News

1543: What Was a Morning Like for Catherine Parr at Hampton Court Palace

The paper was folded small, the way men folded things they meant to carry against their chest.

Someone had found it on the floor.

It had slipped out of the doublet of one of the king’s councillors as he walked, and he had not noticed, and the person who picked it up had read just enough of it to understand that it must not be handed back.

So it was carried, quickly and quietly, to the queen.

Catherine Parr was thirty-four years old in the summer of 1546.

She was Henry VIII’s sixth wife.

She had been queen for three years, longer than Anne of Cleves, longer than Catherine Howard, longer than Jane Seymour.

She had governed England while the king was at war in France.

She had published books under her own name.

She had made a home, for the first time in years, for all three of the king’s children.

She unfolded the paper and began to read.

It was a list of charges.

They were charges of heresy, the crime for which people in England were being burned alive that very summer.

They were charges against her.

And at the bottom, in the place where it mattered most, there was a signature she knew better than her own.

The king had signed it.

What happened in the next two days has been told and retold for more than four centuries.

It involves a doctor who could not keep a secret, a walk down a long corridor in the dark, a conversation in the king’s bedchamber that may be the most dangerous conversation any of Henry VIII’s wives ever had, and forty armed men marching into a palace garden to arrest a queen who was, at that moment, laughing with the king.

By the end of it, one of the most powerful men in England would be standing in front of his master being called four names in a row.

But first, the queen had to survive the night.

—

## The widow who had already said yes to someone else

Catherine Parr did not want to be queen.

She had made that very clear, at least to the one person she trusted with the truth.

She was born in 1512, the daughter of Sir Thomas Parr, an officer in Henry VIII’s household, and Maud Green, a clever and ambitious woman who served Catherine of Aragon.

Her father died when she was five.

Her mother raised her with an education unusual for a girl: languages, scripture, and the habit of reading seriously.

At seventeen, Catherine was married to Sir Edward Burgh, a young man from a Lincolnshire family.

By twenty-one she was a widow.

Her second husband was much older: John Neville, Lord Latimer, a northern nobleman with a castle at Snape in Yorkshire and two children from an earlier marriage.

That marriage dropped her straight into the middle of a rebellion.

In the autumn of 1536, the great northern rising called the Pilgrimage of Grace swept through Yorkshire, and Latimer was forced, or persuaded, to join the rebels.

When it collapsed, he was caught between both sides.

In early 1537, a band of rebels broke into Snape Castle while he was away.

They ransacked the house and held Catherine and her two stepchildren as hostages.

She was about twenty-four.

They were released, and Latimer survived, but he lived the rest of his life under suspicion.

By 1542 he was ill.

Catherine nursed him through months of decline in London, and in March 1543 he died.

She was thirty, twice widowed, wealthy, and free for the first time in her adult life.

And she was in love.

The man was Thomas Seymour, brother of the late Queen Jane Seymour, uncle of the little Prince Edward.

He was handsome, ambitious, reckless and very good company.

Years later, after everything was over, she wrote him a letter about the spring of 1543.

As truly as God is God, she told him, her mind had been fully bent, the last time she was free, to marry him before any man she knew.

She did not get the chance.

Somebody else had noticed her too.

Henry VIII was fifty-one.

He had buried one wife, divorced two, and sent two to the block.

His last queen, Catherine Howard, had died on a scaffold in the Tower barely a year before.

He was enormously fat, his leg was ulcerated and often agonizing, and he was still the most powerful man in the kingdom.

Catherine Parr had come to court to serve in the household of his daughter, Princess Mary.

He began sending her gifts.

Thomas Seymour was quietly given a job abroad.

There was no proposal in any sense a woman could refuse.

When the king of England decided he wanted you, the only question was the date.

There was also a law hanging over any woman who caught his eye.

After the fall of Catherine Howard, Parliament had made it treason for a woman who was not a virgin to marry the king without first confessing her past to him.

The law was aimed at another Catherine Howard.

A twice-married widow was safe from it, in theory.

But everyone at court understood what it said about the man.

He had put one wife to death for her past.

He had written the lesson into the statute book.

Catherine Parr agreed to marry him anyway, because there was nothing else she could do.

—

## A wedding with eighteen witnesses

The date was July 12, 1543.

