News

Henry VIII — The King Who Rotted Alive In His Own Bed At Whitehall

Whitehall Palace, Westminster.

Thursday, January 27, 1547, late in the evening.

The smell reached the door before anyone did.

It came out of the king’s bedchamber every time the door was opened, a thick, sweetish rot laid underneath the smoke of the fires and the herbs that the grooms kept throwing on them, and the men who had business inside learned to take one deep breath in the gallery and hold it as they went through.

Nobody mentioned it.

Nobody had mentioned it for years.

The fires had been banked high all day, because the king felt the cold in his legs.

The air was close and damp.

Candles burned beside the bed, because the curtains had been drawn against the January dark.

He lay propped on a hill of pillows, almost sitting, because he could no longer breathe when he lay flat.

He was fifty-five years old.

He had been king of England for nearly thirty-eight years.

Under the linen of his nightshirt his body spread across the bed like something poured there, and under the coverlet both of his legs were wrapped in bandages soaked in ointment, bound over a wound that had been opening and closing, weeping and healing and opening again, for close to twenty years.

His breathing filled the room.

A long drag in.

A wet, uneven rattle out.

Three physicians stood back against the paneling, as far from the bed as their duty allowed.

Their names were Thomas Wendy, George Owen and Robert Huicke.

All three knew what was happening.

All three had known for days.

None of them had said it.

They had a reason.

It was treason in England to speak of the king’s death, to predict it, to imagine it out loud, and men had gone to the scaffold for less than a doctor’s honest opinion.

So the physicians changed the dressings and measured the doses and watched him breathe, and said nothing at all.

Then a man in a black gown stepped away from the wall and walked to the side of the bed.

He was Sir Anthony Denny, the chief gentleman of the king’s privy chamber, the man who kept the stamp of the king’s signature.

He had served Henry for most of his adult life, and he knew exactly what the law said.

He bent close to the pillows, close enough to breathe the air around that bed, and he did not cover his face.

How do you tell the most dangerous man in England that his body is finished?

What the king said back to him was written down, and it has survived.

So has what happened to that great body after the last breath left it, on a cold night in an empty abbey beside the Thames.

It had been predicted to Henry’s face fifteen years earlier, by a friar who stood in the pulpit and told him that one day the dogs would come for him.

You will hear all of it before the end.

—

## The handsomest prince in Christendom, and the calf he was proud of

It is hard now to picture the young man he had been.

In 1515, when Henry was twenty-three, a Venetian diplomat named Piero Pasqualigo was brought to see him and sent home a description that reads almost like a love letter.

The king of England, he wrote, was the handsomest prince he had ever set eyes on, taller than average, with a fair complexion and auburn hair combed short and straight in the French fashion, and a round face so beautiful it would have suited a pretty woman.

Henry wanted to know one thing above all.

Was the king of France taller than he was?

Was he stout?

And what sort of leg did he have?

Pasqualigo said the French king’s legs were spare.

At that, Henry opened the front of his doublet, put his hand on his own thigh, and said, “Look here. And I have also a good calf to my leg.”

It is a strange thing to read now, knowing what was coming.

The part of his body he was proudest of, the one he showed off to ambassadors, was the part that would destroy him.

He was a giant of an athlete in those years.

He hunted from dawn and wore out eight or ten horses in a day.

Above all he jousted, riding full tilt down the lists at another armored man with a lance aimed at his chest.

The armor made for him in his early twenties, which still survives, was cut for a man with a waist in the low-to-middle thirties, and a chest and shoulders built like a fighter’s.

He was the most beautiful prince in Christendom, his courtiers said, and for once they may not have been flattering him.

What happened to that body happened slowly, and then all at once.

It started with a helmet he forgot to close.

—

## The visor he left open

On March 10, 1524, Henry rode out to joust against his oldest friend, Charles Brandon, the Duke of Suffolk.

They had run against each other dozens of times.

