“Where’s The Gold, Mrs. Linden?” They Strung Her From Her Own Porch Beam Over Her Husband’s $4,000 Saloon Boast… Then A Nameless Gunslinger Stepped Out Of Her Front Door
At twenty minutes to two the shovels were still going behind the barn.
She could hear every one of them.
The bite of the blade into packed dirt, the grunt, the dry hiss of the dirt thrown aside, and then the bite again, three men working at three different speeds, like three clocks in a room that could not agree on the time.
Her name was Mae Linden.
She was twenty-nine years old, and she was hanging by her wrists from the main beam of her own front porch.
They had run a rope through the iron ring her husband used for hanging a dressed deer out of reach of the dogs, and from the ring they had split it into two lines, one to each wrist, and then they had hauled on it until her heels came up off the boards.
Her bare toes could just brush the porch floor if she stretched for it.
Most of the time she did not stretch for it.
Most of the time she held the two ropes in her fists above her wrists and hung from her own hands, because it hurt less than hanging from the knots.
She wore the black work blouse she had put on that morning to do the washing and the fringed buckskin riding skirt she wore to gentle colts, and nothing on her feet, because she had been standing barefoot in the horse trough with a scrub brush when the three riders came over the rise.
That had been a little after nine.
Out past the porch roof the afternoon was white and enormous, and her sorrel mare stood saddled at the corral fence, where they had left her, lifting her head now and then to look at the porch.
Mae was watching the line where the shade of the porch roof ended on the boards.
It had been at the far edge at noon.
Now it was a foot closer to her bare feet.
When it reached them, the man in charge had told her, he would come back and ask her one more time.
Then something moved in the corner of her eye.
Not out in the yard.
To her left, in the dark of her own front door.
Inside her house.
A man was standing in her own front doorway, in the shadow of it, where nobody from the barn could have seen him.
He was somewhere around forty, with a short dark beard and a black hat, a long brown coat and a faded plaid shirt, and a revolver in a worn holster on his right hip, and he was standing perfectly still with one hand on the doorframe, looking at her.
She had never seen him before in her life.
She did not know how long he had been inside.
She did not scream.
She had found out at about ten o’clock that screaming only brought them back sooner.
She whispered it.
“Don’t come out. Three of them are behind the barn.”
The stranger did not come out.
He looked past her, at the barn, for a long moment.
He answered so quietly she barely heard him.
“I counted them, ma’am. Where’s your husband?”
Her voice broke on it.
“Bringing horses home. He’ll ride straight into them.”
The man in the doorway nodded slowly, as if that was the answer he had expected, and the worst one.
“Then we’ll be finished before he gets here.”
The three men behind the barn were digging for four thousand dollars in gold that did not exist.
Mae knew it did not exist.
She had told them so a hundred times since nine o’clock, and every time she said it they hauled the rope another inch.
But before the sun went down on that Saturday, those same three men would be on their knees in her barn, looking at more gold than any of them had ever seen in one place, under the only stall they had not dug.
And the only man on the Raft River who would not be surprised by it was the stranger standing in her doorway.
He had been looking for that gold for six years.
—
## How a man’s joke in a saloon put a rope around his wife’s wrists
The joke was told on a Wednesday night, three days earlier, at the long bar in Hartigan’s saloon in Albion, and the man who told it was the gentlest man Mae Linden had ever known.
Noble Linden was thirty-three years old.
He caught wild horses on the high desert south of the Snake River and broke them to saddle, and he was good at it, the patient kind of good that does not show off.
He talked to colts for a week before he ever put a blanket on them.
He had a laugh you could hear across a corral and a habit, when he had had three whiskeys and no more, of telling stories that got better every time he told them.
He had gone into Albion that week to meet a horse buyer, a man who bought saddle stock for the cattle outfits down in Nevada, and he had come away with a promise of thirty-five dollars a head for twenty-two broke horses, to be delivered in town on Saturday morning.
Seven hundred and seventy dollars, more money than the Lindens had ever seen in one piece.
So he had had his three whiskeys.
And somewhere around the second one, a teamster at the bar had started in on him, friendly, the way men did, about how a horse breaker’s wife must wear flour sacks for dresses.
Noble had put down his glass and grinned.
