News

1560: The Strange Truth About Amy Robsart’s Death

The argument began before the morning was half over.

It was Sunday, September 8, 1560, at a big old stone house called Cumnor Place, a few miles southwest of Oxford.

Bells were ringing somewhere across the fields.

It was the feast of the Nativity of the Virgin, and in the market town of Abingdon, a short ride away, there was a fair.

The lady of the household had made up her mind about that fair.

Everyone of her own was to go.

She wanted them out of the house and on the road to Abingdon.

But one woman in the house would not go.

Her name was Mrs. Odingsells.

She was a widow, a relation of the family that owned Cumnor Place, and she lived there as a gentlewoman, not as a servant.

According to the report written down a few days later, she told the lady that a Sunday was no day for a gentlewoman to be seen at a fair.

Tomorrow would be better, she said.

She would go in the morning.

The lady was angry.

She answered that Mrs. Odingsells could do as she pleased, but all of her own people would go.

Someone asked who would keep her company at dinner if they all went.

The lady said that Mrs. Owen would.

Mrs. Owen was the elderly mother of the man who owned the house.

And so, through the middle of that bright September day, the servants went off along the road toward Abingdon.

The house grew quieter.

Doors were left shut.

The kitchens cooled.

The lady’s name was Amy.

She was twenty-eight years old.

Her husband was Lord Robert Dudley, Master of the Horse, the man who stood closer to Queen Elizabeth I than anyone else in England.

He was not at Cumnor that Sunday.

He was at Windsor Castle, with the queen.

When the servants came back from the fair that evening, they found Amy at the foot of a flight of stairs inside the house.

Her neck was broken.

She was dead.

Within days, people in half the courts of Europe would be saying her husband had arranged it.

A jury would be sworn to decide what had happened in that empty house.

Its full report would then disappear for more than four hundred years.

When a historian finally found it, in 2008, it said something that nobody had expected to read.

It did not settle the question.

It made it stranger.

—

## Why a girl from Norfolk married the son of the most dangerous family in England

Amy Robsart was born on June 7, 1532, in Norfolk.

She was the only child of Sir John Robsart, a gentleman of Syderstone, and his wife Elizabeth Scott, a widow who already had children from her first marriage.

That made Amy an heiress.

Not a great heiress by the standards of the court, but a girl who would one day inherit manors, sheep, farmland and rents across a wide stretch of East Anglia.

She grew up in the flat, windy country near the north Norfolk coast, taught to keep a household and to write a plain hand.

She was not raised for the court.

Then, in her teens, she met Robert Dudley.

How they met is not certain.

The usual story is that it happened in 1549, when Robert’s father, John Dudley, Earl of Warwick, was in Norfolk putting down the great rising of that summer known as Kett’s Rebellion, and the Dudleys passed through the country around the Robsart lands.

What is certain is that by the spring of 1550 there was a marriage contract.

And on June 4, 1550, three days before her eighteenth birthday, Amy Robsart married Robert Dudley at the royal palace of Sheen, beside the Thames.

The young king, Edward VI, was a guest.

So was a rising royal servant named William Cecil.

Years later, Cecil is said to have looked back on that wedding with a sour remark, calling it a carnal marriage, a match made out of desire rather than good sense.

It was meant as criticism, but it tells us something.

Robert and Amy had married for love.

He was the fifth son of the most ambitious man in England.

His father could have found him a far grander bride.

Instead, Robert married a Norfolk gentleman’s daughter, and his family let him.

For the first years, the marriage looked like the beginning of an ordinary, comfortable life.

There were no children, then or ever.

And all the while, Robert’s father kept climbing.

By 1551 John Dudley was Duke of Northumberland, the real ruler of England behind a sickly teenage king.

When a family climbs that high, it has a long way to fall.

In the summer of 1553, it fell.

—

## The summer her husband was condemned to die

In July 1553, Edward VI died at the age of fifteen.

Before he died, the Duke of Northumberland had persuaded him to leave the crown not to his half-sister Mary but to his cousin, Lady Jane Grey.

Jane was sixteen.

She was also, by then, Northumberland’s daughter-in-law, married to Robert’s younger brother Guildford.