On this day, in the noise of the tiltyard, Henry rode down the lists with the visor of his new helmet still raised.

The spectators saw it.

They shouted.

Brandon, inside his own helmet, with his vision cut down to a narrow slit, saw nothing and heard nothing.

His lance struck the king on the brow, just under the open visor, and shattered.

Splinters of wood went into the helmet.

Henry was knocked back in the saddle.

He was not killed, and he refused to be frightened.

He insisted on running six more courses that day to prove to everyone watching that he was not hurt.

But afterward he began to complain of headaches.

They would stay with him, on and off, for the rest of his life.

And a few years later, somewhere around 1527 or 1528, a sore appeared on one of his legs.

At first it was nothing a king’s surgeons could not manage.

They dressed it and treated it, and for long stretches it was quiet.

It did not stay quiet.

And on a January afternoon at Greenwich, eight years later, everything that had been held together in that body came apart at once.

—

## Two hours on the ground at Greenwich

January 24, 1536.

Henry was forty-four.

He was heavier than the young man Pasqualigo had admired, but still strong, still riding, still jousting, still determined to prove himself in the lists against men half his age.

At Greenwich that day he rode a great armored warhorse down the tilt.

Somewhere in the run the horse went down, and the king, in full armor, went down with it, and the horse came down on top of him.

The weight of a war horse in its own armor, on top of a man in his.

What happened next depends on who was writing.

The Emperor’s ambassador in London, Eustace Chapuys, reported that the king had fallen heavily and that everyone thought it a miracle he had not been killed, though he was not badly hurt.

But another report, which reached the Emperor’s court from a different source, said that Henry lay on the ground for two hours without speaking.

Two hours.

If that report was right, the king of England lay unconscious in the tiltyard, in his armor, while his courtiers stood around him not knowing whether they were watching a man faint or watching a reign end.

He woke up.

He recovered.

But within days something in his life had shifted.

Five days later, on the day his first wife, Catherine of Aragon, was buried, his second wife lost a pregnancy.

Within four months she was dead on his orders, and within weeks of that he had married a third.

Historians have argued for decades about whether the fall at Greenwich changed him, whether a blow to the head or the shock of nearly dying turned a cruel man into a far more dangerous one.

Nobody can prove it either way.

What is certain is what it did to his legs.

The old sore broke open.

And this time, it would not close.

—

## The wound his doctors were afraid to let heal

There is a word that appears again and again in the letters written about Henry VIII’s legs after 1536, and the word is “open.”

The ulcer on his leg was open.

Then it closed.

Then it was opened again.

Then there was more than one.

To a modern reader, a wound that will not heal is the problem.

To a Tudor surgeon, a wound that suddenly healed could be far more dangerous.

Medicine at the time held that the body was ruled by humors, fluids that had to stay in balance, and that bad humors needed a way out.

A running sore on the leg was, in that way of thinking, a drain.

If it closed, the poison had nowhere to go.

So the king’s surgeons, at times, kept it open on purpose.

They lanced it.

They packed it.

They laid plasters and ointments on it, and by most accounts they cauterized it, pressing hot irons into the flesh to burn it clean, the way surgeons of the time treated wounds that would not mend.

The king who had once worn out eight horses in a day had to lie still and let them.

In the spring of 1537 he wrote privately to the Duke of Norfolk, explaining why he would not be traveling north that summer.

He asked the duke to keep it to himself.

A humor, he wrote, had fallen into his legs, and his physicians advised him not to go far in the heat of the day.

It is one of the very few times he admitted it on paper.

A year later, it nearly killed him.

In May 1538 the French ambassador, Louis de Perreau, sieur de Castillon, sent a dispatch home describing what had just happened inside the king’s privy chamber.

One of the sores on Henry’s leg had suddenly stopped draining.

For ten or twelve days, the ambassador wrote, the humors that had no way out seemed about to suffocate him.

At times he could not speak at all.

His face had gone black.

