Why You Wouldn’t Survive One Winter in Tudor England
The bull was tied to a stake in the courtyard below, and the dogs had been let loose on it a few minutes before.
From an upper window of the bishop’s palace at Rochester, the young woman could see all of it: the trampled, half-frozen mud, the ring of servants and townspeople stamping their feet against the cold, the breath of the crowd hanging in the gray air, the dogs going in low and being thrown off again.
The noise came up through the glass and filled the room behind her.
It was the first day of January, 1540.
In England, New Year’s Day was the day for gifts.
She was twenty-four years old, and she had been on the road for about seven weeks.
She had crossed the Low Countries by carriage in the worst season of the year, waited fifteen days in Calais for a storm to blow itself out, crossed the sea, and ridden through Kent in rain and wind to reach Rochester on the last evening of the old year.
In a few days she was to be married to the King of England.
She had never seen him.
He had seen her, or rather he had seen a picture of her, painted on parchment by the finest portrait painter in Europe.
She was watching the dogs when the door opened behind her and a group of men came in.
They were dressed alike, in cloaks and hoods of the same mottled cloth, like men who had ridden hard on a winter road.
One of them was very big.
He came straight across the room to her, took her in his arms, and kissed her.
She did not know who he was.
What would anyone do, in a strange country, in a language she could not speak, when a stranger did that on the very day she was waiting for a king?
She did what almost anyone would.
She drew back, said a few polite words, and turned to the window again.
The big man was Henry VIII.
In that room, in the space of a few minutes, something broke that was never repaired.
Within six months the marriage would be over, the minister who had arranged it would be in the Tower, and the king would be married to someone else.
And yet, of Henry’s six wives, the woman at the window is the one who came out best.
She kept her life, her fortune and the king’s friendship, and in the end she was given one thing that none of the other five ever had.
It began with a choice she made in the summer of 1540, at Richmond, when the king’s councillors came to ask her a question that had only one safe answer.
—
## Why the king of England chose a wife he had never met
In the autumn of 1537, Jane Seymour died at Hampton Court, twelve days after giving Henry VIII the son he had waited nearly thirty years for.
For two years, the king was a widower.
In 1538 the Emperor Charles V and King Francis I of France made a truce at Nice, and in December the pope published the sentence of excommunication against Henry.
For the first time in his reign, the king had to consider that the two great Catholic powers might turn on England together.
That winter, new round artillery castles began to go up along the shore of Kent, at Deal, Walmer and Sandown, built to fire on an invasion fleet.
Henry’s chief minister, Thomas Cromwell, had an answer of his own.
He wanted friends in Germany.
The duchy of Cleves sat on the lower Rhine, around the towns of Cleves, Düsseldorf and Jülich.
Its rulers were not Lutherans, but they kept their distance from the pope, they were quarreling with the emperor over the duchy of Guelders, and through marriage they were tied to the Protestant princes of Saxony.
To Cromwell, it looked like exactly the ally England needed.
The ducal house had two unmarried daughters, Anne and Amalia.
Anne was the elder, born in September 1515.
Henry was interested, but he trusted his own judgment of a woman’s face above any envoy’s letter.
So in the summer of 1539 he sent the man he trusted most with a face.
Hans Holbein the Younger, the German-born painter who had become Henry’s court artist, traveled to the castle of Düren and painted both sisters.
The English envoy in Cleves, Nicholas Wotton, wrote home that summer.
As his report is usually summarized, Anne had been brought up quietly at her mother’s side, spent much of her time with her needle, knew no language but her own, and could neither sing nor play, because in Germany such things were thought improper for a great lady.
Holbein, he added, had captured the sisters very lifelike.
Henry looked at the portrait of Anne.
He liked what he saw.
On October 4, 1539, the marriage treaty was signed.
There was one loose thread nobody could quite tie off.
Years before, as a child, Anne had been promised in marriage to Francis, the son of the Duke of Lorraine.
