven Santana’s truck and then built Journey, died in 2021.
Gregg Rolie remembered him with obvious affection.
He said Herbie Herbert used to tell him he had a charmed life, but that he should never say so out loud, or it would destroy it.
So, Gregg Rolie said, he does not say so.
He just feels fortunate.
—
## Still on the Road
Neal Schon never stopped.
Through every change of line-up, he remained Journey’s guitarist and the one constant member of the band.
When Steve Perry left, Journey carried on with other singers.
In 2007 the band found a new one in an unlikely place: Arnel Pineda, a singer from the Philippines whom Neal Schon discovered through videos posted online.
The band is still touring today, more than fifty years after Herbie Herbert and a teenage guitarist from Santana started it.
Gregg Rolie went back to music too, eventually joining Ringo Starr’s All-Starr Band and touring the world with a Beatle.
He has said that if it had not been for Ringo Starr and the Beatles, he might have become an architect.
—
## One Band, Two Legacies
Looking back, the split of the original Santana band in 1972 can look like a loss.
The young, hungry group of Woodstock never got to make a fifth album together.
But the break produced two very different futures.
Carlos Santana followed his music into jazz and spirituality, and decades later came back to the top of the charts with “Supernatural.”
Neal Schon and Gregg Rolie, with the band’s former road manager, built Journey, which went on to sell tens of millions of records and give the world “Don’t Stop Believin’.”
None of it would have happened without a teenager in a school quad, an organist who did not want to be pushy, and a Santana guitarist who asked a simple question: what do you think about having this guy in the band?
And none of it would have happened if, in November 1970, a 16-year-old had said yes to Eric Clapton.