The place was Hampton Court Palace, in a small room in the queen’s apartments, a private oratory just off the long gallery.

It was not a grand state wedding.

About eighteen people were present.

Henry’s two daughters were there: Mary, who was twenty-seven and Catherine’s friend, and Elizabeth, who was nine.

Catherine’s sister, Anne Herbert, was there.

So were a handful of lords and ladies of the court.

The man who read the service was Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester.

He was one of the cleverest men in England and one of the most stubborn.

He had spent years as Henry’s diplomat and lawyer, and he was the leader of the religious conservatives at court, the men who wanted the Church of England to stay as close to the old Catholic faith as it could without the pope.

He had been a brilliant servant of the king for twenty years.

He had helped argue the case for Henry’s first divorce in Rome.

He had written a famous defense of the king’s supremacy over the Church.

But he had never accepted the reformers’ ideas about the mass, and he had a long memory for enemies.

It is worth remembering his face as he read the vows.

Three years later, he would be one of the two men trying to destroy her.

Catherine chose a motto for her new life.

It was short and practical, like her: “To be useful in all I do.”

She took a badge, too, a maiden’s head rising out of a Tudor rose, and she ordered new clothes, new jewels and new furnishings with the energy of a woman who had decided that, if she had to do this, she would do it well.

After the ceremony the new queen began the life that all of Henry VIII’s queens had begun before her: a life lived in rooms that were never really private.

The queen’s lodgings at Hampton Court were a chain of chambers, each one more restricted than the last.

There was a great watching chamber where anyone with a place at court could come to stand and look.

There was a presence chamber where the queen received visitors under her canopy of state.

There was a privy chamber for her closest servants.

And at the end, the bedchamber itself.

Every morning, her ladies, who had slept in the rooms nearby, came in to dress her.

They were not maids in our sense.

They were noblewomen, chosen for their family connections and their discretion, and among them, from the start, was her sister Anne.

Dressing a Tudor queen took time.

First came a smock of fine linen, the only layer that could actually be washed.

Then a bodice stiffened to hold the body straight and flat, then petticoats, then a kirtle, then the gown itself, heavy with embroidery and pearls, its sleeves separate pieces pinned on so they could be changed.

Then the hood.

Catherine favored the French hood, the softer crescent shape that had been fashionable in Anne Boleyn’s day.

At the court of a king who had once loved Anne Boleyn and then destroyed her, even a hat could be read as a statement.

The queen’s day began at chapel.

Hampton Court’s Chapel Royal had been rebuilt by Henry in the 1530s, with a ceiling of carved and gilded pendants and painted stars.

The queen heard mass from a royal pew high above the nave, looking down through windows on the choir and the court.

It was a beautiful room.

It was also the most dangerous place in the palace for a woman with her opinions.

Because the queen who knelt in that pew every morning was, by 1546, a convinced reformer.

After chapel came the first real meal of the day, served at around ten in the morning.

Hampton Court’s kitchens were a world of their own, more than fifty rooms with around two hundred staff, feeding a court that could number a thousand people.

The quantities still astonish anyone who reads the accounts: thousands of sheep a year, hundreds of deer, oxen by the hundred, pigs by the hundred, all of it roasted, boiled, baked into pies and carried up the stairs.

The senior courtiers ate in the great watching chamber Henry had built in the time of Jane Seymour.

The lower ranks ate in the great hall, under the hammerbeam roof.

High up on that roof, carved among the beams, were small wooden faces that people called the eavesdroppers.

The story told about them was that they were there to remind everyone that nothing said in the hall was ever truly private.

The queen’s meal was a performance, like everything else.

Who sat near her, who was invited to speak, who was ignored, all of it was watched and reported.

In the outer court, the great astronomical clock, set up over the gateway in 1540 by the king’s clockmaker Nicholas Oursian, showed the hour, the phase of the moon, the signs of the zodiac and the state of the tide at London Bridge, so that courtiers coming by river would know when to travel.

The whole palace ran on time, rank and gossip.

And for the queen, there was one more thing on that list.

—

## The books she wrote while the king was watching

Henry VIII had broken with Rome, but he never became a Protestant.

He still believed in the mass as Catholics understood it, with the bread and wine truly becoming the body and blood of Christ.

He had made it law, in the Act of Six Articles of 1539, that denying this was heresy, and the punishment for heresy was burning.

