Why Peter Gabriel Walked Away From Genesis in 1975 — and the Rainy Night in 1982 When His Old Band Played to Clear His Debts
On Saturday, October 2, 1982, it rained for most of the day at the Milton Keynes Bowl, an open-air arena in a former clay pit about 55 miles north of central London.
By evening, tens of thousands of people were standing in the mud.
When Genesis came on, four pallbearers carried a white coffin to the center of the stage.
The lid opened, and out climbed Peter Gabriel, wearing the black leather jacket of Rael, the character he had played on the band’s 1974 album “The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway.”
It was the first time he had fronted Genesis in more than seven years.
Phil Collins, Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford had not been told about the coffin in advance.
They were on that stage because their former singer was in trouble.
The first festival he had helped create had lost a fortune that summer, and the creditors were calling him.
To understand why that night mattered so much, you have to go back to the decision that made it necessary: the day Peter Gabriel walked away from a band that was finally on the edge of real success.
—
## Five Schoolboys at Charterhouse
Genesis began at Charterhouse, a boarding school in Godalming, Surrey, in 1967.
Peter Gabriel and Tony Banks had played together in one school group, and Mike Rutherford and guitarist Anthony Phillips in another.
They merged to write songs, and a former pupil of the school who was already working in the record business, Jonathan King, gave them their name.
Their first album, “From Genesis to Revelation,” came out in 1969 and sold almost nothing.
The young band left school, rented a cottage to rehearse, and signed to Charisma Records, the small label run by Tony Stratton-Smith.
In 1970 Anthony Phillips left the group, and a drummer who had answered an advertisement in Melody Maker joined that summer.
His name was Phil Collins.
Early in 1971 guitarist Steve Hackett completed what fans would later call the classic five-man lineup.
—
## The Fox Head and the Red Dress
On stage, Genesis were at first a quiet band.
The musicians sat down to play long, carefully arranged songs, and the gaps between them, while instruments were retuned, could feel endless.
Peter Gabriel filled those gaps with strange spoken stories, and then he began to fill the stage itself.
In the autumn of 1972, at a concert in Dublin, he walked out wearing a red dress and a fox’s head.
The photograph ended up in the music papers, and the band’s profile rose with it.
Over the next two years came a flower mask, an old man’s mask and a bat-winged headpiece.
The albums grew too.
“Foxtrot,” in 1972, closed with “Supper’s Ready,” a song of more than 20 minutes built from several linked movements.
“Selling England by the Pound,” in 1973, gave Genesis their first British hit single, “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe).”
The costumes made Peter Gabriel the face of Genesis in the press.
That was not how the band saw itself.
The songs were written collectively, and the other members were well aware that a magazine cover featuring a singer in a fox head said nothing about who had composed the music behind him.
—
## Summer 1974: A Workhouse and a Call From Hollywood
In May 1974 the band booked Headley Grange, a former workhouse in East Hampshire, for three months of writing and rehearsals starting in June.
The plan was a double album.
Peter Gabriel had a story in mind: Rael, a young Puerto Rican man in New York, pulled into a surreal underground world in search of his brother.
He also had a condition.
He wanted to write all the lyrics himself.
He later defended that position in a way he has never really changed.
“I maintained then (and still do) that not many stories are written by committee.”
Tony Banks saw it differently, saying the band felt a single author would give the album a one-dimensional quality.
Then came an offer from outside the band.
The film director William Friedkin, who had just made “The Exorcist,” had read the short story printed on the sleeve of the 1973 album “Genesis Live.”
He invited Peter Gabriel to work with him on a screenplay.
Gabriel wanted to accept.
According to the accounts collected in later histories of the album, the other members told him he had to choose between the band and the film project, and he chose Friedkin.
For a short time in 1974, Genesis did not have a singer.
Phil Collins suggested making an instrumental album.
The others rejected the idea.
The Friedkin project did not go ahead, and with encouragement from Tony Stratton-Smith at Charisma, Peter Gabriel came back to finish the record.
The crack, however, was already there.
—
## A Difficult Birth in London
That same summer, Gabriel’s wife, Jill, was expecting their first child.
On July 26, 1974, she gave birth to a daughter, Anna, after a difficult delivery.
By later accounts, the first weeks of the baby’s life were spent under anxious hospital care in London.
The band, meanwhile, had moved to Glaspant Manor, a country house in Carmarthenshire, Wales, where Genesis recorded the album between August and October with a mobile studio parked outside.
Peter Gabriel spent those weeks traveling back and forth between Wales and St. Mary’s Hospital in Paddington.
Years later he described those journeys plainly.
“They were out in Wales, so I was making these long pilgrimages.”
