Why You Wouldn’t Last 10 Minutes in a Tudor Prison (1530)
You duck through a low stone archway, and the door slams shut behind you.
The daylight is gone.
The air that hits your face is not just cold.
It is wet, and it carries a smell you cannot name, though your body seems to understand it at once as a warning.
For the first minute, your eyes refuse to adjust.
You cannot see your own hands.
But you can hear breathing in the dark around you.
Several people.
And something else: water dripping somewhere, and small things moving in the straw.
This is your first ten minutes in a Tudor prison.
And for a great many of the people who came through doors like this one, the question was not whether they would be comfortable.
It was whether they would come out at all.
—
## Not a place to make anyone better
The Tudors ruled England from 1485 to 1603.
We remember them for their palaces and portraits, their six wives and their Virgin Queen, their voyages and their plays.
But underneath all of that ran a prison system that could be shockingly brutal.
A Tudor prison was not designed to reform anyone.
For most inmates, it was not even a punishment in itself.
It was a holding place: for people waiting for trial, waiting for execution, waiting for a debt to be paid, waiting for the government to decide what to do with them.
What happened to you while you waited was mostly left to chance, to money, and to the men who ran the place.
So let’s go inside.
Let’s look at what waited for you once the gates closed: the cells, the food, the fees, the fevers, the instruments that now sit in museums with polite little labels beside them, and the people who somehow walked out alive.
—
## The Tower of London
The most famous Tudor prison still stands today, beside the Thames in the City of London.
The Tower was begun by William the Conqueror after 1066.
It was a royal palace, a fortress, an armory, a treasury, and a zoo.
But under Henry VIII and his children, it became something the English feared more than any of those.
It was where the Crown sent its most dangerous prisoners: suspected traitors, fallen ministers, rebellious nobles, religious dissenters, and anyone who had grown too popular, too ambitious, or too close to the throne.
Many of them arrived by boat, rowed down the river and brought in from the water.
Being taken to the Tower was a message in itself.
It told the whole of London that you had fallen.
Anne Boleyn was brought there by barge in May 1536.
Thomas More, Henry VIII’s former Lord Chancellor, was taken there in April 1534.
Lady Jane Grey entered the Tower in July 1553 as a queen, to wait for her coronation, and stayed on as a prisoner after Mary I took the throne.
Most of those who died at the Tower did not die inside it.
The great majority of executions took place on Tower Hill, outside the walls, in front of large crowds.
Only a handful of prisoners, among them Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard, were granted the “privilege” of a private death on the green inside.
Still, there was a strange truth about the Tower.
If you had to be locked up in Tudor England, it was often the better place to be.
—
## Money bought you a room
Tudor society ran on rank, and rank followed people through the prison gates.
A nobleman, a bishop, or a rich merchant could expect lodgings, not a dungeon.
In the Tower, an important prisoner might have a room with a fireplace and a window, a bed brought from home, his own servant, and food bought from outside.
He paid for all of it.
The Tower’s officers, under the Constable and his deputy the Lieutenant, expected to be paid for a prisoner’s keep, his diet, and many small comforts, at rates that depended on his rank.
A duke cost more to keep than a knight, and the officers charged accordingly.
Thomas More’s imprisonment shows how this worked.
He was held, according to tradition, in a stone room in the Bell Tower.
For many months he had his manservant, John a Wood, with him.
He had books.
He had pen and paper.
His wife and his eldest daughter were allowed to visit for a time.
It was cold, and damp, and lonely, and More was not a young man.
But he could read and write and pray, and he used his time to write some of the most beautiful work of his life.
That was a prisoner with resources.
Now take all of that away.
—
## The common side
Imagine you are not a great man.
You are a wool merchant accused of heresy, or a servant accused of stealing a silver spoon, or a debtor who cannot pay what he owes.
You do not get a room.
You go to the common side.
London had many prisons besides the Tower: Newgate, the Fleet, the Marshalsea, the King’s Bench, the Clink, and a crowd of smaller lockups.
Newgate, built into the old western gate of the city, was the most notorious of them all.
In the common wards, prisoners were packed together in numbers that would horrify us.
Dozens of people might share space that we would think crowded for a handful.
The lowest rooms were often below ground or half below it, with floors that never seemed to dry out.
Windows, if there were any, were small, high, and barred, letting in little light and less warmth.