At the same time he had allowed an English Bible to be placed in churches, and then, as he grew older and more suspicious, he had restricted who was allowed to read it.

Women of the lower classes were forbidden to read it at all.

Noblewomen could read it privately.

Nobody could argue about it in public without risk.

His court was split into two camps, each waiting for the other to make a mistake.

On one side were the conservatives: Gardiner, the Duke of Norfolk, and the lord chancellor, Thomas Wriothesley.

On the other were the reformers: Archbishop Cranmer, Edward Seymour, John Dudley, and, increasingly, the queen.

Catherine did not hide her interests.

She gathered around her a circle of educated women and scholars who read and discussed scripture in her chambers.

She encouraged the translation of religious works into English.

She took a personal interest in the education of the king’s children, especially the two youngest, and the tutors who taught them were mostly men of reforming views.

And she wrote.

In 1544 she published, without her name on it, a book of psalms and prayers translated into English.

In 1545 she published “Prayers or Meditations,” and this time her name was on the cover.

It was the first original book ever published by an English queen under her own name.

Somewhere in these years she was also writing a much bolder work, a long confession of her own spiritual journey that would only be printed after Henry’s death, under the title “The Lamentation of a Sinner.”

She ran the country for three months in 1544, while Henry was besieging Boulogne.

She signed proclamations, raised money and men for the war, and kept the king informed with long, careful letters.

The letters she sent him in France still exist.

In one of them she told him that, although his absence had not been long, the want of his presence, so much beloved and desired by her, meant that she could take pleasure in nothing until she heard from him.

It is the language of a loyal wife.

It is also the language of a very careful one.

She signed her official documents “Katherine the Queen, KP,” and the council that worked with her, Archbishop Cranmer among them, found her capable and calm.

It did not escape anyone at court that the king had trusted her with the realm.

It did not escape the conservatives, either, that the men she worked most closely with were reformers.

Elizabeth, then eleven, spent much of that summer with her.

At the end of that year, the girl gave her stepmother a New Year’s present: a translation, in her own handwriting, of a French religious poem, with an embroidered cover she had stitched herself.

The household that Catherine built in those years was, by every account, the closest thing to a family that Henry’s children ever had.

Prince Edward, who had never known his own mother, wrote to Catherine in Latin and addressed her as his most dear mother.

Mary, who was only four years younger than her stepmother, became a real friend, and was persuaded to work on an English translation of the Gospel of John for one of the queen’s projects.

Even the king seemed, for a time, to be content.

And all of it rested on one man’s mood.

By 1546, the king’s leg was worse than ever.

He was in constant pain.

He could barely walk and was sometimes carried around his palaces in a chair.

He slept badly, ate enormously, and lost his temper over small things.

And he liked to talk about religion.

—

## The king who had to be carried

To understand the danger the queen was in, it helps to see the man she was married to in that last year.

The athletic young prince who had danced in his jacket at his brother’s wedding was gone.

The armor made for Henry in his last years shows a waist of more than fifty inches.

The wound on his leg, which some historians link to a fall in the tiltyard years before and others to a chronic infection of the bone, had to be opened and drained by his surgeons when it closed over.

When it closed, he ran a fever.

When it was open, the smell was hard to hide.

He moved around his palaces in a chair carried by his servants, and he had special devices made to haul him up stairs.

He was often awake at night in pain.

His temper, never gentle, now turned without warning.

Men who had been his friends for thirty years had learned that a single conversation could finish them.

In the same months that the queen was being watched, the Howard family was being watched too, and before the year was out the Earl of Surrey, the poet son of the Duke of Norfolk, would be arrested on charges that had grown out of a coat of arms.

The king trusted almost no one.

That was what made him so easy to frighten, and so dangerous to anyone his councillors decided to frighten him about.

Catherine was the one person who spent hours alone with him.

She dressed his leg herself, according to tradition, and she sat with him through his bad nights.

She knew his moods better than anyone alive.

And still, in the summer of 1546, she made the mistake of thinking that the man in the chair was the same man who had trusted her with England two years before.

—

## The woman they racked in the Tower

In the spring and summer of 1546, the conservatives at court began a hunt.

They were looking for heretics, and they were looking for them close to the throne.

The most famous of the people they caught was a Lincolnshire gentlewoman named Anne Askew.