For nine days, the Dudleys held the crown.

Then the country rose for Mary, and Northumberland’s army melted away.

Robert, who had been sent into Norfolk with a body of troops to try to capture Mary before she could rally support, found himself on the losing side in his own wife’s home county.

Within weeks, the whole family was in the Tower of London.

The duke was put to death on Tower Hill in August 1553.

In the months that followed, Robert, his brothers and Jane Grey were all condemned as traitors.

Robert Dudley was twenty-one years old, and under sentence of death.

For Amy, the future she had married into vanished overnight.

She could have stayed in Norfolk and waited for news.

She did not.

From September 1553, according to the records of the council, Amy was given permission to visit Robert in the Tower, and to stay with him for a time, at the pleasure of the Lieutenant of the Tower.

Picture what that meant: a young wife walking under the gateway of the most feared fortress in England, to sit with a husband who might be taken out to the scaffold on any morning of any week.

In February 1554 his brother Guildford and Jane Grey were put to death.

Robert was still waiting.

He was not alone among famous prisoners that spring.

The Princess Elizabeth, Queen Mary’s half-sister, was brought into the Tower in March 1554, suspected of involvement in a rebellion against Mary.

She and Robert had known each other since they were children.

Whether they ever met or spoke during those weeks is not known, and the romantic stories about it are much later.

But they were held within the same walls, under the same threat.

That shared fear would come to matter more than anyone in 1554 could have guessed.

In October 1554, Robert was released.

He was pardoned the following year.

He went home to a wife who had stood by him when nothing about him was worth standing by.

They were poor by the standards of their old life, living on what Amy’s family could provide.

And then, four years later, everything changed again.

—

## The morning a new queen made him the most watched man in England

On November 17, 1558, Queen Mary died.

Her half-sister became Queen Elizabeth I.

She was twenty-five years old.

Almost at once, she named Robert Dudley her Master of the Horse.

On paper it meant running the queen’s stables.

In practice it meant he was with her nearly every day.

He rode beside her when she hunted, and he helped her into the saddle.

Within months he had been made a Knight of the Garter, the highest order of chivalry in England.

Foreign ambassadors started writing his name in their reports more often than the names of the queen’s ministers.

And people began to talk.

The queen was young and unmarried.

Every court in Europe expected her to choose a foreign prince quickly.

Instead she spent her days with her Master of the Horse.

He was tall, dark, a superb horseman, a dancer, a man who knew how to make her laugh.

He was also a married man.

Where was his wife in all of this?

Amy did not live at court.

Robert was almost always there, and the queen needed him there.

Amy did not have a house of her own, either.

The Dudley properties had been lost in 1553, and Robert had not yet been granted new ones on the scale that would come later.

So, from 1558 on, Amy lived as a guest in the houses of other people.

For a time she stayed at Throcking in Hertfordshire, at the house of a man named William Hyde.

Robert came to visit her there for a couple of days at Easter 1559.

In May 1559, Amy came to London and stayed for about a month.

That visit, as far as the surviving record shows, was the last time the two of them were together.

By September 1559 she was in Warwickshire, at Compton Verney, the house of Sir Richard Verney, one of Robert’s men.

Remember that name.

It will come back, many years later, in the ugliest version of this story.

Then, in December 1559, Amy moved again, to a house near Oxford.

It was the last move she would make.

She traveled with a household of about ten servants.

She was the wife of the most talked-about man in England.

And she was living out of other people’s houses, while the talk grew louder.

—

## What the Spanish ambassador kept writing home

The man who wrote down the worst of that talk was the Spanish ambassador.

His name was Álvaro de la Quadra, Bishop of Aquila, and he had been sent to London to watch the new Protestant queen and report everything to King Philip II of Spain.

He was very good at listening.

He was not always good at telling truth from gossip.

The Spanish dispatches from 1559 and 1560 are full of Robert Dudley.

One of them, from 1559, passed on a rumor that Robert’s wife had a malady in one of her breasts, and that the queen was only waiting for her to die so that she could marry Robert.