People slept on straw if there was straw, and on stone if there was not.
In winter, they slept close against each other, because the warmth of other bodies might be the only heat they had.
—
## The smell
Let’s talk about the smell, because it is one of the things the history books hurry past.
A crowded Tudor prison smelled of unwashed bodies, human waste, rotting straw, and damp stone.
People who lived near Newgate complained about it for centuries.
The stench of the prison was said to hang over the surrounding streets on a still day.
In later centuries, judges at the Old Bailey next door carried posies of flowers and sweet herbs into court, partly to protect themselves from the air that came in with the prisoners.
They were right to be afraid of it.
—
## Gaol fever
Tudor England had a name for the disease that haunted its prisons: gaol fever.
Today we know it was almost certainly typhus, an infection spread by body lice.
Lice thrived in prisons.
Clothes were seldom washed or changed.
People were crushed together for weeks or months.
There was no way to get rid of the insects in a dark, damp room full of straw.
Typhus began with headache, chills, and fever.
A rash spread across the body.
Many sufferers became confused and delirious.
A large share of them died within a couple of weeks.
In many prisons, the fever probably killed more prisoners than the hangman did.
And here is the detail that should frighten you most.
It did not stay inside the walls.
When prisoners were brought out to stand trial, the lice and the fever came with them into the courtroom.
The most infamous case happened in Oxford in July 1577, at a trial known ever after as the Black Assize.
A bookbinder named Rowland Jenks was tried there for speaking against the queen.
Within days of the hearing, fever swept through the people who had been in that room.
The chief judge, Sir Robert Bell, died.
So did the sheriff, members of the jury, and many others.
Contemporary accounts claimed that hundreds of people died in Oxford and the surrounding area over the following weeks.
Jenks himself, the prisoner at the center of it all, survived.
—
## Bread, water, and ale
So you have lived through your first night.
Now you need to eat.
In theory, prisoners were supposed to receive some basic food.
In practice, what you got depended on who was running the prison, on charity, and above all on money.
Poor prisoners often lived on bread and water, and whatever thin pottage or broth could be had.
The bread might be the leftovers bakers could not sell.
Sometimes it was stale.
Sometimes it was moldy.
People ate it anyway.
Much of what kept the poorest prisoners alive was charity: bread and meat left in wills by pious Londoners, alms collected in boxes at the prison gate, scraps sent by the city.
Some prisoners begged from the barred windows, holding out a box or a bag on a string to people passing in the street below.
If you had money, things were very different.
You could pay to have food brought in from outside, or buy it from the keeper, at the keeper’s prices.
Water was a danger in itself.
Drawn from wells or from the river, close to drains and cesspits, it could make you sick.
So prisoners who could afford it drank ale instead.
Brewing made it safer than water.
The keepers sold that too.
—
## Garnish: the prison as a business
Now let’s talk about the men who held the keys, because they were not public servants on a salary.
Many Tudor jailers were, in effect, businessmen.
The keeping of a prison was an office that could be bought, sold, or leased, and the man who held it expected to make it pay.
He made it pay through fees.
There was a fee for being admitted.
A fee for being released, even if you had been found innocent.
A fee for your bed and your bedding.
A fee for having your irons made lighter, or taken off altogether.
A fee for food, for candles, for coal.
And then there was garnish.
Garnish was the money demanded of a newcomer by the prisoners already inside.
Pay up, and you would be welcomed with a drink.
Refuse, or fail to pay, and your fellow prisoners might take your coat, your shoes, whatever you had, and you would be left to the coldest corner.
The keepers knew.
Many of them did nothing, and some took their share.
For a prisoner who arrived with nothing, no money and no friends outside, the result was simple: no bed, no blanket, and only whatever food charity provided.
In winter, on the common side, people died of hunger, cold, and fever, and were sometimes found in the morning by the people lying next to them.
—
## The rack
If you were simply a debtor or a petty thief, cold and hunger and disease were your enemies.
But if you were thought to be a traitor, or to know a traitor’s secrets, you might face something worse.
The rack was the most feared instrument in the Tower of London.
It was a large wooden frame.
The prisoner lay on it, wrists tied to one end and ankles to the other, and the ropes were wound tighter with levers.
The body was stretched until joints were pulled from their sockets.
Torture was never part of the ordinary common law of England.