He was in great danger.

Modern doctors reading the description have guessed at a blood clot, broken loose from a diseased vein in the leg and lodged in the lungs.

There is no way to be sure.

He survived it.

But the men around him had now seen something they could never unsee.

The king could be brought to the edge of death by his own leg, in his own bed, with no enemy anywhere in sight.

And the leg was only half of it.

—

## Fifty-two inches of steel

In the Royal Armouries there is a suit of armor made for Henry VIII in 1540, when he was forty-eight years old.

It is etched, gilded, and enormous.

The armor made for him in his twenties was built for a man with a waist in the thirties.

The 1540 armor, measured by the curators who look after it, was built for a waist of about fifty-two inches, and a chest only slightly larger.

Some writers give a figure as high as fifty-four.

Either way, the athlete had nearly doubled around the middle in the space of twenty-five years.

How much did he weigh?

Nobody put a king on a scale.

Historians who have worked from the armor and the clothing records usually suggest something around three hundred pounds by the 1540s, and some think it was closer to four hundred near the end.

What caused it is easier to see.

He had always eaten like a king, at tables that groaned with roast meat, game, pies, bread and wine, and as long as he was riding and jousting every day, his body had burned through it.

After 1536, with the leg open and every step painful, the riding grew less and less and then stopped.

The eating did not.

The weight pressed down on the bad legs.

The bad legs kept him in his chair.

The chair kept him eating.

Courtiers who had not seen him for a year came back to find a different man, red-faced, short of breath, his small eyes almost lost in the swelling of his cheeks.

And with the body, the mood changed.

In the early spring of 1541, around Shrovetide, the season of feasting before Lent, the sore on his leg closed again.

A fever followed.

The French ambassador of that year, Charles de Marillac, reported that the doctors were badly frightened.

The king, he wrote, sank into a strange, dark melancholy.

There was no music at court that Shrovetide, and no festivities.

Henry kept to his rooms and brooded.

He said, according to Marillac, that he had an unhappy people to govern, and that he would soon make them so poor they would not have the strength to rise against him.

That was the man they were serving now.

Huge, in pain, suspicious, and still absolute.

Soon he could not even get to his own dinner table on foot.

—

## The chairs called trams

By the last years of his reign, Henry VIII was carried.

His household had special chairs made for him, which they called trams.

They were upholstered in velvet and fitted with poles, so that strong men from the privy chamber could carry the king, sitting, from his bedchamber to his privy rooms and along the long galleries of his palaces.

When the royal possessions were inventoried after his death, the clerks recorded chairs made to carry the king’s majesty from place to place.

Stairs were a different problem.

Later writers tell a story that a device of ropes and pulleys was rigged to haul the king, chair and all, from one floor to another.

It may be true.

It may be a legend that grew out of the trams.

But the fact that people believed it tells you how the court had come to see him.

Not as a man who walked.

As a weight that had to be moved.

And none of them could show what they thought.

To pull a face was dangerous.

To hold your nose was unthinkable.

To suggest, even by a look, that the king was anything other than strong was to risk being remembered at the wrong moment by a man who had already sent two of his wives, two of his chief ministers and dozens of others to the block.

The leg made him dangerous in a new way.

When it hurt, everyone paid.

And in the winter of 1546, it hurt more than it ever had.

—

## The winter he began to settle accounts

In December 1546 the court was supposed to be at Greenwich for Christmas.

It was not.

The king stayed at Whitehall, out of sight, and most of the court was sent away.

Katherine Parr spent the holiday at Greenwich without him.

Ambassadors who asked to see the king were put off.

Behind closed doors, the man who could not get out of bed was doing what he had always done when he felt the ground moving under him.

He was destroying the people he feared.

On December 12, Thomas Howard, the Duke of Norfolk, the most powerful nobleman in England, and his son, the poet Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, were arrested and taken to the Tower.