He has also said that his bandmates were not very understanding at the time, and that he lost his way in a lot of respects during those months.
Mike Rutherford did not argue with that.
In his memoir, “The Living Years,” he admitted that he and Tony Banks had been horribly unsupportive.
Gabriel himself has pointed to that summer as the beginning of his departure.
He was 24 years old, a new father with a daughter in hospital, and the band’s schedule did not stop for any of it.
Gabriel recorded his last vocals in London at Island’s studio in Notting Hill, where the album was mixed in shifts.
The mixing was finished only four days before the tour was originally meant to begin.
—
## Cleveland, November 1974
“The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway” was released on November 22, 1974, a couple of days after the tour began in Chicago.
It reached No. 10 in Britain and, in early 1975, No. 41 in the United States, the band’s highest American chart placing up to that point.
The stage show was the most ambitious the band had attempted, with slide projections across the back of the stage and a set of costumes for Gabriel.
The best known was the Slipperman, a lumpy, swollen creature suit so bulky that he had trouble getting a microphone near his mouth.
Only a few weeks into the tour, during a stop in Cleveland, Ohio, in November 1974, Peter Gabriel made his decision known.
He would leave Genesis at the end of the tour.
Accounts of the order of events differ slightly: by one well-researched reconstruction, he told the band’s manager, Tony Smith, first, and the other members afterward.
Either way, he agreed to finish the tour and to say nothing in public.
The band kept the secret too.
—
## 102 Shows and a Secret
The Lamb tour ran to 102 dates across North America and Europe.
An injury to Steve Hackett’s hand forced the British dates to be moved into 1975.
Most of an Italian leg was cancelled because of political unrest.
Night after night, audiences watched Peter Gabriel play Rael without knowing they were seeing the last tour of the original Genesis.
The tour ended on May 22, 1975, in Besançon, in eastern France.
One further show, scheduled for Toulouse two days later, was cancelled because of poor ticket sales.
That made Besançon the last concert Peter Gabriel would play as the singer of Genesis.
—
## August 1975: “Out, Angels Out”
The secret held for less than two months.
On July 12, 1975, the New Musical Express reported a rumor that Gabriel had left.
Charisma denied it.
On August 13, Tony Stratton-Smith wrote to Atlantic Records, the band’s American label, to say that Genesis would continue.
That letter, which became public only in 2025, said Gabriel was willing to sing on the next album if necessary, and that a farewell tour was possible if no new vocalist could be found.
On August 16, 1975, Melody Maker ran a front-page story under a headline asking whether Gabriel was out of Genesis.
A press release confirmed it within days.
Gabriel then wrote a personal statement to the British music press, known as “Out, Angels Out.”
Melody Maker printed it on September 6, 1975.
In it, he wrote about his disillusion with the music business and his wish to spend more time with his family.
He also described how the group’s way of working had hardened around its members.
In the most quoted line, he wrote that the band, built as a co-op to serve its songwriting, had become their master and
“had cooped us up inside the success we had wanted.”
The statement did not blame anyone in particular.
It read as the letter of a man who wanted to try something without a group around him, and who was not willing to keep missing his own family’s life to do it.
—
## What the Band Said
The other members’ memories of the split are not sentimental, and they do not all agree.
Tony Banks, Gabriel’s oldest friend in the band, later gave the most surprising reaction of all in the band’s 2007 book “Genesis: Chapter and Verse.”
“It was actually a bit of a relief.”
He also said Gabriel had been getting too big for the group.
Behind that was a practical point.
With Gabriel’s costumes on every magazine cover, the band had increasingly been seen as one man and his backing musicians.
Without him, the songwriters who had always shared the work would be judged on the music alone.
Mike Rutherford’s later account looked back with more regret, especially about the way the band had treated Gabriel during his daughter’s illness.
Steve Hackett had his own frustrations, which would lead him to leave as well two years later.
What none of the accounts describe is a single fight.
The split came out of a long build-up: a band that had grown up together at school, a singer whose life had changed faster than theirs, and a schedule with no room for the change.
—
## Four Hundred Singers and a Drummer
Genesis did not intend to replace Gabriel with someone already in the band.
They placed an anonymous advertisement in Melody Maker for a singer for a Genesis-type group.
Around 400 people answered.
Some sent photographs of themselves in masks and costumes, as if the job were to imitate Peter Gabriel.
Rather than wait, the band began recording the next album without vocals, auditioning singers as they went.
Phil Collins helped teach the songs to the candidates.
None of them worked out.
When the time came to record vocals, Collins went into the studio and tried “Squonk” himself.
The others liked what they heard, and he sang the rest of the album.
“A Trick of the Tail” was released in February 1976.