The Cleves envoys swore the arrangement had come to nothing.
Nobody in London thought much about it.
Not yet.
—
## Seven weeks on the worst roads of the year
She left in November.
Her brother William, duke since that February, sent her off in style.
The escort was enormous, something over two hundred and sixty people and more than two hundred horses by the usual count: councillors, ladies, grooms, cooks, guards and wagons full of plate, linen and the heavy German gowns she would wear as queen.
The North Sea in November was too dangerous for a bride who carried an alliance with her, so she went overland, west across the emperor’s lands in the Low Countries.
That meant a winter journey, and a winter journey in the sixteenth century was an ordeal.
The roads were not roads in any modern sense.
They were tracks of earth and stone that turned to deep mud in the autumn rains and then froze into hard, twisted ridges that could snap a wheel or lame a horse.
Daylight lasted barely eight hours.
By four in the afternoon it was dark, and no sensible traveler stayed on the road after dark.
And the long winter nights were the busiest season for the men who robbed travelers.
A great lady’s procession moved at the pace of its slowest wagon.
On some days Anne’s train is said to have covered no more than a few miles.
At every stopping place, fires had to be lit in cold rooms that had stood empty, and bed curtains hung and drawn tight, because a bed without curtains in December was a bed you did not sleep in.
Food had to be found for hundreds of people in the season when the fields gave nothing: salted meat, dried fish, hard cheese and bread.
At Antwerp, the English merchants who traded there rode out to meet her and brought her into the city by torchlight.
Then she went on through Flanders toward the coast.
What did she think about, in a jolting carriage, hour after hour, through the flat, frozen fields of Flanders?
There is no letter to tell us.
But she knew what kind of man she was going to.
Everyone in Europe knew.
He had put away his first wife after twenty years, sent his second to the scaffold, and lost his third after childbirth.
It is said that when an earlier bride had been suggested to him, the young widowed Duchess of Milan, Christina of Denmark, had joked that if she had two heads, one of them would be at the King of England’s disposal.
The story may not be true, but people across Europe repeated it because it sounded true.
On December 11, 1539, Anne of Cleves rode into Calais, the last English town on the continent.
The sea was waiting for her.
So was the weather.
—
## Fifteen days waiting for the wind
Calais greeted her with guns.
The town’s deputy, Viscount Lisle, met her with the garrison drawn up.
The Lord Admiral of England, William Fitzwilliam, Earl of Southampton, had come over with the ships that would carry her across, and they fired a salute so heavy that the smoke hung over the harbor.
Then the wind turned.
Storms came in off the Channel day after day.
Gales held the ships in harbor.
A crossing that might take a few hours in summer was out of the question, and the bride of the King of England sat in Calais and waited.
She waited for fifteen days.
It would have been easy to sulk.
She did the opposite.
She asked Southampton to teach her an English card game, so that she would be able to play with the king when she met him.
He taught her one called cent, and he wrote to Henry that she played with as good a grace and countenance as any lady he had ever seen.
She asked to see how English lords and ladies dined, so that she would not make mistakes at her new husband’s table.
She watched carefully.
She tried to learn.
Southampton wrote warmly about her to the king.
It would cost him later.
Christmas came and went in Calais, and still the bride watched the gray water and waited for the weather to change.
On December 27, it finally did.
Around midday she went aboard.
The fleet slipped out of Calais harbor, and late that afternoon, in the winter dusk, she stepped onto English sand on the beach at Deal, in Kent.
The new castle at Deal, one of the round artillery forts Henry had ordered built against the very powers this marriage was meant to hold off, was just being finished.
Anne rested there, out of the wind, in a fortress so new the lime was barely dry.
She had arrived.
She still had four days of road ahead of her.
And the man waiting at the end of it had already decided he could not wait for her.
—
## The road through Kent in the dark of the year
From Deal she went on to Dover Castle that same evening, where Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, the king’s oldest friend, and his young wife, Catherine Willoughby, were waiting to receive her with a crowd of Kentish gentlemen.