She was in her mid-twenties.

She had left a husband who threw her out for reading the Bible, and she had come to London, where she preached, argued and quoted scripture with a skill that infuriated the clergymen who examined her.

Her written account of her examinations survives, and it shows a woman who was quick, sharp and almost impossible to trap.

When one examiner asked her whether a mouse that ate the consecrated bread would receive God, she gave no answer.

She simply smiled.

When the Bishop of London tried to get her to sign a confession, she added words of her own before her signature that made it worthless to him.

She openly denied that the bread of the mass became the body of Christ.

That was heresy under the law of 1539.

She was condemned to be burned.

But before the sentence was carried out, the men in charge wanted something else from her.

They wanted names.

Specifically, they wanted to know whether any of the great ladies of the court had helped her, sent her money, or shared her beliefs.

The ladies they asked about were all close to the queen.

The Duchess of Suffolk.

The Countess of Hertford.

Lady Denny.

Lady Fitzwilliam.

Askew was taken to the Tower and questioned.

When she refused to answer, she was put on the rack.

What happened next was so shocking that she wrote about it herself, in an account smuggled out of prison and later printed.

According to her own words, after the lieutenant of the Tower, Sir Anthony Knyvett, refused to continue, the lord chancellor, Thomas Wriothesley, and his colleague Sir Richard Rich took off their gowns and worked the rack with their own hands.

She did not give them a single name.

Sir Anthony Knyvett, alarmed at what had been done inside his walls, took a boat straight to the king to explain himself before anyone else could tell the story first.

Henry, by this account, approved of the lieutenant’s refusal.

But the chancellor was not punished.

On July 16, 1546, she was carried to Smithfield in a chair, because she could no longer walk, and burned with three men beside her.

Those who were there remembered that she was calm.

Small bags of gunpowder were hung around the necks of the condemned, a grim mercy that was meant to make the end quicker.

A pardon was offered at the last moment if she would recant.

She refused to read it.

The lord chancellor, Wriothesley, was among the great men watching from a stand nearby.

The queen could not have missed the meaning.

The men who had turned the rack had been hoping to find a path that led to her.

—

## “A good hearing it is, when women become such clerks”

Almost everything we know about what happened next comes from one source.

His name was John Foxe.

He was a Protestant writer who, in the reign of Elizabeth I, published an enormous history of the people who had suffered for the reformed faith, the book later known as Foxe’s Book of Martyrs.

He collected his stories from people who had been there, or claimed to have been, and he told them with a clear purpose.

So the details should be read carefully.

But the core of what he says is accepted by most modern historians of Catherine Parr, and it goes like this.

The queen, Foxe says, had taken to discussing religion with the king.

She did it often, sometimes in front of others, and sometimes she argued.

At first Henry enjoyed it.

But one evening, when his leg was hurting badly, she pressed a point too far.

The king changed the subject.

The queen left.

And the king turned to the man who happened to be standing nearby, Bishop Stephen Gardiner, and said something that Foxe records almost word for word.

“A good hearing it is,” he said, “when women become such clerks; and a thing much to my comfort, to come in mine old days to be taught by my wife.”

Gardiner saw his opening.

According to Foxe, he told the king that he would be sorry to see His Majesty troubled by such talk, that the queen’s opinions were dangerous, and that if the king allowed it, he and others could prove that she was harboring heresy that the law would not tolerate.

Henry, in pain, in a temper, gave his permission.

Articles were drawn up.

The plan was to arrest the queen, take her to the Tower by night, and search her rooms and her ladies’ rooms for forbidden books.

The articles were brought to the king.

And the king signed them.

—

## The paper that fell

Here the story turns on a piece of luck so strange that people have doubted it ever since.

The king, Foxe says, mentioned the plan to one person outside the council: his physician, Dr. Thomas Wendy.

He made the doctor swear to keep it secret.

Then, a little later, one of the councillors was walking through the palace with the signed articles tucked into the breast of his clothing.

The paper fell out.

He did not notice.

Someone else did.

Foxe calls this person only “some godly person,” and never names them.

They picked it up, saw what it was, and took it straight to the queen.

Foxe does not name the councillor who dropped it either.

Later writers have guessed at Wriothesley himself, or one of his allies, but nobody knows.