English judges were proud of that.
But the Crown could authorize it by special warrant, usually through the Privy Council, in cases of treason and state security, and the rack in the Tower was used again and again under the Tudors, especially in the religious struggles of the later sixteenth century.
One of its best-known victims was a woman.
In 1546, in the last months of Henry VIII’s reign, a Protestant writer named Anne Askew was racked in the Tower in an attempt to make her name other women at court who shared her beliefs.
It was said that two of the king’s own councillors turned the handles themselves when the Lieutenant of the Tower refused to go on.
She named no one.
She was burned for heresy that July.
After the Tudors had gone, in 1605, the Gunpowder Plotter Guy Fawkes was questioned in the Tower with the king’s permission to use torture.
The shaky, broken signature he wrote after his interrogation, beside the bold one he had written earlier, still survives.
—
## The Scavenger’s Daughter
The rack pulled the body apart.
The Scavenger’s Daughter did the opposite.
It was an iron frame that forced the prisoner into a kneeling crouch, head pressed down toward the knees, so tightly that breathing became a struggle.
Writers at the time claimed that it could force blood from the nose and ears.
The strange name was a grim joke.
The device was credited to Sir Leonard Skeffington, who served as Lieutenant of the Tower under Henry VIII.
“Skeffington’s daughter” became, in the mouths of Londoners, “the Scavenger’s daughter.”
—
## Little Ease
Then there was Little Ease.
It was a tiny cell, believed to have been deep in the White Tower, the great keep at the center of the fortress.
It was said to be only about four feet square: too low to stand up in, too short to lie down in.
A prisoner left there could only crouch, hour after hour, in the dark.
Edmund Campion, a Jesuit priest captured in 1581 under Elizabeth I, is said to have been kept in Little Ease for days before he was questioned and racked.
He was executed at Tyburn that December.
—
## Pressed
There was one more terror, and this one was used across England, not just in the Tower.
Under English law, a prisoner could not be tried for a felony unless they agreed to plead, guilty or not guilty.
Some refused to say a word.
Often they had a reason.
A person convicted of a felony forfeited their goods to the Crown.
A person who died unconvicted did not.
By staying silent, a prisoner could save their family’s property, at a terrible price.
The law’s answer was called *peine forte et dure*, “hard and severe punishment.”
The prisoner was laid on the floor, and heavier and heavier weights were placed on their chest, until they agreed to plead, or until they died.
In March 1586, in York, a Catholic woman named Margaret Clitherow, accused of sheltering priests, refused to plead so that her children and servants would not be forced to give evidence.
She was pressed to death on the floor of the city’s tollbooth.
She is now a saint of the Catholic Church.
—
## Prisoners of conscience
That brings us to the people who filled the prisons for what they believed.
The Reformation tore England apart over more than half a century, and every turn of the wheel filled the cells with a new set of prisoners.
Under Henry VIII, those who refused to accept the king as Supreme Head of the Church in England were imprisoned, and some of the most famous were put to death.
Under Mary I, it was the Protestants’ turn: around three hundred men and women were burned for heresy, and many more were held in the Fleet, Newgate, and the Tower.
Under Elizabeth I, it was the Catholics again, the priests and the families who hid them.
Those who left records of their imprisonment often described it differently from ordinary criminals.
They believed their suffering meant something.
And of all of them, the most famous was Thomas More.
—
## The king’s good friend
More had once been one of the most admired men in Europe.
A brilliant lawyer and scholar, the author of *Utopia*, he had been Henry VIII’s friend and companion.
The young king used to drop in at his house in Chelsea unannounced, walk in the garden with his arm around More’s neck, and stay for dinner.
In 1529, Henry made him Lord Chancellor of England.
But More could not accept what Henry did next: the break with Rome, the setting aside of Catherine of Aragon, and the king’s claim to be head of the English Church.
He resigned in 1532.
In April 1534, he refused to swear the oath that went with the new Act of Succession.
He was sent to the Tower.
He stayed there for fifteen months.
In time, his books and writing materials were taken away.
It is said that after that, he kept the shutters of his window closed.
When asked why, he answered that once the goods and tools were gone, it was time to shut up shop.
—
## Among mice and rats
More’s family did not understand why he would not simply swear the oath and come home.