“My Mae,” he said, loud enough for the whole room, “has got four thousand dollars in gold put by. Buried where no man on God’s earth would think to dig.”
The room had laughed.
Hartigan had laughed.
The teamster had laughed hardest of all and bought him the third whiskey.
Three men drinking quietly at the far end of the bar had not laughed.
Noble did not notice them.
Afterward, he could not have told anybody what they looked like.
He rode home Thursday morning, told Mae about the price and the buyer and the twenty-two horses, and told her, laughing, about the four thousand dollars in gold, because he told her everything.
She had laughed too.
Then she had stopped laughing.
“Don’t say that in town again,” she said.
“Somebody might believe you.”
“Nobody believes a horse breaker,” he said, and kissed her, and went out to the corral.
On Friday, before light, he and a hired boy from the next ranch drove the twenty-two horses west toward Albion.
He would camp outside town Friday night, deliver the horses Saturday morning, collect the money, and ride home.
He told her he would be back by sundown Saturday.
She watched them go until the dust went down behind the rise.
She did not know that the three men from the end of the bar had left Albion Friday afternoon, riding east.
—
## Why the house on the Raft River was cheap
The Lindens had owned the place for less than a year.
It sat on a bench above the Raft River, in Cassia County, Idaho Territory, a long day’s ride east of Albion, a two-room house of squared logs with a deep front porch, a log barn with five stalls, two good corrals, and a spring that never quit.
A ranch like that should have cost more than they had.
It had not.
It had belonged to an old man named Ivo Brasher, who had lived on it alone for five years and talked to nobody.
In the spring of 1882 a green horse had thrown him against the corral post, and he had died in his own yard with nobody to hear him.
There was no family.
The county sold the place in the fall to settle his debts, and nobody else bid, because people said Brasher had been a strange, sour man, and because the house was a long way from anywhere.
The Lindens paid nine hundred dollars for it, every cent they had and three hundred dollars borrowed from Noble’s brother.
Mae had loved it from the first morning.
She liked the deep porch most of all, the way the shade lay across it in the afternoon and the way you could stand under the beam and see forty miles of sagebrush and the blue ridges beyond.
She had hung her mother’s old lantern from a nail on that beam.
She had planted morning glories at the post.
Old Brasher had left almost nothing behind.
A broken saddle.
A box of horseshoe nails.
A heavy old iron ring in the porch beam, which Noble used for hanging deer.
And one more thing that nobody noticed at the time, because nobody was looking for it.
In the barn, the third stall from the door had a floor of flat stones instead of packed dirt.
Noble had thought that was a fine idea of the old man’s.
It drained well.
He put his best mare in it.
—
## The three riders who came over the rise at nine o’clock
Mae saw them from the horse trough.
Three riders, coming down off the rise at a walk, spread out a little, the way men ride when they are not in a hurry and do not want to look as if they are coming to any one place.
She knew in the first second that they were not neighbors.
Neighbors came at a trot and waved their hats.
The shotgun stood behind the kitchen door.
She was forty yards from it, in a horse trough, barefoot, with her skirt tucked up and a scrub brush in her hand.
She got out of the trough and walked toward the house.
Not fast.
If she ran, she thought, they would run.
She was ten feet from the porch steps when the biggest of the three put his horse across her path.
The man in charge rode up last.
He was lean and gray at the temples, with a neat mustache and a quiet, careful way of speaking, like a clerk in a land office.
He touched his hat brim to her.
“Mrs. Linden,” he said.
“My name doesn’t matter. I’ll be brief, because I expect you’ve got washing to finish. Your husband says you’ve got four thousand dollars in gold buried on this place. We’d like it.”
Mae looked up at him.
“My husband,” she said, “had three whiskeys and a teamster making fun of him. There is no gold. There has never been any gold. Look at me.”
The quiet man looked at her, at her bare feet and her tucked-up skirt and her wet hands, for a long moment.
“I am looking at you,” he said.
“And I’m thinking a woman with four thousand dollars buried would want to look exactly like that.”
The big man laughed.
Later, she would learn their names.
The quiet one was Sid Kettleman.
He had driven freight in Utah and been jailed once in Salt Lake City for a stage robbery nobody could prove.
The big one was Brock Sadler, who did what Kettleman told him and enjoyed it.