When she set out from Dover toward Canterbury, the wind and rain came in again.
Wool cloaks soaked through and grew heavy, and in places the road over the downs was more water than earth.
Near Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer, the Archbishop of Canterbury, came out to meet her with a company of gentlemen.
She was lodged at St. Augustine’s, the great abbey that had been closed and turned into a royal house only the year before.
The next day she went on to Sittingbourne.
On December 31, the last day of the year, she reached Rochester, where the Duke of Norfolk and a body of lords had ridden out to bring her in.
The old city on the Medway, with its castle keep and its cathedral, was full of her people and of the English sent to meet her.
She was lodged in the bishop’s palace beside the cathedral.
That night was the last night of 1539.
In the morning there would be gifts, and a bull-baiting in the courtyard to amuse her and her ladies.
Thirty miles away, at Greenwich Palace, Henry VIII was making plans of his own.
—
## Why a forty-eight-year-old king put on a disguise
Henry was forty-eight that winter.
The young athlete of 1510 was a long way behind him.
A fall in the lists in January 1536 had ended his tournaments, an ulcer on his leg came and went, and he was heavier every year.
But inside the heavy man, something of the young one still lived.
Henry had grown up on the romances of chivalry, in which knights rode in disguise to test the hearts of the ladies they loved, and he had played those games all his life.
Early in his reign, according to the chronicler Edward Hall, he and a group of his companions burst into Queen Catherine of Aragon’s chamber one morning dressed as Robin Hood and his outlaws, and the queen and her ladies played along, pretending to be frightened before they laughed.
Now, on New Year’s morning 1540, he decided to do it again.
As it was later explained, he wanted to see his bride before the formal meeting, privately, and, in the phrase reported from his own circle, “to nourish love.”
He chose a small company of gentlemen from his privy chamber.
They dressed alike in cloaks of mottled, marbled cloth, with hoods, so that no one in Rochester would be able to tell the king from his men at a glance.
They took horse at Greenwich and rode east along the old road through Kent, through the frozen mud of the season, toward the Medway.
When they reached Rochester, the king sent one man ahead.
Sir Anthony Browne, the Master of the Horse, was to go in to the lady and tell her that a gift had come for her from the king, so that she would be ready to receive a messenger.
Browne went in.
He saw her.
Six months later, when he was asked to remember that moment under oath, he is reported to have said that he had never been more dismayed in all his life.
As his evidence is usually paraphrased, he grieved in his heart to see how far the lady was from what had been reported of her.
What exactly he saw is hard to recover now.
No one at Rochester wrote down the next few minutes as they happened.
Everything that survives was written down later, after the marriage had failed, by men who had every reason to agree with the king.
But Browne did not warn anyone.
He did not tell the king what he had felt.
And the king, who did not know, came in.
—
## The window at Rochester
The room was not large.
Like every great chamber in an English winter, it had a fire at one end and was cold at the other, and the window where she stood was the coldest place in it.
There would have been tapestries on the walls against the drafts, and her ladies around her: a handful of Englishwomen sent to serve the new queen, and the German women who had come with her from Cleves in their high, stiff headdresses.
She was watching the baiting.
According to the account that was later given of the meeting, she was looking out of the window at the bull when the hooded men came in.
She would have seen them, if she saw them at all, as more English gentlemen: travelers, messengers, part of the endless stream of strangers she had been meeting since Calais.
She had been told a gift was coming from the king.
Perhaps she thought these were the men bringing it.
One of them stepped forward out of the group.
He was tall, and he was very broad.
He walked with the slight heaviness of a man with a bad leg.
His face, under the hood, was red from the cold road.
He did not bow.
He did not kneel.
He crossed the room, took her in his arms and kissed her.
Then he gave her a token, a present he said came from the king.
Every instinct of the old romances told him what should happen next.
In the stories, the lady always knew.
Something in her heart recognized the king beneath the plain cloak.
She blushed.