It reached No. 3 in Britain, higher than any album Genesis had made with Gabriel, and No. 31 in the United States.
The band that had worried it might not survive without its singer came out of the change stronger.
For the 1976 tour, Bill Bruford played drums so that Collins could stand at the front; from 1977 the American drummer Chester Thompson took the role, along with guitarist Daryl Stuermer after Steve Hackett’s departure.
—
## Two Careers, Side by Side
Peter Gabriel’s first solo album came out in 1977.
Its best-known song, “Solsbury Hill,” named after a hill near Bath, has long been heard as his account of leaving Genesis: a song about stepping away from something safe toward something uncertain.
Gabriel has described it in broader terms, as a song about being ready to lose what you have for what you might get.
His second album followed in 1978, and the third, in 1980, was turned down by his American label, Atlantic, and released in the United States by Mercury instead.
That third album produced “Games Without Frontiers,” a Top 5 hit in Britain, and “Biko,” his song about the South African activist Steve Biko.
It also featured a guest drummer who knew him well: Phil Collins.
The heavy, gated drum sound on its opening track became one of the defining sounds of the 1980s.
Genesis, meanwhile, were growing into a stadium band.
“…And Then There Were Three…” in 1978 gave them the hit “Follow You Follow Me.”
“Duke,” in 1980, and “Abacab,” in 1981, both went to No. 1 in Britain.
Phil Collins had begun a solo career of his own with “Face Value” in 1981.
By 1982 the singer who had left was respected and influential, but his records sold far less than those of the band he had walked out on.
He was also about to discover the cost of an idea he cared about more than any record.
—
## July 1982: Three Days in Shepton Mallet
In 1980 Peter Gabriel had joined a group of people from Bristol, among them Thomas Brooman, in planning a festival that would bring musicians from around the world to British audiences.
They called it WOMAD, for World of Music, Arts and Dance.
The first WOMAD festival was held over three days in July 1982 at the Royal Bath and West Showground near Shepton Mallet, in Somerset.
Artistically it was praised.
Commercially it was a disaster.
The weather was poor, publicity and ticket sales were weak, and a national rail strike made it harder for people to get there.
Reports put the losses for which Gabriel was held responsible at as much as £200,000.
As the only famous name on the organizing side, he became the target of the creditors.
Thirty years later he summed up the problem to The Guardian in four words.
“Ambition got ahead of reality.”
In the same 2012 interview, he described what followed.
“The debts were way above what I could manage, but people saw me as the only fat cat worth squeezing.”
He said he received a lot of nasty phone calls and a death threat.
Bankruptcy was a real possibility.
—
## The Offer
The way out came from Gabriel’s management, and from the band he had left.
Tony Smith had managed Genesis since the early 1970s, and accounts of the episode describe him as also handling Gabriel’s affairs at the time.
The proposal was simple: one concert, Peter Gabriel singing with Genesis again, with the proceeds going toward the WOMAD debts.
There was no hesitation on the band’s side.
Mike Rutherford described the decision in “The Living Years.”
“When the idea of helping him with a fundraising reunion show came up, there was no deliberation.”
He continued just as directly.
“We decided straightaway to make it happen.”
It was not easy.
Genesis were in the middle of a British tour of their own, and Rutherford called the logistics a nightmare.
The band rehearsed with Gabriel around their three nights at London’s Hammersmith Odeon at the end of September.
Before the show, Gabriel told the NME how he felt.
“I’m very grateful and I’m intending to enjoy myself.”
He added that he did not think the band would choose to work with him again beyond that night.
The concert was named “Six of the Best,” a joke about the traditional British school punishment of six strokes of the cane, appropriate for a band that had met at boarding school.
—
## Six of the Best
Tickets cost £9 in advance and £10 on the day.
The supporting bill included John Martyn, The Blues Band and Talk Talk.
The rain came down for hours.
Estimates of the crowd differ widely: around 40,000 is the figure most often given, Phil Collins put it at 47,000 in his memoir, and other reports went as high as 60,000.
October 2 was also Mike Rutherford’s 32nd birthday.
Jonathan King, the man who had named the band fifteen years earlier, introduced them.
Then came the coffin.
Phil Collins wrote about the entrance in his 2016 memoir, “Not Dead Yet.”
“Typically Pete, and typically dark and humorous.”
He also admitted he was not sure the audience understood the joke.
The set was built almost entirely from the Gabriel years.
It opened with “Back in N.Y.C.” from “The Lamb,” then moved through “The Carpet Crawlers,” “Firth of Fifth” and “The Musical Box.”
Gabriel sang “Solsbury Hill,” his song about leaving, with the men he had left behind him on stage.