The third was a skinny, sunburned young man named Vinnie Haws, maybe twenty-two, who had joined them in Kelton two months before and who had not yet looked her in the eye.
They searched the house first.
She stood in the yard with Sadler’s hand on the back of her collar and listened to them do it.
Drawers dumped.
The flour barrel tipped.
The straw tick of her bed slit open.
The stove lids lifted.
Every board in the floor stamped on, listening for the hollow one.
Kettleman came out with the only thing they had found.
It was a japanned tin box about the size of a family Bible, and he had opened it and gone through it on the kitchen table.
Inside were a tintype of a young man and a young woman on their wedding day in Ogden, looking terrified.
A pressed sprig of syringa.
A silver thimble that had been her grandmother’s.
A lock of gray hair tied with thread.
And a bill of sale, written in pencil, for one sorrel colt, eleven dollars, the first horse Noble Linden had ever sold.
Kettleman held up the bill of sale.
“Is this the treasure, Mrs. Linden?”
“That’s all the treasure there is,” Mae said.
Kettleman folded the bill of sale very neatly and put it back in the box.
“I have known men who boasted about money they didn’t have,” he said.
“They boast about a thousand dollars. They boast about five hundred. Nobody makes up four thousand. Four thousand is a number a man has counted.”
He looked up at the porch beam, at the iron ring in it.
“Brock,” he said, “get the rope off my saddle.”
—
## Where’s the gold, Mrs. Linden?
They did not hurt her more than they had to.
That was the thing she kept thinking, in the hours that came after.
Kettleman did not want her hurt.
He wanted her afraid, and he understood very well that those are different things.
Sadler threw the rope over the beam and through the ring.
Vinnie Haws held her arms.
Kettleman tied the knots himself, quickly and neatly, the way a freighter ties a load, and then he and Sadler hauled until her heels came off the boards, and Kettleman tied it off around the porch post.
She hung there and swung a little and did not make a sound.
Kettleman stepped back and looked at his work.
“Where’s the gold, Mrs. Linden?”
“There isn’t any.”
He nodded at Sadler.
Sadler pulled the rope another inch.
“Where’s the gold?”
“There isn’t any.”
Another inch.
Her toes left the boards completely, and she grabbed the ropes above her wrists and held on, because her arms felt as if they would come out of her shoulders.
Kettleman held up his hand, and Sadler stopped.
“All right,” Kettleman said.
“Here’s how the afternoon goes. We’re going to dig. We’re going to dig in the barn and the root cellar and around the spring and anywhere else a man would bury something he didn’t want found. You’re going to hang here and think. When the sun comes in under this porch roof and gets to your feet, I’ll come back and ask you again.”
He glanced west, toward Albion.
“And if you still don’t remember,” he said, “your husband rides in at sundown. I expect he’ll remember quickly. Men generally remember quickly with their wife on a rope.”
That was when Mae Linden understood what the afternoon was really for.
They did not need her to tell them anything.
They needed Noble to ride into the yard and see her.
And there was nothing on earth she could do to warn him.
—
## Six hours on the porch beam
The first hour was the worst, because she still thought someone might come.
The nearest neighbors were the Overholts, six miles down the river, and Mrs. Overholt sometimes rode up on a Saturday with a pie.
Mae listened for her all through the first hour.
She did not come.
In the second hour Vinnie Haws came up onto the porch, without looking at her, and held a dipper of water to her mouth.
She drank all of it.
He went back down the steps without a word, and she heard Kettleman say something sharp to him behind the barn, and after that he did not come again.
In the third hour the shovels began on the root cellar, and she heard her preserves come out of it one jar at a time and break on the ground.
She thought about the gold that did not exist.
She had, God help her, gone through the whole ranch in her head, looking for it, as if Noble might have done something she did not know about.
He hadn’t.
She knew every dollar they had ever had.
There were nineteen dollars in the coffee can on the shelf, and Kettleman had already taken them.
She thought about Noble’s face when he came over the rise at sundown and saw her.
She thought about the shotgun, which Sadler had found behind the kitchen door and emptied, and the shells he had thrown down the well.
By half past one she had stopped thinking about anything except the line where the shade ended on the porch boards.
She watched it the way a sick person watches a clock.
That was when she felt someone looking at her, and turned her head, and saw the stranger in her doorway.