She laughed.
She understood.
Love, in the stories, saw through disguises.
Anne of Cleves did not see through it.
She did not know this man.
He did not speak her language, and she did not speak his.
A stranger had walked into her chamber in a foreign country, put his arms around her in front of her women and kissed her on the mouth.
The surviving accounts say that she was abashed and embarrassed.
She said a few words, polite and brief, the way a well-brought-up young woman would speak to a stranger she did not wish to offend.
And then she turned away from him and looked out of the window again, at the bull and the dogs in the courtyard below.
It must have been a very long moment.
The king of England stood in the middle of the room with his men around him, and his bride had her back to him.
No one had ever done that to Henry VIII.
Every woman he had ever courted had known exactly who he was.
Catherine of Aragon, Anne Boleyn, Jane Seymour, every lady of his court for thirty years.
The game only worked because, underneath the costume, everybody knew that the outlaw or the pilgrim or the hooded knight was the king.
It was a performance in which the audience was in on the secret.
At Rochester, nobody had told the audience.
Did the gentlemen behind him look at one another?
Did her ladies, the English ones who must have recognized him at once, freeze where they stood, too frightened to speak?
Did someone try to catch Anne’s eye?
The record does not say.
What it does say is what Henry did next.
He withdrew.
He went out of the room with his men, and in another chamber he took off the hooded cloak.
Underneath, or in its place, he put on a coat of purple velvet, the color only the king could wear.
Then he came back.
This time, when he walked through the door, nobody in the room was in any doubt.
The lords and gentlemen dropped to their knees.
Her English ladies sank down around her.
And Anne understood.
She turned from the window and humbled herself before him, as the account puts it, making the deepest reverence she could.
The king raised her up.
He took her by the hand, and the two of them talked, through the men who could translate, in the formal, courteous way that a king and his bride were supposed to talk.
According to Hall’s chronicle, which was written to show the court in its best light, they spoke lovingly together, and after a while the king led her away by the hand and they talked on.
They had supper that evening, or spent the evening together, in the bishop’s palace.
From the outside, it looked like the beginning of a royal marriage.
It was the end of one.
The gift he had brought for her, according to Browne’s later evidence, was a partlet and muffler furred with sable, the richest fur there was, the kind of warm, heavy present that made sense on a winter road.
Henry did not give it to her himself.
The next morning, Browne was told to take it to her, and to deliver it with as few and as cold words as he decently could.
On the ride back toward Greenwich, the king is said to have turned to one of the men beside him, John, Lord Russell, and spoken the words that would later be written into the record of his marriage.
In the form usually quoted, he said that he saw nothing in this woman such as men had reported of her, and that he marveled that wise men would make such reports as they had done.
Then he rode in silence.
Behind him, in the bishop’s palace at Rochester, his bride was getting ready for the next stage of the journey.
She did not yet know what she had done.
She had only turned to a window.
—
## What the king said when he got home
He was back at Greenwich by the next day, and the first man he wanted to see was Thomas Cromwell.
Cromwell had built this marriage.
Now he came into the presence chamber and asked the king how he liked the lady.
Henry’s answer is preserved in a letter Cromwell himself wrote six months later, from the Tower.
As Cromwell remembered it, the king said simply:
“Nothing so well as she was spoken of.”
And then, in words that would be repeated for nearly five hundred years, he said that if he had known as much before as he knew now, she should never have come into the realm.
The council met.
Men were sent to the Cleves envoys to ask about the old promise to the son of the Duke of Lorraine.
Where were the papers that proved it had been set aside?
The envoys did not have them with them.
They swore that the promise had been canceled long ago and offered to stay as hostages until the documents could be fetched from Cleves.
It was not enough to break off the marriage.
But it was enough to give the king something to hold on to.
Yet sending the bride home now, after a progress across half of Europe, would be an insult no prince of the Rhine could swallow, and would leave England with no friends at all.
He is recorded as asking whether there was no other remedy but that he must needs, against his will, put his neck in the yoke.