In another, from the spring of 1560, de Quadra reported that Robert had been heard to say that if he lived another year, he would be in a very different position from the one he held now.

Different how?

De Quadra drew his own conclusion.

He was not the only one.

Across the court, people whispered that Lord Robert meant to be king.

That the queen would marry him the moment he was free.

That he would not wait for nature to free him.

How much of this reached Amy, we do not know.

But servants travel, and gossip travels faster than servants.

And then there was William Cecil.

By 1560 Cecil, the guest at Amy’s wedding, was the queen’s Secretary of State, and he was deeply worried.

He believed the queen’s closeness to Dudley was damaging her, frightening foreign princes, and putting the whole kingdom at risk.

At the beginning of September 1560, according to de Quadra, Cecil took the ambassador aside and told him that he was thinking of withdrawing from the queen’s service altogether.

And in the same conversation, de Quadra reported, Cecil said something else.

That people were thinking of getting rid of Lord Robert’s wife.

That it had been given out that she was ill.

That she was not ill at all, but very well, and taking care not to be poisoned.

De Quadra put those words into a dispatch dated September 11, 1560.

Was Cecil warning him, or spreading a rumor on purpose to damage Dudley?

Historians have argued about it ever since.

Because by the time de Quadra wrote that dispatch, Amy Dudley was already dead.

—

## The house that belonged to someone else

Cumnor Place stood next to the parish church in the village of Cumnor, on a ridge of high ground above the valley of the Thames, about four miles from Oxford.

It was an old house even then.

It had been built in the Middle Ages as a country retreat for the abbots of Abingdon, and when Henry VIII closed the monasteries, it had passed into private hands.

It had a courtyard, a hall, upper chambers and stairs between the floors.

It was not Robert’s house.

The owner was a man named William Owen, whose father had been the king’s physician.

The tenant was Anthony Forster.

Forster was one of Robert Dudley’s most trusted men, a gentleman who handled money and business for him, and it was Forster who had rented Cumnor Place and arranged for Amy to live there.

So Amy was a guest in a house rented by her husband’s treasurer, and owned by a family who still had relations living under its roof.

Mrs. Owen, the owner’s mother, lived there.

So did Mrs. Odingsells, the widow who was also connected to the family.

And Amy had her own people around her, including a woman named Mrs. Picto, who served her and who, by every account we have, loved her.

What were her days like at Cumnor?

We have only a few small glimpses.

One letter in her own hand, dated August 24, 1560, just two weeks before she died, shows her busy with the ordinary business of her wardrobe, giving instructions about a new gown.

That letter matters.

It is not the letter of a woman who had given up.

It is the letter of a woman planning what she would wear in the autumn.

Two weeks later, she sent her household to the fair.

Why?

—

## Why she wanted the house empty

This is the question at the center of everything.

We know about the argument with Mrs. Odingsells because of a man named Thomas Blount.

Blount was a kinsman of Robert Dudley, and one of the officers of his household.

Within days of Amy’s death he was at Cumnor, asking questions on Robert’s behalf, and writing back to him about what he heard.

The scene that opens this story, the anger, the widow’s refusal, the plan to dine with Mrs. Owen, all comes from his report.

That is all the record gives us.

It does not say why.

Was it simple kindness?

The fair came once a year, and a good mistress might want her servants to enjoy it.

Was it a bad mood?

People who are unhappy sometimes want to be left alone, and say so sharply.

Was she expecting someone, a visitor or a message, that she did not want her servants to see?

Was she planning something that she did not want anybody to witness?

Or did someone else want the house empty, and find a way to make sure it would be?

Every theory about what happened next begins at this point, with a woman sending her household away on a Sunday morning, and a widow refusing to go.

The servants left.

Mrs. Odingsells stayed.

Mrs. Owen stayed.

And the house settled into the long, slow quiet of an early autumn afternoon.

—

## The afternoon on the stairs

It was warm for September.

The windows of Cumnor Place looked out over the churchyard and the fields, and the light coming through them was the low, gold light of the end of summer.

In the hall, the fire had been allowed to sink.

The kitchen fires were banked.

Nobody was hurrying across the courtyard with buckets or baskets.