—
## The man who walked through her house
He had come in from the north, behind the house, on the side away from the barn, where the ground drops into the willows along the river.
Later, she would learn that he had lain in the sage on the rise across the river since noon with a pair of field glasses, counting their horses, their rifles, and how often each of them came out into the yard.
When all three of them were in the barn together, he had left his horse in the willows and walked up through the brush to the back of the house.
The back door stood open.
They had left it open after they searched the place.
He had walked through her kitchen and her bedroom, past her slit mattress and her dumped drawers and the broken flour barrel and the open tin box on the table.
Mae would always remember that he closed the tin box as he went past it.
She saw it later, closed, and knew she had not closed it.
And then he had come to the front door and stopped in the shadow of it, and looked at her.
He took a clasp knife from his coat pocket and opened it.
“Ma’am, I’m going to cut you down now. You’re going to want to fall. Don’t fight it. I’ll take the weight.”
“They’ll hear—”
“They’ll hear a shovel,” he said.
“They’ve been hearing shovels all day.”
He stepped out of the doorway.
Not fast.
He came along the wall of the house to the porch post where Kettleman had tied off the rope, and he reached up with his left arm around her waist and took her weight against his shoulder, and with his right hand he cut the rope at the post.
The two lines ran out through the iron ring with a soft dry hiss, and she came down onto her bare feet and her knees gave way completely, and he lowered her onto the porch boards, with her back against the wall of her own house, in the shade.
Her hands would not open.
They had been closed around the ropes for more than four hours.
He took each of her hands in turn and opened the fingers gently, one by one, the way you would open the hand of a sleeping child, and cut the knots off her wrists.
Then he gave her his canteen.
“Small swallows,” he said.
She drank.
He waited.
Behind the barn, the shovels kept going.
Bite, grunt, hiss.
“Who are you?” she whispered.
He thought about it for a moment, as if it were a harder question than it looked.
“My name’s Thad Treat,” he said.
“Six years ago I was a shotgun messenger for Wells Fargo and Company, and I lost a box of gold on the Goose Creek grade. I’ve been trying to find it ever since.”
Mae stared at him.
“There’s no gold here,” she said.
“I swear to you on my mother’s grave, Mr. Treat. My husband made it up. He was drunk and he was proud.”
“I know your husband made it up, ma’am,” Thad Treat said.
“That’s the strange part.”
He looked out across the bright yard at the barn.
“He made it up. But it’s here.”
—
## What was buried under the third stall
The Goose Creek robbery had happened on Tuesday, the ninth of October, 1877, on the long grade where the Kelton road climbed out of the Goose Creek country toward the Raft River, and it had taken about four minutes.
Two men in flour-sack masks stepped out of the rocks at a bend where the stage had to slow for a washout.
One held a shotgun on the driver.
The other held a rifle on the messenger.
The messenger was Thad Treat, then thirty-four years old, who had ridden shotgun for Wells Fargo for six years and had never lost a box.
The rifle was pointed at a passenger’s head when Treat looked up, a woman going to her husband at the Boise barracks.
He had his shotgun across his knees.
He could have fired.
He did not.
They took the treasure box.
Six thousand two hundred dollars in gold coin, consigned to a bank in Boise City.
Nobody was hurt.
The driver, who had a brother-in-law in the company office at Kelton, told the inquiry afterward that Treat had sat there “like a man waiting for a friend.”
Nothing was ever proved.
Nothing ever needed to be.
Wells Fargo let him go at the end of the month, and from then on, in every stage station between Kelton and Boise, when his name was mentioned, someone would say that it was a funny thing about the Goose Creek box.
So he stopped giving his name.
He hunted the robbers on his own time, for six years, in every saloon and jail between the Snake River and the Humboldt.
People remembered a quiet man in a long brown coat who asked a lot of questions about two men and a box, and never said who he was.
A Boise newspaper, years later, would call him “the nameless gunslinger of the Kelton road.”
He hated it.
In 1879 a horse thief named Lem Tollan was sent to the territorial penitentiary at Boise for three years, and then three more for trying to escape.
Thad Treat had a feeling about Lem Tollan.
He visited him once a month for four years.
He brought him tobacco.
He never asked him about the Goose Creek box.
He just sat with him.