The charges against Surrey centered on a coat of arms he had used, which the king’s men claimed showed he meant to seize the crown for his family.

It was thin.

It did not matter.

On December 30, Henry’s will was finished and authorized.

It laid out who would govern for his son, the nine-year-old Edward, after Henry was gone.

The will was not signed by the king’s own hand.

It was stamped, with the dry stamp of his signature that Sir Anthony Denny and his colleagues kept, and inked in afterward by a clerk.

Among the witnesses to it were his three physicians: Wendy, Owen and Huicke.

So the men who would not say the word death out loud had already witnessed the document that would take effect when it came.

On January 19, 1547, the Earl of Surrey was beheaded on Tower Hill.

He was about thirty years old.

His father, the duke, was still in the Tower.

An act of attainder was rushed through Parliament to condemn him without a trial.

On January 27, the royal assent to it was given in the king’s name, by commission, because the king could not attend.

The old duke was expected to die within hours.

Neither he nor anyone else knew which of them would be dead first.

—

## Why nobody would say the word

By the last week of January, the king’s breath was coming short and loud, and his color was bad.

His doctors had stopped pretending among themselves.

They were giving him the medicines they had, and changing his dressings, and seeing nothing that helped.

The fever came and went.

He drifted between sleep and waking.

He was still lucid enough to sign by stamp, still lucid enough to give orders, but he was sinking, and everyone in the privy chamber could see it.

Here is the strange, dark joke at the heart of his last days.

He had made it treason to speak of his death, and the law he had made was now standing between him and the last things a Christian man of his time was supposed to do before he died.

In 1547, dying well mattered enormously.

A man near the end was supposed to be told plainly, so that he could make his peace with God.

To die unprepared was one of the things every Christian in England feared most.

And the king of England was about to die unprepared, because every man in his bedchamber was too afraid of him to tell him.

The physicians would not do it.

The councillors would not do it.

They kept going in and out of that hot, close room, holding their breath at the door, and coming out again with nothing said.

It was Thursday, January 27, in the evening, when one of them finally decided that he would.

The story of what happened next was set down by the Protestant writer John Foxe, who published it within twenty years, and who drew on people close to the men who were there.

It is the fullest account we have.

—

## “I will first take a little sleep”

Anthony Denny did not hurry.

He came to the side of the bed where the king lay heaped up on his pillows, and he waited until Henry’s eyes found him.

The fire behind him was loud in the silence.

The breathing from the bed was louder.

Then he told the king the truth.

He said, as Foxe tells it, that in man’s judgment his majesty was not likely to live.

He said it plainly.

And he urged the king to prepare himself for death, to call to mind the life he had lived, and to ask God, through Christ, for grace and mercy while there was still time, as every good Christian man should.

Nobody in the room moved.

These were exactly the words that the law said no subject could speak.

For fifteen years men had died for saying less.

Denny had just said them to the king’s face, in front of witnesses, and there was nothing to do now but wait and see which Henry would answer.

The great head on the pillows did not turn away.

The small eyes stayed on Denny’s face.

For a long moment there was only the breathing.

And then the king answered, and he was not angry.

He spoke, Foxe says, of the life he had lived, and how badly it weighed on him.

And then he gave the heart of his reply: that the mercy of Christ was able to pardon him all his sins, even if they had been greater still.

“The mercy of Christ is able to pardon me all my sins, yes, though they were greater than they be.”

It is an extraordinary sentence from that man.

The king who had broken with Rome, closed the monasteries, beheaded two wives, burned men on both sides of the religious divide, and sent his loyal friends to the block, lay in the stench of his own sickbed and said that his sins were great, and that Christ could forgive greater.

Denny, Foxe says, was glad to hear him speak that way.

He asked a second question.

Would his majesty like a learned man of the Church sent for, to speak with him and comfort him?

Henry thought about it.

If he had any man, he said, it should be Doctor Cranmer.

“If I have any man, it shall be Doctor Cranmer.”