There were no grooms in the stables, calling to one another.

The house had perhaps a handful of people left inside it, and they were spread across its chambers and galleries, far enough apart that one of them might not hear what another was doing.

Somewhere, at some point that afternoon, Amy Dudley was alone in a chamber of the house.

The coroner’s jury would later say exactly that.

She was alone in a certain chamber.

She came to a flight of stairs that led down from it.

We do not know what time it was.

We do not know what she was wearing.

We do not know whether she was walking quickly or slowly, whether she was calling to someone, whether she had heard a step or a voice.

We know only where she was found.

The stairs at Cumnor Place were not, by most accounts, a long, grand flight.

The ones that mattered that day are usually described as short.

Not the kind of staircase you would think of as dangerous.

The kind a person uses dozens of times a day without a thought.

And then the afternoon went on.

The sun moved across the floors.

The church clock, if there was one, struck the hours.

In Abingdon, a few miles away, the fair was at its loudest: the stalls, the music, the beer, the servants from Cumnor Place laughing with people from other villages.

The house waited.

Toward evening, the servants began to come back.

They would have come in groups along the road, tired, a little drunk perhaps, talking about what they had bought and seen.

They came through the gate into the courtyard.

They went into the house.

And someone found her.

There is no surviving account of that moment in the words of the person who saw it first.

There is no name for the servant who went to the stairs and stopped.

There is only the fact, set down later by the jury, that the lady was lying at the very bottom of the stairs, and that she was dead.

Think of the sounds of that house in the next minutes.

A shout.

Running feet on the boards above.

Someone calling for Mrs. Odingsells.

Someone calling for Mrs. Owen.

Someone, perhaps, calling for Mrs. Picto, the woman who loved her most, and who would have to see it.

Then the terrible quiet that falls on a household when the people in it understand that nothing can be undone.

The women came.

They would have knelt beside her and looked for breath that was not there.

Somebody would have run to the church next door for the priest.

And somebody would have had to think about what came next.

Because this was not just any lady of a country house.

This was the wife of Lord Robert Dudley.

Every person in that house knew what the court was saying about him and the queen.

Every one of them must have understood, within minutes, how this was going to look.

A wife nobody at court saw.

A husband who was always with the queen.

A house emptied of servants on a Sunday.

And a woman dead at the bottom of a short flight of stairs.

They could not hide it, and they could not change it.

All they could do was tell Robert.

A rider was sent.

The man who carried the news was named Bowes, one of the Dudley servants.

He rode through the evening and the night, east and south, the forty miles or so from the Oxford country to Windsor.

On the road, with the horses tiring and the dark coming down, the news traveled with him in a single sentence.

Lady Dudley was dead, by a fall from a pair of stairs.

At Windsor, the castle was full of the queen’s household.

Robert Dudley was there.

So was the queen.

On September 9, Bowes reached him.

Only a short time before, Robert had sent his kinsman Thomas Blount riding off toward Cumnor on some other errand.

Now Robert sat down and wrote to Blount, to catch him on the road.

The letter survives.

In it, Robert told Blount that Bowes had come to him and told him that his wife was dead, by a fall from a pair of stairs, and that he could learn little more from the man.

He said the greatness and suddenness of the misfortune so perplexed him that he could not rest.

And then he wrote the sentences that tell us he understood, as clearly as anyone at Cumnor, exactly what was coming.

He was afraid, he said, of the malicious talk he knew the wicked world would use.

He wanted the truth found out, whatever it was.

He told Blount to go to Cumnor, to see that the coroner chose the discreetest and most substantial men for the jury, and to find out by every means how this had happened.

Whether the letter caught Blount on the road or the news reached him some other way, he did not go straight to the house.

He stopped for the night at an inn in Abingdon, the town where the fair had been the day before.

There, according to his own account, he did something clever.

He did not say who he was.

He asked the innkeeper what news there was in the country.

And the innkeeper told him about a lady who had died at Cumnor, by a fall from a pair of stairs.

What did people make of it, Blount asked.

Some said it was misfortune, the innkeeper answered.

And some said otherwise.

