News

Freddie Mercury and Jim Hutton: The Savoy Barber Who Turned Him Down, the Gold Ring He Wore to the End and What Happened After Garden Lodge

On Saturday, July 13, 1985, a barber from the Savoy Hotel stood in the wings of the stage at Wembley Stadium in London.

His name was Jim Hutton.

He was 36 years old, he came from Carlow in the southeast of Ireland, and by his own account he had never been to a rock concert in his life.

The concert was Live Aid.

About 72,000 people were inside the stadium, and the television audience around the world was counted in the hundreds of millions.

Shortly before seven in the evening, Queen walked on.

For about twenty minutes the man who had brought Jim Hutton there held the entire stadium in his hand.

Jim Hutton would say for the rest of his life that when the two of them first met, he had not known who Freddie Mercury was.

For the next six years he lived beside him.

The public, when it noticed him at all, was told that he was the gardener.

This is the story of who he really was, what he gave Freddie Mercury that the singer never took off, what he was left in November 1991, and what became of him after he walked out of Garden Lodge.

—

## A Barber From Carlow

James Hutton was born in Carlow on January 4, 1949.

Carlow is a county town on the River Barrow, about fifty miles southwest of Dublin.

It is farming country, a long way in every sense from the world he would end up in.

He grew up with brothers and sisters, who were named among his survivors when he died.

He was a hairdresser by trade, and like many Irish people of his generation he took his trade to London.

By the early 1980s he was working in the barbershop of the Savoy Hotel.

The Savoy stands on the Strand, beside the Thames.

It opened in 1889, built by Richard D’Oyly Carte with the profits of the Gilbert and Sullivan operas, and for most of a century it had been one of the grandest addresses in the city.

The men who sat in its barber’s chairs were wealthy.

The man who cut their hair was not.

A newspaper profile from 1994 put his wage at about £70 a week.

He lodged in Sutton, a commuter town in Surrey on the southern edge of London, and traveled in to work.

Nothing in the record suggests that he followed rock music.

That is the detail on which the whole story turns.

—

## The Drink He Turned Down

The first meeting, as Jim Hutton told it, was not a success.

In his memoir and in the interviews he gave when it was published, he placed it in 1983, in a gay club in London.

He was there with the man he was seeing at the time.

A stranger with a mustache came over and offered to buy him a drink.

Jim Hutton said no.

He said later that he had no idea who the stranger was.

A line from a British television interview is often repeated.

“I didn’t know who he was.”

Other retellings give other dates.

One popular video retelling says 1984.

Some articles move the whole episode to 1985.

The 1983 date is the one Jim Hutton himself gave to a reporter in 1994, and it is the one followed here.

Whatever the year, the outline does not change.

One of the most famous singers in the world made an approach in a London club, and a barber on £70 a week turned him down and stayed with the man he had come with.

Freddie Mercury, at that point, was between two lives.

Queen had stepped back from touring for most of 1983.

He was spending long stretches in Munich, where the band recorded and where he was making a solo album, “Mr. Bad Guy,” that would come out in the spring of 1985.

In London he owned a large house in Kensington, Garden Lodge, which he had bought in 1980 and was still having rebuilt to his own design.

He had not yet moved into it.

—

## Heaven, March 1985

The second meeting came in the spring of 1985.

By Jim Hutton’s account it happened at Heaven, the big gay nightclub under the railway arches beside Charing Cross station.

Heaven had opened in December 1979 and by the middle of the 1980s it was the best-known club of its kind in Britain.

The date usually given, following his memoir, is Saturday, March 23, 1985.

Freddie Mercury was 38.

Jim Hutton was 36.

This time the evening did not end with a refusal.

It was still, by his telling, a slow start.

He described a gap of weeks in which he heard nothing at all, and then an invitation to dinner.

After that came weekends in Munich, with the airline tickets arranged for him.

And then, in July, came the afternoon at Wembley.

He told the Manchester Evening News in 1994 that Freddie Mercury had simply announced that they were going to Live Aid.

A car took him to the stadium.

He watched from the side of the stage.

Queen played six songs in twenty-one minutes, a set that a poll of music executives later voted the greatest live performance in rock history.

Later in the evening Freddie Mercury and Brian May came back out to perform a quiet acoustic song about the state of the world.