The wedding, planned for January 4, was put off by two days.
Meanwhile, the welcome had to go ahead exactly as planned.
The whole of London was coming out to see it.
—
## The most splendid welcome ever given to a bride the king did not want
On January 3, 1540, the court came out to meet the new queen at Blackheath.
On the open heath above Greenwich, at the foot of Shooter’s Hill, pavilions hung with cloth of gold had been put up and warmed with braziers.
Thousands lined the way: lords and knights in velvet and gold chains, the mayor and aldermen of London, the merchants of the city, foreign ambassadors, and crowds of ordinary Londoners who had walked out in the frost to watch.
Anne wore a gown of cloth of gold in the fashion of her own country, round-skirted and without a train, and on her head a German headdress with a cap and a bonnet set with pearls.
Next to the English ladies in their gable hoods and French hoods, she looked foreign, and she looked splendid.
The king rode out to meet her in a coat of purple velvet embroidered with gold, on a horse trapped in cloth of gold, with his gentlemen and his guard around him.
They met in front of the crowd.
Whatever he had said to Cromwell, in front of London he played his part perfectly.
Then the whole procession went down the hill to Greenwich, with guns firing salutes from the ships on the river.
Charles de Marillac, the French ambassador, sent home his impression of her.
In the usual paraphrase, he wrote that she was not as young as had been expected, nor as beautiful as people had claimed, that she was tall and slender, of middling beauty, and that she had a determined and resolute face.
He did not say she was ugly.
No one who saw her that day did.
Three days later, on the morning of January 6, 1540, the feast of the Epiphany, the king dressed for his wedding.
Before he went in, according to Cromwell’s later letter, Henry said to him that if it were not to satisfy the world and his realm, he would not do what he had to do that day for any earthly thing.
Then he walked into the queen’s closet at Greenwich.
Archbishop Cranmer married them.
Anne was dressed in cloth of gold embroidered with flowers of pearl.
Her hair, long and fair, hung loose down her back, as a bride’s hair did, and on her head was a coronet of gold and jewels set with sprigs of rosemary.
The ring that was put on her finger is said to have carried a short motto: “God send me well to keep.”
That night, the curtains of the royal bed were drawn.
—
## What happened behind the bed curtains, and what did not
There is no need to look behind those curtains.
The king himself made sure that everyone, eventually, knew what had not happened there.
The next morning Cromwell came to him again and asked, as a minister in his position had to, how the king liked the queen now.
In Cromwell’s account, the answer was worse than before.
Henry said that he had liked her not well before, and that he liked her much worse now.
And he said, in a phrase that would later be used to end the marriage, that he had left her as much a maid as he had found her.
Six months later, under oath, the king’s physicians would say that he had told them the same thing, again and again, through that winter and spring.
Anne said nothing.
She did not know, as far as anyone can tell, that anything was wrong.
The strangest evidence of all comes from her own ladies.
In the summer, when the court was collecting testimony against the marriage, several of the English ladies of her chamber described a conversation they said they had with her that spring.
As they told it, they asked the queen, carefully, whether she might be with child.
The queen, according to their story, answered that she was sure she was not.
When the king came to bed, she said, he kissed her and took her by the hand and bade her good night, sweetheart, and in the morning he kissed her and bade her farewell, darling.
“Is not this enough?”
The ladies, so the story goes, told her gently that there must be more than that, or it would be a long time before there was a Duke of York.
Anne is said to have answered that she was content, for she knew no more.
Historians have long doubted whether that conversation happened as it was told, because it suited the case very neatly.
But if any of it is true, it tells you something about the girl brought up in a quiet household on the Rhine and sent across a continent to a man who did not want her.
She worked at her English and began to dress in the English fashion.
She was kind to her servants and showed affection to the king’s younger daughter, Elizabeth, who was six.
And at the king’s side, among the queen’s own maids, a young girl with auburn hair had begun to attract his attention.