In April of 1883, Lem Tollan was dying of lung fever in the prison hospital.
He sent for Treat.
“It was me and Ivo Brasher,” he said.
“Ivo kept the box. Said we’d split it when it cooled. Then he bought that place on the Raft River and wouldn’t ever split it.”
He coughed for a long time.
“He told me once, drunk. He said it’s under the third stall from the door, under the stone, where the horse stands on it. He said no man on earth would think to dig under a horse.”
He died two days later.
Thad Treat rode to the Raft River and found that Ivo Brasher had been dead for a year, and that the ranch belonged to a horse breaker named Linden.
He went to Albion to learn about the Lindens first.
That kind of news, walked up to a stranger’s door, gets people killed.
On Friday night, in Hartigan’s, the bartender told him, laughing, about the horse breaker who had stood at the bar two nights before and said his wife had four thousand dollars in gold buried where no man on God’s earth would think to dig.
Thad Treat did not laugh.
He asked the bartender who else had been in the room.
“Three fellows at the end there,” Hartigan said.
“Rode out east this afternoon. Asked my boy the way to the Linden place, as a matter of fact.”
Treat had ridden all night.
“Your husband was joking,” he told Mae on the porch.
“But Brasher wasn’t. He buried six thousand two hundred dollars in that barn and died before he could spend a dollar of it. Those three men are digging for a lie, and they’re going to dig up the truth by accident. They’ve done the first two stalls already.”
He stood up.
“When they get to the third one, they’re going to find out that a woman they thought was lying to them all day was telling the truth, and that there’s more gold in this barn than they ever dreamed. And then there’s nothing on this ranch they’ll need you for, and nothing they’ll need your husband for.”
Mae understood him.
“What are you going to do?”
“I’m going to go and tell them they’re digging in the wrong stall,” Thad Treat said.
—
## Why the three of them laughed at him
The barn was dim and hot and smelled of horse and fresh-turned earth and sweat.
The first two stalls were holes, three feet deep.
The third had her husband’s best mare standing in it on its stone floor, stamping, her ears flat back at the noise.
Brock Sadler was in the second hole up to his waist.
Vinnie Haws was throwing dirt out of it with a shovel.
Sid Kettleman was sitting on an upturned bucket in the aisle with his rifle across his knees, smoking.
All three of them looked up when the doorway went dark.
Thad Treat stood in it with his hands at his sides.
He did not draw.
He did not even put his hand near his gun.
“Afternoon,” he said.
“You’re digging the wrong stall.”
For a second nobody said anything.
Then Brock Sadler began to laugh, a big, delighted, unbelieving laugh, and after a moment Vinnie laughed too, high and nervous.
Kettleman did not laugh.
He stood up slowly and put the rifle to his shoulder, not quite pointed at anyone, the way a careful man holds a rifle when he has not decided yet.
“And who the hell are you?”
“A man who came for the same thing you did,” Treat said.
“Only I got the directions six years earlier.”
“Where’s the woman?” Kettleman said.
“Sitting down in the shade. She’s been standing up all day.”
Sadler climbed out of the hole.
He was enormous in the dim barn, and he had his revolver out now, hanging in his hand.
“Sid, let me take him out back.”
Kettleman held up a hand.
He was studying the stranger, the long coat, the beard, the empty hands, the stillness.
“You’re saying it’s here.”
“I’m saying it’s under the stone floor in that third stall,” Treat said, “where the old man who owned this place before the Lindens put it. And I’m saying it isn’t yours, and it isn’t mine, and it was never the Lindens’. It belongs to Wells Fargo and Company. Six thousand two hundred dollars in gold coin, in a box with their name on the lid. You want to dig it up, I’d be glad of the help. You’ll save me an hour.”
Brock Sadler laughed again.
It was a little less certain this time.
“Mister,” he said, “there’s three of us.”
“I counted,” Thad Treat said.
—
## The stone floor nobody had dug
Kettleman made Vinnie Haws lead the mare out of the third stall and tie her in the aisle.
He made Treat stand against the wall with his hands on the logs, and Sadler took his revolver out of its holster and stuck it in his own belt.
Treat let him.
Then Kettleman made Vinnie take the pry bar to the flat stones of the stall floor.
The first stone came up easily.
Under it was dirt.