Thomas Cranmer, Archbishop of Canterbury, was the one churchman Henry had trusted to the end.

He had annulled the king’s first marriage, and stood godfather to his daughter Elizabeth, and when enemies at court had tried to have him arrested for heresy a few years earlier, the king had taken him aside and quietly given him his own ring to show to the council, so that they would have to let him go.

But Cranmer was not at Whitehall that night.

He was at his palace at Croydon, about ten miles to the south, over winter roads.

And then the king said one more thing, the thing that would decide everything that followed.

“But I will first take a little sleep.”

He would sleep first, he said, and then, as he felt himself, he would think about the matter.

The physicians must have looked at each other.

Every one of them knew what a little sleep might mean for a man breathing the way he was breathing.

None of them said a word.

Denny did not argue.

The king’s eyes closed.

The room settled back into its heat and its smell and the slow, wet sound of the great chest rising and falling under the linen.

The little sleep went on.

At some point that night, somebody stopped waiting for the king to wake up and sent a rider to Croydon.

The record does not tell us the hour.

It tells us only that the archbishop came as fast as he could, and that it was not fast enough.

The roads in late January were hard and dark.

The Thames lay between Croydon and Westminster.

Somewhere out there in the cold, a horse was being driven harder than it should have been driven, and an archbishop was trying to arrive before a king could leave.

In the bedchamber, the candles burned down and were replaced.

The fire was fed.

The grooms came and went with their deep breaths at the door.

The king did not wake up the way he had promised to.

When he did surface, it was only partly.

His eyes opened.

His lips moved.

No words came out.

It was past midnight when Cranmer reached Whitehall.

He came up through the galleries and into the bedchamber, and he must have met the smell at the door like every other man who had come through it in those weeks.

The king was still alive.

He could no longer speak.

Cranmer went to the bed.

He leaned over the pillows, into the heat, and took the king’s hand in his.

And because Henry could not talk, the archbishop asked him for something he could still give.

He reminded the king of the mercy of Christ.

He told him to put his trust in it.

And he asked him, if he did trust in Christ, to give some sign of it, with his eyes or with his hand.

Everyone in the room was watching that hand.

It was a swollen, heavy hand, the hand that had signed death warrants and treaties and love letters, the hand that had once opened a doublet to show a Venetian his leg.

It lay in the archbishop’s fingers.

And then it closed.

The king, Foxe writes, wrung Cranmer’s hand as hard as he could.

That was his answer.

It was the last thing the king of England ever said, and he said it without a word.

Cranmer stayed beside him.

The breathing went on for a while after that, slower and further apart.

The physicians came closer to the bed now.

The fire burned.

The candles burned.

Sometime around two o’clock in the morning of Friday, January 28, 1547, the breathing stopped.

Henry VIII was dead, in the bed at Whitehall, with his hand in his archbishop’s hand.

The little sleep was over.

And the men in that room had a problem none of them had planned for: a dead king that nobody was allowed to know was dead.

—

## Three days of dinners for a dead man

Outside the bedchamber, nothing changed.

That was the plan, and it was put into effect almost before the body was cold.

Edward Seymour, Earl of Hertford, uncle of the nine-year-old prince, and Sir William Paget, the king’s secretary, walked together in the gallery of the palace in the dark and agreed between them how the next days would go.

The king’s death would be kept secret until the new government was ready.

So the palace went on pretending he was alive.

According to the accounts of those days, meals were still carried into the king’s rooms at the usual hours, with the usual ceremony, to a man who would never eat again.

The guards still stood at the door.

Councillors still went in and out with serious faces.

Parliament still sat, and was not told.

Behind the door, the body of the king lay in the bed where he had died, in a room still kept warm for a man who no longer needed it.

Hertford rode out to fetch the boy who was now king.

Edward was at Hertford Castle.

His uncle took him to his sister Elizabeth at Enfield, and there the two children were told together that their father was dead.