—

## “Cousin Blount”: the letters between Windsor and Cumnor

The next morning, Thomas Blount rode into the courtyard of Cumnor Place.

The house was full again.

The servants who had gone to the fair were now witnesses.

The coroner had been called.

A jury was being gathered from among the gentlemen and yeomen of the neighborhood.

Blount began to ask questions.

The most important answers came from Mrs. Picto, Amy’s own woman.

Blount asked her what she thought.

Was it chance?

Or had someone done it?

Mrs. Picto said, as Blount reported it, that she judged it very chance, and neither done by man nor by herself.

Neither by another person, nor by Amy’s own hand.

Then she said something that Blount did not leave out of his letter, though he must have known how it would read.

She told him that she had heard Amy pray to God to deliver her from desperation.

Blount wrote it down.

He also wrote that, from what he had been hearing about Amy in the short time he had been at Cumnor, she seemed to him a strange woman of mind.

That is a heavy thing to put in a letter about a dead woman to her husband.

What did it mean?

Desperation, in the language of the sixteenth century, could mean simple despair.

It could also mean something darker, the despair that the church taught could lead a person to take her own life.

Was Mrs. Picto saying that Amy had been unhappy, frightened, ill?

Or was she warning Blount of something she would not say outright?

Blount did not try to decide.

He sent it all to Robert.

Robert wrote back.

In these letters, which survive in later copies, he sounds by turns grieving, frightened and insistent.

In one, he wrote that God’s will be done, and that he wished God had made him the poorest creature that creeps on the ground rather than have this happen.

In another, he pressed Blount again to make sure the jury did its work honestly, and to have no respect for any living person in finding out the truth.

He talked of wanting a second inquiry, with another substantial company of honest men, so that nobody could ever say the matter had been hidden.

Nothing came of that idea.

But it is worth noticing.

A man who had arranged his wife’s death would have every reason to want the inquiry finished quickly, quietly and by men he could control.

Robert, in these letters at least, asked for the opposite.

Of course, a clever man who had arranged his wife’s death might write exactly such letters, knowing they would be kept.

That is the trouble with this case.

Every piece of evidence can be read two ways.

—

## Fifteen men and a verdict that took a year

The coroner’s jury had fifteen members.

They were local men, gentlemen and yeomen of the country around Cumnor and Abingdon, sworn under oath to find out how the lady came to her death.

Their foreman was a man named Sir Richard Smith.

They viewed the body.

They viewed the stairs.

They questioned the people of the house.

Blount wrote to Robert that the jury were being very secret, and that they were going about their work carefully.

He reported that, as far as he could learn, they had found no sign of foul play.

He wrote, in a phrase that has been quoted ever since, that so far it seemed only misfortune had done it, and nothing else.

But the jury did not deliver its verdict that month.

It did not deliver it that year.

Inquests in Tudor England could take a long time to be formally completed, and this one went through the slow machinery of the courts.

The verdict was finally pronounced at the county assizes on August 1, 1561, nearly eleven months after Amy’s death.

The jury found that she had died by misfortune.

An accident.

And, in the old phrase of the courts, not otherwise.

By then, nobody outside a courtroom much cared what the jury said.

The world had already made up its mind.

—

## What all of Europe said next

At Windsor, as soon as the news came, Robert left the court, by most accounts at the queen’s wish.

He went to his house at Kew, beside the Thames.

It was proper for a man in mourning, and very obviously wise.

The court went into mourning for Lady Dudley.

On September 22, 1560, Amy was buried in the University Church of St Mary the Virgin, in the center of Oxford, with a funeral of great ceremony that Robert paid for.

He did not attend.

The chief mourner was Margery Norris, the wife of a neighbor and friend.

The funeral sermon was preached by Francis Babington, a senior figure in the university.

A hostile book written decades later claimed that he slipped and called her pitifully murdered instead of pitifully slain; there is no reliable evidence for it.

Within weeks, the scandal had crossed the Channel.

In Paris, the English ambassador, Sir Nicholas Throckmorton, wrote home in something close to panic.

He told Cecil, in effect, that he was ashamed to hear what was being said about the queen and Lord Robert at the French court, and that every hair on his head stood on end at it.