Some historians suspect that the paper did not fall by accident at all, and that someone close to the king, perhaps even someone on the council who did not want to see another queen destroyed, made sure it reached her.

It is impossible to prove.

What matters is that it reached her in time.

So imagine the scene in the queen’s chambers at that moment.

It is summer.

The rooms are warm, the windows open on to the gardens and the river.

Somewhere in the palace, the king is resting his leg.

Somewhere else, his councillors are preparing a barge and a warrant.

And in her own rooms, among her ladies, the queen of England is holding the evidence of her own destruction, with her husband’s name at the bottom of it.

She knew exactly what it meant.

She had known Anne Boleyn, who had been taken to the Tower by barge and never came out.

She had served at the same court as Catherine Howard, who had been dragged from Hampton Court in tears and never came back.

She had just watched Anne Askew go to the stake.

And she knew something else, the thing that made it worse.

The articles were not fiction.

She did own the books they were looking for.

She did discuss the ideas they were describing.

If the king’s men searched her rooms, they would find things.

Foxe says that the queen fell into a terrible state, weeping and crying out so loudly that it could be heard through the walls.

Some versions say she took to her bed, sick with fear.

The noise reached the king.

And the king, who had signed the warrant against her, sent his doctors to see what was wrong with his wife.

One of them was Dr. Wendy.

He came into the queen’s bedchamber, looked at her, and understood perfectly well what had happened.

Foxe says he took her aside and, breaking the oath the king had made him swear, told her the whole of it: the conversation, the articles, the plan.

And then he gave her the advice that saved her life.

Do not wait for them to come for you.

Go to the king.

Submit to him.

—

## The walk to the king’s bedchamber

It must have been the longest walk of her life.

Foxe says that she first made a show of recovering.

She was helped up, dressed, and composed.

Her ladies were told to get rid of any books that could be used against her; the evidence was quietly removed from her rooms.

We do not know exactly what was taken away or where it went.

Prayer books with the wrong prefaces.

Translations printed abroad.

Perhaps pages of her own manuscript.

Every lady in her household understood that if the search party came, it would not stop at the queen’s coffers.

It would go through theirs too, and the ladies whose names Anne Askew had refused to give were standing in that room.

For a few hours, the queen’s chambers must have looked like a household packing in a fire.

It was not a simple thing to stand up again.

The queen had to look well, look calm and look innocent, and she had to do it within hours, before the councillors moved.

Her ladies would have dressed her as carefully as they did every morning: the smock, the kirtle, the gown, the hood.

Nothing that suggested fear.

Nothing that suggested defiance.

Then, that evening, she went to the king.

Her sister Anne Herbert went with her, and a young relative carried a candle in front of them.

Picture the corridors of the palace at night.

The torches in their brackets.

The guards at every door, who would have stood back for the queen, and who might, by the following day, be the men sent to take her away.

The sound of her own footsteps on the boards.

The king’s apartments, the outer chamber, the inner chamber, and finally the room where Henry VIII sat, his bad leg propped up, surrounded by the gentlemen of his privy chamber.

She came in and made her curtsy.

He received her kindly enough.

And then, Foxe says, he did something that might have been innocent or might have been a test.

He began to talk about religion.

He asked her opinion on a point of doctrine.

It was the trap she had walked into before, and this time everything depended on her answer.

She did not give an opinion.

She gave a speech, and it is one of the most carefully built speeches in English history.

She said that she was a woman, made by God to be subject to her husband.

She said that a woman was weak and of little understanding by nature, and that in matters of religion she must learn from her lord and husband, not teach him.

She said that she would never presume to set her own judgment against his.

The king was not satisfied.

Not so, he said, by Saint Mary.

You have become a doctor, Kate, to instruct us, as we take it, and not to be instructed by us.

This was the moment.

The gentlemen around the king’s chair would have gone very still.

The candle would have flickered.

Somewhere outside the window, the river would have been running down toward London, toward the Tower, toward the water gate that had swallowed two of her predecessors.

She was standing in front of a man who, a few days before, had signed a paper meant to send her through that gate.

He had just accused her, in front of witnesses, of the very thing in the paper.

If she defended her opinions, she would be proving the charge.

If she simply denied having opinions, he would know she was lying.

She needed a third way out, and she had seconds to find it.

Everything that came after hung on what she said next.

She told him that he had misunderstood her completely.

She had never argued with him in order to teach him, she said.