People who saw them said they wept so hard that everyone around them wept too.

And in the Tower, the Duke of Norfolk woke on the morning of January 28 expecting to be taken out and killed.

Nobody came.

The death warrant needed a living king.

The king had died a few hours too soon.

The council had no wish to begin a new reign with the execution of England’s premier duke on the orders of a dead man, and Norfolk stayed in the Tower instead, alive, for the entire reign of the boy king.

He was released in 1553 by Henry’s daughter Mary, and died in his own bed the following year.

The man who had been scheduled to die first outlived Henry by more than seven years.

On Monday, January 31, the Lord Chancellor, Thomas Wriothesley, stood up in Parliament with tears in his eyes and announced that the king was dead.

Edward VI was proclaimed the same day.

The great body in the bed at Whitehall now had to be made fit to be seen, and then carried twenty miles west to Windsor in the dead of winter.

It was on that journey that an old curse came due.

—

## The friar who called him Ahab

Go back fifteen years, to Easter Sunday, March 31, 1532.

Henry was forty, still upright, still riding, still with legs that could carry him into a church on his own.

He was in the middle of the great fight of his life, trying to end his marriage to Catherine of Aragon so that he could marry Anne Boleyn, and the friars of the Observant Franciscan house at Greenwich, right beside his palace, were openly against him.

That Easter, the king went to hear Mass in their church.

The man in the pulpit was the head of the house, a friar named William Peto.

Peto chose his text from the first Book of Kings.

It was the story of Ahab, the king of Israel who let himself be led into evil by his wife, Jezebel, and who took what he wanted from an innocent man.

Every person in that church understood who Ahab was supposed to be.

Peto told the story to its end.

He reminded his listeners what the prophet had said to Ahab: that in the place where the dogs had licked the blood of the man Ahab wronged, the dogs would lick Ahab’s blood too.

And Peto warned the king, to his face, that if he went on the way he was going, he would come to the same end as Ahab.

The dogs would lick his blood.

Henry sat through it.

He did not shout.

He did not walk out.

But the following Sunday one of his own chaplains, Dr. Richard Curwen, preached in the same pulpit, called Peto a dog and a slanderer and a traitor, and praised the king’s cause.

From the rood loft, another friar of the house, Henry Elston, shouted back at him in front of the whole congregation.

Peto went into exile on the Continent.

Within a few years the Observant Friars were suppressed and scattered.

The king had won.

The sermon was a nuisance swept away.

Fifteen years later, on a February night, it came back.

—

## The night at Syon

After his death, Henry’s body was opened and embalmed by the men whose work that was.

It was wrapped in waxed cloth, sealed in lead, and placed in a great wooden coffin.

On top of the coffin, under a canopy, rode a life-size effigy of the king in his robes, its painted face made to look as he had looked in health.

On February 14, 1547, the funeral procession left Westminster for Windsor, where Henry had asked in his will to be buried beside Jane Seymour, the mother of his son.

The coffin rode in a vast chariot drawn by horses hung with black velvet.

The procession of mourners, banners, priests and horsemen behind it was said to stretch for miles.

It was too far to go in one winter day.

The first night’s stop was at Syon.

Syon had been a great abbey once, a house of Bridgettine nuns on the bank of the Thames west of London.

Henry had closed it during the dissolution of the monasteries.

Its nuns were gone.

Now its empty church was opened to receive his coffin for the night.

The coffin was set down in the church.

The watchers took their places around it.

The candles were lit.

And sometime in that night, according to the account that was later written down, the coffin broke.

Whether from the jolting of the chariot or from what had been happening inside a body of that size, the lead cracked open.

What was inside began to seep out, onto the floor of the church.

In the morning, the account says, plumbers were brought in to solder the coffin shut again.

And while they were working, a dog came creeping in among their feet, and began to lick at what had run out onto the paving stones.

The earliest writer known to have told it, a Catholic author named Nicholas Harpsfield, left no doubt about what it meant.