For the barber standing in the wings, it was a first concert of a rather unusual kind.

—

## The Savoy by Day, Kensington by Night

What is striking about the first two years is what Jim Hutton did not do.

He did not give up his job.

According to the same 1994 interview, he moved in with Freddie Mercury and went on cutting hair at the Savoy.

One reference account says he kept his lodgings in Sutton for two more years as well.

He was living, in effect, in two worlds.

By day he was a hotel barber.

In the evening he went home to a household that included a personal assistant, a chef and a driver.

He described the ordinary part of it in a newspaper interview he gave many years later.

“I’d get in from work. We’d lie together on the sofa. He would massage my feet and ask about my day.”

The early period was not all calm, and Jim Hutton did not pretend it was.

He wrote that there was a serious quarrel over faithfulness, and that he told Freddie Mercury to make up his mind.

By his account the answer was that he had.

He also offered his own explanation of why the relationship lasted.

He believed that Freddie Mercury wanted to feel safe with someone down to earth, someone who was not impressed by who he was.

Freddie Mercury is quoted in the biographies as saying much the same thing from the other side: that what he had found was comfort and understanding, and that he honestly could not have asked for better.

Garden Lodge, meanwhile, was finally ready.

In the middle of the 1980s Freddie Mercury settled into the house in Kensington for good, and Jim Hutton went with him.

—

## The Ring

In 1986 Jim Hutton gave Freddie Mercury a plain gold wedding band.

It was not a legal marriage, and it could not have been.

Britain did not offer civil partnerships to same-sex couples until December 2005.

Marriage followed in England and Wales in 2014.

Ireland, where Jim Hutton was born, voted for it in a referendum in May 2015.

In 1986 there was no document of any kind that two men could sign.

There was only the ring.

By several accounts Jim Hutton wore one as well.

Freddie Mercury called him his husband.

It was not the first ring the singer had worn.

In his Munich years he had worn a silver band given to him by Winfried Kirchberger, a restaurant owner with whom he had an intense relationship.

The gold one stayed.

According to Jim Hutton, Freddie Mercury wore it until the end of his life.

That same summer Queen went out on the Magic Tour, which ended at Knebworth Park on August 9, 1986, in front of a crowd of well over 100,000.

It was the last concert the four of them ever played together, and it is told in a separate article.

Jim Hutton traveled with the party for part of that summer.

At public events, though, the two men kept a distance from each other.

—

## The Man the World Called the Gardener

Garden Lodge sits inside a high brick wall, in a garden of about a quarter of an acre.

The garden became Jim Hutton’s job.

After the Savoy years ended he worked at the house full time, and Freddie Mercury paid him a gardener’s wage.

It gave him something to do that was his own.

It also gave the outside world an answer.

For years, when newspapers mentioned him at all, he was described as Freddie Mercury’s gardener, or his handyman.

He said as much himself in 1994.

Both things were true.

He really did plant and prune and look after the pond, where the koi were kept.

He also cut the singer’s hair.

And he lived in the house as his partner.

The household had other permanent residents with four legs.

Freddie Mercury kept at least ten cats over the years, most of them adopted from an animal charity.

One of them, Delilah, was given a song of her own on Queen’s 1991 album “Innuendo.”

Jim Hutton’s memoir is full of small domestic scenes from this period.

One of them concerns another song on that album, a comic number about a man losing his grip.

He recalled Freddie Mercury sitting up late with his friend Peter Straker, the two of them trying to outdo each other with ridiculous one-line jokes in the manner of Noël Coward.

Jim Hutton went up to bed.

He wrote that he fell asleep listening to their laughter coming up the stairs.

—

## “Our Business”

It is easy to forget how narrow the ground was that the two of them stood on.

Sex between men had been a crime in England and Wales until 1967, eighteen years before they got together, and even then the law applied only to men over 21, in private.

In Ireland, where Jim Hutton’s family lived, it remained a criminal offense until 1993.

The British tabloid press of the 1980s treated a famous man’s private life as fair game.

Freddie Mercury’s response, for his whole career, was to say nothing that could be used.

In December 1974 a writer for the New Musical Express had asked him the question directly.

“I’ve had my share of schoolboy pranks. I’m not going to elaborate further.”

He never gave the press a plainer answer than that.