She had argued so that the conversation would take his mind off the pain in his leg, and so that, by hearing his learned answers, she herself could profit from them.

She had argued, in other words, as a nurse and a pupil, never as a rival.

There was a pause.

Then the king spoke, and Foxe’s version of his words has become famous.

“And is it even so, sweetheart?” he asked.

“And tended your arguments to no worse end? Then perfect friends we are now again, as ever at any time heretofore.”

He took her in his arms.

The men in the room watched the queen of England being embraced by the husband who had signed the order for her arrest a few days earlier.

He told her that hearing this from her own mouth did him more good than news of a hundred thousand pounds.

It is hard to know what the queen felt in that embrace.

The arms around her belonged to the man who had approved the plan to destroy her.

His signature was on the paper hidden in her rooms.

He had not apologized, and he never would, because as far as he was concerned there was nothing to apologize for.

She had submitted.

He had forgiven her.

In his mind, the matter was closed.

In hers, it could not have been.

She had seen how little it took: one bad night with his leg, one argument too many, one ambitious bishop standing at his elbow.

She would have to be this careful for the rest of his life.

She stayed with him a while longer.

Then she went back to her rooms.

She had won.

But nobody had told the lord chancellor.

—

## Forty men in the garden

The arrest had been set for the next day.

Foxe says the king and queen were walking together in the privy garden that afternoon, with a few of the queen’s ladies, the king leaning on his stick, the queen beside him.

The privy garden at Hampton Court was one of Henry’s showpieces.

Its paths ran between low hedges and railings painted in the Tudor colors of green and white, and all around stood carved wooden beasts on striped posts, lions and dragons and greyhounds, each holding a little banner with the royal arms.

It was a peaceful scene.

The sun was out.

Then there was a noise at the garden gate.

Thomas Wriothesley, Lord Chancellor of England, the same man who had turned the rack on Anne Askew a few weeks before, came marching in at the head of a body of the king’s guard.

Foxe puts their number at forty.

He had the signed warrant.

He had a barge waiting.

He had come to take the queen to the Tower.

He had no idea that the warrant was now worthless.

Wriothesley was about forty.

He had begun his career as a clerk in the service of Thomas Cromwell, Henry’s great minister, and had risen through Cromwell’s patronage.

When Cromwell fell in 1540, Wriothesley had helped gather the evidence against him.

He had been made lord chancellor in 1544.

Holbein painted him as a sharp-faced young man with a thin beard and watchful eyes, and everything about his career suggests a man who understood that in Henry VIII’s England, the safest place to stand was next to whoever was about to win.

In the summer of 1546, he had bet everything on the conservatives winning.

He was marching into the garden to collect.

What happened next, Foxe says, happened fast.

The king saw him coming.

He stepped away from the queen, met the chancellor a little distance off, and spoke to him in a low, furious voice that the queen could not quite hear.

And then he raised his voice, and everyone heard.

Knave, the king called him.

Arrant knave.

Beast.

And fool.

He ordered him out of his sight.

Wriothesley and his forty guards turned around and left the garden.

When the king came back to her, the queen, Foxe says, did something that only a very clever woman would have done.

She asked him not to be so angry with the chancellor.

She said she supposed the man must have made some mistake out of ignorance, and she would gladly speak up for him.

Henry looked at her.

“Ah, poor soul,” he said, according to Foxe.

“Thou little knowest how evil he deserveth this grace at thy hands.”

On my word, sweetheart, he told her, he has been toward you an arrant knave.

And so the queen of England went on walking in the garden, while the man who had come to arrest her was rowed back down the river without her.

—

## What happened to everyone in the garden

Henry VIII had six months to live.

He died at Whitehall in the early hours of January 28, 1547.

Catherine was not with him.

Before he died, he made a will naming the men who would govern for his nine-year-old son.

Stephen Gardiner was not among them.

When some of the councillors asked about it, the king is said to have replied that Gardiner was a willful man and that he alone could control him.

Gardiner spent much of the next reign in the Tower, and only came back to power under the Catholic Mary I.

Thomas Wriothesley lost the great seal within weeks of the old king’s death, accused of abusing his office.

He died in 1550.

Catherine was a widow for the third time, and for the first time she could choose for herself.

She chose Thomas Seymour.