Friar Peto had stood in his pulpit at Greenwich and told the king that the dogs would lick his blood like Ahab’s.

And here, on the floor of a church Henry had emptied and taken for himself, they had.

A later version of the story has the writer saying that he trembled as he wrote the words.

Is it true?

Historians are divided.

Harpsfield hated what Henry had done to the Church, and he was not there that night.

A story in which a ruined abbey gets its revenge on the king who ruined it is exactly the kind of story such a man would want to believe.

And dogs were everywhere in Tudor England; a stray in an abandoned church would have surprised no one.

But the coffin bursting is not impossible.

The king had lain in a warm room for days before his death was even announced, his body was enormous, and the roads were rough.

That part of the story, at least, is the kind of thing that happens.

The coffin was soldered up.

The procession went on to Windsor.

On February 16, it took sixteen of the strongest yeomen of the guard, with linen bands, to lower the coffin of Henry VIII into the vault beneath the floor of St. George’s Chapel, beside the coffin of Jane Seymour.

The great officers of his household broke their white staffs of office and threw them into the grave after him.

—

## What became of the men around the bed

Sir Anthony Denny, the man who had dared to tell the king he was dying, kept his place and his fortune under the new reign.

He died in 1549, only two years after his master, and was spared the worst of what was coming for the men around him.

Edward Seymour, the uncle who had walked in the gallery that night planning the secret, made himself Lord Protector of England and Duke of Somerset.

He was overthrown by his rivals, and on January 22, 1552, he was beheaded on Tower Hill.

The Duke of Norfolk, who should have died on the morning of January 28, walked out of the Tower in 1553 and lived until 1554.

Friar William Peto, the man who had promised the dogs, outlived the king by more than eleven years.

When Henry’s daughter Mary brought England back to Rome, the old friar returned.

In 1557 the Pope named him a cardinal.

He died in 1558, an old man, in a friary at Greenwich, in the same place where he had once preached against a king.

And Thomas Cranmer, the archbishop who had held Henry’s hand at the end, was arrested under Queen Mary, tried for heresy, and condemned.

Under pressure, he signed a series of statements taking back his beliefs.

Then, on the day of his death, March 21, 1556, in Oxford, he took them all back again in public.

When the fire was lit, he did something the crowd never forgot.

He held out his right hand, the hand that had signed the statements, and he put it into the flames first, so that it would burn before the rest of him.

It was the same hand that a dying king had squeezed as hard as he could, nine years before, because he could no longer speak.

—

## What was really wrong with him

Nearly five hundred years later, nobody knows exactly what killed Henry VIII.

His doctors left no notes that survive, and nobody examined his body the way we would now.

Modern doctors have only the ambassadors’ letters, the armor, the portraits, and the long, sad record of the legs.

Most agree on the outline.

The ulcers were probably chronic, perhaps from failing veins, perhaps from a deep infection of the bone left by a jousting injury, the kind that flares and drains and never quite heals.

The weight, the immobility and the infections together would have worn out his heart.

Many modern writers think he had developed something like type 2 diabetes.

Some researchers argue that his blows to the head, from Brandon’s lance to the fall at Greenwich, changed his mind and his temper.

None of these can be proved.

All of them are guesses made from far away.

What we do have, very clearly, is the arc.

A young man who opened his doublet to show off his leg.

A middle-aged man whose leg was opened and burned and opened again by his surgeons.

An old man, at fifty-five, carried from room to room in a velvet chair, heaped on pillows in a room so hot and close that the men who came to see him held their breath at the door.

It is sometimes said, in modern retellings, that Henry VIII choked to death in his sleep.

There is no evidence for it.

The people who were close to him describe a man who faded over hours, who was told he was dying, who answered, who slept, and who was still alive, and still able to press a man’s hand, when the archbishop finally arrived.

In the end he got the little sleep he asked for.

It just did not end the way he meant it to.