Jim Hutton, in the same late interview, put the view the two of them shared into one sentence.

“We both thought our relationship, and being gay, was our business.”

In the spring of 1987 the pressure increased sharply.

A former personal manager sold a story about Freddie Mercury’s private life to a tabloid newspaper.

By then there was something much heavier to keep private.

—

## Spring 1987

By Jim Hutton’s account, Freddie Mercury was told that he had AIDS in late April 1987, shortly after Easter.

Jim Hutton wrote that Freddie Mercury told him soon afterward, and said he would understand if he wanted to pack his bags and go.

The exact words of the reply differ from one retelling to the next.

The substance does not.

Jim Hutton said that he was not going anywhere.

Only a handful of people were told.

For four more years the public was told nothing, and the newspapers were left to guess.

Life in the house went on.

In September 1987 Freddie Mercury celebrated his forty-first birthday at Pikes Hotel on the island of Ibiza.

He made an album with the Spanish soprano Montserrat Caballé.

He went on recording with Queen.

In 1990 Jim Hutton took a test of his own, without telling anyone.

It was positive.

He told the Manchester Evening News that he kept the result from Freddie Mercury for about a year, because he felt the singer already had enough to bear.

—

## The Last Year

The work of 1991 was done mostly in Switzerland.

Queen recorded at Mountain Studios in Montreux, on the shore of Lake Geneva, and Freddie Mercury rented a place on the water there.

Jim Hutton went with him.

Back in London, on August 28, 1991, Jim Hutton was photographing flowers in the garden when Freddie Mercury walked over and stood for a few frames.

By his account they are the last photographs of the singer ever taken.

The final weeks at Garden Lodge are the subject of a separate article, and only the outline belongs here.

Peter Freestone, the personal assistant, has said that he, Jim Hutton and the chef, Joe Fanelli, divided each day and night between them so that Freddie Mercury was never alone.

Jim Hutton wrote of one small episode from the last days.

Freddie Mercury wanted to go downstairs and look at his paintings once more.

A popular retelling has him half carried down.

In Jim Hutton’s telling he made his own way down, holding the banister, with Jim Hutton going ahead in case he fell, and was carried back up afterward.

He remembered Freddie Mercury remarking that he had never realized how strong he was.

On Saturday, November 23, a short statement was made public in which Freddie Mercury confirmed that he had AIDS.

He died at Garden Lodge the following evening, Sunday, November 24, 1991.

He was 45.

The cause was bronchial pneumonia resulting from AIDS.

Jim Hutton was with him.

He told the Manchester Evening News three years later that Freddie Mercury had died in his arms, and that what he felt was both relief and an enormous loss.

The funeral was held on November 27 at the West London Crematorium, with the family and about thirty-five close friends.

According to Jim Hutton, the gold band was still on Freddie Mercury’s finger.

—

## What the Will Left Him

The will divided the estate cleanly.

Mary Austin, who had been Freddie Mercury’s girlfriend in the 1970s and remained his closest friend, received Garden Lodge and half of everything else, including his future income from recordings.

His parents received a quarter between them.

His sister received a quarter.

Three members of the household were left £500,000 each: Jim Hutton, Peter Freestone and Joe Fanelli.

The driver, Terry Giddings, was left £100,000.

For Jim Hutton that was roughly $900,000 at the exchange rate of the time.

It was a life-changing sum for a man who had been earning £70 a week when they met.

Some retellings suggest that he was upset about what he was left.

Nothing on record supports the idea that he complained about the money.

His grievance, which he stated plainly and more than once, was about the house.

—

## Leaving Garden Lodge: His Account and Hers

This is the part of the story on which the people involved have never agreed, and it is told here as each of them told it.

The first account is Jim Hutton’s, from his 1994 memoir.

He wrote that Freddie Mercury had told him he would be able to stay on at Garden Lodge.

Instead, he said, he was given three months to leave.

The second account is also his, from the interview with the Manchester Evening News in November 1994.

There he added details.

He said he had felt snubbed at the funeral.

He said he had first been moved out of the main house into an annexe, and had then had to leave altogether, to make room for a housekeeper.

He said he bore Mary Austin no animosity.

He also said that his departure could have been handled with more dignity.

The third account is Mary Austin’s.