His wife, Dame Alice, was a practical, sharp-tongued woman, and William Roper later recorded what she said when she was allowed to visit him.
She told him she was amazed that a man who had always been thought so wise would now play the fool, lying in a close, filthy prison, shut up among mice and rats, when he might be at home with his books, his gallery, his garden, his wife and his children, in the king’s favor, if only he would do as the bishops and the best learned men of the realm had done.
More listened.
Then he asked her one question.
“Is not this house,” he said, “as nigh heaven as mine own?”
Margaret visited too, and tried, gently, to change his mind.
She could not.
On May 4, 1535, the two of them were together in his room when a group of Carthusian monks were led out of the Tower to be put to death at Tyburn for refusing the same oath.
More watched them go from his window.
According to Roper, he turned to his daughter and said, “Lo, dost thou not see, Meg, that these blessed fathers be now as cheerfully going to their deaths as bridegrooms to their marriage?”
He knew exactly where his own road led.
On June 22, his old friend John Fisher, the Bishop of Rochester, who had also refused the oath, went to the block on Tower Hill.
Fisher was close to seventy and so weak from his imprisonment that he could barely walk.
On July 1, 1535, he was tried at Westminster Hall for treason, and condemned to death.
—
## A daughter at the Tower wharf
After the verdict, More was taken back to the Tower by river, surrounded by guards carrying halberds and bills.
His favorite child was waiting at the Tower wharf.
Margaret Roper was thirty years old, the eldest of his children, and one of the most learned women in England.
Her father had taught her Latin and Greek himself and was enormously proud of her.
According to the account her own husband, William Roper, wrote years later, she did not wait to be allowed near him.
She pushed straight into the middle of the crowd, through the ring of armed guards, without any care for herself.
She threw her arms around her father’s neck and kissed him, in front of everyone.
He gave her his blessing and spoke a few words of comfort.
She went away.
And then, Roper says, she turned back, and once again forced her way through the guards to hold him and kiss him one more time.
Even some of the guards, it is said, wept at the sight.
—
## A letter written with a coal
On July 5, 1535, the day before he died, More wrote to Margaret one last time.
He had no ink left.
He wrote with a piece of coal.
In that letter, he told her that he would be sorry to be kept waiting any longer than the next day, because it was the eve of the feast of Saint Thomas, his own name saint.
It was, he wrote, a very fitting day for him to go to God.
He thanked her for coming to him at the wharf.
He told her that he had never liked her manner toward him better than when she kissed him last, because he loved it when a daughter’s love had no time to think about worldly good manners.
And he ended: “Farewell, my dear child, and pray for me, and I shall for you and all your friends, that we may merrily meet in heaven.”
—
## Tower Hill, July 6, 1535
The next morning, More was told that the king had shown him one mercy.
Instead of the full traitor’s death, he would be beheaded.
He walked out to Tower Hill.
The scaffold was rickety.
According to Roper, More turned to the Lieutenant of the Tower and said, “I pray you, Master Lieutenant, see me safe up, and for my coming down, let me shift for myself.”
A newsletter sent to Paris reported his last words to the crowd.
He asked them to pray for him, and for the king, and said that he died “the King’s good servant, and God’s first.”
A later story says that as he laid his head down, he moved his long prison beard aside, because the beard, at least, had committed no treason.
—
## The head on London Bridge
And here the story becomes very Tudor indeed.
The heads of executed traitors were not buried with their bodies.
They were parboiled, partly boiled, to slow their decay, and then set on poles above the gatehouse of London Bridge, where everyone coming into the city could see them.
That was what happened to Thomas More’s head.
It stayed there for about a month.
John Fisher’s head had been set on the same bridge two weeks earlier.
A story told by Fisher’s early biographer claims that it did not decay, that crowds came to stare at it, and that it was finally thrown into the river, some said to make room for More’s.
Whatever the truth of the legend, Londoners crossing the bridge that summer walked beneath the heads of two of the most famous men in England.
When the time came for it to be taken down and thrown into the river to make room for others, Margaret Roper made sure that did not happen.
According to the story handed down in her family, she bribed the man whose job was to throw it into the Thames to give it to her instead.
She took her father’s head home.
She is said to have preserved it with spices, and she kept it for the rest of her life.
She was questioned about it by the king’s council and is said to have answered that she had saved it from becoming food for the fishes.