For “Turn It On Again,” a song from the Collins era, the two swapped places: Collins sang, and Gabriel played drums alongside Chester Thompson.
A run of songs from “The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway” followed, and the main set closed with “Supper’s Ready.”
Daryl Stuermer and Chester Thompson, the band’s touring musicians, played throughout.
Tony Banks later remembered wearing a tracksuit with the word “kamikaze” on it, which he said summed up his attitude to the evening.
—
## The Encore Nobody Filmed
There was one more surprise.
Steve Hackett had been recording in Brazil when he was invited.
He flew to London, mostly overnight, to rehearse.
He came on for the two encores, “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)” and “The Knife.”
For those two songs, all five members of the classic lineup were on one stage: Peter Gabriel, Tony Banks, Mike Rutherford, Phil Collins and Steve Hackett.
Hackett later wrote in his memoir, “A Genesis in My Bed.”
“I was thrilled to be involved with the team once more.”
The night was never professionally filmed or recorded for release.
It survives in audience recordings and photographs.
Mike Rutherford later regretted it.
“It was only later that I realized how good it would have been to have a record of it for the fans.”
How much the concert raised has never been clearly published.
Tony Banks said it went some way toward sorting out Peter Gabriel’s financial problems, and WOMAD survived.
Gabriel has publicly thanked Genesis and Tony Smith for that night.
—
## Summer 1986: One Week Apart
Four years later, the two halves of the story met at the top of the American charts.
Peter Gabriel’s fifth album, “So,” released in May 1986, reached No. 1 in Britain and No. 2 in the United States.
Its first single was “Sledgehammer.”
In July 1986, Genesis reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for the only time in their career with “Invisible Touch.”
It stayed there for one week.
The record that replaced it at No. 1 was “Sledgehammer,” the only American chart-topper of Peter Gabriel’s career.
The video for “Sledgehammer” went on to win nine MTV Video Music Awards in 1987.
Gabriel used his new success to build a permanent home for the work that had nearly bankrupted him.
At Box, in Wiltshire, he set up Real World Studios, which opened in 1989, along with the Real World record label.
WOMAD grew into an international festival held in many countries, and it still runs today.
—
## The Reunions That Did and Didn’t Happen
After 1982, the five-man Genesis never played a full concert together again.
They came close in the studio once.
In 1999, Peter Gabriel recorded a new vocal for “The Carpet Crawlers 1999,” a re-recording made by the classic lineup for a Genesis compilation.
In November 2004, the five met in Glasgow to discuss a possible revival of “The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway” on stage.
Gabriel decided not to take part.
Instead, Banks, Collins and Rutherford toured as a trio in 2007.
On March 15, 2010, Genesis were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame at the Waldorf-Astoria in New York.
Trey Anastasio of Phish gave the induction speech and called the band “rebellious, restless and constantly striving for something more.”
Phish played “Watcher of the Skies” from the Gabriel era and “No Reply at All” from the Collins era.
Peter Gabriel was not there.
He was beginning a tour of his own.
Mike Rutherford said that Gabriel sent his apologies, and called it “a very legitimate and genuine excuse.”
In 2014, all five took part in a BBC documentary about the band’s history, “Genesis: Together and Apart.”
—
## The O2, March 26, 2022
In 2020 Genesis announced a final tour, “The Last Domino?”
The pandemic pushed it back, and it finally began in the autumn of 2021.
Phil Collins performed seated, with his son Nic Collins on drums.
The last show took place at The O2 in London on March 26, 2022.
Peter Gabriel was in the audience.
He did not go on stage.
Before the band played “Domino,” Collins acknowledged his old bandmate from the stage, joking that he might be the one shouting for “Supper’s Ready.”
Backstage afterward, Collins and Gabriel were photographed together with Richard Macphail, the band’s former road manager and one of Gabriel’s oldest friends.
It was a quiet ending.
The singer who had left in 1975, and had been rescued by his old band in 1982, came to watch them say goodbye as a member of the crowd.
—
## Why He Walked Away
Peter Gabriel’s reasons for leaving were never really a mystery.
They were in his 1975 statement, and he has repeated versions of them for half a century.
He was tired of the machinery of a band that had become a business.
He wanted to try things a group would not try.
And in the summer of 1974, while his newborn daughter was in hospital in London, he found that the band could not make room for his family.
The band members have been honest too.
Mike Rutherford admitted they had been unsupportive, and Tony Banks admitted to relief.
None of that stopped them, seven years later, from standing in the rain at Milton Keynes so that their former singer could pay off the debts of the festival he had built after he left.
The coffin was his joke.
The rescue was theirs.
And the five-man reunion that fans still talk about lasted exactly two songs.