Mary, Queen of Scots, who was then also queen of France, is said to have made a famous jibe: that the Queen of England was about to marry her horse master, who had done away with his wife to make room for her.

Whether or not Mary really said it, the line went around Europe.

If Robert Dudley had hoped to marry the queen, the death of his wife had made it almost impossible.

If the queen married him now, half the world would believe she had married a man who had gotten rid of his wife for her, and some would say she had been part of it.

Elizabeth understood this better than anyone.

When the jury’s verdict came, she made a point of saying that the inquest had shown the matter to be contrary to what had been reported, and that it touched neither his honesty nor her honor.

But she did not marry him.

Not ever.

Robert came back to court within weeks of the funeral, and he stayed there, closer to the queen than anyone, for the next twenty-eight years.

He just never stood beside her at the altar.

And the record of exactly how his wife had died disappeared into the archives of the court that had tried the case.

It was not seen again for more than four centuries.

—

## The document that vanished for four hundred years

For centuries, historians had only the letters, the dispatches and the legends.

The coroner’s own report, the formal record of what the jury had seen and found, was assumed to be lost.

Then, in 2008, the Oxford historian Steven Gunn was working through the records of the Court of King’s Bench at The National Archives, in Kew.

He was not looking for Amy Dudley.

He was researching something much more ordinary: accidental deaths in Tudor England, the drownings, falls, kicks from horses and collapsing haystacks that coroners recorded by the thousand.

Among those files, he found her.

The document is in Latin, the formal Latin of the Tudor courts, with a few English words dropped in where the clerk needed them.

Its account is short and precise.

It says that Lady Amy, on September 8, was alone in a certain chamber within the house of Anthony Forster at Cumnor.

That she was intending to go down from that chamber by way of certain stairs.

That she accidentally fell headlong down those stairs, to the very bottom.

And that she received two injuries to her head.

The clerk used an English word for them.

He called them dints.

One of them, the report says, was of the depth of a quarter of a thumb.

The other was of the depth of two thumbs.

A thumb was an old informal measure, roughly an inch.

So one wound was shallow, and the other was much deeper.

The report adds that, by the force of the fall and the weight of her own body falling down the stairs, she broke her own neck, and died at once.

And then comes the verdict.

Misfortune.

Not otherwise.

For a moment, it looked as if the four-hundred-year mystery had been solved.

Here at last was the jury’s own record, and it said, plainly, accident.

But read it again.

Two separate injuries to the head, one of them deep.

A broken neck.

On a staircase usually described as short.

Some writers, including Chris Skidmore, whose book on the case drew on the new find, argued that two head wounds of that kind were hard to explain from a single fall down a few steps.

To them, the report raised as many questions as it answered.

Others pointed out that falls are strange and unpredictable, and that a body can strike a step, a wall or a doorframe more than once on the way down.

And the jury, who saw the body and the stairs with their own eyes, had no doubt at all.

The report mentions no one else in the room, no struggle, nothing about her state of mind.

It recorded what fifteen men had seen and sworn to.

What they saw is consistent with an accident.

It is also, as nearly every historian who has studied it has admitted, consistent with something else.

—

## Four answers to one staircase

Over the centuries, four main explanations have been offered for what happened at Cumnor Place.

Each of them has serious historians behind it.

None of them has ever been proved.

The first is the jury’s own answer: an accident.

A woman in a long gown, alone on a flight of stairs, misses a step or catches her hem, strikes her head and lands badly.

Gunn himself was working on the records of thousands of such accidents when he found her file.

The second explanation is illness.

In 1956, a professor of surgery named Ian Aird published a study arguing that Amy may have had advanced breast cancer, and that the disease had spread to her spine.

Cancer of that kind can make the bones of the neck so fragile that they break under very little force.

A stumble, a sudden twist, a short fall that would barely hurt a healthy woman, could have been enough.

Aird pointed to the Spanish report of a malady in one of her breasts, and to the sense, in the sources, that Amy was unwell and unhappy in her last year.

His theory gained wide acceptance for a time.

But it has its own problems.