Her name was Catherine Howard, and she was the niece of the Duke of Norfolk.
Norfolk was Cromwell’s enemy.
And the man who had made the Cleves marriage was about to discover what that meant.
—
## The man who paid for the marriage
In April 1540, Thomas Cromwell was made Earl of Essex.
It looked like the high point of his career.
It was the costume of power, put on just before the room turned against him.
By the late spring, Cromwell’s enemies, led by Norfolk and Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester, had the king’s ear.
They had the young Catherine Howard.
They had his anger over the Cleves marriage.
And they had his fear that the men around him were pushing religious change further than he wanted.
On June 10, 1540, Cromwell came to a meeting of the council at Westminster.
He was arrested at the council table.
According to the French ambassador, he threw his cap to the ground in fury, and the Duke of Norfolk reached over and tore the badge of St. George, the emblem of the Order of the Garter, from around his neck.
Others pulled the Garter from his leg.
He was taken to the Tower by water that afternoon.
Parliament passed an act of attainder against him, condemning him without trial.
But before he died, the king still had a use for him.
From the Tower, Cromwell was ordered to write down everything he knew about the king’s marriage: what Henry had said to him at Greenwich, what he had said on the wedding morning, what he had said the day after.
Cromwell wrote it all down.
At the end of one of those letters, he begged the king for mercy, writing the word three times over.
Mercy, mercy, mercy.
The letter became evidence against the marriage.
It did not save the man who wrote it.
On July 28, 1540, Thomas Cromwell was put to death on Tower Hill.
On the same day, at the royal house of Oatlands in Surrey, the king quietly married Catherine Howard.
But before either of those things could happen, there was a queen to deal with.
—
## The question at Richmond
On June 24, 1540, two weeks after Cromwell’s arrest, Anne was told that she should go to Richmond Palace for a while.
The reason given was the risk of plague in London in the summer heat.
It was a reasonable reason.
It may even have been partly true.
But she would have known what it meant to be sent away from the king.
Everyone in England knew.
Catherine of Aragon had been sent away from court in 1531 and never saw the king again.
Anne Boleyn had been taken from Greenwich to the Tower by water and had not come back.
Anne of Cleves had lived for six months among ladies who had seen it all.
She knew what had happened to the women who held her title before her.
On July 6, a group of the king’s councillors came to Richmond.
They brought a message.
The king’s conscience was troubled.
There were doubts about the validity of the marriage: the old promise to Lorraine, the king’s lack of true consent, the fact that the marriage had never been completed.
The king wished the question to be put before the clergy of the Church of England, and he asked the queen to agree.
There is a story that when the meaning of the visit was explained to her, she fainted.
Perhaps she did.
It would not be surprising.
She was twenty-four, alone in a foreign country, being told by grave men in velvet that her husband wished to be rid of her, in a kingdom where the last wife who stood in the king’s way had died on Tower Green four years before.
But what she did next is not in doubt.
She agreed.
She did not argue.
She did not appeal to the emperor, or to her brother, or to the pope.
She did not insist, as Catherine of Aragon had insisted for seven years, that she was the king’s true wife and would die so.
She said that she would accept whatever the clergy decided.
On July 9, 1540, the clergy of the convocation of Canterbury and York declared that the marriage was null and void, as if it had never been.
Two days later, Anne wrote to the king.
The letter was carefully worded, and it was probably written with English help, but the decision behind it was hers.
She accepted the judgment.
She said she would take it in good part.
And she signed herself not as queen, but as “Anne, the daughter of Cleves.”
She is said to have sent back the wedding ring with the letter, asking that it be broken in pieces, as a thing that she knew to be of no force or value.
“God send me well to keep.”
She had kept it six months.
It was the best decision she ever made.
—
## The king’s beloved sister
Henry’s response was immediate, and astonishingly generous.
He did not want a scandal or an insulted brother in Cleves.
And perhaps, after six months of watching her behave with nothing but dignity, he simply felt relief that she had made it so easy.