Margaret died in 1544, at the age of only thirty-nine.
What became of the head afterward is told in different ways.
But it is believed to rest today in the Roper family vault beneath St. Dunstan’s Church in Canterbury, where a skull has been seen in a niche on the rare occasions when the vault was opened.
In 1935, Thomas More was declared a saint.
—
## Who survived
So who did survive a Tudor prison?
Not necessarily the strongest.
Typhus and frost did not care how broad your shoulders were.
The survivors were usually the ones with money, or friends, or both.
Someone outside who brought food, paid the fees, found a lawyer, and kept up the pressure for release.
Inside, survival was a social skill.
Prisoners who could make allies, trade a service, write letters for those who could not, or make themselves useful to the keeper were treated a little better.
Not out of kindness.
Out of self-interest.
A useful prisoner was worth keeping alive.
—
## Women and children
Women were imprisoned too, and their experience was often worse in ways that the records, written mostly by men, only half reveal.
In the common wards, they faced the same cold, the same fever, and the same hunger as men.
They also faced the keepers.
Complaints about jailers abusing women prisoners do appear in the records, which tells you something about what went unrecorded.
Women who could pay for private rooms generally got them.
Women who could not, did not.
The Fleet was mainly a prison for debtors, and debtors’ families sometimes came to live with them inside, because outside they had nowhere else to go.
Children grew up within its walls.
Children could also be prisoners in their own right.
English law assumed that a child under seven could not commit a crime, but older children could be held, tried, and punished.
A boy accused of stealing food might wait for trial in the same wards as hardened adults, with no one to protect him.
—
## What walked out of the gate
Not every prisoner died.
Debtors were released when their debts were settled.
Petty criminals served their time and were let go.
Political prisoners were sometimes freed when the wind changed in London, by a new monarch or a new set of councillors.
But the person who walked out was not the person who had walked in.
Long imprisonment left people thin, pale, and trembling.
Their eyes sank, their skin turned grayish from months without sunlight, and their legs often struggled to carry them after weeks in cramped, cold rooms.
Some carried other scars too: fear of closed doors, nights without sleep, the smell of the cells coming back whenever they closed their eyes.
The Tudors had no word for trauma.
They described it anyway.
—
## The dark
Of all the things visitors remembered about the worst cells, the darkness was the one they came back to most often.
Two centuries later, the reformer John Howard toured English prisons and wrote about them in grim detail.
Many of the buildings and customs he found had changed little since Tudor times.
He described dungeons so dark and so damp that it was hard to imagine anyone living in them.
Long darkness does strange things to the mind.
People lose track of day and night.
Their judgment slips.
Their eyes, starved of real light, begin to see shapes that are not there.
Prisoners called it the prison breaking a man.
—
## Names in the stone
There is a room in the Tower of London called the Beauchamp Tower.
Its walls are covered in carvings left by prisoners over the centuries: names, initials, dates, prayers in Latin, coats of arms, religious symbols.
Some of them must have taken weeks to cut, scratched with a nail or a scrap of metal by people who had nothing but time.
One, near the fireplace, is a long Latin prayer believed to have been carved by Philip Howard, Earl of Arundel, a Catholic nobleman imprisoned under Elizabeth I. It says, roughly, that the more suffering we bear for Christ in this world, the more glory we shall have with Christ in the next.
He died in the Tower in 1595.
These carvings are the prisoners’ way of saying: I was here.
Whatever this place took from me, it did not take my name.
—
## Ten minutes
Today the Tower of London is a World Heritage Site.
Schoolchildren take photographs in front of the Crown Jewels.
There is a café and a gift shop.
The carvings in the Beauchamp Tower are lit and labeled.
But stand in one of those stone rooms on a cold, gray November morning, when the crowds are thin and the walls are breathing damp air into the room, and it is not hard to imagine the people who waited there.
Thomas More, writing by the light of a small window until even his pen was taken away.
The men and women whose names are cut into the walls.
And beyond the Tower, in Newgate and the Fleet, thousands of ordinary people whose names nobody carved anywhere at all.
That is Tudor imprisonment.
Not a legend.
Not a metaphor.
Stone, cold, hunger, fever, and the sound a heavy door makes when the lock turns.
And sometimes, in the middle of all of it, a daughter forcing her way through a ring of armed guards to hold her father one last time.