Under the second was dirt.
Vinnie looked at Kettleman.
Kettleman looked at Treat.
“Middle of the stall,” Treat said, without turning his head.
“Under where she stands. He said a horse would stand on it.”
Vinnie Haws moved to the middle of the stall and put the bar under the largest stone, a slab of gray rock nearly three feet across, and leaned on it.
It did not move.
Sadler came and put his weight on the bar too, and the slab grated up out of the floor with a sound like a door opening in a cellar.
Under it was a hole, lined with flat rocks, a foot and a half deep.
In the hole was a box.
It was smaller than anyone expected.
About two feet long, a foot wide, a foot deep, made of wood bound with iron straps, gone black with damp.
Vinnie Haws knelt and brushed the dirt off the lid with his hand, and in the gray light from the barn door the four of them could read, in faded paint, the words WELLS FARGO & CO.
Nobody said anything for a long time.
“Sid,” Vinnie Haws said at last, and his voice cracked.
“She was telling the truth. She was telling the truth the whole time, and there was gold anyhow.”
Kettleman did not answer him.
He was looking at the box the way a man looks at a woman across a room.
Thad Treat watched him do it.
And he watched Brock Sadler stop looking at the box and start looking at Vinnie Haws, and then at the barn door, and then at the house, and he saw the exact moment the arithmetic changed in Sadler’s head.
Six thousand dollars split three ways was two thousand dollars.
Six thousand dollars split two ways was three thousand.
And there was a woman on the porch, and a husband coming at sundown, who knew their faces.
Kettleman saw it too.
He did not stop it.
“Brock,” Kettleman said, very quietly, still looking at the box, “take this gentleman out behind the barn.”
Sadler grinned.
He took the stranger’s revolver out of his own belt and tossed it into the second hole, and he raised his own.
“Walk, mister.”
Thad Treat took his hands off the wall and turned around.
“No,” he said.
“I’ve done all the walking I mean to do today.”
What happened next took perhaps two seconds, and Vinnie Haws, who was kneeling beside the box and saw all of it, told the court in Albion that he never saw where the second gun came from.
It came from inside the long brown coat, from a holster under his left arm, a short-barreled revolver that Thad Treat had carried there every day for six years and had never once fired at a man.
He did not fire it at a man now.
He fired it at the lantern.
There was a lantern hanging from a nail on the post beside Brock Sadler’s head, unlit, full of coal oil.
The bullet went through the glass chimney and the tin reservoir, and coal oil sprayed down across Sadler’s face and his eyes and his gun hand, and Sadler screamed and dropped his revolver and clawed at his eyes, and Treat stepped forward and kicked the revolver into the third stall, down the hole, on top of the Wells Fargo box.
Kettleman swung the rifle around.
He found himself looking down the short barrel of the revolver from four feet away.
“Mr. Kettleman,” Thad Treat said.
“Put it on the floor.”
Kettleman’s eyes narrowed at the sound of his own name.
Nobody had said it all day.
“I know your face from Kelton,” Treat said.
“I know most of the faces in Kelton.”
Kettleman did not move.
His eyes were on the stranger’s face.
For the first time all day, something in his own face was uncertain.
“Goose Creek,” Kettleman said slowly.
“You’re the messenger. Everybody in Kelton knows that one. The Wells Fargo man who let the box go.”
His mouth twisted.
“You won’t shoot. You didn’t shoot then. You haven’t got it in you.”
“I let the box go,” Treat said, “because a man was holding a rifle to a woman’s head, and I would rather have lost my job than her. You’ve had a woman on a rope since nine o’clock this morning.”
He did not raise his voice.
It did not need raising.
“Do you really want to find out what I’ve got in me, Mr. Kettleman?”
The barn was absolutely silent.
Even the mare in the aisle stood still.
Sadler had stopped screaming and was on his knees, gasping, rubbing his face in the straw.
Then a woman’s voice came from the barn door.
“He’ll do it, Mr. Kettleman,” Mae Linden said.
“I wouldn’t wait to see.”
She was standing in the doorway, barefoot, gray with dust, holding herself up against the doorframe with one hand.
In the other hand she had a hay fork.
Kettleman looked at her.
He looked at the stranger.
He looked, for a long moment, at the box in the hole.