—

## The door, one more time

The most famous picture of Henry, Hans Holbein’s great wall painting at Whitehall, showed him standing with his legs planted wide apart, daring anyone to look away.

It burned in 1698, with almost all of Whitehall Palace.

The bedchamber where he died is gone.

The gallery where Hertford and Paget whispered is gone.

The door where the courtiers took their last deep breath before going in is gone.

What is left is the vault at Windsor.

In 1649 it was opened again to receive the body of another king, Charles I, beheaded outside the windows of the same palace where Henry had died.

In 1813 it was opened once more, by order of the Prince Regent, so that his physician could find and examine Charles I’s remains.

The men who went down into the vault reported that Henry’s great coffin had split open around the middle, and that his skeleton could be seen inside.

The coffin had broken once at Syon.

It had broken again in the dark at Windsor.

On a winter evening in 1547, a man in a black gown walked through the smell at the door of the king’s bedchamber, bent over the bed, and told Henry VIII the one thing no one in England was allowed to tell him.

The king did not send him to the Tower.

He asked for his archbishop.

And then, like a tired man at the end of a long day, he asked for one thing more.

“But I will first take a little sleep.”

—

## What the record actually says, and what is legend

**Well documented:** Pasqualigo’s 1515 description of the young king and his calf (Venetian dispatches); the open-visor joust of March 10, 1524 (Edward Hall’s chronicle); the fall at Greenwich on January 24, 1536; Henry’s 1537 letter to Norfolk about a humor in his legs; Castillon’s report of May 1538 and Marillac’s of Shrovetide 1541; the 1540 armor in the Royal Armouries; the arrests of Norfolk and Surrey, Surrey’s execution on January 19, 1547, and the stamped will of December 30, 1546, witnessed by Wendy, Owen and Huicke; the death at Whitehall in the early hours of January 28, 1547, announced only on January 31; the burial at Windsor on February 16, 1547; Friar Peto’s Easter sermon of March 31, 1532, and Curwen’s reply.

**From a single strong source:** Anthony Denny’s warning, the king’s answer about the mercy of Christ, his choice of Cranmer and his wish to “first take a little sleep,” and Cranmer’s arrival to find him speechless and the squeeze of the hand, all come from John Foxe’s *Acts and Monuments*, published in the 1560s by a writer who admired Cranmer.

Historians generally accept the outline, but the exact wording is Foxe’s.

**Uncertain:** That the king lay two hours without speaking after the 1536 fall comes from one report that reached the Emperor’s court; the imperial ambassador in London said he was not badly hurt.

The date of the first leg sore (often given as 1527 or 1528) and the use of hot irons on it are not documented by any surviving surgeon’s record.

Weight estimates are modern guesses.

The 1540 armor’s waist is usually given as about 52 inches, sometimes as 51 or 54.

The meals carried in to the dead king come from accounts of those days, not from an official order.

**Later account or legend:** The bursting of the coffin at Syon and the dog licking what ran out comes from Nicholas Harpsfield, a Catholic writer hostile to Henry who was not there, and was repeated and embroidered by later authors; historians disagree on whether it happened, and some think it was simply too good a story to resist.

The ropes-and-pulleys machine for hauling the king upstairs is a later story; the carrying chairs called trams are better attested.

The claim, repeated online, that Henry choked on his own vomit in his sleep has no support in any record of his last day.

**What we reconstructed:** The heat, the smell at the door, the candles, the curtains, the herbs on the fire, the frozen road to Croydon and the exact positions of the men in the room are not described in the sources; they are drawn from what is known of Tudor sickrooms and of the season.

**About the video:** the short clip with this story is a modern AI reconstruction in the style of an old oil painting, not a historical image.

The flies and the faint haze in it are artistic symbols of the sickroom; it was January, and no source mentions flies.

The king’s three lines are taken from Foxe’s account of his last evening, slightly shortened.

You Might Also Enjoy