She was to be treated as the king’s sister.
The phrase was used in all seriousness: she would be “the king’s beloved sister,” and she would take precedence at court after the queen and the king’s own daughters, above every other woman in England.
She was given houses.
The palace at Richmond, where she had received the councillors.
The manor of Bletchingley in Surrey.
And, in a turn that must have struck some people at court as very strange, Hever Castle in Kent, the moated house where Anne Boleyn had grown up, which had come to the crown after Anne Boleyn’s father died in 1539.
She was given an income of several thousand pounds a year, plate, jewels, furnishings and servants.
She was free to stay in England or go home.
She chose to stay.
Going home meant returning to her brother’s court as a rejected bride.
Staying meant being one of the richest women in England, with her own houses, her own household and no husband at all.
She stayed.
Marillac, the French ambassador, wrote home with some amusement that summer.
In the usual paraphrase of his report, the lady seemed as joyous as ever and wore new dresses every day.
And the king, who had once ridden away from Rochester in silence, began to visit her.
They dined together.
They were said to be merry together.
When he came to Richmond, she received him not as a cast-off wife but as a friend of the family.
The woman who had turned to the window had found the one role in Henry VIII’s life that nobody had ever survived better.
Not wife.
Sister.
—
## The sister who danced with the new queen
On New Year’s Day, 1541, exactly one year after Rochester, Anne of Cleves came to Hampton Court to give her New Year’s gifts.
According to the imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, she brought two fine horses with trappings of purple velvet as a present for the king and his new queen.
When she came into the presence of Catherine Howard, the girl who had once been one of her own maids of honor, Anne knelt to her.
The young queen, it is said, raised her up and received her with great kindness.
The king came in and greeted Anne warmly.
He kissed her.
After supper he went off to bed, and the two women, the former queen and the new one, stayed up and danced together.
The next day the king sent his young wife a ring and a pair of small dogs, and Catherine, so the story goes, passed them on to Anne.
It is one of the strangest scenes in the history of Henry’s marriages, and one of the gentlest.
It did not last.
By February 1542 Catherine Howard was dead, put to death on Tower Green like her cousin Anne Boleyn before her, and for a few weeks there was talk, in Cleves especially, that Henry might take Anne back.
He never did.
In 1543 Henry married his sixth wife, Catherine Parr.
On January 28, 1547, Henry VIII died.
Anne of Cleves outlived him by ten years.
Under his son, the boy king Edward VI, her lands were exchanged for others and her income was not always paid on time.
But she was never in danger.
When Henry’s elder daughter came to the throne as Mary I in 1553, Anne rode in her coronation procession in an open chariot alongside the young Princess Elizabeth, the girl she had been kind to when she was six.
By then Anne had embraced the old religion, as the new queen had.
At the end she lived at Chelsea, in the riverside manor that had once belonged to Catherine Parr.
She fell ill in the summer of 1557.
She made her will, remembering her servants, the poor, the queen and the Lady Elizabeth.
She died at Chelsea on July 16, 1557.
She was forty-one years old.
Every one of Henry’s other wives was already gone.
Catherine Parr, the last of them, had died in 1548.
The woman he had not wanted had outlived them all.
And now the question was where to put her.
—
## The one thing none of the other wives ever got
Think about where the six wives of Henry VIII lie.
Catherine of Aragon was buried at Peterborough in 1536, with the honors of a dowager princess, not a queen.
Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard lie in the chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula, inside the Tower walls.
Jane Seymour was buried at St. George’s Chapel, Windsor, where the king was later laid beside her.
Catherine Parr was buried at Sudeley Castle in Gloucestershire.
Not one of them was buried in Westminster Abbey, the great church where English kings and queens had been crowned and laid to rest for centuries.
Anne of Cleves was.
On August 3, 1557, her body was carried from Chelsea to Westminster, and she was buried in the abbey with full honors, in a funeral provided by Queen Mary.