Asked about it by The Guardian in September 2026, she said the decision had not been hers.

“It had nothing to do with me. It was all down to the executors of the will.”

Those are the accounts.

What is not in dispute is small.

The will gave the house to Mary Austin.

Jim Hutton said he had been given a spoken promise that he could stay.

And within months of the funeral, the household that had nursed Freddie Mercury through his last year had broken up.

Jim Hutton moved to another house in west London.

Outside the wall he had left behind, fans went on covering the brickwork with messages for the next quarter of a century.

—

## The House in Carlow

In the years that followed he went home.

He built a bungalow in County Carlow.

Even here the sources do not quite match.

Irish newspaper reports at the time of his death said that Freddie Mercury had left him, along with the £500,000, a plot of land in Carlow, and that he built the house on it.

Other accounts, drawing on his memoir, describe the bungalow as something the two men had planned and paid for together while Freddie Mercury was still alive.

Either way, the house in Ireland came out of the years in Kensington.

Jim Hutton lived there quietly and gave very few interviews.

Ireland changed around him.

The law that had made his private life a crime in his own country was repealed in 1993.

By the time he died, Ireland was only months away from passing its first civil partnership law.

—

## “Mercury and Me”

In the fall of 1994, three years after the death, Jim Hutton published a memoir.

It was called “Mercury and Me,” it was written with the journalist Tim Wapshott, and it was published in London by Bloomsbury.

An American edition followed in 1995.

It contained private photographs that had never been seen, including pictures from the garden.

He gave his reasons to the Manchester Evening News that November.

One was grief.

Writing it down, he said, was a way of coping with the loss.

The other was the press.

He wanted to correct stories that had appeared since 1991, among them the claim that Freddie Mercury had died alone.

He recalled that a writer had approached him with an offer for the inside story within two days of the death, and he called that insensitive.

He also said he would give no interviews on the third anniversary.

The book is the source for much of what is now repeated about Freddie Mercury’s private life: the date of the diagnosis, the last photographs, the ring.

It is one man’s account.

Peter Freestone published his own memoir a few years later, and other people who were in the house have given their own recollections.

It is normal for several people to remember the same rooms a little differently.

It is the reason this article says “by his account” as often as it does.

After the book, Jim Hutton spoke rarely.

He appeared in the documentary “Freddie Mercury: The Untold Story” in 2000.

In 2006, when Freddie Mercury would have turned 60, he took part in a British television documentary and gave the interview to The Times.

Those were among the last public words he spoke about any of it.

—

## The Film Version and the Real One

In 2018 the film “Bohemian Rhapsody” introduced Jim Hutton to an audience many times larger than his book had ever reached.

He was played by the Northern Irish actor Aaron McCusker.

In the film he is a waiter, hired for a party at Freddie Mercury’s house, who is still clearing up when the host comes home.

Freddie Mercury later tracks him down, and the two arrive together at Wembley on the day of Live Aid.

It is a neat piece of screenwriting.

It is not what happened.

Nothing in Jim Hutton’s own account has him working as a waiter, at a party or anywhere else.

He was a barber who was approached in a nightclub and said no.

The film also places Freddie Mercury’s diagnosis before Live Aid.

Jim Hutton, who was there, dated it to the spring of 1987, almost two years after the concert.

The film did one thing for him that nothing else had done.

In the wake of it, his memoir was reissued and newly translated.

He did not live to see it.

—

## January 1, 2010

Jim Hutton died in Carlow on New Year’s Day, 2010.

He was 60, three days short of his sixty-first birthday.

Irish reports said he had been ill with cancer for a long time, and later accounts specify lung cancer.

Some retellings say he died after years of battling AIDS.

That is not how his death was reported.

He had lived with HIV for about twenty years, and the cause that was reported was cancer.

He was buried in his home county, and the death notices listed his brothers and sisters among those he left behind.

He had outlived Freddie Mercury by eighteen years.

In all that time he never changed the outline of the story he told.

A man he did not recognize offered him a drink, and he refused it.

The same man asked again, and he stayed for the rest of that man’s life.

He gave him a gold ring that the law did not recognize, and by his account it was never taken off.

To the world outside the wall on Logan Place, he was the gardener.

Inside it, he was the person Freddie Mercury called his husband.

You Might Also Enjoy