Then he bent very slowly and laid the rifle on the floor of the barn.
—
## Eleven minutes before sundown
They tied Sid Kettleman and Brock Sadler with their own rope, the same rope that had been through the iron ring on the porch beam all day.
Mae insisted on that.
She tied one of the knots herself, with fingers that still would not close properly, and pulled it hard.
Vinnie Haws did not have to be tied.
He sat down in the barn aisle with his back against the wall and his face in his hands, and when Thad Treat asked him to, he got up and helped him lift the box out of the hole.
They set it on the porch, in the shade, under the beam.
Treat did not open it.
“It isn’t mine to open,” he said.
Then they waited.
The sun went down the sky.
The shade of the porch roof came in across the boards, a foot, two feet, and reached the place where her bare feet had hung all afternoon, and went past it.
Mae watched it go and did not say anything.
At a little before eight o’clock, two riders came over the rise from the west, at a hard gallop.
One was Noble Linden.
The other was a deputy sheriff of Cassia County named Delbert Cordell.
Noble had camped with the horses in the buyer’s pasture outside town on Friday night, because he had promised Mae he would not set foot in Hartigan’s again.
On Saturday he delivered the horses, collected his money, and went into Hartigan’s only to buy the hired boy his dinner.
Hartigan told him, as a joke, that three fellows had asked the way to the Linden place on Friday, and a fourth had asked about them that night and ridden out like the devil was behind him.
Noble Linden had gone white.
He had found Deputy Cordell at the courthouse, and they had ridden east without stopping.
He came over the rise expecting to see his wife on a rope.
He saw her sitting on the porch steps in the evening light, with a cup of coffee in her hands, a tied man lying at each end of the porch, a sunburned boy sitting in the yard, a stranger in a long brown coat leaning against the porch post, and a black, iron-bound box under the beam.
He came off his horse before it stopped and took the porch steps in one stride.
Mae did not get up.
She held up her hands so he could see her wrists.
“Noble,” she said, “the next time you tell a story in a saloon, I’d like you to tell them it’s in the tin box.”
Thad Treat took out his watch and looked at it.
He had looked at it when he had come out of the barn with the box.
They had been finished for eleven minutes.
—
## The name the deputy remembered
Deputy Delbert Cordell knelt in front of the box, read the faded letters on the lid, and sat back on his heels.
“Goose Creek,” he said.
“October of ’77. I was a boy in Albion when that box went. My father was on the posse.”
He looked up at the man in the long coat.
“You’re the messenger.”
“I was,” Treat said.
“They said you sold it,” he said.
“They said it was a funny thing about the Goose Creek box.”
“They did,” Treat said.
Sid Kettleman, lying tied at the end of the porch, turned his head and laughed, not kindly.
“Six years,” Kettleman said.
“Every saloon from Kelton to Winnemucca, there’s a story about a man in a long coat who asks about a box and won’t give his name. The Boise paper had a piece about him once. Called him the nameless gunslinger of the Kelton road. I always figured that was a different man from the one who let the box go.”
He spat into the dust.
“If I’d known they were the same man, I’d have stayed in Kelton.”
Deputy Cordell opened the box.
He did it there on the porch, with all of them watching, because Treat asked him to.
He said he wanted witnesses.
The lid had been nailed shut and the iron straps had rusted, and it took a pry bar and two minutes, and when it came up the last of the evening light went into the box and came back out yellow.
Gold coin, in canvas sacks rotted half through.
Twenty-dollar double eagles.
Deputy Cordell counted it on the porch boards while the sun went down, three hundred and ten coins, and wrote the number in his book, and showed Thad Treat what he had written.
Six thousand two hundred dollars.
Every coin of it.
Ivo Brasher had never spent a dollar of it.
He had lived five years like a poor man, with six thousand dollars under the feet of his horse.
Mae Linden found she did not want to look at the gold at all.
What she wanted was to watch Thad Treat’s face as the deputy wrote down the number.
She did.
It did not change much.
But something went out of his shoulders that had been there, she thought, for a very long time.
—
## What Wells Fargo wrote to the man it had fired
Sid Kettleman and Brock Sadler were tried at Albion in October of 1883.
Kettleman got five years in the territorial penitentiary at Boise for robbery and for what the indictment called “the unlawful hanging up of Mrs. Mae Linden by the wrists.”