That Spanish report was gossip passed on from court, not a physician’s word.

Amy’s last letter, about her new gown, does not read like the letter of a woman who was seriously ill.

And the coroner’s report, found half a century after Aird wrote, mentions wounds to the head, which his theory did not have to account for.

The third explanation is suicide.

It rests above all on Mrs. Picto’s words to Blount, that she had heard Amy pray to God to deliver her from desperation.

On Blount’s own impression of her as a strange woman of mind.

And on the way she insisted, against all objection, on emptying the house that day.

A woman abandoned in other people’s houses while her husband lived in the shadow of the queen, a woman who had heard what was being said at court, may well have been in despair.

In the sixteenth century, a verdict of suicide would have been a disaster for her family.

Her goods could be forfeited, and she could be denied burial in consecrated ground.

Some historians have wondered whether the people of the house, and even the jury, might have preferred the kinder word: misfortune.

But Mrs. Picto, the same woman who spoke of desperation, also said that Amy’s death was neither done by man nor by herself.

And a woman who meant to end her life had surer ways to do it than a short flight of stairs.

The fourth explanation is the one that the world believed at the time, and that many people still believe today.

That Amy was put to death.

The most famous version of it comes from a book printed in 1584, twenty-four years after her death.

It is known as Leicester’s Commonwealth.

It was written by Catholic exiles abroad, and it was not a history.

It was a savage attack on Robert Dudley, then the queen’s chief favorite, accusing him of a long list of crimes, many of them invented or wildly exaggerated.

According to this book, Robert sent Sir Richard Verney, the same Richard Verney at whose house Amy had stayed in 1559, to Cumnor to deal with her.

It claimed that Verney broke her neck and arranged her at the foot of the stairs to look like a fall.

It even claimed, in a mocking aside, that her hood was still standing neatly on her head, as if she had not fallen at all.

That detail has been repeated as fact for centuries.

It comes from a book written to destroy a man’s reputation, by people who were not there, two dozen years after the event.

There is no earlier source for it.

And the jury’s report, found in 2008, says nothing about any hood.

There was one more attempt to turn suspicion into a case.

In 1567, Amy’s half-brother, John Appleyard, was approached by people who wanted him to accuse Robert of having her done away with.

He was offered a large reward.

He talked, and the queen’s council took it seriously enough to hold him in the Fleet prison for about a month while they questioned him.

In the end Appleyard was shown the jury’s report.

He read it.

And he said that it had put his doubts to rest.

If Robert Dudley was guilty, it was not proved in 1561, not in 1567, and not since.

The historian Alison Weir has even suggested that, if anyone arranged it, the likelier hand belonged to someone who wanted to ruin Dudley’s chances, perhaps William Cecil himself.

It is only a suggestion.

If Amy’s death was a crime, the man with the most to lose from it was her husband.

Her death ended his best chance of becoming king.

—

## What became of everyone in that house

Robert Dudley never married the queen.

In 1564, she made him Earl of Leicester, and for the rest of his life he was one of the greatest men in England, a councillor, a soldier, a patron of writers and players.

He was granted Kenilworth Castle in Warwickshire and spent a fortune turning it into a palace.

Three years later, in 1578, he married again, secretly, to Lettice Knollys, a widow and one of the queen’s own cousins.

When Elizabeth found out, she was furious.

Robert died in September 1588, a few weeks after the defeat of the Spanish Armada, at the house of Cornbury in Oxfordshire.

He died, by an odd chance, less than twenty miles from Cumnor.

Anthony Forster, his treasurer and the man who had rented Cumnor Place, did well in the years that followed.

He went on to buy the house outright, became a member of Parliament, and lived there until his death in 1572.

He was buried in the church at Cumnor, next door to the house where Amy died.

Sir Richard Verney, the man the 1584 libel named as the one who did the deed, died years before the book appeared, by most accounts in 1567, and was never charged with anything.

Mrs. Odingsells, the widow who would not go to the fair, and Mrs. Picto, the maid who loved her mistress, disappear from history after the letters of September 1560.

Amy herself lies somewhere beneath the floor of the University Church of St Mary the Virgin in Oxford.