Her tomb was placed near the high altar, close to the shrine of Edward the Confessor and the tombs of the medieval kings.
It is a low, quiet monument, much less grand than the royal tombs around it, and parts of it were never finished.
Among its carvings, it is usually said, are her initials, the letters A and C, beneath a crown.
The woman who had been queen of England for six months was given, at the end, the resting place that every other queen of Henry’s had been denied.
That was the payment for the choice at Richmond.
She did not fight the king.
She let him go.
And in return, she got what none of the women who fought him, loved him, or gave him children ever got: freedom from him while he lived, the last word over all of them, and a grave in the abbey.
—
## The window, again
Go back to the bishop’s palace at Rochester, on the first morning of 1540.
The dogs are still barking in the courtyard.
The frost is still on the cobbles.
A tall young woman in a heavy German gown is standing at a cold window, far from home, waiting for a king she has never seen.
A stranger crosses the room and takes her in his arms.
She does not know him.
She turns back to the window.
For nearly five hundred years, that moment has been told as a joke: the bride so plain that the king rode home in disgust, so dull she did not even recognize him.
But look at it again.
A woman alone in a foreign country, who has not been told the rules of the game, is grabbed and kissed by a man she has never met.
She does not scream, and she does not fawn over him in case he is someone important.
She keeps her dignity, and she looks away.
Six months later, in a room at Richmond, she would be faced with the same kind of moment: a group of men walking into her chamber with a message she did not want to hear.
And once again, she did the thing nobody expected.
She did not turn on them.
She turned to the window, and she let the king walk out of her life.
It saved her.
—
## What The Record Actually Says
Anne of Cleves was born in September 1515; the marriage treaty was signed on October 4, 1539, after Holbein painted her and her sister Amalia (his portrait of Anne is in the Louvre).
Wotton’s report on her upbringing is paraphrased here.
Her journey across the Low Countries, the arrival at Calais on December 11, the delay of about fifteen days, the card lessons with Southampton, the crossing on December 27 and the route through Deal, Dover, Canterbury and Sittingbourne to Rochester on December 31 follow the usual accounts; the size of her escort varies between sources.
The meeting at Rochester on January 1, 1540, is known from Hall’s chronicle and from depositions collected in July 1540 for the annulment, written down by witnesses supporting the king’s case.
The disguise, the bull-baiting, the kiss, her turning back to the window, Henry’s return in purple velvet and the gift sent through Browne come from those sources; the room and the reactions in it are reconstructed.
The words of Browne, Lord Russell and Henry are reported speech and are paraphrased here.
Henry’s remarks to Cromwell at Greenwich, on the wedding morning and the day after come from Cromwell’s letters from the Tower; they are quoted from memory and partly paraphrased.
The conversation with her ladies comes from the same depositions and may have been shaped to suit the case.
The Blackheath reception on January 3 and the wedding on January 6, 1540, are described by Hall; the ring’s motto is the traditional one.
Cromwell was arrested on June 10 and put to death on July 28, 1540, the day Henry married Catherine Howard.
Convocation declared the marriage void on July 9; Anne’s letter signed “the daughter of Cleves” survives; the fainting story is reported but uncertain.
Her settlement and her rank as “the king’s beloved sister” are documented, though the yearly sum varies between accounts.
The New Year 1541 visit comes from Chapuys.
She died at Chelsea on July 16, 1557, the last of Henry’s wives to die, and was buried in Westminster Abbey on August 3, the only one of them buried there.
The claim that Henry called her “the Flanders mare” does not appear in any source from his lifetime; it surfaces in the late seventeenth century, in Gilbert Burnet’s history of the Reformation.
Nor is there contemporary evidence that Holbein flattered her: Wotton called the likeness lifelike, Henry kept Holbein in his service, and observers such as Marillac called her tall, resolute and of middling beauty, not ugly.
The winter travel, cold rooms and winter food are drawn from what is known of Tudor daily life; the scenes of the journey are reconstructions.