They married secretly in the spring of 1547, so soon after Henry’s death that it scandalized the court.

It did not end well.

The young king’s council was furious that it had not been asked.

Seymour’s own brother, Edward, now Lord Protector of England, was angry, and his wife and Catherine quarrelled over precedence at court.

Catherine took Elizabeth into her household at Chelsea, and then at Sudeley, as she had always intended.

Seymour’s behavior toward the teenage Elizabeth, who was living in their household, led to the girl being sent away.

In August 1548, at Sudeley Castle in Gloucestershire, Catherine gave birth to a daughter, Mary.

Six days later, on September 5, she died, of the same kind of fever after childbirth that had killed so many women before her.

She was thirty-six.

Thomas Seymour was put to death for treason a few months later.

Her sister Anne survived the whole storm; her husband, William Herbert, rose to become Earl of Pembroke.

The Duchess of Suffolk, one of the ladies the chancellor had tried to reach through Anne Askew, lived to flee abroad under Mary I and came home again under Elizabeth.

The women the rack had been meant to catch outlived the men who turned it.

The baby, Mary Seymour, vanishes from the records before she was two.

And there was one more strange chapter.

In 1782, people exploring the ruins of the chapel at Sudeley found a lead coffin inscribed with Catherine’s name.

They opened it.

Those who saw it reported that the body inside was remarkably well preserved.

Over the following years, the coffin was opened again more than once by curious visitors, and locks of her hair were taken away as souvenirs.

Her remains were eventually given a proper tomb in the restored chapel, where she lies today.

She is the only one of Henry VIII’s queens buried in a private house rather than a royal church or cathedral.

—

## The other piece of paper

Go back to the first scene, the folded paper in the queen’s hands, with the king’s signature at the bottom.

There is another paper in this story that matters just as much.

It is the one she wrote herself.

In November 1547, after Henry was dead and buried, Catherine Parr finally published “The Lamentation of a Sinner,” the book she had been writing in secret in the years when owning the wrong book could send a woman to the stake.

In it she wrote openly about her faith, about reading scripture for herself, and about the years when she had been, as she put it, blind to it.

She had kept it hidden all through the summer of 1546.

The men with the warrant had been looking for exactly that kind of thing.

They never found it.

The paper with the king’s signature on it was lost, picked up off a palace floor by someone whose name we will never know.

The book is a strange document to read with this story in mind.

In it she praises her late husband warmly, as a Moses who had led the people of England out of captivity to Rome.

She writes nothing about the summer of 1546.

She never mentions the articles, the doctor, the garden or the forty men.

Perhaps she thought it was safer not to.

Perhaps, by then, she had made her peace with him.

Or perhaps she simply understood that the most powerful thing she could do with that story was to survive it, and then publish everything they had been looking for, under her own name, with her husband safely in his tomb.

The paper with her name on it is still in print.

—

## What The Record Actually Says

Almost the entire story of the 1546 plot against Catherine Parr, including the dropped articles, Dr. Wendy, the conversation in the king’s chamber and the scene in the garden, comes from John Foxe’s “Acts and Monuments,” first published in 1563 and expanded in later editions.

Foxe was writing as a Protestant historian under Elizabeth I, decades after the events, and he does not name his informants.

Modern biographers of Catherine Parr generally accept that a serious attempt was made against her in 1546, and that Gardiner and Wriothesley were behind it, while treating the specific details and dialogue with caution.

The quoted words in this article, including “a good hearing it is, when women become such clerks,” “and is it even so, sweetheart,” and the king’s insults to Wriothesley, follow Foxe’s account.

The number of guards, forty, also comes from Foxe.

The date of the episode is not recorded; historians usually place it in the summer of 1546.

Anne Askew’s racking by Wriothesley and Rich comes from her own written account, later published by John Bale and Foxe.

The account of Catherine’s earlier life, including the rebel attack on Snape Castle, her wedding to Henry VIII at Hampton Court on July 12, 1543, her books and her regency, is well documented.

Her letter to Thomas Seymour about her “mind” being “fully bent” on marrying him survives.

The opening of her coffin at Sudeley in 1782, and its reopening by later visitors, is recorded in local accounts.

Some details of her daily routine at Hampton Court, such as the exact order in which she was dressed, are reconstructed from what is known about the households of Tudor queens in general.

You Might Also Enjoy