The exact place of her grave is no longer known.

A memorial in the church marks her burial there.

Cumnor Place did not survive.

It stood empty and decaying for many years, and in the early nineteenth century it was pulled down.

Some of its stone is said to have been carried away and reused in other buildings.

Today, the site lies beside St Michael’s Church in Cumnor, and there is little to show where the house once stood.

But the story did not need the house.

In Cumnor, a legend grew up that Amy’s ghost walked the old building, and that it was so restless that nine clergymen were eventually brought from Oxford to lay it to rest in a nearby pond.

That is a legend, and nothing more.

In the eighteenth century, the poet William Julius Mickle wrote a ballad called Cumnor Hall about a lonely, betrayed wife.

And in 1821, Sir Walter Scott published his novel Kenilworth, in which Amy is a secret bride and Robert’s servants are her murderers.

The novel was a huge success.

For generations of readers, Scott’s version simply was the truth.

The real Amy, the girl from Norfolk who married for love, who sat with her husband in the Tower when he was condemned, who spent her last summer ordering a new gown, was lost beneath it.

—

## The empty house on a Sunday

Go back to that Sunday morning.

The bells across the fields.

The fair waiting in Abingdon.

A young woman of twenty-eight, standing in a house that was not hers, insisting that every one of her people should go.

A widow telling her that a Sunday was no day for a gentlewoman.

An old woman agreeing to keep her company at dinner.

Then the servants walking off down the road, and the house growing quiet behind them.

More than four and a half centuries later, we know more about what happened inside that house than anyone has known since the day the jury met.

We know she was alone in a chamber.

We know she came to the stairs.

We know about the two wounds, one shallow, one deep.

We know her neck was broken.

We know fifteen men looked at all of it and called it misfortune.

What we still do not know is the one thing that matters most.

Why she wanted the house empty.

And what was waiting for her in it, at the top of the stairs, after everyone had gone.

—

## What The Record Actually Says

Amy Robsart was born on June 7, 1532, the daughter of Sir John Robsart of Syderstone, Norfolk, and married Robert Dudley at Sheen on June 4, 1550, in the presence of Edward VI.

Robert Dudley was held in the Tower of London from 1553 to October 1554; council records show Amy was allowed to visit him from September 1553.

After Elizabeth I’s accession in November 1558, Robert became Master of the Horse; Amy lived in the houses of others, at Throcking, at Compton Verney and, from December 1559, at Cumnor Place, rented by Anthony Forster.

The account of September 8, 1560, including Amy’s insistence that her people go to the fair at Abingdon, her quarrel with Mrs. Odingsells and her plan to dine with Mrs. Owen, comes from Thomas Blount’s letters to Robert Dudley; it is given here in paraphrase.

Mrs. Picto’s words, that the death was “very chance” and that she had heard Amy pray to be delivered from desperation, are as reported by Blount.

Robert Dudley’s letters to Blount survive in later copies; their wording is paraphrased here except where quoted.

The innkeeper at Abingdon, the messenger Bowes and the order of the riders on September 9 follow the letters as usually summarized; the details of the evening scene at Cumnor, including who found Amy and what was said, are reconstruction.

The Spanish ambassador Álvaro de la Quadra’s reports, including Cecil’s alleged words about Amy’s life being in danger, survive only in his dispatches and may reflect gossip, misunderstanding or deliberate rumor.

The inquest verdict of misadventure (“misfortune”) was delivered at the assizes on August 1, 1561; the coroner’s report was found at The National Archives in 2008 by Steven Gunn, and its wording about two head wounds and a broken neck is paraphrased from published translations.

The theory that Amy had breast cancer that weakened her spine was proposed by Ian Aird in 1956 and remains unproven.

The story that Sir Richard Verney broke Amy’s neck, and the detail of her undisturbed hood, come from Leicester’s Commonwealth (1584), a hostile libel, and are not supported by any contemporary record.

The ghost of Cumnor Place is a local legend; Walter Scott’s Kenilworth (1821) is a novel.

No court, then or since, has found that Amy Dudley was put to death by anyone; the cause of her fall remains unknown.

You Might Also Enjoy