Sadler got four.
Vinnie Haws testified against both of them.
He told the court about the dipper of water, and Mae told the court the same thing, and the judge gave him eight months in the county jail.
When he got out, Noble Linden gave him a job breaking colts.
He stayed on the Raft River for the rest of his life.
The gold went to Boise under guard.
In December a letter came to the Linden ranch from the Wells Fargo superintendent in San Francisco.
It thanked Mr. and Mrs. Linden for their assistance in the recovery of treasure lost in the Goose Creek robbery of 1877, and enclosed a draft for six hundred and twenty dollars, the company’s customary reward of ten percent.
A second letter went to Thad Treat, care of the Albion post office.
It said that the company’s inquiry into the Goose Creek robbery was now closed, that its conclusion was that the messenger had acted properly to protect the life of a passenger, and that the company would be glad to have him back in its service on any route he chose.
He read it on the Lindens’ porch.
Then he folded it and put it in the inside pocket of his coat, next to the short-barreled revolver.
“Will you go back?” Mae asked him.
“I don’t know,” he said.
“I spent six years trying to get somebody to write that letter. I never thought about what I’d do the day after.”
He stayed through the winter and helped Noble break horses.
In the spring he went back to Wells Fargo, on the Boise run, and rode it for nine more years, and never lost a box.
He always gave his name.
—
## The tin box on the kitchen shelf
Noble Linden never told another story in a saloon, though the big laugh you could hear across a corral came back by the next summer.
He wanted to saw the iron ring out of the porch beam.
Mae would not let him.
“It holds a deer just fine,” she said.
“And it’s my beam.”
The morning glories came up at the porch post every summer for thirty years.
Mae Linden lived on that ranch until 1921.
In her last years a young woman from the Boise newspaper came out to ask her about the Goose Creek gold, and about the man who had found it, and Mae took down an old japanned tin box from the kitchen shelf and opened it on the table.
Inside were a tintype of a young man and a young woman on their wedding day in Ogden, looking terrified.
A pressed sprig of syringa.
A silver thimble.
A lock of gray hair tied with thread.
A bill of sale, written in pencil, for one sorrel colt, eleven dollars.
A letter from Wells Fargo and Company, dated December of 1883.
And a clasp knife with a worn horn handle, the blade still bright.
“He left it on the porch post the morning he went back to the Boise run,” she said.
“I never knew if he meant to.”
The reporter asked her whether she had been afraid, that day on the porch.
Mae Linden thought about it for a while.
“Of the rope? Yes,” she said.
“Of those three men? Yes. But do you know what I remember most?”
She touched the knife.
“They asked me all day where the gold was, and I told them the truth, and nobody believed me. He was the only one who did. He walked out of my own front door, and he said, I know there isn’t any, ma’am. And then he went and found it.”
She put the knife back in the box and closed the lid.
“That’s all the treasure there is,” she said.
—
## What is real in this story, and what is told
The people in this story are invented.
There was no Mae or Noble Linden, no Thad Treat, no Sid Kettleman, Brock Sadler, Vinnie Haws, Ivo Brasher, Lem Tollan, or Deputy Delbert Cordell, and there was no Goose Creek robbery of 1877.
The porch, the iron ring, the three stalls, and the box under the stone belong to the story.
The setting is real.
The Raft River runs north through Cassia County into the Snake River in southern Idaho.
Cassia County was created in 1879, with Albion as its county seat.
For years the main road into southern Idaho was the Kelton road, a freight and stage route that ran north from the Central Pacific railroad at Kelton, Utah, through Cassia County toward Boise, and Goose Creek is a real stream in that country.
Stagecoaches on routes like that one often carried a Wells Fargo treasure box, guarded by an armed “shotgun messenger,” and stage robberies in the Idaho and Nevada country were common in the 1870s.
Wells Fargo was well known for pursuing stolen treasure for years and for paying rewards for its recovery; the ten percent in this story is told, not recorded.
The Idaho territorial penitentiary at Boise opened in the early 1870s and held many of the territory’s stage robbers and horse thieves.
Stories of outlaw gold buried under a barn, a hearth, or a stall and never dug up are told all over the West.
Almost none of them has ever been proved.
This one is a story too.